Serialously with Annie Elise – Episode 281: Held Hostage & Tortured for 17 Days in Luxury NYC Brownstone
Release Date: May 29, 2025
Introduction & Podcast Structure
In this episode of Serialously with Annie Elise, host Annie Elise dives deep into multiple gripping true crime cases, providing listeners with detailed analyses and insightful commentary. As with every episode, Annie maintains her conversational and engaging style, ensuring that even those new to the podcast can follow along effortlessly.
CrimeCon Announcement and Giveaway
Annie begins the episode with exciting news about her upcoming appearance at CrimeCon 2025 in Denver, Colorado, scheduled for September 5th through 7th. "I've already shared with you previously that I'm going to be there. I'm going to be doing a live episode from CrimeCon as well," she announces (00:04), inviting listeners to join her at this massive three-day convention. CrimeCon brings together true crime enthusiasts, content creators, experts, victims, families, and guest speakers for a multitude of panels and discussions.
To celebrate her attendance, Annie is giving away two free passes to listeners. She explains the simple steps to enter: "All you have to do is go to the show notes, click the link, and enter to win the two free passes" (25:00). The winners will be announced on June 5th via the Headline Highlights episode and her YouTube community page.
Additionally, she offers a 10% discount on CrimeCon passes using her code "Annie Elise" for those who prefer to purchase tickets early.
Case 1: Heroic 13-Year-Old Fights Attacker in Carmel, California
Annie recounts a remarkable incident involving a 13-year-old girl who was held hostage and tortured for 17 days in Carmel, California. While walking home from school, the young girl encountered a suspicious man lurking between two cars. Her instincts proved correct when he ambushed her, punching her in the face (06:30). Demonstrating extraordinary bravery and self-defense skills learned from three years of Jiu Jitsu training, she fought back fiercely:
"She put him in a headlock, she kneed him multiple times and she even literally like put him in a headlock, spun him around and threw him to the ground." (09:15)
Her quick thinking and martial arts training enabled her to dominate the attacker, ultimately forcing him to flee with a broken ankle. Tragically, the assailant remains at large, and authorities are urging the community to remain vigilant.
Notable Quotes:
- Annie Elise (09:15): "This girl had superhuman strength... That's pretty remarkable."
- Police Statement: Description of the attacker as "about 6ft tall, muscular," with an injured left foot.
Annie emphasizes the importance of self-defense training for young individuals, hoping to inspire others with the girl's courage and resilience.
Case 2: Orphanage Founder Michael Guyenfield Sentenced for Sexual Abuse
The second case delves into the disturbing actions of Michael Guyenfield, the 73-year-old founder of St. Joseph's Home for Boys in Haiti. Initially celebrated for his charitable work, Guyenfield was arrested in January 2024 for illicit sexual conduct, having abused at least six boys under his care over two decades (12:06).
During his three-week trial, victims recounted their harrowing experiences:
"I grew up in the street... we went to people to the police station... nobody believes us because his guys control the whole thing." – Daniel, one of Guyenfield's victims (12:06)
Guyenfield received a 210-year prison sentence, marking a significant victory for the victims and their families. The courtroom's reaction was one of unanimous support for justice:
"When this sentence was announced, the entire courtroom actually stood up and started applauding." – Annie Elise (13:37)
Annie underscores the prolonged struggle for justice faced by the victims and lauds the eventual accountability of Guyenfield.
Case 3: Former Police Chief Grant Hardin Escapes Prison
Annie shifts focus to Grant Hardin, a 56-year-old former police chief in Arkansas serving a lengthy prison sentence. In 2017, Hardin committed first-degree murder by shooting James Appleton through his car window without a known motive (20:10). Subsequently, DNA evidence linked him to a 1997 unsolved sexual assault of an elementary school teacher, resulting in an additional 50-year sentence.
Shockingly, on May 25th, 2025, Hardin escaped from Calico Rock Prison by donning a makeshift police officer uniform. Authorities have described him as:
- Height: 6ft
- Weight: 259 pounds
- Age: 56
"Grant should be considered extremely dangerous and he should definitely not be approached," warns law enforcement (26:30).
Annie speculates on potential factors contributing to his escape, questioning whether his knowledge as a former police chief or inside assistance played a role.
Giveaway Details
Returning to her earlier announcement, Annie provides detailed instructions on how listeners can enter the CrimeCon giveaway:
"Just click the link and it'll take you directly to a form where you answer a couple of short questions, and bam, you are entered to win." (25:45)
Winners will be informed on June 5th through multiple channels, ensuring transparency and accessibility.
Case 4: Kim Kardashian Jewelry Heist Comes to Trial Closure
Annie revisits the high-profile case of Kim Kardashian's jewelry heist during the 2016 Paris Fashion Week. After being held at gunpoint and robbed of millions in jewelry by a group dubbed the "Grandpa Robbers," the trial has concluded with eight out of ten defendants found guilty (27:00).
Despite the gravity of the crime, the sentencing was criticized as lenient:
"They were all sentenced to either three to eight years in prison. And all of the sentences got suspended due to the time that the defendants had already served in jail." – Annie Elise (28:00)
Kim Kardashian expressed gratitude for the pursuit of justice and her hope for healing:
"I believe in second chances... Tell me what you think, but wanted to at least give you... the final resolution of that case." – Kim Kardashian's Lawyer (29:00)
Annie reflects on the disparity between the severity of the crime and the resulting sentences, highlighting ongoing debates around criminal justice reform.
Case 5: New York Subway Assault – Good Samaritan Beaten and Robbed
Annie reports a tragic incident on a New York City subway, where a 61-year-old man attempting to de-escalate a confrontation between two riders was brutally assaulted. The attacker, approximately 6ft tall and wearing a black vest over a yellow hoodie, knocked the Good Samaritan unconscious and subsequently robbed him (29:30).
A second assailant then stole additional items from the incapacitated victim. The victim remains in critical but stable condition in the hospital, while the perpetrators remain at large.
Notable Quotes:
- Annie Elise (29:30): "This man literally tried to step in, be a good Samaritan... but in return, he gets beat up and then robbed twice."
Annie expresses her hope for the victim's recovery and urges vigilance within the community to prevent such senseless violence.
Case 6: Italian Tourist Held Captive and Tortured in NYC Brownstone
The centerpiece of this episode is the harrowing story of a 28-year-old Italian tourist, who was held hostage and tortured for 17 days by crypto investor John Waltz in a luxury Manhattan brownstone. The victim initially flew to New York to meet with his business partners, only to be abducted on May 6th, 2025 (30:00).
During captivity, the victim endured:
- Physical abuse: Beatings, electric shocks, gunshots to the head, leg cuts with a chainsaw.
- Psychological torture: Threats against his family, forced drug use, and restrained movements.
- Technological control: An Apple AirTag placed around his neck to prevent escape.
After nearly three weeks, the victim managed to flee by deceiving Waltz about accessing his Bitcoin password. Upon escaping, a traffic officer assisted him, leading to Waltz's immediate arrest. However, Waltz's business partner remains unidentified and free.
Notable Quotes:
- Witness Daniel (27:46): "I saw like a guy in a white robe and handcuffs come out..."
- Vendor in Soho (29:13): "Everyone are very happy passing by and having coffee ice cream... we really don't know."
Annie details the extensive evidence found at the residence, including Polaroid photos of the torture, drugs, and bloodstains. Neighbors were oblivious to the atrocities occurring behind closed doors, highlighting the façade of wealth and normalcy in affluent areas.
She ponders the motives behind Waltz's actions, given his substantial wealth:
"I guess that shows money doesn't solve all your problems. You can still just be sick in the head and twisted." (29:40)
The investigation continues, with John Waltz facing severe charges that could land him 15 to life on conviction, while his accomplice's role remains unclear.
Other Updates & Patreon Promotions
Annie provides updates on other cases covered in recent episodes, including:
- Diddy Trial Recap: Analyzing major testimonies and allegations.
- Karen Reed Trial Recap: Offering courtroom insights from her firsthand observations in Boston.
- Extra Deep Dives: Available exclusively for Apple Podcast and Patreon subscribers, including a fresh case about a couple's tragic demise linked to SpaceX endeavors.
She promotes a 40% discount on annual subscriptions for additional content, urging listeners to support the podcast through Patreon.
Conclusion
Annie wraps up the episode with her signature blend of warmth and caution:
"Until then, guys, be nice. Don't kill people. Don't go to any freak offs. Don't hang out at the Waterfall Grill in Canton. Just be a good human and watch your back and don't go on Tinder. Or if you do, take a friend with you." (31:30)
Thanking her audience, she reiterates the importance of vigilance, community awareness, and personal safety in navigating the often dark and unpredictable world of true crime.
Key Takeaways:
- Community and Awareness: Highlighting the importance of being vigilant and prepared for unforeseen dangers.
- Justice and Accountability: Celebrating victories in holding perpetrators accountable while acknowledging the challenges faced by victims.
- Impact of Training and Resilience: Showcasing how skills like martial arts can empower individuals to protect themselves.
- The Facade of Normalcy: Examining how appearances can mask heinous crimes, as seen in affluent communities.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps:
- Annie Elise (00:04): "If you've been looking for someone to chat all things true crime with you and a community that’s just as curious as you are - welcome, we're happy you're here!"
- Daniel (12:06): "Nobody believes us because his guys control the whole thing."
- Daniel (27:46): "He didn't look concerned... he didn't look worried or anything like that."
- Vendor in Soho (29:13): "Everyone are very happy passing by and having coffee ice cream, really handy."
For detailed information and to enter the CrimeCon giveaway, visit the show notes of this episode.