Loading summary
Shane
Hello. Welcome to Smosh Mouth. I'm Shane.
Amanda
And I'm Amanda. And we have a very, very special episode. And we have two special guests, Spencer and Courtney.
Spencer
Hi.
Courtney
Hey.
Spencer
I'm Spencer.
Shane
Guys.
Amanda
Courtney.
Shane
It's finally the episode. It's been months in the making. Forever ago, Spencer and I pranked Amanda to believing that Five Nights at Freddy's was a true story. That really happened.
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
Which maybe there's some truth to that. And then that led to us playing a bunch of the Five Nights at Freddy's games, which I dreaded. I hated it.
Amanda
I loved it.
Shane
Yeah. This ended up being the best thing for Amanda. But throughout all of this, we have not told Amanda what the actual story is. What's going on? You've been guessing this whole time. I have. But today we're going to do our best because it is. There's a lot of depth and there's a lot of debate, but we're gonna do our best to explain the real story of Five Nights at Freddy's to you. I wanna preface by saying we will. Cause it's just. There's a whole lot. There's a lot of different theories, and it's all really just a theory. We're probably gonna fuck some things up. I know I will. So the comment.
Spencer
And we know Scott did.
Shane
Yeah. Whoa. So the comments. There's gonna be people who are gonna be mad at us. And I'm saying me. Cause I'm probably gonna really.
Courtney
They're gonna be mad at you, Amanda.
Amanda
No, I can't take that.
Shane
But we're gonna do our best. We want to just introduce you. And I. I will say, like, when we get Matpat, someday he can really clear everything up. But before Matpat, we're gonna give you the one.
Amanda
So you guys are gonna do your best.
Shane
We're gonna do our best. Courtney made this awesome board that's so good.
Spencer
Conspiracy board for the people who are catching up. Still on the lore of this situation. Why are me and Spencer here?
Courtney
Well, since Spencer and Courtney, we got married in the.
Shane
Courtney, you got super into Five Nights at Freddy's. I feel like roughly around the time when we pranked Amanda.
Spencer
A little bit before, it was when we went to Horror Nights and they had the Blumhouse exhibit. I've always loved animatronics. And, like, I used to spend hours as a kid Googling, like, robot dinosaur videos. Cause I was like, that's the coolest thing in the world. And then we went to this Blumhouse exhibit at Horror Nights where they had the animatronics on display. And I was just so into it. And like, I had always loved the Jack Black video where he goes from. And I was just like, I love this vibe. I think I need to dive in. And then. And then that's where it all started.
Shane
Yeah.
Amanda
Wow.
Shane
Courtney, I think is actually knows far more about the lore than I do. You're invested.
Amanda
I believe that.
Shane
And I actually think by the end of today, you might know more than me. I have realized every step of the way that I'm like, I thought I knew what was going on. I realized I don't.
Spencer
And Spencer knows more than all of us, probably, huh?
Shane
Maybe. Yeah.
Amanda
Spencer, talk about this vest that you're wearing and then go into.
Courtney
So last year, Alex and I went to gen con and all the, like, the official gen con helpers had these fishing vests on, and I was like, those look cool as hell. And so I've kind of been looking for one for a while and I finally found one on ebay and so I ordered it.
Shane
It's pretty cool.
Amanda
It's excellent. So does this help you tell the lore?
Courtney
Yeah, well, you know, I kind of wanted to go all in and dress like a full on conspiracy theorist with like a bucket hat and stuff.
Amanda
Yes.
Courtney
But I was like, you know what? This feels like a good time to debut the vest.
Spencer
I love it.
Shane
It's pretty awesome.
Amanda
I think it's incredible because all of us are in jean jackets and you're in this vest.
Spencer
Yeah. We actually thought you were gonna wear a jean jacket with us and then you showed up in this.
Amanda
Yeah.
Courtney
Yeah. How do you guys feel?
Shane
I feel pretty good.
Amanda
I feel like you have answers. That's how I feel.
Shane
Yeah.
Courtney
Okay, good. Yeah. That's the vibe I wanted to put out.
Spencer
Yeah. So is it a play on words like you said, lure lore best?
Courtney
No, that actually just. That just struck me.
Shane
That worked out. That's pretty cool.
Courtney
That struck me like a sleeping bullet.
Spencer
Wow.
Shane
Before we get into this, I should also say I messed my finger up with a vegetable peeler really bad. And so that's why I have a cast on my fingies.
Amanda
Was it a vegetable peeler or was it Freddie, the cut of 24?
Shane
The cut of 24. No, I truly. The tip of my finger.
Spencer
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I heard it so many times now, I can't hear it again. You chopped your lip.
Shane
My finger looks like Frankenstein. The tip of it had to be sewn back on.
Spencer
Ah. And it's like it's black thread. Like a freaking. Like a Tim Burton character.
Amanda
Oh, my God. You're literally five nights at Freddy's. Like, look at their faces. They look like they're sewn together. You just look at your spring trap.
Shane
Okay.
Amanda
Or foxy.
Shane
What the fuck?
Courtney
So did you get hit? Did you hit both fingers?
Shane
Yeah, the very tip of this one. And then this. The. My middle finger is the one that got really messed up.
Amanda
Oh. So you can't flip me off ever.
Spencer
Well, he can now. It just looks really silly.
Amanda
Ew. I can't take that.
Shane
When we film, I think we're filming stuff on green screen.
Courtney
We're gonna have some fun.
Shane
I'm gonna flip people off, and it's gonna be half my finger.
Spencer
Turns out Kermit the Frog was a finger donor.
Shane
Wow.
Courtney
Wow.
Shane
No, it's Shrek.
Amanda
Anyways.
Shane
No, it's Shrek.
Amanda
Before we start, I'd like us all to go around and say which character we feel the most connected to in five nights at Freddy's.
Shane
Okay, I'll start. Who are you most connected to?
Amanda
Chica. Yeah, because I feel like all the other ones were like, whoa, what the hell? And with Chica, it's like, what the hell is going on? Like, I felt like I wanted to know her, you know? Cause she really progressed in, like.
Shane
The second one is when she's suddenly like.
Courtney
Yeah, that's toy Chica.
Amanda
I think Toy Chica. And then she becomes a woman. And then Shadow Chica. Shadow Chica. And then it. Security breach, where she's like kind of a little.
Shane
Well, yeah, that's not even chica. That's a whole different. Those are different ones.
Amanda
Okay.
Spencer
Yeah, yeah, yeah. We'll get there.
Shane
We'll get there, we'll get there.
Courtney
Spencer Michael Afton. Cuz he smells bad.
Shane
Okay, okay.
Amanda
Don't know who that is.
Spencer
You'll find out. You'll find out.
Amanda
Okay. Court.
Spencer
I really. Bonnie's my favorite, but maybe I'm more connected to Foxy.
Amanda
Ooh. Okay.
Courtney
Foxy Rising.
Shane
And I'm Balloon Boy.
Amanda
You're balloon Boy. You're the nightmare, love.
Courtney
Hello.
Amanda
You're such a nightmare.
Shane
Hi. Hi.
Amanda
Awful. Okay, let's go.
Shane
All right, before we start. Now, Amanda, you've been talking about what you think is going on. Yeah. What are your theories? What do you believe is the story of.
Spencer
Yeah. Now that you've played all the games, what have you gathered?
Shane
Generally, you don't have to nail every single part of what's going on?
Amanda
The spark. I definitely think there's a fungus going on.
Shane
Okay.
Amanda
There is an under layer connecting underneath the pizza parlor or whatever it's called. And they're all connected. And, like, all the little souls are connected and they're controlling the animatronics. And when one animatronic gets hurt, the other one feels it. Oh, and then when they were at. What's the house? 1.
Shane
What's it, 4.
Amanda
So when they were there, the animatronics lured the kids to this house to have, like, a pizza party hangout, and they trapped them there, and they had to do it. Like, they have to have some type of charismatic powers to make the parents just be like, yeah, sure, take my kid. You know?
Shane
Interesting.
Amanda
And I think it's like they're all working together because they're all fungus underneath. They're all connected.
Shane
Well, you're wrong about some stuff, but honestly, Amanda, there's a lot of stuff you're gonna be like, wow, I wasn't following.
Amanda
Really?
Shane
I think. I think.
Amanda
Okay, what you just said.
Courtney
No, yeah, that's everything different than incredible. Every word of what you just said was wrong.
Shane
No, Billy, what you just said. Fine, but I.
Courtney
But you did correctly. You did correctly. One to one, do the plot of Resident Evil 7, which. Which was actually incredible. Yeah, that's the plot of Resident Evil 7.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
Guess you have to play that.
Courtney
Which we'll be playing.
Shane
You're gonna love that game.
Amanda
Wait. That's fucking awesome.
Courtney
Yeah. A lot of fungus.
Spencer
Is it scarier than so much fungus?
Courtney
It's different.
Shane
It's a different kind of scary.
Amanda
I love fungus in, like, the really positive way. But also to think of it as a scary way is cool.
Shane
Oh, yeah.
Spencer
You like a fun guy?
Amanda
Yeah, I like a fun guy.
Shane
Yeah, totally. Let's begin then with this. Let's start off with the first game. Five nights at Freddy's.
Amanda
Okay.
Shane
So you're. You're a security guard. You're working at a pizza place.
Amanda
Michael Schmidt.
Shane
Mike Schmidt.
Amanda
Mike Schmidt.
Shane
Nice. Good memory.
Amanda
Not Michael. Mike.
Shane
Now, something that there was a lot of lore that we probably didn't pick up. Pick up on because we were talking whenever the phone. Phone calls.
Amanda
Yeah. We talked the whole time. We were like, how do we play?
Shane
But in that one, he talks about a bite that happens. That I believe. Yeah. It's Five nights at Freddy's one that he's talking about.
Courtney
He talks about the bite of 87. Yes. Which is different from the bite of 83.
Shane
There's two different bites.
Spencer
But you only at this point, learned about the bite of 87.
Shane
Bite of 87. Okay, now the bite of 87, as far as we know. There's not a ton of details on it, but we know that a guest was bitten by one of the animatronics.
Courtney
So let me stop you right there.
Shane
Okay. Whoa.
Courtney
So I actually. I downloaded all this right before.
Shane
Great.
Courtney
So do you want to start in chronological order? Yes. Do you want to start at the beginning?
Amanda
Yes.
Courtney
Okay, so in the beginning, there are these two guys. One is William Afton.
Shane
Wait, hold. Hold on. Stop, stop, stop. Do we really want to go through the entire.
Courtney
I think I can. I think I can speed us through and, like, get us to the games pretty quickly. Okay, so there's William Afton. Okay. And he is a like an imagineer type guy. There's William Afton, and then there's Henry, Emily, and their business partners.
Amanda
Name.
Courtney
Yeah. So their business partners. Their business partners are like, we want to make Freddy Fazbear's whatever Pizzeria.
Amanda
Okay.
Courtney
There's like a million different, like, Freddy Fazbears.
Spencer
Yeah. Because first of all, even you're wrong there, because they both had their own. And then they kind of started working.
Courtney
Oh, yeah, well, they had. They had Freddy. Like, it's like Freddy's Diner or some shit like that.
Shane
Yeah.
Spencer
Fredbear's family diner.
Courtney
Yeah. So the two of them, they had a restaurant.
Shane
No, the animatronics. They were like, normal.
Spencer
There are suits at first or there's.
Shane
Suits, but they wasn't. It was nothing crazy.
Amanda
So there were people in the suits.
Courtney
Well, so William. William's claim to fame is he invented the spring lock suit, which is a. It's essentially an animatronic. So it's on stage, it's doing its fucking thing. And then if you, like, press this button or whatever on the back, it kind of flips open.
Amanda
Oh, yeah.
Courtney
That's what you've been seeing. And then you could get into it and then move it around. So it's like an animatronic slash suit. That's like his.
Amanda
Never get in that suit.
Shane
And they were. They're apparently very dangerous. Cause the lock mechanisms could fuck up. And then the person inside would get skewered by the suit.
Courtney
And then. So that was like kind of his claim to fame. And they had their thing where, you know, like the. It was like a Chuck E. Cheese basically.
Amanda
Yeah.
Courtney
And then that's when things started to go wrong.
Amanda
Uh oh, Someone got in the suit. And that's the bite of 87 kind of.
Courtney
So first he had the bite of 83. So he had three kids. William did. William Afton had three kids of his three kids. One of them the youngest one who you play in Five nights at Freddy's four. When you're the little kid running around. He is deathly afraid of the animatronics.
Amanda
I think the one who.
Spencer
Because he saw something.
Courtney
I think his name is Evan. So Evan's like the little kid never saw his name.
Shane
How do you find out his name?
Courtney
It's. It's in one of the books, I guess.
Spencer
So. Okay. This is why I was nervous about going in chronological order because I think it might be a lot harder to download to Amanda's mind. But, like, they're like. The lore is basically Amanda. The lore is so big and the creator got so deep entangled in his own lore that there's literally books, there's like toy like journals that have clues and Easter eggs are in every piece of his merchandise about this entire franchise. And so it's like. There's a lot and. And it's really. At a certain point, it's a lot of guessing.
Courtney
He's actually texting me Laura right now.
Shane
Whoa. Yeah.
Amanda
Scott Cawthorn.
Courtney
Yeah.
Spencer
He also had a habit, like people had, like, it became a game for people who played the games to find hidden Easter eggs in these video games, basically, where if you had. You had to turn up the brightness on a certain frame in the video game, then you'd find like a secret word or stuff like that, like. Or a code.
Shane
That's why the lore is so literally.
Spencer
That's why people are so obsessed with this is because it's a lot. It's like, controversial because there's so many secrets and so many missed things. And there's the biggest way that you learn the lore of these stories is in those mini games where it's the eight bit stuff. That's where you learn most of the story. And sometimes you don't even get all of those when you play through. And sometimes you have to play it a certain way in order to get a certain cutscene that will tell you something very dark and very good by.
Courtney
Like failing it or winning it.
Shane
So we didn't get everything, but we got a lot of good stuff.
Courtney
So in four, you're the little kid and you're running around, and those are basically his nightmares. Like, he is having nightmares. Whose nightmares?
Amanda
The kid.
Courtney
The kid. Evan Afton, I think is his name again.
Amanda
Got it.
Spencer
We just jumped really far.
Courtney
Well, yeah. So he's running around. He's having all these nightmares and stuff like that. And then, you know how you do the minigame and you're kind of walking through and then you see the foxy mask pop out. That's your older brother, Michael Afton. So that is the older brother. And he knows that you, Evan Afton, are really afraid of the animatronic, so he's kind of scaring you. And then it kind of culminates in a prank where William Afton. And I think you guys saw this and it's where William Afton. No, sorry, Michael Afton. It gets really confusing. Michael Afton, all his buddies, they take Evan Afton and they're all at the pizzeria and they're like, hey, stick your head in the. Stick your head in the machine. Stick your head in Freddy Fazbear or whatever fucking thing. And then the animatronics are.
Amanda
The kids.
Courtney
Snaps in the cutscene.
Spencer
The kids put his head in.
Courtney
Yeah. So their prank is like, haha, we're gonna stick you in the animatronic. The animatronic snaps and essentially kills one of the sons. The son. So one of the sons. It's a Cain and Abel situation, Kills the other son. Well, he technically puts him in a coma or whatever. And like the fifth night is like you in a coma. But yeah, so you, the player of the fourth game, are killed basically at the end by the other son.
Spencer
Are you sure about that?
Amanda
Yeah, by the other son. So there's three sons.
Courtney
There's. There's two sons and a daughter. We haven't even gotten to the daughter yet.
Spencer
Yeah, I feel like. No, no, no, no.
Courtney
She becomes.
Spencer
Hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. I think we're really getting ahead. I really do.
Courtney
This is the first in chronological order of the games.
Amanda
Wow.
Courtney
Four.
Spencer
So what? One important thing to know.
Amanda
This is fun. I'm having three people tell me the lore.
Spencer
I know. And there's going to be a lot of arguing because it's all theories from different people. Like you watched a different YouTuber's videos than I did.
Shane
Yeah.
Spencer
So are we.
Amanda
I think we have to.
Shane
Courtney's an expert on the mat.
Spencer
I watched all the MatPat videos. So I think they're different. I think they have different theories.
Amanda
Is Matpat 100% correct?
Spencer
Well, there's a lot of controversy because Matpat got so deep into the lore that people argued that Scott, the creator actually was like. Actually, yeah, that is the lore. Because he got so lost in his own story.
Amanda
Got it, got it.
Spencer
But one thing that is important also is. Yeah, the games are in an order, but that's not the story's order. There's like this 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, sister location, whatever. That's not how the order of it all happened.
Courtney
Yeah, four takes place first.
Shane
Yeah, four.
Amanda
Oh, and four is with the kid and, and the. The rock stars.
Shane
No, no, that was the. That's the last one that we.
Amanda
Oh, four is the Texas Chainsaw House.
Shane
That's one where you thought the kid was. It's like they're being invited back to this house for the pizza party. But actually you're playing as one of the children of the creator of Freddy the Animatronics.
Amanda
While they're still alive.
Courtney
Yeah, he's still alive during the game. And then he is killed, I think between the fourth and fifth night.
Spencer
Well, and there's controversy because at first the creator said it was all a dream and then later he said it's actually not and that there was a lot more to the story. Because there was. Apparently Scott said that. I keep calling him Scott like I know him on a first name basis. I don't know this man. Don't.
Courtney
That's what my friend talks about. Markiplier. It's really funny. She's like, ugh, I'm watching the new Mark video. I'm like, that's.
Spencer
That's crazy weird. But yeah, like this kid gets bitten and his dad is devastated and is kind of making sure that he can make his son okay again. And that ultimately is what drives him insane.
Shane
Yeah.
Amanda
Why are the animatronics at his house in the fourth one?
Shane
Well, they aren't. Well, they up for debate. It's up for debate there too. But this is the. He is the creator of these animatronics. So there is a. There are theories that. And you were saying, like, oh, something's connected underneath. There's theories that there were. There was something connected to him making animatronics and robotics underneath his house that were then tormenting.
Amanda
Okay, okay.
Shane
But there's also the. There's also the thing. The original theory of like, oh, it's all a dream. So it's kind of like it's up for debate. But there are theories that it. There was stuff that was coming up.
Spencer
That the dad was using in the books. It's like very clear that a, a factory or a facility is connected to a house.
Courtney
Yeah, that's sister location. That was the.
Amanda
So I think, I think for me, I think that we should go in order, not based on the games, but in order where like the origin story starts and give me which game that Correlates to.
Courtney
So that was. That was. That was four. And then. So after the kid is bitten, after his brother shoves him in the animatronic and he's bitten. That is the bite of 83.
Shane
That's the first one.
Courtney
That's the first bite.
Amanda
And that happens at.
Courtney
In the fourth game.
Shane
That happens.
Amanda
Diner.
Shane
But that.
Courtney
No, no, sorry. The. The fucking. The names of all, like, the pizzerias. It's like the diner, the pizzeria, the pizza store. Like, it. It doesn't frankly make any sense, but it's like basically they keep closing and reopening and closing and reopening and it's confusing. And I think we should de. Emphasize like the names of the. Basically, like it happened at one of the pizza places.
Amanda
Okay.
Shane
So know that there are multiple locations of Freddy Fazbear's Pizza. Like, because he. It was successful. So they. They opened up new ones.
Amanda
Got it.
Shane
Sometimes they would close down because of controversies such as that.
Spencer
Yeah, like, controversies. Like there was. There was one location where they had the animatronics, and then there was. For some reason, kids kept getting murdered at this place. So they closed it down and they opened a new location with. With those newer. The toy animatronics that you see supposedly. I think I have that right. And those ones were built with this special predator pedophile detecting security wear in their technology for some reason, but it still just like keeps happening and they don't know why.
Amanda
So the animatronics started killing kids after they bit the creators because.
Courtney
We haven't gotten to the concept of priority possession or like, as it happens in the Five Nights at Freddy's Universe. So after some. After a child is killed in or around the animatronic, typically they will possess the animatronic. And the first instance, the child's soul.
Amanda
Will possess the animatronic.
Courtney
And the first instance of this is in the fourth game, which is the first in the chronological order after his. After the child is bitten, Evan, he kind of takes the. He's in the Fredbear animatronic. And the Fredbear one's confusing.
Amanda
I remember that because didn't he say, like, climb in me to be safe?
Shane
That was security.
Courtney
That's. That's security breach. And that's.
Amanda
Oh, oh, oh.
Shane
I wouldn't worry about that game.
Courtney
There's.
Amanda
There's Fredbear because the game is not good.
Courtney
No, there's Fredbear and then there's Freddy Fazbear. It's in Golden Freddy.
Shane
I Think we're okay if I can pause for a second? I think we're getting into a lot of nuances. First, I'd rather us focus on William Afton.
Courtney
Yeah.
Shane
Like, and that story first. And then we can start branching out into the more nuanced things.
Courtney
Yeah. So four. You know, William Afton has two sons and a daughter. The one son accidentally kills the other son. And this drives William basically crazy.
Amanda
Yep.
Shane
He's already kind of a crazy guy. He's already a very determined, like, think about, like, you know, the. The weird types out there who run big companies with his craft. Yeah. He's obsessed with animatronics and he wants to make these things. He's also got a fear of death a lot of people talk about in their theories and a desire to live forever kind of thing. Now he starts going crazy after his son's bite. And he has his business partner.
Amanda
When you say bite, is he dead?
Shane
He's in a com. Yeah.
Courtney
He goes into a comb and then he dies.
Shane
Yeah.
Amanda
Oh.
Shane
But he has his business partner, Henry Emily, who he feels a lot of animosity and jealousy towards why Henry Emily had.
Spencer
They had different. They both had like. They made animatronics, basically. Henry Emily made a different kind and they were like, newer. And when they had come together, they had kind of disputed over what which animatronics would be on the stage and stuff. And I think there's a lot of resentment from Willie and Afton and it was just like they didn't get along very well and they didn't stay working together for very long.
Amanda
So which animatronics did Henry Emily make?
Shane
He made. So if we're going back further, then they did originally start by having their own restaurant types of places. And Henry Emily was known for having Chica's Party World or something like that. It was. But he had. He had made Chica and he had made.
Amanda
Is he more of the rock star?
Spencer
Bonnie.
Shane
He made Bonnie and. Or no. No.
Courtney
Yeah.
Spencer
Because William Afton had this one and they didn't. They was disputing over.
Courtney
They used to get in the stage when they were at the diner. They would be the ones in the costume.
Amanda
Right. I was wondering that.
Courtney
Yeah. So I think. I think. I think Henry would be Bonnie and William will be Fredbear.
Shane
Yeah. So they. But they came together to make the diner and then. Then they eventually opened Freddy Fazbear's Pizza. So they were. They were doing really well. But William Upton starts to lose his fucking mind.
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
And he's. He's crazy, right? And he's. He's becomes kind of a sadistic monster.
Amanda
Okay.
Shane
And he eventually, I believe the first he murders children. The first one he murders is Henry Emily's daughter.
Courtney
This is after though he loses his own daughter.
Spencer
Yeah, but that's too deep. We gotta.
Shane
We'll go back to that later because I wanted to get just to the main five nights first. So he kills Henry Emily's daughter and now we get into the whole family dispute. Yeah, but I don't think Henry Emily knows that William Afton's the one who killed her.
Amanda
And how does he kill her? He goes into the animatronic.
Courtney
She is outside of a birthday party at like one of the establishments.
Spencer
You see this in an 8 bit cutscene.
Courtney
And she is being protected by the puppet. The puppet is someone who Henry Emily makes to basically protect kids from like the murderous.
Amanda
He's the scariest. Yeah, he's the scariest.
Shane
See. Cause what I. The theory I read is once she is murdered, William Afton murders her. She then her ghost, her spirit possesses the puppet.
Courtney
That is correct.
Shane
Do you remember the puppet thing that if you didn't wind the thing up.
Amanda
I remember. And the little kid that came up, Balloon boy.
Shane
Balloon boy. So. Oh, that's Shane possesses the puppet, but then William Afton. And we'll probably dial it back at some point, but William Afton then continues killing kids.
Spencer
And it's because he wants to like, because he keeps just wanting to bring back his own kid. Basically.
Courtney
He wants to learn more about how the possession stuff works. So he's like, if I can.
Amanda
Like, so his kid can come back.
Courtney
Even if he does this. I think you have it on there. Scientists, I will put you back together. That's what he says to his son. As his son is like slipping into death from the coma.
Shane
And I think there's probably different theories on his reasoning why, but we know for sure that he murders a bunch of kids now. He murders a Cool. He murders a bunch of kids. And with the help of the. Now that the girl is possessing the puppet, she helps guide these kids spirits into the animatronics. And so.
Amanda
And Henry, Amelie's like, what's happening?
Shane
Exactly, pretty much. So you were saying it was a fungus. We finally get to one of the answers, big answers. You thought it was a fungus? It was actually that all of these animatronics that you saw in Five Nights at Freddy's one have the ghosts of children that the creator had murdered and they possessed these animatronics.
Spencer
And supposedly in One of the cutscenes of when the first kid gets. Gets. Or is it the second kid? No, basically, William Afton would stuff their bodies into the animatronics to hide them, and apparently one of his kids saw that, and that's why he was so afraid of the animatronics at some point.
Amanda
So none of the owner's kids are actually in the animatronics except for the puppet.
Shane
Well, Henry, Emily's daughter is in the puppet, but otherwise just other kids. That. What he would do is he would get in the Freddy suit, he would lure kids to the back and then kill them.
Amanda
I remember seeing this. I remember, like. Remember we saw an old man in the Freddy suit.
Courtney
That's. Well, that's William Afton. Yeah, we'll get there.
Amanda
Remember, what color was he at the fourth one? It was the beginning part. It almost looked like, like, what's Pac man game? Yeah, Remember it was like, dee Dee, dee, Dee dee. Yeah.
Spencer
Yeah. What color? That's. When I say eight bit. That's that pixely?
Amanda
Yeah. What color? What? Oh, yeah. But then. But then I remember the. The purple one looks familiar. But then I remember I could actually tell it was an old man.
Shane
Interesting.
Amanda
In the Freddy suit. And I can't remember which one it was.
Courtney
So he wasn't old. He was dead. I think if. If what you're talking about because, like, essentially, we'll get there. But.
Amanda
So that should be the title of this podcast.
Courtney
We'll get there.
Amanda
Essentially, we'll get there.
Courtney
So after the fourth game, blah, blah, blah, then you have, like, quickly, like, you know, the daughter, Henry, Emily's daughter, dies, becomes the puppet wild. Then you have the events of Five Nights at Freddy's 2.
Amanda
Henry, Emily's daughter was murdered by William Afton.
Shane
And the murderer. He's killing.
Courtney
He's the bad guy.
Shane
He is the ultimate bad guy.
Courtney
And then. And then. Then you have the events of Five Nights at Freddy's 2, which is the one where you're kind of. You're sitting there in the security room, and it's like. Yeah, it's black in front of you. You kind of click the flashlight. So that one you play Springtrap is.
Amanda
The only one that can.
Shane
That's three.
Courtney
No, that's three. That one's confusing.
Spencer
Two is the one where you didn't need to use the cameras.
Shane
That's the mask you put on the mask.
Amanda
Yes. I thought the mask. Right. I thought the mask was also. You use the flashlight in front and spring trap.
Shane
It's not spring trap. No.
Courtney
So Two is. Three is the one where you're just.
Shane
Seeing that guy, that bunny guy, that.
Spencer
That spring trap move differently.
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
One who'd be peeking at the. Out the doorway and looking at you. Oh, yeah, that's spring trap.
Courtney
It was the one we did mostly in VR where you have to pick the thing up and put it on.
Amanda
Yes.
Courtney
The mask comes straight down.
Shane
And that's where Chica's suddenly, like, different.
Amanda
Looking and also huge. In VR.
Courtney
Yeah.
Amanda
She is so tall in VR.
Courtney
So the second one, you play as, I think, kind of just a normal security guard for the first, like, five nights.
Spencer
Yeah. But it's the security shirt that makes the animatronics be like, oh, you're the bad guy.
Courtney
Yeah.
Amanda
Why? Oh, because William.
Courtney
Yeah, got it. But then it's a purple shirt. Basically, at the end of Five Nights at Freddy's 2, you are killed off screen. That is the bite of 87. That is when William Afton is.
Amanda
No, no. Oh, sorry, me, the security guard.
Courtney
Yeah, you, the security guard. And two, you have your frontal lobe bitten out. And like at a birthday party, because the phone guy who calls you is like, hey, like, I need you to like, you know, wear like the. Wear the security guard outfit and stay close to the animatronics. And then your frontal lobe is bitten out.
Amanda
Security guard is William Afton.
Courtney
No, no. And then.
Amanda
Come on.
Courtney
And then after. After he dies, there is like a sixth or seventh night, I'm not sure which. And that's when you take over and you play as Michael Afton, the other son, the son who accidentally killed his brother.
Amanda
But is he alive?
Courtney
He's alive. The brother.
Amanda
How does he live with himself?
Shane
He's alive. But he smells bad.
Courtney
Yeah, he's alive, but he smells bad.
Amanda
Why is that part of it?
Courtney
But then. So after two ends, then it goes into one and one. In the order or in chronological order, then it's one. And that is where you're playing as Mike Schmidt, AKA Michael Afton, who is William Afton's son, who is basically. He's going around. And at the end when it's like you're fired for tampering with the electronics, it's. Cause he's kind of trying to find and dismantle everything that's happening.
Amanda
So Michael is trying to. So Michael killed his brother. He's trying to dismantle the animatronics because he feels bad that he killed his brother and he wants to stop his dad or. Yeah, more or less he wants to stop his dad. Does he feel bad that he killed his brother, of course.
Shane
Yeah, I think he does.
Spencer
He was a kid as well.
Amanda
He was a kid as well. So he's actually. So who's the person calling?
Courtney
I think that might be William Afton.
Spencer
It's also. It's up for debate whether it's a phone call.
Amanda
That's what I just said. And you said no.
Courtney
Oh, I thought you were saying who the security guard is.
Amanda
No, the guy calling William Afton.
Courtney
Yeah, I think it's. I'm not sure. I think it might be William Afton.
Shane
I've never heard that it's William Afton. I've heard that it was Courtney.
Spencer
But it's also. It's open for debate if it's actually a phone call or if it's a tape that you're listening to.
Amanda
Oh.
Spencer
And not.
Amanda
That's what it says on there. Phone call or tape on the board. Oh.
Shane
So, yeah.
Amanda
God. The guy who created this was probably like, what did I do?
Shane
Literally, what's funny is, as Courtney said, like, these games would be made, but then Matpat and other theorists would, like, create this story that they think is going on, and that would then affect the games, what he then makes. And he. They're kind of one upping each other.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
Because that's why things.
Spencer
Their theories would be, like, better than his lore. And then he'd be kind of stubborn and wanting to be like, actually, it's something else, and try and like, it was a very. Like.
Amanda
So they were literally Mat. Pat, and this creator was literally Henry, Emily and William.
Courtney
Exactly.
Amanda
That's just a theory.
Shane
In many ways. Scott was William Afton and Matpat was Henry, Emily. And there was some jealousy. There was a lot of sounds like it. It's. You know what it's like. Do you remember the movie the Village?
Amanda
Of course.
Shane
Do you remember how that ending got leaked months before the movie came out? And then M. Night Shyamalan changed the ending, and the ending then sucked.
Amanda
The ending sucked. But I do not remember there being a leak.
Courtney
I don't remember.
Amanda
That's Ron Howard's daughter. And then what's Ron Howard's daughter? And then what's that other actor's name? Who's in.
Shane
We do this every episode.
Courtney
I've never seen it.
Shane
Who was that actor?
Courtney
I've never seen it.
Spencer
So much to cover.
Shane
Anyways, so back to this. But that's what was going on, and that's why the lore is confusing and there's a lot of debate and things often don't make sense. Or there's very. Got.
Amanda
It takes that I can understand because.
Shane
You know, like I said, Courtney is from the school of matpat. There's a lot.
Amanda
Spencer's from the school of vest.
Shane
Yeah, yeah. Spencer's from the school of vest. I don't know what's going on.
Amanda
And you're from.
Shane
I thought I. I thought I knew what was going on in every single sentence that said. I'm like, I know as much as Amanda. I knew that. But I wanted to get to the. The big first thing, which is great. It's ghosts. It's ghosts of children that are. That are controlling the now.
Amanda
The children are. What is their motive to, like, move around? They're trying to find William Afton or they're just trying to live and have a party?
Shane
I don't think they're trying to live and have a party. I think they are probably vengeful. Vengeful spirits.
Amanda
Are they vengeful?
Courtney
I think they're trying to.
Spencer
They're trying to get William Afton to stop.
Amanda
Got it. Understood.
Shane
So do we now move on to Five Nights at Freddy's 3?
Courtney
Sure. I don't know much about this one.
Shane
Oh, this was. This is the one that I think I.
Spencer
Perfect. Let me.
Shane
So Five Nights at Freddy's 3 is the one where it's kind of more of like it's years in the future, and it's like, oh, we want to make this haunted. Based on all these stories we've heard about Freddy Fazbear's and all the weird shit that's gone on there and the murders and supposed things that have happened. We want to make this horror attraction.
Courtney
Sorry, Real fast. Do you Remember which 13 is?
Shane
3 is the 1 where it's just the. That yellow rabbit coming. And then you'd have the flashes on screen, but it would be dead, and.
Amanda
You turn it off, and then you'd hear. Is that what you're talking about?
Shane
That's the bedroom.
Amanda
No, no, no, no, no. That weird hallway that. It was really dark and it was like a little game. And you turn on the light and rap to the spot.
Shane
No, that was four. That was for a minigame. That's a mini game in 4. 3 is the 1. 3 is the 1 with the computer where you'd have to reboot. Remember, it's like, reboot all.
Courtney
Let me show you what the room looks like in FNAF3. If that. It's like where you're in that room, like, the whole time. It's like where he pokes his head out of the. It's like he'll walk by.
Spencer
It might blend into.
Shane
Okay, yeah. That's one where you have to turn to the computer and it's like, oh, I have to reboot the systems.
Amanda
Oh, oh, remember? And we had to keep rebooting. And I was like, let's just reboot.
Shane
It all at once.
Amanda
And you were like, no, don't do that.
Shane
Just reboot the vents. Just. I remember whatever.
Amanda
When I was told not to do something that gets me.
Shane
Yeah.
Spencer
So we.
Courtney
Remember we got in trouble when we had to take you out back.
Shane
Yeah, yeah.
Amanda
It was awful.
Shane
Only being chased by the yellow rabbit. But there's the weird faces that would just pop up sometimes. Jarring. That was the first one where you, like, cried.
Amanda
Oh, yeah, yeah.
Shane
Oh, my God.
Amanda
That's. That's why I forgot it.
Shane
Yeah.
Spencer
And then you see, there was one really fucked up, messed up robot animatronic thing on the ground in one of the cameras. There was different eras where they would take away certain animatronics or bring in other ones.
Amanda
Yes.
Courtney
They vaulted them.
Spencer
And those shadows that you saw was their spirits. And it was like kind of the game being. So it's like you could get scared but still play. But it was like they called it Nightmare or Shadow Bunny.
Courtney
It's because you had to, like. It's like. It's because you're like running out of air. Remember you had to, like, reset the air.
Amanda
Now I remember. I remember that. The ventilation.
Shane
Yeah, but you're being. We're only running away from that yellow rabbit.
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
What is your theory? Did you have a theory on who that yellow rabbit was? Springtrap.
Amanda
Springtrap.
Shane
There's just the one guy. And we'd be sitting there being like, fuck you. Like, don't I remember that.
Amanda
Well, now I have more of a theory than I did back then. Maybe it's the. Well, you said none of the kids are in the animatronics.
Shane
Well, the spirits of children are in these animatronics.
Amanda
So which spirit of. Yeah, but.
Spencer
But the. The bodies were eventually found. They did, like, find. But then the animatronics were still left behind.
Amanda
Oh. So the possession. So it wouldn't be Springtrap, wouldn't be the youngest son, the bite of 83.
Shane
I like that. I like that. Guess, though the story's pretty insane. You're probably not going to tell me. It's. It's a lot. I. So I know the general one.
Spencer
And then we can add that. We can solve.
Shane
You can add the. Add the Details. So William Afton's killing all these children, right?
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
But he's. He's. He eventually ends up. He goes back to the Five Nights at Freddy's. Or he goes back to Freddy Fazbear's Pizza. He's there and then he sees the ghosts of these children and they.
Spencer
And it's famously known that it's five of them.
Shane
Five of these children. And he sees them. He's freaking out. They chase him and corner him. We got to this cutscene at one point in Five Nights at Freddy's three.
Amanda
Yes.
Shane
Where they all. They all show up. And you see this yellow bunny suit.
Amanda
Yes.
Shane
And there's this purple guy. And you're like, who's this purple guy? He then is like, okay, you're not gonna get me. I'm gonna stop you.
Spencer
I'm gonna hide in this suit.
Shane
I'm gonna hide in this suit. I'm gonna get in this suit.
Amanda
William Afton.
Shane
William Afton, the guy who killed all these children, the guy behind it all. He gets into this suit and then the springlock stuff messes up and it skewers him and just completely decimates his body on the inside.
Amanda
So he's now possessed.
Shane
This is what's really crazy. Fucks him up. He's there in this room. Nobody finds him for decades. And he doesn't die. He refuses to die because he's such a hateful, vengeful, crazy person.
Courtney
I aspire.
Shane
This is where the game takes a train to crazy town.
Amanda
Okay.
Shane
He doesn't die. He's just in the suit, basically, as it's like weird, undead, robotic nightmare person. And he's there until it's. That's found and it's brought to that horror attraction. And so that is literally William Afton coming after you. He's just a murderous monster.
Spencer
And one of the fun things that's on this board that's like, for example of how people are putting some of these things together, is this kid who's leading the other kids in chasing him. You see on this shot, there's a tear streaming down with an eye very similar to. These are tears going down the puppet's face.
Amanda
That is so sad.
Shane
That's the. That's Henry's daughter who is leading all, like, helping all these spirits get revenge. And then he was. He's like. He's like, I refuse to die. I refuse. So then he's in this suit now, and he just doesn't die. Because he just doesn't die.
Amanda
And he's the worst looking One.
Shane
Yeah, he's super messy.
Spencer
That's why he moved differently than the animatronics that were just like.
Amanda
Yeah, because he doesn't understand well, because he's a body.
Spencer
He's like. They're just spirits within a actual animatronic. And so he's a. He's literally.
Amanda
That is so scary. I think that if I knew that, the games would be scarier.
Shane
Really?
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
See, I think that made it less scary for me because I'm just like, oh, there's all this crazy lore.
Amanda
Oh, I think. I think attaching like. Like I know it's not true. Well, I don't know. Attaching those type of facts to it would make it scarier for me.
Courtney
Wow.
Amanda
Yeah.
Shane
Are there any questions you have? Like, as far as the first four games that you are curious about?
Amanda
So William Afton's son Michael killed his brother by accident. He was young. He felt really, really bad about it. So he became the security guard. And William Afton was like, oh, fuck, I can't believe this is happening, but I wanna keep going. And then because he was so upset, he wanted to figure out the possession of his own son. He started killing kids, stuffing them in the animatronics. And the animatronics started coming as the possessed souls. And then he had this. During all of that, William Afton had this kind of like, fuck you, one upping situation with Henry Emily. And then he kills Henry, Emily's daughter, and then she becomes a puppet and then kind of protects the realm. And then all the souls of the kids go after him. And then he jumps into the yellow bunny and then he's now springtrap and fucked up. That's what I've gotten so far, honestly.
Spencer
Pretty good. You gathered it really well.
Shane
Yeah. Look, people in the comments might dispute some things, but.
Spencer
Oh, our comments.
Shane
You're going to, you know. You know, the general story. I like.
Spencer
Your comments are going to be a nightmare.
Amanda
I like information. I like information. Like, I didn't realize this about myself, but Garde's always just like, okay, you won't. You won't like, say yes until you get all the information. Like, I love information so much. So I am eating this up right now. Whether. Whether it's true or not, whatever.
Courtney
This is our theory also for.
Shane
For people watching, we will have you watch the Matpat videos so you can then fully know. But this is like the introduction.
Amanda
I'll watch him if I can meet him.
Shane
Because this is us regurgitating Matpat. As far as we interpreted it to you. So it's a game of telephone, and we're probably fucking up a lot, but that's okay. This is fun.
Amanda
Big question. Should I watch the movie?
Spencer
I want to watch it with you.
Amanda
Okay.
Spencer
Yeah, but it's also. The movie doesn't align very much with this lore. It's confusing.
Shane
It's a kind of a different.
Spencer
It's a weird Frankenstein.
Shane
More of a.
Spencer
Honestly, it's visually really cool. Blumhouse did the best they could with the script.
Amanda
Got it understood.
Courtney
And they had, I think, Jim Henson Co. Make all the puppets.
Spencer
Not even joking.
Shane
No, it's really cool looking.
Amanda
That's really.
Courtney
Or sorry, not the puppets, but like, animatronics son. And, like. Because I think his son took over the.
Spencer
It's really cool.
Amanda
His son took over the company because he did what to his other kid.
Courtney
Yeah, because Jim Henson. See, Jim Henson and Stan Winston had a.
Shane
No, no, we're joking.
Courtney
That.
Shane
It's a Henry, Emily, William Afton situation.
Courtney
Jim Henson was a real.
Amanda
Okay. What else?
Shane
Okay, I guess we get into sister.
Courtney
Location now, which takes place kind of in between four and two up for debate.
Amanda
Sister location is.
Courtney
That was the. That was the one where you guys. It was the first one where you guys were like. This is really different. It's, like, where you, like, crawling and you have.
Amanda
Oh, I was not a fan of this one. The door. The door, yeah.
Shane
You're trying to hold the door.
Amanda
The goddamn door.
Shane
Yeah. It's awful.
Courtney
You're holding the door from. Yeah, that baby.
Amanda
The ba. This one drove me nuts. Okay.
Shane
Yeah. So that one. You are playing as Michael Afton?
Courtney
I believe so, yes.
Shane
And I see. I heard chronologically that this could. This could take place. Who fucking knows when? But you are playing as Michael Afton. Now, the crazy thing about this one. Do you remember this girl was the one who was, like, talking to us and leading us around.
Amanda
She did it. She talked so much, man.
Shane
So the theory is that that is William Afton's daughter who got scooped.
Amanda
Scooped.
Spencer
You just used the word scooped. She didn't know what that is.
Amanda
What's scooped?
Courtney
She got scooped.
Amanda
What? Scooped?
Shane
Did she get scooped?
Courtney
Yeah, it's scooped.
Amanda
Give me the definition of scooped.
Spencer
So these animatronics had. They were like a different model, very different from the other stuff. And they had these weird, mysterious storage compartments in their abdomen. And so you might have seen in some of the gameplay, where you look at blueprints of these animatronics that you could almost see, like a child inside of the abdomen of these Things. And so basically, the kids love these. Some of the kids love these animatronics. The daughter loved them. Some of the cutscenes, you see the brother, like, seeing her in the backyard playing with her little FNAF dolls. And she was just like, courtney. Yeah. And, like, you might have heard a recording of the daughter being like, hey, like, why won't you let me near the animatronics? Like, I really didn't you make her for me? Oh, that made. And the daughter saying that made this one because they wanted to be alive. It was like a weird storm of William Afton wanting to create life for himself to live on forever. But also then it was just. This factory wasn't just making these animatronics. It was harvesting children's souls. Because there was something special and magical about a child's soul that is truly magic and can be used as this infinite energy that he was trying to use. And so she snatches the kid up and puts her in there, and then she's stuck in there.
Amanda
She scoops her. Is that what scooping is?
Spencer
Scooping is a thing that happens in the factory where it's supposedly for the robots, but it ends up being done to people, and it becomes this weird back and forth where William Afton is trying to basically create life. And then these robots want to be alive.
Amanda
Oh.
Spencer
So there's books and there's cut scenes that kind of make it. That. It's potentially feels like one of those.
Amanda
Typical stories where, like, the mad scientist, his project takes over.
Shane
Yeah.
Amanda
Ex machina.
Shane
That's very much. I think, fnaf.
Amanda
That's what this feels like.
Shane
FNAF is just like, X Mina.
Amanda
It's kind of.
Courtney
Yeah. Essentially his daughter. So he's already lost the son. He's already lost Ethan or What?
Shane
Evan.
Courtney
Evan.
Amanda
Bite of 83.
Courtney
He already lost Ian Hecox from Smoke. And then he's like, this can't happen again. Blah, blah, blah, blah. And then, you know, as he's like, making all these other robots. Cause he's fucking stupid. His daughter is left alone with baby. And baby.
Amanda
Baby's like, baby wants baby inside of baby.
Courtney
Exactly. And then baby kills and then is ultimately possesses. I don't remember.
Spencer
Her eyes change colors in the game. You see, the daughter has. I think it's. The daughter has blue eyes and baby had green eyes. And when that might be switched. And then when the daughter gets possesses the robot, her eye colors change to the daughter's color.
Shane
Oh.
Amanda
Because baby's like, I want to know what it's like to have the child's soul in me.
Courtney
Well, if you listen, this was the. I listened to this, like, right before we did this. You hear. It's when you're, like, pulling the fucking door shut.
Amanda
I hate that.
Courtney
It's like when you're in the door, you hear baby talking to you, and baby's like, hey. Like, I was in the room with this girl and, you know, I gave her ice cream, and the next thing I knew, like, she was inside my stomach. She was like. And she was like, that's where I think you guys heard her. She's like, oh. The screaming stopped, like, really quickly.
Amanda
I remember this now. That. See, that makes it way scarier. Whereas, like, when I was doing it, I was so annoyed with the fucking door that now I would be like, oh, God.
Courtney
And I think that is the freaky. If I can get bigger picture here for a minute, I think that's what's hard to do about horror and like, horror games especially, you have to know the lore.
Amanda
Well.
Courtney
No, it's like the second you get frustrated, the second it kind of becomes not scary. And I think that's what you guys were encountering a lot in the newest one.
Shane
It's like, security breach. Yeah.
Courtney
Second, you guys, we were getting frustrated.
Amanda
So we weren't as scared. So the game wasn't as fun.
Courtney
Yeah. Like, you want in a horror game to feel like if you fail, then it should becomes frustrating. But if it's like, if you, like, feel like. If you feel like you're about to fail, that's when it's really.
Shane
Yeah. Tension is what's scary. And that's why, like, when we did VR, what was so scary for me is I never saw the animatronics. And that actually made it worse for me because I was just, like, waiting to see them.
Spencer
The Jaws effect, because that's the thing with horror is, like, sometimes it's a perfect amount of mystery that makes it more scary. And I think that that's also why those games weren't as scary, because you're seeing too much.
Courtney
You're seeing way they're like, they're like interacting with you. You're like crawling around in Freddy Fazbear. He's like, well, he's walking you around like there's not there in daylight.
Spencer
And the movie. The movie fucks up in that way where you see too much and you're like, you get the ick.
Amanda
You don't want to see. You don't want to see too much. It's like the Classic movie Halloween. Like, that was one of the first real horror movies that really did that so well, which is what you don't see is the scariest part. And it's just a guy with a mask. But that movie is terrifying.
Shane
It's why, like, my favorite of all the games and the one I had the most fun playing was the first one because it's just so minimal and you're just truly in a room. You're looking at security cameras, and they're just there. They're just static. They're not moving around. And that always freaked me the hell out the most. Once you get. Later on, you're seeing them move around. I'm just like. I'm not as scared now. Like, there's too much going on when it's just, like, still images, still security cameras knowing.
Amanda
I think the. Knowing that they're getting closer, but you can't see them. You can only see them through, like, a blurry image.
Courtney
It's brilliant, frankly.
Spencer
Like, signs.
Amanda
It's really, really brilliant.
Spencer
Do you want to get back to it?
Shane
Yeah. A theory that I. Maybe I misinterpreted this from Matpat, but I think something that made me less scared just thinking about the story itself is at the end. Because we didn't beat a lot of these games, but at the end.
Amanda
Well, we tried.
Shane
We did try. We tried our best. We really did. But at the end of Sister Location and you're playing as Michael Afton, it. What happens at the end of that game is that you get scooped.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
You get led to a room by Baby. She. She leads you to a room, and it then scoops all. Everything out of him. And then he is replaced.
Spencer
They replace what they scooped out with an animatronic, like a machine.
Shane
So Michael Afton is actually an animatronic, which.
Amanda
Animatronic.
Shane
Just.
Spencer
He's a human with animatronic insides. Then it starts getting really messed up because then these robots, they start wanting to take on the people. It's like the roles are reversed and there's cutscenes of him walking around in the world, and his body gets more and more messed up because he's basically this walking corpse, but with a machine moving his body.
Shane
And so he smells bad.
Courtney
That's why he's stinky.
Amanda
Wait, guys. I don't remember playing it and having the smell bad thing ever be a thing.
Spencer
It's a cut scene. I don't get it either.
Courtney
It's only at the end, when it's fired for tampering with A machine and odor.
Amanda
Oh, I remember that. And I was like, that's weird.
Shane
So. Oh, that makes a lot of stuff crazier. Is that the entire time you're playing as an animatronic person?
Courtney
Kind of. Yeah.
Amanda
Like, the rest of those games are, when am I playing as an animatronic?
Courtney
As One and Five Nights at Freddy's One and Two, you're playing as Michael Afton, who has been scooped and is a dead guy, but who's still, like.
Spencer
He'S trying to fix it.
Courtney
He's driven to solve the. Or, like, resolve the.
Amanda
Make amends for his father's mistakes. Wow.
Spencer
So he's trying to, like, the. William Afton was, like. Had a. Like, a side quest of, like, making synthetic people. Almost, like. And that's what Michael Afton ended up becoming was like. Because it's like, robot inside, look, person outside. And a lot of the books are like. I guess they're not the best written, but, like, there's books where it's, like, about the daughter and how she might have been taken on by Baby. But the story is about this young girl who's, like, she's grown up, and then she starts to learn that she's not a real person. And she was supposedly the daughter of William Afton. So, like, there's all these weird, interesting side plots of him. He literally tried to recreate his kids with this soul energy and with robotics.
Amanda
I see. So the kids are just dealing with the father's madness.
Spencer
Did you ever meet her? Did you ever meet her?
Amanda
I do remember her.
Shane
She's the one in the dark room that we're trying to hide.
Courtney
The ballerina.
Spencer
She sings.
Shane
Yes, Mother. Yeah.
Spencer
So it's really annoying to me because Matpat at first totally dismissed her, and a lot of people don't really pay attention to her. But it's, like, so obvious to me that William Afton made her after his wife. Because there's so many, like, cutscenes where there's upset, disgruntled wife and literally baby the daughter and then this woman. So that's why I put Mother, because it's, like, very obviously, like, I don't think it's her soul, but I think she left him and he wanted to replace her. In a sense, he's definitely left him. That's my personal theory.
Amanda
I believe that that feels like it's like, why else?
Spencer
And then people are like, no, he just wanted to make more sexy characters because there is this community that, like, totally sexualizes the animatronics, and it's It's a thing. It's a different.
Courtney
It's a pretty awesome community and it's frankly pretty children.
Amanda
Yes.
Shane
So what was funny is when you were like, talking about Chica is. It's like. Is Chica a baby or a woman? It's like kind of both. But a ghost of a child.
Amanda
Well, she's both, but the young child is stunted in growth. They're not growing up to be adults. Right.
Shane
I guess.
Amanda
But then again, why did the animatronic change so much? Is it a different animatronic?
Spencer
There's constantly new models, so it's a different model.
Amanda
So the kid goes off and possesses the new models?
Shane
No, I don't think so.
Courtney
I think they're just fully different, like updated.
Amanda
So maybe it's a possession of someone else, but it's not an adult.
Shane
Well, I think he also murdered more kids than those five.
Spencer
Yeah. Oh, yeah, no, those are just the original five. So. Yeah, I think you're right where it's like. Yeah. He was literally harvesting children's soul energy in this sister location facility where he's creating all these robots and that's what powered them.
Courtney
And that's where you see, it's like the underground. Like, it is like the sister location. I think it might be under his house.
Spencer
And that's way too where the fungus is.
Courtney
Or the funguses.
Shane
Where the fungus is.
Courtney
The fungus is the soul energy I don't think we really addressed. But in five Nights at Freddy's four, you know, where you're like the sun, you're running around and blah, blah, blah.
Amanda
Yeah, that sun was so annoying.
Courtney
You know, there's like the animatronic, like the little mini fazbear on the bed. That's how the dad would kind of keep him in check. It's got like, camera eyes. And I think you see the footage, like, of that, like later in the.
Spencer
Game, his little toy and it talks to him, right?
Courtney
Yeah, that's like, you know, his surrogate dad kind of like, you know, I.
Spencer
Thought it was just like him. Yeah. Just surveying his.
Courtney
Yeah, so, like, there's like surveillance cameras in the. In, like all throughout the house.
Amanda
So when the little kid, Evan, is going through one of the games, he's not dead yet.
Courtney
He's not dead, but he dies in the game, like, kind of like off camera.
Shane
I didn't know that.
Courtney
Like.
Spencer
Well, because sometimes in the gameplay you see, like, hospital stuff. You might not have paid attention to the environment so much.
Courtney
Well, I don't think y'all got that far. Which understandable, is so scary. That gives it.
Shane
Yeah. There are occasional moments, I guess in the game where if. And I need to just watch someone else play it again because I watched Markiplier play it. But you'll occasionally see like, is it like an IV or something? You'll see like bottles. So it's like once you're on the fourth night or fifth night.
Courtney
Yeah.
Shane
And so you're like, oh, wait, why is the environment kind of changing? And it's because then I guess supposedly you're then playing.
Courtney
So like the first four nights you're like having a nightmare. And then in between like night four and five or five and six or whatever, that's when the bite of 83 occurs. You're in the coma and you're in the coma. And then like, as you're dying, you have like the one last like nightmare. And that's when your father's like, I will put you back together.
Shane
That's truly the most horrifying plotline of any of the games. And that's. That is also the worst game to play. Is so terrifying.
Amanda
I love that we're putting all of this information and then attaching game to it.
Shane
I know. It's like game and the game is like so minimal and silly. No.
Spencer
Because when in Matpat's videos he's telling all this lore and story and showing cutscenes, but he doesn't show a single lick of gameplay. It's so.
Courtney
It's because you see the gameplay and you're just like.
Shane
Yeah, you're just like.
Courtney
The gameplay's not. It's sitting guy. But it's funny. I mean, even all these like horrific events, when you see them in the like, in the like cutscenes, it's just like. And then like the worst thing ever happened. You see like those silly little.
Shane
All told in eight.
Amanda
So do we know which kids are in which animation?
Shane
I don't think like there are.
Spencer
There is content that it says there's.
Courtney
Like they all like. Like one of the kids. I think one of the kids names is like Fritz or something silly.
Spencer
It's Fitzgerald who's in Chica.
Amanda
That's what I want to know.
Spencer
A girl. A little girl.
Shane
Little girl.
Amanda
She's hungry Now.
Shane
I don't even know the answer to this, but is like another kid in Balloon Boy and stuff.
Courtney
Is it, I don't know, the balloon Boy.
Amanda
We gotta give this a. Shane, this is.
Shane
He needs to think.
Spencer
Okay, so the kid. Okay, so there is a child within Balloon Boy. His name is Shane Topp.
Amanda
Yeah, it's me. And he keeps coming in. Hello.
Shane
Hello, it's me.
Amanda
Hello.
Courtney
Hello.
Amanda
So we need to know balloon boy lore.
Spencer
I don't know balloon boy lore.
Shane
I don't either. I think I wanted to cover just that it's ghosts.
Spencer
Yeah. And there was a lot of. And a lot of these animatronics. Like the puppet. It was supposed to be like surveillance by like purpose.
Amanda
Yeah.
Spencer
And it was a surveillance thing for not just for the kids spirits, but like when it was built for Henry, Emily, the pizza place. It was to watch kids.
Amanda
Oh.
Spencer
Just to like. Oh, I'm sorry.
Courtney
So balloon boys. His. His pronouns are he, him. According to the five nights at Freddy's Wiki as five nights at Freddy's wiki is fan made.
Amanda
Oh, it is.
Spencer
Yeah, it's all. It's all fan made. But the creator of these games be popping off on Twitter or at least used to be.
Courtney
Yeah, there's no lore on the wiki.
Spencer
Good job. Well, I guess the literally interrupted me deep into some lore to give us nothing. Go off, girl. Give us nothing.
Courtney
He wears blue pants and simple brown shoes.
Shane
Wow. See, I didn't know that.
Courtney
See, I actually didn't know that due to the fact that his only lines of dialogue depict him saying hello, hi. And laughter. Balloon boy's personality is not clearly specified.
Spencer
Yeah, but the way that the. So but all of those. These animatronics that were being made and with the timeline being all crazy. This sister location where it was the facility where they like they made a lot of these animatronics. These animatronics weren't just in the facilities, they were also rented out to birthday parties. So there was like, I think you could see a schedule of availability, a schedule of availability for each of the animatronics. And you could see like, oh, Chica wasn't available because she was either in maintenance or at a party. And like so balloon boy could have been made and then they all just like had at some point they just had a soul, a generic soul that was just taken at some point.
Courtney
And we haven't even gotten to brother location.
Amanda
But doesn't that. Is that made up? Yeah, but doesn't that suck that you die and you have to possess and then you have to work kids parties. It's almost like getting killed. And then you're like, all right, well you're dead. Sorry about that. Go work this princess party. You're gonna be Cinderella for a bunch of 10 year olds. Her fate words to death. Yeah, I don't.
Courtney
I like. I think balloon. But, like, some might just legit be animatronics. Because, like, the animatronics work they do. Like, you can, like, might just legit just be an animatronic.
Spencer
Like, they sing songs and give ice cream. Like, that's like the whole thing.
Courtney
Have you met Charles Entertainment? Cheese?
Amanda
No.
Courtney
Chuck E. Cheese. Oh, I.
Amanda
So when I was a kid, I did not like going to Chuck E. Cheese because I don't like animatronics and dolls. I get scared of them.
Shane
I like dolls, animatronics.
Amanda
I'm not around animatronics that much, but, like, I don't. I remember Chuck E. Cheese being like, even remember in the Goofy movie when they went to go to a pizza place and they had fake animatronics and it was kind of a scary scene. Do you remember that?
Spencer
Well, I mean, what's crazy is one. So you know how the thing that started, the thing that started all of this, which was them telling you that Five Nights was a true story. The game itself is roughly inspired by a true story that happened at Chuck E. Cheese. And this is Trigger Warning. It is, like, based on a real murder that happened. It was an ex employee came into a Chuck E. Cheese after hours. Like, a party was running late, and five employees were still there. Five. And they were all, I'm so sorry, this is dark. But they were shot. And he thought he killed all five of them. But the fifth person was still alive, survived. And then that person was put to trial and arrested.
Amanda
So that person was able to be like, no, no.
Spencer
This happened where this person thought he killed all them in Chuck E. Cheese. They were not in the suits.
Amanda
Well, I need to look this up.
Spencer
Yeah, that's what started it all. And that was in the early 90s, I believe.
Shane
Damn.
Amanda
This is like, it's such a crazy story. But it's also like, you know how they say there's like 10 stories and we just keep doing theories based on those 10 main stories? This is true. It's like very much greed, hunger. Well, yeah, kind of hunger, but greedy jealousy and, like, having a bunch of people pay for, like, one person's greed and their mistakes. It's very much that story. But shall I say it's also very fungus like, because everything is connected and all the animatronics are also. They're kind of like talking to each other. So really, I was correct.
Shane
Yeah, I think you were right.
Courtney
It's like a spectral fungus.
Shane
Well, the creator of Five Nights at Freddy's could Come out and say, you know what? Actually, Amanda's correct.
Spencer
Yeah, he might.
Shane
He could change it all and then that's it. That's true.
Amanda
Now I doubt it, but that's awesome.
Shane
Yeah.
Amanda
This was unbelievable.
Spencer
Yeah. There's also so much we didn't touch on. Some things might have been out of order. Like, there is all. There is cutscenes and stuff that has. Stuff that happened to Emily, Stuff that happened to Henry. Emily, the business partner.
Amanda
Yeah. I want to know about that.
Spencer
But, yeah, I feel like. I feel like. I feel pretty good about what we told Amanda today.
Shane
You now could have a conversation with someone about it.
Amanda
Absolutely. When I meet Matpat, we will talk.
Shane
Literally. No, I mean, look, I tried reaching out to him. I've had no success. But when someday we do have him on, because that's my dream. You will be able to just riff on it now.
Amanda
So you'll have Matpat on, and I'll have Keith Morrison on, and we'll bring them on. On the same episode.
Shane
Exactly.
Spencer
Amazing.
Shane
They're basically the same.
Amanda
Oh, okay.
Courtney
But it's also. It's also important to note that we didn't really get to any of, like, the resolutions of any of this. Like, some of the games do kind of try and, like, resolve this.
Shane
Yeah.
Courtney
But it's just like, frankly, there's been, like. There's like, five different endings where it's like. And then they finally kill William Afton. But he's back.
Shane
Yeah, but we didn't play some of the games.
Spencer
Yeah. There's one thing he says. He says, I always come back.
Shane
Yeah. But, you know, the general idea, you know, it's ghosts now.
Amanda
It's not for Guys have launched me into the beginning of my research.
Shane
Yeah. And I will be sending you the entire playlist of Matpat's explanations.
Spencer
We should make sure we send her the important ones. You can see when you get the playlist, you can see there's, like, some that have, like, 600,000 views. And then you'll see some that have, like, 48 million views.
Amanda
48 million.
Shane
Yeah. He's Matpat.
Courtney
And the problem. Not the problem. But, you know, when he's making the earlier videos, he doesn't have all the information, like, because no one did. So he's making, like, his theories based on, like, just playing the first two, and then by the time the third or fourth one comes out, it'll kind of, like, undermine or cancel, like, things that, like, he cancel out.
Spencer
Yeah.
Courtney
Like predicted. So I would recommend. And, you know, we'll try and curate. Like, you know, maybe we'll post something in the comments too, or the. In the description. It's like, hey, I love that idea.
Spencer
It's hard journalism and research that he's done. Like, he worked so hard. Don't laugh at that.
Shane
No, I'm saying it's. It's. It. There's a truth to it.
Spencer
I don't even know how many hours he spent researching the gameplay itself, all these forums, and trying to make sense of it all himself, like. And he truly told an amazing story. So much so that he threw the creator for a loop. And honestly, it all imploded on itself.
Shane
Whoa.
Amanda
So he became the mad scientist. No, he's Henry, Emily. That's what you.
Spencer
And then with the VR game that potentially plays into it, where it's like, oh, he sold off the gameplay, but turns out Springtrap is inside the VR because you, as an employee of this VR company, are inspecting the games when you're playing them, and you get led down to actually let Springtrap out on accident. It's crazy.
Amanda
Which is William Afton. Yeah, you think? But that's just the theory. You said it. So cool.
Shane
I said it.
Amanda
I'm so cool.
Shane
Well, thank you both for being here.
Amanda
Yes. Thank you so much for covering this.
Shane
For me, because I didn't know.
Amanda
And this board. We need to take a picture of this board and post.
Shane
Oh, this is the thumbnail.
Amanda
Okay.
Shane
Just that none of us just picture Matpat. Amanda. The five nights at Freddy's Journey has been insane.
Spencer
Oh, and there's so much I didn't get to say.
Shane
I know we scratched the surface. I'm sure there's inconsistencies and people who.
Spencer
Are watching right now. If you're a FNAF fan and this made your little soul cringe, I'm so sorry, but it's all just a theory, like Amanda said.
Amanda
That's right.
Shane
Yeah. That's what Amanda's known for saying. That's just a theory.
Amanda
Yep.
Shane
A game theory.
Courtney
Okay, now he's never gonna Come on.
Shane
Yeah, I know.
Amanda
Don't do that. Hey, Henry, Emily, it's fine. Just come on the show.
Shane
Yeah, come on down, Henry, Emily. Thank you all for watching Amanda. Thanks for being such a sport throughout all this.
Amanda
Oh, my God, I love it. I was so, so, so curious, and now I have this information. Thanks for spending so much time on it. I appreciate it. I'm excited. I love scary shit.
Spencer
Love you.
Amanda
Love you.
Shane
All right.
Amanda
I guess I, I. I'm attracted to you. What's going, huh?
Podcast Summary: Smosh Mouth Episode #49 - Explaining Five Nights At Freddy's Lore To Amanda
Release Date: June 10, 2024
Introduction
In episode #49 of Smosh Mouth, hosts Shane Topp and Amanda Lehan-Canto delve deep into the intricate lore of the popular horror game series Five Nights at Freddy's (FNAF). Joined by special guests Spencer and Courtney, the group embarks on a mission to unravel the complex narrative that has both fascinated and baffled fans for years. This episode aims to provide a comprehensive overview of FNAF's storyline, character motivations, and various fan theories, making it accessible even to those unfamiliar with the series.
1. The Journey Begins: Pranks and Gameplay
The episode kicks off with Shane reminiscing about a long-running prank where he and Spencer convinced Amanda that Five Nights at Freddy's was based on true events. This led Amanda to play several games in the series, sparking her fascination with the lore.
Amanda admits her enthusiasm, contrasting Shane's initial dread of the games.
2. Introduction of Special Guests and the Conspiracy Board
Courtney joins the conversation, unveiling an elaborate conspiracy board designed to map out the FNAF lore meticulously.
3. Exploring the Origins: William Afton and Henry Emily
The discussion shifts to the foundational characters of the FNAF universe—William Afton and Henry Emily—and their roles in creating the animatronics.
Shane highlights Afton's obsession with animatronics and his descent into madness following a tragic family incident.
4. Major Plot Points and Game Chronology
The hosts outline the chronological order of the FNAF games, emphasizing significant events such as the "Bite of 83" and "Bite of 87," which are pivotal to understanding the overarching story.
Amanda shares her evolving understanding of the lore, acknowledging inaccuracies while appreciating the depth of the narrative.
5. The Role of Possession and Vengeful Spirits
A central theme in the FNAF lore is the possession of animatronics by the spirits of murdered children. The discussion delves into how these souls interact with the living and each other.
Amanda presents her theory connecting the animatronics through a metaphorical "fungus," suggesting an underlying interconnectedness.
6. Michael Afton's Quest and Transformation into an Animatronic
The narrative progresses to Michael Afton, William's son, who seeks to undo his father's wrongdoings. This journey leads to his transformation into an animatronic hybrid.
7. The Puppet and Protection of Spirits
Henry Emily's daughter, who becomes the Puppet, plays a crucial role in safeguarding the souls of the children and guiding them towards vengeance against William Afton.
8. Fan Theories and Creator Interaction
The conversation touches upon the influence of fan theories, particularly those by MatPat, and how they may intersect or diverge from the creator Scott Cawthon's intended storyline.
Notable Quotes
9. The Impact of Gameplay Design on Horror Effectiveness
The hosts discuss how the minimalist design of the earlier games, relying on static images and limited animations, enhances the horror experience by leveraging player imagination.
They compare this to other horror media, such as the classic movie Halloween, emphasizing the power of suggestion over explicit visuals.
10. Conclusion and Future Discussions
As the episode wraps up, Amanda reflects on her newfound understanding of the FNAF lore, expressing excitement for future deep dives and potential guest appearances from notable theorists like MatPat.
Final Thoughts
Episode #49 of Smosh Mouth serves as a thorough introduction to the convoluted and captivating world of Five Nights at Freddy's. Through collaborative discussion, the hosts and their guests dissect key elements of the lore, offering both established facts and personal interpretations. Not only does this episode cater to long-time fans seeking a deeper understanding, but it also invites newcomers to explore the rich narrative tapestry that FNAF presents. With plans to engage further with prominent theorists and possibly integrate expert insights, Smosh Mouth promises to continue unraveling the mysteries that make FNAF a standout in the horror genre.