HAUNTED: Lake Lanier

Summary

Podcast Summary: So Supernatural – HAUNTED: Lake Lanier

Podcast: So Supernatural
Hosts: Yvette Gentile and Rasha Pecorero
Episode: HAUNTED: Lake Lanier
Release Date: May 15, 2026
Production: Audiochuck | Crime House

---

Episode Overview

This episode of So Supernatural dives into the chilling legacy of Lake Lanier, a seemingly idyllic vacation spot outside Atlanta, Georgia, but one that conceals a harrowing history and hosts a myriad of tragic accidents, disappearances, and supernatural tales. The hosts, sisters Yvette and Rasha, peel back the layers of Lake Lanier’s past—from the violent displacement of Indigenous people and the brutal erasure of Oscarville’s Black community, to countless eerie drownings and ghost stories—probing both factual and paranormal explanations behind its deadly reputation.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Illusion of Paradise: Setting the Scene

• Lake Lanier’s Reputation: A premier tourist destination with 14 million visitors annually, boasting 700 miles of shoreline, islands, beaches, and water sports attractions (05:53).
• Contrasting Appearances: “Lake Lanier seems like a tiny slice of heaven right in Georgia. But appearances can be deceiving. And beneath those still waters lie dark and murky secrets.” – Rasha Pecorero (06:29).

2. The Dark History Beneath the Waters

Indigenous Displacement and Suffering

• Before the Lake: Lake Lanier did not exist before the 1950s; the area was originally occupied by Cherokee and Creek nations for thousands of years (06:48–07:14).
• Trail of Tears: Gold rush prospectors pressured the government for land, resulting in the Indian Removal Act (1829) and forcing tribes west along the Traumatic Trail of Tears (07:14–09:02).

“Between 1830 and 1850, roughly 60,000 Cherokee people were forcibly kicked out of their homes and another 4,000 were killed. A fifth of their total population died on the Trail of Tears.” – Rasha (09:02)

Oscarville: A Case Study in Racial Violence

• A Thriving Black Community: Post-Civil War, freed Black Americans established Oscarville, building a prosperous, tight-knit town despite mounting racial tensions (09:58–10:58).
• Outbreak of Brutality (1912): The disappearance and eventual death of May Crow, a white woman, led to baseless accusations, a lynching, and a white mob’s campaign of violence to expel all Black residents (11:31–19:19).

“They all built their lives in a community that didn’t belong to them. And this was where things stood for the next 30 years or so.” – Rasha (20:10)

The Drowning of History: Lake Creation

• From Town to Lake: To supply water and manage flooding, the federal government constructed a reservoir right on top of Oscarville starting in 1946—purchasing land at unfair prices, leaving structures and graves submerged (20:52–22:33).
• Erasure and Renaming: The new lake was named for a Confederate poet, Sidney Lanier, compounding the erasure of the region’s painful legacy (22:33).

3. The Emergence of Ghost Stories and Bizarre Accidents

The Lady of the Lake

• Urban Legend: In 1958, Delia Mae Parker Young and Susie Roberts died after their car plunged off a bridge. Years later, sightings of a young woman in a blue dress with no hands became common—the supposed vengeful ghost “Lady of the Lake” (23:19–24:42).

“Visitors have regularly reported seeing a strange figure walking on the shoreline or even standing on the bridge… Local legend says this is Delia’s restless spirit.” – Rasha (24:42)

Other Haunting Tales

• Mr. Brown's Spirit: Another fatal crash in 1964 led to stories of a lingering ghost on the infamous bridge—sometimes detected by ghost hunting equipment, especially when offered alcohol (25:47–26:43).
• Historic Toll: Since its creation, over 500–700 people have died in Lake Lanier due to drownings, accidents, or disappearances. Numerous bodies remain unrecovered (26:43–27:15).

Miraculous & Sinister Supernatural Accounts

• Chasity Blunt’s Rescue (1997): Chasity describes hearing a mysterious, calming voice (that knew her name!) guiding her to escape from drowning (27:15–29:15).

“They knew her name. Yeah, they said her name. So it couldn’t have been just a bystander.” – Rasha (29:15)

• Violent Phenomena: Swimmers report feeling unseen hands pulling at them; boats have caught fire inexplicably; some say water spirits or the unrested dead are responsible for the lake’s extraordinary danger (29:15–29:51).

4. Freak Accidents in Modern Times

• Thomas Milner (2023): A young man jumped into the lake and suffered fatal electrical burns due to a faulty power box—a tragic accident initially unexplained (32:42–33:54).
• Ramon Diaz Soria (2025): A strong swimmer, wearing a life vest, inexplicably sank and drowned. His empty vest resurfaced without him (33:54–35:12).

“He was wearing a life vest, and...even though he had his life jacket on, he sank like a rock. His friends were so stunned, it was like Ramon just vanished right in front of their eyes.” – Yvette (33:54)

• Kyle Glover (2012): The stepson of singer Usher died after a jet ski struck his inflatable inner tube; the tragedy brought national spotlight to the lake’s deadly record (36:04–38:11).

5. Theories: Cursed or Just Dangerous?

• Curse Theory: Some, like haunted tour guide Dave Kahn, cite the “triangle of dark energy”—three historical injustices—that may have cursed the land (38:22–39:46).

“I’m not going to say that I believe in ghosts. I’m going to say I believe in bad juju. And there’s enough of it here to go around.” – Dave Kahn [quote relayed by Rasha] (39:30 approx)

• Rational Explanations:
  • Electrical hazards, improperly worn or malfunctioning safety equipment, and lack of boating regulations.
  • Up until 2013, anyone could rent boats/jet skis—many unlicensed, inexperienced operators led to numerous accidents (40:47–42:06).
  • Out-of-state visitors remain exempt from stricter safety regulations, and the lake bottom is cluttered with submerged vehicles, buildings, and debris—making it hazardous for swimmers and divers (42:06–43:50).
  • Environmental hazards such as large catfish mistaking swimmers for prey (43:50).

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Would you still long to go back if you knew the history?” – Rasha (01:41)
• “Real people, real loss, real grief. For many residents of Atlanta, yes, the lake is a place of joy... But for others, the history of the land sits heavy.” – Yvette (44:56)
• “Remembering and respecting the past of the aina, the land, and our ancestors is powerful because beauty and pain are often rooted in the same soil.” – Yvette (45:30 approx)

---

Important Timestamps

• Origins and History of Lake Lanier: 05:41–22:33
• Oscarville Massacre and Aftermath: 11:31–19:24
• Creation and Drowning of Oscarville: 20:10–22:33
• First Paranormal Event (“Lady of the Lake”): 23:19–24:42
• Modern Supernatural Accounts: 27:15–29:51
• Recent Bizarre Accidents & Deaths: 32:42–36:04
• Regulatory Changes & Ongoing Hazards: 40:47–43:50
• Reflective Closing Thoughts: 44:26–45:59

---

Conclusion

Yvette and Rasha meticulously weave together the historical injustices, endemic dangers, and reported hauntings of Lake Lanier, balancing empathy, skepticism, and reverence for the truth. They drive home that while ghost stories fascinate and terrify, the real horror lies in the documented suffering submerged—pain and beauty, memory and mystery, all tangled beneath those troubled waters.

“The ground remembers, and so should we.” – Yvette (45:41)

Episode dedication: To their friend Monique, the Cherokee Nation and Creek communities, the Black families of Oscarville, and all who lost their lives at Lake Lanier.

---

For more haunting stories and in-depth history, follow @sosupernaturalpod on Instagram or visit sosupernaturalpodcast.com.

Transcript

[A]

We've been the trusted experts since 1960 because nobody knows tires better than we do. And with over 90 tire brands, we have an abundance of options in stock for your vehicle. Buy and Drive [e-mail] Let's get you taken care of. You may think you know McDonald's drinks, but you don't know them like this. From fruity refreshes like the Strawberry Watermelon Refresher and the Mango Pineapple Refresher with Popping Boba to crafted sodas like the Sprite Berry Blast with Berry Flavored Sprite topped with cold foam. Who knew ice cold drinks could be so fire six? All new drinks are here. Try them all now at McDonald's. Refreshers contain caffeine.

[B]

Hey so supernatural listeners, if you enjoy the mysterious and eerie stories we discuss here, then we've got another show you need to check out. Park Predators.

[C]

Hosted by our friend Delia d', Ambra, Park Predators dives into the dark and twisted crimes that have taken place in some of the most beautiful places on Earth. These haunting cases range from stories of disappearances and murders to unsolved mysteries.

[B]

Delia's storytelling will transport you right into the heart of these breathtaking landscapes, and

[C]

her dedication to finding the facts ensures that you get all the details of each case.

[B]

So if you're looking for some more chilling cases, Park Predators is for you.

[C]

Listen to Park Predators available wherever you listen to podcasts.

[B]

All of us have our happy place. For me and Yvette, it's going back home to Hawaii, where the air smells different the second you step off the plane, the sun glistening as it sparkles off of the ocean, the beauty of the aina, the land wrapping you in its embrace. Think about it for a moment. What's your happy place? The place you yearn to go back to the second you leave. It might not be the Hawaiian Islands for you. It could be anywhere that makes you happy. A place you have created beautiful memories. Have you ever stopped to ask what your special place looked like before you got there? Who stood on that land 50 or even 100 years ago? What happened there before it became a picture perfect postcard in your mind? And if you did know the history, would it change the way you feel about that place? Would you still long to go back? Because when we started researching today's topic, which to the naked eye seems like a peaceful, fun, inviting vacation spot outside of Atlanta, Georgia, we had no idea just how much the past could color the these picturesque destinations we get so attached to.

[C]

Rush is talking about Lake Lanier, which is about 60 minutes outside of Atlanta, Georgia. Its shoreline stretches across 700 miles, wrapping around quiet coves, thick Georgia pines, and wooden docks that glow at sunset. It's been a destination full of happy times and good memories for a lot of families. But not everyone knows the lake's heartbreaking and brutal dark history and what truly lies beneath it. There have been numerous sudden drownings and horrific accidents at Lake Lanier. But there are also deeper stories that don't appear on the accident reports, because Lake Lanier holds a hidden, blood soaked chapter in American history. One that's been literally washed away. Which is why the lake is said to attract spirits, curses, and evil forces, all lingering just below the surface. I'm Yvette Gentile.

[B]

And I'm her sister, Racha Pecorero. Let's dive into another episode of so supernatural.

[C]

Before we begin. This episode contains discussions of racial brutality and lynchings, sexual assault and murder. So y', all, please listen with care.

[B]

Picture this. You wake up one Saturday morning. You don't have any plans. The sun is shining and the day is warm. All you can think is how nice it would be to have a picnic by the water, maybe go swimming or even rent a boat or a jet ski. So you hop in your car, go for a quick drive, and spend the day at the most beautiful lake you've ever seen in your life. For those who live in the Atlanta area, this isn't just a pleasant fantasy. It's a typical weekend escape, because just 60 minutes outside of the city limits is Lake Lanier. It's a major tourist attraction with roughly 14 million visitors every single year. This makes it comparable to Niagara Falls or even the Louvre in Paris in terms of foot traffic.

[C]

And that fact alone should tell you that Lake Lanier is a very big deal. It not only draws people from nearby Atlanta, but also vacationers travel from all over the world to take a dip in its waters. It has 700 miles of shorelines with some shallow beaches, but at its deepest point, the lake goes down 200ft, which makes it great for water sports. People can go swimming or rent boats and jet skis. There are public barbecues that are set up on the beaches for people who want to grill. And there's even an amusement park full of water slides. So if you're feeling extra adventurous, the water itself is dotted with 160 islands, some of which are very small, but some are enormous. And that water park is one of them.

[B]

So whether you want to swim, nap in the sun, or rent a boat, Lake Lanier seems like a tiny slice of heaven right in Georgia. But appearances can be deceiving. And beneath those still waters lie dark and murky secrets.

[C]

To understand the lake's legacy, we have to tell you about its history. Because thousands of years ago, Lake Lanier didn't exist. Instead, two major rivers snaked across those plains, and the Chattahoochee and the Chestatee. Stormwater from the nearby Blue Ridge Mountains fed these rivers. And occasionally, during rainy seasons, there would be dangerous floods.

[B]

Two indigenous communities lived in the area, the Cherokee Nation and the Creek. This was their home for thousands of years. But in the 1820s, a group of miners discovered gold in the Blue Ridge Mountains. Suddenly, people from all over the country poured into the area, hoping to strike it rich. However, the prospectors didn't want to share their wealth with those who actually owned and lived on the land. So they campaigned for the federal government to remove the Cherokee and Creek people from Georgia altogether. And in 1829, President Andrew Jackson sided with these claim seekers. He signed the so called Indian Removal act that said every indigenous person who lived east of the Mississippi river had to relocate to a reservation in the West.

[C]

The mass migration didn't happen overnight, though. It took roughly two decades for everyone to gather all of their belongings, leave their ancestral lands and make their way along what was called the Trail of Tears. The journey was long, brutal and heartbreaking, and many indigenous people became ill while traveling. Others didn't have access to clean water or food. And the indigenous communities were accompanied by army soldiers who beat and tortured them if they showed signs of resistance. Anytime someone refused to leave their beloved home, the army would try to evacuate them by force. If the soldiers couldn't threaten or drag them off, they'd kill them right there on the spot.

[B]

It's so heartbreaking to me. Between 1830 and 1850, roughly 60,000 Cherokee people were forcibly kicked out of their homes and another 4,000 were killed. A fifth of their total population died on the Trail of tears. An additional 3,500 Creek people died before they could reach the reservations in the West. And once all the indigenous people had been evacuated from the Blue Ridge region, the settlers moved in. This included miners who wanted to dig gold out of the hills and farmers who hoped the floods had left nutrients in the soil that would make a great harvest. But the farmers needed laborers to work on their plots of land. Luckily for them, there was a huge influx of new settlers in the region in the late 1860s.

[C]

The Civil War had just ended and many formerly enslaved black people had no Home, no job, no formal education. So they wandered through the south looking for work. And many of them settled outside of Atlanta because they could find paid jobs there. Some moved into a community called Oscarville. It sat right on the banks of the Chattahoochee river, close to the farmland. The town had both white and black residents, and while the black residents were outnumbered, they took great pride in building their homes, planting trees and gardens, and investing in local businesses. Which sounds great, except for the fact that racial tensions in Georgia were very high at that time and they got worse with each passing year. That was especially true in the early 1900s, when the economy was in a slump and many white residents couldn't pay their bills or cover their mortgages. Some farmers who lived outside of Atlanta for generations were losing their family homes. In spite of that, Oscarville's black community was thriving. Work was still plentiful, and the residents were living comfortable, secure lives. If anything, this only made their white neighbors in town jealous and angry. And that tension came to a head on the Evening of Sunday, September 8, 1912.

[B]

That evening, an 18 year old white woman named May Crow went missing from her home in Oscarville. Her parents had no idea where she was. So all day and all night, Mae's parents and her siblings wandered through the neighborhood calling her name. They also searched the woods around their house, thinking she might have just gotten lost. The family was still looking for her well after midnight when on the morning of September 9th, someone else found May and she was in bad shape. Mae was lying near the banks of the Chattahoochee river, partially hidden under some large pine tree branches. She was covered in cuts and bruises. Someone had beaten her badly, but she was still alive. May's family took her home and called for a doctor, but they weren't able to wake her up. For the next two weeks, Mae was in a coma. Finally, she passed away from her injuries at the end of September. And since she never woke up, she was never able to tell her family who hurt her or why. But that didn't stop the locals from speculating.

[C]

Just a few days before Mae's attack, in early to mid September, another white woman fell victim to a violent crime. It happened about 20 miles outside of Oscarville. She survived, but she was sexually assaulted. That woman's attacker hadn't been identified by the time of May's death, but based on her statement to police, it was supposedly a black man. Now, there was no evidence whatsoever that her sexual assault had anything to do with May's death. But lots of white residents thought that the same black man must have committed both crimes. And when the local papers wrote about May's homicide, they reported that she was also sexually assaulted before she died. But it's unclear where they got that information or if it's even true. Still, the police turned their attention to four young black people who all lived together in Oscarville. 18 year old Oscar Daniel and his 22 year old sister Jane. Their 16 year old cousin Ernest Knox, and a 24 year old friend named Robert Edwards or Big Rob. Even though there was no evidence linking Oscar, Jane, Ernest or Big Rob to the attack on May, nothing. This reminds me of the five young African American teenagers who were wrongfully accused of a crime they didn't commit in Central Park, New York back in 1989. They served years in prison, but were finally proven innocent. We now call them the Exonerated five. Sadly for Oscar, Jane, Ernest and Big Rob, the only thing tying them to the case was that the four of them lived in a house near the spot May was found beaten. In the police's eyes. That's all the proof they needed to arrest the four roommates and charged them with sexual assault and murder. Then they began building a case to bring to the judge.

[B]

Except this didn't satisfy the accusers. They didn't want to wait for a fair trial. They wanted blood. And they wouldn't be satisfied until someone, guilty or innocent, paid with their life.

[A]

Stitch Fix.

[B]

Stop shopping.

[C]

Get styled. Not today, sweatpants. Somebody's wearing jeans that fit.

[A]

Wow. No photos, please. I'm just a regular dad who happens to have a stylist.

[C]

I really look my best when someone

[A]

else makes the decisions.

[C]

Hey, we can all see you. Two way mirrors. Just share your size, style and budget.

[A]

And your stylist sends personalized looks right to your door. Stitch Fix. Get started today@stitch fix.com.

[C]

i want to hug you.

[B]

I'm gonna hug you. I'm coming.

[C]

I'm coming in for a hug.

[A]

It's time. Time to get credit for the work you've put in. Time to earn the recognition you deserve for what you've learned. Purdue Global is designed especially for working adults, and it's backed by Purdue, one of the nation's most respected and innovative universities. When you have a degree respected by employers, there's nothing stopping you from building the career you want. You can do more, be more, have more. For you and your loved ones. Purdue Global advisors and faculty are here to support you from start to finish as you earn your degree. And that support doesn't disappear after you graduate. You'll join a powerful alumni network. This is your time, and you're worth the work it takes to get an education and build a life you're proud of. Start your comeback today at purdueglobal. Edu.

[C]

On September 9, 1912, May Crow was found beaten near her home in Oscarville, Georgia. The police didn't know who had hurt her, but they arrested four black locals and charged them with the crime despite zero evidence against them. And then on September 10, three days after May was found, an angry mob assembled outside the local jail. Among them were a few Klansmen, stoking the crowd into a frenzy. Once their anger was at a boiling point, they broke into the jail and searched the cells for the four prisoners, but they only found one, Big Rob. The others were being held at a county facility. The townspeople dragged Big Rob out of his cell and beat him with crowbars. Then he was shot to death before they strung up his body. And the mob didn't stop there. That night. They marched and rode their horses up and down the streets of Oscarville. Each time they passed a house where a black family lived, they set it on fire. The mob did the same to the churches the black community attended and the stores they shopped at. Men and women and children were woken in the middle of the night smelling smoke and hearing flames crackling outside their bedrooms. They had to jump out of the windows and race out of their back doors trying to get to safety. But when they got outside, there was often a gang of Klansmen and their own white neighbors waiting for them with guns and knives. They drove their victims to the banks of the Chattahoochee river, and another group of violent locals blocked the only bridge across it. Many frightened black families had no choice but to swim in the dark in their pajamas because it was the only way to get out of town alive.

[B]

This is so heartbreaking to me. By the time dawn arrived on September 11, many families had fled and the mobs began to disperse, many of them going to tend to their farms. But when night fell, they assembled again, and they went right back to terrorizing the black neighbors who were left. The same thing happened the night after that and the night after that. The attacks continued for weeks, well into October.

[C]

That same month, Jane, Oscar and Ernest went on trial for May's sexual assault and murder. While Jane was found not guilty, Oscar and Ernest were both convicted without a shred of evidence against them. After their verdict came down, another mob assembled to lynch the two men. And after that, the nightly attacks still continued. By mid November, Oscarville's black community had completely disappeared. There were 1100 black people living in the town before May's murder. Now there were none. Everyone had either been killed or run out of town.

[B]

Which meant there was no one to stop the white residents from taking all their land, their houses, and their businesses for themselves. Farmers began planting their crops on their stolen plots of land. Families moved into newly abandoned houses. They all built their lives in a community that didn't belong to them. And this was where things stood for the next 30 years or so. By the mid-1940s, the descendants of those white farmers were still living on the same land. However, a new threat was looming, A natural one this time. The Chattahoochee River.

[C]

The river had still been flooding on a regular basis, but it was now considered a major problem because Atlanta was a growing city with lots of suburbs. And those floodwaters were a threat to newly built houses, highways, and businesses. And when you have more people, you need more drinking water. So Atlanta was in desperate need of more reservoirs for its residents. Which is why, in 1946, the US Congress funded the construction of a reservoir. And they decided to build it right on top of Oscarville.

[B]

The federal government offered the residents there a deal. They'd buy the land from them for much less than what it was actually worth. But because many of the farmers were uneducated, they accepted the payout, only to realize after the fact that they couldn't even afford a place anywhere else. With that cash. Once everything was bought and paid for, the government built dams and channels in and around the town of Oscarville, which sent river water onto the streets, the parks, and the lawns that were once part of the town. They didn't remove the homes, the trees, the businesses, or even the graves in the local cemetery. So each time it rained, and every spring when the snow melted, enormous amounts of water raced down city streets. Lawns and sidewalks, flooded. Park benches, picket fences and big trees were all swallowed up. It took 10 years in total, but by 1956, Oscarville was almost completely underwater.

[C]

We say almost because there are some tall hills that aren't completely submerged. They formed those 160 islands we mentioned earlier. But now the region was officially a lake. And to make it even more controversial, they named that lake after a Confederate soldier turned poet named Sidney Lanier. Tragically, there was no sign of the thriving town that once stood there. At least not above the water. But Oscarville's secrets hadn't disappeared. They were only submerged. And before long, whispers said that something dark and Supernatural was lurking just beneath the lake's surface.

[B]

The gossip begins about two years after the lake was created in 1958. That's when two young women go out dancing in the Atlanta area. Their names are Delia Mae Parker young and Susie Roberts. They end up having a great time, but once the night is over, they need to drive back home. And their route takes them on a bridge that stretches right over Lake Lanier. Except that night, the bridge seems to be slicker than usual because the women only make it part of the way before their tires start sliding, and they end up losing control of the car. It plunges straight into the lake, and neither of them makes it out alive.

[C]

Sometime in the following year, a fisherman finds Delia's body floating. She's in the same blue dress she wore on her night out, and she's missing her hands. Nobody knows how she ended up in the water because no one witnessed the accident. Plus, the lake is too muddy for anyone to see the car sitting at the bottom. But that changes 31 years later in 1990. That's when rescuers finally discover her car on the lake bed, and her friend Susie's remains are still belted into her seat.

[B]

Ever since Delia and Susie's death, visitors have regularly reported seeing a strange figure walking on the shoreline or even standing on the bridge. They describe her as a young woman in a blue dress who doesn't have any hands. Local legend says this is Delia's restless spirit, and they've given her a nickname, the lady of the lake. Rumors claim she's angry enough to lash out at anyone who crosses her path. Plus, there are a ton of stories of people going swimming in Lake Lanier just for them to see. A woman beneath the water wearing a blue dress. If anyone gets too close to her, it's said she will pull them under the surface. But according to local legend, the lady of the lake isn't the only ghost haunting those shores. Apparently, Lake Lanier is crawling with spirits, like reports of a man known only as Mr. Brown.

[C]

Eight years after Delia and Susie's deaths. On Christmas Day, 1964, Mr. Brown got behind the wheel of a passenger van after drinking. He was on a road trip with his wife and four children and another family they were friends with. He lost control of the van while on the same bridge that Susie and Delia had fallen from, and his vehicle and its 11 passengers plunged into the water. Four people managed to escape, but the other seven, including Mr. Brown, died. It's said his restless spirit still lingers on the Bridge. Today, he's not always visible, but if someone is carrying an electromagnetic field reader or other ghost hunting equipment, they can detect his presence, especially if they offer him booze.

[B]

Supposedly, there are a lot of other spirits at Lake Lanier that can't be identified, which makes sense. Since the lake was created, roughly 700 people have died in its waters. This includes people who have drowned while swimming, those who've been injured in boat crashes, and individuals who've gone to the lake and then disappeared, never to be seen again. As of this recording, more than two dozen people have gone missing in the lake and have since been declared dead.

[C]

Which only adds to the legends and ghost stories about Lake Lanier, because people say there are a lot of spirits with unfinished business, some of which are supposedly angry and violent. But other spirits are rumored to be helpful, too. For example, a woman named Chasity Blunt shared this story on her TikTok. In June or July of 1997, she went to Lake Lanier with some friends. They all decided to go swimming. Chastity was a Florida native who'd grown up right by the shore, so she considered herself a strong swimmer. But during that excursion, she got tangled in the branches of a submerged tree. Her head was stuck underwater. And even though Chasity should have panicked in that moment, she didn't. She had an odd feeling of calm wash over her. And then she heard an unfamiliar voice speaking to her. It was a man's voice, and his words were as clear as day. He said, and this is a quote, chasity, you're underwater. Next, the voice told her to extend her arms as though she was flying like Superman. So she did just that. That's when she said a man pulled her from the lake and carried her back towards shore. Chastity didn't recognize him. He wasn't even dressed like a lifeguard or a first responder. And she never got a chance to thank him because once her friends and some bystanders surrounded her, she lost sight of the guy. To this day, it's unclear if this was just a good Samaritan who saved her or if it was a friendly ghost. And I also have to say I watched a documentary with Chasity, and this still affects her to this day. When she speaks about it, she has no clue how she got out of that water, but she's very thankful that she did.

[B]

And they knew her name. Yeah, they said her name. So it couldn't have been just a bystander. How would they have known that her name was Chastity? Yeah, well, there are plenty of reports of paranormal activities that aren't so uplifting. In the summer of 2025, one boat carrying a family of seven caught fire for no apparent reason. Luckily they all managed to escape. Plus some swimmers say they feel hands grabbing their feet and bodies trying to yank them deeper into the water, which

[C]

might explain another odd feature of the lake. There are a ton of drownings there every single year, and some of their stories are so bizarre and so unlikely they almost have to be supernatural. So lately I've been more intentional about what I wear day to day. I mean truly leaning into pieces that feel effortless and super comfortable but yet still pull together. It just makes getting dressed simpler.

[B]

Quince makes it easy to refresh your everyday this spring with pieces that feel as good as they look. They use premium materials like 100% European linen, organic cotton and ultra soft denim. Yvette, you look amazing.

[C]

What are you wearing girl? I am wearing my trench coat from Quint. It is beige and fabulous. Like I wear it with my leggings, with my jeans, with my tennis, with my heels. All the things it is a must

[B]

have Refresh your everyday with luxury you'll actually use. Head to Quince.com supernatural for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com supernatural for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com supernatural.

[A]

You may think you know McDonald's drinks, but you don't know them like this. From fruity refreshers like the Strawberry Watermelon Refresher and the Mango Pineapple Refresher with popping Boba to crafted sodas like the Sprite Berry Blast with Berry flavored Sprite topped with cold foam. Who knew ice cold drinks could be so fire six? All new drinks are here. Try them all now at McDonald's. Refreshers contain caffeine Life Experience is an excellent teacher. It's time you get the recognition you deserve for those hard earned lessons. Purdue Global values the experience working adults bring to the table. Whether you're interested in a rapidly growing field like cybersecurity, business, nursing or any of Purdue Global's other 170 programs, earning the credentials you need may be faster than you think. Try our experience calculator to see if you could be eligible for course credit and start your comeback today at purdueglobal.edu.

[C]

since its creation, over 500 people have died at Lake Lanier. Many of those deaths were in freak accidents that nearly defied explanation.

[B]

Take the story of Thomas Milner. In the summer of 2023. He was 24 years old and living in the Atlanta area. On Thursday, July 27, he and his family went to Lake Lanier for a day of swimming and relaxation. Almost as soon as they arrived on the shore, Thomas ran toward the water and jumped right in. Then he started screaming. His family didn't know what was wrong. They'd been to the lake countless times before. Thomas definitely knew how to swim, but now he was begging for help and not getting out. His family members were hesitant to follow him into the water, not knowing what the issue was. But eventually someone worked up the courage to jump in after him. And the moment they landed with a splash, they felt a tingling, burning sensation. The rescuer eventually pulled Thomas back onto dry land. His uncle performed CPR while other relatives called 911. An ambulance carted Thomas off to a hospital, but the doctors there determined his internal organs were severely burned. Eventually, his heart had stopped and he died of those injuries the very next day.

[C]

It gets even crazier than that, because two years later, another bizarre incident claimed a life at Lake Lanier. This time it was a 27 year old named Ramon Diaz Soria. On June 14, 2025, he was at the lake celebrating a friend's birthday. He and his pals rented a boat, and Ramon and his friends were taking every precaution. He was wearing a life vest, and he was surrounded by friends who were keeping an eye out on him. At one point, Ramon jumped into the water, and even though he had his life jacket on, he sank like a rock. His friends were so stunned, it was like Ramon just vanished right in front of their eyes. They swam around yelling his name each time they came up for air, but they didn't find any sign of him. Not until a few seconds passed and his life vest floated to the surface. But Ramon wasn't in it. Some friends called 911 while the others kept looking for him. But nobody found Ramon until the next day. He had drowned to death, and his waterlogged body was 60ft under the lake's surface. Again, another tragic accident.

[B]

So it's probably no surprise to hear that Lake Lanier is known as one of the deadliest lakes in all of the United States. Some lakes are more popular and get more visitors, and yet they have just a fraction of the fatal accidents Lake Lanier does. Clearly, something makes this lake especially dangerous. In fact, to this day, professional search and rescue divers try to avoid going into the lake. If someone is trapped underwater and needs Help. They'll send submersible drones instead. That policy went into effect in the year 2022. It was partly to raise awareness about how dangerous Lake Lanier truly is, because, frankly, very few people knew about its dark history. Until one tragic event brought the lake into the spotlight.

[C]

It happened in July of 2012 when the Glover family drove from their Atlanta home to visit the lake. This included an 11 year old boy named Kyle. At one point, the family attached an inflatable inner tube to their boat and sped around with the tube behind them. And Kyle took a turn riding the waves. He was having a blast until a jet skier appeared out of nowhere. The jet ski was going 60 to 70 miles per hour, and it was on a collision course with the boat. There was no time to slow down or stop, so he swerved to avoid the vehicle and slammed into the inner tube carrying Kyle instead. Kyle was immediately rushed to the hospital, where doctors determined he had severe brain damage from the collision. They hooked him up to life support and prayed he'd wake up. But two weeks went by with no signs of improvement, which is when Kyle's mother made the difficult decision to say goodbye to her son. Now, there's one detail that sets Kyle's story apart from all the others we've told, because it had a celebrity connection. Kyle's mother was married to the rapper Usher. And even though Usher wasn't Kyle's biological dad and he was going through a divorce with Kyle's mother, his stepson's death hit him hard. Afterward, Usher spoke publicly about the accident that took Kyle's life. And the more news coverage he got, the more people learned about the other deaths that happened over the years. The hundreds of drownings, disappearances, and freak accidents on the lake. For a lot of people, this was completely shocking. They'd lived in Atlanta their whole lives. They'd been visiting Lake Lanier every summer without ever suspecting that they were in danger. And many of them didn't know about the lake's blood soaked history until now.

[B]

I remember that clear as day when that was happening with Usher and his soon to be ex wife. It was so heartbreaking.

[C]

Yeah, that was devastating.

[B]

Well, naturally, some people wondered if all of the tragedies in the past were linked to the ones in the present day. As though the modern deaths were some sort of spiritual payback for the historic injustices. A local tour guide named Dave Kahn fully buys into this theory. Dave knows a lot about Lake Lanier's history. During the day, he educates visitors on historical events, and at night, he leads haunted tours around the lake, and he believes the lake is cursed because it sits on what he calls, quote, a triangle of dark energy. Dave knows there are three huge injustices in Lake Lanier's past. The expulsion of the original Cherokee and Creek residents from their ancestral lands, the attack on Oscarville's thriving black community, and the exploitative buyout 30 years later. In other words, the land was stolen from the people who lived on it three different times. And as Dave put it, quote, I'm not going to say that I believe in ghosts. I'm going to say I believe in bad juju. And there's enough of it here to go around. So perhaps the history of death and destruction has changed the lake in some supernatural way.

[C]

I mean, you and I definitely believe that. But there's also a natural explanation for all of the deaths, like in the story of Thomas Milner, who died after swimming in the lake. After his death, the authorities learned there was a power box which generates electricity on a dock nearby. These are designed to be used around the water, and they're usually pretty safe. But due to some technical glitch that day, one of the power boxes on a nearby dock turned Lanier into an electrified death trap. Then there was 27 year old Ramon Diaz Soria, who went swimming with his friends in the summer of 2025 and drowned. After an investigation into his death, the authorities concluded that Ramon must not have put on his life jacket properly. So when he jumped into the lake, it possibly popped off and that's why he drowned.

[B]

It turns out a lot of these accidents could have been prevented, and local officials are finally starting to recognize that. As we mentioned before, Lake Lanier is a huge tourist destination. It brings in a lot of money to the region, and local officials want to do everything they can to attract visitors. So up until 2013, they had a policy that literally anyone could rent a boat or a jet ski. It didn't matter if they were a legal adult, if they had a boating license, or if they even knew how to operate it safely. Basically, if you could afford the rental fee, you could operate a boat or a jet ski. Which meant the lake was full of inexperienced tourists operating dangerous vehicles and trying not to crash into one another. That was a major factor in the death of Kyle Glover. The man he collided with had never ridden a jet ski before. He didn't realize it didn't have brakes, not until it was too late. So a year after Kyle's death in 2013, lake officials changed the policies. Georgia residents couldn't rent A boat or jet ski unless they had a license and passed an aquatic safety class.

[C]

But the law doesn't apply to out of state visitors, meaning tourists from all over the country and the world can still borrow vehicles that they don't know how to drive. They can actually hit the water after just watching a short 10 minute training video. There are also loose regulations around disposing trash in Lake Lanier, even when the litter is something really big like a boat. It's unclear how often this happens, but apparently it's quite common for people to buy boats, take them out on the lake, then the vessel springs a leak, and instead of paying to have it hauled out of the water and repaired, the owners just let it sink. Other times, drivers lose control of their cars and trucks or aren't paying enough attention and drive straight into the water. Even if they manage to get out before they drown, they may be unwilling or unable to haul it to land, so they just leave it behind. Which is why the bottom of the lake has a lot of abandoned trucks, cars, boats, fishing poles, I mean, etc. Plus the remains of an entire town. Everything that used to be a part of Oscarville. Trees, houses, buildings, souls.

[B]

The lakebed is also very uneven. There are sudden drops and shallow areas that aren't visible above the waves. So it's very hard for swimmers to know if they're about to do a breaststroke through open water, slam into a shallow, muddy area, or get tangled up in a web of underwater branches.

[C]

There are also huge catfish in the lake and some grow to be £50. They can't tell the difference between the smaller fish and insects they like to eat and people's toes and fingers. So sometimes the catfish will bite someone as they swim by and then drag them deeper. To be clear, this usually isn't a life threatening situation. After a second or two, the fish realize that the person isn't food and spit them out. But this could explain all those stories people tell about watery spirits grabbing their feet and dragging them under.

[B]

Okay, some of those theories kind of make sense to me, but I am still not buying it. Before we let the mystery carry us too far, it's important to pause. Because ghost stories and the supernatural can be so compelling. Legends can be mesmerizing. But whatever theories swirl around Lake Lanier, it's not all folklore. It's real, documented history.

[C]

The land beneath that water holds stories of racial terror and forced displacement of people. When the lake was created, an entire community and history was erased. And in the decades since, there have been devastating accidents, sudden drownings, boating tragedies, families whose lives have been changed forever. Real people, real loss, real grief. For many residents of Atlanta, yes, the lake is a place of joy, of summer rituals and family memories. And that's valid too, because beauty and pain can live in the same space. But for others, the history of the land sits heavy. The knowledge of what happened there before and after the water came is enough to make the shoreline feel different, quieter, sobering. And you don't always need a ghost story to feel that weight. Remembering and respecting the past of the Aina, the land, and our ancestors is powerful because beauty and pain are often rooted in the same soil. The ground remembers, and so should we. And this episode is dedicated to our friend Monique, who shared the true history of Lake Lanier with us, and especially to the indigenous communities of the Cherokee Nation and the Creek, to the African American families of Oscarville, and to every single human being who has tragically lost their life at Lake Lanier.

[B]

This is so Supernatural. An Audio Chuck original produced by Crime House. You can connect with us on Instagram at so supernatural pod and visit our [e-mail] join Yvette and me next Friday for an all new episode. I think Chuck would approve.

[A]

You may think you know McDonald's drinks, but you don't know them like this. From fruity refreshers like the Strawberry Watermelon Refresher and the Mango Pineapple Refresher with Popping Boba to crafted sodas like the Sprite Berry Blast with Berry Flavored Sprite topped with cold foam. Who knew ice cold drinks could be so fire six? All new drinks are here. Try them all now at McDonald's. Refreshers contain caffeine.

[B]

In the world of true crime, the real story isn't always in the headlines. It's in the evidence. I'm Brandi Churchwell, host of 13th Juror podcast, and I'm here to take you past the news cycle and straight into the courtroom. Every week, I'll break down the investigation, the prosecution, the defense, and everything that unfolds beyond the jury box. We'll examine every testimony, every exhibit, and every hidden motive. Listen to 13th Juror wherever you get your podcasts.