
Two officers from the Kotzebue, Alaska Police Department enter a living room and ask the two small children watching SpongeBob, “Did someone call the police?” One just points to a bedroom door. Inside, a man, Anthony, cradles a young woman’s body drenched in blood. He says she’s his girlfriend, Jennifer. That he too, was just watching SpongeBob in the living room when he heard a ‘pop’ from the bedroom and found her with a ‘self-inflicted’ gun shot wound to her chin. An investigation begins. The rifle used measures 27 and 1/8th inches long from barrel to trigger. Jennifer’s arm is 26 and 3/16th inches long. Nothing comes of it. The medical examiner observes red strangulation marks around Jennifer’s neck. The investigation is over within one day. Jennifer’s death is declared a self exit. They don’t test for gunshot residue on the boyfriend, Anthony. They don’t look into his past record of abuse and SA. After all, Anthony lives with his father, Clement Richards Senior, the ma...
Loading summary
Narrator/Host
Having insurance isn't the same as having State Farm. It's like showing up for movie night ready for a heart pounding thriller. But getting a three hour documentary on lawn care, that's kind of like insurance. Insurance may all seem the same on the surface, but when it comes to getting the help you need, State Farm is the real deal. You wouldn't settle for a snooze fest when you came for a thrill ride. So don't settle for just any insurance when there's State Farm. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice
Adobe Acrobat, your new foundation. Use PDF spaces to generate a presentation. Grab your docs, your permits, your moves, AI levels of your pitch. Gets it in a groove. Choose a template with your timeless cool. Come on now, let's flex those tunes. Draft, design, deliver, make it sing. AI builds the deck so you can build that thing. Do that, do that, do that with Acrobat. Learn more@adobe.com do that with Acrobat.
Narrator/Host
Bada bing, bada boo. 6pm in Kotzebue, Alaska it means absolutely nothing because in Kotzbu it's always either very bright or always very dark. There is. I mean, that's really not a metaphor. This is not something deeper. It's always either sunny all day long until you drive yourself crazy at night because you need to block out any light that's coming in through the window so that you can fall asleep at 11pm or, or you get three hours of sunlight the entire day and then you just live in perpetual darkness. There is no middle ground like most places to give you a point of reference. In New York City during the summer you get about 14 hours of sunlight. During the winter you get closer to 10 hours of sunlight. But it is pretty standard. You know, usually during the winter, sun sets at 5pm during the summer it's closer to 8pm that's not what happens in Kotzebue. Katzebue is above the Arctic Circle in Alaska, which means the winters are almost pitch black all night, all day long.
Interviewer/Guest
But it's in the U.S. yeah, in Alaska. Okay.
Narrator/Host
It's actually closer to Russia than it is to Anchorage, Alaska. It's very interesting. Now the area north of the Arctic Circle is Probably only about 4% of the Earth's entire surface. And all you really need to know is that if you live above the Arctic Circle, things like daytime, nighttime, it doesn't mean anything. During the winter time, it feels like Katzebue has, has some sort of dread countdown that starts in September. September starts, you wake up, sun rises at noon 11:57am noon when half the workday is already over for most of everybody else. And then the sun sets before you're even out of the office at 3:21pm Barely 3 hours and 24 minutes of actual sun. But that's not even the worst of it. Each day of early December shave off another five to seven minutes of daylight. In Katzebue, the shortest day of the year is December 21st. Sun rises just right around 1pm and sets at 2:39pm you get 2 hours and 5 minutes of sunlight and that's it. And also, this is not 2 hours of high UV. Go outside and just get blessed with the vitamin D just blasting in the summer sun. That's not what it is. The sun does not go more than a few degrees over the horizon. So it feels like a very eerie two hour long golden hour. And then it's just gone. And sometimes it's not even just pitch black. There's a lot of residents, they say that they actually prefer pitch blackness in the winter, but they have these hours that they call blue hours. And everything is like a really haunting, intense, saturated blue. It's not bright, it's not dark, but it's just like everything is a blue tint during the winter. Alaskans have a term called big dark. It's just like a heavy weight that you feel during the wintertime. Even though there might not be anything inherently wrong, you just feel like everything is wrong. It's likely due to the melatonin production in the body. And serotonin also crashes when there's less light input. So you have surging melatonin falling serotonin. And Alaska has one of the highest rates of seasonal depression in the entire country.
Interviewer/Guest
Wow.
Narrator/Host
Someone who moved to a town north of the Arctic Circle thought it's going to be easy. It's going to be easy to acclimate because quote, you know, I knew it would take some time to acclimate for it, but I thought I prepared. I love the cold. I love the dark. I've always wanted to go somewhere dark and cold because I feel like I would thrive in this climate. I was dead wrong. I did not realize how much humans rely on light and dark cycles. I've tried to become more physically active by going on daily walks and taking all my vitamin D supplements, but my mind is beyond fucked. And then the minute that you adjust, it's time for summer. Starting in May, Katsu Bewitched Suddenly never gets dark. The sun rises at 5:53am and then it sets at midnight. Damn, you have nearly 18 hours of sunlight. But that's just the beginning. Eventually the sun is going to be up for close to 23 hours.
Interviewer/Guest
That is crazy to be living in a place like this.
Narrator/Host
And when that, you know, 23 hours of the 24 hours, that doesn't mean that you have that one hour of like pitch darkness. It never really transitions into dark either. So it just always feels like daytime. And that is when a call is made to 911. 6pm May 2018. You don't even know if the sun is setting anytime soon. It probably isn't. 911 gets a call in Katzebue that someone might be dead. Two officers from the local police department. They drive up to the house in question. They walk up to the front door and it doesn't really strike them as the type of house where something bad is happening inside. They swing open the front door. It's open. And in the living room there are two small children, one watching SpongeBob on the TV. It's kind of like a weird feeling. One of the officers gets one of the kids attention. Did someone call the police? One of the young boys points to the bedroom door. Okay, very strange. The officers start walking closer to the door in question. It's partially open. And when they peer in, there is a man holding a woman's body. This man is coated in blood. His clothes are soaked in blood, his arms, his pants, any part of this man named Anthony that the police can see. There is blood coating Anthony. And the woman that he's holding is this small 25 year old Inupiaq indigenous woman. She's in a fetal position. There's this.22 caliber rifle laying nearby. And the officers glance around and they do notice blood splatter on the floor, the dresser, mattress, blankets, there's even a few plastic totes on the ground nearby that's covered in blood splatter. She's been shot under her chin. Her name is Jennifer Kirk and she's now dead. The man holding her body, Anthony, he speaks up first. He's her boyfriend. He says he was in the living room watching spongebob with the two kids when he heard this pop sound go off. It sounded like a firework inside the bedroom. So he runs in, he finds her on the ground bleeding heavily from her head. Quote, I have no idea what happened
Interviewer/Guest
when you say under her chin, like right here under her chin, from bottom to top.
Narrator/Host
The investigators, they place Jennifer's body into a body bag to transport to the medical examiner's office. Bag is Sealed with the tag number 001-0959. The investigators, they notice a few things. I mean, first they pull out a tape measure. They measure the rifle from the tip of the barrel. So this is where the bullet comes out. It exits the gun at that point. And then the tip of the trigger, not the handle, not the other end of the gun, the trigger. You need to press this for the gun to fire. It is 27 and 18 inches long. And then they measure Jennifer's arm. Jennifer's arm is 26 inches and 316 inches long. Her arm is shorter than the trigger to the barrel. Her arm is shorter than the gun. But they believe she self exited. Then at the morgue, as the medical examiner unseals the body bag number 001-0959, they notice red markings around Jennifer Kirk's neck. And there's clear handprints around her neck. So Jennifer Kirk did not just stain a fatal gunshot wound. She was strangled before she died. The investigators, they do not ask the next obvious questions. Instead, they close the case within one day of investigating. And they state that Jennifer Kirk sadly, tragically, self exited. They don't ask the man, Anthony to test his hands or his clothes for gunshot residue. They don't look into his past because he has a past record of abuse and essay. They barely question him. They don't canvass the neighborhood. They don't interview anyone that might know something. They also don't go into the house and turn it upside down, searching every square inch for any sort of evidence. Because after all, it would be kind of weird to search the mayor's house, right? Anthony Richards, the man covered in blood, is the son of Clement Richards Sr. The mayor of the Northwest Arctic Bureau. How could a mayor's son ever turn out to be a killer? And even if they find another body in that house two years after Jennifer Kirk, do they really need to do something about it? We would like to thank today's sponsors who have made it possible for Rotten Mango to support the manilac Association. They are an indigenously operated nonprofit that provides high quality, culturally relevant health, social and tribal services in the Northwest Arctic Bureau. This episode's partnerships have also made it possible to support Rotten Mango's growing team. And we would also like to thank you guys for your continued support. I will say that there is this huge expose done with ProPublica and Anchorage Daily News with the journalist Kyle Hopkins. It's so informative. They went and they spoke to so many people in town. They did investigative boots on the ground, investigative work and it's just a great piece of journalism. So please go take a look at that. With that being said, today's case involves mentions of self exit DV gun violence. However, the biggest thing to be aware of it involves missing and murdered indigenous peoples. There's going to be especially sensitive conversations about institutional racism, systemic neglect, police negligence, misconduct, prosecutorial failures. So please, if you feel overwhelmed, take a break and I will see you in the next one. Statements and quotes have been condensed for brevity. Everything researched for this video was found publicly available and that is in comments. Statements, speculations and accusations are not our own. And our own only mentioned for comprehensive reporting. So with that being said, nobody has been charged. But I have my opinions. But let's get into it.
Interviewer/Guest
Really.
Narrator/Host
Yeah. Being a political figure is all about how you deal with a scandal. Almost all the time. It's a scandal that is caused by their own actions. But nevertheless, it is how they bounce back from the scandal. It's not even about the scandal itself. Sometimes it requires you take the shit that is thrown at you for good reason. You deserve shit thrown at you, but then you take it and you throw it back at somebody else. You think I'm bad? Go look at that person. Did you see what they said? Sometimes it's all about ignore the giant elephant in the room. You ignore it so much that everybody else gets used to the elephant being in the room. It's like how you forget how to blink or breathe because you're just always doing it. You're always breathing and blinking without addressing it. So everyone forgets that the elephant is in there. And then once in a while, someone will walk into the press room and go, holy shit, there's an elephant in here. And everyone goes, forgot about the fucking elephant. Or sometimes the comeback requires going to jail and serving your time. It feels like most mayors have their scandal at some point in their careers. Are you really a politician if you're not? Probably. In the Epstein files, former mayor of D.C. marion Barry. Thankfully not in the Epstein files. I will say that this is historically one of the biggest mayoral scandals. And this is not me saying that this is like the worst thing a mayor has done. It's just historically known as a massive mayor's scandal. It's the crack scandal. And I will say for all that Marianne Barry and all that he did, that was kind of bad, okay? Because most and all mayors seem to be bad. There always is some level of corruption. The standard is all mayors are bad. Some just do a little bit more good than bad for their Own citizens. It does need to be noted that Marion Barry had some very bad streaks. Marion Barry was the former D.C. washington D.C. mayor and he was known as the Chocolate King. Chocolate King of the Chocolate City. They called it the Chocolate City. And he did, I will say, like people love Marion, but he was known for having a lot of hot takes. He offended Polish Americans by calling them a slur. He then stated that he would like to, quote, do something about these Asians coming in, opening businesses, those dirty shops they ought to go. Then he offended Filipino Americans by pointing out that there's so many nurses immigrating from the Philippines into the United States to, you know, save lives. And he says, and no offense, but let's grow our own teachers, let's grow our own nurses so that we don't have to be scrounging around in our community clinics and other kinds of places having to hire people from somewhere else. So he managed, yeah, to piss off a lot of communities. But he loved his own people. And for that a lot of people just could not fault him. As mayor of D.C. he increased the share of government contracts awarded to black owned businesses from 5% to 40%. He also required private corporations doing businesses in Washington D.C. to appoint women and minorities to leadership positions. One tribute about Barry's work says, quote, single handedly expanded the black middle class in D.C. and created a generation of black millionaires in a time when economic and cultural segregation was rampant. He was also notorious for like driving around the city and if he saw someone on the street, he'd be like, do you have a job? And they would say no and they'd get a job by the afternoon. He wanted everyone to have a job. Yeah.
Interviewer/Guest
Wow.
Narrator/Host
I would hope that his discriminatory remarks against Asians, Polish people, I mean, I hope it was a big learning moment for him, a moment of growth. But regardless, he won reelection countless times. And regardless of these remarks, he just keeps getting elected and elected. And he honestly did change the trajectory of so many families lives, probably with generational impact. Like ultimately, Marion Barry did a lot of good, but then he smoked crack and this was a huge thing. So for years federal investigators, they've been trying to get Barry on something. You have to wonder if. It's almost like they were, they chose their target and they're just waiting for something to come up so that they could take Marion Barry down. They didn't like that a black Democrat kept winning mayor for Washington D.C. when was this? Oh, this was a long time ago, decades ago. He's, he's since Passed.
Interviewer/Guest
Okay, okay.
Narrator/Host
But this is probably one of the biggest mayoral scandals that there ever was. This is like back when mayors did regular crimes of corruption and drugs. And now they do like Epstein crimes. So, you know, they get Mayor Barry's ex girlfriend come in, the feds, the FBI. And she's also under pressure. The FBI are being overwhelmingly nice to her, and she agrees to set up a room, a hotel room outfitted with two secret cameras, courtesy of the FBI. And just three days before Mayor Barry is going to announce that he's going to run for mayor for the fourth term, he walks into the hotel room and he wants to rekindle this relationship romantically. She denies, especially because there's just another strange woman sitting in the corner of the room. Her name is Wanda, but her name is not really Wanda because she's an FBI undercover agent. And so she's sitting there and she's like, oh, I'm just a friend of your ex girlfriend. Do you want to smoke crack? Mayor Barry is like, no. She then asks him again, are you sure you don't want to smoke crack? He's like, no, I don't want to smoke crack. And then she brings it up again and again. And finally, Mayor Berry picks up the crack pipe, inhales twice, and a second later, the door is kicked open. FBI agents, D.C. police, they arrest Mayor Barry. To which he responds, and this is now the viral quote, goddamn bitch. Set me up like this. Set me up. Ain't that. Those are his words. And that's why people love Mayor Barry, okay? Like, people love Mayor Barry. And then he looks.
Interviewer/Guest
They did set him up.
Narrator/Host
They literally said it. I mean, I don't even know how. This is not entrapment. It's just straight up entrapment. At this point, she asked so many times, are you sure you don't want to smoke crack?
Interviewer/Guest
So what? Why the fucking girlfriend sold out like that.
Narrator/Host
I think they were scaring her. I think they were scaring the shit out of her. Now, I do want to know. Mayor Berry did a lot of drugs. Like, it is a truth. He's done a lot of drugs, all various sorts of drugs. This was a huge scandal back then because the press is racist. So first of all, the setup itself is disturbing. I think it's entrapment. And then instead of the articles afterwards just saying, oh, my gosh, our mayor was caught doing drugs. Which would have been the headlines, had a white mayor been caught doing cocaine. There is the persistent racism of a black man smoking crack. Which, by the way, I just want to note that there is a sentencing ratio of 100 to 1 between crack and powder cocaine, which technically the molecule high is like the same thing. Which means if you have two sugar packets of crack, you get a mandatory five year prison sentence. Meanwhile, you'll probably see an influencer do more than that of cocaine in a Carbone or Nobu bathroom on any given Saturday night. So in order to get a mandatory five year sentence for cocaine, you need to have over a pound of cocaine. Perhaps the more cleanly moral, morally indisputable act is that he tried to rekindle his relationship with his ex in the hotel room while he's married. And his wife did support him through the entire trial. So anyway, he goes to jail for six months in federal prison and once he's released, he runs for mayor again and he wins.
Interviewer/Guest
He's back.
Narrator/Host
Yeah, he's back.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice 2
He's back.
Narrator/Host
Yeah.
Interviewer/Guest
Wow.
Narrator/Host
He has since passed, but yeah, he was back. This is like a crazy comeback from Mayor. This is, I mean, a lot of political consultants, they study Mayor Barry.
Interviewer/Guest
Wow. So people actually like the fact that he was like, the bitch set me up.
Narrator/Host
Yeah, they love that he was very real about it. And they also love the fact that he was dealing with addiction because I think a lot of people could relate to it. And again, it's like, wouldn't you rather your mayor be doing drugs than committing crimes against women and children? Because nowadays it seems like every other mayor is at risk of being found in the files or being accused of essay. But even that would be more easily navigated than a situation that Mayor Clement Richards Sr. Finds himself in. Monday morning, police are called to the mayor's house. You know how this goes. You've heard it before. A woman, Inua Pag, found in the house dead, strangulation marks. Boyfriend is the mayor's son. You already know this story From May of 2018, when the sun had no intention of setting. It's hot outside. The sun is up. Jennifer Kirk is found dead at the foot of the bed. We but this is not that Monday morning. This is March 9, 2020. It's 8:32am the sun hasn't even gotten up. It won't rise until 9:30am the temperature is 13 degrees below zero. And the police find another body. 30 years old. Anua Pag, beaten. Strangulation marks around her neck. And her name is Susanna Norton, but everybody calls her Susu. She shares the same birthday as Jennifer Kirk. August 21st. And both of them are found dead in the mayor's house.
Interviewer/Guest
So Mayor Lives in this house, too?
Narrator/Host
Yes.
Interviewer/Guest
With the son?
Narrator/Host
Yes.
Interviewer/Guest
And in the beginning, who are those two kids watching tv.
Narrator/Host
So the son's kids with Jennifer Kirk.
Interviewer/Guest
Oh, that's Jennifer Kirk's kids. How old are they?
Narrator/Host
They're described to be juveniles.
Interviewer/Guest
That's crazy.
Narrator/Host
Okay, the term op book is not like a new term. It's been around for a while. It's a research book for the op, the opponent, the opposition in a political race. So what you do when you're trying to run for mayor or any elected office where there is a lot of money funneled into the campaigns, you hire two to three specialists, they're called researchers, and you pay them anywhere between $20,000 to $80,000 to do a full workup of the inside and outside your opposition. The researchers will go and dig through archived old news reports, voting records, campaign finance filings, social media posts. An op book researcher says, I was hired because they saw the opposition as a threat. My job was to try and kill him. I mean, not literally, but you get what I'm saying, right? Let's say you do find some dirt on the opposition. What do they do then? Well, they study it for the debates. But there's been this long standing tradition, it seems that the researchers will share that material with a journalist on the condition of no fingerprints. The journalist gets to break a story with inside sources. The campaign recycles the published story into attack ads, debate talking points. And while the candidate acts like I found out through the news, just like everybody else, and they act just as outraged as all the other citizens, you can sometimes tell by the release timing if this is from an op book. In mayoral races, if one candidate consistently has bad information coming out on the day of press releases or big gatherings and rallies. And it could just be very well released from the other party, which is why it's important. Usually big campaigns, if they only have the budget to do one op book, they do a self op. Oh, researchers, yeah, make an op book on you, the candidate, because you know the other party's going to do it. You need good counterpoints. You need to make sure that you're not taken off guard. I mean, it takes a lot to run for mayor or really any elected office beyond that. And that's why people like to play dirty. So some wealthy candidates have also been known to hire every political consultant in the market not to use all of their services at once, but to prevent the opponents from accessing them. It's kind of like when wealthy people, they get a divorce and they hire all they put all the best family attorneys in the city on a retainer so that their partner can't use them. It's kind of like that. It takes a lot to win the race to be mayor, but it really depends what you get out of it, depending on the mayor system. So some cities have what's called a strong mayor system. New York, Chicago, Houston. Mayor gets to appoint the heads of departments, they help draft and propose budgets. They have a lot of executive power. Then you have a weak mayor system where you're pretty much just like chairing the council meetings and cutting ribbons. Like you don't really have any independent executive authority. You're just there.
Interviewer/Guest
So there's more money in the strong one. Is that what you mean?
Narrator/Host
And it's very strange. So there are some major cities where the mayor only gets paid like $100,000. And then there will be a city in Florida with a thousand residents and the mayor is getting paid a quarter million dollars.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice 2
Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance. And now we're customizing this rush hour ad to keep you calm, which could help your driving. And science says therapy is great for a healthy mindset. So enjoy this 14 second session on us. I think you've done everything right and absolutely nothing wrong. In fact, anything that hasn't gone your way could probably be blamed on your father not being emotional, available because his father wasn't emotionally available, and so on. And now that you're calm and healing, you're probably driving better too.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice
Liberty, Liberty, Liberty. Liberty. Adobe Acrobat, your new foundation. Use PDF spaces to generate a presentation. Grab your docs, your permits, your moves. AI levels up, your pitch gets it in a groove. Choose a template with your timeless cool. Come on now, let's fly. Flex those tunes. Draft, design, deliver, make it sing. AI builds the deck so you can build that thing. Do that, do that, do that with Acrobat. Learn more@adobe.com do that with Acrobat.
Interviewer/Guest
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile with a message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint.
Narrator/Host
You can get premium wireless for just 15amonth.
Interviewer/Guest
Of course, if you enjoy overpaying. No judgments.
Narrator/Host
But that's weird.
Interviewer/Guest
Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront
Narrator/Host
payment of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See full terms@mintmobile.com. Now the Northwest Arctic Bureau in Alaska That's a strong mayor system. The charter for it explicitly states the executive power in the borough is vested in the mayor. The borough mayor, as the chief administrative officer, is responsible for all proper administration of all bureau affairs. That gives Mayor Clement Richards a whole lot of power. A lot of power. Enough power that he is going to be in charge of a $60 million construction contract and there's going to be allegations that he's blackmailed into this contract to. Because there is a video of him that exists with an underage girl.
Interviewer/Guest
Is that a rumor?
Narrator/Host
It's a rumor now. One month after Mayor Clement is elected into office, a police officer knocks on his door. I mean, technically this is a very uncomfortable situation for the police officer to be in, but he's got a job to do. The officer was called by Jennifer Kirk, a 22 year old. So this is when she's 22, she passes away. At 25, she reports that she was punched in the face by someone who lives in this very house, the mayor's son. So the report reads from the perspective of the officer. I asked Jennifer how Anthony assaulted her and she stated that they were having intercourse and he tried to have anal intercourse. And when she told him no, Jennifer then stated that Anthony punched her in the back three times, causing pain, and punched her in the right eye twice, causing pain, swelling and a bloodshot eye. Jennifer said Anthony also grabbed her right arm, leaving bruises just above her wrist. Obviously the officer has to investigate. He walks up to the mayor's front door and he knocks and he knocks again. And then Mayor Richards, Mayor Clement, he opens the door and he smells drunk, or at least according to the report, quote, appeared extremely intoxicated. And then the mayor just aggressively starts asking, how can I help you? How can I help you? How can I help you? Doesn't give the officer a chance to respond. He asks, how can I help you? Three times and then slams the door shut. It's like very odd behavior. This is one month after he becomes mayor. What is the officer supposed to do? Knock again? He doesn't. Instead he just moves on and so does everybody else until three years later, Jennifer Kirk is found dead inside that house. And there are clear markings of strangulation. She was shot with a gun that is longer than her entire arm. And it's ruled a self exit. And the police and the mayor, they move on and to the next big case. So instead of answering questions about what happened in his own house, what his son could have been involved in, the mayor is out there on a podium involved in Another case answering questions about Ashley Johnson bar. Ashley Johnson Barr is the girl in purple. So, okay, there's a lot that you have to know about the whole area of Kotzebue. It's closer to Russia, like I said, than Anchorage. It's a very isolated area. It's part of this like frying pan shaped peninsula in Alaska. And it's actually believed to be one of the oldest continuously inhabited settlements in the Americas. The land should belong to the Inuit people, and they do comprise of roughly 75% of the population. But of course it's stolen land. But a lot more on this later. It's a very small population where. Yes, the trope. Everybody knows everybody. And it's true. It's also true that September 6, 2018, everybody knows that 10 year old Ashley Johnson Barr does not come home. And everybody knows Ashley Johnson Barr. People say she's the kid that just seemed to be everywhere. Like she could teleport. She'll be picking blueberries with her family and then showing up to five different church services and Bible studies every single week. If there's a body of water, she's probably trying to change into a swimsuit and swim in it, even if it's a puddle. But that Thursday evening, she goes to hang out at the playground in the town center. And this is not like other parts of the US where kids are not out by themselves. She's got a phone, she's at the town center. This is very normal for kids in this area.
Interviewer/Guest
This happened after Jennifer's body was found,
Narrator/Host
or three months after Jennifer's body is found in this case. Ashley Johnson Barr's case does make national news. And because the mayor is the mayor of the town that this is occurring in, he almost becomes like this spokesperson for this case, and yet nobody's asking him about the fact that three months ago a woman was found dead on his property and his own son was covered in her own blood.
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah. How does that make sense? Why does nobody.
Narrator/Host
Exactly.
Interviewer/Guest
This is just like he has so much power that it's been silenced from the town. Wow.
Narrator/Host
And again, this is a town where, like I said, it's that trope. Everybody knows everybody. And Ashley goes missing. And for eight days, all hell breaks loose. Boats, helicopters, canine units are flown into the town to help. The Coast Guard gets involved. At any given time, there were as many as 50 people searching for Ashley. September 14, 2018. A volunteer spots Ashley's body in the tundra a few miles outside of town. She had been essayed and strangled to death at 10 years old. So very quickly, a 41 year old man, Peter Vance Wilson, gets arrested. I mean, the first sign that something was wrong with Peter was a relative. A relative of Peter's was going to. Everyone in town is looking for Ashley and he's going through Peter's coat. I don't know if he was hanging the coat up or if it was just like sprawled out on the couch. So he's picking it up and he notices something heavy in the pocket. He reaches in and it's Ashley's phone. Okay? Now, DNA testing also showed that he was the one that kidnapped Ashley, essayed her, and then strangled her with her own pants. He also eventually confessed. But the infuriating part about all of this is that all these people start coming forward and they keep saying, we knew that Peter had problems. And we tried to tell everybody that Peter had problems. Two female relatives stated that Peter had repeatedly throughout their entire childhoods essayed them and he never got in trouble. He started essaying his relatives when he was 12 years old. Family members describe as many as 40 different accounts of essay from Peter. And they tried to tell people and nobody was listening to anybody.
Interviewer/Guest
Like, the police station isn't doing anything.
Narrator/Host
Yeah, nobody's doing anything. They just, you know, Ashley's father even states, quote, some ladies and young girls sure did try and go and speak up. Guess what happened? Nothing happened. People told them, they never did this to you. You're just making up stories. But Ashley's case is monumental for a number of reasons. I mean, I could do a whole episode on this, but people realized how much resources they could actually mobilize. I mean, the way that people came together to find Ashley, how the entire state of Alaska seemed to come together, that means the resources are there. So if the case is there, this should be the reception for every missing and murdered indigenous person. Not just like once in a while, but every single time. Secondly, there was this sentiment in Alaska that a culture of silence is not going to be tolerated anymore. If someone had taken accusations against Peter seriously, Ashley would still be alive. Many of Peter's relatives would have been safer. Ashley's dad stays. Our daughter started something. No more silence. I mean, there's just so much more to the case. But I mean, her parents are doing a lot of good for women and children in Alaska. However, one of the most vocal people during the entirety of this case is this one man who just kind of inserts himself into all of this, Mayor Clement Richards. He's all over the news stations when the searches for Ashley is taking place. And it's infuriating because like everything that Ashley's legacy symbolizes, the mayor is exploiting because it's. If anyone profits from a culture of silence, it's clearly Mayor Clement Richards Sr. Because just three months before he makes himself the spokesperson for Ashley's passing, Jennifer Kirk was found dead in his house. And he's just sweeping it under the rug. Some people just really make it easy for the police to do their job. Some cases just like are very easy to solve. Or at least that's what it feels like. You get a checklist, hey, these are the five things you need to do. Find the evidence, check off the box. We're going to trial, you're getting a conviction. Jennifer Kirk's case feels like that. It feels so easy. Either the truth is it's in the evidence that she did self exit like the police claim that she did, or naturally there's something else to look into, like the mayor's son, Anthony. I mean, how much more literal with the red flags do we have to get? The police department in their own report, quote, I noted the rifle from the tip of the barrel to the tip of the trigger as being 27 and 118 inches long. Jennifer's arm, they note in the report, is shorter than that. When the police first bring in Anthony into the police station right after finding Jennifer Kirk's body, they interview him. They don't arrest him, they don't interrogate him, they just ask him questions and they listen to Anthony's side of events, which go like this. I was watching TV with the kids, I heard a pop. And then I saw Jennifer, you know, I had seen Jennifer go into the bedroom, so I freaked out. I go into the bedroom, I see her. I go to the neighbor's house and I told them to call 911. He states that Jennifer was still breathing when he found her. And you know, they've been in this very long relationship, they have kids together who are in the living room and she just self exits. He explains. It's kind of a long story. And they're like, well tell us. So she has this court date in her hometown, which is like a few towns over for dui. She's supposed to turn herself in, but she was scared to go. But I keep telling her like, you gotta just get it over with, you gotta go and turn yourself in. I kept telling her that she needed to. And then she starts getting emotional, emotional crying and like accusing Anthony of not wanting to be with her anymore. And Anthony tells the officer, essentially I told her not to cry in front of the kids. And I told her to go lay down in the room and calm down. He stays out in the living room watching SpongeBob with the kids. And it's like an hour in when he hears that firecracker go off. So he rushes into the room, he finds that she shot herself. And he explains, you know, this is very Jennifer. She's really good at hiding her emotions until she. It's like an explosion. Why did you go to your neighbor's house to call 91 1? Well, I couldn't find my phone, so I ran next door. Which side note, the mayor's house is about a block away from the police department. So continuing on, he gets back from telling the neighbor to call the police. He goes back to Jennifer's body, and he holds her. That's how he's described. It's described that he does not attempt cpr. He doesn't try to stop the bleeding. He's just, like, coating himself in her blood, holding her. After what can only be described as a very suspicious story, the police are like, well, you're free to go. We're not arresting you. Right. When he leaves, the investigators get a call from the Emmys office, and they advise the police that not only does Jennifer's body have a fatal bullet wound, but there are signs of strangulation on her neck, like handprints. She was strangled before she died. And this police department is not big at all. Which, by the way, that's another thing that I have a personal gripe about this. Okay, so we tried to FOIA request this case a long time ago, and a team member on the RM team was kept trying to get in touch with the police department. And we've, like, we do FOIA requests all around, different states and different towns, different cities, different police departments. And some police departments, each one operates differently, and each one feels like a whole new learning process of, like, how to get a FOIA request. This is a small, tiny little police department, and it took suspiciously long to get a response from them, like, in a way that it didn't make any sense, in my opinion. So this entire little, tiny, little police department, they probably know everybody. And they know that a month after Clement is elected into office. So a few years ago, an officer got called out to the mayor's house by Jennifer Kirk because she reported that Anthony had assaulted her. And now she's dead a few years later. All they have to do is a little bit of due diligence. And if you're already pulling up his profile, you can also clearly see that September 2017, Jennifer called 911 again. She's actually still at the mayor's house. She waits for the officers to arrive. She's standing out in the driveway, she's crying. And she tells the responding officer, anthony just choked her. He strangled her. And she's explaining like she had gotten into town, she wanted to see Anthony. So right from the airport, she goes to the mayor's house. Both of them start drinking, and Jennifer just wants to go back to her hotel and. And she even offers Anthony, do you want to come back to my hotel with me? But Anthony does not want her to go back to her hotel. In fact, he doesn't even want her to go. And the fact that she even offered for both of them to go is seemingly so offensive and such a heinous thing for Jennifer to do that Anthony starts verbally screaming at her. And then he slams her down onto the bedroom floor, sits on top of Jennifer, putting his entire body weight on top of her. So he's not only preventing her from getting up, he's full on suffocating her. Jennifer states that she just kept trying to struggle with Anthony to get up. And he only does because she starts pinching him really, really hard. He gets up and I assume it felt like they were both cooling down because Jennifer sits on the bed. And then she calmly tells him once more that she wants to go back to the hotel. This time he climbs up onto the bed, pushes her down, and he grabs her neck with both of his hands and starts strangling her. Her vision starts narrowing. She tells the police that she couldn't breathe. She's terrified of passing out. And the report reads, Jennifer eventually was able to get away from Anthony, and during this struggle to do so, she sustained a visible laceration from the top right side of her head. The officers go to investigate and guess what? Anthony is on probation. He's drunk. When they go to talk to him, he's drunk. He's violating state law by abusing, violently abusing Jennifer. So he's arrested for breaking probation. And with this, I feel like the police have a pretty at face value a suspicious story of death. They've got strangulation marks on the deceased, a history of violence and strangulation documented by various criminal charges. And the police officers, they were even trained. Top 10 red flags for domestic violence killings. And pretty much every single one of them checks off. The red flags consist of victim dies prematurely. Jennifer Kirk is 25. Self exit or accident scene One partner wanted to end the relationship. Prior history of DV victim found dead in a home or a residence. Victim found by current or previous partner. Prior history of DV includes strangulation or suffocation. Partner is the last to see victim alive. Partner has control of the crime scene and body is moved or seen or evidence is altered in some way.
Interviewer/Guest
I mean, it's very clear what's going on. So has anybody said anything? Or they just closed the ca. Like there's. There's nothing.
Narrator/Host
Yes. So they bring Anthony back in and they're like, hey, we found strangulation marks on Jennifer Kirk's body. You didn't mention any of that. Do you care to tell us what happened? And he explains that. Well, he just blocked out that part because it's just like been a bad day. And he said it was all in self defense. He said that Jennifer started punching, slapping him on the side of his head. So in order to stop her, he does what any normal human does. He holds her back by her neck with both of his hands. It's like the most reasonable defensive stance. Of course, everybody's done it before. And Anthony says while he's doing this, she's still trying to slap him. Now when the police are like, well, how much pressure did you apply? He doesn't recall, did she fall unconscious or not? He doesn't remember. He doesn't remember if he knocked her unconscious or not. And all of this is happening in the kitchen. This is what he says, which is also kind of crazy because he made this whole thing about like, I don't want her to cry in front of the kid, but you're strangling her in front of the kids. So after she might have been maybe, maybe not knocked out. Anthony can't remember. And when she does become conscious, she goes to the bedroom and that's when she dies by herself. And with that, the police are given a pretty easy pathway to get to the bottom of what happened to Jennifer Kirk. And the entire town gets wrapped up in this hunt for the police department to find the strangler. Authorities are asking for the public's help. Help us find out who this. Here are the clues that we have. They're putting out like, pictures. One investigator states the police department suspects foul play and is pursuing all investigative leads. And they start putting up photos of the suspect in question. Tipsters are calling in. Volunteers are raising thousands of dollars. I mean, this news is all over the area. The strangler needs to be brought in and there needs to be justice. And they do catch him. They catch the strangler, they drag him to court. But it's not for Jennifer's death. It's not for the death of Jennifer Kirk. All of this police investigative efforts is for a husky. So around the same time that Jennifer Kirk is found dead, the city fire department's pet husky is also found dead. They close Jennifer's case and they do like a citywide hunt for the strangler.
Interviewer/Guest
For the husky.
Narrator/Host
Yes. And like, don't get me wrong, I think that person needs to be punished for sure. But what? Nothing.
Interviewer/Guest
For Jennifer, you think it's like a cover up? It's like a.
Narrator/Host
It seems like priorities. They don't care for Jennifer Kirk.
Interviewer/Guest
In fact, you think they don't care or they're hiding something. Right. Like they don't care is like, okay, I'm not going to do more investigation. Hiding is someone is covering up for. For. For someone.
Narrator/Host
I don't know if they're that smart.
Interviewer/Guest
Really?
Narrator/Host
Yeah.
Interviewer/Guest
You're telling me. Mayor's son.
Narrator/Host
Yeah. House.
Interviewer/Guest
A woman died. The gun was longer than her arm. It wasn't. You don't think it was a cover up from the mayor?
Narrator/Host
No, I don't think the mayor is that smart. I think the mayor really runs on.
Interviewer/Guest
What made you think that, though?
Narrator/Host
Because everyone in town thought it was weird.
Interviewer/Guest
Everyone in town thought Jennifer Kirk's death is weird? Correct.
Narrator/Host
They don't care to make statements and make it make sense. They don't care to address it. It's just like, well, what are you gonna do about it? That's the feeling that I get. It's so blatant. It doesn't, it doesn't feel like a cover up of like, ooh, a diversion. Don't pay attention to this. Pay attention to this. It doesn't feel like that.
Interviewer/Guest
So why is there no investigation if.
Narrator/Host
Because the mayor controls the police department. This is a really small town.
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah.
Narrator/Host
And they don't care to investigate.
Interviewer/Guest
So the. Even the police who made the report rolled the gun is longer than the arm. That means he also suspected something, some kind of foul play.
Narrator/Host
Yeah, but he doesn't care.
Interviewer/Guest
Or he was told not to look
Narrator/Host
and he doesn't care enough to go against the status quo.
Interviewer/Guest
Right. So there's. There are some, Some kind of like cover up from the higher ant.
Narrator/Host
Yes, but I don't. They are alleged. Right. That's our personal opinion of just the limited information that we have. Right. In terms of the husky and the search for the strangler, I don't think it's some sort of Ooh, diversion. Don't let the community members. It doesn't seem like that. It seems like the community knows and the mayor is like, what are you going to do about it? Okay, that's the feeling.
Interviewer/Guest
But Jennifer's case.
Narrator/Host
Yes.
Interviewer/Guest
Is like someone said do not continue.
Narrator/Host
Yeah.
Interviewer/Guest
Okay. Okay. So that's a cover up.
Narrator/Host
It's unclear if someone said do not continue or the lead investigator got bonked on the head with a coconut and decided to close the case. You know, we don't know what happened behind closed doors. Legally speaking, that would be bad to say. Okay, you can come to your own personal conclusions about that. But all we know is that within one investigative day the case is closed and it's deemed a self exit. Whether the mayor said shut it down, whether the investigative lead said, wow, I did my due diligence of fucking eight hours and I think that this is a self exit. It's hard to say. Right.
Interviewer/Guest
What about Jennifer's families?
Narrator/Host
They think something is weird. They just want more investigations. They absolutely do not believe that she would self exit. She was just on the phone with her mom. They were preparing for like future plan. There was nothing to indicate that she is someone that would want to self exit. And then with all the history of domestic violence from Anthony, like it just to them it makes zero sense. Now with the ProPublica piece, the expose, the police are going to come back and say something about Jennifer's death and I'm going to get into it. And it's so infuriating. But it just feels like to some people, because of the lack of investigation into Jennifer Kirk's death, another person is going to end up dead. Because two years after Jennifer Kirk dies, Susu Norton dies. And the mayor's son is going to be in the court once more answering questions about Susu's death. But this time it's not Anthony. It's a different mayor's son, Amos. Okay, so Mayor Clement Richards Sr. Has three sons and all three of them have been charged with assaulting women on the mayor's property.
Interviewer/Guest
They all live together?
Narrator/Host
Yes. And it's not just one that's violently abusive. All three of them. There are at least 31 criminal cases involving the three sons and a total of six different victims. All three sons have been charged with a combined 16 counts of domestic violence. None of these charges resulted in felony domestic violence convictions. And when you start putting these timelines together, it's actually so disgusting, you want to lock the whole family up in a basement cell and feed them copious amounts of Advil on an empty stomach. It's just heinous. Okay? A few months after Jennifer Kirk is found dead, a woman walks into the police station with a right eye that is black and blue. It's swollen shut. She can't even open her eye. She's crying and she reports that her boyfriend Amos, the eldest of the mayor's three sons, has been abusing her. This is after. This is a few months after Jennifer Kirk is found dead on the mayor's property. So the police are like, well, we just found a dead woman on the mayor's property, and now another woman is walking in. She's got clear evidence of abuse, and she's saying that. That a different mayor's son, you know, the same mayor but a different son, is beating her. And she's got strangulation marks on her neck just like Jennifer or Jennifer Kirk had. This is Susu Norton, who will soon be killed. She says that her boyfriend Amos, he's a bit of a drinker. She wanted him to stop drinking, so she poured out his beer. He becomes so enraged, he grabs her by the hair, drags her around the entire house, kicks her repeatedly in the head, stomach, face, back. Her forearms are swollen from trying to protect her head and face while he's kicking her. And she's six months pregnant with his child. The incident report states, officer was unable to locate the defendant. That's pretty much it. Within two years, Susu Norton, just like Jennifer Kirk, will be found dead. They don't do anything. I mean, what do you expect from the sons whose own father, Mayor Clement Richards Sr. Has a felony domestic violence charge.
Interviewer/Guest
This is still the out. Is he still the mayor? Is he still out and about? What's going on?
Narrator/Host
He tried to run for reelection. He did not get reelected in 2018. And then in 2022, Susu Norton's body is found in the mayor's house and he's still out there. Kyle from ProPublica tried to go talk to him and he's like, no comment. He won't make any comments, nothing.
Interviewer/Guest
This is so bizarre. What is going on.
Narrator/Host
Now this happens when the mom, Annette. So this is Clement Richards. This is like the ex first lady of the town, I guess, right? But Annette is pregnant with their third son, Anthony. So they have three sons. Anthony is, you know, Jennifer Kirk's ex boyfriend. She's pregnant, and by this point, they already have two sons. She's eight months pregnant. And Clement Richards, in a fit of anger, beats her, kicks her in the stomach repeatedly until she starts profusely bleeding from her private area. The police are called to the house. Clement and his wife Annette are just sitting in the living room. She's bleeding. And the officer concludes that Clement had been dragging Annette around by her hair, kicked her in the stomach with boots on, and then punched her in several other parts of her body. The very next day, Anthony is born. Clement Sr. Pleads no contest to felony domestic violence assault and goes to jail for six months. Here's the mind boggling part. Remember the whole op book that political candidates get on their opposition. Former Mayor Clement Richards has a domestic violence charge. This charge that is publicly available to see. It's a matter of public record before he's elected to become mayor. Meaning when he runs for mayor, none of his opponents, nobody in the area, nobody in the media mentions or brings up the fact that he nearly killed his wife and child. Child nobody.
Interviewer/Guest
Because they don't do their homework.
Narrator/Host
Either they don't do their homework or it's like what a lot of people are saying. Enough is enough. This culture of silence is over with. I see he becomes vice mayor. Mayor. He's on the city council. He held political office from 1999 to 2018. I feel like that's longer than some of you guys have been alive with this charge.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice 2
Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance. And now we're customizing this rush hour ad to keep you calm, which could help your driving. And science says therapy is great for a healthy mindset. So enjoy this 14 second session on us. I think you've done everything right and absolutely nothing wrong. In fact, anything that hasn't gone your way could probably be blamed on your father not being emotionally available because his father wasn't emotionally available and so on. And now that you're calm and healing, you're probably driving better too.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice
Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty. Adobe Acrobat. Your team's home base. Collaborate within a shared PDF space.
Narrator/Host
You've got your docs, your plans, your
Advertiser/Commercial Voice
specs, and then invite the crew to build what's next. They talk up the teamwork. They think that this design could be a contender. When somebody wonders what's the next steps, AI helps you finish the rest.
Narrator/Host
Bolts are tight now. Your plan's refined. Run a smoother business.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice
When you're all aligned. Do that with Acrobat. Learn more@adobe.com Dothatwithrobat.
Narrator/Host
You're juggling a lot, but you can still squeeze in a financial plan with the Northwestern Mutual financial advisor as your partner. It's not only possible, it's personalized. So if you're tying the knot, closing on a house or welcoming a little one. You'll be ready for whatever life tosses your. Right time to feel less stressed and more certain. That's a better way to money. Let's get started@nm.com the Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company, Milwaukee, Wisconsin. And his wife Annette. She starts working for the Alaskan state troopers, working with prosecutors in the local area that later become judges. These judges then later oversee her son's domestic violence cases. Which side note, when Clement Richards was mayor, there was this huge scandal. So aside from Jennifer Kirk dying inside of his house while he holds public office, there's this huge construction bid, the construction project, $60 million. He's the mayor in a mayor strong system. And he gets to have like he's aggressively pushing for this no bid contract to be awarded to a local company called called Remote Solutions. They're going to get a 60 million dollar contract to construct the school, the highway. Like this is what they need. The school district still has to vote on it. So does the borough assembly. But he's like going to each person and he's like, you got to vote yes. It's got to go to Remote Solutions. Mayor Clement is using all of his power to swing the votes in his favor. They've got three special bureau assembly meetings. These were a huge scandal too. So one of them is like randomly held in Seattle. So they have to fly everybody out to Seattle and they spend like over $100,000 of taxpayer money. It's like, why do you have to have it in Seattle? It just seemed like a vacation. But then out of nowhere, allegedly, Clement Richards is like, wait, never mind, never mind. I take it all back. I don't want Remote Solutions to be the bid for this contract. Out of nowhere, all of this feels kind of par for the course. Like some political corruption go into Seattle, but it doesn't feel that bad. Right? But like, why did he suddenly change his mind? Why? Well, Clement Richards fires his chief of staff for the borough Eugene. And Eugene files a complaint to the police department. And he states that he was fired because he knew information that the mayor does not want to get out. Apparently this is what he alleges. The mayor was drunk driving a bureau vehicle. This is like a city car with a young underage girl in the car. He almost hits another car on the road. And that other driver that almost got hit, his name is Chris. He starts allegedly recording this incident on his phone that depicts the mayor driving drunk in a borough vehicle with a girl that appears to be Underage. Chris then goes and shows it to a bunch of people, who then notifies Eugene, the chief of staff. So Eugene is like, oh, my God. There's this video. He says, quote, I told our mayor that he needs to go talk to Chris about the situation. Clement notified me that Chris agreed to delete the video and told Clement. Clement not to do it again. Now he notices. Eugene is, like, noticing all these bureau meetings, and Clement is like, oh, we got to do Remote solutions. We got to do remote solutions. This is the bid for the construction work. Right? And then suddenly he's like, no, it's not. We're not doing remote solutions anymore, okay? And so Eugene is like, what the hell? And then Clement is, like, visibly upset. And so Eugene is like, what's wrong? Why are you upset? Eugene says, this is his claim, that Clement was told that. That Chris did not delete the video. And now the other parties who want this contract are telling Clement, drop. Get rid of the Baker Brothers. The Baker brothers own Remote Solutions.
Interviewer/Guest
Who's Baker Brothers?
Narrator/Host
They own Remote Solutions. Get rid of the Baker brothers, or this video goes out. So all of a sudden, he said, I don't want Remote Solutions anymore.
Interviewer/Guest
So basically, he has, like, a little underground deal with Baker's brother.
Narrator/Host
Brother. That's a big allegation, but okay.
Interviewer/Guest
You know, I mean, he really is trying to get Baker's brother.
Narrator/Host
Yes.
Interviewer/Guest
This deal for whatever personal. Whatever.
Narrator/Host
Could be for love, could be for whatever.
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah, yeah. He really liked them.
Narrator/Host
Yes.
Interviewer/Guest
And then someone, a competitor got their hands on Chris's video.
Narrator/Host
Yes.
Interviewer/Guest
Now they're kind of telling him to. We want the contract.
Narrator/Host
Kill the contract. Kill the deal. Because we want it. Now there's scandal about.
Interviewer/Guest
So why is Eugene getting fired for that, then?
Narrator/Host
So then Eugene is like, that's messed up. Up. He's like, telling Clement Richards, no, Like, that's messed up. You got to do something about it. Like, I. You cannot let this affect how you mayor this town. Then he gets fired. So then he's like, okay, well, I'm gonna file a report because you wrongfully terminated me for, like, having a morally upstanding take, okay? So. But I will say the other side of it, I went into too many rabbit holes, okay? But the other side of it, this is an allegation, but the other company, they. One of them shares a child with someone on the school board. So everybody's just trying to get the company that they get a kickback from. And I don't know if kickback should be used in, like, the very strict Definition of contractually, you get this much, but just you get some sort of indirect benefits. The driver was contacted by a journalist, and they say that there is no video, there's no involvement, but the whole thing was just a massive scandal. Just huge. It was an even bigger scandal than what's going on inside that house. The mayor's three sons, Amos, he has multiple charges against him, he's the eldest, for victimizing and abusing his girlfriend and the mother of his children, Susu Norton, while she's pregnant. He's violently assaulting her, just like his dad violently assaulted his mom while she was pregnant. Susu Norton's death is being investigated right now, and I would say almost would be, in most people's opinion, suspect number one. And then you have the second son, Clement Jr. One complaint filed against Clement Jr. Reads that a redacted victim called 911 to report that Clement Jr. The mayor's second son, was assaulting her inside the mayor's house. This is Clement Junior's girlfriend, and she says that she was trying to leave the house. Clement Jr gets up in her face, and she starts pushing her as she's walking out of the bedroom. Quote, the victim stated that when she turned around to push the defendant away from her, he began to punch her in the. And face, face. The victim said that she attempted to get away from the defendant but was unable to. He just keeps punching her until a third party, one of his friends that happens to be there, rips him off of her. The officers contact the defendant, Clement Jr. And they write that the defendant was extremely uncooperative and denied anything happened. He had a strong odor of alcohol on his breath as well as on his person. Red, watery eyes and poor balance. Now, Clement Jr. Pleads guilty to harassment and receives a second suspended sentence, and his conviction is wiped from public record. And then you have Anthony, the youngest son, Jennifer Kirk's abuser. He's got a lot of cases. Many of them are the ones that we've covered with Jennifer Kirk, her reports before her death. He also has another case against him, an essay case, where the victim states to the judge that she's terrified of running into Anthony because it's a small town. Which, by the way, Superior Court Judge Paul Roatman decides that he's going to give Anthony a special chance. And by special, I just mean very uncommon. So he gives Anthony a very low bill. This bill goes from being $7,500 to $2,500. And he explains his decision by saying that he worked with Anthony's mother and knew his father held elected office. What the fuck does that mean? The judge states, I know Mrs. Richards for when she used to work with the troopers. She has a lot of experience with these types of cases and know what these are like. Mr. Richards has been part of city council. You know, if you're not now, I don't know if you are now. So he's been part of the local council. So they're gonna be fine third parties?
Interviewer/Guest
I think they're gonna be fine third parties.
Narrator/Host
Yes. Okay. This is the system in which all of these little. Okay, they violently assault a woman, they get charged with felony assault, and then the judge gives them a low bail. And the judge is like, find third parties. Meaning, I think your mom and dad are gonna make sure that you don't try to run away, that you don't do anything crazy while you're out before the trial. And guess what? A trial never fucking happens. Because the prosecutors then come in and they're like, hey, plead guilty, and instead of a felony charge, we'll give you a misdemeanor for something like harassment. Instead of violently kicking someone in the
Interviewer/Guest
stomach while they're pregnant, they really run to town, huh?
Narrator/Host
Yeah. The judge even says, to say that you dodged a bullet is an understatement on this one. These are some pretty serious charges, and I understand the evidentiary issues that had been presented, but had those not been there, had those been less complicated? You were facing facing some very serious charges that involve a lot of jail time. You understand that? Of course. It just seems like a. Who's dodging a bullet? And how are they dodging a bullet? Through you? Judge Paul Rotman declined to comment, and a court spokesperson has stated judicial officers cannot and do not comment on their cases in order to maintain the integrity of their decisions and to ensure that for fairness reasons, their thinking is reflected solely in the official court record without extraneous commentary. Even though the code of conduct for judges state that, quote, shall not allow family, social, political, or other relationships to influence. Influence the judge's judicial conduct or judgment. So the sheer fact that he's like, why not your parents?
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah.
Narrator/Host
Even after the death of Jennifer Kirk, July 17, 2020. So this is actually after Jennifer Kirk's death and Susu Norton's death. There's another filing after two women are found dead in the house.
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah.
Narrator/Host
Except, okay, there. A woman reports her boyfriend scratched her face and kicked her. Her boyfriend being Anthony Richards.
Interviewer/Guest
What is going on in this house?
Narrator/Host
Yeah. She said that Anthony threw her onto the ground, kicked her and punched her in the face, started kicking her in the ribs, her legs, her back, her butt, causing pain. The officers actually located a third party witness who was like, oh, yeah, I saw that happen. And when they finally find Anthony in the report, it states that he starts cussing out the officers that he's not going to jail. And quote, while declaring to Anthony that he was under arrest, Anthony attempted to walk into the residence. Officer Aaron and I got a hold of him while I was trying to place handcuffs on Anthony. He grabbed my handcuff by the loop and would not let go, prompting me to pull my laser and demand that he let the handcuff go. Anthony Richards was arrested and transported to krj, where he remained uncooperative and refused to participate in a preliminary breath test.
Interviewer/Guest
Okay.
Narrator/Host
Okay.
Interviewer/Guest
And.
Narrator/Host
But he's out now.
Interviewer/Guest
So these, like, cops, they first get involved. They're like, that's us. I'm going to arrest you. You're going to get punished. And then they turn around just like, there's nothing going on here. Yeah, drop it.
Narrator/Host
Yeah. Or they arrest them. And then the judge is like, you guys are good, fine people. I see no reason to be suspicious of you. You can be out on bail until the trial. And then prosecutors. Remember Annette used to work with the prosecutors. Not saying that there's a connection, but I'm just saying that's an odd thing. Right, Right. They'll come in and they'll say, hey, plead guilty. I'll give you a misdemeanor. They do tiny bits of jail time here and there, but barely any. And these judges are actually insane. There's one judge that lowered his bail to $100. $100 while he's out on probation. $100. And he. There's an audio of this where he's talking to Anthony and he's explaining why strangulation is such a bad thing, aside from the fucking obvious. And he says, talking about the gravity of the situation, what jumps out at me in both of these cases is there's an allegation of strangulation in both cases, and that's the reason that this was charged as a felony case. Listen, I hope you do understand that you're serving a large amount of jail time. It's not large at all. Okay. But continuing. But you are getting away from a felony conviction by taking this agreement. That's a big benefit to you. But what I'm getting at is strangulation is a very serious thing, and it's recognized that way by the legislature. That's why these types of cases can be charged as felonies. You know, one thing I would like to point out to you is the natural result of a punch or kick or kind of, you know, your typical misdemeanor assault is a bruise or injury or that sort of thing, which is fucking false. Like you're a judge, you should know better. You should have at least some working neural pathways because people have died from one punch. The result of strangulation, if not stopped, is the person can't breathe. And that's death. And that's a serious thing. And that wasn't the result in your abuse case, fortunately, but someone who wasn't trained in the medical profession, that sort of thing, it's a, it's a dangerous thing because someone like you or I, you don't know when to let up or when it might be too late. So keep that in mind.
Interviewer/Guest
It's like you're talking to a five year old of not to play fight.
Narrator/Host
But also. And one comment reads, keep that in mind. The judge is literally saying next time you beat a woman, keep in mind strangulation is a bigger charge because you might accidentally kill them. Like, what do you mean keep in mind? And like, what do you mean a medical professional? We're not medical professionals, so we, we can't strangle women. Which. Side note, I don't know if you want to take a random comment online as truth or a fraction of the truth or like a flat out lie or a hallucination, it's up to you. But it reads, I worked a summer job in that town in 2008. One of my 16 year old co workers was viciously jumped by one of the Richards brothers while I was there. And another ex coworker got jumped right after I left. I tried to get the kid to go to the police, but he said their family is too powerful. Also, one of the police officers in that police department was basically fucking every girl in the area that was between 18 to 20 years old. And I'm not exaggerating, he was openly flaunting his relationship with these teens he groomed in front of everyone and nobody did a thing about it. I was just telling my partner how insane this place was like a week ago.
Interviewer/Guest
This town is out of control.
Narrator/Host
Yeah.
Interviewer/Guest
Whoa.
Narrator/Host
There's another nearby town, I believe in the Same Bureau where ProPublica did a huge expose on them as well. But every single police officer in that small police department, not this one, but it's a town nearby. They all have domestic violence charges. Every single one. And Actually, Alaska is one of the most dangerous states in the United States for a woman. Women are two and a half times more likely than the national average to be killed by a man in the state of Alaska. More than four in five indigenous women specifically have experienced violence in their lifetime. And indigenous women are killed at a rate 10 times the national average on any given day in the United States. Thousands of indigenous women and girls are listed as missing in federal databases. And no matter how large that number is, it's still not comprehensive. There is not even like a way to identify that someone is indigenous when they go missing. It's always like, white, Hispanic, Asian, black. There's no way. There's actually no comprehensive federal database that tracks how many indigenous women are missing. There's no reliable count of how many have been murdered. It said that. That when an indigenous woman disappears, she disappears three times in life, in the media, and then in the data. So we're working on a full episode on a few other cases. I mean, a lot of these take a lot of time because it's hard even to get, like, the FOIA requests, and it's just really difficult. But it all just comes down to this, which don't even get me started on the boarding schools, that they would systematically just eradicate indigenous culture, culture while saying indigenous women saying that their culture is lesser than other cultures. Meanwhile, you're r wording them. Every elected official gets up on every single fucking podium, shoves their face inside of a mic, and they pledge, they promise everyone that there's going to be change. And the only way that they're going to bring about change is the minute that their ass touches the seat of power. So you must vote for them specifically. It's very, very sympathetic words that are spoken with all of these politicians. And then the execution is completely hollow. It's empty. There's nothing of substance. Do they actually do something after the ProPublica expose on this case? In an open letter, the police chief states that state investigators reviewed the case of Jennifer's death in 2018 and they found no new leads. The letter reads, to the Kotzubi community. Since the news articles about several deaths were published by the Anchorage Daily News, past traumas and pains have been reopened in our community. These difficulties are not lost on me or your police department. The tragedy around the death of Jennifer Kirk in 2018 is one of many that weighs on our hearts. We need to advise the public that reading this letter may be disturbing for community members. Many in our community have raised questions or concerns about Jennifer's untimely death. I wanted you to hear from me directly on how the investigator assigned to the case took care to investigate Jennifer's passing and what the process looked like. So you have as much information as possible to make informed decisions about what you read, see or hear. They allege in this letter that the investigator spent at least 16 days interviewing witnesses, collecting evidence and following up leads before closing the case. Jennifer's own sister has come out to state that the police failed to properly communicate with the family during the initial investigation. They failed to interview certain witnesses. They even declined to provide the family police audio and video recordings from this closed investigation. Previously, Jennifer's parents were outspoken about stating that she would never self exit and that the police never even really spoke to her about anything. Also, it, it was closed within one investigation day. I don't know where he's coming up with 16 days all of a sudden. And also, if that's the case, you should prosecute Anthony for strangulation, even if you don't prosecute him for potentially being involved in something more sinister. But he admitted to strangling her before she died. They continued, the medical examiner has the ultimate authority in determining the case of death. After a thorough review of the evidence and post mortem autopsy, the medical examiner determined that there was no evidence that Jennifer had in any way been strangled prior to her death that day. There was also no evidence that anyone other than Jennifer fired the gun that ended her life. The police wrote in their own report that her arm is shorter than the gun. So suddenly it's no longer shorter than the gun and it's actually physically feasible that she could have pulled the trigger. They don't provide any context because I'm sure you could MacGyver the trigger in a way where if you pull something else, maybe the trigger is pulled. But they're, they're not saying that's what happened. They're just saying, no, I'm telling you this so you're going to believe it. And they counter it with this. Some have expressed concern whether it would have been physically possible for Jennifer to fire the rifle. Measurements taken of both Jennifer's body and the firearm show that it was. How? Literally how?
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah, it's just like physically like physics doesn't make math doesn't make sense.
Narrator/Host
I know this is hard to hear. Something I do want to note to you. We are aware of the domestic violence history in this case and in others. I want to be clear. I strongly and vehemently condemn that. No one should ever think that it is okay. To abuse another and cause harm. Those who do harm should face consequences. Okay, then persecute him for strangulation. While it is not my decision, nor my department's on prosecuting or sentencing those incidents, I do want you to know that I denounce domestic violence in the strongest possible terms. And while many of you have asked about Jennifer, others have also inquired about Susannah Norton. Her ongoing homicide investigation, Susanna, is not forgotten. We know that many find similarities in the location, family involved, and other circumstances surrounding her murder. I understand that. As your chief, I want you to know that we have reached out to the Alaska Bureau of Investigations and asked that them in 2021 to review the investigation. Which side note, they kind of refuted this. They were like, we were not requested in 2021 to look into Susannah Norton's death. Okay, so they're like, actually we were asked, like, later, not in 2021. So this police chief, I don't know where he's getting his numbers. Maybe I'm getting the numbers wrong, but, like, it just is not adding up at all in any sense of the word. I'm sure the Alaska Bureau of Investigations Missing and Missing and Murdered Indigenous Peoples Unit will provide updates to us and to the community as they move forward. Forward? This doesn't make sense. The Same reporter from ProPublica actually reached out to the police chief last year and asked a few series of questions. On what day did investigator Millette close Jennifer Kirk's death investigation? May 24, 2018 is the police chief's word. That's one day. One day. But now he's saying it's 16 days. The death investigation record suggests that the case was closed before investigator Miliet received the final autopsy report for Jennifer Kirk. Is that Kirk? Correct. And he says, correct. But then in this open letter, now he's saying, well, this is up to the ME we don't decide anything. So why is he switching up? Jennifer's sister even states this open letter. Definitely took us by surprise again. And it was almost like adding insult to injury. Okay, then what about the death? What about the investigation into Susu Norton's death? Alaskan state troopers have taken over the investigation in 2022. That's two years after she was found dead. Said they told Susu's family that they're going to send investigators into the town, and that never happened. And Susu's family would know because they live three houses down from the mayor. They never came into town. They never investigated. They're not talking to anyone. They just keep saying that they're investigating. And they also released this video on YouTube where they're like, let us know if you know anything.
Interviewer/Guest
What's the video?
Narrator/Host
It's a state trooper standing there being like, we are taking this very seriously. We are investigating the death of Susan Norton. Please let us know if you've known anything, seen anything. And it's like, isn't that your job? As for Susu's family, they weren't even told that she was strangled to death and they live three houses down from the mayor. It just feels like there are certain cases where it's kind of like the whole sympathy in words execution is hollow. Everyone is like, okay, we're gonna take missing and murdered indigenous people people so seriously now. So what we're going to do is we're going to create a subunit inside of our police department or the Alaskan state troopers are going to have their own dedicated unit into investigating missing and murdered indigenous people. And we're going to name it mmip. And then we're going to investigate all these cases and they come out online and they're like yeah, we're investigating. And then ProPublica goes to the family and they're like are they investigating? No, it just seems like they're not doing anything thing.
Interviewer/Guest
So what's like the latest update on the the previous mayor and the family
Narrator/Host
now they won't give any comments. They all still reside in that house. And Susu Norton's death is so called being investigated.
Interviewer/Guest
So all the local knows this I'm assuming and they're all thinking the same thing that we're thinking but still nothing's being done done in that town because nothing's being done.
Narrator/Host
And okay, here's another thing, right? So while I do think that the rules around a FOIA request. So in the United States if you, it's the Freedom of Information act, if you want information about a particular case, especially like a criminal case, you as a citizen, each state is different. Some states are really annoying. Some states you have to like be a resident of that state anyway you submit a request and you can get redacted case files, files. They're not going to give you everything. They're just going to give you what is mandated by law to give you. And with Jennifer Kirk's case there wasn't a lot but you can FOIA request it because it's a closed case because she was deemed to have self exited. Now here's the thing with Susanna Norton they keep saying it's an ongoing investigation which means you cannot get a FOIA request on an ongoing investigation. Because most of the time it's probably not good. They're investigating right now. You should not impede the police. Police on doing their work. But if they're not doing the work, it almost feels like they're doing this so that nobody can get information. Nobody can point out things that are weird or ask questions, and then everybody forgets about it and then they move on.
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah, yeah.
Narrator/Host
So they keep. They requested our FOIA request for Susu Norton's death, and they're saying. Yeah, the request. They denied it. Yeah, they denied it. And they said it's because it's an open, ongoing investigation. Right. But then. Then I'm looking online and the family is coming out to journalists and saying, what are they investigating? They told us they were going to come into town and they haven't come into town. So it's just open. It's not an investigation also. I'm just saying it's a really small police department. And the fact that they took so long to get back to us, because usually police departments, if they want to reject you for a FOIA request, it's like they already have a template. They're like, for abc. Bye. You're not getting it. Okay. And then you can try to file, because sometimes you're like, I don't think that's legally right. You can try to kind of maneuver around it. But no, they took so long, and it didn't make any sense. One comment about this case reads, when it's rich billionaires who jettison themselves to the bottom of the ocean, we've got enough resources and money to send the Coast Guard to the bottom of the sea to retrieve their bodies and the debris. When it's two indigenous women, no one cares. Suddenly there's no more money, no more resources. Resources. No bother, no care. This is documented discrimination in broad daylight. Other people are commenting. How is this coordinated Silence. Okay, like, who's holding these organizations accountable? Why are they allowed to just not answer? Like, why is the former mayor allowed to just not respond to comments?
Interviewer/Guest
Yeah.
Narrator/Host
And so that is where we are right now with this case. There's going to be a lot more. We're working on multiple different episodes. But. But if you live in Alaska, if you live anywhere near this town, call their police department, send in tips, send in requests to the state troopers, interact with anything that you see online about Jennifer Kirk and Susannah Norton. I think police typically don't care until everybody cares. And then they still don't care. They just don't want to be seen as not doing their job. What are your thoughts? Let me know in the comments and I will see you in the next one. Be safe.
Advertiser/Commercial Voice 2
Your new home is now ready Dr. Horton, America's builder has new homes that are ready today with new construction communities in Ellensburg and throughout the Greater Seattle area. Dr. Horton has the right home for you. At Dr. Horton, we're still building with flexible living spaces, smart home technology and two and three car garages. More communities and more homes available every day. Hey, find your new home in Ellensburg now ready@doctor Horton.com Dr. Horton, America's builder and Equal Housing Opportunity Builder There's a
Advertiser/Commercial Voice
reason Chevy trucks are known for their dependability. It's because they show up no matter the weather, push forward no matter the terrain and deliver. That's why Chevrolet has earned more dependability awards for trucks than any other brand in 2025, according to J.D. power. Because in every Chevy truck, like every Chevy driver, dependability comes standard. Visit Chevy.com to learn. Learn more Chevrolet received the highest total number of awards among all trucks in the J.D. power 2025 U.S. vehicle Dependability Study Awards based on 2022 models. Newer models may be shown. Visit J.D. power.com awards for more details. Chevrolet Together let's drive.
Podcast: Rotten Mango
Host: Stephanie Soo
Episode: Young Woman Self Exits W/ Gun Longer Than Arms In Mayor's Home - 2 Yrs Later Another Girl Is Dead
Date: March 26, 2026
This episode of Rotten Mango dives into the tragic and deeply troubling cases of Jennifer Kirk and Susanna “Susu” Norton—two Indigenous women found dead inside the same house belonging to a powerful family in Kotzebue, Alaska. Both deaths, years apart, occurred in the residence of Northwest Arctic Borough Mayor Clement Richards Sr., raising harrowing questions about systemic racism, domestic violence, community silencing, and law enforcement complicity. Host Stephanie Soo explores police negligence, Alaska’s high rates of violence against Indigenous women, political cover-ups, and corruption, while highlighting the broader crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous people (MMIP) in Alaska.
Discovery:
Key Details:
Police Response:
Notable Quote:
Notable Quotes:
Notable Quote:
Community members express disbelief at the lack of response, with a culture of silence and resignation prevailing.
Stephanie highlights the disparity in national responses:
Call to Action: Stephanie urges listeners in Alaska to contact police, demand action, and keep attention on cases like Jennifer Kirk’s and Susu Norton’s, emphasizing that public pressure is the only way to hold institutions accountable.
Stephanie Soo’s exhaustive retelling exposes not only the harrowing pattern of violence that led to the deaths of Jennifer Kirk and Susu Norton, but also the deeply broken system that continues to enable and obscure such tragedies, especially against Alaska Native women. The episode is a sobering call for transparency, accountability, and justice, drawing a direct line between small-town power, institutional neglect, and the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous people. Stephanie urges listeners to remain vigilant, speak out, and help break the cycle of silence.