Podcast Summary: True Crime This Week – "Criminal Athletes"

Podcast: Scams, Money, & Murder
Host: Vanessa Richardson (Crime House)
Episode: True Crime This Week: Criminal Athletes
Date: January 4, 2026

Overview

This episode of True Crime This Week explores two of the most notorious cases involving professional athletes turning criminal: the 1994 assault on figure skater Nancy Kerrigan (with Tonya Harding's subsequent implication) and the 2015 trial of NFL star Aaron Hernandez for the murder of his friend Odin Lloyd. Host Vanessa Richardson takes listeners beyond the headlines, delving into the personal histories, motives, and aftermaths of both stories to illustrate how athletic greatness can be overshadowed by poor choices and criminal acts.

Case 1: The Attack on Nancy Kerrigan and Tonya Harding’s Involvement

Setting the Stage

• [04:11] Vanessa details Nancy Kerrigan’s career and the high stakes of the 1994 U.S. Figure Skating Championships, which were a stepping stone to the Winter Olympics.
• Kerrigan, after practice at Detroit’s Cobo Arena, was violently attacked with a police baton to her right leg by a masked assailant, crying out, “Why? Why? Why?” as cameras captured her agony.
• Timestamps:
  • Attack occurs: [04:11]
  • Key emotional moment: “As Nancy’s trainers tended to her injuries, she cried, ‘Why? Why? Why?’” – Vanessa Richardson

Tonya Harding’s Story

• [04:40] Background on Tonya: a difficult childhood filled with poverty and abuse, leading to an intense focus on skating as her escape.
• Early success under coach Diane Rawlinson, but always facing financial struggles and personal trauma.

Rivalry with Kerrigan

• [06:45] Though competitors, Tonya and Nancy often shared rooms and came from similar working-class backgrounds. The media, however, contrasted their images heavily—Nancy as the graceful beauty, Tonya as the “outsider.”

The Plot and the Attack

• [14:00] Tonya’s relationship with her abusive ex-husband Jeff Gillooly, who lived with her and stood to gain from her Olympic success.
• Jeff, wanting to eliminate Nancy as competition, recruits Shawn Eckardt, who brings in Derek Smith and Shane Stant as henchmen.
• The group’s plan: injure Nancy so she couldn’t compete. Botched attempts lead to the January 6, 1994 Detroit attack.
• Shane Stant executes the attack, escaping clumsily by crashing through arena doors.
• Quote: "The plan had been poorly thought out and sloppily executed, but against all odds, it worked." – Vanessa Richardson ([17:11])

The Investigation and Fallout

• [19:30] The conspirators start to unravel after one brags about the attack and plays a tape of their planning.
• Arrests follow; Tonya, under pressure, initially denies but then admits knowledge after the fact, covering for her ex-husband and associates.
• Both Tonya and Nancy qualify for the 1994 Olympics amid intense public scrutiny. Nancy recovers, wins silver; Tonya falls apart and finishes eighth, ultimately banned for life from skating.
• Quote: “Tonya Harding’s time on the ice was over. It was a disappointing ending to what could have been a beautiful career.” – Vanessa Richardson ([26:55])

Case 2: The Downfall of Aaron Hernandez

Early Life and Football Stardom

• [28:55] Aaron Hernandez, NFL tight end for the New England Patriots, stands trial for murdering Odin Lloyd, reversing a meteoric ascent in the world of professional sports.
• Origins: Raised in Bristol, Connecticut by a harsh, demanding father whose violent discipline shaped Aaron’s worldview.
• Both Aaron and his brother excel in football; Aaron’s talent stands out, leading to a scholarship at the University of Florida.

Escalating Issues

• [31:20] Aaron, after his father’s death, self-medicates with marijuana, distances himself from his mother, and ingratiates with criminal circles via his cousin.
• At Florida, despite legal trouble (e.g., assaulting a bar manager), Aaron is shielded by coaches and legal teams.
• “Both on and off the field, Aaron could do no wrong.” – Vanessa Richardson ([33:10])

Criminal Behavior Grows

• [35:00] After NFL stardom, Aaron associates with criminals from Bristol; his closest confidant becomes drug dealer Alexander Bradley.
• In 2012, Aaron is implicated in a double homicide following a nightclub altercation.
• [37:25] Betrayals escalate: Aaron, paranoid Bradley will inform, shoots him in the face in 2013; Bradley survives and vows revenge.

The Murder of Odin Lloyd

• [41:30] Odin Lloyd, Aaron’s close friend and his fiancée’s sister’s boyfriend, is found dead, shot six times. Suspicion quickly falls on Aaron due to sloppy efforts to conceal the crime.
• Lloyd’s cryptic texts before his death: “Did you see who I am with? NFL, just so you know.”
• [45:10] Police quickly assemble evidence: security footage, rental cars, and Aaron’s own lack of caution.

Trial, Prison, and Tragedy

• [46:50] Aaron tried and convicted for Odin Lloyd’s murder; sentenced to life without parole.
• Quote: “On April 15, 2015, they found Aaron guilty of murder, which carried an automatic sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.” – Vanessa Richardson ([47:50])
• In prison, Aaron struggles, accumulating infractions before dying by suicide in 2017 at age 27.
• Post-mortem, he is found to have advanced CTE, a brain disease linked to repeated head trauma.
• Quote: “A lifetime of football didn’t teach Aaron Hernandez the difference between right and wrong. While he amassed fame and fortune, his victims paid the ultimate price.” – Vanessa Richardson ([55:55])

Notable Quotes & Moments

• “Why? Why? Why?” – Nancy Kerrigan ([04:23])
• “My mom hit me and she loved me. He hits me, he loves me. It’s just the way life goes.” – Tonya Harding ([08:53])
• “The plan had been poorly thought out and sloppily executed, but against all odds, it worked.” – Vanessa Richardson ([17:11])
• “Tonya Harding’s time on the ice was over. It was a disappointing ending to what could have been a beautiful career.” – Vanessa Richardson ([26:55])
• “Both on and off the field, Aaron could do no wrong.” – Vanessa Richardson ([33:10])
• “Did you see who I am with? NFL, just so you know.” – Odin Lloyd, in a text before his murder ([43:30])
• “A lifetime of football didn’t teach Aaron Hernandez the difference between right and wrong. While he amassed fame and fortune, his victims paid the ultimate price.” – Vanessa Richardson ([55:55])

Key Themes & Insights

The Intersection of Talent and Turmoil

• Both Tonya Harding and Aaron Hernandez overcame disadvantaged backgrounds and childhood trauma to rise to the top of elite sports.
• Their success, however, could not erase deep-seated issues related to abuse, poor decision-making, and the company they kept.

Criminal Acts that Changed Lives and Sports History

• Harding’s implication in the Kerrigan attack reveals the lengths to which jealousy, pressure, and bad influences can drive someone.
• Hernandez’s violent acts reflect unchecked aggression, mental illness (CTE), and the dangerous insulation of football fame.

The Cost

• Both tales end in tragedy: Harding banned, her legacy forever tarnished; Hernandez dead by suicide in prison, leaving behind broken families and communities.

Final Reflection

Vanessa closes by emphasizing that athletic greatness does not guarantee sound judgment or moral character. Both stories serve as complex cautionary tales for athletes, fans, and society as a whole.

Host: Vanessa Richardson
Notable Segment Start Times:

• Kerrigan Attack & Harding’s Backstory: [04:11]
• Execution and Fallout of Attack: [14:00–26:55]
• Aaron Hernandez’s Story: [28:55–56:25]

For more True Crime This Week, subscribe to Crime House on your podcast platform of choice.