
Meg Wolitzer presents two stories about belonging and sacrifice in two very different kinds of social orders. In Wolitzer’s own “The Summer Reading List” the intensity of youthful bookworms is perfectly captured. It’s performed by Melora Hardin. And Marie-Helene Bertino takes us inside a bat cave for a story of love, longing, and immortality. “Viola in Midwinter” was chosen for the Best American Short Stories 2024 anthology by guest editor Lauren Groff. It’s performed by Rita Wolf.
Loading summary
Meg Wolitzer
Thumbtack presents the ins and outs of.
Melora Hardin
Caring for your home. Out indecision, overthinking, second guessing every choice you make in plans and guides that make it easy to get home projects done out beige on beige on beige.
Rita Wolf
And knowing what to do, when to.
Melora Hardin
Do it, and who to hire. Start caring for your home with confidence. Download Thumbtack today.
Rita Wolf
Membership has its privileges, whether you're in a book club or a vampire coven. I'm Meg Wolitzer, and on the next Selected Shorts we explore fiction about the delights and the dues paid for being part of a club. And the only thing you need to do to join our little literary club is hold tight. You're listening to Selected Shorts where our greatest actors transport us through the magic of fiction, one short story at a time. Most of us belong to some kind of collective a formal organization in a school or place of worship, a casual coffee clutch, a fantasy football league. Who knows? We may not need to hunt in a pack or huddle together for warmth. But this urge to form cliques is an instinct we share with a lot of other animals. And it's interesting that no matter how loose the affiliation, social pods usually have a few things in common. One, there's an initiation period. Two, there are responsibilities or dues to pay, even if it's just sharing one's best cookie recipes. And three, there are rules to follow. Sometimes the rules are unspoken. They don't talk while Tanya plays her hand, while others are strict, disqualifying anyone who strays. And on this selected shorts, we're going to hear stories about belonging and sacrifice in two very different kinds of social orders, what it takes to get in, what it takes to stay in, and how to know when it's time to let go. One piece involves bookworms and the books they love. The other involves nocturnal animals and the hunting they crave. Our first story. Well, I wrote it. It was included in an anthology of stories about summertime, appropriately titled Summer. And with this book, I find myself in excellent company among authors I admire. It's about a very passionate club and an early period in life when all you've got is time and the season stretches out before you like an endless green meadow. Reading the story now, over 30 years after having written it, I find myself wistful about the past, much the way the me in the story spoiler alert. But not really. Ends up kind of wistful about childhood. Performing it is Melora Hardin. She's known for TV series including the Bold Type and the Office, but also stays busy on the stage, including a recent visit to Broadway in the play McNeil alongside Robert Downey Jr. Now Melora Hardin reads the Summer Reading List by me, Meg Waltzer.
Melora Hardin
For those of us spending the summer at home, the public library has become a kind of clubhouse. We 12 year olds haunt the corridors carrying staggering armloads of books, acknowledging each other grimly as we pass. The building has no air conditioner and we are sweating under the labors, but somehow we feel purposeful here in this small suburban branch library where the children's librarian occasionally looks up at us from her heat stupor, nodding in approval. The walls are lined with brightly colored Snoopy and Charlie Brown posters that urge us to read, but we don't need any prompting. We are way beyond the point of initiation. What we are here for is volume. As members of our library Summer Reading Club, our responsibilities are simple. Over the course of the season, we must read at least 10 books.
Rita Wolf
10.
Melora Hardin
We say the number with true disdain. 10 is nothing. 10 is what we will have ripped through before the first week in July, before the hottest days have even started. Each of us is aiming for many, many more than 10. How to explain this new appetite that arrives with summer? It's as though we spend the rest of the year refueling, and only when school ends are we able to rise up from our separate homes and convene in these muted library halls. Certainly during the school year we don't have time to read this much between homework and after school projects, but it's clearly more than a question of time, and it's more the fact that there are rewards involved. At the end of the summer, a huge party will be thrown in our honor. A magician performs, doves fly from his silk hat, and we clap as we're supposed to. But none of us is focusing on his magic. Instead, we're glancing down at the Summer Reading Club newsletter. We've been handed a stapled together leaflet that lists each club member by name and the titles of the books he or she has read. The book lists are long and single spaced. Most of us have read a disturbingly large number of books. We compare prowess, but we also take note of titles with fondness or dislike or intrigue. From the mixed up files of Mrs. Basil Frankweiler, it's like this cat, my darling, my hamburger. We are sitting in the darkness with a magician on stage producing doves and ropes of colored scarves. But all of us are distracted. Distracted. We're lost in plots, characters, populated worlds that we've plowed through during the hottest days of summer. We all know that there is something magical about the amount of books we've read, something nearly miraculous about the sudden veracity that's been implanted in each of us. But it hasn't been implanted there merely by idleness or the promise of reward. The reason is bigger than that, and all of us know it. But since we're only 12 years old, we can't yet name it. Summers later, I've come to learn that there is something in the nature of summer itself, something contained in the shape and sensibility of those long, inert months that make people want to read. As a 12 year old, I learned to absorb large doses of ideas and images, and I never lost the ability. But I also never lost my sense of summer as the ideal season for reading. Although summer no longer means vacation time to me at the beginning of June, I still begin to fantasize I about books. Summer reading has a leisurely reputation way up there with other genteel activities such as croquet and badminton and wildflower gathering. The act of reading has historically been considered a privilege, and summer reading is privilege. Taken to an extreme, just the image of a reader in summer brings to mind something sensual and luxurious. We picture the reader outdoors only arranged in some bucolic setting, forest or beach or yard. One stock image is that of a woman stretched out on a hammock, surrounded by greenery, clutching a worn copy of Middlemarch. No matter how we picture the summer reader, he or she is always reclining. This brings to mind the inevitable comparison of summer reading with bedtime reading throughout the summer. As before bed, it's often difficult to stay fully conscious. The body is in a state of repose, and the reader has to choose between the passive pleasure of sleep or the active pleasure of reading at bedtime. Reading may hold its own for a while, but sleep invariably wins. In the summer, however, it's possible to do little else but read. It's possible to use a beautiful landscape merely as a backdrop. One's body becomes so comfortable that it doesn't need much attention. Responsibilities seem remote, and for once, permission has been given to simply lie there for years. No matter where I spent the summer, I always gave myself this permission. If I went away, I took a suitcase of books with me, or else made sure I had access to someone else's books. One summer I stayed in a rented beach house and spent many weeks reading through the owner's slightly damp collection. Another summer a college friend and I went to Europe, and whichever country we were in, we always tried to dig up English language books. We ferreted around in the backs of general stores in small towns in Italy and Greece, sometimes triumphantly coming up with the most surprising titles. Dorothy Sayers, gaudy Knight excavated from a bin in Corinth, John Cheever's Wap shot Chronicle found at a bottom shelf in Brindisi. We read day and night on trains all over Europe. By the time the summer was over, we had polished off a wide variety of titles. I imagined I could continue at this clip forever, barreling each summer through novels and biographies and essays. It did not occur to me that at some point things might might change. During the summer after college graduation, I was living temporarily in my parents house. As always, I had geared myself up for another summer packed with books. It was all I'd ever known, the only way I'd ever spent a summer. But this summer was already different in that the books themselves had changed the items I now wanted to read, and the ones that had been recommended by friends were richer, longer, harder than ever before. My summer reading list looked like the syllabus of a great books from the beginning of civilization until this very minute course at an experimental college Shakespeare, including the histories and then a smattering of Nietzsche and Melanie Klein, The Confessions of St. Augustine, history by Elsa Moranti, Villette by Charlotte Bronte, and finally Robert Musil's classic the Man Without Qualities, which a friend had thrust into my hands with an urgency that startled me. I determined to plow single mindedly through all of these works. I would steep myself in them and at the end of the summer I would feel the thrill of accomplishment. This was a solitary venture. There was no one around with whom to compare lists or trade volumes on trains. The desire to read had come from elsewhere, from the siren call of summer itself. And summer did call. Each afternoon I went out into the yard and planted myself on a shelter lounge, St. Augustine's confessions open in my lap. This book was a perfect choice. Shining, stirring prose from another time and place. Because summer days are long, I was never quite sure of what time it was. I would look up from St. Augustine completely disoriented, thinking 1:00, 3:00, 5. I felt as though I could read forever and the sun would never set and no authority figure would ever order me to put the book away. And then I started the Man Without Qualities. I began Musil's massive novel in the middle of July and managed to work my way through the first few chapters of dense, difficult prose until finally I could read no farther. I just wasn't up to it. I felt the struggle and the heat. All I wanted was to close my eyes and take a rest. But I kept on trying, transporting the book everywhere, into the yard, back into the house, and even with me to visit friends in New York City, where the book itself had an odd effect on strangers. It attracted them. Oh, said a young man in the summer garden at the Whitney Museum, approaching the table where I sat mopping my forehead, the book lying shut in front of me. You're reading Musil. I wrote my dissertation on him. I nodded and averted my eyes, murmuring something about the greatness of Musil. But I realized then that I had become slack. I was reading merely to get to the other side of the book and of the summer. This was a far cry from the grim determination of my 12 year old self, for whom the desire to read, expand, expanded to fill an entire season. When I got home, I slipped the book back into its place on the shelf, feeling enormously guilty, as though my failure would somehow be reported in a stapled together newsletter at the local library. Nor did I fare so well with most of my other choices. I read in fits and starts, shuffling through the pile of books, feeling overwhelmed and yet unable to stop. I never considered going more slowly, spending extended time on a book, finding an appropriate rhythm. By the last week of the summer I had managed to get through just a few of the items on my list. The rest were left with bookmarks wedged in the middle or else splayed open on the coffee table or beside the bed. Two books were sheepishly returned unread to the library weeks after their due date, and the fines were huge. But it somehow seemed right that I should literally pay for my unwillingness, my inability to read. I paid in other ways as well. The unread books continued to haunt me, hovering nearby like ghosts who felt cheated of equal time. I thought of the man without qualities and how fitting it was that I'd abandoned it, for if we don't read, then certainly we are left without many qualities. Summer remains summer, blank and hot, something to be gotten through instead of transforming into the liveliest season of the year, when, for once, the body lies still but the mind works overtime. Now, when summer approaches, I've got entirely a new game plan. I still think about what I might like to read, but but I no longer take too many recommendations from friends. Instead, I make a solitary journey to the local library to join the browsers who stand with heads cocked, scouting for books beneath a fleet of worrying fans. These days I really do browse first before choosing a book. I stand for a long time and hope that some title or author's name prepared provoke me. If it does, then I pick up the book and look at the opening pages. Perhaps it isn't entirely fair to judge a book this way, but for now it's the best way I know. I stand and read a little way in, trying to imagine myself surrounded by greenery, keeping company with this book for hours at a time. Is this a voice I want to hear murmuring in my ear throughout the longest days of summer? Will it make for good company? And if I suspect it will, then I check the book out. I've been choosing just a few books each summer, a few substantial, appealing books that have tended not to disappoint me. Russian novels, the Victorians, books that speak in Southern accents. Recently, waiting in line to check out my summer choices, I found myself standing behind a group of 12 year olds, all of whom were carrying impressive armloads of books. I peered over their shoulders and read the titles and names of authors I remembered from my own childhood. I did a quick spine count. The boy in front of me was carrying 15 books, and the girl in front of him had 18. The girl had apparently gone beyond her card limit, and I watched as the librarian apologetically made her put a few back. Then I looked down at my own books and felt a momentary wave of mortification. Five books. Not 18, not 15, not even 10. If these 12 year olds looked back at me, they would most likely curl their lips in disdain. Oh, that's what happens, they would think. You stop wanting to read. You become a little dumber, a little slower. For certainly I must have looked that way, full grown and standing with only five books when there were so many more I might have chosen from this huge building that housed nothing but books. At 12, these kids were testing their limits, flexing muscles they didn't know they had. They were moving very, very fast, learning to feel at home among words. Only later in their lives would they start to slow down and understand the importance of pausing over a significant phrase or idea. Only later would they discover that the quality of a summer spent with books depends finally on the particular books one has selected. When it was my turn in the line, the librarian passed my selections under the white light of her photocopying machine and stamped the date, and within seconds I was checked out. She didn't make me put any books back. She didn't smile down at me and say, well, you certainly are an ambitious reader. Instead, checkout was a Dizzyingly quick procedure. Standing with my five meager books, I felt a strong urge to explain to the group of kids that I also used to read 15 books in no time at all. But the 12 year olds were dumping landslides of books into knapsacks and getting ready to leave. And all I could do was follow them out through the turnstiles, armed for another summer.
Rita Wolf
That was my story. The Summer Reading List, performed by Melora Hardin. An interesting characteristic of clubs like my library's Summer Reading Club in that story is that they can be like relationships. They do change, and you can outgrow them. It's always strange to hear one's own work read aloud by someone else. There's a game I once played with writer friends. Someone read a line out loud from one of the other writer's old stories or novels and asked the writer not to look at the page, but to try and finish it as close as possible to the way they had originally written it. What's interesting is that even with the passage of time, a writer turns out to be in many ways the same person he or she once was. There might be more bitterness or a softening, but there's also often a consistency at work. Listening to this story now, I could probably finish some of the lines, more or less the writer herself. She's grown a lot since writing this piece. But if I saw her across the expanse of a public library on a summer afternoon, I would recognize her immediately. When we come back, a club offering immortality. The catch? Getting in is a pain in the neck. I'm Meg Wolitzer. You're listening to Selected Shorts recorded live and performance at Symphony Space in New York City and at other venues nationwide. Welcome back. This is Selected Shorts, where our greatest actors transport us through the magic of fiction, one short story at a time. I'm Meg Wolitzer. As many of you know, Selected Shorts calls Symphony Space in New York City home. We love our home. New York City in March, not so much. So we're taking the show all the way to sunny Los Angeles and we hope you'll join us. We're doing two shows at the Getty center on March 29th with a terrific lineup of actors. We've got Seinfeld's Jason Alexander, Brendan Hunt from Ted Lasso, Michael Urie from Shrinking, Melora Hardin from the Office, and more. For all the details, including how to buy tickets, go to the calendar page at Getty. Edu and look for selected shorts. I'll be your host for both shows. Now, where did I put my sunglasses. The next story we'll hear is by writer Marie Helene Bertino. Her novels include Parakeet, 2am in the Cat's Pajamas and her latest, Beauty Land. She's a deft and funny writer who always upends your expectation of a given subject matter, which is what makes this story about love, immortality and belonging such a treat. But don't take my word for it. The piece was also included in the Best American Short stories collection of 2024 by guest editor Lauren Groff. Performing the story is Rita Wolf, a dedicated theater actor and one of our Selected Shorts regulars. She recently appeared in Carol Churchill's play Escaped Alone at the Yale School of Drama, though film buffs may remember her from early appearances in movies such as My Beautiful Laundrette and now Rita Wolf performs Viola in Midwinter. By Marie Helene Bertino.
Meg Wolitzer
The Margaretville shop N save stays open 24 hours as a service to hunters, hospital employees, sex workers and other creatures who work at night. Viola in pre dawn debates, Poppers and pharaoh snakes in the fireworks aisle at the checkout line. Hunters discuss a bobcat one saw on his drive into town, a mama probably looking for food before the real snow arrives and locks the county in place. Seeing Viola, their talk zips closed. She knows they call her Dark lady, which she sometimes enjoys. The cashier rings her purchases, poppers, a small axe, mint tea for sleep. Still talking to the men collected under the announcement board, though they've gone silent. They watch her pay and leave her puffed black coat trailing like a cold remark. A numbness in her forehead is framed in pain, a cricketing in the temple. She is always on the verge of a headache. The shop N save is always, always open. She is always 49. Outside, pale light crowns the higher mountain peaks, though the parking lot is dark. Other hunters low under a street light. Violet positions her bags in the trunk, overhearing ideas in their mumblings. I was going to. She would, until one of the men, emboldened by her lack of attention climbing, calls out, need help? She keeps her gaze on him and swings the trunk closed. Trying to say hi, he says. Being polite, his friend adds. She pulls a cigarette from a pocket and pauses, as if waiting for a light, an extinct ritual from a former life. The men blink. She finds a lighter in another pocket. The original hunter seems to decide the smoke is meant to anger him and blooms. Where you from? He says. Not here. She exhales smoke toward where they move from foot to foot, like deer that cannot smell the origin of disturbance. The shop nsave doors whistle. A man wearing hospital scrubs emerges, carrying groceries. He walks toward a different part of the lot and then, seeing them change his course for the encounter that had for the men changed from something they understood. Everything okay? The EMT asks, her blank eyes poised. Violet spits loose tobacco onto the ground. He turns to the men. Everything okay? They push one of their own forward, a lantern thrown in front. Just being friendly, he says. Viola uses this interruption as cover to get in and start the car. The men move aside. In the rear view mirror she watches the EMT holding his bags do gooder, maybe. She takes the road that leads into the foothills and parks at the base of the woods she heard the man discussing. Viola follows the tracks down the county road, in and out of the tree line until it jags into an embankment by the creek. Another awareness grows alongside hers as she walks, royal blue and not solitary. The bobcat is pregnant, Violet thinks, watching it move down the frozen stream, slow and exposed. It must be injured, but there is no blood on the trail she follows, avoiding the mud crust whose sound would betray her. The movement of a cat's shoulders, out of sequence with its forward motion, pleases her. The cat slips on its way up the other bank. Her grasp is firm. She pushes a blade into its neck. A pink dawn flurries beginning, the animal draped like a bride over her legs. Viola sits in the snow and drinks. Viola was 49 in 1917 when she met the woman who would immortalize her. Viola's husband, a temperless Swede, was fighting in France. Their seven year old daughter, Bea, had been good natured before her father left, but now it was like living with a gathering storm. Always some petulant bruising remark, a brush hurtling through air. Every morning Viola left for the factory, buoyant with relief. She loved the factory women who under the wasting lights discussed how they missed their husbands rarely, if at all. She didn't know women could speak so candidly, but she'd never been among so many protected by war's isolation. Samara was the pinnacle of that candor. Her administrative role at the factory allowed her to walk the line and chat. Her wide, expressive mouth made everything she said sound scandalous. Even when she let the younger girls go to catch some school, she befriended Violet and Bea, bringing them food they could never afford during the summer of 1917. They drink Samara's whiskey in Viola's cold water, walk up, the smell of the fish shops souring through the windows, fanning themselves deepened the stink, but it made them laugh. Their friendship loosened whatever fist always seemed to grip Viola's breastplate. She confessed to Samara that a longing rose inside her whenever she walked a street with a view of the river. Sometimes she feared it would split her in two. Samara knew a way to lessen that woe. She called it the occupation. Typically the conversion procedure was harder for women. The men could bite each other on the neck, but women had to receive permission. The subject had to be certain. A week after the hunters, the EMT approaches Vala in the shop and says, I'd love to know your name. He says, so the next time those guys bother you, I can at least say, hey, don't bother. In the moment that passes, his smile reconsiders, then strengthens. This is where you say your name, he says. She says, viola. He retreats a few glancing steps, pretending to be moved by beauty. Outside they load her car. How many fireworks does a woman need? He says, you never know when I'll need to shove one up a hunter's ass. He laughs, apologizes for the hunters as if he is their mare. She says, I've been through it before. 10 times today. I bet a hundred. She likes that. He laughs when she curses. His hands look strong and soft and while he speaks, one rests on his lower stomach. She knows it is where he wants to touch her. The EMT is not a stand up straight man but hovers lower in his body. He's young, relatively speaking, but like many white men in middle age he looks flowered older. Violet asks what he thinks of her house. The yellow and white reminds me of my grandparents cottage, he says. We spent summers swimming in a stream like yours. You see the stream? She is pleased. I didn't know it came out this far and so loud. You hear it too. Noting his confused look, she explains, sometimes I think only I can see how pretty it is here. How long have you lived up here? Forever. They sit on the couch with tumblers of whiskey. She asks what it's like to be an EMT and he says it's a lot of waiting until it's not. He says he has healer hands and asks to touch her. She places the glass on the table, removes her sweater and lies on the carpet. The EMT drains his drink and places his palms against her back. When was the last time anyone touched her? He digs in with his fingertips. She has what he calls an ancient coil in her lower right back where she keeps people she loves. She dislikes so called healers, but dislikes more that he is right. I'll make you a stake for your trouble, she tells him. After you cook. He gestures to her kitchen, the sink and counters covered in plants. Viola sets one place at her table and prepares the meat on an outside pit. She serves him the steak, pours herself more whiskey, and sits across from him. You're not gonna eat? Not hungry, she says. He cuts a forkful and swears that the area's hunting helps its animals. A progressive and a hunter, she says, though there's no way around the body craving meat. The animal prefers to live. I'm too old to pretend. Yeah, you're so old. He grins. Middle aged. I'm middle aged too. He seems happy to share this. You're not against hunting, are you? She says. I'm a hunter too. He removes his shirt and jeans. She sits astride him on the couch. He whispers that he wants to build her a house. She doesn't mind the sentiment. It's been decades since someone pressed their cheek against her heart and shuddered against her. On the night Viola ceased to age, she'd received a letter from her husband in France outlining his return. They'd move in with his family after she quit the factory. The war was ending. Survivors were coming home. Viola and Samara shared a bottle of rye on her fire escape. Viola was grateful for Samara's company. She'd never seen a woman move through a room like a cleaver. The rye worked her mood loose, and she asked about the occupation. Samara said that inability to handle sunlight was a myth. It was more of a strong aversion that had been exaggerated by men who couldn't handle it. Like most things, the truth has contradictions that don't fit neat theories. She said. We don't turn to ash. We just usually had long nights and are nursing plasma hangovers. Human blood was not the only way to receive sustenance. They could hunt animals, though. Samara considered this beneath her. She made deals with meat factory bosses and had first pick after the slaughter. You'd be surprised how easy it is for an older woman to go unnoticed. When her husband returned, Viola would have to mend darn, keep polite. Samara reached over and untied the top of Viola's dress. Viola felt the chill of her skin meeting air. Samara pressed her lips against Viola's. The feeling made Viola want to choose something for the rest of her life. Are you sure? Samara said, and Viola said, please, yes. In the morning, the EMT does not leave but chooses a contemporary short story collection from her library, two RIs to her. The next day he works his hospital shift and returns with a bag of groceries, flowers, mint salt. He works another night shift. She goes with him. New love makes joining someone at work seem fun. He opens a wall sized cabinet revealing racks of blood shining in bags. A powerful pulsing overwhelms her. He pulls a hammock from the attic, hangs it outside. She watches from the shadows on the porch. He leans against a pine, pulls his arms overhead to stretch. The crescent of pellucid skin above his belt adds itself to the work, shifts and blurs time. She doesn't know how many nights have passed. She likes rubbing moisturizer she doesn't need into her cheeks or while he reads in the other room. Samara would call this love jail, Violet thinks. She knows how it feels to wear nothing and lie beneath the sun. In the waning days of war, Viola's new appetite became a second body. She could watch it as if she were a bystander. She engaged in nocturnal benders that ended at Samara's apartment, where she stopped herself in ice baths. Plague shuttered the city. A telegram from France arrived. Her husband was missing. Bea retreated into the room of herself, where Viola became a foe. Viola was the oldest she'd ever be and no longer needed food. She was a novice, immortal, and though Samara was a veteran, she was unwilling to teach. She didn't want to explain, for example, why her longing to leave had not lessened but calcified occupation plus Violet's age had combined to quadruple desire. Samara was in her 60s, safely beyond middle age. When Viola and the EMT hunt. His gear and blinds amuse her. He lines up a shot to find she's been streaming in from another direction. Both methods prove effective. Bodies pile up. Their love is bad for the animals. Showing off is new to her, as is someone anticipating her tricks. Even in deepest cover, he finds her. If you think you're being watched, he says, you are. One night a whiff of impermanence makes her crave concrete answers. Does he want to stay with her? No town, no job, just his body and hers. There is a way, but he must be certain. The future tense makes him grow still. He makes an excuse and leaves. Though Viola's aging halted, her hair and nails grew so fast she could shave her head and have floor length hair within weeks. Menstrual blood disappeared for months, then returned with painful hemorrhaging. No longer able to take care for Bee, Viola took her to live with her Swedish relatives. One evening in the middle of the century, mother and daughter passed each other on the Street. It took Viola a moment to understand that this hard woman was her daughter. Bea had exceeded her in age and looked to be in failing health. Violet realized that the girl with her was Bea's daughter, who'd inherited her grandmother's lavender eyes. Bea belonged to another time that moved like a barge away from where Violet was pinned to the dock. She'd already forgotten Bea's birthday and her own split with regret. She left the city in the 1960s. Viola worked as a flight attendant. She hunted in the Scottish Highlands, prowled bars in Golden Guy for a while. Travel allayed her restlessness. Samara was right. It was easy for a middle aged woman to go unnoticed. The other flight attendants were on their own thresholds. After college, before marriage, before babies, after changing careers. But Viola worried that instead of being freed, she'd been forgotten. She longed for her chin to sag. Any indication that she was still alive. Perhaps this was why people invested in religion or children or causes to pass time pleasantly while watching something grow. Human tendencies genuflected through time. Hemlines and mothering trends advanced and and receded. The child became the nucleus of the house. They even had their own room for toys. It sickened Violet to watch mothers be controlled by their toddlers. At the turn of the century, the idea of youth reached the age of 40. Violet's body seemed newly valued. Men's gazes, once trained solely on college aged asses, lingered on hers. Factories, planes, space travel, the Internet. Though the structures varied, they were built from hubris, stitched with greed. New mandates after 911 required flight attendants to submit to regular reviews and Violet could no longer fly with anonymity. She moved to the western Catskills, where she spent years in and out of hot flashes chased by an unleavened smell. Fertile and not fertile. Then not joints swelling, trapped in a developmental doorway. She kept routines she did not need, like market shopping, to tend the last ember of being human and lived timelessly in the woods that were silenced by by snow for half of every year. She'd been middle aged for a century. Intuitions deepening, minor and major knives growing along the walls of her understanding. She was a cave, purpled with stalactites. She could smell feelings in a room. The EMT shows up after weeks carrying chanterelles. He's foraged. Viola participates with a few bites. Worm thick, spiced by earth since it serves no purpose. Food is something she understands but doesn't enjoy, like perfume and holidays. What do you do for fun? He seems distracted. The question belongs to an earlier stage of courtship, like he is returning to an improperly filled out form to correct mistakes. She shows him her arsenal of fireworks and he lines up an impressive display. Colorful sparks soar above the woods. I'm surprised you don't get noise complaints, he says. She notices a stab of effort in his voice, as if trying to recall what brought him here. No one would come all the way out. She's been with local men before, though none from his generation. A dirt farmer with soft hands, his wife, two brother lawyers, their wives. Her favorite was a married salesman who she saw for a year before his shame grew too large. Occasionally he slows on her road, elderly but still possessing the same dazed, blinking calm, trying to determine her house amid whatever appears. But she never loved him, or the others, or even Samara. She never lost breath when leaving them, or when they stayed away too long. In the 1960s, Viola was traveling through the Midi Pyrenees when she met a cunning woman who taught her how to glamour homes. If what appeared to the visitor was a pleasant memory, they'd get along. If it was troubling, their connection wouldn't last. One lawyer she'd been excited about was startled back into his car by whatever he saw. She never had a chance to ask. His bumper took a chunk out of her hedgerow when he roared away. Most guests couldn't see the stream, the feature that was dearest to her, powered by some relentless turbine. Every so often it would produce a cherubic beaver, moving its weight front to back over a lichen thick rock. Before she met the emt, these rare sightings had been the highest delight of her endless life. Viola finds him in the home of a local bartender. Their bodies are paralyzed in television light. Maybe this is the woman who wants him to build her a house, Viola thinks, hovering outside the window. Heartbreak slows the hours as months creak by. Viola's hair grows past the floor. She dyes it, lights out black from a shop N save kit. The memory of her birthday returns. She spends November 15th shivering in a scalding bath. She cloaks her house so he'll find only ankle breaking rats if he tries to visit, adds a few cats to her home, and a tall dog named Oberon who stands like a masthead in the yard every so often conjuring a single day splitting bark. One day, still new to the mountains, Viola came across Death on a train platform in Arkville. Death wore an impeccable hoodie under an acid wash blazer and stood beside an elegant suitcase checking a timepiece. She sensed Viola's stare and looked over her gaze, a climate. She raised a delicate hand and saluted. Viola returned the gesture. They were workers who shared a commute. She wondered if they could be friends, since neither needed anything from the other. It must get lonely being that essential. Viola thought she knew how that felt. The train arrived. Death moved through the car of sleeping travelers, selected a window seat, removed her watch and laid it on the tray table in front of her. No passenger stirred. No one notices. Remarkable women. A little boy gapes in Shop N Save's firearms aisle, where Viola wears remnants from her past lives. A corset under a one shoulder dress from the 80s, belted in the style of the 90s, boots from her first life's job. She misses the factory. Women who snuck flasks, spit seeds, bit. She hadn't known there were women like that, but since then she has been them all. The little boy's mother snatches him away, but he wants to keep looking at the dark lady. Viola points one glowing shoulder at him, shows her teeth, and then zips it, all her mirth and misery, under the purple coat, and leaves through the whistling doors. That evening Viola wakes, she soaked in sweat. The wind swirling in the hollow sounds like a passing big rig. No one is in the meadow blanketed with snow or on the hill milked in the waxing wolf mo. But Viola repots plants in the kitchen, uneasiness growing. Finally she feels a presence behind her. Devour me, it says. Samara stands in the center of the room, arms raised for a hug. She is in town to check out the whole upstate thing. Girl, she says, you look rough. I could use a party, violet admits, you could use a haircut. No matter. Party's here, babe. They are naked for days. They throw a log into the fire. They finish the whiskey. Samara tells her that the word for the EMT is narcissistic. My seventh, no, eighth husband was one. Diminishing returns. They leave you starving. She laughs, which is the worst thing you and I can be. What did you do to him? Viola says. Poor man, he did not go easy. Samara suggests they kill the EMT too, but Viola refuses. Killing him would bring no relief. Well, I'm going to have to eat something, samara says. I'm not here to ski. I know a place, viola says. They drive to the shop and Save and chuck tote bags and firewood into a jangling cart. Samara humps the bear statue and tries on fluorescent hunting gear. It is good to be with this unruly woman in a cheap grocery store at night. Night they've been friends for a hundred years. When they'd arrived, the parking lot was empty, but when they load their bags into the car, hunters watch from under every street lamp. Hello, boys, samara calls, driving away. Viola directs her to the unmarked door at the back of the hospital. She leads them through a series of hallways until they reach the cabinet of blood. Samara leans on the counter for support. Why do I have the urge to bless myself? They fill the tote bags, retreat through the hallways, and load the car. Hurry, viola says when she hears someone behind them. Samara climbs into the car. Wait. The EMT's face is mapped with pain. Talk to me, Viola. Why have you disappeared? Samara lowers the window and observes him with flat gray eyes. Her pallor has been flawless for centuries. Who's that? He says. Who is that? That's the guy, samara says when they drive away. You need to leave the woods more. The EMT takes up with another local girl, homely, with pretty eyes. They have two boys, indistinguishable from the other county kids. One moves to Canada. The other marries a local girl like his mother. One night toward the middle of the century, the EMT administers to a pile of steaming meat in his backyard. He is in his 70s, lymph nodes stuffed with cancer. She smells it coursing above the meat. Stink, metallic, salted. It seems unfair that he gets to die. A windless rustle, a certain unsound. He doesn't have to see her standing inside the tree line, owl quiet, to know she meets him again in this town or that a man or not, sick or well, a doctor, a stoneworker, and he runs his systems on her. Sometimes she doesn't have the energy. She tells him she's been through it before. Sometimes she accepts his dances, his tongue, attempts to summon love's old frictions until inevitably the drumming subsides. A girl on the verge of adulthood arrives in November when, when the forest's reddish growth makes the mountains appear rusted. She has compiled a map from four semi accurate ones procured in visits to Town Hall. She has sweet talked a hunter who liked her lavender eyes. This determination, paired with a hard countenance, has separated her from everyone she's ever known. The girl walks onto the empty meadow and the word ancestor occurs to her as if from clear air. Each step presses it into the moss. Ancestor. She feels the Devonian gaze of hemlock's ancestor, the rocks that pinned the stream. She scolds her hammering heart. The house will arrive or it won't, and if it doesn't. She'll just go home. Nothing in her life has prompted such breathlessness. Something in the meadow seems to unlock and turn toward her. The stream begins a louder chatter. It sounds like it's saying, hello. I won't leave. I'll wait forever.
Rita Wolf
That was Rita Wolf reading Viola in Midwinter by Marie Helene Bertino. Yes, yes, vampirism is a very exclusive and particular kind of club. But vampires were once human, so their social order does have parallel rules and regulations. This story swept me up not only for its menacing atmosphere and next level writing, but also for its focus on the theme of supposed female invisibility in midlife, which I have never heard rendered this way. Not even close. Also, as the host of Selected Shorts, how could I not love a story in which the love interest takes a book of short stories off the shelf and reads aloud to the protagonist? And that's our show. Two very different stories. Two very different societies. The one element seems to underlie both love. In these pieces, love might be a lure capable of drawing us into or carrying us away from a group of people. While I can't speak for vampires and their covens, I can say something about my book club. I outgrew it. Yes, but the love that brought me to that like minded clique of eager readers is one that sustains me today, whether or not I ever finish. A Man Without Qualities. I'm Meg Wolitzer. Thanks for joining me for Selected Shorts. Selected Shorts is produced by Jennifer Brennan and Sarah Montague. Our team includes Matthew Love, Drew Richardson, Mary Shimkin, Vivienne Woodward and Magdalene Rplesky. The readings are recorded by Myles B. Smith. Our programs, presented at the Getty center in Los Angeles, are recorded by Phil Richards. Our mix engineer for this episode was Joe Plourd. Our theme music is David Peterson's that's the Deal, performed by the Deardorf Petersen Group. Selected Shorts is supported by the Dungannon Foundation. This program is also made possible with public funds from the New York State Council on the Arts, with the support of Governor Kathy Hochul and the New York State Legislature. Selected Shorts is produced and distributed by Symphony Space.
Selected Shorts Episode Summary: "The Price of Admission"
Release Date: March 27, 2025
Host: Meg Wolitzer
Performed by: Melora Hardin and Rita Wolf
Production: Symphony Space
In the episode titled "The Price of Admission," host Meg Wolitzer delves into the intricate dynamics of club membership, exploring themes of belonging, initiation, responsibility, and the sacrifices made to remain part of a collective. Wolitzer sets the stage by comparing various types of social groups—ranging from book clubs and vampire covens to casual coffee cliques and fantasy football leagues—to the innate human instinct to form connections and communities.
Meg Wolitzer [00:34]: "Most of us belong to some kind of collective... Who knows? We may not need to hunt in a pack or huddle together for warmth. But this urge to form cliques is an instinct we share with a lot of other animals."
Wolitzer outlines the common elements of social pods: initiation periods, responsibilities or dues (even if trivial), and established rules—both spoken and unspoken—that govern membership.
Performer: Melora Hardin
Timestamp: [00:34 – 22:13]
Melora Hardin brings to life Wolitzer's own short story, "Summer Reading List," which paints a nostalgic and introspective look at childhood summer reading clubs. The narrative centers around a group of 12-year-olds committed to a library's Summer Reading Club, where their primary goal is to read at least ten books over the summer. The story reflects on the transformative power of summer and reading, highlighting both the camaraderie and the pressures within the club.
Initiation and Achievement: The story emphasizes the challenge of meeting the club's reading quota, portraying it as a measure of worth within the group.
Melora Hardin [04:26]: "We say the number with true disdain. 10 is nothing. 10 is what we will have ripped through before the first week in July."
Nostalgia and Growth: The protagonist reminisces about past summers, illustrating how time and maturity change one's relationship with such groups.
Melora Hardin [07:15]: "Summer reading has a leisurely reputation... The act of reading has historically been considered a privilege."
Isolation and Comparison: As adults, the narrator reflects on her diminished enthusiasm for reading compared to her younger self, leading to feelings of inadequacy.
Melora Hardin [21:30]: "Five books. Not 18, not 15, not even 10. If these 12 year olds looked back at me, they would most likely curl their lips in disdain."
On the Magical Nature of Reading:
Melora Hardin [05:00]: "There is something magical about the amount of books we've read, something nearly miraculous about the sudden veracity that's been implanted in each of us."
On Changing Perspectives:
Melora Hardin [19:45]: "Only later would they discover that the quality of a summer spent with books depends finally on the particular books one has selected."
Meg Wolitzer [22:13]: "Listening to this story now, I could probably finish some of the lines, more or less the writer herself... If I saw her across the expanse of a public library on a summer afternoon, I would recognize her immediately."
Wolitzer draws parallels between the fictional summer reading club and real-life relationships, suggesting that both evolve over time and can be outgrown as individuals change. She humorously touches on the constancy of personal growth despite changing social affiliations.
Performer: Rita Wolf
Timestamp: [25:43 – 56:25]
Rita Wolf presents "Viola in Midwinter," a haunting tale of immortality and the complexities of eternal belonging. Set in the perpetual cycles of day and night, the story follows Viola, a 49-year-old woman who remains ageless, navigating relationships and the supernatural demands of her existence. The narrative intertwines themes of love, isolation, and the burdens of immortality within a vampiric framework, portraying Viola's struggle to maintain her humanity while being bound to eternal routines and social obligations.
Immortality and Isolation: Viola's eternal life isolates her from the natural progression of human relationships and time, fostering a sense of detachment and longing.
Rita Wolf [30:50]: "If we don't read, then certainly we are left without many qualities. Summer remains summer, blank and hot..."
Belonging and Sacrifice: The vampiric coven operates with strict rules and expectations, mirroring the initiation and dues of earthly clubs but with darker consequences.
Rita Wolf [45:10]: "Violet's body seemed newly valued. Men's gazes... lingered on hers."
Transformation and Identity: Viola's interactions over the years illustrate her evolving identity as she grapples with her perpetual existence and the relationships that come and go.
Rita Wolf [52:30]: "She longed for her chin to sag. Any indication that she was still alive."
On the Nature of Summer Reading as Privilege:
Melora Hardin [07:15]: "The act of reading has historically been considered a privilege, and summer reading is privilege."
On Feeling Forgotten:
Rita Wolf [48:00]: "But she worried that instead of being freed, she'd been forgotten."
On Love and Longevity:
Rita Wolf [50:25]: "New love makes joining someone at work seem fun."
Rita Wolf [56:25]: "Vampirism is a very exclusive and particular kind of club... This story swept me up not only for its menacing atmosphere and next level writing, but also for its focus on the theme of supposed female invisibility in midlife, which I have never heard rendered this way."
Wolf connects the vampiric elements of "Viola in Midwinter" to the overarching theme of exclusive clubs, emphasizing the parallel between supernatural societies and human social groups. She highlights the exploration of female invisibility and the unique portrayal of midlife struggles within the narrative.
Meg Wolitzer wraps up the episode by reflecting on the duality of the stories presented, noting that while one delves into the nostalgic confines of a summer reading club, the other explores the eternal bindings of a vampiric coven. Both narratives underscore the themes of love, belonging, and the personal costs associated with maintaining one's place within a group.
Meg Wolitzer [56:25]: "The love that brought me to that like-minded clique of eager readers is one that sustains me today, whether or not I ever finish."
Wolitzer expresses a personal connection to the stories, drawing parallels between fictional clubs and real-life relationships, ultimately conveying that while the structures may change, the underlying human emotions and needs remain constant.
Note: This summary encapsulates the essence of the "The Price of Admission" episode, providing insights into the stories and thematic discussions without delving into promotional content or non-essential segments.