Podcast Summary: Sherlock Holmes Short Stories

Episode: The Adventure of the Reigate Squire: Part One

Host & Narrator: Hugh Bonneville

Date: December 18, 2025

Episode Overview

In this suspenseful installment of Sherlock Holmes Short Stories, Hugh Bonneville narrates the first part of "The Adventure of the Reigate Squire." Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson escape to the English countryside for Holmes’ health, only to land amid a baffling local crime wave involving burglary, murder, and cryptic clues. The story unfolds through atmospheric narration, lively dialogue, and Holmes’ trademark deductive brilliance as he faces one of his most peculiar cases yet.

Key Discussion Points and Story Developments

1. Holmes’ Exhaustion and the Promise of Rest

• [00:33 – 02:00]
  • Following intense investigations across Europe, Holmes is unwell and plagued by depression. Watson brings him to Surrey for recuperation at Colonel Hayter’s residence, hoping that rest and peaceful country air will restore his health.
  • Quote: “Even the triumphant issue of his labours could not save him from reaction after so terrible an exertion… I found him a prey to the blackest depression.” — Watson/Hugh Bonneville [00:56]

2. Setting the Scene: Rural Surrey and Recent Crimes

• [02:00 – 04:30]

  • The tranquility is quickly disturbed by talk of a recent break-in at the house of local landowner Mr. Acton, foreshadowing trouble ahead.

  • Colonel Hayter recounts the odd assortment of items stolen—books, candlesticks, twine—suggesting the burglars took anything at hand.

  • Holmes is curious but Watson cautions him to rest.

  • Quote:

    • Colonel Hayter: “Old Acton, one of our county magnates, had his house broken into last Monday. No great damage done, but the fellows are still at large.” [03:20]
    • Holmes: “The county police ought to make something of that… Why, it is surely obvious that—” [04:00]

3. Shocking News: Murder at the Cunningham Estate

• [07:17 – 09:00]
  • The following morning, the Colonel’s butler brings news of a murder at the nearby Cunningham estate: the coachman, William, was shot dead while confronting a burglar.
  • Holmes immediately senses a connection between the Acton burglary and this murder, challenging assumptions about rural safety.
  • Quote:
    • Butler: “It was William the coachman. Shot through the heart, sir, and never spoke again.” [07:42]

4. The Cunningham–Acton Feud and Motive

• [09:00 – 10:20]
  • Colonel Hayter explains an ongoing legal dispute between the Cunninghams and Acton, draining their wealth and potentially generating resentment.
  • Holmes theorizes a local perpetrator could be at work, targeting the area’s two grand estates.

5. Inspector Forrester Arrives

• [10:20 – 13:00]

  • Inspector Forrester visits, seeking Holmes’ aid. He provides details:

    • William was killed interrupting a burglary.
    • Both Mr. Cunningham and his son Alec were present and glimpsed the fleeing assailant.
    • A torn scrap of paper, possibly part of an appointment note, was found gripped in William’s hand.

  • Holmes is instantly absorbed.

  • Quote:

    • Inspector Forrester: “There’s no doubt it is the same party in each case. The man was seen... but he was off like a deer after the shot that killed poor William.” [11:32]
    • Holmes: “This writing is of extraordinary interest… These are much deeper waters than I had thought.” [12:40]

6. Holmes’ Immediate Interest and First Theories

• [13:00 – 15:18]

  • Holmes surmises the person who wrote the note is intimately connected to the crime and reasons about how the scrap may have been torn free during the fatal struggle.

  • He is energized and requests to visit the scene with the Inspector, leaving Watson and the Colonel behind. Holmes’ illness, it seems, is already forgotten when a mystery appears.

  • Quote:

    • Holmes (excitedly): “There is something in it which fascinates me extremely. If you will permit me, Colonel, I will... step round with the inspector to test the truth of one or two little fancies of mine.” [15:10]

7. Holmes’ Behavior at the Scene: Method or Madness?

• [15:46 – 18:30]
  • Later, Inspector Forrester returns, reporting that Holmes is acting oddly—restless, excitable. Watson reassures him: “I have usually found that there was method in his madness.” [16:44]
  • The group heads to the crime scene, meeting Holmes outside, who proclaims: “The matter grows in interest, Watson; your country trip has been a distinct success. I have had a charming morning.” [17:27]
  • Holmes shares his findings:
    • The body suffered a revolver wound.
    • The Cunninghams pointed out where the suspect escaped.
    • William’s mother is too feeble to provide useful testimony.
    • The note with the time of death is likely critical—Holmes stresses its role in fishing out the criminal.

8. At the Crime Scene: Clues and Confrontation

• [18:30 – 22:30]

  • Holmes, Watson, the Colonel, and the Inspector tour the Cunningham estate, retracing events:

    • Where young Alec saw the struggle.
    • The route taken by the assailant.
    • The achingly limited physical evidence.

  • The Cunninghams themselves make a brief appearance, with Alec casting doubts on Holmes’ legendary reputation.

  • Suddenly, Holmes collapses dramatically—eyes rolling, body writhing in agony—much to everyone’s shock.

  • Quote:

    • Alec Cunningham (taunting): “Still at it then? I thought you Londoners were never at fault. You don’t seem so very quick after all.” [21:12]
    • Holmes: “You must give us a little time… You’ll want it.” [21:20]
    • Inspector: “Good heavens, Mr. Holmes, what is the matter?” [22:09]
    • Narrator: “My poor friend’s face had suddenly assumed the most dreadful expression… with a suppressed groan, he dropped on his face upon the ground.” [22:13]

Most Memorable Moments & Quotes

• “Even the triumphant issue of his labours could not save him from reaction after so terrible an exertion… I found him a prey to the blackest depression.” — Watson/Hugh Bonneville [00:56]
• “It was William the coachman. Shot through the heart, sir, and never spoke again.” — Butler [07:42]
• “This writing is of extraordinary interest… These are much deeper waters than I had thought.” — Holmes [12:40]
• “I have usually found that there was method in his madness.” — Watson [16:44]
• “The matter grows in interest, Watson; your country trip has been a distinct success. I have had a charming morning.” — Holmes [17:27]
• “My poor friend’s face had suddenly assumed the most dreadful expression… with a suppressed groan, he dropped on his face upon the ground.” — Narrator [22:13]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Holmes’ ill health and departure for Surrey: [00:33-02:30]
• Initial discussion of Acton burglary: [03:15-04:40]
• Butler announces murder at Cunningham’s: [07:17-09:00]
• Inspector Forrester’s entrance and first details: [10:20-13:00]
• Holmes’ first investigation, analysis of clues: [13:00-15:18]
• Holmes acting ‘queerly’/method in his madness: [15:46-18:30]
• Tour of crime scene, Cunninghams confrontation, Holmes collapses: [18:30-22:30]

Tone & Language

The episode maintains the classic tone of a Holmes mystery: atmospheric, curious, and laced with dry wit. Bonneville’s narration fuels suspense, and Holmes’ lines are incisive and lightly sardonic. Interactions between characters, especially Holmes and Alec Cunningham, are charged with subtle rivalry.

Conclusion

Part One concludes on a cliffhanger, with Holmes dramatically collapsing at the scene of the crime. The investigation remains open, filled with cryptic clues, shadowy motives, and the promise of Holmes’ deductive prowess—should he recover in time.

Next time: Promised themes include Holmes’ illness affecting his work, a dramatic revelation, and the unravelling of a dastardly plot involving a mysterious piece of handwriting.
To listen early or ad-free, subscribe to Noiser+.