Transcript
A (0:00)
Welcome to this episode of Sister sidebar with Jill Wine Banks and me, Joyce Vance. You know, we get so many fantastic questions from our listeners here at the SistersInLawpodcast that we don't have enough time to cover all of them in the main show. And on Sisters sidebar, we can dive deeper into the topics you care about the most. Every Wednesday, we'll have a new episode with two or more of the sisters. Just informal, just us hanging out. So you'll still be hearing from all of us. If you have a question for us, and we really mean this, so please do, please email us@sistersinlawolitikon.com or tag us on social media using Sisters in Law so we can answer your most pressing questions and you don't have to just type them out. Your voices are so important that we want to hear them too. So consider emailing us a voice memo using one of your notes apps and we'll play it live on the show. Remember, we love seeing you rocking our Sisters in Law merch. So if you're gonna send us an audio, really get yourself ready for the SistersinLaw experience and pick up some T shirts or sweatshirts@thepolitikon.com merch shop. Now let's get started.
B (1:16)
Joyce. Our first question is an audio question. And I'm really excited that someone knew how to do this. And I think I have finally mastered it. And if I can do a voice memo and send it to someone, then so can everyone else. So please, we love hearing your voice and I'm very excited. Please, I'm encouraging you to get the question that you have to us with your own voice. And today our first question comes from Jessica, and she's from Hillsborough, North Carolina. And here she is her. Her own voice asking Joyce a question. Hello, my name's Jesse Kelly from Hillsboro, North Carolina. I have a question for you. There is reporting that federal agents are taking pictures of protesters and license plates so that they can create a database. First of all, how legal is that? Second of all, if I get on that database, how do I get off?
A (2:16)
Hey, Jesse Kelly, thanks for the question. I think that this is something that we've all seen right there has been in both Minnesota and in Maine, we've seen federal agents turning the cameras on protesters. And it's sort of weird, to be quite honest. There's this one video clip up in Maine where an ICE agent is filming a protester, and she says, what are you doing? And he says, I'm taking your picture. Now you're in our Little database and you're a terrorist, a domestic terrorist. I find that clip to be absolutely chilling. And so your first question is, how legal is this? Look, federal agents are entitled to gather any evidence that they need to assist the jurisdiction of their agency, right? They can gather evidence of crimes or other offenses and it's all fair game. But what they can't do is trample on Americans civil rights. And so there are some databases where agents collect evidence and that's perfectly legitimate, or at least the law allows it. The no Fly List is one example of that. You know, a list of domestic terrorists. I, I would like to see that challenged in court, to be honest. But we are, as we have said so many times, in uncharted territory here. I mean there may be some parallels from the civil rights era and what the FBI did to folks, Martin Luther King and others, and it may be that we'll have to draw on that law to determine the limits of legality. But these are, I think difficult and troubling questions because this is simply not something that we've seen the government engage in for the last few decades, at least not overtly like this. In a non criminal context where people are just exercising their rights and say, not participating in some form of international terrorism or other criminal conduct, you know, how do you get off the list? I'm quite frankly not sure that there's a legal mechanism. I think it would be interesting to see people start foying the government using foia, the Freedom of Information act to try to get information about their status. But of course that comes at a cost, putting yourself on the government's radar screen. I think though that we will see some sort of an effort to challenge this sort of thing just because the evidence is so pervasive that agents are now doing this in Minnesota just in the last couple of days. The agents have been ordered not to engage with protesters. And I'll be interested to see if that will extend to no longer videotaping or photographing them in addition to assaulting them. Lots of moving pieces in this one.
