Sidebar: A Suits Watch Podcast - Episode Summary: "Play the Man"

Introduction

In the December 3, 2024 episode of Sidebar: A Suits Watch Podcast, hosts Patrick J. Adams and Sarah Rafferty delve deep into Season 1, Episode 7 titled "Play the Man" from the hit TV series Suits. This episode is a pivotal moment in the series, featuring the first mock trial that brings the entire Pearson Hardman firm together. Patrick and Sarah share their personal experiences, behind-the-scenes stories, and insightful analysis, making it an engaging listen for both fans and newcomers to Suits.

Episode Overview

"Play the Man," written by Erica Lopez and directed by Tim Matheson, originally aired on August 4, 2011. The episode centers around Mike Ross facing off against Lewis's protégé, Kyle, in a mock trial setting. A significant guest from Harvey Specter's past, Dana Scott (played by Abigail Spencer), complicates the firm's merger negotiations. The episode also marks the return of Jenny, adding layers to Mike's personal and professional life.

Key Discussions and Insights

1. First Mock Trial and Its Impact

   Patrick emphasizes the importance of "Play the Man" as the first of four mock trial episodes, highlighting how it serves as a foundational episode that knits together the Pearson Hardman world. He notes, "the mock trial knits together the Pearson Hardman world. I think it's really fun to get to see everybody in the same room" (07:15).

2. Erica Lopez's Contribution

   The hosts commend Erica Lopez for her exceptional writing, particularly her portrayal of strong female characters. Patrick mentions, "I'm really loving how the device of the mock trial knits together the Pearson Hardman world," attributing this to Lopez's writing skills (07:50).

3. Character Development: Donna Paulsen

   Sarah and Patrick discuss Donna's evolution in this episode, noting how she gains a "surer footing in the ecosystem of Pearson Hardman" and showcases her wit and fearlessness. Patrick shares his admiration, stating, "Donna gets to really joyfully feel like she matters to the firm in a unique way" (07:15).

4. Abigail Spencer's Debut as Dana Scott

   The introduction of Dana Scott is a standout moment. Sarah praises Spencer's performance, describing her entrance as powerful and memorable: "It's just so clear from the first moment" (23:08). The episode also includes a voicemail from Spencer, where she shares her excitement about joining Suits and her experience on set.

5. Mock Trial Dynamics and Humor

   The hosts humorously critique minor continuity issues, such as Sarah's helmet disappearing, and discuss the authenticity of the mock trial scenes. Sarah remarks, "It feels like a very complex and difficult feat, and he [the director] did a really beautiful job" (24:08).

6. Emotional and Ethical Choices

   A significant portion of the discussion revolves around Mike's ethical dilemma during the mock trial. He chooses to lose the case to stay true to his morals, leading to a heartfelt moment between him and Jessica Pearson. Sarah highlights, "This is an episode about people and people changing, and what are they willing to change" (66:35).

7. Behind-the-Scenes Anecdotes

   Patrick and Sarah share personal stories from the set, including Patrick's past experiences working with director Tim Matheson and Sarah's memories of taking headshots for her episodes. These anecdotes provide listeners with a glimpse into the actors' off-screen lives and camaraderie.

Notable Quotes

• Patrick J. Adams: "I'm so excited to dig into Erica's first episode. It is our first episode written by a woman, and obviously she's writing with Aaron." (07:15)

• Sarah Rafferty: "It's a great question, and I think we talked a little bit about it. But what it's making me think now is that Donna is a champion for Mike in this part of him." (64:00)

• Abigail Spencer: "I watched the first episode of Suits and I was like, oh, my God, it's going to be Mad Men for lawyers." (26:44)

• Patrick J. Adams: "Mike wins the case by losing it. In many ways, he wins our hearts by losing the case." (58:29)

Conclusions and Reflections

Patrick and Sarah conclude the episode by reflecting on the profound impact "Play the Man" has on both the characters and the overarching narrative of Suits. They appreciate how the episode balances humor, emotional depth, and character development, making it a standout installment in the series. The hosts express their admiration for the collaborative efforts of the writers, directors, and cast, particularly highlighting Donna and Mike's evolving relationship.

Patrick remarks, "Can I please come work with you again? We love jobs," emphasizing his deep respect for Erica Lopez's writing (70:51). Meanwhile, Sarah shares her pride in being part of such a meaningful project, stating, "I'm just so proud of everyone and honored to be a part of it" (69:16).

Final Thoughts

"Play the Man" serves as a testament to Suits' ability to intertwine personal and professional lives seamlessly, offering viewers a rich blend of legal drama and character-driven storytelling. Patrick and Sarah's insightful analysis not only highlights the episode's strengths but also underscores the show's enduring appeal.

Notable Timestamps

• [07:15] - Discussing the importance of the mock trial and Erica Lopez's writing.
• [23:08] - Introduction of Dana Scott by Abigail Spencer.
• [64:00] - Donna's role as Mike's champion.
• [26:44] - Abigail Spencer's voicemail and experiences.
• [58:29] - Mike's ethical choice in the mock trial.
• [70:51] - Patrick's admiration for Erica Lopez.

Note: Timestamps refer to the podcast transcript's timing.

Timestamps Reference: <a id="timestamp-07:15"></a> 07:15 - Initial discussion on mock trial's significance and Erica Lopez's influence.

<a id="timestamp-23:08"></a> 23:08 - Sarah and Patrick discuss Abigail Spencer's impactful entrance as Dana Scott.

<a id="timestamp-26:44"></a> 26:44 - Playback of Abigail Spencer's voicemail highlighting her joining Suits.

<a id="timestamp-64:00"></a> 64:00 - Analysis of Donna's support for Mike and its implications.

<a id="timestamp-58:29"></a> 58:29 - Reflection on Mike's decision to lose the mock trial ethically.

<a id="timestamp-70:51"></a> 70:51 - Patrick expresses his desire to collaborate again with Erica Lopez.

<a id="timestamp-69:16"></a> 69:16 - Sarah shares her pride and honor in being part of Suits.

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the essence of the "Play the Man" episode as discussed in the podcast, providing listeners with a clear and engaging overview of the episode's key moments and thematic elements.