Scoop City: Aaron Rodgers Breaks Offseason Silence, Details Jets Exit, & Explores Playing or Retirement Options

Released on April 18, 2025

Hosts:

• Diana Rossini - The Athletic’s Senior NFL Insider
• Chase Daniel - Longtime NFL Quarterback

Aaron Rodgers Opens Up: Playing or Retirement on the Table

In this episode, Diana Rossini and Chase Daniel delve deep into the latest developments surrounding Aaron Rodgers' offseason activities. Rodgers made headlines by appearing on the Pat McAfee show, where he addressed his future in the NFL, leaving fans and teams alike in suspense.

Rodgers’ Ambiguous Future: Rodgers communicated a non-committal stance regarding his future, stating, “I’m open to anything,” and hinted that retirement remains a viable option. Rossini highlights Rodgers' focus on his personal life, emphasizing the uncertainty of his decision-making process.

[05:15] Diana Rossini: “Right now my focus is and has been and will continue to be on my personal life.”

Chase expresses frustration over Rodgers' lack of concrete information, questioning the quarterback's openness and the implications for interested teams like the Pittsburgh Steelers.

[06:00] Chase Daniel: “He didn’t say anything. He didn’t tell us anything.”

Implications for the Pittsburgh Steelers and NFL Landscape

Rossini and Daniel explore the potential fallout of Rodgers' indecisiveness on teams actively seeking his signature, particularly the Pittsburgh Steelers. The Steelers have been in continuous talks but have yet to receive a definitive answer from Rodgers.

Control of the Narrative: Daniel criticizes Rodgers for seemingly attempting to control the narrative without providing substantial details about his intentions or personal life.

[06:00] Chase Daniel: “I just don’t understand why he said he’s going to play for $10 million, which is clearly not the fact he might play for $10 million for Minnesota.”

Rossini suggests that Rodgers’ comments might give the Steelers more clarity, allowing them to strategize their draft plans without lingering uncertainty.

[08:33] Diana Rossini: “Maybe this gives Mike Tomlin and Omar Khan a little bit more ammo to make a move.”

New York Giants’ Quarterback Workouts: Assessing the Competition

Shifting focus to the New York Giants, Rossini and Daniel discuss the team's recent efforts to evaluate quarterback prospects ahead of the draft. The Giants have been conducting late private workouts, flying out to Colorado and Louisville to assess players like Shador Sanders, Jalen Milroe, and Tyler Schuck.

Strategic Information Gathering: Rossini explains that the Giants' actions are more about gathering intel rather than making immediate decisions, countering speculations of internal disagreements within the organization.

[03:59] Diana Rossini: “We’ve been putting out tons of information about this upcoming draft.”

Daniel concurs, pondering whether the Giants are preparing for various scenarios as the draft approaches.

[17:30] Chase Daniel: “It seems to me, I mean, you’re the one saying it. You just said it. But it, it wouldn’t…”

Draft Strategies: Mock Drafts and Team Preferences

The discussion transitions to mock drafts, with Rossini emphasizing their value in predicting team behaviors and identifying consensus picks as the draft nears. She notes that while mock drafts become more aligned as teams reveal their preferences, uncertainties like the Giants' quarterback plans introduce variability.

[24:36] Diana Rossini: “I like comparing all the different mock drafts and what starts to happen as we get closer. They start looking alike.”

Chase shares his focus on the New Orleans Saints' upcoming pick at number nine, debating whether they will bolster their edge rusher line or invest in a quarterback to secure their future after Cam Jordan’s potential retirement.

[30:12] Chase Daniel: “What are they going to do at 9?”

Top Prospects and Team Needs: Tyler Schuck vs. Jackson Dart

Both hosts analyze key quarterback prospects such as Tyler Schuck and Jackson Dart, speculating on their draft positions and suitability for different team systems. They consider factors like team needs, player readiness, and fit within existing offensive schemes.

[13:31] Chase Daniel: “Why haven’t he made a decision yet? You know what I mean?”

Influence of Team Owners on Draft Decisions

Rossini introduces the topic of owner involvement in draft decisions, suggesting that some NFL owners play a significant role in influencing their teams' picks. This adds another layer of complexity to predicting draft outcomes.

[35:03] Diana Rossini: “There are roughly about 13 or 14 that are involved with the draft heavily.”

Personal Segment: The Pineapple Pizza Debate

In a lighter interlude, Rossini and Daniel engage in a playful debate over pineapple as a pizza topping, revealing their divergent culinary preferences. This segment showcases the hosts' chemistry and adds a touch of humor to the episode.

[48:30] Chase Daniel: “How is that bold? It’s fresh pineapple from Hawaii on cheese. It’s sweet and it’s savory.”

Rossini firmly opposes the combination, highlighting their differences in taste and upbringing.

[50:07] Diana Rossini: “I can’t do it, that is. It just doesn’t make sense.”

Upcoming Shows and Final Thoughts

As the draft looms closer, Rossini and Daniel outline their plans to continue analyzing team strategies and draft moves. They encourage listeners to engage with their content across various platforms and tease upcoming discussions and live shows.

[58:37] Diana Rossini: “We have so much to pay attention to between now and then. So much stuff is going to be flying around, and it's probably why it's one of the best NFL events on the calendar, because we just don’t know.”

Notable Quotes:

• Chase Daniel ([05:15]): “He didn’t say anything. He didn’t tell us anything.”

• Diana Rossini ([08:33]): “Maybe this gives Mike Tomlin and Omar Khan a little bit more ammo to make a move.”

• Chase Daniel ([17:30]): “It seems to me, I mean, you’re the one saying it. You just said it. But it, it wouldn’t…”

Conclusion:

This episode of Scoop City offers a comprehensive look into Aaron Rodgers' uncertain future, the New York Giants' quarterback evaluations, and the broader implications for the NFL draft landscape. Rossini and Daniel provide insightful analysis, blending serious discussion with engaging personal anecdotes to keep listeners informed and entertained.

For those eager to stay ahead of the NFL curve, this episode is a must-listen, packed with expert opinions, timely insights, and a dash of host chemistry that makes Scoop City the ultimate destination for NFL enthusiasts.

Stay Connected:

• YouTube: Subscribe to the Scoop City channel for video content and live shows.
• Podcast Platforms: Available on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever you get your podcasts.
• Newsletter: Subscribe to the free Scoop City newsletter for daily updates and exclusive insights.

Next Episode Preview: Tune in next week as Rossini and Daniel return with post-draft analyses, breaking down the biggest picks and uncovering hidden gems. Plus, don’t miss their fun segment on "Scoop City Olympics," featuring listener interactions and debates.

Subscribe Now: Ensure you never miss an episode by subscribing to Scoop City on your preferred podcast platform or following them on YouTube.

Thank you for tuning into Scoop City: A Show About the NFL, brought to you by The Athletic.