A (29:30)
21 years after Klaus Barbie was found hiding out in Bolivia when another fugitive mass murderer was brought to justice. But this killer targeted his allies just as often as he went after his enemies. It was just after 11am on January 19, 1993, when 25 FBI agents stormed up the driveway of a spacious three bedroom home in suburban New Jersey. The agents pounded on the front door, yelling for the residents to open up. When nobody replied, the agents used a battering ram to smash the metal door. With their guns drawn, they rushed into the foyer of the house. That's when they heard yelling from upstairs. It was a man's voice calling down to let them know that he'd heard them and he wasn't gonna cause any trouble. Moments later, 52 year old Anthony Casso appeared on the staircase holding his hands above his head. He was was naked except for a towel wrapped around his waist. As he explained to the arresting officers he'd been in the shower when they knocked. At that time, Anthony Casso was considered one of the most dangerous mobsters in the country. He was a ruthless sadist who'd killed dozens of rivals, suspected informants and people he just didn't like. For the past three years, he'd been in hiding, on the run from racketeering charges. But that hadn't stopped him from running the Lucchese crime family while he was a fugitive. Now Casso was going to have to answer for a life of crime. One that began decades earlier when he was just a kid roaming the streets of Brooklyn. Anthony Casso was born on May 21, 1942, and he was always close to organized crime. His godfather had been a captive in the Genovese crime family, one of the five Italian mafia families that fought for control of New York City throughout much of the 20th century. His father had once made a living as a burglar, but had given up his life of crime and found honest work as a longshoreman. He hoped that his son would follow in his footsteps and become an upstanding citizen. But even as a boy, Casso had other plans. As a child in Casso joined a street gang called the South Brooklyn Boys. He and his friends got into frequent scuffles and street fights with rival gangs. And it didn't take long for Casso to develop a reputation as a tough guy. That reputation followed him as he got older. By the time he was 21 in 1963, Casso had picked up the nickname Gas pipe in honor of the lead pipe he liked to use as a weapon in street fights. Shortly after he he graduated from the South Brooklyn Boys into a much bigger criminal organization, the Lucchese crime family. The Lucchesis put Casso to work as an enforcer. His job was to make sure people who owed the family money paid up and suffered the consequences if they didn't. Casso loved herding people just for fun, which made him a great fit for the job. Throughout the 1960s and 70s 70s Casso rose through the organization's ranks. He bullied local businesses into signing mob friendly union contracts, sold drugs and ran underground gambling operations. All this lawbreaking didn't go unnoticed. Casso was repeatedly arrested on assault and drug trafficking charges. But whether he was in state or federal court, prosecutors could never make the charges stick. Everybody Knew that Casso was a maniac, and witnesses were terrified to testify against him. Time after time, charges against him were dropped and Casso went free. The leaders of the Lucchesi family could tell that Casso was a keeper. So in 1974, when he was 32 years old, they formally inducted him into the family as a made man. Now Casso had the first full backing and support of the Lucchesi family, and New York would never be the same. In the mid-1970s, Casso partnered with another made man named Vittorio Amuso to put together a team of professional burglars who they called the bypass gang, Named for their skill at bypassing locks and alarm systems. Relying on tips from friendly bank employees, the gang found locations with poorly secured safes in their basements. On the weekends when the banks were closed, members of Casso's crew would get access to the basement of whatever building was next door to the bank, then break through the wall. Once they were inside, Casso's expert safecrackers would go to work opening all the safety deposit boxes to steal the jewelry, cash and valuables inside. By the end of the weekend, they'd be gone, leaving a big hole in the wall for bank employees to find on Monday morning. It's estimated that casso stole over $100 million through heists like these over the next 10 years. He was a gifted thief and he brought in a lot of money for the family. But he did his best work with a gun. While Casso was running the bypass gang, his bosses in the Lucchese family were also using him as their go to hitman. Whenever the bosses suspected someone of stealing from them or talking to the police, they counted on Casso to take care of the situation. During the 1970s, the family learned that one of their business partners was passing information along to the local district attorney. So Casso invited the man to a late night poker game at one of the locations. Casey family's bars. Once the target was seated at the poker table and had ordered a drink, all the other players made excuses to get up and leave as soon as they were alone. Casso drew a.38 caliber pistol and shot the unsuspecting target in the head. When the job was done, Casso and his friends rolled the body up in blankets, then dumped the snitches remains in a vacant vacant lot. A year later, in 1975, Casso learned that one of his associates in the Bypass gang had been robbing other members of the gang, stealing back their ill gotten gains. This level of disloyalty was unacceptable and an example had to be made. Socasso and one of his underlings ambushed the traitor in broad daylight on the streets of Brooklyn, gunning him down in front of a crowd. Crowd of people. Even though there were plenty of witnesses, nobody came forward to implicate Casso in the crime. He had a reputation as a cold blooded killer. And soon that reputation would put him on a collision course with another bloodthirsty gangster, John Gotti. John Gotti was a captain in the Gambino family, another one of the five Mafia organizations that ran New York City. He was a top earner taking part in the Lufthansa heist, the theft of nearly $6 million from a cargo terminal at John F. Kennedy Airport, the largest heist in U.S. history at the time. He was brutal and never hesitated to kill anyone who got on his bad side, even his own next door neighbor. And most of all, he was ambitious. In 1985, Gotti was upset with the leadership of the Gambino family. He felt that their leader, Paul Castellano, was weak and out of touch with the men on the street. And Gotti didn't like that Castellano was taking a big cut of his earnings. So he hatched a plan to take Castellano out. On December 16, 1985, Castellano and one of his top advisors were leaving a Manhattan steakhouse when a group of heavily armed assassins ambushed them. Both men were gunned down and left to die on the street. In the aftermath, Gotti was elected as the new head of the Gambino family. Everybody knew that Gotti was responsible for the assassination. It was an unprecedented act of violence. And it was also a violation of the Mafia's most sacred codes. Even though the five families were rivals, they all agreed to play by the same set of rules. And one of them was that the head of one family couldn't be killed without the consent of the heads of all the other families. The rule was there to try and keep the Mafia's operations somewhat civil and avoid violent power struggles that would draw police attention. By murdering a boss in front of a crowd of civilians, Gotti had broken that rule. Now the public was outraged and calling for reform. And the FBI was coming down hard on Mafia operations all over New York. The heads of the other four families agreed that Gotti needed to be taken out. And they knew just who they could call to get the job done. Anthony Casso. At 43 years old, Anthony Casso had become the most feared hitman in the Lucchese crime family. In he was the family's go to guy for making informants, rivals and traitors disappear. But in 1985, he was given his biggest target yet. John Gotti, who'd just risen to the top of the Gambino crime family after assassinating the previous boss. The heads of the other families wanted Gotti killed, so nobody else tried to pull off a coup like his. So they hired Anthony Casso to take him out. Working with his longtime partner, Vittorio Amuso, Casso bought a brick of C4 explosives, which he wired up to a radio receiver from a remote control car he got at Toys R Us. Then he handed off the bomb to a couple of underlings and had them attach it to Gotti's car while he was visiting a Brooklyn social club on April 13, 1986. Hours later, when they spotted some someone getting into the car, the killers hit a button on the remote. The bomb went off, incinerating the car and scattering pieces of the driver's body all over the street. Casso and his men celebrated a job well done until a few hours later when they learned that Gotti hadn't been the one in the car. Instead, they'd killed Gotti's top advisor, Frank DeCicco. But as far as Casso's bosses were concerned, the hit was still a success. Gotti had lost one of his top men, and they'd sent him a powerful message. At the same time, though, Casso had made a powerful enemy, and Gotti was about to strike back. Several Months later, on September 14, 1986, Casso was driving away from a restaurant in Brooklyn when a car flew full of hitmen, pulled up alongside him and opened fire with shotguns. Casso saw them coming and ducked just in time to avoid the gunfire. Thinking quickly, he scrambled out the passenger side of his car and ran through a hail of gunfire back into the restaurant where he hid inside the kitchen freezer. The would be assassins took off before the police arrived, and Casso called a friend to pick him up and take him to the hospital. He'd been shot six times, but he was alive and he was ready for revenge. Casso had informants everywhere, and he soon learned that one of his attempted assassins was named James Hydell. So Casso paid a pair of corrupt NYPD detectives to pick Hydell up at his home in Staten Island. The cops told Hydell he was under arrest, but instead of taking him to a police station, they took him to the basement of a mob stat safe house where Casso was waiting. There, Casso savagely beat Hydell until He finally confessed that John Gotti had hired him and his accomplices. As soon as Casso had the information he wanted, he pulled out his gun and killed hydell, shooting him 15 times. Once hydell was dead, Casso took revenge on the other assassins. One was found shot to death and stuffed in the trunk of his car. Casso sent his men to take out another of the hitmen, Nikki Guido, not realizing that the would be killer was already in jail on cocaine charges. Instead, Casso's men accidentally killed a different and completely innocent man named Nikki Guido outside his Brooklyn home. Casso was on the warpath. But before he could take the fight all the way to John Gotti, he got distracted by a promotion. In November of 1986, the head of the Lucchese crime family was convicted of racketeering and sentenced to 100 years in prison. Before he left for jail, the boss put Casso's friend Vittorio Amuso in charge of the family. In turn, Amuso appointed Casso as his second in command. After a lifetime of service to the family, Casso had now made it to the second highest place in the organization at the age of just 44. But not everybody in the Lucchesi family was happy about Casso's rise to the top. Many of the captains underneath him and Amuso were resentful about having to give a cut of their earnings to two guys who were younger than they were. And some of them started loudly, publicly grumbling about the change in leadership. Soon, Casso put his feud with John Gotti on the back burner. He needed to clean house within his own family. Michael Papadillo was a Lucchese captain who frequently complained about Amuso and Casso. In the spring of 1989, he was beaten and shot to death in the back of a bagel shop, then cremated at a nearby cemetery. Later that year, Michael Salerno, another critic of the new regime, was found shot to death with his throat slit a few blocks away from his home in the Bronx. In February of 1990, another of Casso's rivals fled New York fearing for his life and took up residence in California. Casso used his sources in the NYPD to find find the fugitive's new address, then dispatched a team of four hitmen to kill him in his home. Casso would go on to order the killings of 14 more Lucchesi family members who'd been critical of him in the past. He justified these killings to his associates by claiming that the men he was having killed were all police informants. But in reality, Casso had gone mad with power. He'd long since eliminated his critics and was now just ordering hits on anyone he didn't like. One Lucchese soldier, Bruno Facciola, hadn't visited Casso in the hospital after he was shot in 1986. That was all it took to earn a death sentence. Casso lured him to an auto shop in Brooklyn where he was shot and stabbed to death, then left with a dead canary stuffed in his mouth. It was a message meant to suggest that Bruno had been singing, otherwise known as talking to the police. Once this message sank in, Casso killed two of Fasciola's friends, intending to eliminate them before they tried to take revenge on him. Ironically, even though Casso killed so many of his own men he claimed were informants, he was eventually brought down by an actual snitch in the family. In May of 1990, his sources in the NYPD tipped Casso off that he and Amuso were about to be indicted on racketeering charges. A fellow member of the Lucchese family, Peter Salvino, had implicated them both in a long running fraud in which mob aligned companies rigged bids for window installation contracts. It wasn't as big of a crime as the dozens of murders Casso had committed, but some. Savino's testimony could put him and Amuso behind bars for years. Casso was determined to stay out of jail, so he and Amuso both packed their bags and went on the run. But he didn't let that stop his killing spree. On May 27, 1990, just six days after his 48th birthday, Casso kissed his wife and children goodbye and disappeared. He'd broken the news to them a few days before that he had to go on the run to avoid going to jail for their own safety. Though he couldn't tell them where he was going, he and Amuso had made arrangements to keep running the family while they were in hiding. They'd call one of their captains, Al Darko, on designated payphones around New York to give him orders, which he would pass along to the rest of the family. Besides Darko, they would have no contact with any of their old associates or loved ones. One day after Casso left, the FBI showed up at his house with an arrest warrant. But his wife didn't know where he was. Agents staked out all of Casso's usual hangouts, but he didn't show up anywhere. As far as the FBI knew, he'd fallen off the face of the earth. In fact, he, casso was just 40 miles away, living at his mistress's house in New Jersey. For the next year, Casso kept a low profile. He woke up late, took long walks, and made frequent phone calls to Al Darko to manage the family's business. And most of that business consisted of organizing contract killings. First, he tried to solve his legal problems by getting the informant, Peter Savino, killed. But federal prosecutors weren't taking any chances. Savino was being kept on a military base in Hawaii where no hitmen could get to him. Instead, Casso tried to order hits on the prosecutor and judge assigned to his case. But both of those attempts fizzled out as well. Instead, he turned his attention to more attainable targets and settle old grudges. Working through Darko, Casso arranged for a pair of corrupt cops to kill another one of Gotti's captains. He had Darko pay them $75,000 to pull the target over on an empty road near a high school and shoot him dead in his car. He also ordered a hit on an architect named Anthony Fava, who he'd hired a few years before to design a house for his family in Brooklyn. Casso claimed that Fava had tried to blackmail him, but in fact, he just wanted him dead so he wouldn't have to pay him for the work he'd done. Fava's body was found in the trunk of his car, beaten, burned, stabbed, and shot to death. Eventually, Al Darko began to doubt that all the men Casso wanted killed were actually informants. But the final straw was when Casso ordered him to kill one of his longtime hitmen, Pete Kodo. Casso claimed Kyodo was about to begin cooperating with police. But Darko knew Kyoto would never rat his friends out, and he was outraged when Casso ordered him to have Kyoto's parents and sister killed as well. Ordering a hit on a mobster's family was unheard of, a violation of another one of the five Families Cardinal rules. Darko realized that if Casso was willing to go after the people closest to him like that, it was only a matter of time until he wound up with a target on his back. So In September of 1991, Al Darko put his wife, son, and parents in the car and went speeding out of New York City. He wanted to get as far away from Casso's network of informants as he could. Finally, he. He arrived at an FBI office in upstate New York, where he turned himself in and offered to testify against Anthony Casso. Darko didn't know exactly where Casso was, but over the next year and a half, he and a growing number of Lucchese family informants helped the FBI narrow it down. Everyone could see that Casso had gone off the deep end. He didn't have their backs. So every member of the family who got arrested was eager to give up what they knew about him to secure a lighter sentence. It took another year and a half to figure out his exact location. But finally, in early January of 1993, the FBI was able to trace Casso's cell phone to his mistress's house in Mount Olive, New Jersey. And on January 19, they went in to get their man. When agents broke down the door of the house, they caught Casso in a towel as he came out of the shower. Now that so many of his former allies had turned on him, the authorities had plenty of dirt on Anthony Casso. Shortly after his arrest, he was charged with 72 criminal counts, including 14 murders. Facing a lengthy sentence, the man who'd ordered hits on dozens of suspected snitches did the unthinkable. He took a plea bargain and agreed to become an informant himself. For the next five years, Casso was held in a luxurious low security prison in Texas, where he gave up the names of dozens of his accomplices, including the corrupt NYPD detectives who helped him with many of his hits. At the time, he was the highest ranking mafia figure to cooperate with prosecutors. But the arrangement wouldn't last. In 1998, the government retracted Casso's plea agreement after learning he'd assaulted other inmates, tried to bribe his guards and made a number of false statements about the mobsters he'd testified against. Instead, he was put on trial for his lifetime of thievery, racketeering and murder and sentenced to 455 years in prison without parole. Anthony Casso was willing to do anything and betray anyone to stay out of jail. Instead, he spent the rest of his life in America's toughest prison, ADX Florence until his death. From COVID 19 in November of 2020 at the end age of 78. He was the last of a dying breed of old school gangsters. And the world became a more peaceful place when he left it. Looking back on this week in crime history, we can see that eventually the law always catches up with you. Klaus Barbie spent decades building a new life for himself on a new continent. Anthony Casso spent years hiding out on a New Jersey cul de sac. But in the end, both of these cold blooded killers had to answer for their crimes and spent their final days inside a jail cell. Thanks so much for listening. I'M Vanessa Richardson and this is True Crime this Week. True Crime this Week is a Crime House Original powered by Pave Studios. At Crime House, we want to express our gratitude to you, our community, for making this possible. Please support us by rating, reviewing and following True Crime this Week. Wherever you get your podcasts, your feedback truly matters. And for ad free and early access to True Crime this Week, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. True Crime this Week is hosted by me, Vanessa Richardson and is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. This episode was brought to life by the True Crime this Week team Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benedon, Natalie Pertzovsky, Lori Marinelli, Sarah Camp, Truman Capps, Leo Roesch, and Michael Langsner. Thank you for listening. Looking for your next listen? Hi, it's Vanessa Richardson and I have exciting news. Conspiracy theories, Cults and crimes is leveling up starting the week of January 12th. You'll be getting two episodes every week. Wednesday. On Wednesdays we unravel the conspiracy or the cult, and on Fridays we look at a corresponding crime. Follow Conspiracy Theories, Cults and Crimes now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music or wherever you listen.