Listener (24:48)
Missing, a team of police officers and local volunteers mounted an entire intensive search of the surrounding area, combing through the wooded areas around Lovers Lane for any trace of the missing couple. They followed up lead after lead and tip after tip. But no one could find hide nor hair of Jesse or Patricia. With frustration mounting, police decided to widen the range of the search area and enlist the help of helicopter support and specially trained forensic diversity. But in the end, it was the misfortune of a surveyor in nearby Orange county that provided the police with their most important lead. On February 25, 1971, a full 12 days after Jesse and Patricia went missing, Robert Kirby is walking along a dirt road in the backwoods of Orange County, North Carolina, when something catches his eye. Among the trees, maybe 50 meters or so off the trail, the surveyor thinks he sees what appears to be the limb of a mannequin laying among the fallen leaves. Curious, he wanders over to check it out. But the distinct shape of a human leg he sees is not that of a plastic mannequin. It is real human flesh. He rushes to a nearby roadside diner to have someone call the police. And by the end of that, forensic investigators discovered not one, but two human corpses up in the woods of Orange County. And they turned out to belong to none other than Jesse McBain and Patricia Mann. Finding the young couple and that they were decomposing was bad enough for the searchers, but the manner in which they had obviously been dispatched was massively disturbing to them. The couple had their hands tied, and they were made to stand back against a tree. So another Larger rope could be wrapped around them. Once their killer had secured them in place, he began to torture them. Jesse's ear and mouth were both found to have blood in them, and a variety of large and small abrasions to his lips and forehead suggested he was beaten senseless before he was killed. At some point, Jesse and Patricia's killer had ripped their eyelashes off before continuing to savagely beat them. Then, when whoever had tied them up had grown tired of beating them, they wrapped rope collars around their necks using a kind of knot that could be repeatedly tightened over and over again. We can only assume that the killer used these rope collars to slowly choke the life out of ch. Jesse and Patricia, gradually tightening the rope collars over a drawn out period of time until neither was able to breathe. Each of the couple's bodies had all of their valuables intact. Jesse was still wearing an expensive wristwatch and a class ring when his body was found. Patricia was also wearing jewelry, and her purse was left back in the abandoned car. Their deaths were not part of some robbery. Their killer had absolutely no monetary gain in mind when he had taken them. Neither were there any signs of indecent assault on Patricia. She had a great deal of bruising around her face and neck, but nothing below the waistline. There was no ulterior motive. All their killer wanted to do was torture and kill them. The investigation that followed was severely hampered by different agencies complete lack of collaboration. For example, the FBI seemed to consider the local sheriffs as frankly beneath them. And a feeling of contempt quickly grew between the two groups. Everyone worked on the case as individuals. As detective Tom Horn once put it, not a lot of information was being shared by the various agencies, and the rivalry was tremendous. A lot of work was done, but it was individual, so there was definitely some missed opportunities. Yet even with the appalling level of disorganization that pervaded, a number of likely suspects emerged as a result of some tip top police work. Some had to be ruled out after taking polygraph tests which proved their innocence. But one of the men who failed was actually a doctor at Watts hospital who had previously worked with Patricia Mann. When the police sought to question him again, he completely refused to cooperate and would only release a statement through a defense attorney he began to keep on retainer. This made him the number one suspect in the entire case. And to this day, there's never really been anyone else who had garnered such legitimate scrutiny. But without the proper evidence to charge him, very little action was taken against any of the supposed killers. No one Ever really zeroed in on anyone, Detective Horn stated. And as a result, the case quickly went cold. 43 years later, in 2014, Detective Tim Horne was still working for the Orange County Sheriff's department when a cousin of Patricia's, Carolyn Spivey, contacted him with some fresh information regarding her cousin's murder. Along with his partner at the time, Detective Horn opened up the previously closed case file. Poring over old statements and boxes of evidence, they reanalyzed the possibilities of former suspects, considered new ones, and began to condense as much of the multi agency information as possible into the pursuit of one solid suspect. And they succeeded. Detective Horn then contacted almost every single one of the detectives who worked the case back in 1971 and gathered them together for a presentation. It was one which would show them how he had pieced together multiple pieces of a decades long puzzle, only to come to one solid conclusion. That it was the watchdoctor, A man Patricia had actually known that had murdered her and her boyfriend Jesse. When the presentation was finished, what followed was a prolonged silence to all in attendance. Tim Horn's hard work had presented them the best opportunity yet to end a mystery that had persisted for almost half a century. They had their suspect, they had evidence. Now it was time to make their move. Using what's known as an M Vac, Detective Horn was able to extract a DNA sample from the knotted ropes used to tie up and strangle Jesse and Patricia. An M vac is basically a wet vacuum DNA collection system that is designed to extract strands of DNA from difficult to reach places. Places just like the fibrous folds in a length of rope. What came back was a DNA sample that didn't match either Jesse or Patricia. So in all likelihood it belonged to the killer. Detective Horn then requested a DNA sample from their number one suspect, the Watts doctor that Patricia had worked with. Horn's argument was that after all this time, the doctor would finally be able to clear his name and prove that it wasn't him that executed the young couple. But the doctor refused having his defense attorney contact law enforcement to release a statement in legales. And that just might be the most suspicious thing about our doctor because it really does raise the question of what does he have to hide. Yet despite such obvious suspicion, this doctor has never been charged. And whatever new evidence led to him being asked to provide a DNA sample hasn't been shared with the public. We can only assume that the Durham County Sheriff's department are in the process of putting a serious case against the man and are trying to find Some way of forcing him to give a sample of his DNA. And with that DNA sample, law enforcement might just be able to end the 40 year old mystery of who could be cold and cruel enough to wrench a loved up young couple away from one of the happiest nights of their lives. Only to torture and eventually execute them in a secluded wooded area. Turning a romantic Valentine's Day night into the very last that each of them would ever spend on earth. I was traveling through Europe from mid August all the way through January. While I was in Greece, I met this really cute, sweet couple named Maggie and David. They were from the UK and lived along the border of England and Scotland. And they invited me to come and stay with them from October to mid November. Their youngest child was attending university and they felt like they wanted another youngin around their cottage house since they found they didn't enjoy the empty nest as much as they thought they would. So I agreed that when I was finished exploring Thessaloniki, I would come and stay with them and maybe help around the house and see some of the countryside. I don't know why Maggie called it a cottage house. It was much larger than a cottage. Old. Definitely. Very fancy, but old. It was very long and narrow. I suppose she called it a cottage because it was out in the country. I don't know if there was any houses for kilometers in any direction. Maggie was just about the sweetest person I had ever met. Still is. And her and I talk all the time. To this day I don't really talk to David, but that's because David is just not much of a talker. Whereas Maggie was bubbly and warm and loved to tell the stories and jokes. David was more stoic and stern. That isn't to say that he was mean or anything. He was quite friendly, but he just didn't talk very much and certainly didn't joke around and wasn't much of a storyteller. Most of the time Maggie would be singing in the garden or talking on the phone with somebody while David would just sit in his armchair and read a history book. I spent a lot of time helping them out by chopping a lot of firewood for the fireplace due to the house being drafted and cold. Quite often Maggie was really friendly and she introduced me to all of her son's friends and today in turn introduced me to some really cute girls. And we would leave the countryside and go to the nearest town and get a few pints at the pub. Halloween was soon approaching and we made plans to have some sort of celebration. Maybe by going out to one of the old cemeteries and playing with a Ouija board or something. No plans were yet solidified, but we were in the midst of making something, so that's basically the backstory. Onward with what leads up to the event the cottage was a long, narrow one story house and I got to stay in the guest bedroom that was located sort of in the middle of the establishment and it was placed closest to the kitchen. It was my second or third night there when I woke up in the middle of the night to hear somebody walking upstairs. Now, as I have already established, this was a one story house, so I was confused. How could somebody be walking up and down stairs when there were no stairs? The first time I heard this I figured maybe I was in the middle of a dream perhaps, or maybe there was just something outside that was hitting against the walls, or maybe I was just tripping. I shrugged it off and went back to sleep. The day after, I had completely forgotten about it as the excitement of being in the UK was overpowering any anticipation I might have felt. I went out with the other folks that Maggie had introduced me to and went out for more pints at the pub and played darts and other things. I got home late and crawled into bed. It was near midnight now and there it was again. Unmistakably, it was something walking up and down a set of stairs. I knew I hadn't gone off to sleep at this point because I was still scrolling through my phone for sights to see. The next day, curiosity got the better of me and I got out of bed and opened the door and peered into the kitchen and down the hallway one direction and then to the other. But there was nothing. Absolutely nothing. Being a bit spooked and feeling a chill, I approached the fireplace, put a log on it, sat in David's armchair for a moment and watched the log get eaten by flame when I heard a creaky door close. It wasn't a slam, but it was loud, almost as if the door was heavy. Okay, I said to myself. This is too weird. The morning after at the breakfast table, I casually brought up the stair stepping. You folks got an invisible staircase or something? I joked. Oh. Maggie's face brightened up with a mischievous smile. You hear the steps, don't you? Yeah, I admitted. Don't you worry about him, love. He's just the butler. I was confused at this point. The butler? I asked. You guys have a butler? No, no, no, silly. Maggie laughed. Here, I'll show you. Maggie gets up from the kitchen table, takes a few steps and removes a corner of a rug and there's this small sort of hole. It turns out there was a handle there because the next thing I know, Maggie lifts up the floor with this arduous, freaky creaking sound that revealed a doorway in the middle of the floor. See, she said, we have a wine cellar. Oh. I gasped, surprised. Back in the middle of the 19th century, this house belonged to some high class people, royalty and all. This is where the butler slept down here. So you mean. That's right, mate, david said. Our house is haunted. Oh, don't scare him, Davey. Maggie slapped at David's shoulder, continuing to say, listen, love, most people never even hear the footsteps. Just ignore it. The butler's harmless. The phone rang and Maggie answered it and went into the next room. Aye, the butler's harmless, david said. Then, whispering almost to himself, it seemed, he continued, continued. It's the other one you gotta worry about. I asked. The other one?
