Summary of "Question Everything" Trailer Episode

Podcast: Question Everything
Host: Brian Reed
Release Date: September 16, 2024
Produced by: KCRW and Placement Theory
Available on: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and other major platforms

Introduction

In the trailer episode of "Question Everything," Brian Reed, renowned for his work on the acclaimed podcast "S-Town" by Serial Productions, introduces his new venture aimed at reexamining the field of journalism. Reed emphasizes his commitment to scrutinizing not only the broader journalism landscape but also his own practices within the profession he has been part of for over fifteen years.

Brian Reed (00:00): "Question Everything with Brian Reed. And I really am trying to question everything, including my own work."

Exploring the Purpose and Criticisms

Reed delves into the genesis of the show by addressing criticisms previously levied against his work, particularly concerning "S-Town." He recounts an interaction with a fellow journalist who deemed his most notable story morally indefensible and questioned the legitimacy of pursuing such narratives.

Fellow Journalist (00:15): "Why do you think this is a story at all? What's your answer to that criticism of mine and others even questioning whether or not it's legitimate to do this?"

Reed responds by framing "Question Everything" as a real-time quest to enhance journalistic integrity and effectiveness, especially in an era where public trust in the media is waning.

Brian Reed (00:25): "Question Everything is my real time quest to try and make journalism better. It's a show for anyone who's felt frustrated or misled by the news at a time when so many people believe that journalism and journalists are failing."

Addressing the Current State of Journalism

The discussion shifts to the challenges faced by journalists today, including widespread misinformation and public skepticism. Reed acknowledges the pervasive "bullshit" that undermines journalistic efforts and describes his role as grappling with these failures rather than attempting to preemptively mitigate backlash.

Brian Reed (00:45): "I do feel like that as a reporter that, like, it is an exercise in failure."

He narrates an incident where a "jailer" suggested he might stop writing about the District Attorney's office, to which Reed responds that he is already preoccupied with stories unfolding in real-time.

Brian Reed (01:00): "Well, I guess you'll quit writing about the DA now. I said, dude, I'm already writing this story that's happening right now. I'm already writing that in my head. As we sit here."

The Challenge of Influence and Objectivity

Reed touches upon the delicate balance journalists must maintain between reporting objectively and inadvertently influencing events. He recounts a conversation with a woman skeptical about his motives, questioning what he stands to gain from reporting on these stories.

Woman (01:20): "What do I possibly get out of that? To tell the story on the radio."

Reed contemplates the intrinsic value of storytelling in journalism, highlighting the connection and emotional resonance that well-told stories can foster among listeners.

Brian Reed (01:35): "When people hear a story that they can connect to it, like, it gives you a feeling."

Despite critiques about the quality and impact of certain stories, Reed remains steadfast in his belief in the importance of journalism.

Woman (01:50): "This is so corny. I definitely think they should be placed in jail. I think the reporter should still be in jail. Yes, I do."

Commitment to Journalistic Integrity

Brian Reed concludes the trailer by reaffirming his dedication to maintaining journalistic integrity despite external pressures and criticisms. He underscores the necessity of questioning established norms and practices to foster a more trustworthy and effective media landscape.

Brian Reed (02:10): "I really had to think about, like, what does she get out of this? To tell the story on the radio."

"Question Everything" promises to be a reflective and critical examination of journalism, led by Brian Reed's extensive experience and unwavering commitment to truth and integrity in reporting. Listeners can anticipate insightful discussions aimed at addressing the current challenges faced by the media and exploring pathways to restore public trust.

For more information and to subscribe, visit nytimes.com/podcasts or sign up for the newsletter at nytimes.com/serialnewsletter.