So Supernatural: DISAPPEARED - Anjikuni Lake
Release Date: August 15, 2025 | Host: Ashley Flowers | Featuring: Yvette Gentile & Rasha Pecorero
1. Introduction to the Anjikuni Lake Disappearance
The episode opens with Yvette Gentile setting the stage for a chilling mystery from the remote northern Canadian wilderness. She introduces the audience to the perplexing case of Anjikuni Lake, where a small Inuit village seemingly vanished without a trace in November 1930.
"Back in 1930, a fur trapper was roaming in a very remote part of northern Canada when he stumbled upon the unthinkable... the villagers were nowhere to be found."
— Yvette Gentile [01:19]
2. Joe Labelle's Eerie Discovery
Fur trapper Joe Labelle ventures into the desolate region of Anjikuni Lake, hoping to find sustenance and shelter. Instead, he encounters an abandoned Inuit village devoid of its inhabitants. The meticulous abandonment—tents left untouched, supplies stored neatly, and sled dogs unattended—raises immediate red flags.
"It's like they all just vanished midway through an ordinary day."
— Rasha Pecorero [06:21]
Joe's investigation uncovers disturbing signs: half-finished sewing projects, a disturbed grave, and starvation among the sled dogs. These anomalies suggest something far more sinister than a simple evacuation or accident.
"The bedding, clothes, and boots are all put away where they belong. It's not like they packed up for a long journey."
— Rasha Pecorero [07:45]
3. The Mounties and the Mysterious Sky Lights
Realizing the gravity of his discovery, Joe contacts the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP). Upon arrival, the Mounties conduct a thorough investigation but find little beyond Joe's initial observations. A recurring detail that perplexes the investigators is the sighting of strange, pulsating lights in the sky—distinct from the natural aurora borealis.
"They kept seeing a weird flashing light in the sky, but they couldn't figure out where it was coming from."
— Ashley Flowers [15:10]
Efforts to gather information from nearby Inuit communities yield minimal results. The remoteness of Anjikuni Lake means little contact with neighboring villages, and interviews reveal no knowledge of the missing residents.
4. The Enigmatic Little Boy and Unsolved Leads
A potential lead emerges when a 10-year-old Inuit boy appears in a distant village, claiming no knowledge of his origins. The Mounties consider him a possible sole survivor from Anjikuni Lake but find his story lacks corroborative evidence, leading to dead ends in the investigation.
"It's running out of evidence and tips, and it's looking like they're not going to be able to solve this."
— Rasha Pecorero [20:14]
5. Reemergence in Pop Culture and UFO Theories
Three decades later, Frank Edwards’ 1959 book, Stranger Than Science, reignites interest in the Anjikuni Lake mystery. However, Edwards’ account contains discrepancies, such as the presence of kayaks during winter—a detail Joe Labelle never reported.
The narrative takes a speculative turn when Betty Hill, a renowned alien abductee, introduces the theory that extraterrestrials were responsible for the villagers' disappearance. She claims that Captain Larson, a Mountie deeply invested in the case, concluded that aliens abducted the Inuit people.
"Captain Larson was utterly convinced that all of the villagers were taken by aliens back in 1930."
— Ashley Flowers [25:29]
Additional accounts from fur trappers in The World's Great UFO Mysteries suggest UFO involvement, but these stories lack verification and contain significant inconsistencies.
6. Exploring Inuit Legends and Mythical Explanations
The episode delves into Inuit folklore, introducing the Qalupalik—a mythical sea creature akin to an evil mermaid. According to legend, Qalupaliks lure individuals onto unstable ice, dragging them to watery graves. While captivating, this theory falters under scrutiny due to the frozen state of Anjikuni Lake during winter months and the absence of physical evidence.
"The Qalupalik will burst from the sea, grab their unsuspecting victim, and drag them to a watery death."
— Rasha Pecorero [33:30]
Alternative theories, such as polar bear attacks, are dismissed due to the lack of signs of struggle or remains in the village.
7. Debunking and Skepticism: Was the Story Fabricated?
Critical analysis reveals potential fabrication elements in the original story. Joe Labelle’s lack of official trapping licenses and inconsistencies in Emmett E. Kelleher’s 1930 newspaper article—such as the misrepresented photograph of the village—cast doubt on the authenticity of the disappearance narrative.
"According to the Mounties, there's no record that their officers ever investigated a disappearance near the lake."
— Rasha Pecorero [38:16]
Moreover, Inuit oral traditions, rich with history and detail, make no mention of a village ever existing at Anjikuni Lake, suggesting the possibility that the entire story may have been a journalistic fabrication aimed at sensationalism.
8. Modern Reflections and the Disappearance of Inuit Cultures
Concluding on a somber note, the hosts emphasize the real and pressing issue of the ongoing disappearance of Inuit cultures due to climate change and systemic neglect. The episode draws parallels between the fictional Anjikuni Lake mystery and the tangible struggles faced by indigenous communities today.
"Situations like what happened to 15-year-old Tina Fontaine... highlight the urgent need to work with indigenous leaders to preserve their cultures and protect their people."
— Rasha Pecorero [42:58]
Notable Quotes:
-
"A lot of us don't even know which we'll choose until we find ourselves in those situations."
— Yvette Gentile [01:19] -
"So if you add a monster to the mix and one that might lure the villagers into the lake, it does start to feel like a real theory."
— Ashley Flowers [34:17] -
"Maybe the whole village died in a mass suicide. Maybe everyone got up together and walked into the freezing lake."
— Rasha Pecorero [11:50]
Conclusion
The Anjikuni Lake disappearance remains one of true crime's most enigmatic cases, blurring the lines between folklore, speculative theories, and potential journalistic embellishments. As Yvette and Rasha Gentile unravel the layers of this mystery, they not only question the veracity of historical accounts but also shed light on the broader issues affecting indigenous communities today. This episode serves as both a captivating exploration of an unresolved mystery and a poignant reminder of the real-world challenges faced by marginalized groups.
Connect with So Supernatural on Instagram @sosupernaturalpod and visit sosupernaturalpodcast.com for more mysterious tales and in-depth investigations.