Small Town Murder: Episode #579 - "Millions To Murder - Sunnyside, California"

Hosts: James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman
Release Date: March 20, 2025

In this gripping episode of Small Town Murder, comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve deep into the unsettling case of the Yule family’s tragic murders in Sunnyside, California. Blending thorough research with their unique comedic perspective, the hosts unravel the intricate layers of this horrifying event, exploring both the personal dynamics of the Yule family and the broader implications within the small community.

1. Introduction to Sunnyside, California

James and Jimmie set the stage by introducing Sunnyside, a census-designated suburb in Fresno County. They provide a rich backdrop of the town’s history, demographics, and socioeconomic status, painting a vivid picture of the environment in which the tragedy occurred.

James Pietragallo [07:11]: "Sunnyside used to be known as Malta Morrow... Sunnyside sounds like there's gonna wake up to waves crashing on your front."

They discuss Sunnyside’s transformation from sheep and wheat farming to a community with significant oil production, highlighting both its economic growth and underlying social issues like high unemployment rates and crime.

2. The Yule Family: Background and Dynamics

The focus shifts to the Yule family, comprising Glee Ellen Mitchell Yule, her husband Dale Allen Yule, and their daughter Tiffany Ann Yule. The hosts meticulously outline each member’s background, revealing a family marked by privilege, control, and underlying tensions.

Jimmie Whisman [07:13]: "A couple Years older. He's from Ohio. He is described as a tall, husky Air Force pilot."

Glee, portrayed as a devoted mother and community pillar, contrasts sharply with Dale, a ruthless and manipulative businessman with little regard for personal relationships. Tiffany, the quiet daughter, adds another layer of complexity to the family’s dynamic.

3. The Murder Incident

On April 21, 1992, the Yule family’s beach house became the scene of a brutal triple homicide. James and Jimmie provide a detailed narrative of the events leading up to and following the murders, supported by timestamps and direct quotes from the investigation transcripts.

James Pietragallo [20:09]: "So the killer just stepped into the hallway behind him and shot him. They never even got the chance to bring in their suitcases from the Jeep that they arrived."

The victims—Tiffany, Glee, and Dale—were found murdered in various parts of the house, with signs pointing to a meticulously planned execution rather than a random act of violence. The absence of forced entry and the staged burglary suggested deeper motives behind the killings.

4. Investigation and Suspects

The investigation unveils numerous potential motives, primarily centered around Dale’s contentious business dealings. Dale’s aggressive sales tactics and accumulation of wealth garnered him many enemies, making him a prime suspect in the eyes of law enforcement.

James Pietragallo [34:31]: "He's more concerned about more money, but it was hard to c. He was the ultimate manipulator."

James and Jimmie discuss how the investigation initially focused on former associates and family members, highlighting the complex web of relationships and financial entanglements that complicate pinpointing the true perpetrator.

5. The Trial and Verdict

The episode delves into the courtroom drama that unfolded as Dana Yule, the son of the murdered couple, stood trial for the triple homicide. The hosts analyze the prosecution’s focus on Dana’s obsession with wealth and his strained relationship with his father, juxtaposed against the defense’s arguments of procedural misconduct and lack of concrete evidence.

Jimmie Whisman [164:46]: "He's the greediest person I've ever met in my life."

Despite a compelling case presented by the prosecution, the trial concludes with the jury finding both Dana and his close associate Joel Radovich guilty of first-degree murder. They face life sentences without the possibility of parole, a decision influenced by the overwhelming narrative of greed and manipulation.

6. Aftermath and Reflections

James and Jimmie reflect on the broader impact of the murders on Sunnyside and the Yule family’s legacy. They ponder the societal and psychological factors that may lead individuals to commit such heinous acts, emphasizing the delicate balance within small communities where everyone’s actions are closely scrutinized.

James Pietragallo [166:49]: "I don't think any one of it has been beneficial to solving this crime. The challenge is to resolve every aspect of the crime and identify the perpetrator, not to simply take aim at Dana in light of one's own limitations or inabilities."

7. Notable Quotes and Moments

Throughout the episode, numerous poignant and revealing quotes from both the investigation transcripts and the hosts themselves provide deeper insights into the case:

• James Pietragallo [03:02]: "We have some, some greedy, greedy people today and some very... It's just weird."

• Jimmie Whisman [07:32]: "Have you been?"

• James Pietregallo [117:32]: "That's how it worked. Now, after learning about all these lies that he told the Yules, Dale and Glee modified their estate plan slightly."

• James Pietregallo [175:17]: "This is a bit of symmetry with Menendez. They're still doing it."

8. Conclusion

Small Town Murder successfully combines meticulous storytelling with sharp comedic elements, making for an engaging exploration of the Sunnyside murders. James and Jimmie invite listeners to ponder the dark complexities of human nature and the hidden secrets that small towns can harbor.

James Pietragallo [178:42]: "We will be here and we'll keep coming back. You want to follow us? Shut up and give me murder.com. Drop down menu. Take you wherever you want to go."

For those intrigued by true crime woven with a touch of humor, this episode stands out as a compelling listen that not only narrates the events but also encourages deeper contemplation on the motives and consequences of such tragedies.