Scamfluencers Episode 154: Conrad Black: The Fleet Street Fleece

Release Date: April 14, 2025 | Host/Author: Wondery

Introduction

In Episode 154 of Scamfluencers, Wondery delves deep into the rise and fall of Conrad Black, one of the most infamous figures in the world of media fraud. Hosted by Scaachi Koul and Sarah Haggie, alongside guest Barbara Amiel, the episode meticulously unpacks Black's journey from a privileged Canadian upbringing to becoming a media mogul embroiled in scandal and deceit.

Early Life and Foundations of Ambition

The story begins in 1957 Toronto, where a young Conrad Black, then a 13-year-old student at Upper Canada College, exhibits early signs of his entrepreneurial spirit and disregard for rules. At [08:08], Black steals exams and sells them to fellow students, an act that leads to his expulsion and social ostracization. This incident not only marks the beginning of his penchant for bending rules but also foreshadows his future endeavors.

Barbara Amiel reflects on Black's characterization of influential figures, noting his admiration for individuals like William Randolph Hearst who operated above conventional rules:
"Hearst had a conviction… the rules that applied to others didn't apply to him." [07:38]

Black's father, George Black, a successful businessman, falls into depression and alcoholism after a fallout with his business partner. This familial turmoil instills in Conrad an obsession with success and a belief that maintaining power and wealth justifies unethical means.

Partnership with David Radler: Building an Empire

A decade after his expulsion, Black partners with David Radler, another ambitious man from a privileged background. Together, they acquire the struggling Sherbrooke Record for $20,000 Canadian ([10:04]) and implement ruthless cost-cutting measures. Radler’s expertise in finance ensures the paper turns a profit within three months by halving staff and delaying payments to suppliers.

As their media empire grows, Black and Radler adopt a strategy of aggressive acquisitions, eventually owning over 500 newspapers by 1995 ([30:03]). Their expansion is marked by unethical practices such as inflating circulation numbers by discarding unsold copies to charge more for advertising, thereby artificially boosting profits.

Sarah Haggie comments on Black's disregard for journalistic integrity:
"These people don’t care about news… It’s just a way to be powerful and start an empire." [11:50]

Ascending High Society: Marriage and Aristocratic Aspirations

In 1991, Black's social ambitions lead him to London, where he marries Barbara Amiel, a charismatic right-wing columnist. Their union is both personal and strategic, aimed at ingratiating Black into the British elite. The couple hosts opulent parties attended by prominent figures like Margaret Thatcher and Sarah Ferguson, Duchess of York ([22:25]), leveraging these connections to solidify their status.

Black's relentless pursuit of influence is further exemplified when he is appointed to the House of Lords in 2001, earning the title Lord Black of Crossharbour ([36:23]). This prestigious position not only elevates his social standing but also extends his sway over political decisions in the UK.

The Web of Fraud: Skimming Shareholder Funds

Behind the facade of media success, Black and Radler orchestrate a complex fraud scheme. Through their holding company, Ravelston, they siphon off millions from Hollinger International—Black's media conglomerate—under the guise of management fees and personal expenses ([30:53]). These unauthorized payments divert funds intended for shareholders directly into their personal accounts, with little oversight from the board.

Barbara Amiel expresses disgust over their schemes:
"It’s a level of evil that really, really gets me." [30:53]

Their deceit remains unchecked until Laura Jarecki, a former investigative journalist turned stock analyst, notices the financial discrepancies at Hollinger. Her persistent investigation uncovers the extensive embezzlement, revealing that Black and Radler have stolen nearly $400 million over seven years ([41:27]).

The Investigation and Downfall

As Jarecki compiles her evidence, Black and Radler find themselves under increasing scrutiny. Black's extravagant lifestyle, highlighted by his ostentatious purchases and lavish parties ([43:17]), becomes a focal point for suspicion.

In 2003, under mounting pressure, Radler strikes a deal with federal investigators to testify against Black. This pivotal move weakens Black's position, leading to a series of legal challenges. By 2006, Black faces conviction on multiple counts of fraud and obstruction of justice, resulting in a six-and-a-half-year prison sentence ([34:39]).

Barbara Amiel shares her frustration with Black's lack of accountability:
"He doesn’t think anything needs to be learned." [44:41]

During his imprisonment, Black continues his intellectual pursuits, authoring memoirs and maintaining a semblance of his former status among fellow inmates. However, his influence wanes as legal orders severely restrict his financial freedom.

Release, Pardon, and Legacy

Upon his release in 2012, Black returns to Canada, attempting to reclaim his place in the media landscape by hosting a talk show and authoring biographies, including one on Donald Trump. His ties with influential figures, including Trump's support, culminate in his 2019 pardon by Trump, allowing him to restore some of his former prestige.

Despite his release, Black's reputation remains tarnished. He continues to deny wrongdoing, asserting that his legal battles were merely a series of unfortunate events rather than deliberate fraud.

Sarah Haggie reflects on the pervasive nature of Black's deceit:
"Having friends in high places always pays off… it's someone who will always have access to it." [58:28]

Hosts' Reflections and Conclusions

Throughout the episode, Barbara Amiel and Sarah Haggie express their disdain for Black and the unethical culture he perpetuated. Their discussions highlight the broader implications of Black's actions on the media industry and the mechanisms that allow such frauds to thrive.

Barbara Amiel poignantly remarks:
"These scammers are smart enough to implicate enough powerful people that punishing him requires a class traitor." [57:29]

The episode concludes by emphasizing the critical role of investigative journalism in uncovering and challenging corporate fraud, underscoring the lasting impact of Black's scam on the media landscape.

Notable Quotes

• Barbara Amiel on Black's early rule-breaking:
  "He was always treated like a prince because he kind of is one." [07:59]

• David Radler on Black's aspirations:
  "Conrad wants to be known as an intellectual and be accepted by the upper echelons of Canadian society." [13:01]

• Barbara Amiel reacting to Black's fraudulent activities:
  "It's so disgusting… You can’t say no." [30:53]

• Sarah Haggie on Black's inability to change:
  "He never took accountability for what he did." [57:51]

• Barbara Amiel on Black's arrogance:
  "What can I say, he has no blood on these hands." [59:45]

Conclusion

Episode 154 of Scamfluencers offers a comprehensive and engaging exploration of Conrad Black's life, illustrating how his relentless ambition and unethical practices led to a significant downfall. Through detailed storytelling and insightful commentary, the hosts and guest provide listeners with a nuanced understanding of one of the most audacious frauds in modern media history.

Credits:
Written by Jessica Lucas, with additional writing by Sachi Cole and Sarah Haggie. Produced by Olivia Briley, Lexi Perry, and James Morgan, among others. Special thanks to contributors from various publications and authors for their research.

For more exclusive content and early access to episodes, consider joining Wondery+ through the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.