Small Town Murder Episode #572: "Murderous Male Stripper - Wantage Township, New Jersey"
Hosts: James Pietragallo & Jimmy Whisman
Release Date: February 22, 2025
1. Introduction
In Episode #572 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmy Whisman delve into the chilling case of a murder in Wantage Township, New Jersey. Balancing in-depth research with their signature comedic flair, the duo unravels the complex dynamics that led to a tragic event in this seemingly peaceful community.
2. Setting the Scene: Wantage Township, New Jersey
Wantage Township, a small town in northern New Jersey, serves as the backdrop for this harrowing tale. With a population of 10,831 and a median household income of $88,563, the town boasts a serene environment characterized by rolling hills, farm animals, and historic sites.
Notable Quote:
"[06:35] James Petrigallo: It's about an hour to the northwest of New York City, which I know sounds so weird."
3. The Victim: Virginia "Gina" Liotta
Virginia Liotta, known as Gina, was a successful law school graduate and the daughter of Elizabeth Lott, an economics professor at Pace University. Born in October 1969, Gina led a promising life, balancing her career and family.
Notable Quote:
"[12:03] James Petrigallo: Virginia Liotta, which I guess if you took the eye out. There's Gina's in the name, I suppose."
4. The Perpetrator: Paul Foglia
Paul Foglia, born in October 1960, was a male stripper with a tumultuous past. Standing at 6'1" and weighing 200 pounds, Paul was known for his muscular build and long, dark hair—a stark contrast to his declining reputation over the years.
Notable Quote:
"[16:05] James Petrigallo: Paul Foglia, a real interesting guy here. He does a lot of stripping."
5. The Toxic Relationship
Gina and Paul's relationship was fraught with instability and conflict. Despite Gina's aspirations and Paul's lack of steady employment, their bond produced two sons. However, Paul's erratic behavior, including obsessive calls and deceit about his personal life, strained the marriage.
Notable Quote:
"[18:10] Jimmy Wisman: Not call her to make sure the story was accurate, to make sure she's."
6. Events Leading to the Murder
On the night of September 24, 2004, tensions reached a breaking point. After a series of verbal abuses and erratic behavior from Paul, Gina found her mother, Elizabeth, brutally murdered in their home.
Notable Quote:
"[37:21] Jimmy Wisman: Oh, one of those, like, dinner trays."
7. The Murder and Investigation
Elizabeth Lott was discovered lying face down in the family room, her skull shattered by a heavy wooden tray table. The crime scene showed no signs of forced entry or robbery, indicating a targeted attack.
Notable Quote:
"[39:54] James Petrigallo: This week we have had Visine and a fucking tray table. Two things we've never had before."
8. Arrest and Trial
Paul was arrested five days after the murder when DNA evidence linked his blood to Elizabeth's at the crime scene. Despite his inconsistent alibis and prior criminal record, Paul maintained his innocence, claiming self-defense during a heated argument.
Notable Quote:
"[47:15] Jimmy Wisman: I smell sex on her still."
9. Verdict and Sentencing
After a lengthy trial marked by emotional testimonies and conflicting evidence, Paul Foglia was convicted of first-degree murder. The jury cited his clear intent and the brutal nature of the crime as decisive factors, sentencing him to life imprisonment with the possibility of parole after 30 years.
Notable Quote:
"[68:45] Jimmy Wisman: Yeah, yeah."
10. Aftermath and Appeals
Paul's conviction faced multiple appeals, primarily challenging the admission of his prior bad acts into evidence. Despite these efforts, the appellate court upheld the original verdict, emphasizing the overwhelming evidence against him.
Notable Quote:
"[73:44] Jimmy Wisman: Unbelievable."
11. Conclusion
The tragic case of Elizabeth Lott's murder in Wantage Township highlights the devastating impact of a toxic relationship and unchecked personal turmoil. Through meticulous research and engaging storytelling, James and Jimmy shed light on the complexities of this small-town tragedy, leaving listeners with a profound understanding of the events that unfolded.
Notable Quote:
"[75:22] James Petrigallo: Gina said those jurors did not convict him because he took a credit card out my son's name. They didn't convict him because he was a male stripper or a bum. They convicted him because he killed my mother."
12. Final Thoughts
Small Town Murder effectively combines comprehensive case analysis with a touch of humor, making complex legal and emotional issues accessible and engaging for listeners. Episode #572 serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of seemingly idyllic communities and the dark secrets that can lurk beneath the surface.
Connect with Us:
- Website: shutupandgivemurder.com
- Social Media: Instagram @SmallTownMurder, Facebook @SmalltownPot
- Merchandise & Live Shows: Available on shutupandgivemurder.com
Support the Show:
- Patreon: patreon.com/crimeinsports for exclusive bonus content.
This summary was crafted based on the transcript provided for Episode #572 of Small Town Murder. For a detailed account, listeners are encouraged to tune into the full episode.