Episode 10: Closing the Case – Detailed Summary

Release Date: April 28, 2025

Introduction

In the culminating episode of Season 1, "Closing the Case," Somebody Knows Something: The Elgin Police Cold Case Podcast delves into the resolution of the decades-old disappearance of Karen Schepers. Hosted by Detectives Andrew Houghton and Matt Vartanian, this episode encapsulates the exhaustive efforts of the Elgin Police Department's Cold Case Unit in uncovering the truth behind Karen's fate.

Recap of Recent Developments

The episode opens with Detectives Houghton and Vartanian reflecting on the significant breakthroughs achieved in previous episodes. They highlight the recovery of Karen's 1980 Toyota Celica and Karen herself from the Fox River, marking pivotal milestones in the investigation.

• Detective Andrew Houghton [01:58]: "Finding Karen's car was a huge piece of this puzzle, and then recovering her remains was another giant leap forward for us."

These discoveries not only provided closure but also opened new avenues for understanding the circumstances surrounding Karen’s disappearance.

A New Tip Emerges

A turning point in the investigation was a fresh tip from Jane, a former employee at PM Bentley’s, who had previously not been associated with Karen's department.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [02:15]: "Finding Karen and her car was one big step in this investigation, but it was not the end of this case."

Jane's testimony offered critical insights:

• Jane [03:48]: "Karen... was always so friendly and kind... I noticed her in the vestibule crying because her boyfriend wouldn't come out to party with her."

She further described seeing Karen alone in her car, turning south on Illinois Route 25, which was a pivotal detail confirming Karen's solitary departure from the bar.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [05:21]: "We now have an independent witness who says she actually saw Karen leave in her car alone that night."

This information significantly bolstered the detectives' confidence that Karen had left the establishment by herself, shaping the narrative of the night's events.

Forensic Analysis and Identification

The recovery of Karen’s remains allowed forensic experts to conduct a thorough examination, shedding light on her final moments.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [07:13]: "We recovered extensive skeletal remains, including dental remains. This allowed the forensic odontologist to identify Karen in days rather than weeks."

Key findings from the forensic analysis included:

1. Location of Remains: All of Karen's remains were found in the front seat area of her vehicle, corroborating that she was alone when the car entered the Fox River.

2. Condition of Remains: No significant structural injuries, gunshot wounds, or trauma were detected, suggesting that Karen did not suffer from external violence prior to her vehicle entering the water.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [19:43]: "We believe that Karen Shepers suffered no significant structural injuries... she was found in the front seat."

Mechanical Examination of the Toyota Celica

A comprehensive analysis of Karen’s Toyota Celica provided further clarity on the circumstances leading to the vehicle's entry into the river.

• Detective Andrew Houghton [13:49]: "There were no major dents or impacts on the body of the car... the car was actually in remarkably good physical condition for being submerged for almost 42 years."

Key mechanical insights included:

1. Engine Status: The key was in the ignition and in the “on” position, indicating the car was running when it entered the river.

2. Transmission and Speed: The car was in fourth gear and seized in that position, suggesting she was driving at a speed consistent with fourth gear prior to the incident.

3. Brake System: Front brake lines were intact, while the rear brake hose showed corrosion but no signs of tampering.

4. Emergency Brake: The emergency brake was pulled completely up and rusted in place, suggesting it was engaged before the car entered the water.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [15:51]: "Karen's vehicle... was in fourth gear and seized in that position, likely due to the extensive time in the water."

Determining the Cause of the Accident

Based on the combined forensic and mechanical evidence, Detectives Houghton and Vartanian presented their assessment of what transpired on April 16, 1983.

• Detective Andrew Houghton [17:55]: "We believe that Karen's death was simply a very tragic accident."

Key conclusions drawn include:

1. Driving Conditions: Karen was likely driving alone under challenging weather conditions—cold, dark, and slick roads with severe flooding along her route.

2. Vehicle Movement: The pristine condition of the car, coupled with intact windows and deflated tires that retained air, indicated that the vehicle could have floated a significant distance without external impacts.

3. Emergency Brake Engagement: The engagement of the emergency brake suggests Karen may have attempted to regain control of the vehicle before it entered the river.

4. Absence of Foul Play: The lack of major vehicle damage or injuries excludes possibilities of violence or intentional acts leading to the accident.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [20:08]: "We both strongly feel that options like suicide or someone pushing Karen's car into the river are eliminated from this case."

Community and Expert Contributions

The episode underscores the collaborative efforts between the Elgin Police Department, forensic experts, and community members. Special acknowledgment was given to Chaos Divers for their role in the recovery, and to Elgin Toyota for their mechanical expertise.

• Detective Andrew Houghton [07:59]: "We really do appreciate the care they showed, the expertise with which they do their work, and the number of resources they brought in for us."

Conclusion and Reflections

As the investigation wraps up, the detectives express their gratitude towards the community’s support and emphasize the importance of collective efforts in solving cold cases.

• Detective Matt Vartanian [20:51]: "Karen's friends and family deserve to be heard one more time. Please join us next time as we remember Karen Lee Shepers here on Somebody Knows Something."

The episode closes with a poignant reminder from Chief Anna Lally, encouraging anyone with information to come forward, reinforcing the ongoing commitment to resolving cold cases.

• Chief Anna Lally [21:38]: "If you or anyone you know has information about this case or any other cold case in Elgin, please contact the Elgin Police Department Cold Case Unit..."

Final Thoughts

"Closing the Case" not only provides a comprehensive resolution to Karen Schepers' disappearance but also exemplifies the dedication and meticulousness of the Elgin Police Department's Cold Case Unit. Through persistent investigation, community engagement, and expert collaboration, the podcast delivers a narrative of hope and closure, honoring Karen's memory and serving as a testament to the pursuit of justice.