So Supernatural Podcast Summary: "DISAPPEARED: The Lost City of Atlantis"

Podcast Information:

• Title: So Supernatural
• Host/Author: audiochuck | Crime House
• Episode: DISAPPEARED: The Lost City of Atlantis
• Release Date: June 20, 2025
• Description: Most mysteries can be solved by looking at the facts. But sometimes, the truth lies somewhere in the unknown… Enter the realm of true crime’s most bizarre occurrences, and unravel all the possible explanations. No matter how strange or surreal they get.

Introduction

In the episode titled "DISAPPEARED: The Lost City of Atlantis," hosts Yvette Gentile and Kylie Lowe delve deep into the enigmatic legend of Atlantis, exploring its origins, proposed discoveries, and enduring allure. They navigate through historical accounts, modern archaeological claims, and metaphysical interpretations to present a comprehensive exploration of Atlantis.

Atlantis in Plato's Writings [06:41 - 10:36]

The discussion begins with the foundational source of the Atlantis legend—Plato, the renowned Greek philosopher.

• Kylie Lowe explains, “The earliest recorded mention of Atlantis comes from the Greek philosopher Plato in the year 360 BCE” (06:41).
• Plato described Atlantis as a vast and advanced civilization that existed around 9,600 BCE, featuring impressive architecture and a circular city layout surrounded by islands and moats.
• According to Plato, Atlantis thrived as a utopian society but eventually succumbed to arrogance and corruption, leading to a catastrophic natural disaster that sank the entire continent beneath the ocean (09:12, 10:09).

Rediscovering Myth: From Troy to Atlantis [11:45 - 14:30]

The narrative transitions to the discovery of Troy by Heinrich Schliemann in 1870, drawing parallels between mythical cities and archaeological reality.

• Yvette Gentile notes, “Up until that year, many people thought Troy was fictional too” (12:44).
• The realization that Troy was real spurred interest in other mythical cities like Atlantis, suggesting that some legends might be rooted in historical truth.

Ignatius Donnelly's Antediluvian World [17:26 - 22:14]

The episode highlights Ignatius Donnelly, a former U.S. Congressman who authored "Antediluvian World," positing that Atlantis was the cradle of all modern civilizations.

• Yvette explains, “In 1882, just 12 years after Troy is discovered, a guy named Ignatius Donnelly enters the chat” (17:26).
• Donnelly theorized that Atlantis was located in the Atlantic Ocean before the continents split, serving as a cultural and technological hub influencing global societies.
• His ideas gained popularity despite criticisms regarding his methodology and lack of scientific rigor (22:14).

Edgar Cayce's Visions and Predictions [23:28 - 27:37]

The hosts delve into the metaphysical realm with Edgar Cayce, a mystic who claimed psychic visions about Atlantis.

• Kylie Lowe describes Cayce’s abilities: “Edgar believes he can use psychic abilities to heal sick people by dreaming” (23:28).
• Cayce envisioned Atlantis possessing advanced technologies, including silicon chips and sustainable energy sources long before such inventions existed (26:14).
• He predicted the discovery of Atlantis near Bimini in the Bahamas around 1968-1969, igniting widespread interest (27:37).

The Bimini Road: A Clash of Hope and Skepticism [28:35 - 31:26]

Following Cayce's prediction, the Bimini Road discovery is scrutinized.

• In 1968, scuba divers discovered an underwater formation resembling a cobblestone road near Bimini, sparking claims it was evidence of Atlantis (28:35).
• Yvette shares the enthusiasm: “everyone is speculating that this must have been an Atlantean throwaway that sank with the rest of the city” (29:24).
• However, scientific investigations concluded that the Bimini Road was a natural rock formation, debunking its association with Atlantis (31:26).

Alternative Theories: Antarctica and Southern Spain [31:26 - 40:29]

Exploring alternative locations, the hosts discuss theories linking Atlantis to Antarctica and Southern Spain.

• The Piri Reis map (1513) is cited by some as evidence of Atlantis in Antarctica due to its depiction of the continent without ice, although this is largely dismissed (32:11, 34:49).
• In 2018, Merlin Burrows claimed to find clues in Spain pointing to Atlantis, but these were later revealed to be artificial structures built for plankton habitats (37:18, 39:27).

The Santorini Connection: Reality Behind the Legend [40:29 - 47:27]

A more plausible theory connects Atlantis to the Minoan civilization on Santorini.

• Kylie outlines how the Minoans, an advanced civilization, were devastated by a massive volcanic eruption around 1600 BCE (44:28).
• This catastrophic event drastically altered Santorini’s geography and led to the disappearance of the Minoans, possibly inspiring Plato’s Atlantis story (40:29, 46:31).
• The hosts suggest that Plato may have used the real devastation of Santorini to craft a cautionary tale about societal collapse (47:27).

Conclusion: Atlantis as a Symbol of Hope and Caution [48:02 - 49:00]

Yvette and Kylie conclude by reflecting on the enduring legacy of Atlantis.

• Yvette emphasizes, “the story of Atlantis is about hope,” highlighting its role in inspiring humanity to learn from past mistakes and strive for a better future (48:02).
• Kylie echoes this sentiment, suggesting that whether Atlantis was real or mythical, its story serves as a powerful reminder of the potential and fragility of human civilization (49:00).

Notable Quotes:

• Kylie Lowe: “The earliest recorded mention of Atlantis comes from the Greek philosopher Plato in the year 360 BCE” (06:41)
• Yvette Gentile: “Ignatius feels confident enough about his theory to publish it in a book. It claims that all modern day cultures evolved from one particular ancient civilization, Atlantis” (17:26)
• Kylie Lowe: “The destruction was one of the greatest disasters in all of human history” (21:36)
• Yvette Gentile: “But some people do think Atlantis sank in the Bermuda Triangle, and that's why there's so many eerie disappearances and strange events that still happen there” (29:28)
• Kylie Lowe: “The Minoans were one of the first human cultures ever. They also built huge cities and made beautiful art” (45:45)

Final Thoughts: "DISAPPEARED: The Lost City of Atlantis" offers a thorough examination of one of history’s most captivating mysteries. Through historical analysis, exploration of modern theories, and a balanced discussion of evidence and skepticism, Yvette Gentile and Kylie Lowe provide listeners with a nuanced perspective on Atlantis, blending factual history with the allure of the supernatural.

For more insights and discussions on supernatural mysteries, follow So Supernatural on Instagram at sosupernaturalpod and visit their website at sosupernaturalpodcast.com.