HAUNTED: Cranmer Family Demon with Two Girls One Ghost

Summary

So Supernatural Podcast Episode Summary

Title: HAUNTED: Cranmer Family Demon with Two Girls One Ghost
Host: audiochuck | Crime House
Release Date: June 13, 2025

---

Introduction and Special Guests (00:02 - 05:20)

In this episode of So Supernatural, hosts Ashley Flowers and Yvette Gentile delve into the chilling tale of the Cranmer family's encounter with a demonic presence in their Pittsburgh home. Enhancing the discussion, they are joined by Sabrina Deanna Roga and Corinne Vian from the popular podcast Two Girls, One Ghost. The special guests bring additional insights and personal paranormal experiences, enriching the narrative and providing a collaborative exploration of the Cranmer case.

---

The Cranmer Family’s Haunting Begins (05:21 - 16:53)

The story centers on Bob Cranmer, a former army officer turned politician, who, along with his wife Lisa and their four children, moved into their dream home located at 3406 Brownsville Road, Pittsburgh, in October 1988. The house, built around 1910, is described as a majestic three-story residence with four rooms, a dedicated music room, and three working fireplaces. Bob's fascination with the house began in his childhood, where he felt an inexplicable draw to it, almost as if it was calling him.

Notable Quote:
Bob Cranmer reflects on the incident when he was hitchhiked home and dropped off directly in front of his dream house:
Bob Cranmer (16:09): "They drop him off right in front of 3406 Brownsville Road. I mean, what."

Despite initial excitement, the family soon experiences unsettling events. During a walkthrough, their two-year-old son, Bobby Jr., inexplicably wanders off and is found terrified on the grand staircase, crying without explaining the reason. This eerie incident does not deter Bob and Lisa from purchasing the house, highlighting Bob's obsession.

---

Escalation of Paranormal Activity (17:02 - 30:44)

Upon moving in, the Cranmer family begins to encounter a series of bizarre occurrences:

• Unexplained Lights and Rearrangements: Bob wakes up to find downstairs lights on despite remembering turning them off, and furniture shifts overnight.
• Children’s Distress: Bobby Jr. rejects his bedroom, preferring to hide in his closet, while other children exhibit fear and discomfort at night.
• Attempts to Combat the Haunting: In response, Bob invites a priest to bless the home. However, during the blessing, Bobby Jr. adamantly refuses entry into his room, intensifying the family's fears.

Notable Quote:
Bob considers putting his trust in faith to combat the haunting:
Bob Cranmer (26:28): "What do we think? Is Lisa a mom experiencing normal burnout, or do you think this is the effects of living in a haunted house?"

The hosts discuss with the guests the effectiveness of religious interventions, sharing personal anecdotes and skepticism about traditional exorcism methods. They suggest that ignoring paranormal activity can sometimes diminish its influence, though in the Cranmer case, the disturbances only escalate.

---

Descent into Chaos and Exorcisms (30:44 - 51:56)

As the paranormal activity worsens, the Cranmer family's personal lives begin to unravel:

• Lisa's Decline: Lisa becomes increasingly forgetful and overwhelmed, eventually agreeing to a two-week stay at a mental health facility to recuperate.
• Bobby Jr.'s Aggression: In 2003, a severe incident occurs where Bobby Jr., then 16, violently attacks Bob during a heated argument, leading to Bob’s arrest for assaulting his minor son. This incident propels Bob to seek more definitive solutions for the haunting.

Notable Quote:
The hosts ponder the impact of the haunting on the family’s dynamics:
Ashley Flowers (33:28): "What do they say about him and their childhood?"

Bob employs multiple exorcisms over two years, each attempt seeming to offer only temporary relief. The family's deteriorating mental health and the physical manifestations of the haunting, such as bleeding walls and scratches on their skin, push Bob to seek increasingly desperate measures.

---

Historical Mysteries and the Ultimate Revelation (51:56 - 69:40)

Bob's investigation into the house's past uncovers a haunting history:

• 1792 Massacre: Records indicate that in early 1792, a European woman and her three children were brutally murdered in Brentwood, with her husband planting an oak tree at the site as a memorial.
• Early 1900s Curse: A construction worker, spurned by Mrs. Malik, who built the Cranmer house, allegedly cursed the property by placing a singular plank of wood in the basement.
• Dr. M’s Illegal Activities: In the 1920s and 30s, Dr. M, a local doctor, performed illegal abortions in the house, resulting in the death of a patient whose body he disposed of in the basement furnace.

Notable Quote:
Bob seeks to understand the depths of his house’s dark history:
Ashley Flowers (55:22): "The facts? I think it's just according to Bob."

A psychic named Connie reveals to Bob that he is a reincarnated soul destined to purify the house from its malevolent forces. This spiritual revelation aligns with Bob's relentless pursuit to rid his home of the haunting.

---

The Aftermath and Unanswered Questions (69:40 - 74:29)

Bob eventually succeeds in his mission, converting his haunted house into a bed and breakfast. He openly shares the house's history but warns guests against engaging in activities like using Ouija boards to prevent reigniting the demonic presence. Despite achieving peace, the episode raises critical questions about the long-term effects on Bob’s family, the authenticity of his experiences, and the broader implications of attributing mental health issues to supernatural causes.

Notable Quote:
Reflecting on the interplay between mental health and supernatural beliefs:
Ashley Flowers (70:00): "What is important is that the family was struggling at times. At some point while he lived in the House, Bobby Jr. Was diagnosed with schizophrenia."

The discussion concludes with a nuanced view, acknowledging both the possibility of genuine supernatural phenomena and the importance of addressing mental health with professional support.

---

Conclusion and Final Thoughts (74:29 - End)

As the episode wraps up, hosts and guests emphasize the complexity of the Cranmer case, leaving listeners to ponder the delicate balance between supernatural explanations and psychological realities. They highlight the enduring mystery surrounding the Cranmer family's experiences and the lingering questions about what truly transpired within the walls of 3406 Brownsville Road.

Final Quote:
Yvette Gentile (73:16): "We want the answer either way. I mean, Bob believes this tragedy helped attract evil energies to his house, but he doesn't think it's the only factor that led to the possession."

The episode underscores the enduring allure of supernatural mysteries while advocating for a compassionate approach to unexplained phenomena, encouraging listeners to seek understanding from multiple perspectives.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Bob Cranmer (16:09): "They drop him off right in front of 3406 Brownsville Road. I mean, what."
• Bob Cranmer (26:28): "What do we think? Is Lisa a mom experiencing normal burnout, or do you think this is the effects of living in a haunted house?"
• Ashley Flowers (33:28): "What do they say about him and their childhood?"
• Ashley Flowers (55:22): "The facts? I think it's just according to Bob."
• Ashley Flowers (70:00): "What is important is that the family was struggling at times. At some point while he lived in the House, Bobby Jr. Was diagnosed with schizophrenia."
• Yvette Gentile (73:16): "We want the answer either way. I mean, Bob believes this tragedy helped attract evil energies to his house, but he doesn't think it's the only factor that led to the possession."

---

Final Thoughts

The Cranmer family's story is a compelling blend of historical tragedy, spiritual warfare, and personal struggle. So Supernatural expertly weaves together firsthand accounts, expert opinions, and historical research to present a multifaceted narrative that challenges listeners to consider the intersections of faith, fate, and the unexplained. Whether one believes in the supernatural or views the events through a psychological lens, the episode offers a thought-provoking exploration of how families cope with and interpret profound disturbances in their lives.

Transcript

[Ashley Flowers]

Hey, so supernatural listeners, if you enjoy the mysterious and eerie stories we discuss here, then we've got another show you need to check out. Park Predators.

[Yvette Gentile]

Hosted by our friend Delia d' Ambra, Park Predators dives into the dark and twisted crimes that have taken place in some of the most beautiful places on Earth. These haunting cases range from stories of disappearances and murders to unsolved mysteries.

[Ashley Flowers]

Delia's storytelling will transport you right into the heart of these breathtaking landscapes, and.

[Yvette Gentile]

Her dedication to finding the facts ensures that you get all the details of each case.

[Ashley Flowers]

So if you're looking for some more chilling cases, Park Predators is for you.

[Yvette Gentile]

Listen to Park Predators available wherever you listen to podcasts.

[Dr. Horton]

Your new beginning starts now. Dr. Horton has new construction homes available in Ellensburg and throughout the greater Seattle area. With spacious floor plans, flexible living spaces and home technology packages, you can enjoy more cozy moments and sweet memories in your beautiful new home. With new home communities opening in Ellensburg and throughout the Seattle area, Dr. Horton has the ideal home for you. Learn [e-mail] Dr. Horton, America's builder and equal Housing Opportunity Builder in the summer.

[Oregon Lottery]

All of Oregon is our playground thanks to our incredible park system. That's why it's so cool that Oregon Lottery gameplay like Viv Video Lottery or Cash Pop helps support tons of parks projects statewide like accessible trails at Silver Falls State park or upgrades to your favorite dog park in Newburgh. It's just one way a little lottery play for many Oregonians can add up to a lot of good the Oregon Lottery. Together we do good things. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only. Must be 18 or older to play.

[Dr. Horton]

USAA knows dynamic duos can save the day like superheroes and sidekicks or auto and home insurance. With USAA you can bundle your auto and save up to 10%. Tap the banner to learn more and get a'@usaa.com bundle restrictions apply.

[Bob Cranmer]

One thing I've learned from my years of working in true crime is to always check a source. Where does the information come from? What does this person stand to gain from offering up their version of events? Can they be trusted? But this might be even more applicable when it comes to what we're doing here on so Supernatural because there are a lot of wild stories out there. And while, you know, I love to believe in stuff, there's always a part of me asking or wondering, could this be made up for attention? How might someone benefit from sharing their ghost stories, their alien encounters, their run ins with a cryptid or more importantly, when it comes to the stigma surrounding the supernatural, the question becomes, who? What do they stand to lose? In some cases, the answer is literally everything. That's what's so interesting about Today's story. In 1988, Bob Cranmer and his wife Lisa bought their dream house in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. But it wasn't long until that dream turned into a nightmare. Bob and his family experienced so much paranormal activity in that house that it turned their lives upside down. But the wildest thing about it is Bob wasn't someone who was out for money or even his 15 minutes of fame. Quite the opposite, actually. His job would have had him dodging the controversy like the plague because Bob was a former army officer turned politician, and his haunted house was such a big scandal, it could have cost him his career. Yet he shared his story anyway. And today, Rasha and Yvette are going to share it with you with a twist. I'm Ashley Flowers. Welcome back to so Supernatural.

[Yvette Gentile]

Hi, y' all. I'm Eyvette Gentile.

[Ashley Flowers]

And I'm Rasha Picarero. And we are beyond excited for today's topic because we aren't alone.

[Yvette Gentile]

No. And we're not just referring to ghost and spirits that we're going to meet in this episode. We have two of our friends joining us to share this story. The host of Two Girls, One Ghost.

[Ashley Flowers]

We had to do that.

[Yvette Gentile]

We couldn't resist.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

That was so good and so unexpected.

[Yvette Gentile]

We have Sabrina, Deanna Roga, and Corinne Vian in the house. Ladies, welcome to Sew Supernatural.

[Corinne Vian]

Hello.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Thank you.

[Corinne Vian]

Thank you for having us.

[Ashley Flowers]

We're so honored.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

We're so excited.

[Corinne Vian]

We might have a ghost with us. That's why, you know, when we say two girls, one ghost, there is a ghost or many ghosts that do haunt our show. And so we always caution people who listen to our podcast that we might haunt you. And we're sorry or you're welcome, depending on what you want.

[Ashley Flowers]

You're sorry or you're welcome.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. And for the team at SEW Supernatural, maybe we're sorry because oftentimes it does interfere with the technology. So let us pray that nothing happens when recording today.

[Corinne Vian]

Knock on wood.

[Ashley Flowers]

Knock on wood. All the prayers.

[Yvette Gentile]

We're gonna be fine. We are divinely blessed. We're gonna be just fine. Okay.

[Corinne Vian]

Good intentions manifest.

[Yvette Gentile]

Amen to that. Amen. Okay, so I think we have the perfect topic, because from what I understand, this particular topic we're gonna be talking about, you guys have not covered on your show.

[Corinne Vian]

We have not.

[Ashley Flowers]

Well, today we're exploring the terrifying case of the Cranmer family demon. And I know you just said you haven't covered this story before, but had you even heard about it?

[Corinne Vian]

You know what's so interesting is on my bookshelf, there is a book, the book, the Brownsville demon book, that a listener had given to us a couple years ago. And it's just been sitting on my bookshelf, so I've never read it. And then in preparation, obviously, for this episode, I did a little Google search, but not too much because I wanted to be surprised. And I found out that there is a very similar by name case that happened in Cranford, New Jersey, which is, like, very close to where I grew up in New Jersey.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Oh, wow.

[Corinne Vian]

But the family name is Cramner, so the M and N are switched.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Oh, that's so confusing.

[Yvette Gentile]

That's wild.

[Corinne Vian]

But it's a different demon case.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I know, but is the demon the same? Did the demon get confused trying to hunt down the family, find them again?

[Corinne Vian]

I don't think so. Maybe. Right, A demon with dyslexia.

[Yvette Gentile]

All right, but any potential dyslexic demons.

[Corinne Vian]

Aside, otherwise, no, we. We are coming in blind. And we're excited.

[Ashley Flowers]

We are so excited, too. So let's dive right into it. It's the 1970s, and Bob Cranmer is a teenager living in a Pittsburgh suburb called Brentwood, Pennsylvania. And for the most part, Bob's your average kid. He loves to be out riding bikes with his friends, pushing the boundaries of his curfew, you know, that sort of thing. Though Bob has one weird fascination that other kids might not, one that started back when he was in the second grade. Bob's obsessed with riding his bike past this particular house at 3406 Brownsville Road. The house was completed around 1910, so, yeah, it looks a little bit older, but to him, it feels like something out of a fairy tale.

[Corinne Vian]

This sounds like the beginning of a Stephen King novel, doesn't it?

[Ashley Flowers]

It totally does. The house is red with white trim, and it's covered in windows and ivy. It's three stories tall with a big front porch and a balcony on the second floor. You can't tell from the outside, but it has four rooms in total. It also has, I think they call it a foyer or a den, a dedicated music room, and three working fireplaces. So it's really, really majestic. There's also this beautiful grand staircase. All to say, this home is incredibly striking. It's the sort of place that catches your attention even if you've only ever seen the outside.

[Corinne Vian]

It sounds beautiful.

[Ashley Flowers]

It does.

[Corinne Vian]

I'm like, I want to see this Zillow listing.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I know. It's one of those things where you're like, is this going to be like 2.4 million or is this going to be 200,000? I don't know anything about this area.

[Ashley Flowers]

Right. I don't either.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah.

[Ashley Flowers]

Well, each time he passes it, Bob can't help but just stop and stare. He kind of feels like something is drawing him towards the house, almost as if it's pulling him in. In fact, he's so drawn to it that his biggest dream in life is to own the house himself one day.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

There's a creepiness to that because it's like, well, is the house calling him? Like, is this something that came from within him himself?

[Ashley Flowers]

Right.

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Or was this implanted?

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah. Given the fact that this is so supernatural and we already know demon is a part of this story title, I'm apprehensive about this lure from the house.

[Ashley Flowers]

Agreed.

[Yvette Gentile]

Well, even though it's Bob's biggest dream to own this house, it's a long road for him to get there, and he has a tough time. In high school. He falls in with a bad crowd, he begins drinking a lot, and he gets into trouble for a bunch of petty crimes. His parents are devout Catholics, so they're a little concerned about their son. And they finally tell him that they want him to find Jesus. Like he actually needs Jesus to save him. But the thing is, Bob doesn't believe in God. Eventually, Bob's bad behavior catches up to him, though. And this is in May of 1975, when he's about 18 or 19 years old. He and his friends get drunk one night and they go for a little joyride. Thankfully, you know, nobody gets hurt. But they do end up getting a flat tire in front of this furniture store. Then one of Bob's brilliant friends makes this decision to impulsively smash the window of this particular store. Of course, the alarm sets off and Bob's afraid that the police are gonna be like, right there, lickety split. So he ditches his friends, he runs from the scene of the crime, and he just hitchhikes home. But he ends up getting a ride from two men, like two strangers that he doesn't know he hasn't met before. They're not from the neighborhood and they don't have time to bring him all the way back to his house, so they offer to drop him off nearby in Brentwood. And guess where they drop him off? Y' All. No, no, I'm telling you, they drop him off right in front of 3406 Brownsville Road. I mean, what.

[Corinne Vian]

Oh, my gosh.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

My God.

[Corinne Vian]

Of all places.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

It's like, you couldn't have written this more perfectly if this was a movie, right? Like, of course. He's delivered right back to the house that's called him. He was young.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, exactly. The same house that he has been obsessing over since he was a kid. But to Bob, he doesn't feel like this is a coincidence. He actually feels like it's fate.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah, well, fate is such a positive word. Right? It makes it feel like, oh, it's destiny. But, like, I don't know. I don't know if this is. Well, I'm gonna say I don't know if this is a good thing or a bad thing, but based on the subject of this episode, I feel like this is a very bad thing.

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah. We've actually read stories from listeners on our podcast before where for years, they've had dreams of the same house over and over and over. And then there are good versions where, like, one person, when they were, you know, in their 30s with their family, found the house that they had been dreaming about for so long and bought it and moved in with their family, like, you know, happily ever after. But then there's other iterations where it's nightmarish repeating of the house over and over. And then someone saw it in real life, and it was like, I need to stay away from here.

[Ashley Flowers]

Wow.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

It also makes me think. And this is. I mean, again, I don't know what's going to happen here, but it does make me think a lot about past lives, and it makes me curious about if this connection to the house that Bob felt at such a young age, because this is a bizarre thing to experience, like second grade, and he's feeling connected to this house. Like, that's a strange behavior for a second grader. It makes me curious if the connection goes much further than his present life.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah, I definitely think that it does. And something about this interaction convinces Bob to get his life in order. Bob finally listens to his family's advice and becomes a devout Christian, specifically a Baptist. He even considers becoming a minister, though ultimately he decides not to pursue that dream. Instead, he goes to college, then joins the army in the late 1970s, when he's in his early 20s. In 1979, while he's enlisted, his friends set him up on a blind date with a woman named Lisa. So they end up hitting it off they get married and eventually have four children together. Lisa and the kids live with Bob in Virginia as he works in Washington, D.C. doing military intelligence. But eventually, Bob feels it's time for a new chapter. So In October of 1988, the family decides to move back to Bob's hometown of Brentwood while he looks for new work.

[Yvette Gentile]

And they're looking for a house to live in. And wouldn't you know it, the Brownsville street mansion is up for sale.

[Corinne Vian]

I'm just shaking my head so much.

[Ashley Flowers]

I know, right?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

But it almost feels like. Have you guys heard of the invisible string theory?

[Yvette Gentile]

No, what's that?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

It's basically like, this theory that it kind of goes back to, like, fate and destiny, where something is always meant to be, and, like, whatever's meant to be will be sort of thing, but, like, that your fate is predetermined and that you have these moments where you kind of pass by someone or something that's meant to be in your life so many times before it actually solidifies. So for someone who might find a romantic partner, perhaps they're looking back at childhood photos and they see a photo of themselves standing together on, like, the deck of a cruise ship that both of their families went on vacation at the same time. You know, something like that. Where it's like, was this always meant to be and he just was always finding himself around this house for this exact moment?

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah.

[Ashley Flowers]

I love the idea of the invisible string theory because it's almost like we're all in alignment. That leads us to the right place at the right time, no matter what.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Right. Like, what are the chances that his family is looking for a house when this house is up for sale and that they're specifically looking in this area? Like, it has to perfectly align.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, Agreed. Agreed.

[Ashley Flowers]

Totally. Again, just like the invisible string theory. So get this. The owners say they have to sell because they need a place closer to where they work. But frankly, they seem a little too eager to get rid of the house. Bob figures he won't be able to afford a home this big, this old, and this beautiful. Remember, he's been romanticizing this place for years, but he figures it's worth an offer. And when he tells the owners what he's willing to pay, they accept his offer literally on the spot.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

No.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yes.

[Corinne Vian]

That's the biggest sign.

[Ashley Flowers]

Even though it's way less than the house should be worth. So obviously, Bob is totally ecstatic.

[Corinne Vian]

My mind goes to. Damn. He should have gone lower, right?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Oh, my God. And this is like a mansion.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah. 14 rooms.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

You would think people would be lined up to own this home. Wow.

[Yvette Gentile]

You totally think so. But when the family goes to do a walkthrough with the sellers, things get a little weird. The whole time, the former owners are acting extremely anxious and nervous, like they're obviously keeping something from the cranmers. Then at one point, Bob notices that one of his kids is missing.

[Corinne Vian]

Excuse me.

[Yvette Gentile]

While everyone's been touring the home, his two year old son, Bobby Jr. Has somehow just wandered off, nobody noticing where he's gone.

[Corinne Vian]

Why do I feel like he's going to be in like a dumb waiter? I know down to the basement?

[Ashley Flowers]

I'm sure there's a dumb waiter in that house, right? I'm sure, right?

[Yvette Gentile]

Oh my goodness. But Bob, you know, he's not too concerned. But the former owners are freaking panicked. So they start searching the house and they eventually find Bobby Jr. Standing on the first landing of the grand staircase. But he's not just standing there, y' all, he's screaming and crying because he is absolutely terrified of something. I don't know what. And when the adults actually ask him what happened, he won't say, oh no. So not only won't Bobby Jr say what happened to scare him, apparently the owners don't explain why they were so worried either. But for some reason, this doesn't deter Bob and his wife from signing this paperwork. Let me just put you two into the situation. If that was to happen to you, would you still want to sign those papers?

[Corinne Vian]

Actually, this reminds me so much of. Corinne is having an experience right now in her house with her 10 month old son. So what?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah, I think if you'd asked me this a year ago, I'd be like, absolutely not. I'm not buying this house. But now, given what's happening here in the house that I do own, I'm like, well, I think, oh, I might be able to handle it. I could have a mansion for a few pennies.

[Yvette Gentile]

Sure.

[Ashley Flowers]

Okay, but wait, wait. We totally need to hear about this.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

So the house that we moved into, my husband and I, a few years ago, we know the whole history of like the land, the people who've lived here before. So there's by no accounts like any murders or anything that has happened before in this house that would indicate it being haunted. But, but since my child was born, he's been interacting with people that I can't see and specific to his room. It's always been just in his room and he's having a good time. Like he's laughing, he's really enjoying whoever's entertaining him. And I struggled a lot with postpartum depression. Well, I guess still struggling with postpartum depression. And multiple times through my, like, journey in the night of feeding him, multiple times the lights would turn on in his room, or I would hear someone walking and stop, like, right at the door of his bedroom. I'd see feet going back and forth, like the musical aquarium. Toy aquarium would go on to, like, play a little jingle. And all of those experiences felt generally positive. But there's one space in my house, which is where Sabrina and I record two girls. One goes, oh, geez.

[Corinne Vian]

Where you're sitting right now, where I'm.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Sitting right at this present moment. And this is where the vibes don't feel so great. And we've had a lot of weird things happen in here, like, weird noises coming from the bookshelf that we can't figure out exactly what's happening or why. I had dirt materialize and fall on me from the ceiling.

[Ashley Flowers]

No.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah.

[Yvette Gentile]

What?

[Corinne Vian]

But it's never been scary. Like, it's just been, like, little odd things. And then until recently, something happened.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

So Noah, my child, he comes in here because he loves being in here, and he loves playing with a skeleton that we call snow. Fun.

[Ashley Flowers]

My daughter loves her big skeleton, too. She's 13, though, right?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah, we love a creepy kid. We love an appreciation for. For the spooky. But he's in here, and he's having a good time, and he's seen everything, right? He's seen Raggedy and Andy, the skeleton. Like, nothing is surprising. He's playing, and he looks up directly in the spot on our bookshelf where we keep hearing these phantom noises. We cannot figure out what's causing it. And he starts shrieking like a bloody murder. So scared. I've never, ever seen him this scared in his life. He could not calm down. My mom was here visiting. She rushes in. She's like, what scared him? And then she's looking, and she's like, something right there. Something right there. Cause he was staring, and he was so, so scared. And neither of us could see anything. And my mom and I both are pretty in tune and often can, like, see and hear spirits, but we couldn't see anything. So we get him. We rush him out. Takes him a while to calm down. He avoids the room for some time. But I left it at kind of like, a light threat. So this is why I say, if I were in Bob's position, I might end up taking this house because I came back into the office. I stood at the threshold and I said, whoever is in here, if you scare the baby again, you're on borrowed time. And then nothing has happened since.

[Ashley Flowers]

Really?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah.

[Yvette Gentile]

Mama don't play.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I was like, you better behave or you're getting kicked out, my friend. Yeah, but then it is.

[Corinne Vian]

It is one of those things where you already live there. You're already in the house.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Right.

[Corinne Vian]

But if something happened right before you were about to sign papers, maybe you would have had a different perspective. And my family actually had. This is when I was in eighth grade and my family was moving to Princeton, New Jersey, and there was one house that we looked at that it was like, among two or three that we were like, these are the top contenders. Brand new build. And the weirdest stuff happened there. Like, my dad had nightmares about it when we would go to see it. My mom had a BlackBerry at the time, and it was mostly when blackberries were used just for emails. So it was not set up to receive or have any phone calls. But she kept getting phone calls on her BlackBerry when we were in that house.

[Ashley Flowers]

How weird.

[Corinne Vian]

And it was almost like a warning of, like, get out. We did not buy that house. And I think, like, someone moved in, sold it immediately. So there was something weird about that house.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah. Sometimes there are signs, like, get out.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah. I mean, I think for us, like, growing up, our mom was all about signs and symbols. So for me, like, if it was for me looking at a house and something like that happened, that would be a. Oh, hell no. That would be a major sign and symbol.

[Corinne Vian]

You know, he's, like, blinded by his obsession with it.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, exactly. Exactly. For them, they're all in. You know, he's been fantasizing about this house again since forever. So on December 12, 1988, a moving truck pulls into the driveway to start unloading all of their things. The house is officially theirs. But that doesn't mean it's unoccupied.

[Oregon Lottery]

In the summer, all of Oregon is our playground, thanks to our incredible park system. That's why it's so cool that Oregon lottery gameplay, like video lottery or cash pop, helps support tons of parks projects statewide, like accessible trails at Silver Falls State park or upgrades to your favorite dog park in Newburgh. It's just one way a little lottery play from many Oregonians can add up to a lot of good. The Oregon Lottery. Together, we do good things. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only. Must be 18 or older to play.

[Dr. Horton]

Does it ever feel like you're a marketing professional. Just speaking into the void. Well, with LinkedIn ads, you can know you're reaching the right decision makers. You can even target buyers by job title, industry, company seniority, skills. Wait, did I say job title yet? Get started today and see how you can avoid the void and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn ads. We'll even give you a $100 credit on your next campaign. Get started at LinkedIn.com results. Terms and conditions apply.

[Ashley Flowers]

Bob Cranmer is talking to a friend one day when he shares his new address. And the friend says something like, so you bought the haunted house, did you? Bob's first thought is that his buddy must be confused. But that's when the guy is like, bob, hello? Are you living under a rock? Everyone knows that house is haunted. He says. There have been weird rumors about it going all the way back to the 1930s. At least. Now Bob doesn't take his co worker that seriously. I mean, this is his dream house, after all. But little by little, Bob starts to wonder if maybe there's some truth to starts when he's home alone, he can't shake the feeling that he's being watched. His wife, Lisa, even admits she kind of gets that same feeling, too. And on top of that, his son Bobby Jr flat out refuses to sleep in his own bedroom.

[Corinne Vian]

Is this the same kid who is terrified?

[Yvette Gentile]

Mm.

[Ashley Flowers]

And it's not just him. The other kids are pretty uneasy, too. Every single night, at least one of them gets scared and crawls into bed with Bob and Lisa, something they weren't doing in their old houses, from what I can tell. And poor little Bobby prefers to fall asleep hiding in his closet, which I think is just so sad.

[Corinne Vian]

Oh, poor baby.

[Ashley Flowers]

I know, but it's so much more than that. Sometimes Bob wakes up in the morning to find that all of the downstairs lights are on, even though he distinctly remembers turning them off the night before. And at one point, he also notices the furniture is getting rearranged overnight. Like what? So Bob decides maybe it's time to appeal to a higher power. And that is when he invites a priest to come bless his home. So my question for the two of you. I know this area is literally your specialty. Do you think this works, like bringing in, like, a shaman or a priest or someone to bless the home? Do you think it has any merit to it?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

We have heard that you should do whatever you feel most connected with. So if you do not go to church, if you were not a devout Christian or whatever your religion or beliefs to be, if that doesn't resonate with you. Calling in a priest might not actually do anything that makes sense. So you have to figure out, like, what speaks to you, what feels like it will do something. And I don't know why that works if it's just because, like, your sheer belief in it working is what contributes to something being, like, banished from the house.

[Corinne Vian]

We've also heard, though, so many different stories, you know, especially the more notable cases like the smurl possession and different poltergeist cases, where even when they bring in a priest, it doesn't do anything, and sometimes it happens to make it worse. One of the houses I grew up in, so when I was, like, from 4 to 4 to 13, I lived in this house. There are some weird, dark things that happened in that house that led my dad to calling a priest to bless the house. Like, truly, my sister was, like, basically possessed, and my dad called a priest. And after that, whatever darkness, like, it kind of got sent down to our basement where my brother would have nightmares, reoccurring nightmares of the one closet in our basement.

[Ashley Flowers]

Oh, your poor brother.

[Corinne Vian]

It does seem like the priest coming and blessing it at least pushed it downstairs.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

So maybe this is just one of the things that you have to check off your list when you have a severely haunted home where it's worth a shot. Will it work? Unknown, but maybe worth a try.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[Ashley Flowers]

Like, I'm not religious at all. I'm very spiritual, and I would have, like, a Hawaiian kahuna or someone come in and bless the home for sure.

[Corinne Vian]

I asked Corinne to come bless my house. Like, Corinne is my. Is my guru.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I grew up in a very haunted house. So, yeah, my house and the things that my mom and I owned and would regularly use to try to get rid of some of the activity when things were getting bad, we were like, basically our own little metaphysical shop.

[Corinne Vian]

Wow.

[Yvette Gentile]

So that's where it all began for you.

[Corinne Vian]

I guess so.

[Yvette Gentile]

Obviously, was with your mom, right?

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah. I love that.

[Yvette Gentile]

Wow.

[Ashley Flowers]

Okay. So his friends said that everyone knew this house was haunted. Do you think Bob knew and just blocked all of it out of his mind?

[Corinne Vian]

That's so tricky. Maybe it's partially Bob just not wanting to believe it, but I do have a hard time believing that if he grew up in this neighborhood, he never heard about it.

[Ashley Flowers]

Right.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

And what. What motives does a second grader have to not believe in the haunted house? Right, Totally.

[Ashley Flowers]

But whether or not Bob always knew the house was haunted, it's pretty clear that by now he definitely thinks it is. And Bob's hope is that maybe God, or at the very least the ritual will drive out whatever evil spirit might be in the home. And so the priest walks from one room to the next. In each one he stops and he says a little prayer. Overall, it's pretty uneventful. That is, until they get to the now three year old Bobby Jr. S room. When the priest approaches, Bobby Jr. Stands in the doorway, flat out refusing to let the priest come inside his room.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

No. Yeah, that's the one room that needs it.

[Yvette Gentile]

I know there's little things that happen in the house. Like the lights are flickering on and off, a chair or two is out of place. And sometimes the kids still don't really like sleeping in their own beds, but they just laugh it off, you know, with things like, oh, that's just Casper the friendly ghost.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I will say ignoring the activity is actually one of the recommended things to do when you have a poltergeist or some dark demonic presence because they thrive off of the fear, they thrive off of the recognition. So by ignoring it, yeah, you might ruffle some feathers and might get pissed off and try to do a little bit more to get your attention. But if you're consistent with it, you give it a lot less energy to feed on and perhaps it might actually eventually give up and slink away.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah. So basically it seems like that's the plan. They're hoping that if they just ignore the weirdness, it'll strip the demon of its power.

[Yvette Gentile]

Which is helpful because Bob's very focused right now on his new career. Ever since he moved back to his hometown, Bob wanted to get into local politics. So after settling in, he ran for an elected position and he actually won a spot on the Brentwood town Council in 1991. From there he became the chairman of the county Republican Committee. Even people who don't agree with his party or his agenda seem to really respect him a lot. And he has a great reputation and I guess he's under a lot of pressure to maintain it. And that means he's like always going to community events. And he's generally coming across as this very upstanding, reasonable guy, Even though in 1995 things at home are in anything but reasonable.

[Ashley Flowers]

While Bob's living his politician life, his wife Lisa is handling the bulk of the housework and childcare. And of course it's taking a toll on her. Not just because four kids is a lot to deal with, but also because her partner is always out working or at charity events, dinners, you name it. And on top of that, the House itself seems to be influencing her somehow. It's in 1995, when Bob senses something isn't right with his wife. She's constantly tired and also very forgetful. All of a sudden, the house is getting neglected. And even worse, she hasn't been handling a lot of the bills like she usually does. It gets so bad that they fall really behind on their mortgage to the point where they're actually in danger of losing the house. Once Bob realizes this, he's able to help her sort everything out. But what's really concerning Bob is how out of character Lisa's been acting. Lisa claims she's just feeling overwhelmed and stressed, though she isn't 100% clear with Bob on what all of that means. Either way, the two of them agree she should go to a mental health facility for two weeks. So what do we think? Is Lisa a mom experiencing normal burnout, or do you think this is the effects of living in a haunted house?

[Corinne Vian]

It's so hard because. And I think this is a result of, you know, Bob Cranmer is the one who has written a lot about this story and his experience that we're not really getting Lisa's perspective. But, yes, I mean, the life that she's living, I can absolutely understand how that could lead to normal burnout. But it's also very common for a dark entity to single someone out.

[Ashley Flowers]

Oh, is it?

[Corinne Vian]

To take away their energy so they can become stronger.

[Ashley Flowers]

Oh, wow.

[Yvette Gentile]

And someone who is already feeling overwhelmed and tired. Right.

[Ashley Flowers]

Is vulnerable.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. And oftentimes it does end up being one of the children, which it does sound like perhaps their youngest was the target. But honestly, this demon, if this is kind of the moves that it's making, that's a very strategic move to take down the mom who's also responsible for caring probably the majority of the time for all of the children, because then it makes the children more susceptible to all being fed on by the demon. But I will say, and you guys can speak to it, too, motherhood is very tough. I can't imagine having four kids.

[Ashley Flowers]

I can't imagine. I know you. And I only have one.

[Yvette Gentile]

I don't have any. I have a Chihuahua. And that's already. That's hard enough.

[Corinne Vian]

I have a cat, so.

[Ashley Flowers]

No, you have a cat. That's your child. Right? Right.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. I'm here in two weeks in a mental health facility, and I'm like, man, maybe that would fix me. Like, maybe I need that. That does sound like a nice vacation.

[Ashley Flowers]

Well, after Lisa comes home from those two weeks, I Don't know if it was a vacation for her. We don't really know Lisa's side as much as Bob's. Something extremely weird happens in the house while they're there. The kids tell Bob they saw a stranger in the bathroom. Someone dark and shadowy, who they say looks like. And get this. The Grim Reaper. Great, right? That's when Bob starts realizing, okay, maybe it's not just Casper the Friendly Ghost. Maybe something is starting to really come alive in the house. I mean, Lisa, his wife, seems unsettled and distracted. Both his kids and his kids friends are seeing strange figures in this home. And now they can't sleep throughout the night again. But at the same time, Bob has a political career to maintain. He's up for the county Board of commissioners in 1995, and he ends up getting the seat and begins service at the beginning of 1996. So like any good politician, Bob keeps any and all drama in the Cranmer house from getting out to the press. But come 2003, something happens that he just can't keep under wraps.

[Dr. Horton]

T Mobile Home Internet is all about speed. Speed, value.

[H]

What you doing, Zach?

[Dr. Horton]

I'm rehearsing for our T Mobile Home Internet radio commercial. There are so many benefits and awards. You gotta talk fast.

[H]

Well, let me try. T Mobile Home Internet ranks number one in customer satisfaction for home Wireless Internet by JD Power.

[Yvette Gentile]

Wow, you are good.

[H]

Try singing. It loosens up the vocal cords. Watch. T Mobile has a five year price guarantee.

[Dr. Horton]

They won't raise your rate on Internet.

[H]

That's not bad. Try enunciating. Be Loud, Hulu and Paramount Plus. On them.

[Ashley Flowers]

On them.

[H]

Not bad. We make a pretty good duo.

[Dr. Horton]

It's pronounced duet. T Mobile Home Internet all in just 55 bucks a month with autopay and any postpaid voice line. Plus get our five year price guaranteed.

[I]

Exclusions like taxes and fees apply. Guarantees, regular monthly rate plan price of fixed wireless 5G Internet data with qualifying service after $15 bill credit with the postpaid voice line plus $5 a month without auto pay with debit or rack account. Regulatory fees include for qualifying accounts, $35 connection charge applies. Speeds vary due to factors affecting cellular networks. Additional terms apply for J.D. power 2024 award information.

[Yvette Gentile]

In 2003. The Cranmer family has spent over a decade in this house. Bobby Jr. Their second oldest, is now 16 and in high school. And like his father, he's also going through a rebellious phase. He's skipping class, he's disappearing for days at a time. And he regularly takes his Parents car without asking, even though he doesn't even have a license. On September 14, 2003, Bob tries to get through to his son by planning a fun day out with. So they go to a baseball game, and then they just drive around town just talking and bonding. And things seem to be going really well. But when they get home, something shifts in Bobby Jr. He gets into an argument with his dad over something so small, and Bobby Jr just flies into this massive rage. He starts cursing at his father, and then he actually begins beating him. And according to Bob, he has no choice but to defend himself from his son. It's so bad that their other son, Charlie, joins in attacking his father. And then he feels like he's got to call 911. The police actually arrive, and since Bob is The adult, Bobby Jr. Is the minor. Bob is arrested for assaulting his son. And this is seriously upsetting. But it makes a light bulb go off in Bob's head because he thinks Bobby Jr. Is not inherently violent, and neither is he. Bob decides something is going on in his house that he can simply no longer ignore. Maybe his family is being influenced by something sinister. Perhaps something that's just been reawakened.

[Corinne Vian]

Well, especially because it happened the moment they pulled back into the driveway. It's like, everything was fine. Great day. The second they're in the influence of this house, something changed.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I also, I don't know, I'm becoming a little bit suspicious of Bob. The fact that the youngest son joined in to attack his father made me question, is this demonic influence or is there something else Where Charlie is seeing this and he presumes that his father did something and immediately joins his brother in the fight, rather than saying, oh, no, there's a quarrel going on. I need to try to stop both parties here. I just find it bizarre that he immediately jumped to also attacking his father and start fighting.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah, right. And defending his brother. Heavy stuff.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah, for sure.

[Ashley Flowers]

Well, to find out more, Bob finally reaches out to every spiritual leader in town. Ministers, priests, and nuns. And when he talks to one nun in particular, he learns something new about his home. She says from everything that she's heard, Bob's house isn't actually haunted. It's possessed by a demon.

[Corinne Vian]

I'm just also so confused. Like, this nun is like, oh, yeah, your house is possessed by a demon. It's not just any spirit. Like, how would she know if people know this?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah.

[Yvette Gentile]

How did she know that? Yeah.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

And also, wouldn't the priest have done.

[Ashley Flowers]

More if it was a demon?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah, if that were common knowledge within. Yeah, the church.

[Ashley Flowers]

Right.

[Corinne Vian]

We've also talked a lot about this on our podcast, where I feel like when you give something power, you know, maybe there is a haunting happening, but if you start to say, oh, there's a demon haunting my house, you do give it more power. And can our minds manifest something more sinister than what was actually there? To start off, it's totally possible.

[Ashley Flowers]

But according to the nun, this only happens when serious sins are committed. Things like adultery, suicide, even murder. So it's not like demons can possess just any old house. According to her, there has to be a dark history there. The nun asks Bob if he knows of any serious sins that have happened in his home prior to him owning it. And he can't think of any offhand. But something about her theory resonates with him. After their conversation, he's convinced he has to be dealing with some sort of possession. But it's almost like once Bob catches onto this, the demon acts up even more.

[Yvette Gentile]

And the thing is, he and the family, they can't rest. They're waking up to unexplainable scratches on their arms and their legs.

[Corinne Vian]

Jeez.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, this is some heavy duty stuff.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Which is like, how do you explain that, like, all of the things that have happened so far we could attribute to burnout, to developing minds, to old creaky houses, Right? Like, there's ways to write them all off, but random scratches that you wake up to? I mean, what's your explanation? That's the question that I have for all the skeptics out there. How do you explain that?

[Yvette Gentile]

Right, Exactly. And I agree with you 100%. And it's not just the scratches. On some occasions, they're even waking up where the walls are bleeding. This is where I get, like, really freaked out, because this is. You know, people are actually seeing this. Right? So he and his wife Lisa, they said that they woke up one morning and they literally found pools of blood on the floor. Now, Bob certainly doesn't know what to do with this, so again, he goes back to the priest for advice, and he gets this. The priest says the best response is to pretend not to notice. If the demon realizes the bloody walls are bothering the family, it'll just keep doing it. Instead, the priest advises Bob to keep sleeping in the room with the bleeding walls and to continue to have regular sex with his wife, Blood or no.

[Ashley Flowers]

Blood in that room.

[Corinne Vian]

What? Ew.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Is this guy okay?

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah, the priest. I don't know.

[Yvette Gentile]

I mean, have you. I've never heard of this. Anything like this in the stories that we've done when we were talking about priests to stay in the room and.

[Corinne Vian]

And advised to have sex.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Ugh, no, never.

[Corinne Vian]

I. Okay, so we covered recently the San Pedro poltergeist, and they had a similar situation where some weird liquid was oozing out of the wall. And they tested it in a lab and it showed up as blood, like belonging to a male human. And now I'm so curious if they tested this blood.

[Ashley Flowers]

Not that I know of.

[Yvette Gentile]

Geez, can you imagine? This is not what Bob was imagining. Like for the priest to tell him, you know, stay in the room, have sex while the walls are bleeding. So he sort of takes the matters into his own hands. So one night, Bob shuts himself in his closet and he starts to read the Bible out loud. He's hoping that God's word will make the evil spirit go away. Instead, the more Bob reads, the more he gets this horrible feeling of dread, like something even more terrible is coming. And night after night, he sits and he reads the Bible for as long as he can stand it. But the demons, they don't go away. They're still there.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

And what a scary thing too, for him now as a religious man who looks to God for protection, to do it consistently, to constantly call out to use all of the tools he has been told to use, and it change nothing.

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah, seems like it's making it worse more than anything for sure.

[Ashley Flowers]

And whether it's a demon or several demons, they start acting up even more after this point. So for example, at one point Bob has. Do you remember that movie? You too might be a little too young with the Passion of the Christmas.

[Corinne Vian]

I feel like I probably watched it in like ccd.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah, I've seen clips of it, but I've never. I've never watched it.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah, I. I don't know why I watched it, but I remember watching it. But anyway, Bob has the Passion of the Christ playing on loop in the living room. He thinks it might just annoy the demon enough so much that it leaves his home. Instead. The spirit just keeps shutting off the television.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Okay, well, let me interject once here and say I am almost positive that the Passion of the Christ is one of those movie sets that has the reputation of having been horribly haunted.

[Ashley Flowers]

I think you are correct. So maybe not the best movie for him to pick.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

So he was just. Yeah, making it even worse.

[Corinne Vian]

I'm just picturing like the same demon was the one who haunted that set and was like, that wasn't my best work. I need to turn this off.

[Ashley Flowers]

I know Bob should have picked something else. But of course, there's other eerie things happening around this time. Bob keeps finding loose change around the house, only it's standing upright on the rim. Bob thinks this is the demon trying to catch his attention. So the family starts hanging crosses and crucifixes all over the house, only to find they never really last. They're always torn off the walls and broken by morning. So the one thing Yvette and I are always screaming at this point of the story is, get the f out.

[Corinne Vian]

Right?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

When in doubt, move out.

[Yvette Gentile]

Move out.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yes. When in doubt, move out.

[Yvette Gentile]

Say, yeah.

[Ashley Flowers]

Well, in Bob's case, he can't move out. He ends up listing the home for sale, but no one is even remotely interested, which is actually sort of a relief for Bob at the same time, because he's feeling a little bit of guilt about putting another family through what his family is going through. It seems irresponsible and unfair on his part. Instead, he decides, for better or worse, it's up to him to figure out how to get rid of this spirit or demon.

[Yvette Gentile]

So Bob returns to the private sector in the year of 2000. But one of the perks of being a former government owner official is that Bob has connections. He knows people. So he reaches out to the mayor of Pittsburgh, and the mayor, in turn, is friends with a powerful Catholic bishop. And the bishop agrees to send an official exorcist to the house. So in early January of 2004, Bob has the priest come over, and he hosts a short, private religious service for Bob and his family. And then he walks around the house, and he prays in every single corner, just like what happened, you know, shortly after they moved in. And this time, the priest stops in every room, including Bobby Jr. S. Now, Bob is hopeful that this will solve his demon problem, but it doesn't. And here's how he knows. Bob is a huge art fan. He has a lot of frame pieces all over the house. And the morning after the exorcism, every single one of them is crooked or even upside down. Like the spirit spent the whole night knocking them around just to show how unbothered it was by this exorcism. So the priest comes back, and they go through the whole thing again. And at this point, Bob has to be thinking, well, this didn't work the last time. I mean, are we going to try something new? Is this going to work? Right? But the holy man tells him that sometimes you need to perform a whole bunch of exorcisms to get rid of a demon permanently. He says it's like fighting a war. And it's not like it's not over at the first battle, so you have to keep fighting, like, again and again and again. Have you guys heard this before where people do exorcisms over and over again?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. And I. Sabrina, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it might have been the Smurl family possession case, where they actually had many people from their church come over and had this, like, massive prayer and exorcism on the house. And unfortunately, it did very little for them.

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah, but I also. And, you know, we've been doing this for seven or eight years now at this point, so we've only scratched the surface, really, in terms of possession and exorcism cases. But, like, a lot of them seem to, like, have this repetitive cycle of exorcisms performed, and yet it doesn't really. Like, it might put it to bay for a little bit, but it doesn't actually get rid of the possession or the demon. And the demon, the only way it leaves is just, like, randomly out of.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

The blue when it chooses to.

[Yvette Gentile]

When it's ready to go.

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah.

[Yvette Gentile]

Well, I mean, Bob seems to buy into this whole exorcism, you know, is a war. Like, the war is on for him because he has two more priests come over for an exorcism on a Friday night in February 2004, and then they come back in May and they do the same thing again. And this goes on and on and on. And Bob does what he can. I mean, between exorcisms to make his house as unpleasant for these evil demons as possible, he does what we all would do. I mean, I know Rasha and I do this where you sprinkle salt across your doorway in the home. And that's what Bob does. He. You know, he does the salt, he does the crosses. And if you've ever seen the movie the Exorcist, you might imagine this is how it all played out, Right? For weeks, maybe months. But no. You guys, do you know how long this took? Two years of doing this regularly? Like, repeated exorcism after exorcism for two years? I mean, is that not dedication? I mean, this man obviously wants to stay in this home because how dedicated is he to be going through all of this for how many years now with his family?

[Corinne Vian]

Also, what's happening to them within this two years?

[Yvette Gentile]

I know, but.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Okay, wait. I'm trying to do some math here. Is there only one child left in the house at this point, because his second oldest was 16. And now there's two years of exorcisms happening. Did one child moving out happen at the same time that the exorcism stopped? That's another question I have.

[Yvette Gentile]

Ooh, that's a good question, Corinne. Ooh.

[Ashley Flowers]

We should have Sabrina grab the book on her shelf and find out.

[Corinne Vian]

Yeah, if I could just touch it, put my hand on the book, and just consume everything it had in there.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Quick, Sabrina, read 300 pages and let us know the answers in the book.

[Ashley Flowers]

And let us know.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, okay. So obviously it was a long two years, because even in 2006, the Cranmers are still waking up with bizarre scratches all over their bodies. They're actually still seeing dark figures lurking around the home, and the furniture is still moving.

[Corinne Vian]

Jeez.

[Yvette Gentile]

While everyone is still irritable. They're exhausted. They're stressed. I mean, it's like the house has this bad mojo, and it's getting to all of them, which is obviously, it's totally understandable. But that year, the exorcists do another ritual, and this time, it actually seems to work. Bob is so relieved and impressed by the priest's work that he actually converts back to his childhood faith of Catholicism. Afterwards. And to this day, he is a devout Catholic. In fact, Bob goes on to write a book about his experience. It's called the Demon of Brownsville Road. And right on the first page in the acknowledgments, he says, and this is a quote, I owe everything to the Lord Jesus Christ, who died for me on a Roman cross.

[Ashley Flowers]

And speaking of Bob's book, it generates a lot of controversy. Now, some people love it. Fans of ghost stories devour the spooky narrative. And interestingly enough, devout Christians like how Bob's account highlights how good and powerful God can be. Copies fly off the shelves, and lots of bookstores sell out. But then, of course, there are the critics. Lots of people accuse Bob of making the whole story up for attention or money. People end up taking sides. Some Brentwood residents are pro Bob, and others side with the skeptics, assuming he's being dishonest. Either way, his credibility is shot, as is his political legacy. But as far as Bob's concerned, it was worth the cost. And he's not afraid to tell his truth or. Or to evangelize about his faith. He and his family start getting the peace and quiet they were hoping for. By 2019, his children are all grown up and living lives of their own. Bob doesn't need the whole house. To himself anymore. But he still can't bring himself to sell his dream home. So he converts it into a bed and breakfast. Interestingly, he's open with his customers about the house's history. And okay, you might be thinking, like, he must be marketing the B and B as a haunted house, right? Maybe he had made up the whole story about the haunting to make money after all. But Bob is very clear with his clients that his home is not haunted. At least not anymore. He doesn't want them to think of it as a spooky destination or that he's trying to profit off the earlier possession. The thing is, Bob seems almost afraid of reinviting the demon back in. He even goes as far as to ban guests from using Ouija boards. And he outright refuses to book ghost hunting teams. Bob knows that the house has a dark history beyond the one he experienced. Remember back in 2003 when Bob met with that nun? She told him that demonstration only haunt places that have serious sins in their histories. And at that time, Bob did look into this. That's when he found out that his house didn't just have one tragedy in its past. Turns out the land's entire history is soaked in blood.

[Dr. Horton]

T Mobile Home Internet is all about speed. Speed value.

[H]

What you doing, Zach?

[Dr. Horton]

I'm rehearsing for our T Mobile Home Internet radio commercial. There are so many benefits and awards. You gotta talk fast.

[H]

Well, let me try. T Mobile Home Internet ranks number one in customer satisfaction for home Wireless Internet by JD Power.

[Yvette Gentile]

Wow, you are good.

[H]

Try singing it. It loosens up the vocal cords. Watch. T Mobile has a five year price guarantee.

[Dr. Horton]

They won't raise your rate on Internet.

[H]

That's not bad. Try enunciating. Be loud. Hulu and Paramount plus on there on. Not bad. We make a pretty good duo.

[Dr. Horton]

It's pronounced too F. T Mobile Home Internet all in just 55 bucks a month with autopay and any postpaid voice line. Plus get our five year price guarantee.

[I]

Exclusions like taxes and fees apply. Guarantees regular monthly rate plan price of fixed wireless 5G Internet data with qualifying service after $15 bill credit with the postpaid voice line plus $5 a month without auto pay with debit or rank account. Regulatory fees included for qualifying accounts. 35 connection charge applies. Speeds vary due to factors affecting cellular networks. Additional terms apply for JD Power 2024 awarded information. Visit jdpower.com awards.

[Ashley Flowers]

After Bob Cranmer met with a nun in 2003, he wanted to learn more about the house he was living in. In particular he wanted to know what kind of evil could have happened on this property to attract such a dark and sinister entity. So he dove into historical research, and he found records of a massacre that happened all the way back in the year 1792. This is right after the United States was established as a nation. And in Brentwood, Pennsylvania, there was still a lot of unrest between the European settlers and the indigenous people of that time. Sometimes tensions erupted into violence. At some point in early 1792, a European woman was walking down the street with three of her children. Without warning, a group of indigenous people surrounded the four of them and in a heated dispute, ended up killing the woman and her children.

[Corinne Vian]

Oh, no.

[Ashley Flowers]

Yeah. The woman's husband, who was on the other side of town at the time of the attack, ended up planting an oak tree at the site of the murder. It's still standing today, towering in the front yard of one particular house. Bob's house, at least according to him. Now, I want to be very clear. The murders have been verified in numerous official records and news articles, but historians say that there is no evidence that the massacre took place on Bob's property. This is all mostly coming from him. And I have to say, we don't really know the truth. I mean, what if the Europeans were provoking the indigenous people? I just. Just have to put that out there. We don't know all the sides to the story.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. Saying that there are records and newspaper articles, like, written by who?

[Ashley Flowers]

Right, Exactly.

[Corinne Vian]

And also, I feel like this is Bob really trying to find a reason. And I totally get that, because after going through something like this or enduring hauntings, you want to find a reason. You want to be like, yeah, the reason this place is haunted is because XYZ terrible things happened here. But as we've learned through the years of our own personal encounters and through reading other people's and researching them, sometimes there is no reason. And it's kind of like anywhere in the world can be haunted. Any person can be haunted. Anything can be haunted. But as humans, we want to find rationale in the unknown, right?

[Yvette Gentile]

Right. We want the answer either way. I mean, Bob believes this tragedy helped attract evil energies to his house, but he doesn't think it's the only factor that led to the possession. Because about 100 years go by after those four deaths that we just talked about. And then in the early 1900s, a woman named Mrs. Malik and her husband buy the land. She builds a house, namely the house that Bob lives in now. But she's also married, which is a problem for one of the construction workers building the house because he has a huge crush on her. Every day, Mrs. Malik comes out to the construction site to see how things are going, you know, and of course, she's wearing fancy clothes and her hair is done nicely. And this construction worker is just stunned every time he sees her. But Mrs. Malik doesn't give him the time of day. And it's not that she doesn't return his feelings. It's just that she doesn't even realize that he exists. So eventually, the construction worker gets fed up. Or supposedly, this is what they say. He puts a curse on the house.

[Corinne Vian]

So he was obsessed with her, and.

[Yvette Gentile]

Right. She didn't pay any attention to him. So he's like, well, I'm gonna get you. I'm gonna curse this house. So supposedly he puts a curse on one particular plank that is left in the home's basement and stays there until Bob moves in and actually learns about it.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I will say one thing. I do think that this man was a little bit clever in cursing just one singular plank of wood, because who could figure that out?

[Corinne Vian]

Right?

[Ashley Flowers]

Right.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

There was some thought behind this. Have you heard about the egg technique to find out if you've been hexed or if there's a curse on you?

[Ashley Flowers]

No.

[Yvette Gentile]

No.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Okay. So if you crack an egg into a cup of water and you give it, like, a couple minutes, you see how the yolk transforms in the water. And based on the pattern, it's almost like tea leaf rating based on what happens to the yolk. It means different things. And one of those things could be that there was a hex or bad energy placed on you. And what's also very interesting, I actually did it the other day because I had, like, a million car accidents and a bunch of stuff happen to me and hospitalizations all at once. And I was like, what's happening to me? And someone told me about the egg thing, and I did it, and it said that there was a curse placed on me.

[Ashley Flowers]

How do you get rid of it?

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

That's a great question. I asked everyone in our. In our two girls, one ghost community to just send good vibes to me, and it seemed to have done the trick.

[Ashley Flowers]

Hey, good vibes help.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. But one thing I learned from some of the practicing witches in our community is that curses and hexes don't have to be created with intention. So, like, someone doesn't have to consciously think, I need to place a curse on this person. It could just be so many negative thoughts and feelings that someone has that's Projecting through the space and onto this other person. They don't know that they just cursed you, but it does kind of speak to, like, the power of our thoughts and our minds and how powerful we can be and just trying to, you know, manifest good in thinking good, energetic things. And that will all come back to you in the end.

[Ashley Flowers]

I love that.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, me too.

[Ashley Flowers]

Well, after Bob learned about the curse Wooden plank. He also uncovers reports about a person he calls Dr. M. Bob says that in the 1920s and 30s, this man lived in the brownsville street house. He also had a bad reputation and a tendency to drink too much, which is not a good quality for a doctor, Especially one who performed illegal abortions out of his own home. Which, according to Bob, is exactly what Dr. M did. The house's back door was impossible to see from the street because of how the doorway and the porch were set up so women could sneak in and out of the home late at night with little risk of anyone knowing what they were up to. Unfortunately, the door came to be known as the door of sorrows because of the bad treatment many of the clients received during their surgeries. Allegedly, Dr. M didn't really want to help his patients. He looked down on them and was often rude and dismissive, and he also didn't follow proper medical procedures.

[Corinne Vian]

My question, though, is, is this a rumor, or are there documents about this?

[Ashley Flowers]

The facts? I think it's just according to Bob. Okay, I think. But again, I haven't read his book, so I don't know 100% for sure. But allegedly, there was a report of at least one of Dr. M's patients who died. And to cover up her death, Dr. M burned her body in the basement furnace. Then he ended up burying the ashes in the backyard of the home. Bob thinks that Dr. M's work may also be what attracted evil spirits to his house. The woman's murder, along with her children in 1792 and the curse on Mrs. Malik probably didn't help either. But he believes Dr. M is the main reason that evil resides there. Although Bob does say that the woman's ghost is still around, and she's definitely not evil. To this day, people claim to see a woman dressed like an 18th century puritan walking the grounds outside of Bob's house. She doesn't harass anyone or hurt anyone. She's not an angry spirit, apparently. She's just a restless ghost going about her eternal business. Now, here's a question. Do you believe that there are good and evil ghosts, and can they live in the Same place.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yes, totally. 100% yes. Without a doubt.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah.

[Corinne Vian]

Okay. This is a random theory that. Because when I was briefly, just in preparation for this episode, looking up the case, there was this theory that I ran into that some people speculated that the Cranmer family was targeted because of their bloodline.

[Ashley Flowers]

Oh.

[Corinne Vian]

And allegedly, one of Bob Cranmer's ancestors was a real historical figure named Thomas Cranmer, who was the first Protestant archbishop of Canterbury during the English Reformation and worked helping dismantle the Roman Catholic influence with King Henry viii.

[Ashley Flowers]

Wow.

[Corinne Vian]

And was later executed, burnt alive at the stake for heresy by Queen Mary I, AKA Bloody Mary.

[Ashley Flowers]

Stop.

[Yvette Gentile]

What?

[Corinne Vian]

So, again, allegedly. But when I read that, I was like, okay, this kind of makes sense. If Bob now is this devout Catholic and he comes from a family bloodline that dismantled Catholicism, is there some darkness that his ancestors kind of sent to him?

[Ashley Flowers]

Gotta break that generational trauma, baby.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah. Well, and also with the woman who's wandering the grounds, it's interesting because when you guys were first saying that the family would come downstairs and all the lights would be on, my first thought was, someone else is in that house who is afraid. Like a spirit is in that house who's afraid of who's upstairs at night or who's in the basement. Like, the first floor is the safe zone. And that was my first thought. So I do wonder if this woman perhaps was the person who was turning on the lights and is kind of around and responsible for maybe some of the lulls in the demonic activity.

[Ashley Flowers]

Ooh, that's a really interesting thought.

[Yvette Gentile]

Okay, so let's just summarize everything. So Bob thinks there's a lot of tragedy and heartache in his house's history, obviously. Right. We know a lot of stuff went down on that particular land going back to the European family's murder, the curse on Mrs. Malik and. And Dr. M's illegal medical practice. Bob also believes there's only one person who was capable of getting rid of the demon, and that was Bob himself. In fact, he believes he was fated to fight this demon since before he was born. At one point in his research, Bob talks to a psychic named Connie who had helped with his successful exorcism. And Connie tells Bob that he is a reincarnated soul. She tells him his mother was one of the women who went to Dr. M for an illegal abortion. The procedure killed him and his mother. But instead of moving onto the afterlife, Bob had another shot at existence. He was born as himself Bob Cranmer. And that's why he's always been drawn to this house as a child because he was literally fated to purify it from the evil forces that were possessing it. Drop the mic.

[Ashley Flowers]

Boom. Right?

[Corinne Vian]

I mean, if this were a movie, that's a beautiful tie a bow on it story, But I have just reservations in terms of, like, did Connie know all of the information that Bob gave him? And sure, maybe Bob was fated to defeat whatever evil was here. And I love that for him, if that's his narrative. But I don't know, that feels almost too perfect.

[Ashley Flowers]

Agreed.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

And it does make me think of just some of the reincarnation stories that we have heard. And I feel like there's often at least the energy or the thoughts about a certain place where the person had previously resided. Especially if it was a place where they lost their life. It wasn't rosy, rainbows, butterflies. I want to move here. This place is majestic. So I do find it interesting that he was so drawn to it. If his mom lost her life in a really terrible way, if he also lost his life here, and if this was a place where. Because one of the questions I had when thinking about this doctor who was performing these illegal abortions and he was, you know, just treating people so poorly, I'm like, why even risk your license? Why operate like that? But in the end, it sounds like he was just an evil dude who wanted access to these super vulnerable people. And so, yeah, it just does make me question, I guess, like, well, I guess he's saying his purpose was to go back and banish the evil from this house.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah, yeah.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

But, yeah, no, I'm also left with some questions and reservations, But I also don't want to not believe someone's story.

[Yvette Gentile]

I know. And this is the thing, you know, I think it's the happy ending we would all want to think. Because you think about this man who has put his family through so much by staying in this fricking house for so long and doing these exorcisms for two years.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

But also, like, at the expense of who or what. Right. Like, he's doing all of this to fix the past. But, like, what about his future? What about his kids? How much trauma has he created for them by keeping them in this house and performing exorcisms? Like, what do they say about him and their childhood?

[Yvette Gentile]

That's what I want to know, too.

[Corinne Vian]

That's what I'm left so in search of is what happened to his children and his wife. Like, what are their experiences? And it kind of goes back to what I was saying.

[Ashley Flowers]

Earlier.

[Corinne Vian]

This whole story is coming from Bob, which it's his experience. Like, I'm happy to hear it, but there's so many perspectives we're not hearing.

[Ashley Flowers]

There's other pieces to the story.

[Yvette Gentile]

We need to save that for another episode.

[Ashley Flowers]

But there is something else that we have to talk about. That the demons the Cranmer family were fighting were real, but also metaphorical. It's important not to overlook the mental health conversation here. Right. Whether the house was the catalyst or a symptom to that isn't what's important. What is important is that the family was struggling at times. At some point while he lived in the House, Bobby Jr. Was diagnosed with schizophrenia. Many medical professionals believe his mood swings and his aggression were symptoms of his mental health condition. Not an influence from a dark spirit, much like what happened to Lisa. And sadly, it's very common for people with disorders like schizophrenia to believe that they're being tormented by demons. But more often than not, the best way for them to get help is by talking to a trained mental health professional, not by getting an exorcism. So it's possible that Bob latched onto the idea of this evil spirit or demon to help him make sense of a very difficult situation. If there's one thing we've learned from doing this show, it's that anything is possible. But then again, we may never know the full story of what truly went on inside the Cranmer house. Because, remember, it's not just the Cranmer saying this. There were other people that experienced things there that to this day, they cannot explain. You have the kids, friends who say they saw a shadowy figure in the home, priests who came to perform exorcisms multiple times. And then there are some details that Bob definitely didn't imagine, like his walls bleeding so bad that the liquid was puddling on the ground, which Lisa also saw. Apparently, this damaged the paint so bad that they had to put up brand new wallpaper when he converted his home into a B and B. So, yeah, I think it's more likely than not that the Cranmers were dealing with something that they couldn't explain or control. And if you believe the story, Bob heard from the psychic that he was literally reincarnated to deal with the house. Well, then it sounds to me like this tale is about destiny and fate and a reassurance that no matter how dark things get, good will always find a way to overcome evil.

[Corinne Vian]

Well, that's a beautiful sentiment.

[Ashley Flowers]

Right? I mean, we have to have hope.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Yeah.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yes, you have to. Especially in Telling all of these stories, we always have to look for the light. Always.

[Corinne Vian]

Right. I do want to know what happened to the family who lived there and sold the house to Bob, because we don't have that story either. And they were in such a rush to sell it. They were worried the whole time they were touring the house. They accepted a low offer. So. And people the rumors of the house being haunted. So since the 1930s, there's clearly a lot of stories that went around.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

Well, I know that. I mean, it's kind of a confusing thing, the fact that Bob does not want to discuss the house being haunted today, which I understand, because he's not trying to attract the demonic energy back to the place. But I am curious if there are any reviews out there of people who stayed there and what they may have experienced. Because he can't control the review on the Internet.

[Yvette Gentile]

Right.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

He can only control what he says.

[Corinne Vian]

Is it still a bed and breakfast?

[Yvette Gentile]

It is. Yeah. It's still a bed and breakfast. It is.

[Corinne Vian]

Why do I want to go?

[Yvette Gentile]

Girls trip. Yeah, no.

[Corinne Vian]

Me by myself.

[Sabrina Deanna Roga]

I have enough hauntings of my own over here.

[Ashley Flowers]

I don't need to pick them up. Right, right, right, right.

[Yvette Gentile]

Corinne's like, I love you, but no, no. Well, you guys, I cannot tell you how much of a joy it has been to have you on our show. Sabrina, Corinne, like, you guys are truly the experts, you know, of all of this.

[Corinne Vian]

Rasha and I with an asterisk.

[Yvette Gentile]

Yeah. But truly, like, Rasha and I are just diving into all of these, you know, hauntings and paranormal stories. So to have you two on with us today has been the absolute honor. So thank you so much. Everybody should listen to their podcast. It's called two girls, one ghost.

[Ashley Flowers]

Two girls, one ghost. If you didn't hear us whisper, you.

[Yvette Gentile]

Can find them on YouTube or wherever else you get your podcasts. Mahalo, nuiloa. Thank you guys so much.

[Corinne Vian]

Thank you so much. And we're so excited. Can't wait to have you on our show to talk more about your paranormal experiences and maybe, I don't know, maybe haunt you a little bit on our show.

[Ashley Flowers]

I love it.

[Yvette Gentile]

We're ready. We're ready.

[Ashley Flowers]

This is so supernatural. An audio Chuck original produced by crime house. You can connect with us on Instagram at So Super Supernatural Pod and visit our website at SoSupernaturalPodcast.com Join Yvette and me next Friday for an all new episode. So what do you think, Chuck? Do you approve?

[Yvette Gentile]

Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach. Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families. With Greenlight, you can set up chores, automate allowance and keep an eye on your kids spending with real time notifications, kids learn to earn, save and spend wisely. And parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money with guardrails in place. Sign up for Greenlight [e-mail] podcast.

[Corinne Vian]

Not sure if you have the experience to start your dream job? Good news these days it's the skills that count. Udemy can help you get those in demand. Skills? Want to be an AI mastermind? Learn with us Game developer. We've got you covered. AWS Certified Cloud Practitioner. We can help you prep. You'll learn from real world experts who love what they do so that you can love what you do. Go to udemy.com for the skills to get you started and get set for your dream job.