Small Town Murder - Episode #577: Behind A Serial Killer's Mask - Lenexa, Kansas

Hosts: James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman
Release Date: March 13, 2025

Introduction

In Episode #577 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve deep into the chilling case of John Edward Robinson III, a seemingly upstanding man from Lenexa, Kansas, who led a double life as a serial killer. This episode combines meticulous research, harrowing tragedy, and the hosts' signature comedic perspective to unravel the dark layers of a man who masqueraded behind a mask of normalcy.

Background of John Robinson

[03:44] James Petragallo: "He couldn't be more different from Haddon Clark... almost like if BTK had social skills, this is who he would be."

John Edward Robinson III, known later as John Robinson Jr., was born on December 27, 1943, in Cicero, Illinois. The third of five children, his early life was tumultuous, marked by absenteeism from his mother and a father struggling with alcoholism. At the age of 14, Robinson embarked on a journey towards the priesthood by joining the Quigley Preparatory Seminary. However, his inclination towards discipline waned as he engaged in brawls and spent significant time in detention, ultimately abandoning his religious aspirations.

Early Criminal Activities

After dropping out of seminary, Robinson pursued various careers, including a stint as an X-ray technician, where he deceitfully secured positions without proper qualifications by falsifying diplomas and recommendations. His pattern of embezzlement began in the mid-1960s, leading to multiple arrests for theft and fraud. Despite repeated convictions, Robinson's charm and deceit allowed him to evade significant punishment, receiving minimal probation sentences each time.

[12:03] Jimmy Wisman: "Well, what is that about?"
[12:04] James Petragallo: "That's a lot. It's just a wealthy little suburb."

In 1975, his fraudulent activities culminated in an indictment for securities fraud and mail fraud, for which he pled no contest and was fined $2,500 with additional probation. His criminal endeavors continued unabated, leading to further fraud charges in 1986 and subsequent convictions, although his sentences were often mitigated through appeals and probation loopholes.

Establishing a Façade in Lenexa

By the late 1970s and early 1980s, Robinson had relocated to Lenexa, Kansas, a seemingly idyllic suburb with low crime rates and a high median household income. Here, he presented himself as a devoted family man and community member, engaging in roles such as a Sunday school teacher, Scoutmaster, and neighborhood Santa Claus. His outward persona was meticulously crafted to earn the trust and admiration of his neighbors.

[16:18] James Petragallo: "They have the power to ticket vehicles. In Kansas City, the barbecue really rules the roost."

Robinson's charm extended into establishing legitimate businesses, including Professional Services Association, Inc., and later, Hydro Grow Inc., a medical consulting firm. These enterprises served as fronts for his fraudulent schemes, embezzling funds from unsuspecting clients and investors.

BDSM Involvement and Criminal Escalation

In parallel to his financial deceit, Robinson developed a deep involvement in the BDSM community. This facet of his life was characterized by manipulative and abusive relationships with young women, whom he would lure with promises of employment, financial support, and personal attention.

[27:19] Jimmy Wisman: "This kid praises like nobody."

Notable victims included:

• Lisa Stasi (1984): A young mother promising stability and a job, who disappeared without a trace.
• Paula Godfrey (1984): Another woman entangled in Robinson's web of deceit, coerced into a subservient role.
• Suzette Trouton (1997): A BDSM enthusiast who vanished after moving to Kansas under false pretenses.
• Isabella Lewicka (1999): An artist and submissive partner who disappeared alongside Suzette.

Robinson's pattern involved gaining the trust of vulnerable women, exploiting their desires for control and acceptance within the BDSM lifestyle, and ultimately resorting to violence and murder when they attempted to break free or uncover the truth.

[35:25] Jimmy Wisman: "That would get us all in trouble."
[35:27] James Petragallo: "You can't do that, man."

The Disappearance and Murders

Between the mid-1980s and late 1990s, Robinson's criminal activities intensified, leading to the disappearance and eventual death of at least five women. His modus operandi involved:

1. Recruitment: Offering employment or relationships within his businesses.
2. Isolation: Moving victims to secluded locations such as apartments or storage units.
3. Exploitation: Engaging in abusive and violent BDSM practices.
4. Concealment: Disposing of bodies in concealed areas like storage units with barrels, often tied up or hidden behind objects.

[52:17] Jimmy Wisman: "You're ugly. Leave me alone."

The bodies were discovered years later in various storage units, confirming the quadruple murder charges Robinson faced. The forensic evidence, including fingerprints and DNA, directly linked Robinson to the crimes, cementing his status as a serial killer.

Arrest and Investigation

In March 2000, Robinson was apprehended following a series of investigative leads:

• Surveillance: Probation officer Steve Hames identified suspicious patterns and incongruities in Robinson's stories.
• Undercover Operations: FBI agents posed as potential victims, leading to direct confrontations and evidence of his violent tendencies.
• Forensic Evidence: Fingerprints and DNA linked Robinson to the remains found in storage units across Kansas.

[82:43] Jimmy Wisman: "Meanwhile, he's running schemes constantly."
[82:45] James Petragallo: "But he's just like this middle-aged, you know, got a tie on, his hair's combed neatly."

Robinson's charismatic facade made it difficult for authorities to uncover the extent of his crimes, allowing him to evade detection for years despite consistent red flags and missing persons reports.

Trial and Sentencing

Robinson's trial was a complex affair, involving multiple jurisdictions and charges. Ultimately, in October 2003, he was found guilty of capital murder for the deaths of five women and sentenced to death. Additional sentences included life imprisonment and extended probation for various fraudulent activities.

[176:24] Jimmy Wisman: "Don't you dare think we thought we forgot about the theft of the dildos. You'll be doing that first."
[176:26] James Petragallo: "He's got how many bodies more are out there that we haven't found? Yeah."

His sentencing highlighted the challenges of prosecuting white-collar criminals who maintain impeccable outward appearances while committing heinous crimes behind closed doors.

Current Status and Conclusion

As of the episode's release in 2025, John Robinson III remains on death row in Missouri, now over 80 years old. His case serves as a stark reminder of the dual lives some individuals lead and the importance of vigilance within communities. Despite his apparent remorse and attempts to portray himself as rehabilitated, the evidence against him remains incontrovertible.

[187:53] James Petragallo: "They found Trouton's contact list with all their mailing addresses. They also found 31 pieces of pastel colored stationery with 'Love you Suzette' signed at the bottom."

The hosts conclude by reflecting on the disturbing ease with which Robinson manipulated those around him, emphasizing the need for awareness and trust within small communities to prevent such tragedies.

[185:27] Jimmy Wisman: "So she broke it off and didn't see him anymore."
[185:29] James Petragallo: "Yeah, she didn't see him anymore because he was lying to her and shit like that."

Notable Quotes

• James Pietragallo at [03:44]: "This is who BTK would dream to be. Just dream about it."
• Jimmy Whisman at [12:03]: "Well, what is that about?"
• James Pietragallo at [27:19]: "But we're not scumbags."
• James Pietragallo at [35:25]: "You can't do that, man."
• Jimmy Whisman at [52:17]: "You're ugly. Leave me alone."
• James Pietragallo at [82:43]: "But he's just like this middle-aged, you know, got a tie on, his hair's combed neatly."
• Jimmy Whisman at [176:24]: "Don't you dare think we thought we forgot about the theft of the dildos. You'll be doing that first."

Conclusion

Small Town Murder Episode #577 offers an in-depth exploration of John Robinson III's life, unraveling the deceptive layers that allowed a serial killer to operate within a community believed to be safe and prosperous. Through detailed storytelling and engaging dialogue, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman shed light on the complexities of human behavior, the allure of false personas, and the dark realities that can lurk beneath the surface of small-town America.

For those intrigued by the intersection of true crime and human psychology, this episode serves as both a cautionary tale and a compelling narrative on the nature of deception and criminality.

Disclaimer: This summary is based on the provided podcast transcript and is intended for informational purposes only. The events described are based on the hosts' discussion and may contain speculative elements.