411: Part 2: We Have the Footage & Interrogation Netflix Couldn’t Get | Netflix's "Maternal Instinct": Reagan Hancock & Taylor Parker

Summary

Serialously with Annie Elise – Episode 411: Part 2

“We Have the Footage & Interrogation Netflix Couldn’t Get”

Podcast Host: Annie Elise
Date: June 15, 2026
Main Topic: The actual police footage, interrogations, and case details behind the Netflix documentary "Maternal Instinct"—the shocking story of Reagan Hancock’s murder and fetal abduction by Taylor Parker.

---

Episode Overview

This episode is the second half of a comprehensive deep dive into the murder of Reagan Hancock and her unborn daughter, Braxlin, at the hands of Taylor Parker. Annie Elise brings listeners exclusive case footage, police interviews, and court documents that go beyond what’s shown on Netflix’s "Maternal Instinct." The episode reveals Taylor’s intricate web of lies, her evolving stories during interrogation, and the disturbing aftermath—including her behavior in jail and at trial, family dynamics, and continuing legal appeals.

---

Key Topics & Insights

1. The Interrogation: Taylor Parker’s Web of Lies

• Exclusive Footage & Warnings: Annie cautions (03:00) that the episode features sensitive and graphic content, as well as real police footage not shown elsewhere.
• Taylor’s Denials and Evolving Story (04:41-17:00):
  • Initial Denial: Taylor repeatedly claims "I didn't kill anybody." (00:41-00:49)
  • Pressed with Facts: Detectives confront Taylor with evidence: she had a hysterectomy, wasn’t recently pregnant, and the baby's DNA didn't match hers.
  • Taylor's Version of Events: She admits to seeing Reagan that day, blames Reagan for initiating a fight, and says Reagan’s wounds were self-inflicted to frame her (11:02).
• Fabricated Heroism: Taylor paints herself as trying to save the baby, claiming Reagan asked her to perform a C-section as she was dying (12:08-15:47).
  • Detective: "That shows what a good person you are." (12:41)
• Detective’s Logic Gaps: Annie points out (17:34) Taylor never called 911, didn’t seek help for the baby or Reagan, but instead tried to pass the baby off as her own—with afterbirth "stuffed in her pants" (18:08).
• Key Quote: On Taylor’s C-section story:
  "…the evidence clearly showed that Taylor didn’t heroically save Braxlyn after this fight gone wrong with Reagan. What she really did was kidnap little Braxlyn from Reagan’s womb, killing Reagan in the process, and then killing baby Braxlyn…" (18:27)

---

2. Details Revealed at Trial

• Taylor's Elaborate Pregnancy Fakery (20:08-20:40)
  • Fake pregnancy bellies, fake emails, and staged maternity photos.
  • Used fakeababy.com to research props and faked hospital documents.
• Wade’s (Boyfriend) Role:
  • Annie and the prosecution note disbelief that Wade didn’t realize Taylor was never pregnant.
    "Does that mean they weren't intimate for the entire 10 months that she was pregnant? How did he not ever see the baby bump without clothes on it?" (20:48)
• Timelines and Pre-Meditation (21:33+)
  • Taylor researched C-sections, hospital births, and stalked other pregnant women in the days before the murder.
  • Left Reagan’s house after the crime and immediately called hospitals, watched C-section YouTube videos, and attempted to maintain the ruse.
• Trial Testimony: Numerous witnesses—family, doctors, and even a clinic worker invited to Taylor's fake gender reveal (22:35-23:30).
• Legal Tactics:
  • Defense tried unsuccessfully to argue Braxlyn couldn't be kidnapped if not yet born (24:51).
  • Taylor’s team didn’t call a single defense witness.

---

3. Taylor Parker’s Jailhouse Schemes

• Manipulative & Deceitful Behavior (28:50+)
  • Schemed with her mother to hide money from jail debts by using other inmates' accounts (30:12).
  • Repeatedly destroyed jail-issued clothing to get new items, flirted and had relationships with inmates (32:00-34:00).
• Romantic Manipulations: Boasts about needing a "sugar daddy" and communications with multiple inmates (34:00+).
• Framing Others / Creating Alternate Narratives (36:33-42:00):
  • Attempted to frame other inmates, especially a mentally ill inmate named Hannah, for the murder.
  • Circulated forged documents, scripts, and letters instructing others to lie or plant evidence.
  • Offered inmates money to pass confessions to media.
• Medical Malingering: Fabricated or exaggerated health crises to gain privileges or attention in jail (44:00+).

---

4. Personality Profile and Notorious Behavior

• Expert Psychological Testimony (63:33-67:01):
  • Forensic psychologist Dr. Michael Armbula: "…nothing regarding mental illness and nothing regarding intoxication… she does have borderline personality…people with narcissism and antisocial personality disorder…" (66:14)
• Jailhouse Behavior: Manipulates, flirts, and exerts power within inmate population. Writes murder stories, offers to assist the FBI(!), and seeks infamy (52:42-73:46).
• Manipulating Family & Children:
  • Exploits her children emotionally through guilt-laden letters, and even used her daughter to help select trial outfits meant to antagonize Reagan's family (e.g., sunflower masks) (53:25).

---

5. Sentencing, Appeals, and Aftermath

• Sentencing Phase Drama (55:51–85:27)
  • Lasted four weeks; family, former friends, medical professionals testified to Taylor’s lifelong deceit, lack of remorse, and manipulation.
  • Jurors and witnesses described her as having a scowl throughout and show no emotion at the verdict—until victim impact statements (85:53).
  • Taylor sentenced to death (85:27), now on death row.
  • Notable Juror Quote: "…their decision to sentence Taylor to death was unanimous from the very first vote. That's how compelling the evidence was." (85:27)
• Life on Death Row: Taylor described it as "like the Hilton" (87:11), still enjoyed privileges, and became the youngest woman on Texas death row at the time.
• Appeals: Defense cited irrelevant arguments (weight, past cheating) and tried to undermine the kidnapping/murder charge by arguing the baby wasn't born alive—courts rejected all appeals, up to the Supreme Court (87:17-89:27).

---

6. The Real Victims and Lasting Impact

• Reagan’s Daughter’s Trauma:
  • Surviving daughter Kinley witnessed parts of the attack and now exhibits PTSD-like symptoms (81:50, 90:51).
  • Reagan's family continues to honor her memory.
• Annie’s Closing Thoughts:
  • Strong condemnation of Taylor, frustration with enabling behavior in her family.
  • Calls out the ongoing pain and trauma experienced by Reagan’s family.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Taylor Parker (repeated, 00:41):
  "I didn't kill anybody."

• Detective Exposing Flaws (17:34):
  "If Taylor really was just trying to save baby Braxlynn ... why didn’t she call an ambulance? Why didn’t she try to get help for this little baby who wasn’t breathing right away? Why didn’t she try to get help for Reagan?"

• Forensic Psychologist Dr. Armbula (66:14):
  "There is nothing regarding any mental illness ... her actions before, during, and after the crime show she has a borderline personality."

• Medical Examiner on Reagan's Last Moments (73:45):
  "...two fingernails embedded in the placenta…Reagan was alive during the forceful extraction...she was holding onto the placenta as a way to keep her baby safe..."

• Juror on Guilty Verdict (85:27):
  "...decision to sentence Taylor to death was unanimous from the very first vote. That's how compelling the evidence was."

---

Key Timestamps

• 00:41: Taylor's initial denials in police footage.
• 04:41–17:00: Full interrogation and Taylor’s shifting explanations.
• 18:27: Annie’s breakdown of the real evidence.
• 20:40: Revelations at trial about faked pregnancy.
• 28:50: Jailhouse schemes, relationships, and manipulation.
• 36:33–44:00: Plotting to frame others and create alternate narratives.
• 52:42–54:00: Taylor’s obsession with crime, notoriety, and correspondence with the FBI.
• 63:33: Expert testimony on Taylor’s psychology.
• 73:45: Medical examiner details Reagan’s last moments.
• 85:27: Jury’s unanimous death penalty verdict.
• 87:11: Taylor describes death row as “like the Hilton.”
• 89:27: Appeals rejected, Taylor remains on death row.
• 90:51: Kinley and Reagan’s family’s ongoing trauma.

---

Summary Tone

Annie Elise blends detailed investigative research with a passionate, direct, and occasionally sardonic tone. She exposes overlooked case files and highlights the failures in accountability, both within Taylor’s social circle and her family, always centering the pain of Reagan’s surviving family and the gravity of the crimes.

---

Final Reflection

This episode pulls back the curtain on a case far more horrifying—and riddled with manipulation—than Netflix or headlines suggest. Annie provides listeners with exclusive access to interrogation footage, breaks down the mind games and pathology of Taylor Parker, and keeps focus on the devastating cost for Reagan, Braxlin, Kinley, and their family. All of it is delivered in Annie’s signature “true crime bestie” style: empathetic, deeply researched, and unfiltered.

Transcript

[Interviewer]

From taco night in Tulum to sushi in Tokyo, make every bite rewarding with gold from Amex. Wherever you dine four times. Membership rewards points at restaurants worldwide are piling up. Learn [e-mail] Explore Gold terms and points cap apply.

[Podcast Host]

Hey, true crime besties. Welcome back to an all new episode of Serial Asleep.

[Taylor Parker]

I didn't kill anybody.

[Interviewer]

Where'd this baby come from? We're past all of that. We're past that.

[Taylor Parker]

I did not kill anybody. I didn't kill anybody.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Now, in part one of this deep dive, we covered the absolutely unhinged details of Taylor's lies and deception. So if you haven't listened to that part yet, you. You definitely need to go check it out because you need the lore, you need the backstory in order to be caught up here. In this episode, we also follow Taylor's path of destruction all the way up to the moment that the detectives confronted her with the truth that the baby that she claimed was hers. No, not only did that baby not belong to her, but that baby was also now dead. So that meant that Taylor was being charged with the murders of both Reagan and her baby girl, Braxlin. But there is also so much more to this story and so much more to the interrogations and the interviews and everything that goes in it. And that's what we're going to be talking about now in part two. Like I said in my last episode, my team and I, we did a ton of digging into this case and we have the footage straight from law enforcement to show you and to share with you. So if you heard about this case from the Netflix documentary or you've heard about it just in passing or on Tik Tok, you definitely are going to want to stick around because we've got all the details for you and we have all of the footage that they didn't show you. Now, since this case is very footage heavy and covers extremely sensitive topics, including fetal abduction, the death of a baby, and this DIY C section surgery, I do want to warn you that this episode is incredibly difficult to listen to. There are also parts, of course, that are too graphic to show on YouTube. Now, I still want to give you the full case file, everything that we were able to gather all of our resources. So similarly to what we've done in the past with cases over on Patreon, we have a whole case folder where we've uploaded all the documents, all the media, everything that we've received from law enforcement. So that if you want to do your own digging and your own due diligence and dive into it a little bit deeper. You have all of the information that we also have, so you can find all of our research and our full case folder with all the stuff that we didn't include in this episode over there on Patreon. With all that said, though, we have a lot to unpack, so let's get right into it. This is part two of the case of Reagan Hancock and Taylor Parker. Now, when we left off in part one, detectives were sure that the baby that Taylor had claimed was hers was. Was, in fact, not hers at all. They realized that Taylor had cut Reagan's baby right out of her body, killing Reagan in the process. Then she climbed into the car with Reagan's newborn baby girl and tried to pass her off as her own, as though she delivered this baby. Now, tragically, Reagan wasn't the only victim. Somewhere along the way, little Braxland stopped breathing, and she died, too. So that left Taylor charged with both of their murders. But even as the detectives started pressing her, she wasn't ready to give up the truth. She was going to dig her heels into this lie as hard as she could. For most of her hospital room interrogation, Taylor even refused to admit that she knew Reagan, let alone did anything to Reagan. But slowly and surely, detectives started confronting her with more and more evidence. They also told Taylor that they had received her medical records and that they had proof that she had undergone a hysterectomy. They also explained that a doctor had done a full body exam on her and found no signs that she had recently been pregnant. Her blood work also didn't show any sort of pregnancy hormones, and the baby's DNA did not match hers. She was just being confronted with one lie after another. So, little by little, with the detectives also now pushing her, Taylor finally started to crack. Finally, she admitted that she had seen Reagan on the day that she died. The story that she told them, though, well, it still didn't sound much like the truth. She basically said that Reagan had invited her over, then insulted her, and. And then from there, a huge fight broke out. Now, a quick warning. This is raw police footage that I'm about to share with you. There is some background noise. There are a few times where the officer's pager makes a very loud buzzing sound. But I still wanted to share it with you so that you get the full story. And again, for my audio listeners, you may want to watch the video version after this.

[Interviewer]

So. So what happened?

[Podcast Host]

I mean, what.

[Interviewer]

I mean, how did this. How did this all come about. I mean, when did you first see the woman this? Today.

[Taylor Parker]

She checked on me.

[Interviewer]

Is she a friend of yours? Okay, so she come over. Did she come to your house? Oh, she. So you went to her house. Okay, what happened then?

[Taylor Parker]

Don't believe with me.

[Podcast Host]

Come on now.

[Interviewer]

Yeah, you do. Yeah, you do. So what happened? You go over to her house and what happened?

[Taylor Parker]

Her reaper pulled up and did you go inside?

[Interviewer]

Did you talk very long, or did she say something to you to make you ma' am or something? Or what happened?

[Taylor Parker]

She went to hug a meeting, told me that I was alive.

[Interviewer]

Okay, so she grabbed hold of you and did. Did you try to fight back? You both fought back? Yeah,

[Taylor Parker]

We both hit each other.

[Interviewer]

Okay. That's okay. Stuff happens sometimes, you know? Stuff happens. It's all right.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Taylor continued on with her story, still putting most of the blame on Reagan, saying she pulled her hair and she hit her.

[Taylor Parker]

She grabbed me my hair and show me in the garage.

[Interviewer]

She.

[Taylor Parker]

She hit me.

[Interviewer]

Stars are blue or.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And as for that circle indentation on Reagan's head, Taylor said that she just happened to slip and fall, that that

[Podcast Host]

is what caused it.

[Interviewer]

So at some point, she hits her head, falls down and hits her head.

[Taylor Parker]

She pushed me in the garage. I pushed her back. She got it, grabbed me like this.

[Interviewer]

So you go from the garage into the living room?

[Taylor Parker]

I went from a colorful garage to the living room.

[Interviewer]

She's still fighting as she go falls again, come back. Was that the last time she fell?

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

We went along at some point in this supposed fight. Reagan apparently got a hold of a knife, and Taylor claimed that it was actually Reagan that threatened her with this knife, not the other way around.

[Interviewer]

See, hollowed up in the garage. And she falls. She pushes you. You push her back. She falls pretty hard. And then I think you told me

[Taylor Parker]

that she grabbed, scraped a knife.

[Interviewer]

Okay.

[Taylor Parker]

Because I remember she stabbed me in my hand.

[Interviewer]

Where bounds the gun right there. Flipped it around so I can see. Oh, right there. Okay.

[Taylor Parker]

Something else.

[Interviewer]

Okay.

[Taylor Parker]

Right there. She got me tipping right there.

[Interviewer]

Okay.

[Taylor Parker]

I just remember hitting car.

[Interviewer]

Okay, but she had a knife, though. Okay.

[Taylor Parker]

Yeah, but I. I did. I don't know why she grabbed it.

[Interviewer]

You end up with a knife and she hit you. Was. She picks up. Apparently picks up something, hits you with something heavy, you're not sure what it was. And then she failed. And there was blood. Did you stick her with the knife or was it.

[Taylor Parker]

She felt with the knife? Because I shoved her.

[Interviewer]

Okay, so she gets a knife back from you.

[Taylor Parker]

We. We both had it in Our hands a few times.

[Interviewer]

Okay. I'm just trying to get it out my head, you know what I mean? So.

[Taylor Parker]

Because she stuck me first. Okay. And I don't remember why she kept calling me.

[Interviewer]

What was she calling you mean like still calling you a liar or just still calling you something else?

[Taylor Parker]

No, she taught me that I was gonna write that she'd kill me if I touched her again.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And as for Reagan's stab wounds, well, Taylor said that all of those were self inflicted and that the reason that they were self inflicted was so that Reagan could frame Taylor.

[Interviewer]

So she falls and she's got the knife. Did she fall on the knife? Is that what you believe or tell what you know or. Or you don't know?

[Taylor Parker]

She had to because I didn't.

[Interviewer]

You didn't stab.

[Taylor Parker]

I didn't stab her.

[Interviewer]

Okay, that's fine. So afterwards, did it look like she been like the knife she grabs.

[Taylor Parker]

She grabs him and started smacking herself with it and told me that they would believe I did it.

[Interviewer]

Oh, okay. So she started hitting herself with something. Okay, what was that? Before or after she fell and started bleeding out of her neck?

[Taylor Parker]

That was after.

[Interviewer]

After she was bleeding out of her neck?

[Taylor Parker]

Yes.

[Interviewer]

Okay, so she picks up something, starts hitting herself with it, saying that they're kind of setting you up.

[Taylor Parker]

I guess she only said it like twice. She didn't just keep saying it.

[Interviewer]

Okay, was she on the ground? She was doing that.

[Taylor Parker]

Was she saying you stand it up in the living room?

[Interviewer]

Okay.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Now apparently, somewhere in the mess of this crazy fight that Taylor says happened, Reagan apparently realized that she was dying. So that is when, according to Taylor, Reagan asked her to cut baby Braxlin out of her body. As though Reagan now wanted Taylor to be the martyr and save her unborn child.

[Interviewer]

This is a deal where maybe she. When she hit her head, did you think she died and he was trying to save the baby?

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Me,

[Interviewer]

I understand that. Well, and that shows what a good person you are. That shows what a good person you are. Did do what? I understand. Understand. I mean, that's obvious. You called the ambulance, you know, so she hit her head.

[Taylor Parker]

And

[Interviewer]

so you tried to. You tried to save the baby. Soon as you. You. I guess you cut the baby out of it. You left C section on her. You don't remember. So how did you go from her laying there with her head to ye. How maybe in your hand? Do you remember if you. Did you. Do you remember if you used a mask that was from her house or did you have one already.

[Podcast Host]

Her?

[Interviewer]

Cuz you had to get the baby, had to come out of. Right. So had that happen.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

So basically Taylor had tried to paint herself as the hero. Like, oh yeah, maybe she and Reagan did get into a little bit of a fight. But all of Reagan's injuries were her own fault. They were self inflicted. She did it. And then when she realized that Reagan was dying, and when Reagan had the realization that she was dying too, Taylor stepped in and did the heroic thing, trying to save the baby.

[Interviewer]

At that point, I mean, she's obviously pregnant. You're worried about the baby because of her, she's dying. You know that let your baby die. Right? So is that the point where you decided to try to save your baby? Good. So what happened? Did you get that? Did you get the knife that she had? So imagine it was laying there handy, or did you go get another dodge?

[Taylor Parker]

She said take her.

[Interviewer]

Oh, she wanted you to type her.

[Taylor Parker]

She, she said it a lot, that she would fish,

[Interviewer]

she wouldn't, wouldn't come out. But she's the one you to take her. Okay, so she asked you to. She asked a little taper. That's okay. Listen, it's all right. I mean, you're, you're thinking of the kids best interest, you know, so, so what happened? Did you get, did you use the knife that was there or did you go. Have to go get one?

[Taylor Parker]

Okay, but I don't know what I had.

[Interviewer]

Okay, that's fine. That's fine. Okay. Do you remember cutting her open to get the baby out? Did you have much trouble getting it up, Cutting her open? Okay, yes, that's fine. That's fine. So did, so she, she's wanting you to save the baby.

[Taylor Parker]

She said she was dying.

[Interviewer]

She said she was dying. Okay, that's okay. So. So you take the baby, but you don't remember what with, right? I don't put words in it now.

[Taylor Parker]

No, I don't remember.

[Interviewer]

That's fine. That's okay. And it's okay. So. So you take the baby out of her stomach, Is that right?

[Taylor Parker]

It fell out like she was pushing and it come out, it come out

[Interviewer]

of her vagina, out of her stomach. Okay.

[Taylor Parker]

She was still in the sack.

[Interviewer]

Oh, okay.

[Taylor Parker]

All right.

[Interviewer]

So it comes out of her stomach and it's still in the sack. Did you have to, did you have to pull the sack apart to get the baby?

[Taylor Parker]

Yeah, to pull it open. Turned her over and started smacking her back. Then she.

[Interviewer]

Okay, so then, so you get the baby out. You're saving the baby. All right. And then you leave, right? Did you call for an ambulance, or was she going to the hospital to try to get some help for the baby?

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Okay, but as you heard the detective mention at the end, Taylor's story had a massive hole in it. If Reagan really did die by accident during this fight gone wrong, and if Taylor really was just trying to save baby Braxland, then why didn't she call an ambulance? Why didn't she try to get help for this little baby who wasn't breathing right away? Why didn't she try to get help for Reagan? Why did she just throw this baby

[Podcast Host]

into her car and take off?

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And more importantly, why did Taylor tell everyone that the baby was hers, so much so that she had the afterbirth

[Podcast Host]

stuffed in her pants to make it

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

sell her lie even more? I mean, the whole thing was not adding up, not by a long shot. There were other parts of Taylor's story, too, that didn't make sense at all. Or parts that changed constantly. For one, like you heard in the interview, Taylor originally said that she had no idea what she even used to perform the C section. She admitted that she carried a knife, but she insisted that it definitely was not what had killed Reagan. Yet later, Taylor suddenly seemed very sure that she used a knife that came from a medical kit that she used with the hogs. So, I mean, which was it? Did she have no idea what the weapon was, or did she know exactly where it came from? Taylor also claimed that after she finished the C section, she. She just laid down the knife very gently. Yet during Reagan's autopsy, the scalpel that had been used, it was found broken inside her neck. So the evidence clearly showed that Taylor didn't heroically save Braxlin after this fight gone wrong with Reagan. What she really did was kidnap little Braxton from Reagan's womb, killing Reagan in the process, and then killing baby Braxlin all through her own recklessness and complete disregard for this baby's life after going to such extreme dreams to steal this baby and kidnap this baby and pass her off as her own. So, with that, Taylor was charged with capital murder for Reagan's death. She was also eventually charged with capital murder and kidnapping in connection with Braxland. But Reagan and Braxland, they weren't the only victims. One of the saddest parts of this entire case is that Reagan's other daughter, Kinley, was inside the house as this whole massacre unfolded.

[Podcast Host]

Taylor said that Kinley came out in the middle of it, and she yelled at her to go back in her room. And it's been said that she was found hiding under a blanket, which I can't imagine the fear that she had when she saw her mom getting murdered and heard this attack taking place. Taylor pled not guilty and was held on $5 million bail in Bowie County.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Taylor's case eventually went to trial in late 2022, two years after the murders.

[Podcast Host]

And so much information came to light in the trial. First, that Taylor made up everything. Made up everything about finances, the people in the emails, and pretty much everything else that she has ever said has been a lie. Also, that pregnancy was, of course, fake, and she had taken elaborate measures to fake it. In August, she was on random websites such as fakeababy.com looking@fake pregnancy bellies and even bought a new one right around the time those maternity pictures came out.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And that had a lot of people saying the same thing.

[Podcast Host]

How the hell did her boyfriend Wade

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

not realize that something was up?

[Podcast Host]

Because does that mean that they weren't intimate for the entire 10 months that she was pregnant? How did he not ever see the baby bump without clothes on it? And that's not to say he's not a victim, but it just seems strange.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And Homer Reagan's husband seemed to agree. Shortly after Taylor's arrest, he actually sued Wade for negligence in Braxland's death. Basically, Homer argued that Wade should have known that Taylor was lying about this pregnancy, and also that he should have never given her access to his car, knowing that she was, you know, batshit crazy. Which, as of now, that civil case is still unresolved. But Wade aside, the trial also revealed a lot about Taylor's other relationships, including her relationship with her ex husband, Hunter.

[Podcast Host]

Allegedly, Taylor faked seizures and medical problems consistently to try to keep Hunter around. She also had been pushing him to have a baby, despite having had a hysterectomy. She told him that he should get a loan so that they could hire a surrogate and that her grandmother would pay for it all in cash. Allegedly, a man by the name of Tim Hightower was supposed to bring the money. And Hunter got many texts from this Tim man, including a picture of a duffel bag full of cash. But Tim never showed up. Taylor told Hunter that Tim had gotten in an accident on the way, and the paramedics stole the money. Another elaborate lie and story that Taylor concocted. After her divorce from Hunter, things got even crazier. Taylor told her friends that she and Hunter had, in fact, hired a surrogate, but that Hunter cheated on her with the surrogate. And apparently, she was so desperate for a baby that right after the divorce, she offered two friends 100,000 doll to carry a baby for her. Both of them declined, thank God. And honestly, why do you want more kids when you don't even have custody of the two you have? Taylor was pretty emotionless the entire trial, clearly showing no remorse. There was only one time that her eyes looked like she had been crying, and that was right after her attorney called for a recess. The timeline of the murder was spelled out in the trial, and prosecution said that after September 15th of 2020, she began researching things about delivery. More than ever, she was googling things about hospital births, videos of C sections, among many other weird things. When she was sitting on a bench outside that clinic on September 30, after rescheduling her appointment, she actually was looking up the license plates of pregnant women that she was watching going in and out, possible plots to follow them home to see where they lived. It's disgusting. After she left Reagan's house on the night of the 8th, she ended up going home. And between 3:11am and 3:30am on the 9th, she made five calls to McCurtain County Hospital. At 3:45am she had a brief call from Wade's phone. Then Wade's GEO data showed he was heading to Oklahoma. Starting around 4:28am Taylor watched YouTube videos about C sections and births at 35 weeks, the same duration of pregnancy that Reagan was at. She left her house at 5:36am Investigators have been able to prove that Reagan died between 7:52am and 9:14am Other testimony on the prosecution side was from the doctors, from witnesses from Wade's mom, Connie Wade himself, and a clinic worker from the very first clinic who was actually invited to Taylor's gender reveal, which, by the way, is just extremely odd. So the clinic worker didn't go to the gender reveal, but was invited. And apparently her hands were tied due to hipaa. But she apparently knew the whole time that Taylor was not pregnant. So Taylor inviting someone who knew she wasn't pregnant is just so odd and such a ballsy, bold move, I guess, because to her, it would make her story somehow more credible having them there. During Wade's testimony, he discussed that he believed Taylor because she showed him documents and emails and she had an explanation for everything. So clearly he was also a victim of her lies and manipulation. But I'm sorry, I'm not trying to shame you. You're kind of a dumb. Dumb like you could have figured it out. I think Taylor's team was really trying to get her off the Hook. Initially, they tried to get the capital

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

murder charge thrown out.

[Podcast Host]

They said that a fetus has not yet been born, so if it's not alive, it can't be kidnapped. Which makes no sense because Braxlen was already born when she put her in the car with the umbilical cord in her pants. So the judge denied the motion to drop the charge. They also tried painting a picture of Wade knowing that she actually wasn't even pregnant. They said that he, since he has assisted in hog births, he would know if she were truly pregnant or not. But it was made clear that Taylor was on trial here, not Wade. In the end, her defense team never called even one witness. And to me, that sends a clear message about the type of person Taylor is and the crime that she committed. Not even one single person was willing to vouch for her. Taylor also declined to take the stand as well. During closing statements, the prosecution spent 40 minutes, and Taylor's attorneys spoke for just eight minutes. Within an hour of deliberations, the jury came back with a guilty verdict for capital murder. According to people who were there, Taylor sat emotionless during this verdict reading. She didn't even flinch at the verdict.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Taylor's sentencing hearing started shortly after, and this was where the jury really had to decide whether she deserved life in prison or the death penalty. But, guys, this was also not a typical sentencing hearing. This wasn't one of those short hearings where the victim's family speaks, the judge gives a sentence, and then everything is wrapped up in a day or so. This was basically an entire second trial. And during it, a brand new pile of disturbing information came to light. We're talking about Taylor trying to seduce prison guards. Taylor trying to frame other inmates. Even more heartbreaking details about the day that Reagan and Braxton Axelin lost their lives. I mean, there is so much more information. In fact, we kind of need to rewind a little bit back to right before the sentencing trial even began to get through all of that and explain it.

[Podcast Host]

Your next unforgettable experience can happen anytime. Take an AMEX card with you for rewards wherever you go. Morning coffee.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Run with an old friend. Earn cash back.

[Podcast Host]

Weekend getaway.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Earn miles.

[Podcast Host]

AMEX rewards your inner explorer. Learn more@american express.com terms apply.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Big color, bigger savings. Sherwin Williams super sale is here. Get 40% off paints and stains June 5th through the 11th, with prices starting at 30 89. Whether you're refreshing your interior or exterior, we've got the colors to bring your vision to life. And with delivery, getting everything to your door. Is easier than ever. Shop online to have it delivered or visit your neighborhood Sherwin Williams store. Click the banner to learn more. Retail sales only some exclusions apply. See store for details. Delivery available on qualifying orders. Take the short drive to Genesee county in Batavia Downs for the Rockin the Downs concert series when we welcome legendary Motown artists the Spinners.

[Interviewer]

Friday, June 26 get tickets at bataviaconcerts.com

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Hear songs like the Rubber Band Man Working My Way back to to you, I'll Be around and many more.

[Interviewer]

Tickets start at just $20 and include

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

$10 in free play. Be sure to get them [e-mail] Batavia down with more.

[Podcast Host]

Lots more. When it's time to scale your business,

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

it's time for Shopify. Get everything you need to grow the way you want.

[Podcast Host]

Like all the way. Stack more sales with the best converting checkout on the planet. Track your cha chings from every channel right in one spot and turn real time reporting into big time opportunities. Take your business to a whole new level. Switch to Shopify. Start your free trial today. On October 11, the day before the sentencing period started, supplemental documents were released for the public's viewing. These documents contain some of the latest evil shenanigans of Taylor and what she has been up to during her time in Bowie County Jail. Information in these documents varied from medical encounters and schemes, inmate relationships, and attempts to frame these inmates. New confessions, Taylor's obsession with murder. I mean, just so much stuff, guys.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And I've gotta say, a whole lot of Taylor's jailhouse schemes were being flat out enabled by her parents, especially her mom. Which is a little bit surprising too, because if you remember from part one of this episode, Taylor made up some pretty serious lies and accusations about her mom. She basically claimed that her mom was framing her and trying to ruin her life. Yet I don't know, I guess her mom somehow forgave all of that because she really did seem more than happy to keep enabling Taylor from behind bars. And you know what this also kind of reminds me of and I'm just going to go off a little bit here. Mackenzie Shurilla, Right? Because if you follow that case at all or you saw my deep dive, you know that her parents also enabled her through and through. Mackenzie is another young woman who is responsible for two deaths, just like Taylor. And just like Taylor, her parents keep making excuses for her and enabling her while she's locked up. Sounds familiar, right? It's just wild to me. But now I want to go through a little bit of Taylor's schemes one by one. Now, the first had to do with Taylor and her mom scheming together financially. And the root of that problem was that by February 2022, Taylor had racked up about $2200 in debt. And this was in debt to the jail. Now, I don't know what that is for. Who really knows what. But because we know Taylor takes no accountability for anything, she was doing everything in her power to avoid paying it back.

[Podcast Host]

Now, the way that the financial situation in the jail is supposed to work is that when people put money on somebody's books, whatever they owe is deducted from that amount. Well, since Taylor doesn't want to pay it, she repeatedly had her mom, Shawna put money on other inmates books. Then those inmates were going to go and get her commissary for her. Taylor would pay them by giving some of her commissary items to them. Shauna also ordered commissary items for at least 10 other inmates during all of this. Yet again, they would get the commissary ordered in their name and then hand it over to Taylor. But the thing is, Taylor and Shawna are just both complete idiots because they discussed these schemes at length over the phone, over snail mail and even emails sent to and from the jail kiosk. So it was a all documented. Now, I honestly have no idea how Shauna hasn't been arrested for playing a part in these schemes because you're basically defrauding the jail. And also as a mother, she is just like a horrible enabler. There's a difference between loving and enabling a child. And her child murdered somebody and their unborn baby. So the next thing that these supplemental documents talked about is a clothing issue. Taylor was repeatedly ripping up her jail clothes, then complaining about it to her parents and asking for more money for new clothing. On January 5, 2022, Taylor was on the phone with her dad and was recorded saying, I'm in lockdown from yesterday until Friday because we have the crew. So not able to call again until Friday. I was trying to see if you were able to put some money on my books. I need to get new warm clothes. I've had mine for a year and there's holes in the front of them. Now let me just clarify that. Taylor refers to the correctional officers who enforce the rules at the jail as the the crew. So clearly she has a problem with authority and has continuously tried to maintain a sense of power in jail in any way possible. But she didn't tell her dad that she was the one ripping her clothes. In order to make her clothing more revealing. Nonetheless, as her enabling parents do, he sent her Money. Also, just three weeks later, on January 28, Taylor told her mom Shawna that she needed new clothes due to holes in the front. So why would they have holes again in the front just three weeks later? Unless it was intentional. She claims it was because she had had them for so long, but clearly she was just trying to play off both of her parents. The DA's office also put a lot of efforts into discussing Taylor's romantic life while in jail. They highlighted that her clothes were ripped solely for the sake of being more provocative and that she would flirt with other inmates and actually had several relationships while in jail. One was with a woman named Lana Addison, who Taylor eventually told that she was tired of being lonely and tired of being around all female inmates. Then she moved on and had romantic relationships with other male inmates and began writing to inmates who were in different facilities. She began using her family too to get a hold of these inmates. So as we've been able to see clearly before, her family doesn't know how to tell her no, right? So she initially went to her mom and told her to look up an inmate named Travis Blocker. Travis had apparently gone home and was released, so she wanted her mom to look him up on Facebook and message him for his email address so that Taylor could communicate with him via email. For the next couple of months, she continued to reach out to different family members to have them communicate with Travis for her. And at one point she even said, I need a sugar daddy to load me some money on this damn thing. Laughing my ass off off. Anything on Blocker, AKA Travis. Clearly she was just continuing her schemes

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

of just using people for the things

[Podcast Host]

that she wanted and felt like she needed. In one email with an inmate named Alan Pulley after he asked her what she was in jail for point blank, she said, unfortunately I can't talk details information wise since I'm in pre trial. I don't go to trial until September 2022. I'm innocent. Assuming you have been to jail before, you know how unjust our bullshit system is. She then went on to say, it does suck, but I have a great team. I have become very close with him and have all the faith that it will work out. I do freelance recruiting for manufacturing industrial plants in the kill trade departments on top of breeding and selling cattle. You can say I'm a farm girl. Please don't think I ever want anything from you. I'm a very independent response, respectful person. Now I Just got to say, I don't know what faith she had in her innocence and that her innocence was going to be found, but clearly it just did not work out that way for her. And as if that's not mind boggling enough, she went on to write letters to yet another inmate. How Many is this? 3? 4? His name was Augustine Diaz. Now, I won't go into all the details of the letter, but I will say that they were super explicit, not very YouTube friendly, and part of her email said that her ex would actually hit her if she ever even gained an ounce of weight, so that if Augustine didn't like big thighs, it wouldn't work. But then she goes on top of that and tells him that she values honesty. Yes, you heard that right, if you're wondering. She literally told him that she values honesty and tells him, I've said this before. I'm so understanding. Just don't lie to me. I love to build a home. Home and family with you Based on God, that's a dream and hope I will hold on to and pray for. That was followed by I love to read, but my true joy is writing. I love every part of putting together a story, which I just gotta say, I mean, obviously she loves putting her stories together. Stories of pregnancies, stories of fake jobs, family drama, family inheritance, being a millionaire billionaire, whatever she had said, these bomb threats, I mean, you name it, girl has got a story for it. She's like a walking telenovela, honestly. So in a letter after that, she said, I gotta tell you this. So E says, parker, girl, I got some much needed D this weekend, meaning dick. Saying, she told me all about it, showed me the bruises, and I said, damn, you released the tension beast.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

We were rolling.

[Podcast Host]

I said, get some bruises for me too, please. Laughing my ass off. I told her that I was so sexually frustrated that if I won, I'd be humping the light poles all the way home. Literally. Just disgusting. Disgusting. So enough of her ridiculous and nasty conversations with people. Let's move on to her trying to scheme and frame other people, because this is where it gets crazy. So the next thing that was discussed by the DA's office was Taylor's plan to frame another inmate named Hannah, who was mentally fragile. And she wanted to frame Hannah as guilty for her crime. In January 2021, Hannah gave the staff at the jail letters that she had written that supposedly contained information about the crime. But when law enforcement interviewed Hannah, it was clear that Hannah was not writing truthful things and that something more sinister was going on here. During the interview, Hannah told them that Taylor told her to say that she, meaning Hannah, saw a black car with wheels and occupied with a black man making drug drops around the jail. Hannah was to tell them that the black car was the same vehicle that she had seen at the murder scene. So this apparently was supposed to help Taylor get off the hook here. But Hannah then took it a step further and revealed what Taylor had actually told her happened in that house with Reagan. Taylor allegedly told Hannah that when she went to Reagan's house the night before the murder, they had gotten into a very big argument. The argument was specifically because Reagan knew Taylor wasn't actually pregnant and was past her due date. Taylor told Hannah that Reagan was supposed to call Wade, who was Taylor's boyfriend, who thought she was pregnant, and tell him that Taylor lost the baby while he was hauling hogs on that mission he was on. But apparently Reagan backed out and then wouldn't do it. So then what else would Taylor do? She said that she then decided to remove Reagan's baby from her, then that she did CPR on baby Braxlin on the couch. She said that she watched Reagan die before leaving. And Taylor told Hannah word for word, it didn't really go as planned. By planned, she meant that she planned on taking this baby home to Wade and pretending that little Braxlyn was their baby. Obviously, Taylor knew what she was doing, and she definitely knew what she was doing by trying to pull Hannah into her mess. But if you thought she was done there, you would be wrong. While she was scheming with Hannah, she also met another inmate named Shana Rae. Shana Rae worked for Texarkarna Gazette. So Taylor gave Shanarae a sealed envelope. In that envelope was allegedly a 13 page envelope, handwritten document. Taylor said that Hannah had given it to her and that she had actually never even read it. Her instructions to Shanarae were to open the envelope, copy the letter down in her own handwriting, and then destroy the copy that she had given her. Then she needed to get the copy to the newspaper. So Taylor claimed that the document, who she said was written by Hannah, had details about the events leading up to the murder and the kidnapping of the baby. But if Taylor didn't write that, how would she know what was even in there? Because, remember, she said that she didn't even look at it. And if it was indeed Hannah's writing, why would Taylor be so adamant that it be rewritten with the original copy destroyed? Seems more likely that she was trying to get her copy and her handwriting documented by somebody else. But the thing here is, is that Taylor's stories to Shauna Array changed a couple of different times. One time, she said that she was in Reagan's house at the time of the attack, but that she wasn't the attacker. She said she heard commotion and went to the other side of the house where Reagan was. She said Reagan begged her to cut her belly to save the baby. She said that's when she got the baby out and that she held Braxland up to Reagan's face and said, tell your mama bye. Just awful and evil. Then Taylor said when she got pulled over, the responder had mistakenly formed the opinion that she was the one who had the baby because the cord was so close. But remember, she also had stuffed the placenta in her pants. So, like, that is, again, one of the many, not even half truths, like, fractions of truths that she's telling. Later, Taylor told Shana Rae that she had absolutely nothing to do with the crime, but she did tell her that she was faking a pregnancy pregnancy and that she was going to Oklahoma to fake a miscarriage and that someone was supposed to call Wade, but last minute decided not to. So, again, we're starting to see, like, pieces of the truth start to form together based on versions. She's telling all of these different players and people she's working with, but still not the outright truth. So after giving Shauna Ray these documents, she went to another inmate, Sylvia. She is just, like, trying to play chess with everybody here, guys. Taylor gave her a document which had Mama Sylvia written on the front in the document she handed her. She denied committing the murder. Once again, she also accused law enforcement of making up and withholding information that would prove her innocence. Both of those letters to Sylvia and to Shauna Rae are believed to have been written by Taylor. So Taylor offered Shauna Rae $5,000 to get the documents to the Texarkana Gazette and that newspaper. And then she also offered Sylvia $15,000 to take the envelope out of the jail and get it delivered to the newspaper. Now, law enforcement realized that Taylor does indeed practice alternating her handwriting frequently. Multiple inmates told them that she changed her writing style often, so it would make sense that she does practice. She doesn't seem to have much else to do in jail either, so she would obviously have all the time in the world to do this. But tampering with witnesses are felony charges, so this just proves that she's still been doing illegal things behind bars. She's also offering these inmates money to help with those schemes. Now, Most of those inmates are in there for drug charges. And people who have drug issues are typically willing to do anything for money for drugs so that they can get a fix. So she was still trying to take advantage of other people's weaknesses.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

In February 2021, law enforcement interviewed a

[Podcast Host]

former inmate named Phyllis Dawson. I know, guys, there are a lot of inmates here to go through. Phyllis had a letter from somebody named D.C. the initials D.C. so Phyllis told the agent interviewing her that Taylor told her D.C. also called. Detective Chris was a detective who was helping her out so that nothing bad

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

would happen to her and that she

[Podcast Host]

she was going to get out. Taylor had Phyllis write a letter to this DC character. But Phyllis was obviously confused because she never got a letter back. So she gave the agent another sealed envelope that had a 10 page confessional that framed Taylor once again, as innocent. Taylor had given Phyllis instructions to take this letter and mail it out when she was released from jail. The confessional had details that were not known to the public and would only be known to somebody who was close to the crime. So Taylor is creative, but not smart enough to double check her sources and her information. It seems she also isn't smart enough to find the correct people to cover for her. So Phyllis gave this agent a puzzle book. And it kind of seems like a Sudoku book or something similar. And in the book, across many pages, were instructions on where to send the documents and also instructed her to find someone to lie to the police. The writings even included a script for what the person was supposed to say and had details matching up to all the confessional letters that were written. The book also said specifically, be smart, granny. Pick someone smart who will bring the details to life once it's done. And Detective Chris says, I will mail you $500. In another scheme that she used to frame Hannah for the murder, as if, you know, she hadn't done enough at this point, was to have her now jail girlfriend, Lana Addison, Shawna Rae, and another inmate named Callie be witnesses for her. She gave Lana a document with the plan and told her not to turn it over to law enforcement. The three witnesses were supposed to find evidence in different places throughout Bowie county and then turn that over to law enforcement. But apparently it would only work if all of them did their jobs correctly. However, before her plan could even have a chance to work, Lana had a cell shakedown and the document was found. So the jig was up. So probably not a smart idea to write things down and give them to people when all of their things are subject to be searched at any point in time. Again, very creative, I'll give her that. But not very smart. Now, Taylor told Lana that Wade believed that she was pregnant because he was, and I quote, an effing dumbass, and that she also ordered a fake belly to attach to that to sell the story. She also said that she avoided intimacy by complaining of cramps and pain and saying that doctors apparently don't recommend sex during high risk pregnancy. So now let's kind of shift our years. We've talked about the inmates, we've talked about some plotting, some scheming, some relationships. Now let's talk a little bit about some medical issues or some tall tales. Let me, you know, position it that way. The jail even had to change many of their procedures due to Taylor's schemes. She was calling in sick constantly to go get medical care, but was actually using that to try to flirt with her jail boyfriends and pass notes on the way to the nurse. In the documents, it released that if she wasn't completely lying about being sick or not feeling well, she was just massively exaggerating. And she was also getting furious if she wasn't handcuffed in the front instead of the back. One time she showed up to a mental health session and was apparently not handcuffed and the mental health officer reminded the officer that she needed to be handcuffed for safety reasons. And apparently Taylor immediately just flew off the handle. Also, when she has been called in to go see the nurse if it's not a convenient time for her, Taylor see any of her boyfriends or pass notes, she's been known to refuse to go. So they decided to just start actually examining her in her cell instead of taking her down to the designated nurse's area, which also made her super upset, which I would think if she was really sick, she wouldn't care where she was seen as long as she was getting medical attention and feeling better. But again, it just proves that her whole reason for doing this was to plot, to scheme, to see people, to pass notes, to, you know, have her own agenda. On October 15, 2020, less than two weeks after the murder, Taylor was taken for a mental health crisis assessment. When asked why she was there, she responded, I murdered a lady. She also told the crisis worker that she had a previous attempt on her own Life. Back in 2015, after going paralyzed, she told her that she isn't eating much, had lost around 20 pounds, wasn't sleeping well, would have blackouts for no reason, and so much more. Then less than a month later, she convinced Staff she needed to go to the emergency room. When they got there, she told hospital staff that she had a history of having a stroke and having had been diagnosed with Factor 5 Leiden disorder. Now, Factor 5 is an inherited disorder that can cause somebody to get blood clots. People are born with factories, factor five. But Taylor was not born with it. In fact, she was tested for it multiple times, and every test came back negative. So five days later, she told physical therapists she was vomiting and that her head was hurting. I mean, it's just constantly something, something, something. But physical therapists who evaluated her were quickly able to see that she was purposely walking unsteady and exaggerating the entire claimed illness. She got a CAT scan of her head, a brain mri, and an ultrasound that all came back normal. It was pretty clear that she was faking it. So back to the jail she went. Then on March 3, 2021, Taylor told her jail girlfriend, Lana in a phone call that she had been taken to the hospital on March 21 and that she had been diagnosed with congestive heart failure. Then on a April 23, she told Nana that she couldn't have any red dyes due to her new heart medication. But when her mom took her a commissary order the very next day, she had ordered Red Island Punch, which has those red dyes. I mean, it's not even like Munchausen's. It's just like pathological. I think at one point, when a nurse asked her if she possibly had an std, she said, oh, my God, if I have an stage std, I'm going to be a murderer. Hold on, you already are a murderer. And she also used all of these fabricated mental illnesses and medical illnesses to get things that she wanted in jail, such as saying that it was recommended that the lights be completely shut off at night because of her seizures and her migraines. But her medical records didn't show that recommendation, nor did they ever show seizures. She continued to make multiple bogus medical claims for things such as blood clots, a uti, chest pain, falling, just so much. And if she didn't refuse the medical care entirely, prosecutors have basically noted that she was just a complete jerk to the medical staff and did not act in any sort of distress at all during these visits. And then if jail staff didn't do as she pleased, especially with these medical things, she was known to threaten or sue them them again. A total master manipulator, or, I guess, a wannabe. Now, while awaiting trial at Bowie county, inmates receive regular counseling services if they wish. So in August 2021, Taylor told her provider that her prayer was that Reagan's family knew who she was and that she would not do something like this. She started discussing how it might be best to take a plea deal and her hatred for the real person who did this. Crime time, which I just hope she hates herself for this. Then she talked about how she didn't want to see her kids seeing her in jail. If you didn't want your kids seeing you in jail, then you shouldn't have killed an innocent woman and her unborn child or done something to put yourself in jail in the first place.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Then In April of 2022, Taylor headed back to the jail counselor with a new complaint. She said that she was now hearing voices.

[Podcast Host]

She said that these voices bother her the most when she she's reading or doing yoga, and that she argues with them throughout the day. Then in May, she told them that the voices were something that she has dealt with before. She told them that she was medicated for this at 11, but stopped taking the medication. Now, this is interesting because in March and July of 2021, she had told them that she was never medicated for mental health issues before. She also told them in June of 2021 that she was never treated for any mental health issues. So which one is it? Were you treated before? Were you not treated? It's time to get your story straight, Taylor. Now, let's talk a little bit more about that staff treatment, because I did touch on it a little bit about her manipulation, saying she's going to sue them, saying all these things. The supplemental documents go on to discuss her antics towards jailhouse staff. If she doesn't get what she wants, she apparently will scream at them, make stories up about them, and threaten to ruin their lives. She will also scream racist and horrible remarks at them. She is also known to go back to other inmates and create stories about the staff physically hurting her, and even telling the inmates that certain staff members are talking about their cases publicly, trying to stir the pot, incite hate, get these inmates against the staff. And that happens whenever things don't go her way. Just a clearly deranged and dangerous person. So let's start talking about her obsession with murder and notoriety and, you know, attention. So these documents go on to discuss Taylor bragging to a girl named Christina that she's writing a book about the murders and that she was also getting Netflix deals and movie deals.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Now, we know that Taylor is a liar, right? However, she was right about that one thing, because, like I said this new Netflix stock, it just dropped. So I mean, I guess you win this one, Taylor.

[Podcast Host]

She also said that Lifetime and Nancy Grace both want to work with her. She also told Christina she misses her best friend Reagan and hates that people think that she could do something like this. Which let me just say, if you really didn't do it and if you miss someone, you wouldn't be trying to profit off their death by book deals, movie deals, Netflix deals, all of this stuff. So the rest of the supplemental document contains some more really disturbing information. Taylor has had multiple books given to her by her mom while she's been in jail because of course, one of

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

the main things you do is read

[Podcast Host]

while you're in jail. Now, almost all of these books are books about murder. She spends her time reading the murder books, writing short stories about murder, and even has written a letter to the FBI offering to assist them in solving murders. And guys, we're going to talk about that letter to the FBI in a little bit here because it is just insane. But first, let's talk a little bit about her kids, the ones that she said she was so worried about seeing her in jail. So she has decided to play off of her kids, mainly her 7 year old son's emotions. She wrote him a letter saying, maybe daddy can let you come and see me soon, but I know you're super busy. In another letter to him she wrote, I sure miss your handsome face and sweet giggles with mama. Talk to you soon. Her son's dad made it clear he was not bringing him to visit her in jail. And he also made it clear that he was not allowing phone calls. Because when Taylor doesn't get her way or she gets upset, she's known to use her son as a pawn and say very hurtful things to him. Obviously her son's dad is just trying to protect this poor kid. But Taylor is so selfish that she just had to write things in letter form that would make him sad. No 7 year old deserves to suffer because of their mother, nor do they need to be, you know, receive these manipulative letters and get feel guilt tripped by their mother for her own actions. Then get this, she had her 10 year old daughter help her plan her outfits for trial, also with the help of her mother, Shawna. But one of the worst parts about this is that she has used this as a way to continue to hurt Reagan, Reagan's family, whenever she can. Let me explain. Reagan's favorite flower was a sunflower and her family has often worn things with sunflowers. To court proceedings in remembrance of her and Braxland. So during many court proceedings, Taylor would wear sunflower masks. Even when nobody was wearing masks, she would wear a sunflower mask in a clear effort to just take a jab at Reagan's family. Just a truly awful human being. So as far as the supplemental documents, that's where we're kind of wrap up with that, because there's still a lot more, but those are the main bullets. So now let's shift over to the actual sentencing court dates, because this is where information just exploded.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

The sentencing period lasted much longer than usual, and it actually went a full four weeks.

[Podcast Host]

During those four weeks weeks, the jury heard from many people, including family members, jail inmates, medical professionals, and more. Prosecutors opened up the sentencing phase by discussing who Taylor is. A liar, a con artist, an actress, and a fraud. The prosecutor said that she was in this to get fame and even making it clear that she would ask jail staff if she could stay up late to watch herself on the news. Taylor's attorney said that they were going to put provide the whole picture of who she is, noting that she was a good mom who just suffered from mental health issues. So first up, let's talk about the family and some of those witness statements. One of the first witnesses was Taylor's stepmom. Her stepmom, Charlotte, described her as a good girl, but said that she would often fabricate lies to get what she wants. Her stepmom said that she did make good grades growing up, but that she was never able to take full accountability for anything. That same day, jurors heard from Tommy Waycasey's divorce attorney. Tommy is Taylor's ex. The divorce attorney testified that Taylor gave up custody of their son, who was 4 at the time of their divorce, and never paid a dime of child support. He also testified of Taylor's urgency in finalizing the divorce and how she married hunter Parker just 11 days after the divorce was finalized. And Tommy, her episode ex, also spoke up. He spoke about Taylor's medical claims. He said that one day she went into the doctor walking, and when she came out, she was unable to walk. But he noticed that whenever Taylor didn't think someone was paying attention, she was magically able to walk again. He also spoke about their marriage failing, but said his son is now doing better. His new wife, Amy, also took the stand. And she said that their son does not want to read any of the letters, letters that Taylor sends him, so she's filed them away for when he's older and ready to make that decision and possibly read them. Amy also talked about wanting a co parenting relationship with Taylor, but quickly realized it wasn't going to be possible. Taylor frequently no showed to her visitations, never paid child support, and did other things that apparently upset their son, Trey. Trey went with her for overnights once and came back a few days later. He had a sore on his bottom and told them that it had been five days since his underwear was changed. So due to Taylor's lack of care for her child, he developed a staph infection. Amy talked about the other issues with visitation, such as Taylor telling Trey it was okay to lie and crying in front of him to manipulate him into saying things and doing things. Just awful with this jail. Phone calls were played, many between Taylor and her mom, Shawna. In one call, Taylor was complaining that Tommy, her ex, wasn't letting her talk to her son Trey. Shawna actually said, if you'd been thinking about the children that you had on earth, you might not be in the situation that you're in, but what's done is done and you have to deal with the consequences as best as you can. You're not the only one dealing with them. We're all dealing with them now. I think that's honestly the very first time Sean has ever said anything that really chastises Taylor and calls her out. But yet, in another call, Shawn is back to the enabling antics when Taylor is complaining of the jail lights being on all night and it affecting her migraines. Such a delicate flower, right? Shawna told Taylor if those lights trigger an episode, that jail is going to have more problems. Maybe, just maybe, you should just hold your eyes open as much as you can so it will trigger another episode. They're not equipped to handle someone in the condition you used to be in. Freaks me out, guys. It really freaks me out. Taylor's ex friend Caitlin also testified Caitlyn discussed how her and Taylor initially bonded over them both being diagnosed with Ms. However, she started to notice that things were seemingly off. Whenever she would be hospitalized with her ms, Taylor would visit her and then then be in the ER a few days later. It was like clockwork, apparently. But the difference was Caitlyn was usually admitted and Taylor was never admitted. She was always sent home with pain management instructions. Taylor was also using a nose spray called Straddle, which apparently is a synthetic opioid painkiller for migraines. So Caitlyn, who was majorly suffering, noticed how Taylor would go through the bottle very quickly. But she, someone who was admitted frequently wasn't Even using opioids. She also discussed them being in the same Jeep Club and Taylor cheating on Tommy during many of the Jeep Club weekends. Eventually, their friendship fell apart due to all of Taylor's lies and the distrust and things just unraveling. Stephanie Ott was another one of Taylor's former friends who testified Stephanie actually hosted Taylor and Wade's gentleman a reveal party. However, she was kind of suspicious, I guess, about what was really happening when she first saw Taylor's ultrasound. The date on it was 2016. When she asked Taylor, Taylor immediately told her that it was a misprint and that the clinic had recently had 300 misprints, which how would she know that? And at one point, Taylor had told Stephanie that she had aborted twins that she had gotten pregnant with by Wade. Another time, the two of them got into another disagreement, and Stephanie apparently felt so unsafe around Taylor that she grabbed a knife from the kitchen just in case. Taylor was also very adamant to stay at Stephanie's house alone with her son one day. He was just four years old and sleeping at the time. Taylor tried three times to be left alone with him, but Stephanie would not allow it, which was definitely a smart move, looking back on it, because who knows knows what she would have done or what she would have done to that child or if she would have kidnapped that child had she been given the opportunity to be alone with him. Taylor's boyfriend and, you know, fictitious baby daddy, Wade, his mom Connie, also testified during this sentencing period. The biggest thing in her testimony was the discussion of a letter from Taylor to her husband Jimmy while she was incarcerated. In that letter, Taylor. Taylor said, I ask you to forgive me, not that I deserve it. I'm asking God for forgiveness. And she also talked about a bond that she and Jimmy had in the letter, saying, I will forever cherish you. You are a wise man who has taught me so much. Next. A lot of people who knew Taylor best and saw her frequently and worked with her frequently, testified old co workers. So next they called up two people that she had worked, worked with in the beginning of 2020. The two co workers discussed the lies that she told, including saying that she had a sister take her own life and that she was missing work for a funeral, telling them that she had cancer, telling them that she was pregnant. I mean, lies on lies on lies. She also had one of those co workers call Wade during that time, pretending to be at the bank, she wrote out a script for this employee to read off to let let Wade know why the money was being delayed. The plant Manager where she worked in HR also testified and testified that she had a blank, hateful stare whenever she got angry. He said that when they let her go, he actually was watching closely in fear of what she might do. He said that she had a purse on her shoulder and that he was watching very closely because it would not have surprised him if she had something else in the purse indicating weapon of some sort. The CEO of Jennison Prime Care also took the stand and testified that Taylor was working for them. In 2018, she was terminated within her 90 day probationary period after things just

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

started not adding up.

[Podcast Host]

Apparently she was trying to get opioids from the pharmacist under false pretenses that she was a nurse practitioner. After that, she was hired for a front desk position at Express, another Health Healthcare place. On her application, she wrote that her greatest accomplishments were getting blood from hard stick anxious patients and being with patients in OB who have lost a child. Yes, you heard that right. One of her biggest strengths is being with patients in OB who has lost a child. Guys, I can't. I can't. So with all this medical drama around her, we now go into more of the testimony from experts. So on the 13th, they had an expert witness come in and testify. Forensic psychologist Dr. Michael Armbula testified that Taylor is not mentally ill. He did not interview Taylor personally until October 14, but reviewed all of the evidence and records prior to that. During his testimony, he said, I was looking for some kind of mental deterioration that would account for that. But instead, I saw that she. She stuck to her plan and there was no remorse afterwards. He went on to say, in this case, there is nothing regarding any mental illness and nothing regarding intoxication. And Ms. Parker fails in the category of fetal abductors, which are rare, but fall into a class of women who don't have a mental illness. The murders are planned, they're premeditated. They have plans for after. He did say that her actions before, before, during, and after the crime show that she does have a borderline personality. He said it would be known as cluster B type. Cluster B is typically characterized by a higher likelihood of behaving dramatically and drastically and erratically. Cluster B includes people with narcissism, antisocial personality disorder, and people who are known as sociopaths. Her former therapist from the jail was next to testify. She discussed an incident where Taylor was so angry that she had to remain handcuffed during their session. The therapist, Ms. Parish, said that Taylor went completely dark, that her eyes went completely dark and her face was distorted. And then she sat down, and she was not happy. She says, we didn't meet for very long that day. She also testified that Taylor is not like a regular inmate. She quickly became top dog due to her ability to get what she wanted. Ms. Parish also described how Taylor seems to thrive in jail in these environments, unlike most people. Taylor apparently also discussed with her how she lost someone, too, in the murder, but would never say Reagan's name during the sessions. She also told her therapist that she was wanting religious people on the jury who knew about mercy and forgiveness. But she mostly wanted carefree, alternative people who wouldn't care what the prosecution said about her. But her biggest thing was that she wanted no women or mothers on the jury. I wonder why. Maybe because a jury member who was a mother would be angry to hear of what another woman did to another mother and that mother's child. Taylor's previous doctor also testified. He testified that Taylor became angry when he would not diagnose her with Ms. And then she went on to see three different doctors to try and get the diagnosis again. Just like Looney Tunes. Now, here's where things get a little bit interesting.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

If.

[Podcast Host]

I mean, they're already interesting, but you get what I'm saying. The next person to testify, and this was a major person on the stand, was Taylor's jailhouse girlfriend, Lana Addison, who we talked about earlier. Earlier, Alana immediately broke out in hives when she got on the stand, and she mentioned how nervous she was. I'm guessing she was probably pretty fearful. When Lana met Taylor, she had no clue what she was actually in jail for. They became quick friends and would write notes back and forth to each other. In the notes, Taylor dove into her version of the crime. Now, we all know her version is not the true version, but Lana didn't know know that. And one of the most notable things that Taylor told Lana during her schemes was that hearing Hannah's voice jogged her memory because that was the voice she had heard when she was drugged and taken to Reagan's house. I mean, how far can these lies go? Because, remember, Hannah is the person she was trying to frame for this. So now she's saying, once I heard her voice, once we were in jail, I remembered that was her at the house, that was her who drugged me, and that that was her who killed Reagan.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

It's crazy.

[Podcast Host]

The story Taylor mostly stuck to with Lana was that she was going to hang out with her friend the morning of the murder. She got up early, got gas at Walmart, and Wade called her, saying that an Insurance adjuster was coming for the fire, so that she needed to let the dogs out. Taylor told Lana that on her way home, she saw a car pulled over on the side of the road with flashing lights. She said that she stopped to ask if everybody was okay and that the last thing she remembered was being drugged. She later claimed that she was put into Wade's car and that she knew it was Wade's car by the smell. She said that she was in and out because she was drugged, but when she woke up, she was in a carport or a garage. She continued switching narratives, but the gist is that she saw Reagan being attacked and that Reagan asked her, could you please help my daughter? Taylor claimed that's when she remembered that she had a scalpel in her car. Yeah, coincidentally, conveniently so. Lana was obviously questioning this by this point and asked Taylor how she knew that her car was there. And Taylor had an immediate answer of, I just guessed it. Taylor told Lana that while she was cutting the baby out, Kinley, who is Reagan's oldest daughter, came out. Taylor said she yelled at Kenleigh to go back into her room room and then never saw her again. She said the baby's foot popped out first, but her umbilical cord was wrapped around her neck and that Braxland was blue. Taylor then said she held Braxland up to Reagan with tears streaming down her face like a hero, and said, look, here's your baby girl. Look, we did it. Here's your baby girl. Taylor then told Lana that Regan smiled before taking one last breath. Literally, like a movie scene. Like she's the hero who delivers this baby. Then Reagan takes her last breath and passes away. She said that she tried doing cpr, but it wasn't working, so that's when she ran out the door. Lana questioned her on why she didn't just call 911. And Taylor told Lana that she didn't know she had her phone until it slipped out from under the seat and hit her in the foot. So let's just pause here and talk about the inconsistencies here. If. If Taylor was really drugged, how would she ever be able to drive after the fact? If she didn't think she had her phone, why didn't she just run outside screaming? The Hancocks lived in a residential area, so surely someone would have hurt her. Her stories, clearly, just once again, do not add up. Lana went on to testify how Taylor said that other perpetrators were gangster members and that Hannah had confessed to the crime. Remember, Hannah's the mentally ill inmate that she was trying to frame and Lana believed her because like most of us, it's hard to imagine one person can come up with such a crazy story.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

If it's that crazy, it has to be true, right?

[Podcast Host]

I mean, it's just bananas. She went on to testify about the documents that she was in possession of. She said, when I learned what she was actually in there for and what was was at stake, I had a confession in detail and names floating around and it scared me. So I called my mother and asked to be contacted because I didn't want that in my hands. True or not true, I did not want any part of it. So that's one inmate and girlfriend's testimony. Let's talk about some other. Phyllis Dawson also testified she was that one who had the 10 page document and that puzzle sudoku book with instructions for the detective. She testified about an agent coming to her house asking if she had anything that Taylor had given her in jail. She initially said no, but once they told her that she could be charged as an accessory, she said, there it

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

is, there it is, here's everything, and

[Podcast Host]

handed it all over. Shauna Ray also testified, if you remember from earlier, Taylor wanted Shauna Rae to copy the documents in her own handwriting. But Shauna Rae wouldn't do that and instead told authorities, I feel that Taylor will try and claim insanity. But to me this just showed the level of manipulation that she is willing to go through. She is constantly trying to put trustees into her schemes. She also testified that when Taylor found out is when her relationship with Taylor got bad. Taylor apparently tried to implicate her in a made up plot to have Taylor killed in jail. Just pure dramatic, insane telenovela like I said. And once again discussing the lengths that she will go to when she feels betrayed. So let's talk about that letter that Taylor sent to the FBI because this letter was also shown in her sentencing period. In her letter, Taylor said, I'm reaching out to correspond with someone within the federal bureau to offer my services in exchange for my own help. For the last year, I have been mingling with many different types of criminals. Part of this is for me and my future, or what's left of it. The other half is my obligation to her. Or maybe I'm just mad as a mfer because I'm going down for something I didn't do. I've accepted that. But being a part of and seeing what unfolded and being unable to change the outcome, that's something I'll never get over because I can't understand it. Then she went on to say that she wanted to work for them on the inside and that she can play sexual mind games with men or women, and that she is manipulative. The ding, ding, ding. The only truthful thing you've probably ever said in your entire life, Taylor. She said that she runs the jail and that nobody crosses her. She went on to say, I have a way of dissecting into a delicate balance of the mind. Knowing it, connecting to it and to them. It makes me good at what I do. In a year, I've allowed myself time to help, educate myself.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Profiling.

[Podcast Host]

What motivates a criminal. My favorite are the murders and their proxy. Your job is to follow up, looking into, monitor, correspond, pursue avenues. And through all of this, you put together a theory. You look at this as a problem which is meant to be solved, and that may very well be true. But the way you measure it, cut and fit the pieces together until it works works the way you want it to work isn't how it always truly happened. Guys, okay, this letter was never actually sent, and it was found in her cell, but my mind is actually blown. The last thing that she should ever want is to have any sort of contact with the FBI. If she was smart, she'd try and stay far away from them based on who she is as a human being. But I'm guessing she, like, read those murder books and thought she was a profiler, and, like, it's just like, did you think you could manipulate the FBI, too? It's one thing to manipulate, you know, a normal layperson. It's another to manipulate and get employed by the FBI. Now we get to one of the saddest parts of the sentencing period, and that was when the medical examiner, Dr. Stephen Hastings, who did Bracklin's autopsy, took the stand. He spoke on his findings and how he found two fingernails embedded in the placenta. The fingernails had purple glitter on them, and they were Reagan's fingernails. So in his professional opinion, the nails were consistent with Reagan being alive during the forceful extraction, as he called it. And not just that, but he came to the conclusion that she was actually holding onto the placenta as a way to keep her baby safe and not. Not be extracted. He said that the reason Braxland died was because of the traumatic extraction, which caused a hemorrhage beneath the scalp. He said that Braxton was born alive, but died with her manner of death being homicide. And it is truly just so horrifying and sad to think about how hard Reagan fought in those moments, both for herself, but also for her daughter, holding onto the placenta, gripping it as you're being cut open. And remember that story that Taylor told about being a hero and how she took the baby and Reagan had her last breath? No. She is anything but a hero. She is a monster. The true hero is Reagan with her determination and love for her baby girl. That was proved by this medical examiner. After the state rested, it was now the defense's turn to try and show why Taylor did not deserve the death penalty. And Taylor showed up happy and ready to go. The first person on the stand for the defense was of course her enabling mother. She started talking about Taylor's childhood, saying that Tyler was in competitive cheerleading, basketball and baseball in elementary school, that she was a great student. But how? Apparently in third grade, Taylor started having stomach pains and said her stomach was always in knots.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

So her mom said that.

[Podcast Host]

Come to find out, she had a teacher who wasn't giving her any feedback and that's what made her stomach in knots. So my first thought when I heard this is like for the love of all things good, is this woman really trying to use a teacher from the third grade who didn't give feedback to this third grade student as an excuse for part of the reason as to how Taylor got where she is now? Are we actually being serious here? Shawna then spoke about her divorce with Taylor's father, Mark, when Taylor was 12 years old. Initially, the two of them decided it would be best for the adults to go back and forth from the house so that the kids could have stability in the house. But Shawna said it didn't last long because she claims that Mark refused to leave the house, which then led to arguments in front of the children. She went on to discuss Taylor's weight issues, citing her grandma as the reason Taylor gained weight. She said that Mark's mother Peggy used food as a comfort and when Taylor stayed there with with her and her father, she tried to comfort 13 year old Taylor with food. Shawna claimed that this led to Taylor being £250 by the time she was 14 and entering high school. But Taylor dropped out of high school at 17 when she got pregnant with her daughter. Shawna also discussed Taylor having a hysterectomy. And this gets a little nutty, guys. Taylor was under anesthesia at the time. The doctor needed a decision made, so Tommy and Shawna told the doctor to do what they needed to do. Later on, Taylor texts her mom asking if she could have her uterus and her mom responded with wtf? Do you think it's Detachable or something. Taylor responded, well, it would be a hysterectomy for you too. No more period, etc. The doctor would take it from you. And yes, it's detachable. Cut here, snip there. The same thing you guys did to mine. Lol. Guys, first of all, scary, but does this also seem like a little bit of foreshadowing to anybody else? I mean, big yikes here. Her mom went on to talk about Taylor's medical issues, but could not even say that she was bamboozled by Taylor's manipulation. It's sad to say that Shauna seems to. To have believed and still seems to believe every word out of Taylor's mouth. The only thing that Shawna said was that if she was normal, we wouldn't be here. Yeah, duh. If your daughter wasn't enabled, if she wasn't a lying, manipulative murderer, nobody would be here. That's for damn sure. When talking about the fake pregnancy, her mom said, there's not much you can do about a fake pregnancy. We didn't come up with a plan. We figured the lie would be exposed and that he would figure it out. If she had come up with a baby, it would not have been hers. That's when the family would have done something and intervened. So let me get this straight. They were just waiting on Taylor to possibly steal a baby and then intervene? As a parent, Barda, your job is to call your kid out on their bs. And she clearly has not taken her role as a parent seriously, it seems. Because how are you just going to go along with something like that and then wait for her to show up with a baby and then be like, oh, you know what, Taylor? What you're doing is wrong. What you're doing is wrong.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

I think you made a mistake here.

[Podcast Host]

Give me a break. Give me a break. But I guess the apple doesn't fall from far from the tree. Now, after all of that, Reagan's Aunt Jamie was actually approached by Taylor's mom in the hallway of the courthouse. Shawna approached her and asked her, what the hell is your problem? Ask this to Reagan's aunt once again. Just kind of like, you know, making other people's problems, not the fact that her daughter killed this girl's niece. It is unreal. I mean, their problem is that they lost a family member and her baby at the hands of this woman's evil, evil daughter. Just unbelievable that Shawna would even ask such a thing. She should have been walking out of that courtroom with her head down and ashamed What a monster. She cried created. In an interesting twist, Taylor's brother Zachary took the stand next. And he was very apologetic to Reagan's family and was truly respectful to the trauma that they are going through. In fact, he testified about having given Taylor a deadline to come clean about her lies. He was the only family member to confront her about her lies. He said he would accept whatever the jury decides, and he doesn't make make any excuses for her behavior. Now it seems like Taylor's mom should take a few lessons from good old Zachary here because he's, like, the only one who is thinking straight here. The defense then brought up a psychiatrist, Dr. Grippon. And this doctor saw Taylor twice for a total of five hours while she was in jail.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

That's it.

[Podcast Host]

But he described Taylor as a pathological liar, saying she had a mix of psych disorders, including narcissism, personality disorder, borderline personality disorder, and being antisocial and histrionic. He said that for Taylor, when the external world is not pleasant, her internal world is pleasant. He said that he could not predict whether or not she would continue to be a danger, but that she would be manipulative and would continue to lie. The last major defense witness to be called was a neurologist from New York. This neurologist tested testified that in his opinion, Taylor has severe lobe dysfunction. He said people with this frontal lobe dysfunction don't have the breaks of inhibition to stop themselves, and impulsivity is great. So they showed MRIs and CAT scans and EEG reports to prove this theory. When discussing her brain in depth, he said her neurons either didn't develop or were lost and that there was no evidence of slowing in her frontal tail temporal lobe. He said that that causes impulsivity and compared to Taylor's impulsivity to a car without brakes, saying she can't stop herself. He also tried to corroborate the Ms. Story, saying that the inflammation in her lobe nerve could indicate Ms. When the prosecutor fired back, showing normal brain scan findings by all of the previous doctors, he said that because they were not looking for the same indicators he was, that they were likely looking for stroke symptoms rather than organic brain dysfunction, and that that's maybe how it was missed. Now we get to closing arguments. Closing arguments began after the defense rested and the state brought back two medical experts who spoke and dispelled much of what the defense was trying to argue. Then the prosecution asked to enter items found inside Taylor's cell as evidence. These items included the sunflower mask, a razor, and a map of the Jail. Unbelievable. Reagan's mom, Jessica, took the stand. During closing arguments, she spoke about the difficulties Kenley has faced since losing her mom. She said that Kinley has told them about things they didn't even know about the murder. And she spoke about Kenley's trauma signs, such as staring at pregnant people to make sure that. That they're not bleeding. Sometimes even asking to see their bellies to make sure. And also not liking the photo in Jessica's locket because Reagan's red shirt looks like blood to Kinley. Just a traumatized little girl, Jessica told jurors. It's never ending right now. Our family has always been very close. I wake up every day, and I think that it's not real. We were happy the way our family was. And now Reagan gone, and it's changed everything. She's gone, number one. And number two, we're distant from other family members that we were close to. And it's just not fair. Watching Kinley grow up without her mommy, that's the worst part. I take all the pain in the world. If I could take it away from her. It's so hard to explain. It's just a void. I have all these people around me, and I'm alone. I'm alone. Jessica ended by saying that Kinley, who is now five, is doing okay and says she has her moments. I don't think any of us can know what's going through her little head. Knowing what I saw, I can't get it out of my head. And I'm an adult. For Kinley to see what she saw, which we don't even know what all she did see, I can't imagine. One of the last things DA Kelly Crisp did was show the entire courtroom a photo of Reagan's lifeless, murdered body. At time the same scene of the crime, gasps could be heard from everyone, and many tears were shed. So the jury was sent to deliberate on Wednesday, November 9, 2022, and within 90 minutes, they came back with a verdict. The verdict was read without any of Taylor's family in the room, and Taylor was sentenced to the death penalty.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Jurors later said that their decision to sentence Taylor to death was unanimous from the very first vote. That's how compelling the evidence was. One juror in particular said that they were struck by Taylor's expression throughout the trial, saying that she always had a scowl on her face and that she never even looked the least bit remorseful. However, that scowl, it was about to get wiped right off Taylor's face, because immediately after receiving the death Penalty, she had to sit through the victim impact statements.

[Podcast Host]

That was the first time anyone has seen any sort of real emotion from Taylor. She could be seen shaking and crying while she was being handcuffed to go sit on the stand and listen to impact speeches. Prosecutors were seen hugging Reagan's family. For them, this was justice. This is what they had worked so hard for. And when Taylor was given the opportunity to speak, she chose not to. Not surprised. It just shows how selfish she is. The judge ordered her to be removed and taken to death row immediately. She was taken in the same van that she wrote in every day to and from the courthouse. Taylor was transported to Mountain View unit, where she sits alongside six other women on death row.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Now, I think a lot of us, myself included, were hoping that Taylor's life on death row would be suck, sucky. That it would be, you know, that

[Podcast Host]

it would be horrible, to put it mildly.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

I mean, after everything that Reagan and Braxlin went through, it's hard not to want or desire at least some tiny scrap of justice, right? Knowing that she's going through something painful, some sort of discomfort or even vengeance, right? But sadly, that does not seem to be happening. In a 2025 interview, Taylor said that her death row cell was like the Hilton.

[Podcast Host]

The Hilton, the hotel chain.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

She even smiled as she was talking

[Podcast Host]

about bonding with other inmates.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And since Taylor is by far the youngest woman on death row, she said that these other inmates have been treating her like the baby of the group and that she even gets special privileges because of it. So I hate to say it, but honestly, I don't think that Taylor has learned one single lesson from any of this. Even now, she still seems to have that same smug attitude. Again, very much like Mackenzie Shurilla. And another reason that I really don't think Taylor Taylor gives a is that in 2025, she and her legal team filed an appeal trying to get her off death row and out of jail. However, their argument, it was kind of strange. In Taylor's appeal, her lawyers argued that the judge should have never allowed the prosecution to bring up evidence about Taylor's weight or her history of cheating in her marriages. According to the defense, that evidence is what unfairly tainted the jury's view of Taylor. And because of that, it meant that she deserved a brand new trial, which I think their perception of her was tainted given the gory graphic details of the case. Not because she cheated in her marriages or because her weight fluctuated at a point in her life. Like, give me a break. The other big issue in the appeal had to do with Braxland's kidnapping. Basically, the reason that Taylor was eligible for the death penalty in the first place was because she committed murder while committing another crime, that other crime being kidnapping. However, Taylor's lawyers argued that Braxland actually had been born stillborn. And if Braxland was stillborn, then legally she couldn't have been kidnapped. And if the kidnapping charge went away, then the capital murder charges would also be knocked down to regular murder charges, which would automatically take Taylor off of death row. So basically, if Braxland wasn't born alive, the entire case collapses. And that's exactly what Taylor's team was trying to argue. But in late 2025, the Texas Court of Appeals ruled against Taylor. On both arguments, the courts pointed to testimony from an EMS worker who said that they were able to get Braxland's heart beating again after she was removed from Taylor's car. Though, as we know, unfortunately, she died later at the hospital. But that meant that Braxland was alive

[Podcast Host]

at some point and.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

And therefore she was definitely kidnapped. Now, as for the comments about Taylor's weight and relationships, the court found they were relevant to the case. It was important that they were stated because Taylor's weight loss was part of her plan to impress Wade. And we know that she later kidnapped Braxland in an attempt to keep Wade. So, because the weight loss and the kidnapping were both tied back to Wade, the court ruled that the evidence was connected and it was valid for trial. So then Taylor's team tried to take the appeal once again step further to the Supreme Court. But In May of 2026, the court declined to even hear the case, which that means that the lower court's decision stands. And with that appeal exhausted, Taylor has no choice but to keep her murdering ass right where it's at on death row. Now, I know that the death penalty is controversial, and that's absolutely fine. We can all have our own opinions. However, mine is that Taylor is exactly where she belongs. To me, anybody who hurts a child, I mean, game over, bye, bye, never see you again, stay locked up for the rest of your life. Part of me wishes that she was in gen pop just because I think she would then get the uncomfiness of it all, rather than like, the privileges that sometimes come with being on death row. But I think especially because she has shown basically no remorse for what she did, I have no remorse for her. And, like, if she ends up being eliminated, like one less person, that is disgusting on the streets, in my opinion. Now, who I do feel forth ho

[Podcast Host]

in all of this is of course

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

Reagan, Homer, Braxlin, and Kinley. Because I can't even imagine the fear that Reagan felt in those final moments. Feeling attacked by somebody you knew, your baby being ripped out of you, knowing your daughter is in the other room and that she's in danger and that she's at risk as well. It is so haunting to think about. I mean, and little Braxland, she had her whole life ahead of her, only to have it slow, stolen in the most brutal way possible. And now Kinley and Homer, they're left behind with these massive holes in their heart and the trauma of everything that

[Podcast Host]

happened and all of the events that unfolded.

[Narrator/True Crime Analyst]

It's just so devastating every single way you look at it. Reagan's family, though, has continued to honor Reagan and Braxland in every way that they can. Keeping their story alive, keeping their memory alive, and advocating for them. Now, I will say I have seen couple, I don't want to say controversial comments, but different opinions since the Netflix doc was released the other day. And I want to know what you guys think. Do you believe any part of Taylor's story, that it was just a fight that then spiraled out of control, or do you think that she truly did plan this the entire time, that this was end game for her? And what about Wade? Do you believe that he truly had no clue that Taylor wasn't pregnant? Because I have so many thoughts about this, this case and I would love to hear yours. So let me know. Either in the comment section on YouTube, Q&A section on Spotify, Apple review section on Apple, let me know. And before you go, don't forget, hit that subscribe button one more time. Hit the like button. It's a free way to support the channel. And if you're listening to the podcast, make sure that you are following. And if you have an extra 30 seconds on Apple, leave a 5 star review. All right, guys, thank you so much for tuning in. I will be back with you on Thursday with headline highlights everything happening this week in the true crime world. And just until then, be nice, don't kill people, protect your family and just watch your back.

[Podcast Host]

All right, bye.