Loading summary
Transcript118 lines
- [00:00]
Sarah Haggie
Audible subscribers can listen to all our episodes of Scamfluencers ad free right now. Join Audible today by downloading the Audible app.
- [00:09]
Sachi Cole
We'll be back in two weeks with an all new episode of Scamflancers. But today we're revisiting the spectacular rise and even more spectacular fall of former political pundit and wannabe media scion, Carlos Watson.
- [00:24]
Sarah Haggie
That's right. We're talking about Aussie Media, a scrappy media startup that was so desperate to succeed, they juiced their views and scammed their investors, business partners and customers.
- [00:35]
Sachi Cole
Carlos was convicted in federal court and sentenced to nearly 10 years in prison for fraud. He was literally on his way to report to a federal correctional institution in California last year when everything changed. Just hours before he was set to begin serving his sentence, Carlos was pardoned by President Trump.
- [00:54]
Sarah Haggie
Some people get all the luck, you know, a presidential pardon. Why? Why? Anyway, good for him.
- [01:02]
Sachi Cole
Couldn't happen to a nicer guy, I think. In a statement, Carlos thanked the President for what he called correcting a, quote, grave injustice. He also criticized the federal judge who sentenced him as, quote, conflicted and unethical. And the clemency didn't just apply to Carlos personally. The President's actions also wiped out the penalties imposed on Aussie media.
- [01:26]
Sarah Haggie
It's like it never happened at all and nobody was affected by it in any way.
- [01:32]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, it is like that. Well, it's a last minute pivot worthy of the story itself. So with this stunning update in mind, we are revisiting our episode on Carlos Watson. The ambition, the unraveling, the. And the commutation that came just in time. Sarah, we've both been laid off from digital media companies in recent history. Do you ever fantasize about quitting media and starting from scratch in a whole new career? Like, maybe we could become welders?
- [02:09]
Sarah Haggie
I don't actually fantasize about it because I have no other skills. So there's really nothing to fantasize about. Like, I can't learn how to do anything new, nor can I do anything else.
- [02:21]
Sachi Cole
Right. Well, today's episode is a doozy. It's all about the unbelievable hubris of the 2010s media boom and a guy who decided that he had to be at the center of it. And no, I'm not talking about my former boss or your former boss or any of our bosses. I can't wait to take you through this episode. You're gonna get so mad. Foreign It's a foggy morning in Los Angeles in February 2021. Alex Piper is working from home. He's a 40 something year old white guy with dark eyes and salt and pepper hair. And he's also the head of unscripted programming at YouTube. This morning, his assistant is on the phone letting him know that someone at Goldman Sachs is on the line. They say they want to clarify some comments that Alex made about Aussie media in a meeting earlier that day. Sarah, do you remember Ozzy Media?
- [03:11]
Sarah Haggie
Yes. I don't know how you could be a writer online and not have heard of Ozzy Media.
- [03:19]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, well, we'll get into the whole thing in a second, but the Goldman rep says they're calling about Ozzy Media's daily YouTube talk show. It's called the Carlos Watson show and it's named after the host and founder of Ozzy. In a meeting earlier that day, Alex had supposedly told Goldman Sachs that the show was a big success and that YouTube was considering making it talk show. That would mean more money and more promotion. On the phone call, Alex even raved about Carlos Watson himself. Now the rep is asking him to expand on these comments, but Alex has no idea what they're even talking about. Not only has he never spoken with this Goldman Sachs team before, he's never even worked with Ozzy or the Carlos Watson show. So Alex tells them, that wasn't me on the phone with you. Alex reports the incident to his bosses at YouTube and Google. And everyone he works with wants to know the same. If Alex wasn't on the call saying those things, then who was? And this question will ignite a firestorm that undermines Ozy Media, its charismatic founder, and the entire industry of digital media.
- [04:31]
Sponsor Voice 1
As a business owner, Jennifer Garner knows it takes hard work and patience to keep growing. So finding a serious business card that goes the extra mile was important for the success of Once Upon a Farm. That's why they chose the Capital One Venture X Business Card. With unlimited double miles on every purchase, they have big purchasing power so they can spend more and earn more. The Capital One Venture X Business Card what's in your wallet terms apply. See capitalone.com for details.
- [05:01]
Sponsor Voice 2
Adobe Acrobat your new foundation. Use PDF spaces to generate a presentation. Grab your docs, your permits, your moves, AI levels of your pitch gets it in a groove. Choose a template with your time this cool. Come on now let's flex those two Draft design, deliver, make it sing AI builds the deck so you can build that thing do that, do that, do that with Acrobat learn more@adobe.com do that with Acrobat.
- [05:36]
Sachi Cole
From Wondery. I'm Sachi Cole.
- [05:37]
Sarah Haggie
And I'm Sarah Haggie.
- [05:39]
Sachi Cole
And this is Scamfluencers.
- [05:41]
Sarah Haggie
Come and give me your attention.
- [05:43]
Sachi Cole
I won't ever learn my lesson.
- [05:45]
Sarah Haggie
Turn my speakers to 11.
- [05:47]
Sachi Cole
I feel like a legend. Ozy Media is an over the top version of the story of so many media startups in the 2010s. From my former employer Buzzfeed News to Sarah's former employers, Vice and Gawker, we have both been victims of the digital media boom and bust. Trust us when we tell you a lot of this industry is just scam. But Carlos Watson's startup, this con, is unparalleled. I'm calling this one Aussie Media pivot to fraud. Our story starts in June 1995. It's a sunny day in Palo Alto, California. The quad outside Stanford Law School is bustling with smarty pants kids in black graduation robes. They're hugging their classmates and posing for photos with their families. And Carlos Watson is one of them. He's 26, black, handsome, with closely shaved hair and a broad warm smile. And he has what the kids might call Riz. He's the kind of guy who would make you feel like you're the only person in the room. Graduating from Stanford Law seems like a natural progression for Carlos. He went to Harvard for undergrad and spent time working for the mayor in his hometown of Miami and for Florida Senator Bob Graham. Growing up, he attended an elite private school. But he doesn't come from wealth. His family just really cares about education. Carlos father is a Jamaican immigrant and sociology professor. His mother is a Mississippi born Fulbright scholar with a PhD. This family collects degrees. They're also a bunch of news junkies. In an interview with Black Enterprise, Carlos credits his dad with inspiring his love of the news.
- [07:34]
Eugene S. Robinson
As a kid, we would go to the Miami airport and he would tell me, run inside, buy him newspapers from around the world. And you know when someone eyes light up, whether you're bringing them good food, that's how his eyes would light up when you would bring him those newspapers. So I grew up loving media.
- [07:49]
Sarah Haggie
I mean, I grew up loving media too, but it was more like the Simpsons, you know, like I couldn't imagine being a news lover.
- [07:59]
Sachi Cole
That was me, I'm so sorry to say.
- [08:01]
Sarah Haggie
Of course it was.
- [08:02]
Sachi Cole
I know, I know. Well, Carlos never loses his love for the news, but his first big jobs are all in politics. He gets hired as chief of staff and campaign manager for a state legislator from Florida. And he briefly works on Bill Clinton's Presidential campaign. After Stanford, Carlos spends two years as a consultant for McKinsey. He's making pretty good money, but he wants to give back. He wants to help kids like him, smart, college bound students who don't have a lot of money, at least compared to their peers. And like everyone else in Silicon Valley around this time, Carlos thinks he can save the world and get rich while doing it. So in 1997, he starts a company. It's a nonprofit called College Track, which helps kids in underserved communities apply for college and find scholarships. He loops in a co founder, Laureen Powell Jobs. Carlos met her while tutoring high school students in East Palo Alto. And Laureen just happens to be married to Steve Jobs. Yeah, that's Steve Jobs. So while Carlos is still just in his 20s, he already has friends in high places. And he's also internalized the Silicon Valley mindset. And now Carlos is ready to take the move fast and break things mentality to the industry he's loved since childhood. By the early 2000s, Carlos has decided that what he really wants to do is host his own TV show. But when Carlos starts to pitch the show idea to networks, he gets rejected everywhere. He has literally no TV experience. But Carlos must have done something right in those pitch meetings, because he gets invited by Fox and Court TV to go on their shows and talk about business and politics. He does well, and he starts making the rounds as a pundit on various cable networks. And then in 2003, Carlos gets his big break. Guest hosting a slot on cnbc. He crushes it, and he gets invited back. Carlos is making a name for himself. He starts hosting specials on cnn, writes a column on their website, and co anchors their election night coverage. In 2004, he also hosts an interview series on NBC. Wolf Blitzer tells Stanford Lawyer magazine that Carlos is a natural. After a few more years, he lands the job he's been gunning for this whole time. He his own show. It's called Live with Carlos Watson, and It launches on MSNBC. In 2009. Carlos finally has his moment in the sun, except it only lasts three months. We don't exactly know why, but Carlos later says it just wasn't the right fit. But this role was a huge deal for Carlos. He has this insatiable thirst to be universally liked and respected as an authority figure. From the time he started pitching his show, Carlos rather ominously compared himself to Charlie Rose. Being a primetime anchor on MSNBC made that dream come true, if only briefly. So after the show ends, Carlos is ready to do whatever it takes to get that power again. And he knows he can't do it alone. It's the early 2010s and a banker named Samir Rao is on his way to lunch. Samir has dark hair, a soft face, and he is tired. For years he's been working as an associate for Goldman Sachs in New York City, and he hasn't been sleeping much. But today he's in California and he turns to the place where so many dudes in their 20s have turned before him. Chipotle. As Samir walks through the Chipotle parking lot, he reportedly runs into a familiar face, Carlos Watson. Samir and Carlos briefly work together in finance after Carlos left msnbc. And they actually have a lot in common. They're both Harvard grads and were raised by immigrants. Samir's parents came to the US From India. He grew up in a suburb of Detroit before getting a math degree and landing a job at Goldman. And eventually, as this story goes, Samir and Carlos's conversation in the Chipotle parking lot lands on this question. How could we reimagine the news for a globally minded, discerning and diverse group? Or at least this is the origin story that Samir and Carlos later publish on their website.
- [12:19]
Sarah Haggie
This is truly one of the dumbest things I've ever heard. Like reimagining the news for a globally minded, discerning and diverse group. So you mean everyone?
- [12:32]
Sachi Cole
Yeah. Well, Samir is impressed by Carlos. He's got a vision and he's super well connected. Maybe Samir even sees his future self and Carlos, who's about 15 years older than him. Over the next few months, Carlos and Samir cook up a new digital media startup. They call it Ozy Media, after the poem Ozymandias by poet Percy Shelley. Yes, it is the one about the futility of human effort, including the line, look on my works, ye mighty, and despair.
- [13:01]
Sarah Haggie
I always wondered if Ozzy was because of the poem, but I never. I never looked into it because I didn't want to know. Now that I do know, I mean, the writing was on the walls.
- [13:11]
Sachi Cole
They said it the first time and we just didn't hear it. Well, on the Ozzy website, they say that they interpret the poem as a call to think big while remaining humble. Of course, this is on the same website where they self mythologize with a story about a Chipotle parking lot. So do with that what you will. The website also includes whimsical biographies of the founders. It notes that Samir is a classically trained Musician who composes jingles just for fun. And that Carlos has played pickup games of basketball. Basketball in places like Iceland and Zimbabwe. Together, the two founders start plotting Ozzy's path to the top. They have a vision for an expansive, captivating media company that meets millennials where they are online. There's just one everybody else has that exact same idea. In 2013, Carlos and Samir go to one of Carlos old pals for money, Laureen Powell jobs. Laureen is running her own company, the Emerson Collective, which invests in everything from education to health care and of course, media. I picture Carlos and Samir sitting in Lorene's modern offices in downtown Palo Alto as Carlos explains that Ozzy will be the HBO of news. Not only will Ozzy uncover what's new and next it'll be, quote, what cool people read to be smart and smart people read to be cool. Sarah, what do you think that all actually means?
- [14:41]
Sarah Haggie
I don't think those words altogether really have meaning, but I think media companies are always trying to be cool without realizing that news isn't cool. It's fundamentally uncool.
- [14:53]
Sachi Cole
Yeah.
- [14:54]
Sarah Haggie
So to me, this says it all, because every company I've written for basically has this mandate for people who work hard and play hard.
- [15:03]
Sachi Cole
Well, it's a big, bold, vague pitch, but media is going digital and venture capitalists want in. This is the era where everyone is taking buzzfeed quizzes and watching Vice documentaries. Now Ozzy is pitching itself as a competitor. Plus, Lorene knows Carlos. Her company leads Ozzy's first round of fundraising, which ends up netting more than $5 million. Lorene even joins the Aussie board. Carlos manages to get some other Silicon Valley backers involved as well. It doesn't hurt that Ozzy starts co hosting an annual Christmas party with the Emerson Collective. These investors give, but more importantly, they give Ozzy an air of credibility, which leads to even more cash. In 2014, Carlos gets $20 million from Berlin based publishing giant Axel Springer. And that sounds like a lot of money until you hear what the other guys have. At this point, Vice has over half a billion dollars in funding. But there's just one thing standing in Carlos way. He's never actually run a media company before. And getting clicks isn't as easy as it might seem. But Carlos will it takes to drive traffic, even if that means burning bridges, faking numbers, and wearing his newsroom down to the bone. Eugene S. Robinson is really looking forward to his weekend off. It's 2012 and he's basically been living at Ozzy's sad beige office in Mountain View, California. Eugene was Ozzy Media's first hire, and as the Deputy Editor, he's been working 18 hours a day, seven days a week in preparation for the website's launch. Eugene is a tall black man with a thin mustache and a gray streak in his hair. Like his boss Carlos, Eugene went to Stanford and is the perfect blend of media meets Silicon Valley. He gets the whole move fast and break things attitude. But he's also skeptical of Carlos vision. Later, in an op ed for the New York Times, Eugene claims that he told Carlos, quote, I think you might be a visionary that is seeing things that are not there.
- [17:14]
Sarah Haggie
That is the worst thing you can say to a guy like Carlos. I love Eugene.
- [17:20]
Sachi Cole
Right now, we love Eugene. Eugene's pulling up as a hero. But Carlos's ambition for Ozzy makes life hell for the upstart editorial team. Carlos wants to make sure Ozzy is telling stories that other outlets aren't reporting on. And that sounds reasonable, but in practice it's nuts. Carlos says that journalists can't cover topics already reported on by major outlets like the BBC, the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal. So there's just not a lot left over. But Carlos and Samir expect the full time staff of about four writers and two editors to produce 40 magazine quality articles per week.
- [17:59]
Sarah Haggie
If he hired the best journalists alive, that is an impossible metric. Yeah, that's unreal. Also, it just shows me fundamentally these two have no idea how journalism works. Like not being able to cover anything that's been mentioned on the biggest sources of news in the English speaking world. Like, that's crazy.
- [18:22]
Sachi Cole
As Eugene describes it, the launch prep is so intense that he's had to tell Carlos repeatedly that he's taking this particular weekend off. According to Eugene, Carlos is livid. He screams at him, fists pounding on the table and everything. Carlos is so enraged that he reportedly fires Eugene on the spot. And when Eugene later writes about this time at Ozzy for Alta Journal, he says that a representative for Watson disputed the events surrounding Eugene's initial exit from the company. He added that the representative did not answer any questions. After a few weeks, the board chair convinces Carlos to rehire Eugene and then she convinces Eugene to come back. But even with Eugene back at Ozy, the writers on staff are drowning in work and it doesn't slow down after the site launches. Ozzy staffers later recount regularly working from 7:30am to 1am each day, writing articles, producing video series and making podcasts. As the site was flounders Carlos, expectations remain sky high to the detriment of everyone around him. In an essay about Ozzy published years later, Eugene describes him as a quote, holy terror. Sarah, can you read this excerpt from Eugene's piece?
- [19:37]
Sarah Haggie
Yeah. He goes texts and calls from him came whenever he was in the mood to send them. The work week was a seven day a week death march. Screaming, shrieking threats of firing and the actual docking of pay for unwritten infractions were normal. We were told that if a friend was getting marri or had died, send flowers. Passion was a number one qualifier since the thinking went, people who are passionate about something will work 24 hours a day. You know, of course, this is a very extreme example of this kind of mentality, but it's not uncommon when you work in digital media, especially if it's like kind of startupish in that sense, where it's kind of like, you know, like, we believe in this. We're a family. This is everything. And it's like those lies, they kind of feed to you and you're not getting any extra money out of it. They're the ones getting money from investors, but they expect you to care about it. Like, you also gave birth to this platform.
- [20:35]
Sachi Cole
But even after big fundraising rounds, Ozzy doesn't hire more people for its newsroom. Instead they spend money on advertising. And it doesn't seem to pay off because after all this time and all this money, Ozzy has still failed to create an audience for its work. Sarah, as someone working in digital media at the time, did you ever organically come across Ozzy stories online?
- [20:59]
Sarah Haggie
I honestly think there was maybe one or two that people were sharing, but I don't ever remember clicking through to ozzy.com and in fact, I think the joke was everyone was like, what the hell is Ozzy?
- [21:12]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, they've barely even started publishing and they've already spent $35 million. But like so many digital media startups at the time, the site isn't anywhere near profitable. And so now Carlos needs to figure out how to make money, and fast.
- [21:33]
Sponsor Voice 1
Spring just slid into your DMs. Grab that boho. Look for that rooftop dinner, those sandals
- [21:38]
Sachi Cole
that can keep up with you.
- [21:40]
Sponsor Voice 1
And hang some string lights to give
- [21:41]
Sachi Cole
your patio a glow up. Spring's calling, Ross, work your magic.
- [21:48]
Sponsor Voice 3
This is a message from sponsor Intuit TurboTax. Tax deadline looming and you're stuck in the dark. We've all been there. Sending documents to a tax pro, then playing the waiting game, constantly checking for updates that seem to never come soon enough. Turbotax changes that match with a TurboTax full service expert and get unlimited support on your taxes at no extra cost. Even during evenings and weekends throughout tax season. Simply upload your documents and watch your return progress in real time while you focus on what matters to you. TurboTax experts work to maximize your refund, ensuring you get every dollar you deserve. No more chasing updates or wondering if everything's on track. With TurboTax Expert full service, you'll have the confidence of knowing exactly where your taxes stand every step of the way. Real Time Updates Only an iOS mobile app now this is Taxes Intuit TurboTax. Visit TurboTax.com to match with your expert today.
- [22:55]
Sachi Cole
For years, the Aussie website trudges along, and while it has occasional successes, it struggles to gain traction. It turns out when reporters can only write about things no one's ever heard of, there aren't a ton of people interested. Companies usually charge for ads based on the number of people they think are going to see them. And online, the way to measure viewers is with clicks. Like that Onion headline says we don't make any money if you don't click the link. Ozzy isn't making any money, but neither is anyone else. The investors and founders behind the digital media boom made a bet that selling ads based on clicks would be a sustainable business model. But by the mid-2010s, it's become clear that the model just isn't profitable. Or at least it's not profitable enough for investors and the industry is a mess. Carlos might think of himself as a unique visionary, but he tries the same strategies that so many other digital media companies do. First up, branded content. JPMorgan Chase, Amazon and Visa give Ozy a bunch of money to run sponsored posts, all on the condition that they get a certain number of page views and Ozzy delivers and but not by making stuff that people actually read. Instead, they use a janky third party service to turn JP Morgan articles into glorified pop up ads they appear before readers get rerouted to the article they actually clicked on. Sneaking these ads in front of readers is basically juicing the stats. No one is actually reading the branded content that they've been selling. Ozzy might not technically be lying to their advertisers, but they're definitely misleading them. And they're not the only startup media company doing it. Among others, Bustle Digital Group, Funny or Die and PC Mag are doing the same pop up scam. Eventually, buzzfeed News runs a story outing them all. It says that over a five month Period. Ozzy got the vast majority of views on its most read articles. Fraudulently, the company gets some negative attention, but eventually the Internet moves on. Even JP Morgan keeps investing with Ozzy. For now, Carlos is acting about as shady as everyone else in his position. But when Ozzy loses its most powerful ally, he'll get desperate. And that's where the real scam begins. In addition to branded content, Ozzy also tries branching out into events as a way to make money and get attention. In July 2016, the company throws their first ever Aussie festival. It has a sort of TED Talks vibe with flashier names like Issa Rae, Cory Booker, and Malcolm Gladwell. But it's not the smash hit that Carlos envisioned. Only 2,000 people show up. The venue, Central Park's Rumsey Playfield, is mostly empty. And still they throw AussieFest again in 2017 and in 2018, somehow getting massive names like Hillary Clinton, RuPaul and Talib Kweli. Sarah, I need you to read how Carlos describes the 2018 event to the New York Daily News.
- [25:58]
Sarah Haggie
Oh, God. He says the whole mission of the festival is to bring diverse voices to one stage and expose people to unexpected perspectives. In years past, people who purchased a ticket to see Jason Derulo have been totally wowed by Jeb Bush. That went somewhere I was not expecting. I don't know what the average Jason Derulo fan is like, but something tells me they aren't like, whoa, this Jeb Bush guy, he's kind of like Jason. I'm wowed by him. I see the connection here. My eyes are open because I would have never been exposed to this man otherwise. Yes, also, I do remember the randomness of Ozzyfest big time. Because I remember seeing the posters and being like, what the hell is this?
- [26:46]
Sachi Cole
Well, Ozzyfest isn't exactly beloved in the rest of the media landscape either. Rolling Stone calls it a neoliberal nightmare. And there's another issue for Carlos. In 2017, Sharon Osbourne sues Ozzy Media for trademark infringement. She thinks Ozzy Fest sounds too much like Ozzfest, the music festival she created with her husband, Ozzy Osbourne. They eventually settle, but the lawsuit is embarrassing. So Carlos works hard to smooth things over. And he even claims on cnbc.
- [27:18]
Eugene S. Robinson
Fun fact. Our friend Ozzy and Sharon sued us briefly.
- [27:22]
Sarah Haggie
Did they?
- [27:23]
Eugene S. Robinson
And then we decided to be friends, and now they're investors in Ozzy.
- [27:26]
Sachi Cole
There's just one problem with that. Sharon says this is a complete lie. She vehemently denies investing in Ozzy, and she says that she rejected company shares that Carlos offered as a part of a potential settlement. And then he gets dealt another major blow. The Emerson collective knows that Ozzy isn't making money. They try to get Carlos to sell the company or at least make new funding dependent on hitting performance targets. And it doesn't work. So around 2019, they bow out. Carlos longtime friend Lorene leaves the board as well, and it gets personal. Remember the annual Christmas party that Ozzy hosted with Emerson? Well, they cut Ozzy out, and Carlos is replaced by celebrity chef Jose Andres. Well, this seems to be a breaking point for Carlos. He hasn't just lost a friend. He's also lost Ozzy's greatest source of legitimacy. With his biggest backer gone and a business model that's failing, Carlos finds the easiest way to keep Ozzy afloat is more lying. He spends most of 2019 traveling the world to woo investors. And instead of admitting that Ozzie isn't doing well, Carlos straight up lies about how much money the company has made last two years, exaggerating by several million dollars. He later tells an investor that a big tech company has offered to buy Ozzy for $600 million.
- [28:50]
Sarah Haggie
Okay, Carlos, like $600 million for a website that barely exists? This man is crazy.
- [28:58]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, I mean, it's all bullshit, but it makes Ozzy look like a more enticing investment, including to companies like buzzfeed. At one point, they're reportedly in talks to acquire Ozy, and who knows if any of it was real or if it was just a ploy to boost Ozy's value. I, as a former buzzfeed employee, have no comment. Either way, the deal doesn't go through, but it does help bolster the image that Carlos is trying to create. And it makes the company more attractive to potential backers. According to the SEC, all the hype helps Ozzy defraud investors out of $50 million. He uses that money to expand Aussiefest. He moves it to Central Park's Great lawn, aiming to bring in 100,000 people. They have a bigger lineup than ever, including Mark Cuban, Spike Lee, Trevor Noah a rod, and Stacey Abrams. And here's a mini scam for you. One former employee told Forbes that Ozzy would book big name speakers by telling them other celebrities would also be there. They would later claim those people had dropped out, even though they never agreed to be in the festival in the first place. Carlos tells CNBC's Squawk Box that people describe Ozzy fest as Ted meets Coachella. It turns out he's just quoting himself here, which is One of his go to media strategies, he's literally doing the many people are saying things, when in fact, the many people are just him. He is many people.
- [30:24]
Sarah Haggie
I mean, you gotta hand it to Carlos. He knows how celebrities work, which is. Wait, this person's doing it? Well, I'm gonna do it, too. Meanwhile, like, have you heard of ozzy? Go on the website. Look it up. It's not legitimate.
- [30:36]
Sachi Cole
I mean, I don't want to go to any of those events, so that feels right to me. Ozzy also goes hard on advertising. They run an estimated $2 million worth of ads across New York city. In one ad, they use a photo of the crowd at global citizens festival, implying it was taken at aussie fest. An aussie spokesperson later apologizes, calling this a mistake. In total, ozzy is projected to spend at least to $6 million on this event. That's way more than they're likely to make on it. But then ozzy gets a miracle. There's a crazy heat wave in New York, Temperatures in the triple digits. Mayor bill de Blasio cancels the event, and Ozzie gets to file an insurance claim. They can blame their losses on the mayor and the weather rather than their own incompetence. Carlos is saved by an almost literal act. Act of God. But he can't count on that to happen a second time. He's gonna have to make his own luck. It's late December 2019, just a few months after the would be catastrophic Ozzy fest. Ozzy media has a new cfo, Tripty Thakur, and she gets cc'd on an email from Samir to a major bank. This email includes documents related to Ozzy's loan application. So remember how Carlos has Ozzy's profits to get more investments? Well, he's made $50 million that way. But it's still not enough. Ozzy is burning through cash, which they seem to be mostly spending, to boost Carlos profile. Ozzy produces documentaries, podcasts, and movies with the Oprah winfrey network, pbs, BBC, and even lifetime. But most of these are hosted by or centered on Carlos in some way. They don't seem to be helping the business. And that's why ozzy is going to the bank for a loan. When tripthi reads the email, she sees a contract with a major cable news network. It's for the second season of an aussie TV show, complete with an episode order, production budget, and signatures from bigwig executives. The contract looks legit, and it implies that there's guaranteed money coming to ozy. But tripthi knows that ozzy is still actively negotiating with the network. This contract is fully made up. Carlos has gone from artificially inflating page views to. To fudging revenue. So why not just manufacture a contract out of whole cloth?
- [33:02]
Sarah Haggie
You know, it's very often in these stories that there's a woman who comes in for a job and she's, like, reads something that's readily available and is the only person to be like, wait a second.
- [33:17]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, man, it just takes one smart broad to figure these things out.
- [33:21]
Sarah Haggie
This is like a pattern in these stories.
- [33:25]
Sachi Cole
I know. Tripthi resigns, effective immediately. Sarah, I want you to read her email to Carlos.
- [33:31]
Sarah Haggie
She writes, this is fraud. This is forging someone's signature with the intent of getting an advance from a publicly traded bank. To be crystal clear, what you see as a measured risk, I see as a felony. Did either of you have any idea or did it even occur to you to care that I could go to jail for forgery and bank fraud? I mean, this is like the most polite way to be. Like, what the hell is going on here? Like, what mess did you get me into?
- [33:58]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, well, Carlos is used to steamrolling his younger employees, but one of them has finally pushed back. And yet he ignores her warnings. Carlos has repeated his lies so many times that it's possible he actually believes them. But the illusion of Ozzy in his mind is about to collide with reality, and the rest of the world will look on his works and despair. Despite tripty's stern email, Carlos is desperate to keep ozzy from ending up in the digital media graveyard. So the company makes another pivot, possibly to what Carlos wanted to be doing all along. In 2020, Ozzy launches the Carlos Watson show. It's an interview series hosted by Carlos that runs exclusively on YouTube. To be clear, the show is not a YouTube original, meaning it's not produced by YouTube's In House studio. It's just uploaded to YouTube. Carlos manages to get some powerful guests on the show, like Matthew McConaughey and Ava DuVernay. According to the New York Times, the show's booker tells them it will air on ae. Many of the show's producers and writers are also told that, but an AE spokesperson says that the network never agreed to air the show. Ozzy plunges money into marketing the series, and the ads are riddled with misleading quotes. Remember what I said about Carlos doing the many people are saying thing? In a promo video for the Carlos Watson show, Ozzy says that the LA Times describes it as, quote, what true discussions look Like a New York bus ad calls Carlos Anderson Cooper meets Oprah. But both of these quotes are from a piece of branded content that Ozzy paid for. It's just Ozzy quoting Ozzy. And here's another one. Ozzy also claims that Dudline called Carlos, quote, the best interviewer on tv. But a critic never said that. Samir did in an interview with Deadline. And an Ozzy billboard in LA calls the Carlos Watson show, quote, Amazon Prime's first talk show. Ozzy uploaded the show to Amazon to get more views, like many YouTubers do, but Amazon played no role in producing or promoting or paying for the show.
- [36:16]
Sarah Haggie
That is so wild because he said a N E bought the show. I know at this point you have to wonder what Carlos thinks about himself. Like, does he think like, you know, just one more lie and people will flock to me in a natural and organic way. Like, buddy, you've been trying for this long. It hasn't happened.
- [36:38]
Sachi Cole
Carlos calls his show the fastest growing Talk show in YouTube history, but the numbers are bullshit. So you know how you get ads before YouTube videos, and some of them let you Skip through after 15 seconds or whatever. Ozzy is paying for full episodes of the Carlos Watson show to play automatically as ads. So even if people click out, the video could still get a view. One source told Axios that more than 95% of the Carlos Watson Show's viewers were paid for. Like many digital media companies, Ozzy is fresh out of ideas. They're just running the pop up scam again. Carlos reeks of desperation, and he's about to go from shady to reckless. Xfinity tech support.
- [37:29]
Sponsor Voice 3
How can I help?
- [37:30]
Sarah Haggie
I can't get Jurassic park back online without.
- [37:32]
Sachi Cole
Oh, you just need Xfinity.
- [37:34]
Sponsor Voice 3
Plug in your gateway and you're good.
- [37:37]
Sachi Cole
All set.
- [37:38]
Sponsor Voice 3
Luckily, Xfinity has reliable self healing WI fi that keeps you safe from threats.
- [37:44]
Sachi Cole
Wow.
- [37:44]
Sponsor Voice 3
You can even boost speeds to your most important devices.
- [37:48]
Sachi Cole
Get reliable WI fi at one price for five years, guaranteed. Xfinity. Imagine that. Watch Jurassic park with Xfinity. Restrictions apply. Select plans only.
- [37:58]
British Scandal Hosts (Matt Ford and Alice Levine)
I'm Indra Varma, and in the latest season of the Spy who. We open the file on Larry Chin, the spy who outplayed Nick. For decades, Chin was embedded deep inside US Intelligence. Then comes an opportunity. Richard Nixon's secret plan to reopen relations with China. Information Chin can place directly into Mao's hands. But the CIA has a weapon of their own. A Chinese mole ready to defect. How long until Qin's gig is up? Follow the spy who now. Wherever you listen to podcasts.
- [38:32]
Sarah Haggie
I feel like a legend.
- [38:38]
Sachi Cole
It's February 2021, and Aussie media is still desperate for cash. Carlos thinks his previous scams didn't work because they didn't go big enough. So he decides to lie to yet another bank. And that's how we get to YouTube executive Alex Piper's call with Goldman Sachs. Remember that one, Sarah?
- [38:56]
Sarah Haggie
I mean, how could I forget? But also, who made the call? Who was fake Alex?
- [39:04]
Sachi Cole
Well, the fake Alex was actually Samir, and he uses a voice distortion app to pretend to be Alex. Throughout the call, Samir gets texts from Carlos, who's hovering behind him, and he reads them back to the Goldman team. For example, quote, I'm a big fan of Carlos, Samir, and the show. At one point, Samir must have used the word we to refer to Ozzy, because court documents show that mid conversation, he gets a frantic text from Carlos. And it just says, use the right pronouns. You are not Ozzy.
- [39:35]
Sarah Haggie
This is like something that happens in a cartoon. Like the jumping around and the. Like, you're this person, not this person.
- [39:41]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, it's like a modern I Love Lucy episode.
- [39:44]
Sarah Haggie
Oh, my God.
- [39:46]
Sachi Cole
Well, when the call ends, the Goldman analysts are baffled. They call Alex to follow up and, well, you know how that goes. Word of the incident quickly gets to the Aussie board of directors. It is not a good look for Carlos, but he manages to protect himself by telling the board that Samir had a mental health crisis.
- [40:06]
Sarah Haggie
Like, that's better. The guy who is also in charge is having a mental episode where he's pretending to be a person who exists in order to get more money from. Like, how is that better?
- [40:19]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, nothing gets better here. But the board does seem to accept the story, and the whole thing remains internal, at least for the time being. Needless to say, Goldman Sachs does not end up giving Carlos the $40 million Ozzy plows. On full steam ahead, they're cranking out more episodes of the Carlos Watson Show. They even have another Aussie fest planned for October 2021. But it never takes place because the New York Times comes calling. They're about to publish a major story on Ozzy, and would Carlos care to comment? The story runs on September 26, 2021. It centers on the fake Goldman Sachs call, but also touches on Aussie media scams more broadly. Eugene, Ozzy's first hire is quoted as calling the company a Potemkin Village, implying the entire thing was a facade designed to trick people in power. The article is written by Ben Smith, the New York Times media columnist Carlos comes back swinging on Twitter, labeling the piece a hit job and calling out what he alleges is a conflict of interest. Ben used to be the editor in chief of BuzzFeed News and was reportedly involved in the BuzzFeed Ozzy negotiation back in 2019. But the new York Times article opens up the floodgates. Everyone in media seemed to think that Ozzy was a total scam. And now their gossip has been confirmed. Forbes, New York magazine, the Daily Beast and many more published their own reporting covering every aspect of the Ozzy scam. The fallout is swift. One of Ozzy's newest hires, a former BBC journalist, resigns. A E. Cancels the second half of an Aussie produced documentary it was actually planning to air. CNBC even calls up Sharon Osbourne for comment. Sarah, can you read what she tells them about Carlos?
- [42:10]
Sarah Haggie
Yeah, she says, this guy's the biggest shyster I've ever seen in my life.
- [42:15]
Sachi Cole
Within a week, Carlos announces Ozzy is shutting down. But then, psych. Four days later, Carlos goes on the Today show with an announcement.
- [42:24]
Eugene S. Robinson
You know, we're gonna open for business. So we're making news today. This is our Lazarus moment, if you will. This is our Tylenol moment.
- [42:30]
Sarah Haggie
What the hell is a Tylenol moment?
- [42:33]
Sachi Cole
I also don't really know what that means.
- [42:35]
Sarah Haggie
This guy has a whole world in his mind. I never want to understand.
- [42:39]
Sachi Cole
Yeah, we are not on this journey with him. And despite all this hum, humiliation, Carlos somehow keeps a stripped down, bare bones version of the Aussie website running. And despite all the fraud, Carlos stays a free man. But he's about to hit that final deadline. On February 23, 2023, the FBI arrests Carlos at a hotel in midtown Manhattan. He's charged with multiple counts of fraud and with aggravated identity theft. Theft? That's for ordering Samir to impersonate Alex Piper during the golden call. He faces up to 37 years in prison. In a statement, the U.S. attorney says that Carlos, quote, ran Ozzy as a criminal organization rather than as a reputable media company. Carlos posts a million dollar bail after pleading not guilty. Samir, meanwhile, has pled guilty to fraud and identity theft. Some suspect he might testify against against Carlos, whose trial has been set for May 2024. But Carlos is determined to fight his case. He takes to Instagram to defend himself. Sarah, can you read this caption for me?
- [43:48]
Sarah Haggie
Yeah. He says, I am deeply disappointed by the government's actions yesterday. I'm not now and have never been a con man. I am and have been a hardworking entrepreneur who has helped build a special company from scratch. Okay. Just because you built a company doesn't mean you're not a con man, because the company legally existed.
- [44:10]
Sachi Cole
Well, Sarah, it seems like Carlos might finally be cornered. His show's YouTube channel stops publishing new content, and Ozzy.com finally shuts down in March 2023. Honestly, it's a better run than I would have expected. Sarah, did this upset you as much as I was hoping and praying it would?
- [44:32]
Sarah Haggie
Yeah. I mean, there's something so fascinating about this story because Carlos clearly idealized these websites that were started from the quote, unquote, ground up by quote unquote, regular people. And he wanted the same thing. You know, he wanted, like, the buzzfeed experience, the vice experience of being like, we started off so small, and then look what we became. You know, I think he just got really lost in this pursuit of creating a media company, and the scam went too far into criminal territory in a way that others didn't.
- [45:08]
Sachi Cole
It's so fascinating to think about it that way. He could have gotten away with this if he had just done, like, two fewer crazy things and if the website had been a little bit more successful. Yes, But a lot of the stuff Carlos was doing, a lot of the stuff that ozzy was implementing Is still very present in digital.
- [45:29]
Sarah Haggie
Also, it was really upsetting to see how these people kind of just do whatever they want, and what happens to people like us, like, just doesn't matter at all. I'm remembering the pivot to video era of layoffs, which was, you know, almost 10 years ago now, where people were laying off writers in favor of video content, which they said was doing better because of Facebook. And then it came out that facebook inflated these numbers of views for video. You know, like, there's just so many things these companies do that doesn't really mean anything to them. At the end of the day, they move on so quickly. And the people who actually face the consequences are the people creating the content, you know, the writers and the producers and the people who are slaving away for $40,000 a year, hoping that, you know, maybe they'll get a raise next year. That's why I wasn't surprised even that Eugene went back after everything he had seen, because he needs money.
- [46:27]
Sachi Cole
I think the real question is, what is Carlos going to start next? Either when he's acquitted or when he pleads out or when he gets out of jail, Because I don't feel like he's done with us.
- [46:41]
Sarah Haggie
Yeah, I would say so, too, I mean, it's easy to hear this and think like, there's no way someone can come back from this level of fraud and, you know, these lies and everything, but it really does happen every single day. I mean, Sarah, I think I speak
- [46:54]
Sachi Cole
for both of us when I say we're really excited for the day that we get onboarded at Carlos's next venture.
- [47:02]
Sarah Haggie
If I was desperate enough, I can't say I wouldn't work for Carlos.
- [47:05]
Sachi Cole
I'm sorry, Sarah, I wasn't being sarcastic. I'm being sincere. There's a decent chance that you and I end up working with or for some of the individuals we made fun of today.
- [47:17]
Sarah Haggie
I think the lesson here is that any website you're reading right now know they're doing something kind of like this. Maybe.
- [47:26]
Sachi Cole
But not us.
- [47:27]
Sarah Haggie
But not us.
- [47:33]
Sachi Cole
Follow Scamflancers on the Audible app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to all episodes of Scamflancers ad free by joining Audible. This is Aussie Media Pivot to Fraud. I'm Sachi Kol.
- [47:48]
Sarah Haggie
And I'm Sarah Hagie. If you have a tip for us on a story that you think we should cover, please email us@scamfluencerswondery.com we used many sources in our research. A few that were particularly helpful were Goldman Sachs, Aussie media, and a $40 million conference call gone wrong by Ben Smith for the New York Times. How Aussie Fest was about to become the next fyre fest by two Jemima McAvoy and David Jeans for Forbes and Ozzie Onward by Eugene S. Robinson for
- [48:18]
Sachi Cole
Ulta Grace Perry wrote this episode. Additional writing by us, Sachi Cole and Sarah Haggie. Our senior producer is Jen Swan. Our producer is John Reed. Our associate producers are Charlotte Miller and Lexi Perry. Our story editor and producer is Sarah Enni. Eric Thurm is our story editor. Sound design is by Sam Ada. Fact checking by Will Tavlin. Additional audio assistance provided by Adrian Tapia. Our music supervisor is Scott Velasquez for Freeze on Sync. Our coordinating producer is Desi Blalock. Our managing producer is Matt Gant. And our senior managing producer is Ryan Lohr. Kate Young and Olivia Richard are our series producers. Our senior story editor is Rachel B. Doyle. Our senior producer is Ginny Blume. Our executive producers are Jeanine Cornello Stefan Jenny Lauer Beckman and Marshall Louie for Wondery. Hello, I'm Matt Ford.
- [49:18]
British Scandal Hosts (Matt Ford and Alice Levine)
And I'm Alice Levine.
- [49:19]
Sachi Cole
And we're the hosts of British Scandal.
- [49:21]
British Scandal Hosts (Matt Ford and Alice Levine)
Now Britain Loves a Royal Scandal Abdications affairs, dodgy uncles. We've had the lot.
- [49:27]
Sachi Cole
But this series is about two brothers
- [49:29]
British Scandal Hosts (Matt Ford and Alice Levine)
raised in palaces, bound by tragedy, supposed to be inseparable.
- [49:34]
Sachi Cole
So how did they end up barely speaking?
- [49:36]
Sponsor Voice 1
Was it jealousy?
- [49:37]
Sachi Cole
The press? The firm? Or was this royal rift always inevitable? This is the story of Harry and Wills and the scandal that split the House of Windsor.
- [49:47]
British Scandal Hosts (Matt Ford and Alice Levine)
Follow British scandal wherever you get your podcasts or listen early and ad free on audible.