Summary of "Somebody Knows Something" – Episode 3: A Desperate Choice

Released on February 17, 2025

Introduction to Theory One: A Desperate Choice

In Episode 3 of Somebody Knows Something, Detectives Andrew Houghton and Matt Vartanian delve into the first of six overarching theories surrounding the mysterious disappearance of Karen Schepers in April 1983. Titled "A Desperate Choice," this episode scrutinizes the possibility that Karen voluntarily left her life behind or may have harmed herself.

Exploring the Voluntary Departure Theory

Detective Matt Vartanian introduces Theory One by revisiting initial speculations from 1983, suggesting that Karen might have "taken off to blow off some steam" after an argument with her boyfriend (02:27). Chief Anna Lally adds that this theory was expanded to include the potential that Karen "made a voluntary choice to either leave or to harm herself in some way" (02:50).

Family Insights: Unlikely to Leave or Harm Herself

The detectives interviewed several of Karen's family members, providing compelling evidence against Theory One. Gary, Karen's older brother, firmly states, "She was tough... You're not gonna ruin my life or anything like that" (05:39). Susan, her younger sister, concurs, expressing doubt that Karen would simply "up and take off without telling anybody" (05:48).

Detective Houghton reinforces this sentiment, noting, "She was a very responsible person... I don't think that all these years would go by when you didn't at some point, reach back out to your mom and say, you know, I had to get away" (06:05). The family's belief is further supported by Karen's meticulous financial habits; her bank account remained untouched after her disappearance, suggesting she had no intention of starting anew elsewhere (07:18).

Karen's Social Ties: A Strong Reason to Stay

Friends and co-workers also weigh in, unanimously dismissing the idea of Karen running away or harming herself. Heidi, a close friend from high school, recalls Karen's commitment to her upcoming wedding: "Karen had just gotten paid on Friday, April 15, and had received her tax return of over a thousand dollars. None of her money had ever been touched" (07:36).

Detective Andrew Houghton shares heartfelt memories, emphasizing Karen's dependable nature: "She wasn't a free-spirited hippie type person that you could see going off to some commune or whatever and not saying anything to anybody" (07:02). Denise, another close friend, describes Karen as "very friendly, very outgoing... Just a beautiful girl from the Midwest" (11:10).

Co-workers' Collective Voice Against Theory One

The episode highlights a poignant moment when nearly 40 of Karen's co-workers signed an open letter disputing the notion of her voluntary disappearance. Dated April 21, 1983, the letter asserts, "None of us believe that Karen was despondent or had any reason to disappear" (20:31). This collective stance underscores the conviction among those who knew Karen that her disappearance was not voluntary.

The Elusive Car: A Tangible Clue

Detectives discuss the mysterious disappearance of Karen's car, a critical piece in evaluating Theory One. The car's absence complicates the notion that Karen simply left town. Both detectives note, "If her car was found at Terry's house or at her house or was found abandoned somewhere, that would totally change the different theories we had about this case" (25:01).

Despite extensive searches, including flying over salvage yards and distributing her vehicle's VIN and license plate information nationwide, the car remains missing (25:13). This unresolved detail casts significant doubt on the voluntary departure theory.

Psychological Factors: No Indicators of Self-Harm

Further discrediting Theory One is the absence of any signs pointing to Karen harboring suicidal intentions. Detective Vartanian remarks, "She had a strong social structure... She was in constant contact with people in her life" (26:04). The lack of evidence suggesting mental health struggles or substance abuse reinforces the improbability of Karen harming herself.

Emotional Toll on Detectives and Family

Detectives share the profound emotional impact Karen's disappearance has had on both their personal lives and the community. Detective Houghton reflects, "I can't even explain it... I don't know if it's ever anything that you ever get over" (15:40). The unwavering hope and resilience of Karen's mother, who has maintained contact through years of unanswered questions, exemplify the enduring search for closure.

Conclusion: Theory One Deemed Highly Unlikely

After thorough examination, Detectives Houghton and Vartanian conclude that Theory One—Karen making a desperate voluntary choice or harming herself—is "highly unlikely but not impossible" (28:04). The combination of Karen's stable financial situation, strong social ties, and the unexplained disappearance of her car strongly suggests that other theories warrant more substantial consideration.

Looking Ahead: Investigating What Happened at PM Bentley's

The episode concludes with a preview of the next installment, which will focus on PM Bentley's, the last known location where Karen was seen. Detectives will explore interactions with the bar's staff and owner, and investigate claims from an individual who purportedly saw Karen both inside and outside the establishment on the night she vanished (28:29).

Call to Action

Detectives Houghton and Vartanian reiterate their appeal for public assistance in solving Karen's case. They encourage anyone with information to contact the Elgin Police Department Cold Case Unit via email at ColdCaseTips@elginil.gov or by phone at 1-847-289-COLD. Additionally, listeners can review all cold case information on the Elgin Police Department's Transparency Hub at https://elginil.gov.

This summary captures the key discussions and insights from Episode 3, providing an in-depth overview for those who have yet to listen. Notable quotes are included to highlight pivotal moments and testimonies that shape the investigation.