Shift Key with Robinson Meyer: "Why the Rest of the World Is Buying Chinese EVs"

Date: December 10, 2025
Host: Robinson Meyer (Heatmap News Executive Editor)
Guest: Ilaria Mazzocco (Deputy Director and Senior Fellow, Trustee Chair in Chinese Business and Economic Studies, CSIS)
Theme: Exploring the global rise of Chinese electric vehicles (EVs), their impact on developing and middle-income countries, and the resulting shifts in industrial policy, climate policy, and economic strategy.

Episode Overview

This episode dives deep into the spread of Chinese EVs across developing and middle-income countries worldwide. Host Robinson Meyer speaks with Ilaria Mazzocco, a leading expert on Chinese industrial and climate policy, about how nations are responding to the surge of affordable, high-tech Chinese EVs. The discussion covers the motivations behind adopting (or resisting) these vehicles, the role of local vs. foreign production, the implications for climate goals and industrial policy, and the larger questions this moment raises for the global auto industry and decarbonization efforts.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Global Expansion of Chinese EVs

• Chinese EV makers like BYD, Goshen, and Great Wall are rapidly gaining footholds in markets across Latin America, Asia, and Africa—countries like Costa Rica, Brazil, India, South Africa, and Mexico (01:28).
• This surge is displacing vehicles from Western and local manufacturers, forcing a rethinking of economic and energy policies in recipient countries (01:28–02:30).
• Quote [03:40]: “The Chinese EV industry is huge...at the technological frontier...this is the first time in post-war history essentially that another country has leapt ahead of the U.S. in a high tech industry when that country was not in the Western security umbrella.”
  — Robinson Meyer

2. How Countries Are Responding

a. Small Importer Nations

• Many smaller economies (e.g., Costa Rica, Ethiopia, Nepal) have always imported cars and are now shifting their supply to Chinese EVs.
• For these nations, the shift is less about conflict over domestic jobs or industry and more about strategy: lowering oil imports, climate goals, or cost savings (08:10–09:12).

b. Large Emerging Markets: Brazil

• Brazil is a classic case of an emerging market with a significant car manufacturing base, mainly via foreign direct investment (FDI) from global automakers (Volkswagen, Stellantis, GM).
• Initially lowered tariffs on EV imports hoping to accelerate adoption, but the influx of Chinese EVs prompted domestic industry lobbying and led to a phased reimposition of tariffs (16:00–18:37).
• Notably, Chinese automakers are now setting up factories in Brazil to bypass higher tariffs—a "win-win" politically and environmentally (17:06–19:46).
• Quote [18:51]: “A 35% tariff is not going to keep out Chinese EVs.”
  — Ilaria Mazzocco

c. Industrial Policy Tactics: Indonesia

• Indonesia is actively shaping its auto sector, removing tariffs only for companies that commit to local production—forcing EV makers to build Indonesian factories (19:56–21:20).
• This model is also used in Thailand and is part of a broader push to integrate nickel mining and battery manufacturing, capturing more of the EV value chain (21:20–22:48).

d. India’s Unique Approach

• India boasts domestic conglomerates (e.g., Tata, Mahindra) already making cars and entering the EV space, seeking to limit dependency on China while nurturing local innovation (23:32–25:25).
• Indian firms remain reliant on Chinese batteries (LFPs), revealing the difficulty of fully separating from Chinese supply chains (26:07–27:38).

3. The Battery Supply Chain Issue

• Most emerging and developed markets depend on Chinese firms like BYD or CATL for affordable, high-quality batteries—critical to EV competitiveness and cost (29:51–31:16).

• This import dependency raises questions about how much domestic value is really being captured in local EV sectors, even as final assembly occurs locally.

• Quote [29:51]: "If you were to say, ‘we make our own internal combustion cars here, we simply import the engines from Detroit,’...That’s essentially what is happening when countries import batteries."
  — Robinson Meyer

4. Implications for Industrial Policy and Economic Growth

• Historically, building a domestic auto sector was a 'rite of passage' for industrializing nations—a source of jobs, innovation, technological advancement, and export revenue (33:17–34:09).
• The scale of the Chinese EV and battery sector now threatens to undermine this export-led industrialization model for countries outside China.
• For some, the path forward is to attract FDI—Chinese companies building factories locally.
• Quote [35:13]: “If you take away the battery industry—which is probably the more technologically advanced part...all the value-added is there. So [other countries] are just assembling the cars and competing with China that’s making them cheaper and at a larger scale. It’s just not clear if this is going to work out.”
  — Ilaria Mazzocco

5. Geopolitics, National Security, and Climate

• EVs are now at the intersection of climate policy and geopolitics: decarbonization is increasingly bound up with questions of economic dependence on China (46:49–47:23).
• Countries must decide if relying on cheap Chinese technology is politically and strategically sustainable, even when it offers rapid climate benefits.
• Local policies are being shaped as much by national security and industrial ambition as by environmental considerations.

6. The Evolving Role of China in Global Exports

• China is not only the dominant exporter of EVs but has become a leading exporter of internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, working with both domestic Chinese and foreign (Western) brands (38:23–41:24).
• Even countries with robust auto sectors, like Mexico, are seeing a major influx of Chinese-built traditional vehicles as well as EVs.

7. What Comes Next? The World’s Dilemma

• The possible futures: Will more countries raise trade barriers to China to protect their own industries, or will they accept ongoing Chinese leadership in EV technology and adapt their economies accordingly? (41:24–42:20)
• Many countries see attracting Chinese FDI as a pragmatic path: it's politically easier to host Chinese-owned plants than to compete head-to-head as exporters.
• Yet this raises thorny questions about technology transfer, employment, and long-term domestic innovation.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “China just has a comparative advantage clearly in electric vehicles—which is of course funny because there’s been all this industrial policy, it’s been like all this industrial strategy behind it, but, you know, whatever.”
  — Ilaria Mazzocco, laughing ([42:06])

• “If you want to make a cheap car, you need LFP. That’s why Ford sought out that licensing deal with CATL.”
  — Ilaria Mazzocco ([28:14])

• “The automotive sector is just so important and so, so emotionally politically important to so many countries that I just don’t see other countries giving up without a fight.”
  — Ilaria Mazzocco ([42:36])

• “Now, if you want to make rapid progress in sectors like power with renewables or electrification of cars...what you need to do is just import very cheap technology from China. But of course, that comes with a whole slew of issues.”
  — Ilaria Mazzocco ([47:23])

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 01:28: Overview of Chinese EVs’ global impact
• 04:35 – 06:56: Hyper-competition & involution in China; expansion into developing world
• 08:10 – 09:12: Countries that are simple importers (Costa Rica, Ethiopia, Nepal)
• 16:00 – 19:46: Brazil’s EV policy shift from tariff reductions to reimposed barriers; arrival of Chinese factories
• 19:56 – 22:48: Indonesia’s conditional tariff removals; localizing EV production and battery supply chains
• 23:32 – 26:07: India’s domestic industrial strategy and persistent dependency on Chinese batteries
• 29:51 – 31:16: The centrality of battery supply chains to domestic value add
• 33:17 – 35:13: Challenges to the export-led growth model for developing countries
• 38:23 – 41:24: Chinese ICE vehicle exports—beyond Russia, expanding into all of Asia and Latin America
• 46:49 – 47:23: Climate policy now entangled with industrial and trade policy concerning China
• 54:45 – 56:50: Lessons for the U.S.: need for policy stability, investment across the full value chain, a focus on batteries

Final Reflections

Industrial Policy Lessons:
To develop a competitive EV sector, a mix of industrial policy, consistent long-term government support, talent development, full value chain investment (especially in batteries), and clarity around national objectives (industrial, climate, security) is needed.

For the U.S. and Others:
Catching up to China in EVs will not be quick or easy. It requires more than just “throwing money at the problem”—it’s about building ecosystems, technical know-how, and securing supply chains, perhaps in partnership with allies.

Big-Picture Takeaway:
The world is at a crossroads: it must decide how to balance its climate ambitions, industrial self-interest, and economic ties with China. Given the pace of change, these strategic decisions cannot be postponed.

Guest Acknowledgement:
“Thank you so much for joining us on Shift Key. This was great.”
— Robinson Meyer ([58:51])

End of Content Section