Small Town Murder Episode #539: Human Snakes – New Florence, Missouri
Hosts: James Pietragallo & Jimmy Whisman
Introduction
In Episode #539 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmy Whisman delve into the mysterious and tragic case of Ben Renick, an exotic reptile dealer from New Florence, Missouri. This episode unravels the unsettling events leading to Ben’s untimely death, initially suspected to involve his own snakes, and the subsequent investigation that uncovers deeper familial and financial intrigues.
Background
The Renick Family
Ben Renick was a prominent figure in the reptile breeding community, running Rennick Reptiles and specializing in designer pythons and other exotic snakes. Born in 1987, Ben grew up on a sprawling 72-acre farm in Montgomery County, Missouri. His father, Frank Renick, was a successful entrepreneur who owned Spectrum Pet Care and formerly owned the Bow Wow Dog Food Company, which was sold to ConAgra. However, in 2011, Frank was indicted for selling unregistered securities and embezzling over $7 million from investors. Facing prosecution, Frank tragically ended his own life by suicide, leaving Ben and his younger brother, Sam Renick, to navigate the aftermath.
Ben's Reptile Business
Ben’s passion for snakes began at a young age, leading him to become a respected snake breeder. His business thrived, catering to a niche market that saw his exotic breeds fetch high prices, some even exceeding $100,000. Ben was known for his meticulous record-keeping and his ability to create unique color combinations and patterns through cross-breeding, earning him the title of a "snake rock star" within the reptile community.
The Murder
Initial Discovery [29:01]
On June 8, 2017, Lindley Renick, Ben’s wife, discovered him dead at his reptile breeding center. The initial fear was that one of his enormous snakes might have been responsible for his death, given the presence of thousands of exotic reptiles in his facility. [29:01] Sam Renick stated, “It must have been a snake,” reflecting the immediate suspicion towards Ben’s own creatures.
Investigation Shifts [30:00]
However, as the Missouri State Highway Patrol delved deeper, evidence began to contradict the snake attack theory. Shell casings were found beneath Ben’s body, indicating he had been shot multiple times. The coroner confirmed that Ben was killed by gunfire, not by a snake. [30:36] Ryan Reynolds (Mint Mobile Ad): "Where's your snake? Ben was murdered, and it wasn’t a snake."
The Suspects
Sam Renick [93:08]
Ben’s older brother, Sam, became a person of interest early in the investigation. Sam inherited Ben’s stake in the reptile business, leading to tensions over control and financial matters. [93:08] Lindley Renick indicated, “I would look at him,” suggesting possible friction between the brothers regarding the estate and business.
Lindley Renick [37:22]
Lindley, a massage therapist and Ben’s wife, had a complex personal life marked by multiple affairs. Her relationships prior to and following Ben’s imprisonment for a severe car accident amplified suspicions about her motives. [37:22] James Pietragallo: "She threw up for it," highlighting the strain in her personal life.
Michael Humphrey [43:04]
Michael Humphrey, a drug dealer and Lindley’s ex-boyfriend, played a pivotal role in the unfolding events. Lindley reconnected with Michael, who later testified against her, claiming she orchestrated the murder together. His cooperation with authorities was instrumental in uncovering the truth. [43:04] Michael Humphrey: "Did you think about it the same way? He thought it was just sex,"
Ashley Shaw [132:43]
Ashley Shaw, Lindley’s coworker and spa manager, was implicated in the murder plot. Ashley received prosecutorial immunity in exchange for her testimony, revealing that she assisted Lindley in poisoning Ben with Percocet-laced shakes before ultimately aiding in the shooting cover-up. [132:43] Ashley Shaw: "We did it," confirming her involvement.
The Trial
Prosecution's Case [136:06]
The prosecution painted Lindley Renick as a cold-blooded murderer driven by financial desperation and personal vendettas. They presented evidence of her affairs, financial troubles, and meticulous planning to eliminate Ben to gain control over the business and estate. [136:06] Prosecutor: "All she's done is deflect and lie throughout the investigation," emphasizing her manipulative behavior.
Defense's Case [140:15]
Lindley’s defense argued that she was a victim of circumstances, dealing with an abusive marriage and mental trauma. They attempted to shift blame onto Michael Humphrey, suggesting that he acted independently and that Lindley was not the primary orchestrator. However, evidence and testimonies from Ashley Shaw and Michael Humphrey undermined this defense. [140:15] Defense Attorney: "She is not planning a murder; she's planning a divorce."
Verdict and Sentencing [163:52]
After deliberating for 12 hours, the jury convicted Lindley Renick of second-degree murder, sentencing her to 16 years in prison—far less than the life without parole she might have expected for first-degree murder. The judge expressed frustration, noting the inadequacy of her sentence given the severity of her actions. [163:52] Judge: "You're awfully lucky, ma'am. You just..."
Aftermath
Appeals and Legal Actions [175:26]
Both Michael Humphrey and Lindley Renick pursued appeals. Humphrey’s appeal focused on the admissibility of Brandon Blackwell’s testimony, arguing it was hearsay and improperly influenced Lindley’s conviction. Lindley initiated a lawsuit against her ex-boyfriend Brandon Blackwell, accusing him of making false statements that led to her wrongful imprisonment and loss of custody over her children. This lawsuit aimed to hold Blackwell accountable and seek damages for defamation.
Community Impact [65:44]
Ben Renick’s death had a profound impact on the local community and the reptile breeding industry. Friends and industry peers mourned his loss, establishing a snake breed named after him—Renick Ghost—as a tribute to his legacy. [65:44] Dave Kaufman: "He made a new breed of snake, Dave, the ultimate snake man."
Financial and Personal Consequences [169:34]
The financial fallout from the case was significant. Lindley sold the family farm and Ben’s reptile business for $740,000, which caused further rifts within the family. Sam Renick grappled with the loss of both his parents and brother, as well as the management of the farm and its associated financial burdens.
Conclusion
The tragic case of Ben Renick in New Florence, Missouri, serves as a chilling reminder of how personal vendettas and financial desperation can culminate in heinous crimes, even in seemingly quiet small towns. Through meticulous research and engaging storytelling, Small Town Murder Episode #539 exposes the dark undercurrents that lie beneath the surface of familial relationships and business dealings, ultimately delivering a narrative that is as insightful as it is sobering.
Notable Quotes
- Sam Renick [28:46]: “It must have been a snake.”
- Ashley Shaw [132:43]: “We did it.”
- Prosecutor [136:06]: “All she's done is deflect and lie throughout the investigation.”
- Judge [163:52]: “You're awfully lucky, ma'am. You just...”
Final Thoughts
This episode of Small Town Murder masterfully intertwines true crime with deep research and storytelling, providing listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the complexities involved in the Ben Renick case. For those intrigued by the interplay of personal relationships, financial motives, and the pursuit of justice, this episode is a compelling listen.
If you enjoyed this summary, consider subscribing to Small Town Murder for more in-depth explorations of true crime stories from small towns across America.