Podcast Summary: Snapped: Women Who Murder
Episode: BONUS: Susan and Blaine Barksdale (Snapped: Killer Couples)
Release Date: June 12, 2025
Host: Oxygen

Introduction

In this compelling bonus episode of Snapped: Killer Couples, Oxygen delves into the harrowing case of Susan and Blaine Barksdale. This true crime narrative spans over several seasons of investigations, uncovering the dark motivations and intricate dynamics that led to Frank Bly's tragic demise. The episode meticulously details the events leading up to the arson, the subsequent manhunt, and the eventual apprehension of the Barksdales.

Frank Bly: A Life Before Tragedy

Frank Bly, a 72-year-old retired Air Force veteran, had settled into a peaceful retirement in Tucson, Arizona. As Frank’s brother recounts, Frank was deeply connected to his community and maintained a close-knit circle with his family. “He kept his circle very small. He was close with his brother and his family and was living his life” (08:09).

Frank's background as a helicopter and jet mechanic for Grumman Northrop, working on top-secret projects like stealth fighters or bombers, showcased his disciplined and structured nature. His hobbies, including an extensive gun collection and motorcycle riding, painted a picture of a man who enjoyed both his solitary pursuits and occasional adventures with friends.

The Fateful Fire

On April 16, 2019, tranquility was shattered when a devastating fire engulfed Frank Bly's home in Tucson. Neighbors reported hearing an explosion and seeing the house fully consumed by flames. “The owner of the house is missing” (00:26). Firefighters struggled to control the blaze, which ultimately destroyed the residence, leaving investigators with limited physical evidence due to the extensive damage.

Initial Investigation

Tucson Police Department treated the incident as a potential homicide from the outset. Investigators discovered large, open, and empty safes inside the house, raising suspicions of deliberate arson possibly linked to theft or robbery. Despite the thorough search, Frank Bly was nowhere to be found, intensifying concerns about his whereabouts.

Frank's Disappearance

Shortly after the fire, Frank's brother, William Skip Bly, became alarmed by his brother's sudden lack of communication. “I knew something wasn't right” (05:14). Skip contacted law enforcement, leading detectives to the charred remains of Frank’s house. The missing red passenger car from Frank’s property became a critical lead in the investigation.

Unraveling Connections: Susan and Blaine Barksdale

Investigators traced Frank’s last known contact to Susan Barksdale, a longtime friend married to Blaine Barksdale. Interviews revealed that Susan and Blaine had recently traveled with Frank, and their interactions raised red flags. “Susan promises to contact authorities if she hears from Frank” (14:19), but soon after, evidence pointed towards their possible involvement.

Discovery of Evidence in Frank’s Vehicle

A significant breakthrough occurred when authorities found Frank’s red car abandoned on Wilmot Road, 10 miles from his residence. Inside the trunk, investigators discovered residues of blood and gasoline-soaked rags. “We were treating it as a homicide” (10:29). DNA tests confirmed that the blood was Frank’s, leading to the conclusion that he had been severely injured and likely murdered.

The Barksdales on the Run

Further investigations revealed that Susan and Blaine had purchased a motorhome and were attempting to flee. A harrowing phone call from Susan’s daughter, Jada, indicated that Susan feared Blaine and believed she was in danger. Authorities traced their movements to New York, where the couple was eventually located in a motel parking lot. “They were nowhere to be found” (20:29) until their dramatic arrest, which involved the use of beanbag rounds to subdue Blaine (42:05).

Confessions and Motives

Under intense interrogation, Blaine Barksdale confessed to orchestrating the arson that led to Frank’s death. “[Blaine] had the combinations” to Frank’s gun safes and had been stealing firearms to sell for quick cash. Susan testified that she was coerced into assisting Blaine, claiming she was a victim of his threats and abuse. “Susan feels that Blaine forced her to clean up the evidence” (35:06).

The Manhunt and Escape Attempt

The Barksdales’ attempt to evade capture included kidnapping their escort during extradition, showcasing Blaine’s desperate and dangerous nature. Their escape intensified the manhunt, involving multiple law enforcement agencies and culminating in a tense standoff in northern Arizona. “Blaine was pretty agitated. Still wasn't compliant” (42:05).

Resolution: Sentencing and Aftermath

Ultimately, Blaine accepted a plea deal, pleading guilty to second-degree murder in exchange for revealing the location of Frank’s body, which was found in Salt River Canyon on January 4, 2022. Susan received a lesser sentence for manslaughter, acknowledging her coerced involvement. “None of this would have happened to Frank if it weren't for Blaine, and none of it would have happened to Frank if it weren't for Susan” (45:08). Frank’s brother expressed lifelong grief and the enduring pain of losing his brother under such tragic circumstances.

Conclusion

This episode of Snapped: Killer Couples intricately weaves the narrative of Frank Bly’s untimely death, driven by the greed and desperation of Susan and Blaine Barksdale. The detailed investigation, marked by confessions, forensic breakthroughs, and relentless pursuit, underscores the complexities of human relationships and the lengths individuals may go to for personal gain. For listeners seeking an in-depth exploration of a true crime story involving manipulation, coercion, and criminal partnership, this episode delivers a thorough and engaging account.

Notable Quotes:

• Frank’s brother on Frank’s disappearance: “I knew something wasn't right” (05:14)
• Investigator on the nature of the crime: “We were treating it as a homicide” (10:29)
• Susan’s daughter expressing fear: “She was panicked. I was really concerned that he would just kill her” (16:44)
• Criminal expert on Blaine’s behavior: “There’s Bonnie and Clyde on the run” (02:35)
• Frank’s brother reflecting on loss: “You never have closure” (43:24)

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the key elements of the Susan and Blaine Barksdale case, providing a clear and detailed account for listeners and those unfamiliar with the episode.