Short History Of…: Arthur Conan Doyle
Host: John Hopkins
Production: Katrina Hughes, Kate Simants, Nicole Edmunds, Jacob Booth, Dorry Macaulay, Rob Plummer, Cody Reynolds-Shaw
Composers: Oliver Baines, Dorry Macaulay, Tom Pink
Release Date: June 29, 2025
Introduction to Arthur Conan Doyle
The episode opens in spring 1877 at Edinburgh Medical School, where an 18-year-old Arthur Conan Doyle serves as a clerk to Dr. Joseph Bell. This early exposure to meticulous observation and deduction profoundly influences Doyle’s creation of the legendary detective, Sherlock Holmes.
"Almost a decade later, this clerk, a young man by the name of Arthur Conan Doyle, will remember how Dr. Bell's deductions cut through mystery." [00:36]
Early Life and Education
Born in 1859 in Edinburgh, Doyle navigates a childhood marked by frequent moves and financial instability, described as "genteel poverty." His mother's influence as a storyteller and his time at Stonyhurst College, a strict Jesuit boarding school, shape his imaginative and literary inclinations despite the harsh disciplinary environment.
"He was pretty miserable actually there for a lot of the time." – Historian [07:50]
Medical Career and Adventurous Seas
Doyle pursued medicine at the University of Edinburgh, financing his studies through tutoring and odd jobs. His adventurous spirit led him to serve as a ship's surgeon on the Hope of Peterhead, experiencing the brutal life of a whaling vessel, which later inspired his writing.
"If you read the diary he wrote, it's absolutely fascinating about his experiences there." – Historian [09:37]
After a second stint as a ship's surgeon on the Mayumba, where he nearly succumbs to fever, Doyle establishes his own practice in Southsea. Balancing his medical career with his passion for storytelling, he marries Louisa Hawkins in 1885, finding stability amidst financial struggles.
Creation of Sherlock Holmes
Faced with financial necessity, Doyle sought to create a detective character that stood out from the existing literary figures like Edgar Allan Poe's C. Auguste Dupin and Wilkie Collins' detectives. Inspired by Dr. Joseph Bell’s keen observational skills, Doyle envisioned Sherlock Holmes as a master of logic and deduction.
"He builds that character like no other, with lots of other different influences." – Tim Hubbard [14:42]
In 1887, Doyle publishes "A Study in Scarlet", introducing Holmes and Dr. Watson. Despite mixed initial reviews, the novel marks the beginning of Holmes' enduring legacy.
"He'd only been there a few times and he took out a post office map and I believe he simply looked at the map, closed his eyes and put his finger down and it landed on what was then Upper Baker Street and 221B did not exist." – Historian [16:52]
Rise to Fame and Personal Struggles
The publication of subsequent stories in The Strand Magazine secures a growing readership. However, Doyle's personal life is fraught with challenges, including Louisa’s battle with tuberculosis and the pressures of sustaining his literary success.
In 1893, grappling with creative exhaustion, Doyle attempts to kill off Sherlock Holmes in "The Final Problem", intending to focus on more serious literary pursuits. This decision sparks immense public backlash, illustrating Holmes’ profound impact.
"He never realized just what he had produced with Sherlock Holmes and Watson." – Historian [30:34]
Resurrection of Holmes and Continued Literary Pursuits
Under mounting public pressure, Doyle resurrects Holmes in "The Hound of the Baskervilles" (1901) and "The Adventure of the Empty House" (1903), revealing that Holmes had faked his death to dismantle Moriarty's criminal network. These stories reinvigorate Holmes' popularity, although Doyle remains ambivalent about his creation.
Advocacy and Real-Life Justice
Beyond fiction, Doyle's sense of justice leads him to champion real-life causes, most notably the case of George Edalji. His investigative efforts culminate in a Royal Pardon for Edalji in 1907, highlighting Doyle’s commitment to rectifying miscarriages of justice.
"He believed that communication with the dead is not only possible, but essential to understanding life itself." – Tim Hubbard [40:04]
Spiritualism and Later Years
Doyle's personal tragedies, including the death of his son Kingsley in 1918, deepen his involvement in spiritualism—a movement seeking to communicate with the deceased. His unwavering belief in the supernatural leads to contentious episodes, such as a failed seance with his wife Jean and the famous Cottingley Fairies photographs.
"To Doyle, the photographs offer proof that unseen worlds might exist beyond our own." [43:37]
Despite skepticism and strained friendships, Doyle remains steadfast in his spiritual pursuits until his death in 1930. His final works include the last Sherlock Holmes story, "The Adventure of Shoscombe Old Place" (1927), cementing Holmes’ place in literary history.
Legacy of Arthur Conan Doyle
Arthur Conan Doyle is remembered not only for Sherlock Holmes but also for his diverse contributions as a doctor, campaigner, and advocate for justice. His boundless curiosity and commitment to his beliefs left an indelible mark on literature and society.
"He was a doctor, a campaigner, a war correspondent, a politician. He fought for justice and grieved deeply for those he loved." [52:16]
Doyle’s enduring legacy is epitomized by Sherlock Holmes, whose intellect and deductive prowess continue to inspire and captivate audiences worldwide.
Notable Quotes
- Historian: "He was pretty miserable actually there for a lot of the time." [07:50]
- Tim Hubbard: "He builds that character like no other, with lots of other different influences." [14:42]
- Historian: "He never realized just what he had produced with Sherlock Holmes and Watson." [30:34]
- Tim Hubbard: "He believed that communication with the dead is not only possible, but essential to understanding life itself." [40:04]
- Historian: "He was a doctor, a campaigner, a war correspondent, a politician. He fought for justice and grieved deeply for those he loved." [52:16]
Conclusion
Arthur Conan Doyle’s multifaceted life—from his medical beginnings to his literary triumphs and advocacy—paints the portrait of a man driven by curiosity, justice, and an unrelenting quest for understanding both the seen and unseen worlds. His creation, Sherlock Holmes, remains a testament to Doyle's profound impact on literature and popular culture.
Looking Ahead:
Next week on Short History Of…, explore the enigmatic journey of the Shroud of Turin and its enduring mysteries.
For more engaging histories and stories, subscribe to Noiser+ for ad-free listening and exclusive content at noiser.com/subscriptions.