Podcast Summary: #SistersInLaw – Episode 289: "Bail Us Out"

Date: March 25, 2026
Hosts: Barb McQuade, Jill Wine-Banks
Podcast Series: #SistersInLaw by Politicon

Episode Overview

In this "Sisters Sidebar" edition, Barb McQuade and Jill Wine-Banks field listener questions on pressing political and legal issues. Their insightful conversation covers a range of topics, from bail reform and selective service registration to voting laws, impeachment logistics, and the binding nature of digital terms and conditions. The hosts break down complex issues using real-life analogies and personal experience, while emphasizing the impact of law on everyday lives.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Bail and Pre-Trial Restrictions

Segment: 01:45 – 04:29

• Listener Question: Does bail always come with restrictions, and are the rules flexible?
• Barb McQuade:
  • Bail rules vary widely by jurisdiction and even by county.
  • The federal system's Bail Reform Act typically assumes release unless certain risks exist.
    • Example: A $10,000 unsecured bond that acts as a promise, not upfront cash.
  • Cash bail can disproportionately affect those with fewer financial resources.
    • Quote (Barb, 03:00):
      “If you’re Mark Zuckerberg... $1,000 is nothing. For some people, $1,000 is the same as being detained with no bail whatsoever.”
  • Bail primarily addresses two concerns: public safety and flight risk.
    • Public safety: No bail if there’s danger (e.g., “axe murderer” example).
    • Flight risk: Measures like surrendering a passport or electronic ankle monitors may apply.
  • Jurisdiction, court culture, and the specific judge all play a role in determining restrictions.

Selective Service Registration

Segment: 04:29 – 05:50

• Listener Question: Why do we still have selective service registration if the draft is banned?
• Jill Wine-Banks:
  • Registration is maintained for emergencies where a draft could be reinstituted.
  • Currently, only men are required to register; this is being challenged as discrimination.
    • Quote (Jill, 04:55):
      “There is a lawsuit... saying, that isn’t fair. This is a violation. It’s discrimination on the basis of sex, and I hope they win.”
  • The presence of registration allows rapid response if the U.S. needs to mobilize forces.

Congressional vs. Presidential Authority Over State Voting Laws

Segment: 05:50 – 07:33

• Listener Question: Does Congress have the power to regulate state voting laws? Does the President?
• Barb McQuade:
  • States set their own election methods, but Congress can modify through legislation (e.g., Voting Rights Act).
  • The President has no authority to direct state election laws.
  • The pending “SAVE Act” (requiring additional ID for voting) would only be valid if passed by Congress, not via executive order.
  • Decentralized elections serve as a security feature.
    • Quote (Barb, 07:22):
      “There’s some real wisdom in having the states set these rules, subject to modification by Congress, but out of the hands of the President, who’s got some serious skin in the game.”

Hypothetical: Trump Justice Department Overturning the 2020 Election

Segment: 14:23 – 15:46

• Listener Question: Would Trump serve an unconstitutional third term if the 2020 election were overturned?
• Jill Wine-Banks:
  • The Constitution states no one can be elected more than twice as President.
  • Since Trump wasn’t elected a third time, the question remains hypothetical.
    • Quote (Jill, 14:38):
      “He wasn’t elected to office. He was only elected twice... But if some weird thing happened and he was elected [for a third time], well, then I guess this would be a third election and would be against the Constitution.”
  • Strong assertion that there is no evidence the 2020 election was illegitimate.

Are Digital “Terms & Conditions” Legally Binding?

Segment: 15:46 – 17:23

• Listener Question: Are you legally bound by terms and conditions you don’t read? Is clicking “agree” perjury?
• Barb McQuade:
  • Skipping the fine print is common; it’s not perjury, but users are still bound by the terms.
    • Quote (Barb, 16:51):
      “You blow through them at your own peril. That is how you agree to certain things on social media, for example, giving up your private data.”
  • Terms give social media sites license to collect and sell your data.
  • Law enforcement can now buy data from brokers that users “voluntarily” gave away via these agreements.

What Happens if a President or Cabinet Member Refuses to Leave After Impeachment?

Segment: 17:23 – 19:07

• Listener Question: Who enforces impeachment verdicts if someone refuses to leave office?
• Jill Wine-Banks:
  • There’s no clear legal mechanism for physically removing a non-compliant impeached official; precedent relies on voluntary compliance and party pressure.
  • Draws parallel to Nixon leaving when told he had lost party support.
    • Quote (Jill, 18:24):
      “A conviction on impeachment is the end of it.”
  • Barb injects humor:
    • Quote (Barb, 19:00):
      “Have you met Donald Trump?”
  • Jill acknowledges hopefulness:
    • “I know, it’s my Pollyanna. What can I say?”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On bail fairness:
  “For some people, $1,000 is the same as being detained with no bail whatsoever.” – Barb (03:00)
• On selective service discrimination:
  “There is a lawsuit... saying, that isn’t fair. This is a violation. It’s discrimination on the basis of sex, and I hope that they win.” – Jill (04:55)
• On presidential power over elections:
  “There’s some real wisdom in having the states set these rules... but out of the hands of the President, who’s got some serious skin in the game.” – Barb (07:22)
• On terms and conditions:
  “You blow through them at your own peril.” – Barb (16:51)
• On enforcing impeachment:
  “A conviction on impeachment is the end of it.” – Jill (18:24)

Episode Timestamps

| Topic | Start – End | |---------------------------------------------------|----------------------| | Bail restrictions and intent | 01:45 – 04:29 | | Selective Service registration & the draft | 04:29 – 05:50 | | Who controls voting laws—Congress or President? | 05:50 – 07:33 | | Hypothetical: Overturning 2020, Trump’s “3rd Term”| 14:23 – 15:46 | | Binding nature of online terms & conditions | 15:46 – 17:23 | | Impeachment: What if the official won’t leave? | 17:23 – 19:07 |

Final Notes

• The hosts encourage listener questions, especially audio ones.
• The episode blends humor, candor, and expertise, supporting civic education on the mechanics of the U.S. legal and electoral systems.

(Advertisements and non-content sections have been omitted.)