Scary Stories For A Rainy Night - Ep. 317 - Jagged Teeth

Podcast: Scary Stories and Rain
Host: Being Scared
Date: February 5, 2026

Episode Overview

This episode immerses listeners in a series of unsettling stories, each blending the supernatural with very real human fear. With calm, engaging narration set against the gentle rumble of rain, Being Scared recounts true accounts of late-night terrors, close calls with predatory strangers, inexplicable hauntings, and childhood nightmares that bleed into reality. The titular story, “Jagged Teeth,” anchors an episode that explores the bone-chilling experiences that hide in quiet, rainy moments when the world seems most vulnerable.

Key Stories & Discussion Points

1. The Wrong Ride (00:01 – 11:35)

• Summary:
  A food service worker, desperate for safe employment during the pandemic, accepts a night shift at a medical office. Exhausted, she calls a rideshare but enters the wrong car—one that isn't her Uber. Abandoned in a dilapidated building late at night, she’s forced to confront her vulnerability, culminating in a narrow escape, aided by a patrolling police officer.
• Highlights:
  • The importance of verifying ride details.
  • The subtle cues of danger—locked doors, abandoned spaces, heavy breathing.
  • Police officer’s suspicion and eventual understanding after the witness pieces together the mix-up.
• Notable Quote [06:24]:
  “There was no way for him to realize this had been the wrong address. My stomach lurched forward and my blood chilled to slush.”

2. The Man with the Unicorn Backpack (11:36 – 16:55)

• Summary:
  A young woman doing late-night laundry encounters an odd man: pink hair, ski mask, unicorn backpack. As subtle paranoia builds, she glimpses duct tape inside his bag and realizes she might have narrowly escaped being attacked or abducted.
• Highlights:
  • Subtle escalation of unease: standing between her and the door, odd questions, concealed hand.
  • The random entry of another customer breaks the tension and likely saves her.
  • The psychological effect—switching to laundry services despite cost, never returning.
• Notable Quote [14:51]:
  “It was like this cold, numb dread just washed down over me. I almost felt calm, like I knew the next steps, knew I had to do something.”

3. Life360 & The Creaking Floorboards (16:56 – 23:09)

• Summary:
  Alone at home, a woman receives a location alert that her boyfriend won’t arrive for another half hour—moments after she hears creaking footsteps in their house. A tense escape through a bedroom window narrowly avoids an intruder, whom she locks eyes with only for a terrifying instant.
• Highlights:
  • The reliance on tracking technology for safety—how it can both reassure and terrify.
  • The split-second decision-making under life-threatening fear.
  • Aftermath includes increased home security and lasting psychological trauma.
• Notable Quote [20:10]:
  “I kept taking peaks into the window and couldn't see anyone. I felt more confident to run past and took one last peek and he was there, looking right at me, not even a foot away from the window.”

4. Jimmy’s Moved Grave (23:10 – 28:31)

• Summary:
  In rural Ireland, a man walking his dogs notices that the grave of a local acquaintance, Jimmy, seems to have inexplicably moved. His dogs are paralyzed by fear at the cemetery gate, and the experience triggers unsettling memories of other odd occurrences in the same graveyard.
• Highlights:
  • A blending of the supernatural and personal memory—grave shifting as an omen.
  • Subtle animal intuition paralleling human unease.
  • Cultural details about local customs and the “Blessing of the Graves.”
• Memorable Moment [26:50]: “As the dogs and I reached the last grave, my heart nearly went into my mouth. Jimmy’s grave was not there.”

5. Stalked by the Neighbor (28:32 – 37:30)

• Summary:
  A woman recounts moving to a new place and befriending her only neighbor, Jake, whose kindness turns into obsession and stalking. After months of escalating harassment—unwanted gifts, unannounced visits, workplace intrusions, a break-in—she narrowly escapes a final nighttime confrontation before securing a restraining order.
• Highlights:
  • The progression from normal acquaintance to terrifying stalker.
  • The frustration with law enforcement’s inability to act until enough evidence mounts.
  • Lingering impacts on mental health and trust.
• Notable Quote [31:00]:
  “He suddenly dropped his cheery demeanor as if he had become someone else. In a matter of seconds, he grabbed his things and left, saying only that he had to go to work.”

6. The Recurring Nightmare — Jagged Teeth (Featured Story)

(37:31 – 43:12)

• Summary:
  A woman shares a childhood nightmare that plagued her for years—involving being dragged into a white basement by a dentist-like figure who forcibly removes teeth. Decades later, she discovers a real man matching the dream's description lived in her former house’s basement, blurring the line between dream and reality.
• Highlights:
  • The haunting detail: jars of teeth with gums still attached.
  • The late discovery that haunts her adulthood.
• Notable Quote [39:39]:
  “He was dressed in all white… There was a long white table with jars and jars all lined up with teeth in them and the gums were still attached. He had an empty jar and his tools all laid out.”

7. A Whisper in the Dark (43:13 – 46:56)

• Summary:
  A young man recounts a terrifying experience with sleep paralysis that goes well beyond the ordinary. A spectral voice whispers in his ear, and a palpable presence climbs onto his chest, caressing him—a physical sensation that leaves him doubting the boundaries between dream, spirit, and hallucination.
• Highlights:
  • Vivid description of the “cuddling” ghost or entity.
  • The merging of sleep disorders and supernatural suggestion.
• Notable Quote [45:23]:
  “In close proximity of my ear, I heard someone say, 'Hey.' It sounded like a woman whispering in my ear.”

8. The Ashland Motel (46:57 – 59:59)

• Summary:
  After spotting a hidden, eerie billboard for the Ashland Motel, a young man and his friends seek it out, only to find themselves beset by supernatural terror: a motel full of figures with gaping eye sockets and gigantic, jagged smiles, plus a shadow figure that haunts their escape.
• Highlights:
  • The feeling of compulsion, nausea, and terror linked to the sign.
  • The climax: escaping the woods as dozens of inhuman, toothy faces scream from the darkened motel windows.
  • Lingering psychological impact described upon return.
• Notable Quote [53:11]:
  “All the faces had a disgustingly large smile, too large to be human, stretching from ear to ear, each showing too many teeth, all of them perfectly white.”

9. Laughter in the Woods (1:00:00 – 1:05:34)

• Summary:
  Alone in his parents’ remote cabin, a young man takes a nighttime walk, only to be harassed by an unseen presence in the woods. A rock he throws is hurled back, accompanied by insane laughter. He flees, later discovering evidence of someone—perhaps dangerous—having recently been there.
• Highlights:
  • The isolation of rural locations and its risks.
  • Unnerving physical evidence discovered by police: a knife, rope, blood, and a nearby, ransacked cabin.
• Notable Quote [1:02:50]:
  “The same rock I threw was thrown right back at me. I never ran so fast in my life.”

Timestamps for Notable Segments

| Segment | Time Range | | ---------------------------------------- | ----------------- | | The Wrong Ride | 00:01 – 11:35 | | Man with the Unicorn Backpack | 11:36 – 16:55 | | Life360 & The Creaking Floorboards | 16:56 – 23:09 | | Jimmy’s Moved Grave | 23:10 – 28:31 | | Stalked by the Neighbor | 28:32 – 37:30 | | Jagged Teeth – Recurring Nightmare | 37:31 – 43:12 | | A Whisper in the Dark | 43:13 – 46:56 | | The Ashland Motel | 46:57 – 59:59 | | Laughter in the Woods | 1:00:00 – 1:05:34 |

Memorable Moments & Quotes

• On listening to warning signs:
  “Quadruple check your license plate and driver name. You just never know.” (The Wrong Ride, 11:20)
• On animal intuition:
  “My dogs—usually so brave—were tails down, refusing to go in.” (Jimmy’s Moved Grave, 24:10)
• On primal fear:
  “I knew that it was better to deal with that thing in the woods than whatever was in the motel. Those faces would do something worse than kill us. I knew it.” (The Ashland Motel, 54:55)
• On the uncertainty of reality:
  “If it was a spirit, maybe it was just lonely and needed a body to lay with. Maybe it was a dream, but I don’t dream that often, especially if the touch I felt is real.” (A Whisper in the Dark, 46:11)

Tone & Atmosphere

Throughout, Being Scared maintains a calm, conversational, and empathetic storytelling style. The narrative pace is deliberate, unhurried—allowing each story’s tension and anxiety to seep in, punctuated by the ever-present soundscape of rain. The episode’s atmosphere is simultaneously soothing and spine-tingling, perfectly pitched for sleepless, rainy nights.

Takeaways

• Trust your instincts—often, a gut feeling is the first line of defense against real danger.
• Technology can be both a shield and a source of dread—stories weave in tracking apps and ridesharing, revealing their strengths and vulnerabilities.
• The supernatural and the all-too-human intertwine—from stalkers and would-be attackers to haunted dreams and shifting graves, the scariest stories are those that leave you unsure where reality ends.

For listeners:
This episode reminds us: caution isn’t paranoia, and sometimes—whether caught in the jaws of a nightmare or alone under stormy skies—the only thing standing between us and horror is the chance presence of something, or someone, else.

Skip ahead for more stories: Every episode delivers new chills for a rainy night. Subscribe for uninterrupted, ad-free listening and exclusive episodes.