
Loading summary
Jason Koontz
Did you know a 2018 study showed half of prenatal vitamins tested had unacceptable levels of heavy metals? I'm Kat, mother of three and founder of Ritual. When I was four months pregnant I couldn't find a prenatal I could trust so I created my own. Ours is made traceable third party tested for heavy metals and recently earned the purity award from the Clean Label Project. But don't just take my word for it. Get 25% off@ritual.com podcast craving your next action packed adventure? Audible delivers thrills of every kind on your command. Like Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir where a lone astronaut must save humanity from extinction. Narrated with stunning intensity by Ray Porter. From electrifying suspense and daring quests to spine tingling horror and romance and far off realms, unleash your adventure aside with gripping titles that'll keep you guessing. Discover exclusive Audible arrangements, originals, hotly anticipated new releases and must listen bestsellers that hook you from the first minute. Because Audible knows there's no greater thrill than the one that speaks to you. Discover what lies beyond the edge of your seat. Start your free 30 day trial at audible.com wonderyus that's audible.com wonderyus so that was my first. Big money making was just straight grading and after a few years the next level was how can we put fuel on this fire? This is Right about now with Ryan Alford, a Radcast Network production. We are the number one business show on the planet with over 1 million downloads a month, taking the BS out of business for over 6 years and over 400 episodes. You ready to start snapping necks and cashing checks? Well, it starts right about now.
Ryan Alford
What's up guys? Welcome to Right About Now. Hey, you know we're getting back to business here, but we've been in the middle of our trading card extravaganza as I call it. It's opening the eyes and the ears to the world of the hobby. And I got introduced to Jason, our next guest through a mutual friend and we had a conversation that was supposed to be, you know, like five minutes. End up being like 55 or two hours. I don't even know. Now I'm going to just call him a brother from another. He is Jason Koontz. He is the founder and CEO of O T I A. I'm gonna let him give that acronym and what it all means. He just a sports card. Past, present, future junkie. What's up Jason?
Jason Koontz
What's up man? So happy to be with you today, Ryan.
Ryan Alford
Hey, I appreciate it. I. I loved Our convo a few weeks ago, and Darren Prince, a mutual friend, was like, you got to talk to Jason. You got to go to the expert. I'm like, well, we'll get him on. Get on the phone. Like, we're just gonna shoot the talk about maybe what we could talk about. Next thing I know, I don't even. We're talking about and traveling and sports cards and everything.
Jason Koontz
Two hours. Two hours later.
Ryan Alford
Yeah, exactly. Man. Where's home?
Jason Koontz
Michigan. We're just north. Big Michigan Wolverine fan. So we're about 10 minutes north of Ann Arbor here in Michigan. Go blue.
Ryan Alford
Go blue. MAN 1 Team International Agency Otia we're going to dig into it. Let's set the table on the past a little bit. Jason's in the. In the trading, hobby, sports, entertainment, a little bit of everything. Maybe tell us a little bit about OSHA and, you know, your legacy in the cards.
Jason Koontz
Well, I mean, this kind of started as a kid, you know, like, most people when they're 9, 10 years old, they're collecting cards, they're going to their shop. You know, like, I was pretty into business from a young age, you know, like nine, ten years old. I'm going out shoveling snow seven, eight hours a day, building up a couple hundred bucks. So I had that part down into making money. And then the unfortunate part was I would end up at the card shop blowing all my money on packs, and at the end of the day, kind of leaving with just a bunch of stories of opening packs all day and back at it the next day. In the summer, mowing lawns. In the winter, shoveling snow. So, yeah, I mean, literally, for the last 30 some years, this is kind of all I've done is sports cards, autographs, memorabilia. You know, the big thing kind of changed for me, especially at a very young age is, you know, 30 years ago, when you went into a card shop, there wasn't the Internet. There wasn't. You know, they kind of had you. They were under control. Like, they set the prices. It was. It is what it is. It's a lot. We'll get into it, but it's a lot different with card shops today. Like, they need to be much more on point and follow, you know, the pricing and everything. But so, yeah, for first year or two, starting off like, I'm stuck in these card shops, and there's not a lot of negotiating. What really caught my eye was when I discovered card shows, when it was more of, like, the. The negotiating the bulk deals and going from table to table, the flipping the Hustling. And I started doing this really young, like 9, 10, you know, 11 years old. And, you know, I haven't looked back since. So. Yeah, from. From starting off there to where we are today, it's been pretty wild to see, you know, this grow over the past 30 years.
Ryan Alford
You bring up a great point. And it's. It kind of has some meta connotations. And I don't mean like the company, I just mean like the way the Internet and information and knowledge has empowered so many industries and so many. So much change. Because I remember growing up and going to the. God, how big a dickheads were the card shop owners of the 80s? I mean, I hate to sort of put everybody in the bucket, but everyone in my, my town in South Carolina were jerks. You know, like, you go in there, they, like you said, they're not. They didn't negotiate. They hold all the cards, literally. And they just all seem like they didn't give two shits if you were there or not.
Jason Koontz
Yeah. You can't. Yeah. And that's basically it. It's like they had a monopoly, like whatever prices they said is if you wanted it and you had nowhere else to go. It wasn't like you were, you know, the next card shops probably a few hours away. So if you wanted cards or product. No Internet. I mean, early, early on for me, like, you know, like AOL message boards in like 95, 96, I started to dabble on the Internet. But it was like, you know, just so new compared to what. What we have today.
Ryan Alford
Yeah. And you, you know, trying to get a value on something. I remember going to the Beckett book, you know, going to find the value of my 87 tops. Cal Ripken. It was $0.87 today. It's $0.91 next month maybe.
Jason Koontz
Yeah. Yeah. And everyone's going off the Beckett. And honestly, like, I haven't used a Beckett in 20 years. So that just shows if anybody's like tuning in that, you know, collected cards as a kid, like, Beckett was like the Bible. You know, everybody went off of Beckett and now, you know, everyone's got real time pricing apps with all the, all the technology that's come to life with, with the market. Yeah. Beckett is long gone as far as pricing goes.
Ryan Alford
It opened it up, but it did change. I'm glad it forced the, the local trade, you know, trade shops or card shops to be, you know, more consumer friendly. And we're, we're blessed. We had the largest dealer here in South Carolina in upstate in Greenville. Matty Rich, awesome guy. Salt of the earth guy and runs a beautiful shop that you know and takes care of his customers. And I don't know if he represents every single person. I'm sure you still have your, your something you like. Some you don't, but it does. It has sort of leveled the playing field from between consumer and shop owner because everyone's. I, I've had it. We've been having these card shows, like at my space here, you know, we got 5,000 square feet. We've been doing little trade nights and stuff like that. And even my nine year old, you ain't getting nothing by my nine year old. Like, he's over here. They're all walking around informed, they got their apps out. It's like everybody knows exactly what the cards are selling for the last 24 hours, right?
Jason Koontz
And that's what, that's one of the cool things. Like the, the big advantage I had kind of in the 90s was like, right now, like you said, everyone's got pricing data in front of them, but really back then, you know, it was really like who had the best memory of what stuff was worth in real time. You could, you know, you could, you could buy a deal at one booth and walk, you know, walk 15 booths over and flip the deal and make money. It's just, it's such a different world. I mean, it's literally. And another thing we'll talk about is in the, you know, mid-90s, and this is kind of where I got lucky, you know, the Internet coming into play. Grading. Grading is like just almost mandatory now. And I remember being at shows in the mid-90s and the head guy at PSA, which is the main grading company at the time, time, it was a guy named Steve Rocky. And he would come booth to booth and try to convince you on why you should grade your cards with psa. And you have a lot of these old time dealers that are like, fuck you. I don't need, I don't need your opinion. I don't need you. And nobody really got it.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
And I was this younger guy who just like, I was like, this is gonna be big. And I just kind of bought in. And I started grading at like 15 years old, really young, and just eventually became one of PSA's. I was PSA's biggest submitter for several years. But timing, I mean, I worked my ass off, but like, I have to put some of the, you know, the timing, you know, it's like if I was coming big into the market right when grading was taken off right when the Internet boom was taken off, like, this was the perfect storm for cards in that era for me.
Ryan Alford
How was money made then for you? And sort of, you know, the arms and legs that where you made money in the industry, you know, and maybe as the industry as a whole versus today.
Jason Koontz
Yeah, so it's a massive difference. I mean, I've always shaped, shifted my business to kind of go with what's hot at the time. And, you know, grading was so new, but the margins were so. And you know, they're still today. I mean, a perfect example. We'll take, you know, Michael Jordan rookie card, you know, now today, an 8, that's like a 7, 8000, our card. And a 9, that's 20,000. And in a 10, that's 200,000. So the same multipliers, you know, took place in the late 90s. We weren't dealing with higher, as high a dollar figure cards, but the multipliers were there. So, you know, to buy cards ungraded and grade them, you know, you could 10 to 100 extra money. So it almost didn't matter, like if you found stuff and had a good eye that was not graded and were able to get it graded in high grade. We were working on like dream margins.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
And it didn't even matter when you messed up because when you made it.
Ryan Alford
Up on five other deals that did.
Jason Koontz
Yeah, yeah. So. And I was just kind of born into, like a gambling family, I guess. So I've always been a degenerate, but this was a way to, like, early on channel my degenerate gambliness into something that was like, heads, I win really big, tails, I break even or lose a little bit. So I kind of just went all in. And there wasn't a lot of competition. Like, there was only a few people doing this. You know, it was so new. And now, like, you go to a show, 10,000 people, everyone's trying to find stuff to grade. And the reality is, especially when it comes to, like, vintage cards, you know, back then, high grade stuff was everywhere on, you know, that you could buy. Now it's all dried up. It's all graded. So that was my first big money making was just straight grading. And after a few years, the next level was, okay, how can we put fuel on this fire? And it was everybody's thought once the card was graded, like, it is what it is, like a nine. Everybody saw a nine in a holder and they just assume, okay, like, that's a nine. They didn't realize the human element of this that you Know, on a Tuesday, the grader made a get made, giving it a nine. But now on Friday, he's in a better mood. It's off the weekend, it's close. Maybe it's a 10. So now I kind of took a different approach to like walking around these shows, looking at stuff that was already graded and like, high grade. And I'm analyzing like all these nines in real time, and I'm accumulating just like massive quantities of nines that I thought were on the fence.
Ryan Alford
You crack them.
Jason Koontz
So I'm like, crap, I'm cracking it. And like Jordan, for example, like, I've hit a lot of 10 Jordans, but I mean, I've cracked out hundreds and hundreds of nines. So you have cards that are like right there on the bubble, they're like 9.7, 9.8, and you crack out 15 or 20 of those, you get 110. You know, you just, you killed it. So like I said, same time, like late 90s, there's three or four people doing that. Now there's 3,000 people doing it. And that was really what kind of put me into a different level of financially, like, early on and the whole grading.
Ryan Alford
Is that still doable today?
Jason Koontz
Not yes and no.
Ryan Alford
Like, you could probably still do it, but the multiplier is not as high, probably.
Jason Koontz
So you gotta remember, like, if you come across like a Jordan rookie, unless it was freshly discovered from a new collection, there's a good chance that things already been looked at 10 times. Like, if it's a nice nine, there's a reason it's in a nine. People that like me and then everybody else in like the last 25 years, they've all looked at that car and like, you know, like, they're like, can this 9 go to a 10? Or like. So like, the game's already been played, so there's just no inventory out there. So I would say it's. I guess it's there technically, but when you take the competition and also add in the fact that, I mean, I. I don't do it anymore. Let's put that.
Ryan Alford
So, like, but what about newer cars? Like, do you still have the Delta? I mean, like, in a position.
Jason Koontz
So here's, here's the other thing is the grading fees. When I was grading cards in the late 90s, like, I was paying like five, six bucks. And now if you go to grade a high dollar card with PSA, you might spend 10,000 because they're basing it off of value now. So it's just all the fun has been taken out of the game is, you know, so I probably, since 2017, haven't really, you know, I went from grading 25 to 50,000 cards a month and being PSA's biggest submitter for several years to maybe grade like 2,000 cards a year now, if that.
Ryan Alford
I mean, I'm looking at it a little bit that way, but also just having fun with my boys, so trying to find both. I think we're finding the line we have. We're having more fun than making money, I'll say that so far. But, yeah, I do see a clear path with what I do know and the people I know, like Jason Coons, that there could be money to be made, you know, so it's. But. And it's okay with it. That's fine. It's more just. It's a lot of work, like at these shows, man. Like, holy shit. With every kid and every person, like you said, it's not like that. I don't want anyone to be informed, slack and take advantage of someone that, man, it's almost exhausting, the constant deal making. Like, it's because everybody thinks they know exactly what something's worth and. And they do, but I don't know. When everybody's a pro, it's a little annoying.
Jason Koontz
You know, it's different now. I mean, it was so easy for so, like, almost too easy to the point where when Covid hit, you know, everybody kind of had time to, like, pull out their old cards and get back into it. I think a lot of smart people realized, you know, a lot of business minds like yourself, they. They all came in and they're like, this business is like, it was so unprofessional. And, you know, and everybody saw these opportunities. So, like, within the last couple years, we've seen so many apps come out, so many business, you know, Nothing changed from 2019 back. Like, it was basically the same. And now there's just so much innovation, which is. It's good, but it's brought in a lot. A lot more smart people. A lot of business people that have come in, they've. They've, you know, added fees to different stuff and, like you said, taken some of the fun away and. But it's turning into. It was already a real asset class. One of the major things for Covid was I've always been bullish on cards. Probably 70% of my net worth is in cards and memorabilia. But there was always in the back of my mind, like, am I crazy having this type of money invested in this and I was confident, but really when Covid hit like, the confidence boost for me went from like 70 to 100%. When if you ask me what could tear down our business is if you took away sports, you know, off tv, basically everything that happened to begin, if you took all that away, I'm like, the card market's gonna crash 99%. And there was like this six week gap where I guess not just cars, but the whole world was kind of in limbo.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
And I was panicking. You know, I had a lot of money, but all on paper and in inventory. And then out of nowhere, like, you just see the market just like go like this and then just take off. And that for me was, it was good on multiple levels financially, but also just like the feeling of knowing, okay, like this has been cemented as a real asset class. And nothing's gonna, I don't wanna say nothing, but like, this is. It is what it is. Like people, this is now, you know, will watches, gold coin. I mean this is like a real asset, you know. And you see people shifting money out of the stock market into some of these massive like million dollar cards because they believe in sports cards more than they do the stock market or some of the other, you know, bullshit going around. So that's been really exciting for me to see. Just being in it from the very beginning to where we're at now is pretty awesome. Just to, you know, kind of can get confirmation that we're here to stay.
Ryan Alford
Watching now because I'm. And this is me like with the kids and kind of looking at the industry, the YouTube factor. You've got these influencers and guys opening packs. Not talking about like selling and whatnot, about just the opening packs. On YouTube you got King of cards. Kyle kind of building his little brand up. This is not unique to trading cards. This is the smart people in any industry have figured out, you know, that attention is money. And you, hey, the Internet is your oyster and the social media is your oyster. What's your take on all of that and the impact on the industry?
Jason Koontz
So two things. One, to me personally, it's so wild to think that like going back to the early 2000s, we didn't have cameras at shows, we didn't have iPhones, obviously. But like the thought of filming at a card show was so like it wasn't. When people asked you what you did for a living, like it was embarrassing to tell them you bought and sold sports cards.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
Usually they would hear sports cars and then you wouldn't correct Them, because, like, that's cool. And so it's like, it's completely shifted. And people say, I can't believe you don't have content from the show. It's like, dude, we were not in a content world to begin with. And then on top of it, we didn't want people.
Ryan Alford
No, you know, no transparency, no secret. All you see, you weren't letting those trade secrets out.
Jason Koontz
Yeah, like, well, the secrets. And just like, you know, it's like you're not gonna pick up chicks telling, you know, telling people you buy and slow baseball cards. So, you know, fast forward, fast forward 20 years. Everybody's doing it now. It's cool. So to me, that's just such a shift to see it go from like 0 to 100 as far as a cool factor goes. So that's part one. The second part of your question is, what do I think about it? And, like, all these guys, you know, a lot of these guys are newer too. Like, they saw the. You know, there's a chance to make authors content. There's clickbait, you know, there's stuff. There's. There's ways to make money through the content, obviously. So, you know, a lot of these guys, they're not experts. They've come into the hobby in 2018, 2017, 2019, so they don't know a lot. They know enough to kind of talk about it. So some of the information is just the blind leading the blind as far as, like, these are new people talking about cards. With that being said, I think the guys that have good intentions, it's good, it's all positive. The guys that are negative, like, whatever. Like, you know, it's clickbait, you know, it's whatever. I don't think that someone's, you know, if someone's new to the hobby, like, that's their first experience. It's not good. So all the guys that are putting out good content, I think it's growing the hobby. I like seeing it. I know a lot of those guys, they're good. They're good people. So I think it's a net positive overall. I think it gets watered down a little bit when you got guys who don't know what the hell they're talking about, but I think the really big guys at least have an idea of the hobby and stuff. So it's just mind blowing to me. I'd rather watch some new Guy's video for 15 minutes just to kind of. I'm always trying to stay in the loop. Like, even with the new guys that work for me. I'm always picking their brain because I don't keep up on them. There's so much new stuff coming out daily. Like it's crazy. I know the vintage better than most. Some of the newer stuff, it's hard to keep up with. So I'm trying to sponge all this in.
Ryan Alford
Yeah, it's different. Especially coming up when you did, like you said, it was just the last, last thing you think of wanting to amplify is either by reputation or by like giving your, I don't know, competitors your kind of like behind the scenes.
Jason Koontz
Speaking of crazy stories so that like here's a perfect example. 1986 floor basketball, you know, like the holy grail of basketball. 80, you know, Jordan's rookie in the early 2000s. Boxes of that were about 12 to 15,000 and now they're like 150,000. We were buying those and cracking them and the people that were selling them to us or me and you know, people I was working with is they thought we were just getting smoke. They felt bad. They sell us these boxes. We were opening them and they kind of felt like we were just these young guys getting screwed. They didn't realize how clean 86 floor basketball came out of the packs. And we were grading this stuff and making a fortune and we just played, we just played the dumb role for like two or three years of like, yeah, I just really like opening this product. But like a box that I paid 12,000 for, like worst case scenario, the ROI was about seven grand. A good box ROI was about 200 grand.
Ryan Alford
Holy shit.
Jason Koontz
Yeah. So like and I, I opened three or four hundred boxes of 86 floor basketball and nobody would pay more. So like they would buy them and we would just, you know, so some of the David Adams car world baseball car, all these guys would sell us, they'd get 86 foot basketball, they'd sell it to us. We would kind of show the image of like, hey, we're these dumb guys cracking 86 floor basketball. And you know, Jordan wasn't even the most expensive card in the set. Like a lot of people were building sets and some of these commons were like 10 or 15,000. In a PSA 10 you could get one common in high grade and it would cover the entire box.
Ryan Alford
Geez, crazy. What you're saying is you guys are taking some collection of cards and repacking them into, you know, 4, 8, 12, 20, whatever it is, into a different rebranded name and you have a higher percent chance of ROI than you did maybe from manufacturer and Maybe even a larger hit rate or something, you know, like with the better cards. I mean my, I'm trying to short phrase that, but is that.
Jason Koontz
Yeah, exactly. Well, and liquidity, I mean like, so generally like let's just say the, the repack is, you know, each repack is one graded card. And you know, like, let's say the repack cost 200. And you know, like over the, over the span of the repack, like the lowest card in there is going to be 40, which you have to have $40 cards in there because in that same repack you want to put cards in there that are, you know, a thousand fifteen hundred. So but you're, you're pulling something that's instantly liquid, you know, or there's instant liquidity versus out of a traditional pack, you know, half, 99% of the cards are all commons that are just going to get chucked. And then let's just say you do pull a good card, then it needs to go off for grading. There's the weightings. Repacks are quicker. There's generally like a floor and a ceiling. So you, you kind of know like, what's my minimum, what's my lot, you know, what's my max? The only thing with traditional packs is you do have that lottery ticket which has kind of been the game the last couple years. You know, like every, every so often they're going to have a, you know, I'm sure you saw the Paul Skeens card, you know, debut sold for 1.3 million. Yeah, like that's one person that hits that.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
So for one person that hits that, like million dollar lottery ticket, there's all the other stuff that just, you know.
Ryan Alford
Yeah, you only hear the good news.
Jason Koontz
You only hear the good news. That's the stuff that doesn't get talked about. So I just think that. And you do see it like the repack is just getting a lot more money. A lot of these guys that like to spend money on high dollar, they still open some packs. Like I still open packs. For me it's just pure entertainment though. Like if I, me and my son, me and my kids sit down and we open a box or a couple boxes and spend a thousand bucks. I'm not planning to get any of that money back. I'm just like entertainment donation, having fun and you know, give them the cards and let them do it. So I think when you go in with that mindset, it's okay because it's the same as, you know, going to a sporting event or go into Whatever you're. Yeah, so. But the problem is you got people that they don't look at as entertainment. They're looking at as, like, making money, opening packs and during a long haul, that's just not going to be sustainable.
Ryan Alford
No, don't, don't do that. Go buy singles and resell them or put them in your collection. But no, no, I do the same thing with my kids. We open, I mean, three nights a week, you know, but I'm looking at it purely as time with my kids where they actually want to hang out with me and we have fun and it's a surprise and delight moment if we get something great. And if we don't, I'm. I'm not, you know, forfeiting their future. You know, like, it's like, it's like, it been nice to have gotten something out of that, but I had fun either way. And that's, that's, that's part of, you know, why I'm doing this series is to remind people this is a lot of fun. It has a lot of great attributes for, you know, fathers, sons, mothers, daughters, whoever's into it. Doesn't matter because there's a trading card and a hobby, you know, variation for everyone. But at the same time, it is an asset class and now and needs to be, I don't know, put on the pedestal that it's earned through a lot of the, you know, time that you've put in. Jason. I mean, you know, being one of the pioneers and people that have been through it all, you know, it sort of deserves its moment in time. You know, you guys are selling on whatnot more than anything else. That's what I'm hearing. That's what I'm assuming. This technology and live selling thing, you know, being in marketing and business, I've been preaching that for about seven years and telling people that it was coming. It was before COVID by the way. I was at a FedEx event. People looked at me sideways and I'm like, you just wait. Sure enough, it's a fascinating part of the industry, this industry, other industries. Where do you, what, what say you about live shopping?
Jason Koontz
Well, I wish I would have met you five years ago because I was on the initial call with Grant, the guy who started Whatnot, and he, he. I still have the email that I look at like once a month because it's ridiculous, basically saying, hey, I got this idea for a live selling platform called Whatnot. I want to talk to you, like, you know, investor. So I had a chance at like, you Know pre.
Ryan Alford
Oh, Jason, I wish I had known you, man, I would have. If you'd have gotten that call, I would have gone with you.
Jason Koontz
Yeah, I just, I just, I was still like, I think if I was younger I would have understood it more at the time. My question to him was I said, I go, so you want to run a 32nd auction at one in the afternoon on a Tuesday? And they said yeah. And I said, just that suck. That was ridiculous to me. But I didn't really process it the way now obviously I'm one of their, I think their number two seller on the entire platform. But at the time if I would have stopped and thought like, you know, even on ebay, all the bidding is in the last few hours and even sniping the last second like the first six days of a seven day eBay auction, irrelevant. So this was just like, I mean I've had plenty of hits, I've had plenty of misses. This was a miss for me. So it's just kind of funny now looking back when I was just so anti or bearish on just not, not bearish. I didn't understand live streaming and now I think we're still really early. I think live streaming is like the fourth or fifth biggest thing in my lifetime to come about. Like the Internet, crypto, you know, bitcoin, you know, it's like social media. Live shopping. Like to me live shopping is like the third or fourth biggest thing where people are going to get really wealthy and in the next couple of years, AI obviously but like you're going to see everybody like Walmart, Costco, like they're all going to have lives. Either they're going to be pushing stuff through other platforms or they're just going to create their own. And I'm very bullish on live shopping and it's still early. I mean I still think is as far as it is like 95% of people still don't know anything about live shopping.
Ryan Alford
So yeah, I think the trading cards and the hobby is well, a lot further down that like conversion path, you know, for their, I don't know, target audience. But it, it's going to meet this professionalism that you talked about earlier. That's where I see it. That's where I'm, I kind of have my brain thinking is like, yeah, as the business as a whole, where I think about, okay, well if Ryan R. Alford is going to get in on this thing, it's going to be in this professionalism marketing content. But there's a delivery with the Live shopping, which you don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater. So it's not that it has to be overcomplicated or too sophisticated, but I do think there's rooms and dials to be turned with all of that experience.
Jason Koontz
Oh, it's huge. We have seven studios that we've built out and we're constantly making them better. But, like, a lot of the people live selling, like they're still live streaming, like out of their garage.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
You know, like, so we have. We're kind of a little bit ahead of that. But we also, you know, we don't. We have. It's really hard to find good live streamers. I mean, I think live streamers are going to become famous, like, personalities and, you know, people are going to hire them and. And because if you can sell, you're going to be, you know, it's like the late 90s, you know, sports cards on TV, the shop at home days.
Ryan Alford
Oh, my God.
Jason Koontz
I don't know if you know, the Don.
Ryan Alford
I've got some videos that we play that I've am actually having cut up right now that are more spoof stuff, but for our. The Breaking Rad Instagram channel. But it's. But it is that, though. But he's. He was great, but it's like, she's in the video. He's like, if you don't buy this, you're. How are you going to wake up in the morning the next day? You're not even going to be able to look in the mirror. He was the greatest salesman of all time.
Jason Koontz
He was amazing. So that was the part we met. I mean, we could talk for 10 hours. So I did a ton of selling on the main two guys that were selling on tv. I was providing them with a ton of inventory and they were buying with reckless because they were selling on TV and killing it. But. So, yeah, Don was hilarious. But the TV days were. Were wild, man.
Ryan Alford
Like, you'll walk into that bar, they'd be like, there's Rick. He knows how to make a decision. He goes all in.
Jason Koontz
If you miss out on this, you're not gonna.
Ryan Alford
You're not gonna look yourself in the mirror tomorrow. I was like. And I was watching going, I don't want to miss out. And then I'm like, oh. I'm like. I was like, he was awesome. He was so good at it. But I learned from him getting serious over there with my kids.
Jason Koontz
They would do. They would do like, limit five per caller. And then, like, you'd have people calling in and like, have their mom calling for them and. Yeah, hey, can we, can we, can we order? You know, just. But have them shipped to the same address, but it's a different person trying to get more, you know.
Ryan Alford
Yeah, exactly. Fomo, man. That's what it is. Fear of missing out. That's what live shopping is, though. It's like every great marketing characteristic, like built into one. You've got the, the last 10 seconds. So FOMO you got, you're racing against the clock. You don't want to miss out. You. It's just everything kind of coming together.
Jason Koontz
The thrill of getting the deal. I mean, we watching stuff, like I said, like sometimes like stuff goes over market. Yeah, stuff goes over market. A lot of times stuff goes under market. So like there, there are plenty of times where I see you, I'm like, holy shit. Like that was a hundred dollar card that just sold for 40 bucks. Like that guy's, you know, which is good. Like that guy's gonna come back and keep buying like crazy, you know, today.
Ryan Alford
That'S arbitrage today because I get in there and I've done both, you know, Like, I, I tend to not be the guy that goes over just to win, but like sometimes I've got a wrong number on a card because there's so many damn cars. I'm like, ah, that's probably $20 over marketer, you know, but that's arbitrage. Getting there and stealing some, you know, $100 cars for 40.
Jason Koontz
Knowing the market, I mean, this is, this is where in real time, when you're running a 30 second auction, you need to make those gut calls. And if you do know the market and something selling for 80% like, you know, and he's spending a lot of money. And I mean a lot. We do that too. I go in there and pick stuff off. Sometimes the collector meet comes out and then I end up overpaying for some stuff that I just want.
Ryan Alford
Yeah.
Jason Koontz
For my purse. But that's kind of the fun in it. Like, you know, what, am I going to see this again? But there's a. Yeah, there's, there's definitely just a ton of money to be made. You, you just have to just spend the time and just get educated and really, you know, don't jump all in and just, you know, spend a ton of money. Like just put a lot of hours in understanding everything before you, you know, go, go big.
Ryan Alford
Yeah. And that's sort of my superpower. Like, I'm the most curious person on the Planet. I go down the rabbit hole, like, and I'm down the rabbit hole in this business. Like, I'm way down it right now. Like, just observing, watching, and curious. Don't know it all. Learning from guys like you, watching the market and stuff like that, because there is stuff to be made. It's just like anything else, though. It's not immediate $12,000 to $200,000 boxes like it used to be. But like anything else, he who goes the furthest often wins. Jason, where's it all headed for you, brother? I mean, you're relaxing, you know, got great people working for you. You're taking care of them, they're taking care of you. When Jason looks down the road and goes, man, you know, you're taking care of your kids, your family. I mean, like, where are we headed with all this?
Jason Koontz
Yeah, I'm in this where my kids are all. I'm like, yeah, I think our kids are in the similar age. You know, I'm like 10, 10, 8, 7, 6. So it's like I am trying to pull back a little bit, you know, like. And when I say pull back a little bit, it's like going from 80 hours a week to, you know, 50 hours a week. I enjoy this. Like, I enjoy business. So, yeah, when I try, like, I don't know about you. When I go on vacation after day three, I'm jonesing to get home. It really takes. It's hard. So I see me doing this forever. It'll keep. I'll keep shifting with it. And I think, you know, talking with a lot of these younger guys and just molding, I've always done that, but I just love it so much that it doesn't feel like work. And so, yeah, I think we're going to be doing this for a while, man. It's just. I'm blessed to be in a spot where I have good managers underneath me. So when I do want to, you know, I'm like, hey, today's, I got kids sporting, you know, I got soccer games, I got basketball. Like, I'm not doing anything right now. I'm going to go do that. So that's. I do feel like I set myself up for that, you know, the 15 years leading up to where we're at today. I do get a lot of hate when people, they think, like, they see where I'm at now, and it's like they think this happened in the last year or two, not the case at all. And it's. It's, you know, it's just the world we live in today, you know, everybody wants, you know, money overnight, and it just, it's not the reality. And, you know, even, like, even in the middle, like, going, going broke in the middle of this, like, you know, really, really learned to put me in a different mindset. So, yeah, I mean, I'm gonna be doing this for a while. Keep, Keep growing. Obviously, if you're not growing, it's not fun. It's. It's. It's exciting to, to watch. I love, you know, planning the next three to six months out, and then I email it to myself. And then six months, you know, like, kind of seeing how far we made it if we surpassed it. And a lot of times, like, and I keep all these emails and I'm just like, I'm looking back at goals from like 20, 22, and it's like, holy shit. Like, not only did we hit that goal, you know, it's like, like 100 million in sales in a year was like a big deal for us. And, like, and we hit that. And this year we're gonna surpass that, hopefully by a decent amount. But that was something that seemed crazy, and now we're there. So it's like, now I gotta set new goals and keep, Keep moving. I think people that are wired in this weird sickness entrepreneur that we all have, you're always. You're always moving the goal post. And for better or worse, it's a blessing and a curse, I think, because I think there's some people, they get to the goal post and they're happy and they can just chill. I think someone like, you know, who's really dialed in, they get to the goal, they enjoy it for about 10 minutes, and they say, okay, let's move that goal post back again and see what else we can do. So that's kind of where I'm at right now. Just I'm trying to enjoy life a little more and, and work a little less. But like I said, even, even less for me is still a lot of damn hours.
Ryan Alford
They say the journey is everything now. And I think, you know, the longer I do what I do, it proves to be true. And it's in almost everything. Because even, like you said, like, my kids get excited about opening a box. We get excited, and you open the packs and you get it. You might get the Jaden Daniels best card ever auto. Ten minutes later, it's what's next, you know, like, and it's not because they can't get enough, but it's just. It's more. I look at it more. Like you said, it's that the journey, the excitement of, oh, you know, building up to wanting that card or wanting that goal in business or all those things. I think the true, the truly motivated are just looking for the next journey and the next challenge.
Jason Koontz
100%. 100%.
Ryan Alford
Hey, man, where can everybody keep up with everything you guys are doing? Where to find you, the company, et cetera, et cetera?
Jason Koontz
Yeah, so the website's just four letters, otia.com on social media, Otis Sports on whatnot. Otia rips. Yeah, I mean, those are. It's pretty much all under one umbrella. If you Google OTIA Sports or Otiah, you'll. You'll find us and you'll join some of our live streams, you know, and enjoy the shows and have fun and, and bid responsibly.
Ryan Alford
Yes. Gotta put that disclaimer on there. Jason, really appreciate you for coming on the show and it's been great. I consider you a friend now and look forward to future opportunities.
Jason Koontz
Ryan, thank you so much for having me on. It was a lot of fun.
Ryan Alford
Hey, guys, you know, to find us, Ryan is right. Dot com. Hey, we're number one for a reason. It's because you're here. Go check us out on YouTube. We got a fast growing page over there. Watch all the content. You'll find links to all of Jason's stuff, Otia rips, all the stuff they're doing over on whatnot and on the website. We appreciate Jason for coming on and we appreciate you. We'll see you next time. All right. About now, this has been Right about.
Jason Koontz
Now with Ryan Alford, a Radcast network production. Visit ryanisright.com for full audio and video versions of the show or to inquire about sponsorship opportunities.
Ryan Alford
Thanks for listening.
Episode Summary: Creating His Own Breaks - The Booming Hobby Series with Jason Koonce
Release Date: June 24, 2025
In this engaging episode of Right About Now with Ryan Alford, host Ryan Alford delves deep into the dynamic world of sports cards and memorabilia with guest Jason Koonce, founder and CEO of OTIA Sports. The conversation, rich with industry insights and personal anecdotes, offers listeners a comprehensive look into the evolution, challenges, and future of the trading card hobby.
Ryan Alford introduces Jason Koonce as a seasoned expert in the trading card industry, highlighting his extensive experience spanning over three decades. Their initial interaction, described by Ryan as a brief conversation that unexpectedly extended into hours, sets the stage for a candid and in-depth discussion.
Ryan Alford (02:36):
“I had a conversation that was supposed to be five minutes. End up being like 55 or two hours.”
Jason Koonce recounts his early passion for sports cards, which began in childhood. Growing up in Michigan, Jason combined his entrepreneurial spirit with his love for trading cards, starting by shoveling snow and mowing lawns to fund his hobby. This dedication laid the groundwork for his future ventures in sports cards, autographs, and memorabilia.
Jason Koonce (03:37):
“For the last 30 some years, this is kind of all I've done is sports cards, autographs, memorabilia.”
The conversation shifts to the significant changes in the trading card market over the past 30 years, particularly the impact of the internet. Jason highlights how the internet democratized pricing and accessibility, moving away from the rigid control previously held by card shop owners.
Jason Koonce (05:04):
“30 years ago, when you went into a card shop, there wasn't the Internet. They set the prices. It was a lot different with card shops today.”
Ryan echoes this sentiment, reflecting on the monopolistic practices of the past and how the internet leveled the playing field, making card shops more consumer-friendly.
Ryan Alford (06:11):
“I remember going to the Beckett book to find the value of my 87 tops. It was $0.87 today. It's $0.91 next month maybe.”
A significant portion of the discussion centers around the evolution of card grading. Jason explains how grading became a game-changer for the industry, offering higher margins and transforming the way cards were bought and sold.
Jason Koonce (08:53):
“Grading was so new, but the margins were so perfect. We were working on like dream margins.”
He shares his experience of becoming PSA's biggest submitter in the late '90s, capitalizing on the perfect storm of internet growth and the novelty of grading.
Over time, the grading landscape has shifted dramatically. Jason discusses the increase in grading fees and the saturation of the market, making it harder to achieve the same returns as in the past.
Jason Koonce (13:16):
“Grading fees...now if you go to grade a high dollar card with PSA, you might spend 10,000 because they're basing it off of value now.”
Ryan concurs, noting that while grading is still feasible, the financial returns are not as lucrative due to higher costs and increased competition.
The episode delves into the emergence of live selling platforms like Whatnot, discussing their impact on the trading card industry. Jason reflects on his initial skepticism about live selling but acknowledges its transformative potential.
Jason Koonce (26:45):
“I was still like, I think if I was younger I would have understood it more at the time.”
He emphasizes the future significance of live shopping, predicting it to be one of the major innovations alongside the internet and cryptocurrency.
Jason Koonce (28:28):
“I think live streaming is like the fourth or fifth biggest thing in my lifetime to come about.”
Jason shares captivating stories from his career, including his success with the 1986 floor basketball cards. These anecdotes illustrate the high-stakes nature of the hobby and the substantial returns that can be achieved with the right strategies.
Jason Koonce (20:37):
“We were opening them and making a fortune. A box I paid 12,000 for, the ROI was about seven grand. A good box ROI was about 200 grand.”
Ryan highlights the balance between treating card opening as a business versus pure entertainment, underscoring the importance of maintaining passion amidst profitability.
Ryan Alford (24:37):
“We're having more fun than making money, I'll say that so far.”
As the conversation wraps up, Jason discusses his vision for the future, emphasizing work-life balance and the enduring nature of the trading card hobby. He reflects on setting and achieving long-term goals, illustrating his commitment to continuous growth and adaptation.
Jason Koonce (34:09):
“I see me doing this forever. It'll keep shifting with it. I'm blessed to be in a spot where I have good managers underneath me.”
Ryan shares his own outlook, focusing on the journey and the excitement of ongoing challenges, both in business and personal endeavors.
Ryan Alford (37:07):
“The journey is everything now. It's the excitement of building up to wanting that card or wanting that goal in business.”
Towards the end, Ryan provides listeners with ways to connect with Jason and follow OTIA Sports' activities across various platforms.
Jason Koonce (38:02):
“The website's just four letters, otia.com on social media, Otia Sports on Whatnot.”
Conclusion
This episode of Right About Now offers a treasure trove of insights into the trading card industry, blending historical perspectives with contemporary trends. Jason Koonce's expertise and candid storytelling provide listeners with a nuanced understanding of the hobby's evolution, the pivotal role of grading, and the promising future of live selling platforms. Whether you're a seasoned collector or new to the world of sports cards, this conversation is both informative and inspiring, highlighting the blend of passion and business acumen that drives the hobby forward.
Notable Quotes:
Stay Connected:
Subscribe to Right About Now with Ryan Alford for more insightful conversations that cut through the noise and deliver real, actionable business and marketing wisdom.