Serialously with Annie Elise | Episode 299 Summary

Title: Ritualistic Sex Cult, Murderer Left Note Behind, & Ex-Boyfriend Snaps
Release Date: July 17, 2025
Hosted By: Annie Elise (10 to LIFE & Audioboom Studios)

Introduction

In Episode 299 of Serialously with Annie Elise, Annie delves into several harrowing true crime cases that have recently surfaced or evolved. The episode primarily focuses on three major stories: the gruesome murders committed by Sam Haskell, the tragic case of Marissa DiNapoli, a bizarre murder involving a note, and disturbing allegations against a police chief involving ritualistic abuse.

Case 1: Sam Haskell – A Family Slaughter and Its Aftermath

Annie begins with the chilling story of Sam Haskell, whose heinous actions turned his family home into a scene of horror.

• Background: Sam, portrayed as a spoiled individual benefiting from his father's Hollywood connections, failed to contribute meaningfully to his family. In contrast, his wife May, a 37-year-old dedicated mother of three, and her supportive parents were the pillars of the household.

• The Murders: On November 6, 2023, Sam murdered his wife and her parents. The following day, he attempted to dispose of the bodies by hiring day laborers, claiming the bags contained rocks and Halloween decorations. Suspicious workers discovered the bags were filled with human remains and alerted authorities, but Sam had already fled, captured on surveillance cameras disposing of the remains.

  Annie Elise (12:34): "He killed his wife, he killed his wife's parents...last week he pulled the ultimate coward move."

• Evidence and Arrest: Upon investigation, the police found blood, weapons, and a Home Depot receipt indicating premeditation. Sam was arrested with a blood-soaked knife, substantial cash, and a one-way ticket to Japan in his possession.

• Suicide and Aftermath: Just days before his preliminary hearing, Sam was found dead in his jail cell, leaving behind a note. His lawyers claimed it was to "end the chaos," but Annie criticizes this act as a cowardly escape from justice.

  Annie Elise (28:15): "He could have just gotten a divorce. He could have left her, the grandparents...now these poor kids don't have their grandparents, their mother."

• Impact: Sam's actions left three young children orphaned and deprived May's parents of justice. The case underscores the devastating consequences of unchecked manipulation and the failure to address red flags.

Case 2: Marissa DiNapoli – Betrayal and Tragedy

Next, Annie discusses the tragic murder of 18-year-old Marissa DiNapoli by her ex-boyfriend, highlighting failures in the investigative process.

• Background: Marissa, in a toxic relationship with 20-year-old Martin, was last seen on June 28 after texting her family about staying at a friend's house. Ring camera footage showed a heated argument between her and Martin, capturing his agitation and her tension.

  Annie Elise (13:29): "Why would you text your ex? I didn't."

• Disappearance and Discovery: Marissa's phone ceased activity near Anderson Lake, and she failed to return to her job or home. Her family reported her missing, but initial police response was lackluster, dismissing immediate suspicions around Martin despite Marissa's expressed fears.

• Murder and Arrest: Two days later, Marissa's body was found near the lake, stabbed five times. Martin was charged with first-degree murder after attempting to flee to Mexico but was apprehended by U.S. Marshals.

  Annie Elise (25:42): "It is incredibly frightening that somebody can be that evil and that violent at such a young age."

• Current Status: Martin awaits his preliminary hearing on September 9th. The case highlights systemic issues in responding to domestic threats and the tragic cost of delayed action.

Case 3: Florida Woman’s Vengeful Murder with a Cryptic Note

Annie shifts to a bizarre case involving a Florida woman accused of murdering a man with a hammer and leaving a disturbing note.

• The Crime Scene: On July 2, police discovered the body of 41-year-old Waduda Woodley, beaten to death with blunt force trauma. A white sheet with the message "pedo touches children" was found on his chest, adding a chilling layer to the crime.

  Annie Elise (34:43): "The words 'pedo' immediately reframes this entire crime... it sounds like he was controlling, manipulative, and jealous."

• Accused’s Claim: Jurnee Mcrew, the alleged perpetrator, claims Woodley had been sexually grooming her since she was eight. She recounts initiating contact to seek revenge, ultimately leading to the violent confrontation.

• Legal and Moral Implications: Annie reflects on the complexities of vigilante justice, questioning whether personal trauma justifies extreme actions.

  Annie Elise (41:25): "Does vigilante justice ever get a get out of jail free card? I mean, does it ever, right?"

• Current Status: Jurnee is set to appear in court on July 24th. The case remains contentious, raising debates about rightful retribution versus criminal actions.

Case 4: David – The Nurse Practitioner’s Dark Deeds

Annie covers a case involving a 49-year-old nurse practitioner, David, who abused his professional position to manipulate and harm a patient.

• Background: Despite being married, David engaged in an unethical affair with a 27-year-old patient, falsely presenting his impending divorce to gain trust.

• The Scheme: In January 2024, after the patient disclosed her pregnancy, David surreptitiously administered misoprostol during intercourse, causing her to miscarry without her consent.

  Annie Elise (36:31): "He is the most manipulative person I've ever met... He used me for his own personal gain."

• Exposing the Truth: The patient discovered the tampered pills after experiencing severe cramps and bleeding, leading her to seek medical help where the truth came to light.

• Legal Proceedings: David was arrested for violating a protective order but was controversially released on a $500,000 bond. In court, his remorse seemed insincere, and his minimal sentence raised questions about justice.

  Court’s Statement (36:48): "Sometimes your character isn't about what you do when people are watching. In this case, your public persona was completely different from the man that this victim knew."

• Impact: The case highlights systemic failures in protecting victims and ensuring accountability, especially when perpetrators hold positions of trust and authority.

Case 5: Courtney Tamagni Accuses Police Chief of Ritualistic Abuse

The most disturbing segment involves Courtney Tamagni's allegations against her father, Scott, the police chief of Leonia, NJ, and a purported satanic cult.

• Allegations: Courtney claims that from the age of three, she and her sisters were subjected to decades of satanic ritual abuse, including sexual assaults, animal burnings, and other horrific acts orchestrated by her father and community members.

  Courtney Tamagni (40:08): "We would go into the woods and we would play games, which were not games... you were always going to be hit."

• Community and Legal Response: The accused, including Scott and neighbor Keith Slevin, vehemently deny the allegations, with Keith filing a defamation lawsuit against Courtney. Scott’s attorney questions Courtney’s mental health, attempting to discredit her claims.

• Support and Controversy: Despite the outlandish nature of the claims, several community members and Courtney's mother support her, indicating deep familial and societal rifts.

  Annie Elise (42:12): "Courtney and her sisters deserve peace and answers... I'm curious to see how the courts handle this."

• Public Opinion: The case has polarized listeners, with debates over the credibility of Courtney’s testimony, the existence of such cult activities, and the potential misuse of power by law enforcement officials.

• Current Status: As investigations continue, Annie expresses uncertainty and emphasizes the need for the truth to emerge, acknowledging the complexity and gravity of the allegations.

Conclusion

Episode 299 of Serialously with Annie Elise presents a series of disturbing true crime cases that underscore themes of manipulation, betrayal, and systemic failures in justice. Annie not only narrates these stories with emotional depth but also prompts listeners to reflect on broader societal issues related to power, accountability, and the quest for justice.

Notable Quotes:

• Annie Elise on Sam Haskell's Case (28:15): "He could have just gotten a divorce. He could have left her, the grandparents...now these poor kids don't have their grandparents."

• Annie Elise on Marissa DiNapoli (25:42): "It is incredibly frightening that somebody can be that evil and that violent at such a young age."

• Annie Elise on Jurnee Mcrew's Actions (34:43): "The words 'pedo' immediately reframes this entire crime... it sounds like he was controlling, manipulative, and jealous."

• Courtney Tamagni Testimony (40:08): "We would go into the woods and we would play games, which were not games."

Upcoming Content: Annie hints at deeper dives into certain cases and upcoming live shows on the East Coast, encouraging listeners to engage and participate in discussions surrounding these complex and emotionally charged cases.

Note: This summary omits advertisement segments and focuses solely on the core true crime content discussed in the episode.