Note: We’re resharing this conversation as Saturday marks the anniversary of Alcatraz Island closing as a federal prison in 1963. This interview originally aired in May 2025, when President Donald Trump publicly floated the idea of reopening the island.

Could Alcatraz reopen today? And what was it really like to live there?
In this episode of SmartHER News, Jenna sits down with Jolene Babyak — one of the leading experts on Alcatraz Island — who actually grew up on “The Rock.”

Jolene shares what most people don’t know about Alcatraz: families lived there, kids took boats to school, and daily life looked very different than the movies suggest.

Together, they explore:

* How Alcatraz evolved from a military fortress to America’s most infamous federal prison
* What life was like for the 75 children who lived on the island
* The truth about escape attempts, including the famous 1962 breakout
* Why Alcatraz closed—and whether it could ever reopen
* The surprising role of mental illness in the prison system
* Why Alcatraz should be viewed as a “site of conscience,” not just a tourist attraction

Jolene also shares how an unexpected job loss led her to become one of the foremost historians on Alcatraz — proof that sometimes, it really does work out.

If you’ve ever wondered what really happened on Alcatraz — or why it still captures our attention — this conversation offers a deeper, more nuanced look.

00:00 Could Alcatraz Reopen
00:36 From Fortress to Prison
02:00 How Her Family Moved In
05:02 Daily Life on the Rock
07:22 Prisoners and Escape Attempts
12:10 The 1962 Escape Night
14:45 Water Sewage and Supplies
18:00 Becoming an Alcatraz Historian
20:55 Who Went to Alcatraz
23:13 Capone and Famous Inmates
25:26 Was Alcatraz Effective
26:54 Why It Wont Reopen
29:49 Alcatraz as a Site of Conscience
31:46 Changing Minds and Farewell

Jolene Babyak: http://jolenebabyakauthor.com/

Love nonpartisan news? Want a bigger serving of the serious headlines? Here’s how you can become a SCOOP insider: https://www.scoop.smarthernews.com/get-the-inside-scoop/

Shop our gear! https://smarthernews.com/shop/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/smarthernews/
Website: https://smarthernews.com/

Alcatraz Uncovered: What It Was Really Like to Live on the Island