A (28:55)
21 years after the attack on Nancy Kerrigan, another famous athlete came under fire. But he left a lot more than bruises. On January 9, 2015 in Fall River, Massachusetts, 25 year old former NFL tight end Aaron Hernandez went on to trial for the murder of 27 year old Odin Lloyd. Odin was a beloved member of his community and at the time of his death, he was also one of Aaron's best friends. Aaron's indictment and trial were a stunning reversal of fortune. Just a few years earlier, Aaron was a beloved football star, a first team All American in college who was drafted by the New England England Patriots at the age of 20. On the field, he was unstoppable, bowling over his opponents and scoring six touchdown receptions in his very first season. But in his personal life, he was increasingly consumed by a downward spiral of guns, drugs, mental illness and violence. The trauma that led him there began in his childhood 2020 years earlier and the man responsible was Aaron's own father, Dennis Hernandez. In his hometown of Bristol, Connecticut, people called Dennis Hernandez the King. Growing up in the 1970s, he was a feisty, well liked Puerto Rican kid who became a star football player at Bristol Central High School. He later scored a football scholarship to the University of Connecticut, but was kicked off the team after a run in with the law. Without any hope of going pro, Dennis moved back to Bristol and got a job as a high school custodian. He later married his girlfriend, Terry and had two sons, Jonathan, born in 1986, and Aaron, born in 1989. Dennis had high expectations for his boys. He also had a short temperature and it didn't take much to set him off. If Jonathan and Aaron brought home a less than outstanding grade on a report card, they'd get a beating. If they got into any sort of trouble at school, they'd get a beating. Sometimes they didn't have to do anything at all. If Dennis was in a bad mood, he'd attack his sons without warning. Dennis's expectations for his sons were even higher when it came to sports. He was determined, determined to turn the boys into pro football players by any means necessary. Dennis signed them up for local youth football leagues when they were eight years old, and he pushed them relentlessly to be the best that they could be. If Dennis ever felt that his boys weren't trying hard enough on the field, he'd fly into a violent rage. Despite his behavior at home, Dennis was well liked and respected around town. But he still showed his violent side when it came to his son's football careers. When Aaron was eight, Dennis got upset about the way his youth football coach was running the team. The two got into a heated argument during one of the games, which ended when Dennis punched the coach in the face. Other parents called the police, but Dennis was able to sweet talk his way out of any charges. It was an early lesson for for Aaron, consequences were for other people. As the boys got older, they both found success on the football field. Jonathan followed in Dennis's footsteps and got a football scholarship to the University of Connecticut. But Aaron did even better. As a high school freshman, he was already 6ft 2 inches tall, and he practiced harder than anybody on the team. On the field, he was fast, nimble, and exceptionally gifted at both passing and receiving. In his junior year, he set a statewide record for completed passes. He started getting attention from scouts at major college football programs like Michigan and Notre Dame. Aaron was well on his way to achieving his father's longtime dreams of football stardom. But then, then the unthinkable happened. In 2006, when Aaron was 16 years old, Dennis died after a routine hernia surgery at the age of 49. Their father had terrorized them with a lifetime of abuse, but his death was still a devastating blow to Aaron and Jonathan. Aaron, in particular, never fully recovered from the loss. But he didn't. He didn't show any of the pain that he was feeling. His father had taught him to keep that all inside. At the funeral, Aaron didn't even cry. Dennis's hardcore approach to parenting had kept Aaron from getting into trouble. That changed after his father died. It was around this time that Aaron started smoking marijuana, a habit that would come to dominate his life in the years ahead. In the year after his father's death, Aaron began smoking weed before school, before practices, and eventually even before games. At the same time, he had a falling out with his mother and moved in with his cousin, Tanya Singleton. Tonya provided a supportive and nurturing home to Aaron, as well as a lot of her other friends, many of whom had criminal records. While Erin was chatting with with scouts and giving media interviews about his college plans, he was also hanging out with a growing number of violent criminals. It was a bad environment for a young man who'd just lost his father. But soon, Aaron had a change of scenery. He accepted a full ride scholarship to play football for the University of Florida. And his high school let him graduate six months early so that he could start practicing. Practicing with his new team asap. Aaron Hernandez started playing for the University of Florida Gators when He was just 17 years old and under head coach Urban Meyer. His schedule was demanding. Aaron often spent 40 to 60 hours a week practicing, playing or attending team meetings. But the hard work paid off. In his first season with the team, he had no. 9 receptions and scored two touchdowns. School was a secondary concern. Aaron, who'd barely passed his SATs, was enrolled in easy classes like bowling and gardening. He was assigned sympathetic professors who would give him whatever grade the team needed him to get. And Aaron didn't just get preferential treatment when it came to schoolwork. Near the end of his first semester in 2007, Aaron went out drinking with Tim Tebow, who was the Gators quarterback at the time. Even though Aaron was just 17, they were still able to order a few drinks. But when the check came, Aaron refused to pay the $12 tab. When the bar's manager got involved in the dispute, Aaron sucker punched him, rupturing the man's eardrum. This was a felony level offense in Florida. But while bar staff called the police, Aaron and Tim called Coach Meyer. The athletic department's legal team stepped in and made the whole incident go away. The bar manager didn't press charges, Aaron wasn't arrested, and the attack was not made public until years later. Both on and off the field, Aaron could do no wrong. Aaron spent the next two years racking up major wins for the Gators, all while partying, drinking and smoking copious amounts of marijuana. By the end of his junior year in 2010, Aaron had received the Mackey Award, recognizing him as the best tight end in college football. But even though Aaron was eligible to play one more year for the Gators, Urban Meyer was done with him. Aaron was immature, entitled, and prone to violence. The previous year, he'd been interviewed by police in connection with a shooting in downtown Gainesville. On top of all that, his drug use was an open secret. So with encouragement from his coach, Aaron left college for the NFL. That same year, he was drafted to play for the New England Patriots. At the age of 20, Aaron Hernandez signed a four year, $2.37 million contract with a $200,000 signing bonus. Team officials were concerned about his disciplinary record at Florida, but Aaron promised that he'd straighten up and stay out of trouble. After all, he was fulfilling his late father's dream of being an NFL star. But Aaron, Aaron wouldn't keep that promise. The Patriots facilities in Foxborough, Massachusetts were just two hours away from his hometown of Bristol, Connecticut and all of the unsavory friends he'd made there. After joining the Patriots, Aaron hired two of his old pals, both of whom had criminal records, as his personal assistants. One of them, Alexander Bradley, was a drug dealer who kept Aaron supplied with with marijuana. It was an important job at that point. Aaron was smoking as much as 4 ounces per week, but the drugs didn't do much to mellow him out. In the locker room, Aaron was unstable and quick to anger. One minute he'd be docile and quiet, the next, he'd be furious and close to violence. Even as Aaron racked up touchdowns and became one of the Patriots most valuable players, his teammates kept him at a distance. Instead, Aaron hung out with a growing circle of criminals from Bristol. Thanks to their influence, he soon took his law breaking to a new level. On July 15, 2012, Aaron and his drug dealing pal Alexander Bradley went out to a nightclub in downtown Boston. Things quickly turned ugly. Aaron often got jumpy and aggressive in loud crowded spaces like nightclubs where he thought everyone wanted to fight him. That night, a fellow patron named Daniel d' Abreu bumped into Aaron and spilled a drink on him. Daniel was apologetic, but Aaron was immediately furious. Alexander managed to calm him down and the two left the club not long after. But Aaron wasn't ready to let the this innocent mistake go. Two hours later, at around 2.30am, Daniel and his friend Safiro Furtado were driving away from the club when Aaron's silver SUV pulled up beside them. Witnesses say someone in the SUV yelled a racial slur and began firing a gun into Daniel and Safiro's car, killing both men. Then the the SUV sped away. To this day, it's unclear whether Aaron Hernandez or Alexander Bradley fired the shots. But Aaron's violent streak was growing stronger. And just a few months later, that violence would come for Alexander Bradley. In 2010, 20 year old Aaron Hernandez signed a multi million dollar contract to play for the New England Patriots. In his first two seasons, he wowed fans with his speed and agility. But off the field, he was out of control. In the locker room or on the streets, he was prone to sudden violent outbursts. And he hung out with a group of violent criminals he knew from his hometown in Bristol, Connecticut. One of his closest friends was a drug dealer named Alexander Bradley, who supplied him with large amounts of marijuana. On July 15, 2012, Aaron and Alexander were involved in the shooting of two men who'd spilled a drink on Aaron in a club. It was the beginning of a downward spiral. Police investigating the shooting reviewed security camera footage from the nightclub where the victims had been that night. They were surprised to recognize the Aaron Hernandez in the club at the same time, but they just chalked it up to a coincidence. None of them suspected that Aaron would mix himself up in a double murder. He had just signed a new contract with the Patriots worth $41 million. It was a reward from the Patriots management for his stellar performance over the past couple years. Why would someone in Aaron's position murder two people for no reason? Reason. Instead, investigators concentrated on trying to find the silver SUV that witnesses said the shooters drove off in. The SUV wasn't registered in Aaron's name. It had been loaned to him by a local dealership as a publicity stunt. After the shooting, he hid the vehicle in the garage at a friend's house. And then he went on with his life as though nothing had happened. He spent his days riding jet skis with friends, practicing with the team, and even partying at the same nightclub he'd been at on the night of the shooting. And he was about to become a family man. His longtime girlfriend, Shayana Jenkins, was pregnant and gave birth to their daughter on November 6, 2012. But Aaron didn't let fatherhood get back between him and a good time. He started renting a second apartment that his girlfriend didn't know about, where he went to smoke weed and play with his growing collection of guns. And he kept hanging out with Alexander Bradley, with disastrous results for both of them. In February of 2013, following a disappointing season for the New England Patriots, Aaron and Alexander took a trip to Florida. Florida. To blow off some steam. They partied at a strip club outside Palm beach, where they ran up a $10,000 tab. But Aaron was growing increasingly paranoid. He was convinced that two other men in the club watching them were undercover police officers, and he was convinced that they were investigating them for the double murder they'd committed in Boston last summer. Alexander tried to calm Aaron down, as he often did, but this time, it didn't work. Aaron was certain he was going to go to jail for murder. The two men fought over who would pay the enormous bill, then stormed out of the club. As they drove back to the house they were staying at, Alexander dozed off in the back of their suv. A few minutes later, Alexander woke up to a Gun in his face, Aaron was pointing a pistol right between his eyes. He was determined not to take the fall for last summer's shooting. So he decided to kill the one person who could put him at the scene of the crime. Before Alexander could react, Aaron fired. Then he dumped his friend in an empty Palm beach parking lot, drove to the airport, and flew back to Boston with a clear conscience. A few days later, Aaron got a phone call. It was Alexander Bradley. Bystanders had found him bleeding out in the parking lot and called 911 even though he'd been shot in the head. Doctors managed to save his life, though he lost his right eye in the attack. Now he was laid up in a Florida hospital and he was furious. But even though police had questioned him, Alexander refused to tell them who'd shot him. As he explained to Aaron he wanted to get revenge himself. Now Aaron really did have something to be paranoid about. Over the next several months, the two men exchanged hundreds of angry text messages. Alexander alternated between threatening to blackmail Aaron and threatening to ambush and kill him. In response, Aaron hired more of his old Bristol friends as bodyguards and added several new guns to his collection. He even spent six figures on a fresh suv, which he intended to use as an armored car. The paranoia started bleeding into his professional life as well. He met with Patriots head coach Bill Belichick and begged to be traded to a West coast team for his own own safety, but didn't explain why. Belichick, who had just paid over $40 million to keep Aaron on the team for the next several years, was confused and rejected the request. Afterwards, Aaron started showing up late to practice, infuriating the team's management. Aaron's fear and self destructive behavior threatened to take over his life. Even with his fiance Shayana and a young daughter at home, he felt increasingly isolated and alone. So at first it seemed like a blessing when he started hanging out with Odin Lloyd in the summer of 2013. Odin Lloyd was a 27 year old who played football for the semi pro Boston Bandits. He was dating Shayana's sister and when the two men met at a family get together, they quickly hit it off. Like Aaron, Odin enjoyed marijuana, video games and clubbing. But unlike most of Aaron's other friends, Odin was a genuinely good influence. He was a friendly, cheerful presence in Boston's working class Dorchester neighborhood. He worked part time as a landscaper and couldn't afford a car, so he biked to all his practices with the Boston Bandits. For a humble guy like Odin, it was thrilling to hang out with a rich NFL superstar. And for Aaron, it was a relief to have somebody close to him who he could trust and confide in. Tragically, Aaron's willingness to open up about his problems may have been exactly what led his relationship with Odin to a sudden, violent end. Odin and Aaron had been hanging out for several weeks when they went to a Boston nightclub called rumor on June 15, 2013. We don't know what the two men talked about that night, but investigators think Aaron revealed some dark secrets to Odin, possibly about what happened to Alexander Bradley. They also believe that this was when Aaron decided that Odin had to die in order to keep his secrets. Two nights later, in the early morning hours of June 17, Aaron, his bodyguard Ernest Wallace and another friend from Bristol, Carlos Ortiz, gathered at a bar in Boston. After numerous drinks, Aaron texted Odin and made plans to meet up. The three men drove to Dorchester and picked Odin up at his house just after 2:30am in the car with them, Odin seemed to sense that something was wrong. Just after 3am he started to texting his sister who'd been at the house. When he left, he asked, did you see who I am with? NFL, just so you know. The following morning, Odin's body was found in an industrial park one mile away from Aaron's house. He'd been shot six times. For years, Aaron had gotten away with murder figuratively and literally. But those days were over. Now. Aaron had not done a good job covering his tracks. When police searched Odin's body, they found a set of car keys in his pocket. The keys belonged to a car that Aaron had rented. When police showed up at Aaron's house with questions, he initially slammed the door in their face. On June 18, they returned with a stranger search warrant. Detectives pulled footage from Aaron's home security system that showed him walking through the front door shortly after the murder, carrying a pistol. Over the next several days, Aaron maintained his innocence. He even tried to show up for football practice. But staff at the stadium turned him away. The Patriots organization saw the writing on the wall and were already beginning to to cut ties. On June 26, 2013, 24 year old Aaron Hernandez was arrested and charged with first degree murder. The multi millionaire football star was taken from his sprawling suburban mansion and locked up in a tiny cell where he waited to finally face the consequences of his action. On January 9, 2015, Aaron Hernandez went on trial for the murder of Odin Lloyd. In the year and a half since his arrest, his life had transformed. His $40 million contract was long gone. The trophies and plaques with his name on them were removed from his high school. The Patriots offered to exchange every Aaron Hernandez jersey they sold, and over a thousand fans took them up on the offer. The trial lasted for three months. As prosecutors presented the extensive physical evidence linking Aaron to the murder, his defense team didn't have much to offer in response. The best they could do was acknowledge that while Aaron was present for the murder, he didn't pull the trigger. The jury wasn't convinced. On April 15, 2015, they found Aaron June guilty of murder, which carried an automatic sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. When the verdict was read, Aaron collapsed into a chair, his face blank, showing no emotion. His fiance and mother both wept as he was handcuffed and led out of the courtroom to begin his sentence. Aaron did not adjust well to prison life. At the Souza Baranowski Correctional center, he racked up dozens of disciplinary infractions. He claimed the guards taunted him and often coped with the stress by smoking K2, a synthetic form of marijuana that other inmates smuggled into the facility. It was difficult to accept that the rest of his life would be like this. These feelings of despair contributed to what came next. In the early morning hours of April 19, 2017, a guard noticed a bedsheet was covering the window into Aaron's cell. When prison staff went inside, they found that Aaron had used another sheet as a makeshift noose to hang himself. They cut him loose and began chest compressions. But by then, it was too late. Aaron Hernandez was pronounced dead at the age of 27. A tragic ending to a tragic life. In the wake of the Aaron Hernandez saga, the of the beginning, biggest question on everyone's minds was why? Why would a gifted athlete with millions of dollars and his whole life ahead of him throw it all away to commit acts of senseless violence? Seven months after Aaron's death, doctors at Boston University offered an answer. A team of specialists examined Aaron's brain and found that he had died with the worst case of chronic traumatic action encephalopathy, or cte, ever recorded in someone so young. CTE is a progressive degenerative brain disease caused by repeated head trauma. Aaron, who'd been playing tackle football since the age of 8 and received multiple on field concussions, was naturally susceptible to the condition. While it's impossible to determine how much CTE is to blame for Aaron's crimes, nearly all medical experts agree it played a major role in his life and death. And Aaron is far from the only football player to suffer from the debilitating effects of CTE. Since 2005, at least 20 former NFL players have died by suicide. Nearly all of them were diagnosed with CTE after their deaths. In the past decade, the the NFL and youth football organizations have struggled to prove to players and their families that the sport is safe. As that debate rages on, one thing is certain. A lifetime of football didn't teach Aaron Hernandez the difference between right and wrong. While he amassed fame and fortune, his victims paid the ultimate price. Looking back on this Week in Crime history, we can see that great athletes don't always show great judgment. Tonya Harding was a legendary talent on the ice, but her choice to help cover up the assault on Nancy Kerrigan cost her her career. Aaron Hernandez was a valuable asset to every team he played on and committed heinous crimes whenever he was off the field. It's a valuable reminder that there's more to life than the points on the scoreboard. Thanks so much for listening. I'm Vanessa Richardson and this is True Crime this Week. True Crime this Week is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. At Crime House, we want to express our gratitude to you, our community, for making this possible. Please support us by rating, reviewing and following True Crime this Week. Wherever you get your podcasts, your feedback truly matters. And for ad free and early access to True Crime this Week, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. We'll be back next week. Sunday True Crime this Week is hosted by me, Vanessa Richardson, and is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. This episode was brought to life by the True Crime this Week Team Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benidon, Natalie Pertovsky, Lori Marinelli, Sarah Camp, Truman Capps, Sheila Patterson, and Michael Langsner. Thank you for for listening. Looking for your next listen. Hi, it's Vanessa Richardson and I have exciting news. Conspiracy theories, cults and crimes is leveling up starting the week of January 12th. You'll be getting two episodes every week. Wednesdays we unravel the conspiracy or the culture and on Fridays we look at a corresponding crime. Follow Conspiracy Theories, Cults and Crimes now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music or wherever you listen.