Episode Summary: "Wait, Should I Not Be Drinking Airplane Coffee? (Classic)"

Released on June 20, 2025 | Host: PJ Vogt

In this compelling re-broadcast of Search Engine’s inaugural episode, host PJ Vogt delves into the murky waters of airplane coffee safety. Originally aired in July 2023, this episode revisits the early days of the podcast, capturing the excitement and discovery that marked its beginning. As summer travel ramps up, PJ and his guest explore whether drinking coffee on airplanes is as safe as passengers believe.

1. Introduction and Personal Anecdotes

[00:00 - 05:35]

PJ Vogt sets the stage by reminiscing about the podcast’s inception and introduces the central question: “Wait, should I not be drinking airplane coffee?” He then introduces his friend, Anthony Perowski, known for his appearances on Netflix’s Queer Eye and as a bestselling cookbook author.

Notable Quote:

“This feels crazy to say, almost 20 years. How do we know each other?”
— PJ Vogt [04:12]

2. The Origin of the Concern

[05:35 - 07:17]

Anthony recounts a conversation with a skeptical flight attendant who revealed that the same water used for coffee and tea is also used for handwashing in airplane bathrooms. This revelation sparked a deeper investigation into the cleanliness and safety of airplane water systems.

Notable Quote:

“Apparently, they only have to legally wash the tank once or twice a year.”
— Nancy Keats [07:17]

3. Early Investigations and Wall Street Journal Report

[07:17 - 12:00]

Nancy Keats, a Wall Street Journal reporter, shares her background in conducting investigative tests. Inspired by a 2002 FlyerTalk forum post by Zachary Bjornsson Hooper, a homeschooled 13-year-old who discovered contamination in airplane water, Nancy and her colleague decided to replicate and expand upon his findings.

Notable Quote:

“We booked 14 different flights... to see if the carrier or the distance might have an impact.”
— Nancy Keats [24:40]

4. Findings of Contaminated Airplane Water

[12:00 - 30:52]

Nancy discusses the alarming results of their tests, which revealed harmful bacteria such as Pasturella, Salmonella, and even insect eggs in the water samples. Despite these findings, airlines largely responded with denial or claimed that their water was "absolutely drinkable."

Notable Quotes:

“One of the water samples had the same amount of bacteria you'd expect to find in a sample of tainted raw hamburger.”
— Lab Director [27:24]

“We did have some great years.”
— Nancy Keats [04:32]

5. Regulatory Response and the Airline Drinking Water Rule (ADWR)

[30:46 - 35:59]

The Wall Street Journal’s reporting prompted the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to establish a working group that eventually led to the Airline Drinking Water Rule in 2011. This regulation mandates that airlines test their water systems at least once a year for coliforms and E. coli. However, Dr. Charles Plattkin, an academic and diet detective, argues that these standards are significantly weaker than municipal water regulations, raising ongoing concerns about water safety on planes.

Notable Quote:

“This is just self-reported data.”
— Dr. Charles Plattkin [37:22]

6. Expert Analysis with Dr. Charles Plattkin

[35:59 - 48:09]

Dr. Charles Plattkin provides a microbiologist’s perspective, explaining that while airline water starts as municipal water and undergoes treatment, the confined environment of airplanes presents unique contamination risks. He conducted his own study at a Dublin airport, finding that the microbiological quality of airplane water was generally acceptable, though chlorine levels occasionally spiked.

Notable Quote:

“Airline tanks must be cleaned once a year.”
— PJ Vogt [30:52]

“You are getting fresh air water in constantly into the tank.”
— Antony Perowski [44:26]

7. Current Perspectives and Personal Decisions

[48:09 - 51:59]

PJ reflects on how the investigation has influenced his own behavior, making him more cautious about consuming shared items. Anthony shares his continued skepticism but ultimately decides to trust the safety measures in place, exemplified by his recent act of drinking tea on a flight.

Notable Quote:

“But I will have tea and coffee on an airplane. I need it.”
— Antony Perowski [47:24]

8. Conclusion: To Drink or Not to Drink

[51:59 - End]

PJ grapples with the balance between skepticism and trust in regulatory frameworks. While some experts like Dr. Plattkin remain wary of the adequacy of current standards, others find the practices sufficiently safe. The episode concludes with a nuanced view, encouraging listeners to make informed decisions based on available evidence and personal comfort levels.

Notable Quote:

“Ultimately, what you're saying is it is safe to drink coffee on airplanes?”
— PJ Vogt [47:42]
“Yes, absolutely.”
— Antony Perowski [47:07]

Key Takeaways

• Airplane Water Systems: Originating from municipal sources, treated water is stored in tanks on airplanes, which are subject to cleaning and testing regulations.

• Contamination Risks: Early investigations found harmful bacteria in airplane water, prompting regulatory changes.

• Regulatory Standards: The EPA’s Airline Drinking Water Rule requires annual testing for coliforms and E. coli, but experts argue these standards are less stringent than those for municipal water.

• Expert Opinions: While some microbiologists confirm the general safety of airplane water, concerns about the frequency of tank cleanings and the scope of water quality testing persist.

• Personal Choices: Investigations have influenced individuals to adopt cautious behaviors, such as bringing their own water bottles or avoiding certain airplane beverages.

Final Thoughts

This episode of Search Engine masterfully navigates the intersection of public health, regulatory oversight, and personal responsibility. By combining journalistic inquiry with expert analysis, PJ Vogt provides listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the complexities surrounding airplane coffee safety. Whether you're a frequent flyer or an occasional traveler, the insights shared here empower you to make informed decisions about what you consume while airborne.

Follow Search Engine:
Listen to Search Engine for free on the Odyssey app or wherever you get your podcasts.