Loading summary
Tiffany Reese
Wondery subscribers can listen to Something Was Wrong early and ad free right now. Join Wondery in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Listening to Audible helps our imagination soar. Whether we're listening to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre we love, we can be inspired to imagine new worlds, possibilities and ways of thinking. Audible has the best selection of audiobooks without exceptionall in one easy app. As an Audible member, I get to choose one title a month to keep from their entire catalog. This month I selected Evil Thoughts, wicked deeds by Dr. Chris Mohandi. Take Audible with you through your week. Listen while doing household chores, going for a walk, commuting, you name it. Audible makes it easy to be inspired and entertained as part of your everyday routine. New members can try audible free for 30 days. Visit audible.comSWW or text SWW to 500500 that's audible. Or text SWW to 500500 this episode is brought to you by Progressive. Most of you aren't just listening right now. You're driving, cleaning, and even exercising. But what if you could be saving money by switching to Progressive? Drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average and auto customers qualify for an average of 7 discounts. Multitask right now quote today@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates national average 12 month savings of $744 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary. Discounts not available in all states and situations. This podcast is intended for mature audiences and discusses topics that may be upsetting. For a full content warning, sources and resources, please visit the Episode Notes Opinions shared by the guests of the show are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of myself, Broken Cycle Media, or Wondery. The podcast and any linked materials should not be misconstrued as a substitution for legal or medical advice. Megan Stoner's responses to these allegations are addressed within this season. I'm Tiffany Reese and this is Something was wrong.
Megan Stoner
You they can know me. You don't know at all. You thinking that with me you never know me well. Hello. You don't know anybody until you tell you someone. You don't know how anybody until you talk to someone.
Justin
Hello. This is a call from an inmate.
Alyssa
At the Hamilton County Jail. This call is from a correction facility.
Justin
And is subject to monitoring and recording. Thank you for using Global tellink.
Megan Stoner
Hey Justin, how are you?
Unknown
Hey Megan, how are you?
Megan Stoner
Hey, I'm good. How are you?
Unknown
I'm good. I do have Some news to share with you that I'm not sure you're going to like.
Megan Stoner
What?
Unknown
The story has been picked up by another journalist that has her own podcast. She's got a very big platform and she is wanting to talk to you.
Megan Stoner
What's her name? Guys, I can't. What's her name? I need her name.
Unknown
Her name is Tiffany Reese.
Megan Stoner
How do you spell that? Someone play my hand. Where is she from?
Unknown
She has a podcast called Something was Wrong. Okay, hang on.
Megan Stoner
Let me write. Hold on. I need a pencil. But you said she's a journalist. Is she with anybody or is she an independent journalist?
Unknown
She's an independent journalist, as far as I know. I know that her podcast is, like, covered by Wondery, which is like, the main podcast company.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I know what Wondery is. Okay, how does she want me to get in touch with her?
Unknown
I have her phone number and you can call her, I think, as soon as tomorrow.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Unknown
I will tell you, this is a very big platform, so she's very nice. I've talked to her like three hours over the last few days. But she does want to talk to you. Re E Se.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Unknown
I believe it's like the number four most subscribed to podcast on Apple. Okay. So it's. It's pretty big. So that's yours to. To deal with. I will give you the phone number. And like I said, I think the thing is, Megan, like, I think she's gonna talk to you one time. Like, do not abuse this number. She was very apprehensive to let you have it. But I was told to give it to you, so I'll give it to you now. Let me know when you're ready.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I'm ready.
Unknown
Okay. The Phone number is 9, 1, 6.
Megan Stoner
Okay. Is she on getting out? Did she say?
Unknown
Oh, I don't think she's on the messaging app.
Megan Stoner
Oh, well, I don't mean that. I mean the video. Well, the video visit. I know it'd be easier to video visit her. That's okay. I'll just call her tomorrow. Would you have any advice?
Unknown
Don't bullshit her. Be honest. Nobody wants to hear you play the victim, Megan. Like, you're going to be asked very specific questions and I would not try to work your way around it. Either answer them or don't, but do not try to lie. It will not go well for you.
Megan Stoner
Okay, well, thanks for the info. I appreciate it. Justin, have you listened to podcasts like her podcast?
Unknown
Yeah, I've actually been a fan of hers for a while.
Megan Stoner
Oh, wow. Okay.
Unknown
I'm not the one that reached out to her, but I guess somebody from the group did and she's taken it up. So.
Megan Stoner
Yeah. Okay. I might give you a call tomorrow night to let you know how things go with Tiffany.
Unknown
Okay. All right, sounds good.
Megan Stoner
Okay, thanks, Justin.
Unknown
All right, bye. Bye.
Justin
Hello, this is a call from an.
Megan Stoner
Inmate at the Hamilton County Jail.
Alyssa
This call is from a correction facility.
Megan Stoner
And is subject to monitoring and recording.
Justin
Thank you for using Global tellink.
Megan Stoner
Hi, this is Tiffany. Hi, this is Megan Stoner.
Alyssa
Okay, I thought so.
Justin
How are you?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I'm okay. Thanks for taking my call.
Alyssa
I spoke to Justin and he told me that he would pass along my number. So I'm glad it got to you.
Megan Stoner
Yeah. I was just curious if you could tell me a little bit about your podcast and kind of your angle on my story.
Alyssa
Yeah, so my name is Tiffany Reese. My main podcast that people know me from is called Something Was Wrong. And essentially audio documentaries is what I make. So the original season started with a story that I came across through someone I knew. But since then, all of our. Our seasons and stories come to us through the listeners. So we actually have a website where we get submissions, essentially, and I actually had multiple people submit your name and this Facebook group that essentially was started surrounding the crimes you've been charged with. So far, I've met with Alyssa and then I spoke with Justin. So far, given the public nature of this case, I've been able to review a lot of the materials quickly given, like the public case files and Twitter and Facebook groups and such. So, yeah, I thought I would reach out to you and see if you would be interested in making a comment. I can also check back in with you once I've had more time to conduct the interviews. But essentially I have a pretty decent idea of what the allegations against you are and what is in the criminal record. And I could certainly go over that from a fact checking perspective with you and have you comment on that if you wanted to, or some people go, no comment. You know, it's really up to you.
Megan Stoner
Okay. How soon are you looking to publish an episode about me?
Alyssa
So we are planning for a season because we've had a lot of people come forward. We have about three to four weeks that we're working on trying to get all of the rest of the interviews done. So in a few months would be the soonest they would start airing.
Justin
Because I have.
Alyssa
I have to conduct a thorough investigation and I have to legally make sure that anything that is included is legally responsible.
Megan Stoner
Right, Okay. I guess I'm just trying to, like, figure out your angle because, you know, I don't want to do an interview and, you know, be made a fool of or just be laughed at, you know, because I am willing to take responsibility and I understand. I just, you know, I don't want to have to, you know, I don't want to be laughed at, essentially.
Alyssa
Yeah. I mean, understandably so, because who wants that? But, you know, given the charges and everything that's out there, you have to know it doesn't look good. I mean, already.
Megan Stoner
Yeah.
Alyssa
And so, honestly, Megan, I don't know how to articulate this. Given that you have put out there publicly that you're a survivor as well, I essentially wanted to, like, extend you extra courtesy.
Megan Stoner
Thank you.
Alyssa
But I'm unclear if those allegations are true or not or which of them are true or not. And so that's what's also difficult, because, you know, being somebody who works with survivors from all over on a daily basis, we take that really seriously, and we take false accusations really seriously because that harms the 97% of survivors who come forward and are being truthful. And so I think that would be the first piece you and I would have to really sort out. You know what I mean?
Megan Stoner
Yeah. And I guess I'm more confused. Are you wanting to look at the crimes that I've committed? I mean, I pled guilty so I can talk about that. That's not, you know, that's not a secret. It's.
Alyssa
Right.
Megan Stoner
Right. Pled guilty. I'm sitting in jail now, but are you trying to go on more my personal life? Because my being a sexual assault survivor, if I am or not, that doesn't really have anything to do with my crime. So I'm just. I'm trying to understand your right.
Alyssa
But false reporting is a crime.
Megan Stoner
Absolutely. I agree.
Alyssa
So that would be a crime. So we will talk about not only the crimes you've been charged with, but if we find that there's other crimes that have been committed, then, yes, we would report on those. And there's a lot of allegations of that that you haven't been charged with, and your victims are seeking justice, you know.
Megan Stoner
Yeah. Well, I guess the other tough part is I've not been able to listen to this pod. I've not really. I don't know what's being said about me out there, honestly, on my allegations, because I've been locked up since April or late part of April, and I was incarcerated for six months prior to that. So it's really really hard to know what even is being said at this point about me. Would you be interested in talking with me after I get out in November, or would that be too late? Because I'd like to review what's being said about me. So when I provide a comment, it's not, you know, shooting just from the hip here.
Alyssa
Well, the problem with that is if I allow you to review all the testimony that's going to come out against you, that will allow you to plot and manipulate further and twist things to make your story make sense. So what we do is we collect everybody's testimony and then we evaluate all of it and that's compiled. We give the opinions of both sides, and we allow the listeners to make the decision. But I don't typically extend my platform to house voices of who we, you know, refer to as like, the predator or the criminal in the situation. But I can always read a comment on your behalf or something of that nature most of the time, honestly, because their lawyer would never recommend that. Especially because you have so many pending legal charges still.
Megan Stoner
I mean, I hear what you're saying. I don't know what is being alleged about me or allegations being said about me right now. I don't know what's out there.
Alyssa
Okay, do you want me to give you a high level of it and you can just not comment on it, but just let me read it to you?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, okay. That'd be great.
Alyssa
So what I have here that I'm looking at just for your reference is like a timeline document that we're putting together, and we organize the evidence in as most, you know, linear way as possible. So the first allegation against you. And I don't have notes on where all of these came from at this time, but we can locate those. But we have from 2012 to 2016, you attended Elmwood Community High School. You started in politics in 2014, and you joined, I believe, called the Young Republicans Club. It's alleged that your parents and you were spoken to by police about falsely accusing one of your church pastors of sexual assault and that the church called you to speak to you upon the realization that you had lied about the accusations. And it was discovered that you had fabricated text messages between you and the accused pastor, claiming that the pastor had wanted you to come to his home to engage in sexual activity with him and his wife. Then we have just, like, basic stuff. So 2015, you were working at Life of America. You were pursuing your CNA license. 2016, 2017, you began volunteering during high school in Local politics. You met Justin in. It sounds like college, heard of you, or you knew of each other, but you never. You only met in person maybe a couple times. It sounds like what Justin reports that he had been told is that you had been essentially fired from your internship for. Let me get the deep lying about the number of places that you were, like, Getting surveys from 2014 to 2017. Your relationship with Kurt Measley was documented a lot. And then I believe that there was allegations made against him at one time. But that's not on here yet. Not against him. Okay.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Alyssa
Just that you worked with him. Basically, he was. Okay, got it. Okay. So 2018, 2022. Your background check shows that you volunteered at the U.S. house of Representatives from 2018 to 2022. Oh, here it is. And this is where it gets murky. Something about you worked with politician Boslo and that that resulted in a sexual assault.
Megan Stoner
Can you say the name? I didn't catch the name. Bos.
Alyssa
You said, I think it's Boswell. Is that. Let me find my notes on that. The autocorrect might have messed me up there.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Alyssa
Something with a B for sure. Hold on one sec. Do you know who I'm referencing? Sorry.
Megan Stoner
Yes.
Alyssa
Okay. And then April 2015, there was a lot of. There's, like, lots of pictures of you with former Vice President Mike Pence before he became vice president. There's a lot of chatter about, oh, Brian Bosma. Excuse me. That was the. That was the person. But a lot of chatter about Pence's security team essentially flagging for you, and you weren't supposed to be there, but somehow you got a selfie with him.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I don't really know much about that, but that's interesting to know. Okay.
Unknown
Yeah.
Alyssa
This is just what's been. Some of this is just. Hasn't been confirmed, obviously. These are just literally the claims that we found thus far. People are claiming that Mike Pence is aware that you're in jail because of, I assume, the Bosma allegations. And there were allegedly some other allegations about Bosma and other politicians involved in a group sexual assault.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Alyssa
2018, there were allegations that you were working with a journalist or had claimed you were working with a journalist from the Indiana Star on a story about the previous sexual assault I mentioned. And claims that the journalists were harassing you. 2019. 2021. Graduated from Ball State. 2020 or 21. Let's see.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Alyssa
Some of the information that people are alleging that is fake information that you have posted online. Fake stalking stories, fake medical Stories, fake deaths of your parents, a fake child, and a fake death of a fake child. False sexual assault allegations, false allegations against a megachurch and that members of that church had sent you a box of sex toys as a form of sexual harassment. And their claim is that you later admitted to lying about all of this when the people in the Facebook group confronted you. 2020. Okay, there's someone alleging that you claimed that Mike Pence was running a sex abuse ring out of your apartment and that you had claimed to drag out dead bodies. June 21, 2020, you were interviewed by the Indianapolis Star about anti masking. December 21st through March 22nd, you had the Sinking Arc podcast about the itown church in Fisher's and that there was a fake murder for hire plot against Pastor Jeff Thompson and it involved another woman. August 2022, you were a teacher at school for only two days. However, you posted an Amazon wish list with around 200 items, many of them personal items. And then you wrote an article urging people to donate. Don't have dates for some of these. Another claim is that while you lived in Indiana, you lived next to a man named Sensual and you were using his cash app. March 2021. There's an allegation that you defrauded the Small Business Administration by obtaining a PPP loan while the program was in effect. November 3, 2021 was when the order of possession eviction damages was sent 21 to 23. The rental scams, which obviously you've already pled guilty to those. And then there's the whole Tesla thread, which when do you go to court for that? December.
Megan Stoner
I'm not. I'm aware that it's small claims action against me in Indiana. I am aware though of a court date. I did that there was a file, but I've not been aware of a court date yet.
Alyssa
Okay, 2022, that's the where the allegation about you lying about your parents being dead. I'm sorry to hear that they have passed away now. But what they're claiming is that before your parents passed away that you had claimed that they had been killed or shot. March, May 2022, Jeff Thompson was on your podcast and afterwards stated he felt he wasn't sure if you were a truthful person. Charged for not paying a tire changing service $75 in 23. So then when were you arrested? April 28th then or I was.
Megan Stoner
Yeah. So it started April 2023 and I bonded out the next I turned myself in at some point point the next day after the warrant was Issued, turned myself in, bonded out, and then caught a new case that is still pending in Elwood City Court that will be heard in December. And I had my bail revoked in Hamilton County. I started doing my sentence, went to work really, in March of this year, and then came back in April of this year. And I'm here until November. Okay.
Alyssa
Yeah, got it. Okay. I'm almost done, I think. Sorry. Do you want me to keep going? Okay.
Megan Stoner
Yes. Okay.
Alyssa
Okay. So then we won't be sharing his name on the podcast out of respect for his wishes, but we'll refer to him as Tom. But I'm sure you're aware of the allegations there. It looks like the allegations are that you opened a credit card and that you were falsely collecting money for him. Around. It sounds like upwards of like 30, 40,000. May 2023. That's when the Twitter was created and started posting documents. Some of these are kind of smaller notes. May 8, 2023, you created a Lyft account using the name Abby, who was your former roommate. I believe that's the one you use with the Tesla stuff. May 2023. And then we like the information about, you know, you being kicked out of the work release and those pieces.
Megan Stoner
I mean, the main problem is, I understand about. I get it, about not wanting to wait to where I can, you know, hear everyone else's side. But the other part of this is I'm in jail. I have no way to prove what I'm saying is true or not. I don't have any documents, you know, I don't have any of my evidence that I could give you. I don't have anything. I'll have access to anything. Tell you the sky is blue right now, but I don't have a way to prove that, and I know that.
Alyssa
Right.
Megan Stoner
I don't expect you to see me. So how. How can I. Being in jail and away from my devices, you know?
Alyssa
No, I. Yeah, yeah, I hear you. Here's my thing. I don't need any documents to review to prove that I didn't falsely accuse someone of sexual assault or commit crimes personally. Like, I don't need any files to reference for that. I don't know what files you would need, but I'm sure we could get them to you.
Megan Stoner
Okay. I guess I'm not aware of how you would do anything to me in here because, I mean, it's a pretty.
Alyssa
Well, I just don't know what. I don't know what you would need that would change. I mean, you. You either committed these crimes or you didn't. It's pretty cut and dry. I mean, there's a lot of evidence here. All I know is that I've spent less than a week on Megan, and I feel like I could prosecute you in a court of law based off of what I found after one week. So I don't know what you could possibly have that would disprove any of this. But you. You not only have, like a handful of people saying this, there are like upwards of 300 victims claiming that you've conned them by now. There's been a lot developing, I think, while you've been in jail that you're probably not aware of. But, like, you know, this is a lot of indisputable evidence. And so I think what I would say is the degree to which a person can grow is directly proportional to the amount of truth that they can accept about themselves. You know, I don't know what your plan is when you get out of prison or jail. I'm sorry, but I hope it's to not harm any other people. That would be, I think, the first start, because the majority of people that I've spoken to are just honestly scared that you're just going to continue to do this to other people, disabled people, like, or some of these other victims, people that have literally reached homelessness because of the crimes that you've committed and the harm that you've committed. It's bigger than just, like, what's criminally illegal. It's. It's morally and ethically repulsive, and it's such a staunch juxtaposition to everything that you purported to support and believe in politically. So that's what makes it such an interesting dichotomy for people.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Alyssa
And so I think that's really where all this, like, online interest is coming from. It's because you are. You already look like a joke to these people. You look like the world's biggest hypocrite. Do you know what I mean?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I mean, I guess all I would say is that obviously I can respect you as a journalist. And, you know, I'm just going to say I hope you. Hope you substantiate your claims, because I'm definitely looking at defamation suits when I get out. I already know that. And I just. I hope you're accurate. You know, I don't have a way to substantiate anything. I would say it doesn't matter what I would have to share with you. Evidence wise, I don't have a way to access that in here. I don't have my file.
Alyssa
Yeah, I would talk to your lawyer. You know, that would be my recommendation.
Megan Stoner
I have a public defender that withdrew because my case is closed. My public defender doesn't want to be a part of this public charade.
Alyssa
Yeah, why would they?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, they don't be part of that. They're not getting paid.
Unknown
Got it.
Alyssa
You don't have the representation? No, Got it. Okay.
Megan Stoner
You have one minute remaining.
Alyssa
Oh, sorry. We have one minute.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I mean, I'm happy to touch base with you in November.
Alyssa
Okay. We're gonna air the story regardless, but we will just list it as no comment then.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Alyssa
If you want to get back in touch with me before then, you can just let Justin know if he's still speaking with you and then. And then we can arrange it that way if you'd like, once I've had more time to like, talk with more people and vet more of this stuff myself.
Megan Stoner
Okay. I might. Okay with you in a month or two then. Yeah, perfect.
Alyssa
Yeah, that would be great. All right. Take care of yourself.
Megan Stoner
All right.
Unknown
Bye.
Alyssa
Bye.
Tiffany Reese
If you've ever worried about the safety of your home and family, there's no better time to act right now. You can get 60% off your new Simplisafe security system. Their best deal of the year. Simplisafe is the home security system I trust. I've been using it for years and I love the peace of mind it brings knowing my home is protected 24. 7. My listeners can get 60% off today just by visiting simplisafe.comSWW I love that Simplisafe is a new way to protect our homes that stops intruders before they break in. Old school systems take action once someone is already inside your home and it's too late. But Simplisafe's Active Guard outdoor protection changes the game by preventing crime before it even happens. If someone's lurking around or acting suspiciously, those agents see them in real time, talk to them directly, set off your spotlights, and even call the police before they've had a chance to break in. Plus, there are no long term contracts, no cancellation fees, and it's about a dollar a day for all of that protection. Simplisafe is offering my listeners exclusive early access to their Black Friday sale this week. Only you can get 60% off any new system with the Select Professional monitoring plan. This is their best offer of the year. Head to simplisafe.com SWW that's simplisafe.com SWW there's no safe like Simplisafe spark something uncommon this holiday. With just the right gift from Uncommon Goods, the busy holiday season has already started. I can't believe it. Whenever I'm looking for a one of a kind gift, I always head to Uncommon Goods. What I love about Uncommon Goods is they scour the globe and curate the most beautiful, original, handmade, absolutely remarkable things. They have something unique for all the hobbyists in your life, like a pickleball paddle snack tray. Choose your own dog breed salt and pepper shakers or a hand painted floral flap candle. Many of their handcrafted products are made in small batches, so shop now before they sell out this holiday season. And with every purchase you make at Uncommon Goods, they give back a dollar to a nonprofit partner of your choice. They've donated more than $3 million to date. To get 15% off your next gift, go to UncommonGoods.comSWW that's UncommonGoods.comSWW for 15% off. Don't miss out on this limited time offer. Uncommon Goods were all out of the ordinary.
Alyssa
This call is from a correction facility.
Justin
And is subject to monitoring and recordings. Thank you for using Global tellink. Can you hear me?
Megan Stoner
Yeah.
Justin
What can I do for you?
Megan Stoner
Hey, I was just really curious. I heard about this podcast. I was just really curious how it's going.
Justin
It's going fine. I think it's gonna really bring to light, like, the true person that you are. I think it'll be great. I did some recording with Tiffany last night. We're going to do some more here soon. There's a lot of people stepping forward that want to come out and speak, and she just has a really large platform. I think the goal has always been to just make sure that you're not going to reoffend. And I'm hoping that this keeps you from reoffending in the future and not being able to commit future crimes because the audience will be so vast.
Megan Stoner
Yeah. Healthy going with you, Lissa.
Justin
You know what? My life got a lot less hectic when I stopped answering your calls.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I understand. I know we've not talked in almost a year or so. Yep.
Justin
I lost my dad to suicide. And then shortly after that, the guy that I was with had an affair and had a baby with another woman. So I've recently moved out with just my kids, my life.
Megan Stoner
Oh, wow.
Justin
Yeah. But all is well. And now I feel like I have the bandwidth to really kind of sit down with Tiffany and, like, help do this podcast, which I think is great. It's been, like, really nice to have Someone else maybe, like, see the full picture of. You know what?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I talked to Tiffany last Friday.
Justin
I know.
Megan Stoner
Oh, okay. Yeah. Hey, has anyone else anything about a court date for the Mason Motors case?
Justin
Megan, I am not willing to give you any information about anything. Like, you should definitely speak to your lawyer if you have one. If you don't have one, you should get one. I do know that, like, Tiffany is going to be working very hard to try to get some more of these crimes seen and heard by the correct people. I think a lot of this stuff wasn't brought to the correct people at the time. And I think that she's got a lot of connections. So whether more charges come or not, I don't know. But I think she's definitely willing to advocate for the victims that their voice wasn't heard. You weren't charged with those crimes. Yeah, I've heard your conversations with other people, and it doesn't really sound like anything has changed. And, you know, I know that when you went to work relief, you were still kind of like fucking off and not doing what you were supposed to do. And that didn't surprise me at all. I kind of figured that's exactly what would happen and that they would see through your bullshit very quickly. And they did. Which, I mean, was really to be expected. If you're not doing what's expected of you there, then you're there, then you're gone. And so I almost find it comical that you're, like, calling me and trying to get ahold of me just to ask me about it. Like, Megan, this is going to ruin your reputation. You will have a really hard time finding a job or scamming someone ever again after this. And that's been my goal through all of this. Like, I put so much effort into making sure that your victims voices were heard. And that's why I reached out and started this process with her, because I really felt like people need to know just how truly malicious and terrible you have been. And I hope that when you get out, like, maybe you pick up and move away and live a different life, or maybe you get out and make amends to the people that you did wrong by paying them back. Like, that would be great, but I just don't think in the future you're going to be able to scam. There will be no asking people for their Social Security numbers or sending a thousand messages a night from Twitter asking people for $20 for underwear like that. That stuff's over now. And I also like to tell you that, like, I. A lot of the phone calls that we've had, I did record. It's a one party consent state. So when you were saying that you had a child that died, I have all of those things that all the documentation of everything you've ever said, I shared all of those with her. So, as excited as you think you are about this podcast and you think you're going to be famous or something, like, I think you're in for a rude awakening. I was actually glad you called me just so I could make sure to tell you that. And I actually feel no remorse for what I'm saying to you now. I don't feel bad at all. You know why? Because the last time that I actually spoke to you, you threatened to call CPS on me and have my kids taken away because I told people that you were shitting in the shower at the jail. Those are the last notice that that was the last time I spoke to you is when you told me you're going to call CPS on my kids and have them taken away. How truly disgusting that is to say to someone. So I accepted this call. But don't call me again. Like I've told you in the past, I don't want to talk to you. I have everything I could ever need to expose you to people. And that's exactly what I'm doing and what I've wanted to do all along. So if there's anything else you'd like to say to me, you can say it now. But this is the last time you will ever speak to me. Okay?
Megan Stoner
The recording of my mom that when she wasn't fine for me. Is it possible to get a copy of that?
Justin
You know what? If I do, I absolutely will share that with you. Because I lost a parent, so I know what that's like to just want to hear their voice. If I find. If I come across that, you let me know when you get out and I'll send it to you, okay?
Megan Stoner
Will you try to look for it, please?
Justin
I have them all in a bin there. I have it all. When I get around to it, I'll get around to it. But I understand what it's like to lose a parent. That sucks. And I hate that you've lost both of yours. And I. You know that I don't have contact with my mom, so I really don't have parents anymore either. And I feel for you for that. But at the same time, like that, sympathy will not be played on me because it doesn't excuse anything that you did.
Megan Stoner
I'M not. I'm not asking you to have sympathy. I'm just asking for the recording. Yeah.
Justin
If I can find it.
Megan Stoner
And she. Okay.
Unknown
Yeah, sure.
Justin
I hope you're doing your time right. It seems like, you know, the little bit of freedom you were given, you pretty much fucked that off really quickly. We'll see what happens when you get out. I think there will be a lot of eyes on you, and hopefully by the time you get out, the podcast will already have been recorded and put out there for the world. And we don't have to worry about any more victims because there won't be a person that doesn't know who you are.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, well, that's the way you feel. I mean, you're entitled to feel that way. I'm not trying to take that away.
Justin
Well, I'm not the only person that feels that way. We're all entitled to feel that way. You hurt a lot of people. I think I indulged you for far too long, answering your calls when I shouldn't have. And it really stressed me out and it put a strain on me that I didn't even realize was happening at the time until I finally stopped answering. It was like I broke free from that conversation that I was having with you because it was, you know, but also I there. I feel like you admitted to crimes over the jail phone to me that you had opened a credit card and name and done things like that. And I have all of that as well. But I think I finally found someone that has the ability to take those recordings into things that I have accumulated against you and possibly charge you with more things. So think that would be the best outcome. But I'm also okay with just the awareness being out there of your crimes and what you've done and the story, because honestly, it's kind of like a movie when you try to explain to people, they don't even believe that someone could be so capable of such evil.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I've gotten a lot of ugly enough. A lot of people that's reached out.
Justin
Like, well, I heard a phone call with you the other day where you were, like, laughing with the girls and they're like, guys, be quiet. We're talking about my podcast. Like, you're a fucking celebrity. Like, how gross. Like, you're using that to, like, gain a following in the jail. Like, oh, it's just gross. Everything you do is gross. Well, I'm not going to use any more of my money to talk to you. I think I've said what I needed to say. If there's anything else you would like to say, I would say it now because like I said, this is the last time I will ever speak to you.
Megan Stoner
I plan to go to transitional housing when I get out. Are you guys going to try to take that for me?
Justin
To take what from you? Transitional housing. I mean, if you go to the halfway house and you start scamming people, baby, we're gonna come after you like you've never seen before. Just get out and do the right thing. That's all you have to do. Don't get out and ask people's Social Security numbers. Don't offer sexual favors for them.
Megan Stoner
Like what?
Justin
Like just do the right thing.
Megan Stoner
That's all anyone has ever expected. Work release didn't charge me with that at the court hearing.
Justin
Well, it was absolutely in the paperwork though, was it not, Megan? You think that we all know how to file a request for documents. We all know how to file a request. Now we all became masters of filing requests for court documents. We've seen everything. We've seen where they said you were messaging like up to a thousand people a day off Twitter asking for money. What the fuck is wrong with you? Who does that? Get a fucking job. Be a good person. Okay, I'm sorry that you didn't see the paperwork. I really could give two shits left. I read it. I know what you did. We all know what you did. No one's stupid.
Megan Stoner
Well, they didn't charge me with that. They funny that they dropped those allegations and got those unaccounted four times.
Justin
Okay, well, let me tell you something. You're not in work release, are you? And whose fault is that?
Megan Stoner
Than if I was and I'm getting out earlier than if I wasn't.
Alyssa
Okay, good.
Justin
Then get out and do something with your fucking life.
Megan Stoner
I plan on it. Thanks, Alyssa. Have a good night.
Justin
Thank you for using Global Taillink.
Unknown
Creating really great retail experiences is tough. Especially with multiple stores, teams of staff, fulfillment centers, separate workflows. It's a lot. But with Shopify Point Point of Sale, you can do it all without complexity. Shopify's Point of Sale system is a unified command center for your retail business. It brings together in store and online operations even across 1000 locations. And let's face it, acquiring new customers is expensive. With Shopify pos, you can keep existing shoppers coming back to your stores with consistent tailored experiences and first party data that give marketing teams a competitive edge. Want more? Check out@shopify.com wondery all lowercase and and learn how to create the best retail experiences without complexity. Shopify.com Wondery Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile.
With the price of just about everything going up during inflation, we thought we'd bring our prices down. So to help us, we brought in a reverse auctioneer, which is apparently a thing Mint Mobile unlimited premium wireless.
Justin
30, 30 bid to get 30.
Megan Stoner
20, 20. Better get 20.
Justin
20. Better to get 15.
Unknown
15.
Alyssa
15.
Unknown
15.
Megan Stoner
Just 15 bucks a month.
Unknown
So give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch 45.
Justin
Upfront payment equivalent to 15 per month. New customers on first three month plan only.
Alyssa
Taxes and fees.
Justin
Extra Speed slower above 40 gigabytes. Detail.
Unknown
Hey, how are you?
Megan Stoner
Hey. I'm okay. Thanks for taking my call. I know it's Labor Day weekend. Okay. Yeah. I did talk to Tiffany last Friday. You didn't. Here.
Unknown
I heard that. She. She just told me. Thank you for putting us in contact because she did talk to you, but I don't know any specific. How did it go?
Megan Stoner
I mean, honestly, I don't think it's fair to request comment for me while I'm incarcerated because I don't know what I'm defending myself against.
Unknown
Okay, well, that was the opposite stance you took from Amanda. So what do you want here?
Megan Stoner
Well, I'm just saying that. I mean, I think that it's hard to issue a comment when I'm incarcerated.
Unknown
Right. Which is what I told.
Megan Stoner
I mean, I agree. Yeah. Right now I can understand that. I mean, I guess it's. I mean, I don't know. We kind of went over all the allegations, but I mean, quite frankly, there's so many. And if there's any proof, I want to submit. I mean, I don't have the ability to do so on incarcerated.
Unknown
Well, what. What allegations did she bring up that you, like, feel like you need to fight?
Megan Stoner
Again, Honestly, I don't have the list in front of me. I don't know specifically. I just know that if there's anything that I want to provide proof for, I don't have that. And I.
Unknown
Okay, but what do you think is going to be in there that you don't. That you need to prove? Like, you need to provide proof against?
Megan Stoner
There's a couple things that I would like to prove against, and I'm not gonna argue about.
Unknown
Give me one. Just. I'm not gonna argue. I just want to know. I'm not gonna argue. I just want to know what they are. I just want to know an example of something that. That you would like so I can better understand where you're coming from. Sure.
Megan Stoner
I Would like to prove about the storage unit thing. I was not scamming on the GoFundMe. That money did go towards the movers, and I eventually did get my stuff back from them in August, I think it was, or September of last year before I got arrested, because I remember they took it to my mom's house. And so, I mean, that's an example. There was no scamming. I. That money went directly to them.
Unknown
I don't think anybody is saying that the GoFundMe was a scam. There's questions as to whether or not your dad's ashes were actually in there. That is. That has been questioned. And we know that when the movers came to your house that day and got your stuff and had it en route to the next location and they were contacted by people in the Facebook group, you did not have the money to pay them that day. You were trying to scam that I had the money.
Alyssa
But I'm not.
Megan Stoner
I mean, again, I can't prove anything while I'm in here.
Unknown
Well, then why did they. Why did they put it in the storage unit, Megan? Why would they put it in a storage unit if you had the money? If somebody called them and said, she doesn't have the money and you had the money, they would have taken it where they were supposed to.
Megan Stoner
Okay, I didn't have the cash. You are correct about that. I was trying to access the cash in the bank, and I couldn't withdraw $3,000 at one time. But they did eventually get paid, and I did get the stuff back. And the money that was raised towards that was for the purpose that it was being said for in the GoFundMe. It wasn't. It wasn't going towards buying chocolate bars or.
Unknown
Nobody said it was going towards buying chocolate bars. Nobody has said that.
Megan Stoner
I'm giving an example. I'm just.
Unknown
If you.
Megan Stoner
Someone said that was scam.
Unknown
The only thing I've ever heard about chocolate bars is that you did put some on your teacher list, but that.
Megan Stoner
Was just an example. I was not out.
Unknown
Okay, okay, that's fine. That's fine. But if you had the money to pay them, Megan, if you had the money in the bank, you couldn't get the cash out. Why did your stuff sit in the storage unit for months while you begged for money every day? If you had the money? That makes zero sense. You. You couldn't pay them on the day you hired them. You hired somebody for a service that you couldn't pay for. That is fair game to talk about.
Megan Stoner
Yes, I was talking about the GoFundMe.
Unknown
Justin, nobody has drawn into question to GoFundMe. There's been questions around whether the story was as tragic as you made it sound because of the whole ashes thing. I don't know if that. If they were in there or not. I'm not going to argue about it. But that is the only thing about the GoFundMe that's been questioned.
Megan Stoner
Then why did so many people try to get it taken down?
Unknown
Because I think somebody. I wasn't one of them, but I think some people felt like you were scamming again, that you were not being honest about what that money was actually for, or that you would take the money and live on it while you were hiding from the cops and not actually go get your stuff back. There's a lot of people that just think you shouldn't be, that online fundraising is probably just the space you need to shy away from, given your history. And I don't know that they're necessarily unfounded in feeling that way, because with your history, nobody can really trust that money's gonna get where you say it's going to. People who might not know different might take that chance. And people are trying to protect other people. So I understand why people did it, whether it went for the storage unit or not. But this is where. This is where I get frustrated with you, Megan. You want to find one thing in all the stuff that Tiffany brought to you and. And find one inconsistency, one crack in her story and then try to shut the whole thing down, or I. I can't respond for comment because I can't prove this one thing. Megan. I haven't spoken to her since she talked to you, but I can tell you that she, like, I. I have a rough idea of the things she wanted to ask you about, and I think every single one of them is true, more or less. She still trying to get her arms around all the details of the story. She's not putting thing out yet. She's just, you know, doing the groundwork right now. But you and I both know every single one of the, like, the big bullet points are true, and you want to try to delay it or stop.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I'm not gonna sit here and give anyone any more ammunition, that's for certain. So if you're asking me to admit to anything, I'm not gonna.
Unknown
I'm not asking you to admit that anything. I have enough. I have enough of you admitting to plenty of things. I have you on call admitting that you made up the Brian Bosnia thing. I got you on call admitting to all that stuff. I've got you on call saying all of it. So I don't need that anymore. I just. I get frustrated because, like, then you. You try to say, like, I don't think this is fair. I don't think. But then you can't really provide anything that she said that wasn't true. You mentioned. Well, that one. GoFundMe did go for what I said it was going to. I don't think she asked you about that. Maybe she brought it up. Maybe she misspoke, didn't know the details when she was talking to you. If that's the best. If that's the biggest detail that is somewhat missed, you're not really going on a whole lot. You don't really have much of a strong case there.
Megan Stoner
Well, I am looking. I am going to look into getting a lawyer when I get out. I do want to look into defamation suits.
Unknown
Okay, well, and. And I've heard that one from you before. And let me just remind you that you have a blue check mark on Twitter. You have a Facebook page that still exists that lists you as a public figure, that you have made multiple media appearances. And getting a defamation suit against somebody with the, like, online profile that you have built for yourself is going to be very difficult and very expensive. And you have a reputation for not paying your attorney. So if you think you can get an attorney to take that case and you are able to come up with the money and you can get one to trust that you're going to actually pay for all their services, be my guess. But I don't know that that is something you're going to be able to do.
Megan Stoner
Okay, I did a couple. I've been in jail, so, I mean, we'll see where it goes.
Unknown
Well, we'll see where it goes because, I mean, you can throw that out there because it's a scary word and think people are going to jump back. I don't know that you're gonna find anybody that's gonna take your case. And you and I both know you don't have the money to pay them if you don't. So this is a paper tiger. You're just trying to scare people because you're trying to control what's being put out there. The empty threats don't win you any favors.
Megan Stoner
All right. Has any more been said on Twitter or anything?
Unknown
Not a ton. No. I think they. They shut the Facebook group down for, like, the summer or whatever just because the admins don't want to deal with it. So.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, who are the admins still? Do you know?
Unknown
The same ones. They're always my.
Megan Stoner
Oh, okay. Okay. Yeah. I talked to Alyssa this week.
Unknown
Oh, what did Alyssa have? Just. Sorry.
Megan Stoner
I'm sure you heard the phone call. I mean, it went about as terrible as it can. I mean, I'm sure I don't have to paint all the details. I mean, it was.
Unknown
I actually haven't heard it.
Megan Stoner
It was pretty gruesome. I mean, I don't really know what to say. I'm sorry. I mean, of course she's gonna be angry at me. I mean, we did find common ground, that she would find me, try to find me, the phone call with my mom, because she knows what it's like to just want to hear a loved one's voice, and I don't have many of those. And she agreed that I could get with her when I get out, and if she finds it, she would send it to me. She said. I mean, that's pretty much the only thing we found common ground on. I mean, she seems pretty excited about the Tiffany podcast, which if you all think that's going to bring you some kind of satisfaction, then going ahead, I mean, it proves. I think if you're all wanting a podcast to bring you satisfaction, I think it proves that the legal process didn't and that you're all pretty unsatisfied with what happened to me. I mean, that's my biggest takeaway, to be honest with you, was I think if you're all looking. Again, if you're all looking for satisfaction in the podcast, and that's going to help stop people or stop me or whatever. I think that it. I don't know. I think you guys are just upset. The legal process only got me six months plus seven and a year of probation, but I think that's pretty telling. That was all the prosecutor could get me on.
Unknown
Is that what you really fucking think? Is that what you actually think? Megan, you and I both know you will never serve a day in jail for what you did. You will never serve a day in jail for what you did to Edward. You. Victoria is not listed on the case that brought you in. There's a million things I could sit here and go through with you about things you did to people, lies you told, that traumatized people, that emotionally flooded people. The things you did, the murder for hires, all of that. Some of it's not provable in a court of law. You are correct. Some of it's not actually a crime. It's still really shitty. And the fact that you can sit there with that smug tone in your voice and say, he didn't get me on very much. Megan, you could have probably just gotten probation if you had turned yourself in the first time, come out, started paying restitution, gotten a job and we're on the right path. Not had all those reoffensive over the summer, not had run from the police, not have gotten kicked out of work release. You wouldn't have served any of this time. If you feel like we're trying to get satisfaction out of watching you suffer, that is not what this is about. This is about getting justice for all the things that you will never actually serve for. Just because it's not a crime, just because it wasn't provable in this jurisdiction, just because this case didn't pertain to it, doesn't mean you shouldn't face consequences for every last thing that you did. That's what this is all about. Got it.
Megan Stoner
Okay. I mean. I mean, you're entitled.
Alyssa
I mean, you're entitled.
Unknown
This phone call is over. This phone call is over. Goodbye.
Tiffany Reese
Next time on Something was Wrong.
Unknown
This was also in the middle of her pissing match with I Town. She claimed on social media that somebody from Itown had come and shot her mom. So she was in the middle of planning two funerals and contemplating the unthinkable that she was about to lose both parents.
Justin
This is a very small community. Everybody knows everybody. And when you talk about sexual abuse.
Alyssa
Or assault, especially in the political world.
Justin
It'S a big deal. I remember Jeff reaching out, very concerned for me, saying that there was a murder for hire plot, that the association of related churches was involved and that they had threatened him and that they were threatening to do something to me as well.
Tiffany Reese
Thank you so much for listening. Something was Wrong is a broken cycle Media production created and produced by me, Tiffany Reese. Thank you so much to our associate producers Amy B. Chesler and Lily Rowe. Thank you to our audio engineer Becca High and our social media marketing manager Lauren Barkman of Luxury Media. Additional thanks to our partners Grant at Wondery, Marissa Travis and our team at wme, Jason and Jennifer at ksco, our cybersecurity team Darkbox Security and my lawyer aligned and to all of you who make our show possible with your support and listenership. Special shout out to Neon Honey and Gabones for covering our theme song gladrag's original song youg Think youk this season. For more music from them, check out the episode notes or your favorite streaming app. In the episode notes, you'll always find content, warnings, sources and resources with links to our website and social media as well. Thank you so much to every survivor and ally who has trusted us to help share their stories. We are forever grateful. Until next time, stay safe friends. If you like something was wrong. You can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey@wondery.com survey.
Unknown
Did you know that after World War II, the US government quietly brought former Nazi scientists to America in a covert operation to advance military technology? Or that in the 1950s the US army conducted a secret experiment by releasing bacteria over San Francisco to test how a biological attack might spread without alerting the public? These might sound like conspiracy theories, but they're not. They're well documented government operations that have been hidden away in classified files for decades. I'm Luke lamanna, a Marine Corps recon vet and I've always had a thing for digging into the unknown. It's what led me to start my new podcast, Declassified Mysteries. In it I explore hidden truths and reveal some eye opening events like covert experiments and secret operations that those in power tried to keep buried. Follow redacted Declassified mysteries with me, Luke lamanna on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts to listen ad free. Join Wondery plus in the Wondery App.
Podcast Title: Something Was Wrong
Host/Author: Broken Cycle Media | Wondery
Episode: S22 E1: "Morally and Ethically Repulsive"
Release Date: October 24, 2024
In the premiere episode of the 22nd season, titled "Morally and Ethically Repulsive," Something Was Wrong embarks on a deep dive into the controversial and tumultuous story of Megan Stoner. Hosted by Tiffany Reese, this episode unpacks the complex layers of allegations surrounding Megan, exploring themes of trauma, accountability, and the quest for truth amidst a web of accusations and defenses.
The episode begins with Megan Stoner receiving a pivotal call from Justin, an inmate at the Hamilton County Jail. Justin informs Megan that her case has garnered attention from Tiffany Reese, an influential independent journalist renowned for her widely-subscribed podcast, Something Was Wrong. This sets the stage for an intense exploration of Megan's past and the serious allegations against her.
Notable Quote:
Megan Stoner [02:33]:
"You don't know anybody until you tell you someone. You don't know how anybody until you talk to someone."
Tiffany Reese, represented by Alyssa, reaches out to Megan with a comprehensive overview of the allegations. Alyssa meticulously outlines a timeline of events spanning from 2012 to 2023, detailing Megan's involvement in various supposed crimes, including:
Notable Quote:
Alyssa [12:39]:
"False reporting is a crime. So we will talk about not only the crimes you've been charged with, but if we find that there's other crimes that have been committed, then, yes, we would report on those."
Megan responds with defensiveness, expressing confusion and frustration over the breadth of allegations. She highlights her current inability to access evidence or communicate effectively due to her incarceration, making it challenging to defend herself comprehensively.
Notable Quote:
Megan Stoner [10:35]:
"I don't want to be laughed at, essentially."
The conversation intensifies as Justin, another inmate, confronts Megan with hard-hitting accusations. He accuses her of scamming, manipulating situations, and causing significant harm to numerous victims. Justin underscores the impact of Megan's actions, emphasizing the emotional and financial toll on those affected.
Notable Quote:
Justin [32:26]:
"You hurt a lot of people. I think I indulged you for far too long, answering your calls when I shouldn't have. And it really stressed me out and it put a strain on me..."
Tiffany Reese discusses the ethical responsibilities of journalism, highlighting the importance of verifying facts to prevent false accusations that could harm the majority of truthful survivors. She emphasizes her commitment to bringing Megan's story to light while ensuring that justice is served without bias.
Notable Quote:
Alyssa [11:18]:
"But I'm unclear if those allegations are true or not or which of them are true or not. And so that's what's also difficult, because, you know, being somebody who works with survivors from all over on a daily basis, we take that really seriously..."
Megan reveals her intention to pursue defamation suits upon her release, though Justin casts doubt on the feasibility of such endeavors given her financial and legal standing. The dialogue highlights the personal toll these allegations have taken on Megan and those around her, painting a stark picture of the emotional and psychological ramifications.
Notable Quote:
Megan Stoner [27:22]:
"I have a right to feel that way. I'm not trying to take anyone's sympathy... I'm just asking for the recording."
As the episode nears its end, the interactions between Megan, Justin, and Alyssa reach a boiling point. Megan expresses a desire to clear her name and find common ground, while Justin remains relentless in his accusations, emphasizing the lasting damage Megan has caused. Tiffany Reese maintains her objective stance, focusing on uncovering the truth and ensuring that victims' voices are heard.
Notable Quote:
Justin [37:00]:
"You are not in work release, are you? And whose fault is that?"
Megan Stoner [02:33]:
"You don't know anybody until you tell you someone. You don't know how anybody until you talk to someone."
Alyssa [12:39]:
"False reporting is a crime. So we will talk about not only the crimes you've been charged with, but if we find that there's other crimes that have been committed, then, yes, we would report on those."
Megan Stoner [10:35]:
"I don't want to be laughed at, essentially."
Justin [32:26]:
"You hurt a lot of people. I think I indulged you for far too long, answering your calls when I shouldn't have. And it really stressed me out and it put a strain on me..."
Alyssa [11:18]:
"But I'm unclear if those allegations are true or not or which of them are true or not. And so that's what's also difficult, because, you know, being somebody who works with survivors from all over on a daily basis, we take that really seriously..."
Megan Stoner [27:22]:
"I have a right to feel that way. I'm not trying to take anyone's sympathy... I'm just asking for the recording."
Justin [37:00]:
"You are not in work release, are you? And whose fault is that?"
"Morally and Ethically Repulsive" offers a compelling and unflinching examination of Megan Stoner's allegations and the surrounding controversies. Through candid dialogues and meticulous investigation, Tiffany Reese and her team strive to present an objective narrative, balancing the voices of the accused and the accusers. This episode serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities involved in unraveling truth from deception, the profound impact of actions on individuals and communities, and the relentless pursuit of justice in the face of adversity.
Note: This summary is based on the provided transcript and is intended to offer an accurate and comprehensive overview of the podcast episode "Morally and Ethically Repulsive." For a complete understanding, listening to the full episode is recommended.