A (39:10)
On May 25, 2002, Erica and Benjamin Siffret spent hours drinking and dancing with their new friends at a nightclub in Ocean City, Maryland. It seemed like an unlikely pairing. Joshua Ford was 32 and his girlfriend Jeannie Crutchley was 51. Meanwhile, Erica and Benjamin were just 24 years old. Even so, the couples were really getting along. It probably helped that Erica and Benjamin were were very drunk and as usual, Erica was supplementing her buzz by snorting crushed up Xanax pills. By the time the lights in the club came on around 2am, none of them wanted the party to end, so Erica and Benjamin invited Joshua and Jeannie to come check out their luxury condo. They said they could smoke weed and hang out in the hot tub there. Once they arrived at the penthouse apartment of the Rainbow Condominiums, Benjamin led Joshua and Genie from room to room, showing off the big screen TV and the Jacuzzi tub. Meanwhile, Erica stepped away to snort some more Xanax, but when she returned, she realized her purse wasn't in the living room where she'd left it because of her obsessive compulsive disorder. Erica panicked whenever she couldn't find her belongings, and it was very Important. Important that she find her purse because it contained a $10,000 canary diamond. Erica ran around the condo, frantically, tearing open drawers and looking in closets. Joshua and Jeie were smoking weed in the living room, but they got up and helped her look when they saw how upset she was. Still, the purse didn't turn up. And that's when the mood shifted. Before I continue, most of what we know about the following events is based on Erica's account. With that in mind, we know the story she told police was designed to minimize her involvement. On top of that, she was incredibly inebriated at the time. But according to Erica, Benjamin went on to accuse Joshua and Jeannie of stealing her purse. Even though. Though they insisted they hadn't touched it. Benjamin didn't believe them. He stomped around the living room and screamed in their faces like a drill sergeant. When he told Erica to bring him the gun from the bedroom, she did. Then he pointed it at Jeannie and Joshua and told them to undress for a full strip search. Jeannie grabbed Erica by the arms and tried to reason with her, reminding her that all they'd done that night was try to help them. Benjamin just laughed, then brandished the pistol and chased Joshua and Genie up to the second floor. They ran into the master bathroom and locked the door behind them, but they had nowhere left to go. They were on the 11th floor. The only way out was past Benjamin, Erica, and the gun. Benjamin tried to knock the door down, but Jeannie and Joshua were bracing it shut with their bodies. That's when Benjamin lifted the.357 Magnum and began firing. Joshua staggered back, shot in the arm. Benjamin saw his opening and kicked the door down. Then he barged into the bathroom and executed Joshua Ford and Jeannie Crutchley at point blank range. A few minutes later, Erica found her purse. It had been under their bed all along, but the damage was done, and the siffrits were going to hide the evidence. Benjamin had been trained as a medic when he was in the Navy SEALS and had experience dissecting corpses. And now he didn't hesitate. He used a pair of knives to remove Genie and Joshua's heads, arms and legs. Then he and Erica stuffed the remains into black duffel bags. Just after sunrise that day on May 26, 2002, Benjamin and Erica loaded the duffel bags into the back of their jeep and drove 30 miles north to Rehoboth Be Beach, Delaware. They pulled into the parking lot behind a Food lion grocery store and threw the bags containing Joshua and Genie's dismembered bodies into the dumpsters there. On the way back to the condo, they swung by a Home Depot for cleaning supplies, then stopped at a seafood restaurant for a plate of crab legs. Erica and Benjamin spent the next few days mopping up gallons of blood from the floor, painting over the blood splatters on the walls, and hanging a new door to replace the one Benjamin had kicked down. But even then, they didn't let the double homicide interfere with their vacation. Photos on Erica's digital camera showed the couple playing mini golf, getting tattoos, and eating chicken wings at Hooters in the days after the murders. In some of the pictures, Erica was wearing a ring on a chain around her neck. It had belonged to Joshua Ford, and there was still some of his blood splattered on the inside. But those weren't the only trophies she'd taken. She'd also put Joshua and Jeannie's driver's licenses in her purse. By the middle of the week, Joshua and Jeannie's co workers in Virginia were starting to worry. Neither one had showed up for their shifts, and when family members visited their homes, it seemed like they'd never returned from their weekend trip to Ocean city. On Tuesday, May 28, 2002, Joshua and Jamie were officially reported missing. That same day, police in Virginia reached out to the Ocean City Beach Police Department with descriptions of the missing tourists and their vehicles. Detectives in Ocean City started combing the small town. Before long, they spotted Genie's red Acura parked outside their vacation rental. Investigators searched the unit and found all their belongings were still inside. It was clear to the authorities Joshua and Genie had been in Ocean City at the time of their disappearance. The detectives geared up for a thorough investigation. They didn't realize it would be over in about 24 hours. Two days later, on Thursday, May 30, Erica and Benjamin spent most of their time ripping out the blood soaked wood molding in the bathroom and dumping it down the condo's garbage chute. By the time the sun set, they were exhausted and looking to blow off some steam. So they turned to their their favorite pastime, breaking into Hooters. There was one restaurant conveniently located just down the road from their condo. Benjamin picked the lock. Then he and Erica carried armloads of T shirts, coffee mugs, and cigarettes from the gift shop to their Jeep. But they didn't realize they'd tripped the restaurant's silent alarm. Minutes later, a police car rolled up alongside them in the the parking lot. The officers put Erica and Benjamin in handcuffs while they sorted through the stolen merchandise. Before long, Erica started to feel a panic attack coming on. She asked the police if they could go into her purse and get her Xanax. Searching through the bag's contents, the officer found her Xanax and Joshua Ford and Jeannie Crutchley's driver's license licenses. The officer immediately recognized their faces from the missing persons flyers currently covering the walls of the police station. He shut Erica's purse, grabbed his radio and called the detectives assigned to Joshua and Jeannie's case. Erica and Benjamin Siffrit's vacation was over. Ocean City police and paramedics rushed to Erica and Benjamin's condo, hoping to find Joshua and Jeie there. Instead, they discovered a poorly covered up crime scene at the police station. Erica and Benjamin were questioned separately. Each of them blamed the other for the murders. In June 2003, after a heavily publicized trial, 25 year old Erica and 26 year old Benjamin were confused. Convicted of Joshua and Jeie's murders, Benjamin's defense team was able to persuade jurors that the killings had been Erica's idea and he was sentenced to 38 years in prison for second degree murder. Erica was sentenced to life in prison plus 20 years. Erica and Benjamin Ciffret had embarked on their life of crime in an attempt to save their marriage. In the end, it wasn't enough. In 2010, while locked up in two separate prisons, the couple filed for divorce. Reflecting on this week in crime history, it's clear that meeting the right person can change our lives for the better. But meeting the wrong person, well, that can end in disaster. Master it's impossible to know if Bonnie and Clyde and Erica and Benjamin Siffrit would have been happier if they'd stayed single. But the world probably would have been a safer place if they had. Thanks so much for listening. Listening. I'm Vanessa Richardson and this is Scams, Money and Murder. If you enjoyed this episode, you can check out more just like it by searching for Crime House the show wherever you get your podcasts. Scams, Money and Murder is a Crime House original. Here at Crime House, we want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you like what you heard today, reach out on social media, rimehouse on TikTok and Instagram. Don't forget to rate, review and follow Scams, Money and Murder and Crime House the show wherever you get your podcasts and to enhance your listening experience, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. We'll be back next Thursday.