BONUS | What We're Still Asking: Zebb Quinn & Mitrice Richardson

Summary

---

SEQUESTERED Podcast

BONUS | What We’re Still Asking: Zebb Quinn & Mitrice Richardson

Release Date: September 15, 2025
Hosts: Andrea (A), Sarah (C)

Episode Overview

In this special bonus episode, hosts Andrea and Sarah revisit two haunting cold cases previously covered on SEQUESTERED: the mysterious 2000 disappearance of Zebb Quinn in Asheville, North Carolina, and the tragic 2009 death of Mitrice Richardson in Malibu, California. The episode's purpose is to circle back on lingering questions, highlight investigative gaps, and honor the advocacy efforts that continue to keep these stories alive.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Revisiting the Zeb Quinn Case (00:58 - 03:00)

• The Page That Sparked It All

  • Zebb receives a page after work, traced to his aunt's house.
    • Key Question: Who actually sent the page? His aunt was with Misty Taylor and her mom at the time.
    • Andrea: “So was the page a coincidence, a setup, or the trap that started everything?” (00:58)
    • Sarah: “That one little page is like a spark that lit the whole fuse.” (01:46)
  • The connection between Zebb’s aunt and Misty’s mom—“They were friends. This wasn’t just some random overlap.” (Andrea, 02:06)

• The Staged Vehicle and Suspicions

  • The discovered car had lipstick marks on the window, a puppy left inside, and a hotel key card—details described as staged.
    • Sarah: “Once I really got into this case, I sort of felt like it was a way to throw off the investigators.” (02:28)
    • Andrea: “Whoever left the car wanted to create a story around it, but the real truth about what happened to Zeb is still missing.” (03:00)

---

The Mitrice Richardson Case (03:00 - 07:37)

• Release from Malibu Lost Hills Station

  • Mitrice is arrested for not paying her restaurant bill; her belongings impounded. She is released after midnight without her phone or wallet into an unlit canyon area.
    • Andrea: “She was released on foot into, basically, a canyon. Right.” (03:00)
    • Sarah: “A dark canyon.” (03:28)

• Family Concerns and Missed Warnings

  • Mitrice’s mother, Latice, calls the station to ask they keep her daughter safe, expressing deep fear for her release.
    • Sarah: “Latice sounds almost like prophetic, like she knows something is going to happen. She’s begging them not to release her daughter.” (04:02)
    • Sarah (on listening now): “…knowing what came next, it’s like her worst fears were realized and the system was warned and it didn’t matter.” (04:24)

• Missing Phone Records and Final Moments

  • The phone call log Mitrice attempted to use before leaving is incomplete or inaccessible.
    • Andrea: “Imagine how different things would feel if we had a name or a timestamp or even just a statement like, yes, Mitrice called me. … But that record is either incomplete or unavailable. And the silence just leaves a huge gap.” (04:35)
  • Questions linger about who, if anyone, she spoke to before vanishing.

• Role of Mitrice’s Girlfriend

  • The hosts discuss Mitrice’s girlfriend, Tessa, her role in the immediate aftermath, and the pain of not knowing details or finding closure.
    • “My heart is connected to her and I just hope that she is doing okay in the years after all of this, because I can’t even imagine ... just losing your person suddenly has gotta be so shocking.” (Andrea, 05:27)

• Why Joffrey’s?

  • Puzzlement remains about why Mitrice drove to Joffrey’s in Malibu—an area unfamiliar to her. The hosts mention their own visit to the location to better understand the context. (06:19)

• Discovery of Remains and Unanswered Questions

  • Mitrice’s remains are found in an inaccessible, remote canyon.
    • Sarah: “Could she have really walked there alone in the dark or did she catch a ride?” (07:04)
    • Uncertainty whether she was alone, or perhaps helped or harmed by someone.

---

Advocacy and Ongoing Efforts (07:37 - 08:46)

• Champions for Justice
  • Mitrice’s mother, Latice Sutton, and Dr. Rhonda Hampton (her mentor) highlighted as relentless advocates (“Writing, documenting and demanding action on their behalf.” Sarah, 08:03).
  • Cece Woods, independent Malibu journalist, commended for public persistence and pressure on local authorities.
    • Sarah: “She kept digging when others moved on and asked questions to the sheriff’s department that they didn’t want to answer.” (08:10)
    • “It just reminds me the power of strong women who won’t give up the fight.” (Sarah, 08:33)

---

Parallels Between the Cases (08:47 - 09:22)

• Both leave families with unanswered questions:
  • “They share the same haunting gaps. The missing body, the staged car, the untraceable page, the mother’s warning, the missed call log, the canyon where her remains were found. Both families were left with more questions than answers.” (Andrea, 08:47)
  • “Both families had to become investigators and advocates and storytellers.” (Sarah, 09:06)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the Importance of Advocacy:
  “We all need people like them in our corner.” — Sarah (09:19)
• On Unanswered Questions:
  “Because like Sarah said, there are reports that she made phone calls? Did she call someone to come pick her up? Did she call her girlfriend? Did she call her aunt? Those are the questions that we have.” — Andrea (05:14)
• On False Leads in the Quinn Case:
  “To me, it felt staged.” — Sarah (02:55)
• On Maternal Intuition:
  “Latice sounds almost like prophetic, like she knows something is going to happen.” — Sarah (04:02)

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:58 — Introduction to Zeb Quinn’s case and discussion of the suspicious page.
• 02:06 — Analysis of familial and social connections linked to Zeb’s disappearance.
• 02:28 — Debating whether evidence around Zeb’s car was staged.
• 03:00 — Transition to Mitrice Richardson; circumstances leading to her release.
• 04:02 — Emotional impact of Mitrice’s mother’s warning call to police.
• 04:35 — Discussion of missing phone records made from the station.
• 05:27 — Reflection on the impact on Mitrice’s girlfriend, Tessa.
• 06:19 — Host’s personal visit to Joffrey’s restaurant; unanswered motives.
• 07:04 — Questions about the plausibility of Mitrice reaching Dark Canyon alone.
• 08:03 — Shout-out to advocates Dr. Rhonda Hampton and Cece Woods.
• 08:47 — Parallels between both cases' unresolved gaps.
• 09:06 — The families’ transition into advocative roles and the value of community support.

---

Conclusion

The episode circles back on the Zeb Quinn and Mitrice Richardson cases, highlighting the enduring uncertainties and the critical role of relentless advocacy. Andrea and Sarah underscore the haunting gaps in both stories—staged evidence, missing links, and institutional failures—while honoring those who continue to push for answers, refusing to let their loved ones fade into obscurity. The hosts urge listeners to keep these cases alive, contribute any information they may have, and remain vigilant in the pursuit of justice.

---

Transcript

[A]

Sequestered is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Fiscally responsible financial geniuses, monetary magicians. These are the things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Visit progressive.com to see if you can save Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.

[B]

I'm no tech genius, but I knew if I wanted my business to crush it, I needed a website. Now, thankfully, bluehost made it easy. I customized, optimized, and monetized everything exactly how I wanted with AI. In minutes, my site was up. I couldn't believe it. The search engine tools even helped me get more site visitors. Whatever your passion project is, you can set it up with Bluehost with their 30 day money back guarantee. What do you got to lose? Head to bluehost.com. that's B L U-E-H-O-S-T.com to start now.

[A]

Welcome to this bonus episode of Sequestered. Andrea and I wanted to circle back on two cases we've already covered. Cases that left us with more questions than answers. We'll revisit the disappearance of Zeb Quinn in Asheville, North Carolina, and the death of Mitrice Richardson in Malibu, California. So let's jump right in. One of the strangest details in Zeb's story is the page he received right after leaving work. That page led him to a payphone, and it was traced back to his aunt's house. Right, but here's the problem. His aunt wasn't actually at home when the page was sent. She was with Misty Taylor and Misty's mom. So was the page a coincidence, a setup, or the trap that started everything?

[C]

And if it wasn't his aunt, who else had access to page him? Was it Misty, Wesley, even Misty's mom? And the bigger question was, did they lure him there? Like, was it meant to get Zeb alone and vulnerable and change the course of his night? That one little page is like a spark that lit the whole fuse.

[A]

Right, and that's what makes the connection between Zeb's aunt and Misty's mom so fascinating. They were friends. This wasn't just some random overlap. It was a real relationship. So now you've got Zeb's family and Misty's family, LinkedIn and Jason Owens in the mix. And Wesley Smith, who was known to be jealous and possessive.

[C]

Yeah, and then there's the car, the lipstick on the window. Like, to me, all of that. Once I really got into this case, I sort of felt like it was a Way to throw off the investigators.

[A]

Right, Like a ruse.

[C]

Yeah, like the puppy left inside. Like, first of all, who does that? Thank goodness it was in the winter.

[A]

Right.

[C]

And then the hotel key card. Like, I just. It felt like they were trying to throw somebody off.

[A]

Absolutely.

[C]

To me, it felt staged.

[A]

Right. When you step back, it feels deliberate.

[C]

Yeah.

[A]

Whoever left the car wanted to create a story around it, but the real story, like, the real truth about what happened to Zeb is still missing. Okay, now turning to California. Mitrice Richardson's case begins with her release from the Malibu Lost hills station. In 2009. She was arrested for not paying a restaurant bill. Her car was impounded with her phone and wallet inside. And just after midnight, she was released on foot into, basically, a canyon. Right.

[C]

A dark canyon.

[A]

Right. An independent review later said deputies, quote, acted properly, that Mitrice had an option to wait until daylight. But her family never believed that was acceptable.

[C]

Right.

[A]

This is the thing that gets me. It's like, okay, I do understand. She was an adult. She can do whatever she wants. She doesn't have to call her mom before she leaves. Right. But I'm so curious what calls were made in that police station.

[C]

I know. We're gonna get to that, though.

[A]

Okay. Okay. Okay.

[C]

And if you listen to her mother's first call to the station, that, to me, was devastating. When we ran across that. I mean, latice sounds almost like prophetic, like she knows something is going to happen. She's begging them not to release her daughter. And she even said at one point, you know, I'm not worried about her staying there. I'm worried about you guys letting her out.

[A]

Right.

[C]

And so hearing that call now, knowing what came next, it's like her worst fears were realized and the system was warned and it didn't matter.

[A]

Right. It's like she knew it was coming.

[C]

Right.

[A]

Okay. One piece that could answer so many questions is the call log from inside the station. So, like, Mitrice asked to make calls before she left, but to this day, we don't have a full, verified record of who she called or what was said. Imagine how different things would feel if we had a name or a timestamp or even just a statement like, yes, Mitrice called me. Here's what she said. But that record is either incomplete or unavailable. And the silence just leaves a huge gap.

[C]

Yeah. We looked everywhere to try and find that. So if anyone's listening and they're like, oh, I actually know that information, we'd love to hear it.

[A]

Absolutely.

[C]

Because like Sarah said, there are reports that she made phone calls? Did she call someone to come pick her up? Did she call her girlfriend? Did she call her aunt? Those are the questions that we have.

[A]

Right? And speaking of her girlfriend, we. We spent a good chunk of one of the episodes talking about her and their love and their partnership and how much Tessa, like, was such an advocate in that initial period following her disappearance. And I again, we researched and tried to find, just follow ups on did she show up when her body was found and all of this stuff. And I just, I don't really know. There's no, there's no reports of that. And so there's just something in me that really wanted to wrap that around in the writing process of those episodes. And so, so I just, I don't know. My heart is connected to her and I just hope that she is doing okay in the years after all of this, because I can't even imagine, like, where are they supposed to meet that night? Like, just losing your person suddenly just gotta be so shocking.

[C]

Yeah, I remember you asking that. When we were looking through this case, we were looking at the Joffrey's restaurant, which, by the way, we actually drove past recently in Malibu when we were in California. We were like, let's go see it. And it is a beautiful place. But we can't figure out why Mitrice was going to Joffrey's that night in Malibu when she wasn't from that area.

[A]

Right.

[C]

And then of course, the park rangers found Mitrice's remains in Dark Canyon near Montenido. And if you've ever seen that area, you know how remote it is, the steep ravines and there's like brush everywhere and it is pitch black once the sun goes down.

[A]

Right.

[C]

And that makes me wonder, could she have really walked there alone in the dark or did she catch a ride? We talked about this a little bit in the episode and that canyon and the isolation at night, I mean, I'm already scared of the dark. Like, I can't even imagine, you know, what was going on with her. We know that she fell asleep on someone's porch or at least was resting. And that was near where she was found.

[A]

But.

[C]

But she was left vulnerable to who knows what.

[A]

Absolutely unimaginable. So I kind of want to bring it around to just the advocates that have continued their support nonstop for Mitrice, this case and just everything. Obviously her mother, Latice, and then of course, Dr. Rhonda Hampton, who we know is Mitrice's mentor and just turned herself into a relentless advocate. Writing, documenting and demanding action on their behalf.

[C]

Yeah. And, you know, I have to give props to cece woods, who is an independent journalist in Malibu.

[A]

Yes.

[C]

We. We talked about her a lot and shared her interviews. She kept digging when others moved on and asked questions to the sheriff's department that they didn't want to answer. And I. I think she was a huge catalyst as well to keeping Mitrice's story in the news in that area.

[A]

Yeah, absolutely.

[C]

It just reminds me the power of strong women who won't give up the fight. And we've talked about that over every case that we've covered this season.

[A]

Yes. Yeah. Just women who refuse to let injustice stand.

[C]

Yeah.

[A]

Zeb's case and Mitrice's case are obviously very different, but they share the same haunting gaps. The missing body, the staged car, the untraceable page, the mother's warning, the missed call log, the canyon where her remains were found. Both families were left with more questions than answers.

[C]

And both families had to become investigators and advocates and storytellers. Zeb's community kept pushing in Asheville, and Mitrice's mother and Dr. Hampton, Cece woods, kept her name alive in California. We all need people like them in our corner.

[A]

Yeah, absolutely. The world would look so much different. Yeah. All right, guys, well, that's it for this bonus episode of Sequestered. Thank you for joining us as we revisit these cases.

[C]

Don't forget, you can shoot us an email if you have any [e-mail] Our goal is always to honor the lives at the center of these cases and to keep asking the questions that still need answers.

[A]

Yeah. And if you've been moved by what you've heard, please take a moment to like and review Sequestered on Apple podcasts and Spotify. It helps more people find these stories and keeps the conversation alive.

[C]

We're so grateful that you're listening. These cases mean the world to us, and we want to tell their stories.

[A]

Until next time, thank you for being a part of this community.

[C]

We'll see you guys soon.

[D]

Hi, I'm Chris Gethard, and I'm very excited to tell you about Beautiful Anonymous, a podcast where I talk to random people on the phone. I tweet out a phone number. Thousands of people try to call. You talk to one of them. They stay anonymous. I can't hang up. That's all the rules. I never know what's going to happen. We get serious ones. I've talked with meth dealers on their way to prison. I've talked to people who survived mass shootings. Crazy funny ones. I talked to a guy with a goose laugh. Somebody who dresses up as a pirate on the weekends. I never know what's going to happen. It's a great show. Subscribe today. Beautiful. Anonymous.