Podcast Summary: Small Town Murder
Episode: #580 - Beauty Shop Butcher - Roebuck, South Carolina
Release Date: March 21, 2025
Hosts: James Pietragallo & Jimmy Whisman
Introduction
In episode #580 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmy Whisman delve into the tragic and perplexing case of Dana Satterfield, a beautician from the small town of Roebuck, South Carolina. Combining meticulous research with their signature comedic flair, James and Jimmy navigate through the complexities of this unsolved mystery, exploring the impact on the tight-knit community and the subsequent legal proceedings.
Background of Roebuck, South Carolina
Roebuck is a small, serene community located in Spartanburg County, South Carolina, with a population of approximately 3,482. Named after Revolutionary War officer Benjamin Roebuck, the town boasts historical landmarks like the Walnut Grove Plantation. The median household income stands at $54,153, with median home prices around $275,500. Described by locals as a "tight-knit" and "safe" community, Roebuck presents an idyllic yet unsuspecting backdrop for the ensuing tragedy.
The Mysterious Murder of Dana Satterfield
[12:54] James Pietragallo: "Dana Satterfield was brutally murdered in her own beauty salon. It was a horrifying scene—she was found hanging by a strap around her neck, covered in blood with clear signs of a violent struggle."
Dana, a 27-year-old single mother, was found dead on July 31, 1995, in her Roebuck beauty and tanning salon. The crime scene revealed extensive evidence of a violent attack, including blood on the walls and numerous contusions on Dana's body. Notably, there was no sign of robbery, as her wallet and cash box still contained over $200.
Investigation and Key Evidence
The investigation revealed that Dana had been struggling in her marriage with Mike Satterfield, leading to their separation. On the night of the murder, witnesses reported seeing a white male matching the description wearing a grayish T-shirt and blue jeans near the salon. Crucially, a semen sample found at the scene matched the DNA profile of Jonathan Christian Vick, a 17-year-old high school student at the time.
[22:34] Jimmy Whisman: "A friend laughed in Vic's face when he tried to date Dana, not realizing the dark turn this would take."
Despite an initial lack of substantial evidence, the DNA match was a pivotal breakthrough, reducing the pool of potential suspects drastically. Additional support came from anonymous tips and Vick's own incriminating admissions during his time in the Marines, where he was noted for violent behavior and assaulting fellow Marines.
The Arrest and Trial of Jonathan Vick
In 2005, Jonathan Vick was arrested after his DNA matched the semen sample from the crime scene. Despite maintaining his innocence, the overwhelming evidence led to his conviction on all counts, including murder, criminal sexual conduct, and kidnapping.
[68:37] Jimmy Whisman: "They didn't even get to the Soup Nazi."
The trial was swift, with the jury deliberating for less than 20 minutes before delivering a guilty verdict. Vick was sentenced to life with parole eligibility in 2035. The sentencing phase was emotionally charged, with family members of both the victim and Vick expressing their anguish and outrage.
Aftermath and Other Cases
Post-trial, Vick continued to exhibit violent behavior while incarcerated, leading to additional convictions for assaulting correctional officers. He was also implicated as a person of interest in the 2002 disappearance of Heather Rena Sellers, though no conclusive evidence linked him to her case.
Dana's daughter, Ashley Satterfield, became a victim advocate, dedicating her efforts to supporting other victims and their families. The case also garnered national attention through its feature on shows like Forensic Files and Unsolved Mysteries.
Conclusion
The Beauty Shop Butcher episode of Small Town Murder presents a comprehensive and engaging examination of Dana Satterfield's tragic death. Through detailed storytelling and insightful commentary, James and Jimmy highlight the profound effect of such crimes on small communities and the relentless pursuit of justice by law enforcement. Despite Vick's conviction, the lingering questions surrounding other potential crimes ensure that the story remains a haunting reminder of the dark undercurrents that can exist beneath the surface of seemingly peaceful towns.
Notable Quotes
- James Pietragallo [12:54]: "Dana Satterfield was brutally murdered in her own beauty salon."
- Jimmy Whisman [22:34]: "A friend laughed in Vic's face when he tried to date Dana, not realizing the dark turn this would take."
- James Pietragallo [68:37]: "He is found guilty on all counts murder, criminal sexual conduct, and kidnapping as well."
- Ashley Satterfield: "I just want to help others like I've been helped."
Additional Information
- Live Shows: Tickets for live performances are available at shutupandgivemerder.com, including the upcoming 4:20 virtual show on April 19.
- Patreon: Support the show and gain access to exclusive content at patreon.com/CrimeInSports.
- Social Media: Follow Small Town Murder on Instagram and Small Town Pod on Facebook for updates and additional content.
This summary aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the episode for listeners and newcomers alike, capturing the essence of the discussion while maintaining a respectful tone regarding the sensitive nature of the case.