Snapped: Women Who Murder – Episode Summary: Georgina Misener

Podcast Information:

• Title: Snapped: Women Who Murder
• Host/Author: Oxygen
• Episode: Georgina Misener
• Release Date: April 20, 2025

Introduction to the Case

The episode delves into the tragic and calculated murder of Matthew Meisner, a hardworking family man, orchestrated by his ex-wife, Georgina Misener. The story unravels the complexities of their tumultuous relationship, leading to a meticulously planned homicide that shocked their small Arizona community.

The Murder Scene

The narrative begins in the early morning hours of February 10, 2020, in rural Arizona. A local fire chief discovers the wrecked black SUV of Matthew Meisner on Rural Highway 191 near Safford, close to the Morenci copper mine. Initially presumed to be a traffic accident, investigators quickly determine otherwise upon finding three bullet holes in the victim’s head.

• Witness (04:04): "He was hunched over to the right towards the passenger side. He went to check the victim, and the victim was no longer alive."
• Investigator (02:09): "We had no witnesses of any license plates, vehicle or anything. It just didn't make any sense. Who would hunt him down like a freaking animal?"

The lack of evidence such as shell casings suggested premeditation, leading detectives to suspect foul play rather than a random road rage incident.

Background of Matthew and Georgina

Matthew Meisner, born in 1984 in Tucson, was known as a sweet and reserved individual who excelled in wrestling and pursued higher education at Pima Community College. In 2011, he met Georgina Mendoza, a vibrant and outgoing woman, at a casino. Their opposite personalities attracted them, leading to marriage in Phoenix in 2013 and the birth of their first son, who faced a difficult premature birth.

• Investigator (09:03): "He left his whole family. He left all of his friends here."
• Narrator (06:03): "Matthew Meisner was born in 1984. He was raised in Tucson along with two older sisters and a younger brother."

Georgina's early life was marred by familial abuse, leading her to drop out of high school and struggle with substance abuse for several years. However, she sought help, spent time in rehab, and focused on rebuilding her life, which coincided with her meeting Matthew.

The Breakdown of Their Marriage

Despite their initial happiness and the birth of their children, marital pressures led to growing tensions. By 2017, the couple filed for divorce due to constant arguments and the strain of impending parenthood.

• Investigator (10:20): "He wants to come home, maybe relax. She's with these small kids all day. It's kind of give, give, give."
• Narrator (09:18): "He was happy to have a little girl. She was a little daddy's girl too. She loved her daddy."

Post-divorce, both sought new relationships. Matthew began dating his coworker Nicole Chacon, finding happiness and companionship, while Georgina also started dating someone else. However, unresolved custody battles and escalating conflicts between Georgina and Nicole set the stage for the impending tragedy.

The Day of the Murder

On February 10, 2020, Matthew was en route to work when he was ambushed and shot multiple times. Initial observations suggested a random act of violence, but investigative details soon pointed to a planned execution.

• Narrator (12:19): "With the Wedding less than two months away, 35-year-old Matthew is found dead on Highway 191."
• Investigator (05:10): "There was about 14 or 15 rounds that were shot into the side of the vehicle in a tight net group pattern."

A crucial piece of evidence emerged when a witness reported seeing a white sedan make a suspicious U-turn and flee the scene, sparking the investigation into the vehicle's origins.

Suspects and Investigation

Eduardo Montano Jr., connected to Georgina Misener, became a prime suspect after matching the description and vehicle registration details. Upon arrest, circumstantial evidence mounted against him, including a 9mm rifle linked to the murder and past misdemeanors.

• Investigator (25:22): "How do you know Georgina?"
• Witness (24:52): "At that point on scene, I did read Eduardo as Miranda rights, and he agreed to speak with us."

Despite Eduardo's initial denial, forensic evidence and inconsistent alibis led to his conviction. However, the investigation took a pivotal turn when Georgina Misener emerged as a manipulative mastermind behind the murder, using Eduardo as her pawn.

• Investigator (29:17): "It tied the gun with the car and it tied the gun to Ed Wordle."

Georgina's Manipulation and Deception

Georgina's deceit was unveiled through deleted text messages recovered from her phone, revealing her manipulation of Eduardo to execute the murder. She feigned severe illnesses and orchestrated conflicts to eliminate Matthew and secure custody of their children.

• Narrator (35:41): "We discovered that Georgina, she did not have cancer. All these medical conditions were false allegations."
• Witness (37:55): "He says, do you want me to notify you once it's done? And she basically responds, I think it'll be best if it comes as a surprise."

These revelations painted Georgina as a master manipulator, controlling Eduardo's actions to fulfill her vengeful desires.

Arrests and Legal Proceedings

Both Eduardo and Georgina were arrested and faced legal consequences for their roles in the murder. Eduardo pled guilty to second-degree murder, receiving a 33-year sentence, while Georgina was sentenced to the same duration for second-degree murder and conspiracy to commit aggravated assault.

• Investigator (42:06): "He unloads his bullets into that car, and Matthew runs off the road."
• Witness (43:24): "There was enough evidence, and she knew that there was no way to say she was not involved in this case."

Georgina’s manipulative tactics were exposed, leaving a shattered family behind, with the children now orphaned following the tragic loss of their father and mother.

Conclusion and Aftermath

The episode concludes with reflections on Georgina’s manipulative nature and the enduring impact on Matthew’s family. Despite the legal closure, the emotional toll on the children and the community remains profound.

• Investigator (44:52): "They had been divorced. The only issues that she had was with Georgina Misner."
• Narrator (44:21): "When the judge handed down her decision, she held nothing back. She told her what a manipulative person she was."

The case serves as a stark reminder of the depths of manipulation and the devastating consequences of unresolved emotional conflicts within familial relationships.

Notable Quotes:

• Witness (02:09): "Who would hunt him down like a freaking animal?"
• Narrator (07:59): "After a stint in rehab, Georgina spent the next two years focused on staying sober."
• Investigator (29:04): "We had enough probable cause to request an arrest warrant."
• Witness (35:20): "We talked to multiple people through Department of Child Services. There was nothing that indicated that Matthew abused those children."

Key Takeaways:

• The murder of Matthew Meisner was a result of Georgina Misener’s calculated manipulation.
• Eduardo Montano Jr. acted under Georgina's influence, leading to his conviction for the murder.
• Georgina’s deceit, including false claims of illness, played a pivotal role in orchestrating the crime.
• The case underscores the destructive power of manipulation and the lasting impact on innocent family members.

This detailed summary encapsulates the key points and intricate dynamics of Georgina Misener’s orchestrated murder of Matthew Meisner, highlighting the layers of manipulation, deceit, and the resulting tragedy.