Summary of Podcast Episode #562 - "Murder On Slide Mountain - Incline Village, Nevada"

Podcast Title: Small Town Murder
Hosts: James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
Episode Number: #562
Release Date: January 18, 2025

Introduction

In episode #562 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve into a perplexing case from Incline Village, Nevada, titled "Murder On Slide Mountain." This episode combines in-depth research with the hosts' signature comedic flair to explore the circumstances surrounding a tragic event that shook this affluent small town.

Setting the Scene: Incline Village, Nevada

Incline Village is portrayed as a picturesque and wealthy enclave nestled near Lake Tahoe, boasting a median household income of $131,914 and a median home price of $1,392,400. The town, with a population of approximately 9,440, is a haven for celebrities and affluent individuals seeking privacy and luxury. Hosts highlight its scenic beauty, recreational activities, and the juxtaposition of its serene environment against the backdrop of a heinous crime.

James (06:28): "Information, Inspiration, Progress."
(Timestamp: 06:56)

The Bergner Family: Background and Lifestyle

Peter Bergner, born in 1953 and adopted as a baby, grew up in a prosperous environment with wealthy parents—his father serving as a district attorney in Santa Clara County. Peter established himself as a fine art appraiser, working for prestigious firms like Butterfields in San Francisco. His wife, Renette Riella Bergner, a successful pharmacist, complemented his affluent lifestyle. Together, they enjoyed extensive travel, philanthropy, and a high-society existence.

Jimmie (14:05): "I've seen too much and I'm going to try stand up. And that's when I started comedy."

The Fateful Night: May 31, 1998

On May 31, 1998, after a six-week period of Renette's international travel, Peter picked her up from the Reno-Tahoe International Airport in his 1997 Ford F150. Instead of heading home, Peter decided to take a detour onto a secluded mountainous road near Slide Mountain, a favorite scenic spot for the couple to discuss personal matters. During this stop, tensions arose as Peter expressed frustration over Renette's extensive travel and their inability to start a family, leading to a heated conversation about their marriage.

Peter (33:48): "I don't cheat on my wife."

Shortly after, Peter claimed that his truck's brakes failed, causing the vehicle to crash through a guardrail and plunge 800 feet down the mountainside. He survived the fall, allegedly clinging to the rocks, while Renette was found deceased in the mangled wreckage.

Investigation: From Accident to Suspicion

Sergeant Jim Beltran of the Nevada Highway Patrol responded to the 911 call from a distressed Peter. Upon investigation, several anomalies raised suspicions:

1. Inconsistent Statements: Peter reported that his wife was in the truck, but exhibited a lack of emotional distress when informing officers of her likely death.
2. Physical Evidence Discrepancies:
   • Minimal injuries inconsistent with a traumatic fall.
   • Peter was excessively dressed for the 60-degree weather.
   • Absence of skid marks or brake fluid near the crash site.
   • The truck was relatively new with dual brake systems, making brake failure unlikely.
3. Behavioral Concerns:
   • Peter's demeanor was detached despite the severity of the situation.
   • His focus on retrieving a "fanny pack" rather than his wife raised eyebrows.

Jimmie (35:50): "Get my wife and my fanny pack."

Experts and investigators noted inconsistencies in Peter's account, leading to mounting suspicions that the crash might have been orchestrated.

Trial: Prosecution vs. Defense

First Trial: Hung Jury

In 2001, Peter Bergner faced his first trial for the murder of Renette. The prosecution argued that Peter, frustrated by his wife's inability to settle down and have children, deliberately caused the accident to eliminate her and secure financial benefits, including life insurance payouts and inheritance.

Key Prosecution Points:

• Peter’s motive centered around marital discord and financial gain.
• Witness testimonies highlighted Peter’s inappropriate advances toward other women and previous instances of domestic volatility.

Defense Arguments:

• Presented evidence suggesting Peter's brakes were operational and the crash was purely accidental.
• Challenged the prosecution's interpretation of physical evidence and Peter’s behavior.

The jury was deadlocked with a 9-3 split in favor of conviction, resulting in a mistrial due to the inability to reach a unanimous decision.

James (75:25): "He loudly calls her a bitch."

Second Trial: Conviction and Sentencing

In 2002, a second trial was held. This time, the prosecution expanded its case by introducing additional witnesses, including neighbors who testified about Peter's aggressive behavior and prior domestic issues. The defense continued to assert that the accident was genuine, pointing to the lack of concrete evidence linking Peter to foul play.

Key Developments:

• Testimonies from Peter’s first wife and a cellmate corroborated his volatile nature.
• An expert accident investigator concluded that Peter’s statements about the crash were implausible.
• Physical and forensic evidence continued to support the theory of a deliberate act rather than an accident.

Ultimately, the jury found Peter Bergner guilty of first-degree murder, sentencing him to 20 years to life with no possibility of parole for the first 20 years.

Jimmie (75:49): "Guilty, Absolutely."

Appeals and Aftermath

Peter Bergner appealed his conviction multiple times, contending that the evidence was circumstantial and that he was neither suicidal nor schizophrenic—traits he claimed would have been necessary to commit such a premeditated act. Despite his appeals, the conviction stood, and prospects of parole remained uncertain as of 2025.

Throughout the legal proceedings, the community of Incline Village remained divided, with some viewing Peter as a victim of circumstance and others convinced of his guilt.

James (73:31): "You don't do that."

Conclusion

"Murder On Slide Mountain" serves as a compelling exploration of a seemingly straightforward vehicular accident that unravels into a complex murder case. The Small Town Murder hosts effectively blend investigative storytelling with their comedic insights, presenting listeners with a multifaceted narrative that questions the nature of truth, motive, and justice in a wealthy small town setting.

James (79:56): "Peter Bergner, Renette Bergner. Crazy ass fucking story."

Notable Quotes

• James Pietragallo (14:05): "I've seen too much and I'm going to try stand up. And that's when I started comedy."

• Jimmie Whisman (35:50): "Get my wife and my fanny pack."

• James Pietragallo (75:25): "He loudly calls her a bitch."

• Jimmie Whisman (75:49): "Guilty, Absolutely."

• James Pietragallo (73:31): "You don't do that."

• James Pietragallo (79:56): "Peter Bergner, Renette Bergner. Crazy ass fucking story."

This episode not only recounts the tragic story of Peter and Renette Bergner but also invites listeners to ponder the complexities of marital relationships, the facade of affluence, and the elusive nature of truth within the confines of a small community. Through meticulous research and engaging narration, Small Town Murder offers a thought-provoking listen that resonates long after the episode concludes.