Sold a Story: Episode 10 - "The Details" Summary

Released April 11, 2024 by APM Reports

In Episode 10 of Sold a Story, titled "The Details," host Emily Hanford delves deeper into the ramifications of her investigative podcast on reading instruction in U.S. schools. This episode emphasizes the personal stories of students, parents, and educators affected by the prevalent teaching methodologies, while also featuring insights from cognitive scientists on the evolving landscape of reading education.

1. Personal Stories: Students and Parents Respond

Zoe Gaul's Journey

• Introduction to Zoe: Emily revisits Zoe Gaul, a fourth-grader from New York City's Upper East Side, who was featured in the podcast's first episode.
• Current School Experience: [01:45] Zoe shares her positive experiences in fourth grade, highlighting her friendships and a "really cool teacher."
• Reading Progress: [02:07] Zoe expresses confidence in her reading abilities and demonstrates her skills by reading a passage aloud, showcasing her proficiency.

Lee Gal on Curriculum Resistance

• Parental Insights: [02:48] Lee Gal, Zoe's father, attributes Zoe's reading success to supplemental phonics instruction he provided, contrasting it with the school's approach.
• School's Stance: [03:32] Despite widespread issues with the Lucy Calkins reading curriculum, Lee notes that his child's school remains steadfast in its use, dismissing critiques like those presented in "Sold a Story."
• Teacher and Parent Reactions: [04:20] Lee observes a decline in concerned parents, many of whom have opted for private or Catholic schooling, leaving behind those reliant on costly tutoring services.

Missy Purcell's Hopeful Transformation

• Matthew's Progress: [05:57] Missy recounts her son Matthew's transformation after transferring to a private school specializing in dyslexia. Within a year, Matthew became a fluent reader, gained confidence, and thrived socially.
• Emotional Impact: [06:28] Missy's satisfaction underscores the potential benefits of alternative educational approaches when public systems fall short.

Sarah Gannon's Shift to Advocacy

• From Specialist to Advocate: [07:00] Former reading specialist Sarah Gannon discusses her transition from believing in the balanced literacy approach to embracing the science of reading after her daughter's struggles.
• Professional Isolation: [07:25] Sarah shares the personal costs of her stance, including strained relationships with former colleagues resistant to change.
• New Role: [08:06] Now assisting school districts in implementing evidence-based reading instruction, Sarah emphasizes the need for critical evaluation of curricula and robust teacher training.

2. Insights from Cognitive Scientists: Balancing Instruction and Practice

Mark Seidenberg on the Science of Reading Movement

• Positive Shifts: [15:55] Seidenberg acknowledges the movement's success in highlighting the necessity of teaching basic reading skills, such as phonics and the relationship between print and language.
• Concerns Over Oversimplification: [16:35] While celebrating increased interest, he warns against the reductionist approach where educators might overly rely on specific programs without understanding the underlying science.
• Depth of Knowledge: [17:32] Seidenberg points out that only a fraction of the extensive reading research is being utilized, potentially limiting the effectiveness of new teaching methods.

Reid Lyon's Cautionary Perspective

• Lessons from the Past: [24:32] Lyon reflects on his experience with the "Reading First" program, emphasizing that providing information alone does not ensure meaningful change in educational practices.
• Systemic Challenges: [25:43] He underscores the complexity of implementing science-based reading instruction across diverse and large educational systems, cautioning against top-down mandates that neglect the nuances of effective teaching.

Balancing Explicit Instruction and Reading Practice

• Decoding vs. Reading Time: [19:47] Seidenberg highlights the importance of teaching decoding skills explicitly while ensuring ample time for students to engage in meaningful reading—a balance that some current implementations may disrupt.
• Implicit Learning's Role: [21:25] He advocates for fostering implicit or statistical learning through extensive reading, allowing students to internalize language patterns naturally over time.

3. Policy Implications and Future Directions

Impact of New Legislation

• Pressure on Schools: [26:01] Emily discusses the tension between necessary policy support—such as funding and resources—and the risk of schools prioritizing compliance over effective, nuanced instruction.
• Curriculum Commitments: [28:00] Seidenberg warns against schools becoming overly dependent on specific curricula or products, which may limit teachers' flexibility and understanding of best practices.

Potential for Constructive Change

• Collaborative Efforts: [12:05] Christine Cronin, now leading professional development for Boston Public Schools, stresses the importance of teachers feeling connected and supported rather than directed by external mandates.
• Ongoing Evolution: [26:27] Lyon remains hopeful, noting a more mature and thoughtful conversation around reading instruction today compared to past initiatives, though he remains wary of dogmatism overshadowing detailed, evidence-based practices.

Emily Hanford's Reflection

• Work in Progress: [12:29] Emily concludes by acknowledging the complexity of nationwide educational reform, emphasizing the podcast's role in raising awareness and sparking necessary debates.
• Looking Ahead: [12:29] She hints at continued exploration into what works and what doesn't in evolving reading instruction methodologies, promising further insightful episodes.

4. Notable Quotes

• Zoe Gaul on Reading: “[Zoe] says reading is going well. Do you feel like you're a good reader?” ([02:09])

• Lee Gal on Curriculum Resistance: “...the podcast is something no one is supposed to mention at school.” ([04:01])

• Missy Purcell on Matthew's Progress: “He is doing so great. First of all, I was told he would never be a fluent reader. He's a fluent reader.” ([06:28])

• Sarah Gannon on Teaching Challenges: “Teaching is a very personal career because it involves children and it involves their lives. And if you feel like you're not doing something right and you potentially harm them...” ([07:53])

• Mark Seidenberg on Oversimplification: “If people decide that all we need to do is stick to the program here and everyone will read, I think that would be a really big mistake.” ([28:00])

• Reid Lyon on Systemic Change: “You gotta have time to do it. You gotta have teachers who feel like they're being taken care of.” ([24:38])

5. Conclusion

Episode 10 of Sold a Story intricately weaves together personal narratives and expert analysis to present a comprehensive picture of the ongoing struggle to improve reading instruction in America. While there is palpable progress driven by the science of reading movement, challenges remain in ensuring that reforms are both evidence-based and practically implementable across diverse educational landscapes. As Emily Hanford continues her investigation, listeners are reminded of the profound impact that effective reading education can have on students' lives and the continuous need for informed, compassionate approaches to teaching.

For more insights and updates, follow "Sold a Story" on your preferred podcast platform and subscribe to their email list for the latest episodes and related resources.