Loading summary
Tiffany Reese
Wondery subscribers can listen to Something Was Wrong early and ad free right now. Join Wondery in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. James Patterson's new thriller, Holmes Is Missing is an ingenious twist on these classic mystery masters. Set in the present, Holmes, Marple and Poe Investigations is New York City's hottest detective agency, combining famous names with secret pasts. But when Holmes disappears, Marple and Poe might not survive their next case. Read it now. Holmes Is Missing is available in hardcover, ebook, and audio wherever books are sold. For more information, visit james patterson.com homes.
Justin
The start of a new year is the perfect time to get organized, set goals, and prioritize what matters most. For me, a top priority is my financial wellness, which feels more important than ever. Thanks to Rocket Money, my goals feel achievable. They show me all of my subscriptions right in one place and help me easily cancel ones that I forgot I've been paying for. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. Rocket Money will even try to negotiate lower bills for you. They automatically scan your bills to find opportunities to save. Then you can ask them to negotiate for you. They'll deal with customer service so you don't have to cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals faster with Rocket Money. Go to RocketMoney.com Wondery today. That's RocketMoney.com Wondery RocketMoney.com Wondery this podcast.
Tiffany Reese
Is intended for mature audiences and discusses topics that may be upsetting. For a full content warning, sources and resources, please visit the Episode Notes. Opinions shared by the guests of the show are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of myself, Broken Cycle Media, or Wondery. The podcast and any linked materials should not be misconstrued as a substitution for legal or medical advice. Megan Stoner's responses to these allegations are addressed within this season. I'm Tiffany Reiss and this is Something was wrong.
Megan Stoner
You.
Unknown
They can know me.
Megan Stoner
You don't love me.
Tiffany Reese
Last episode we learned how Alex led the charge in uncovering the mysteries behind Stoner's Teslas. Alex connected with Steven of Mason Motors, who pursued a civil lawsuit against Stoner for inadequate pay and and falsifying insurance documents. The case documents also revealed allegations that Stoner had stolen the identity of her ex roommate. And although Steven and his company, Mason Motors, won the civil case, Stoner has yet to pay the judgment of $68,002.10 and further criminal Charges have not been pursued at this time. When my team and I first started working on this case, summer of 2024, I spoke with community member and former politico Justin in one of my early interviews. I'm so thankful to Justin and all of the participants this season for their time. In one of our early interviews, Justin prepared me for my first conversation with Megan.
Justin
Before you talk to her, and I'm not trying to tell you how to do your job, you have to tell me, but I'm very well seasoned in dealing with Megan. She's going to approach you as, I've made some mistakes in my life. I'm trying to right my wrongs. It's been really hard to be under this amount of scrutiny. She's going to come off as the most pathetic person you've ever met, and you're going to come away feeling very gaslit and probably even questioning. Is it the right thing to do? You cannot give her a platform to spin that needle. It has to be direct questions like, why did you take the money from Tom on this day? Because if you let her paint with a broad brush, she will. If you let her, and she will make you feel bad for her. Even if you think you won't, you will.
Tiffany Reese
When speaking with someone like Megan Stoner, I knew I had to play my cards correctly. This is why you'll often hear me playing dumb with Megan. I don't want to come across too strong as I want to keep her talking, but I'm also trying to get her to give me information. At this point, the police had already visited Stoner in jail to try and get her to talk, and she refused. But I also knew that Stoner loves attention more than anyone I've ever studied or encountered. She loves it so much that she often puts her own best interest to the side in order to get it.
Unknown
Hello, this is a call from an.
Inmate at the Hamilton County Jail.
Thank you for using Global Tel Link.
Megan Stoner
Hi, this is Tiffany. Hi, this is Megan Stoner. Thanks for taking my call.
Unknown
I spoke to Justin and he told me that he would pass along my number. So I'm glad it got to you.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I was just curious if you could tell me a little bit about your podcast and kind of your angle on my story.
Unknown
Yeah, so my name is Tiffany Reese. My main podcast that people know me from is called Something Was Wrong. And essentially audio documentaries is what I make. We've been doing it since end of 2018 now. So the original season started with a story that I came across through someone I Knew. But since then, all of our seasons and stories come to us through the listeners. So we actually have a website where we get submissions and I actually had multiple people submit your name and this Facebook group that essentially was started surrounding the crimes you've been charged with. Given the public nature of this case, I've been able to review a lot of the materials quickly. So, yeah, I thought I would reach out to you and see if you would be interested in making a comment. I have a pretty decent idea of what the allegations against you are and what is in the criminal record. And I could certainly go over that from a fact checking perspective with you and have you comment on that if you wanted to, or some people go, no comment. You know, it's really up to you.
Megan Stoner
I mean, I'm happy to touch base with you in November.
Unknown
Okay. We're going to air the story regardless, but we will just list it as no comment then.
Megan Stoner
Okay.
Unknown
If you want to get back in touch with me before then, you can just let Justin know if he's still speaking with you and then. And then we can arrange it that way if you'd like, once I've had more time to, like, talk with more people and vet more of this stuff myself.
Megan Stoner
Okay. I might. Okay with you in a month or two then. Yeah, perfect.
Unknown
Yeah, that would be great. All right. Take care of yourself.
Megan Stoner
All right.
Unknown
Bye. Bye.
Tiffany Reese
My second jailhouse call with Stoner was on September 27, 2024, while she was creating plans for her looming release on November 15th.
Megan Stoner
I'm so glad it finally worked. I know that we've been having some trouble getting in contact.
Unknown
It's been a phone tag week. I apologize. The app hates me. How's it been going?
Megan Stoner
It's been okay. You know, I've got seven weeks left today, and I'm.
Unknown
Seven, did you say?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, seven weeks. I'm looking forward to getting out, as you can imagine. I'm just looking forward to seeing my aunt and, you know, my dog and hopefully starting a new life as much as I can.
Unknown
Do you go into some sort of housing or how does that.
Lainey
Because you have.
Unknown
I'm assuming they have like probation and. Or whatever.
Megan Stoner
I have probation for a year, but unfortunately, if I found a place. But if I hadn't found transitional living, I would literally just be on the streets because I'm not under any supervision other than probation. So they would have just basically let me go regardless of I had a place to go or not. So thankfully, I just found a traditional living. We'll see how it goes.
Unknown
And then you go back to the court in Elmwood county court. Right. On December 19th.
Megan Stoner
Sorry. Yeah, it's okay. It's okay. Yeah, I have a city court case in December, and then I have a probation violation. I'm found guilty in ELWOOD on the 20th, the next day in a town called Anderson City Court. Yeah, those are kind of my next two court dates. This is a house cleaner that claimed that I guess she wasn't paid, but shockingly, my mom and I both paid her, so she got paid double. And we both. I have both receipts, and one is from my mom's debit card account, and then one is from my cash app. So I look forward to presenting that to the judge and hopefully getting that dropped.
Unknown
Do you have a public defender or are you pro se?
Megan Stoner
I do. I do. I have a public defender in both cases.
Unknown
Okay.
Tiffany Reese
Because I noticed there had been a lot.
Unknown
It seemed like you had changed counsel a lot, and they wouldn't let you represent yourself.
Megan Stoner
No, they don't like you representing yourself. I mean, there was one gal that tried here in Hamilton county, and they ultimately ended up sending her to a mental hospital over it. And until she agreed to get counsel, they wouldn't let her out.
Unknown
Does your public defender have any insight into. Does he think you'll face time for these upcoming pending charges? No, he doesn't, because they think. It sounds like you think you can get this replacement, the theft thrown out.
Megan Stoner
Yeah, I'm hoping so. And then my license is no longer suspended, and so the judge is pretty lenient there. I mean, at City Court and then in Anderson City Court, it sounds like I can just pay off my fees and hopefully be off probation there. I'm hoping to get that done when I get out. I think I got 800 bucks or whatever left to pay on that one. So I'm hoping to get that paid and I can be off probation in Anderson and, yeah, I'll just be on probation in Hamilton county, and then eventually I'll get it transferred when I move.
Unknown
Is there any sort of, like, plan in place for paying back or some of the other people that are smaller amounts? Like, I know you're in the hole pretty deep to, you know, Mason Motors and Steven in that case. But what is the actuality, you think that you'll be able to pay that back?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, so my first will be the Hamilton county case, because my police stipulates that has to be done first before anything else. So once that money is paid that, let's just say roughly $3,000, once I can get that paid back. Then I'm going to start looking at my other people that I owe, like and Edward and other people. But yeah, you're right, it will be a while before I even get to Mason Motors. I've been counseled that, you know, on those bigger ones I should just declare bankruptcy. So I don't know what's going to happen.
Tiffany Reese
Today's episode is sponsored by Acorns. New Year's resolutions are hard. Everyone wants to achieve their goals, but sometimes they can fall to the wayside if we're not set up properly for success. That's where Acorns comes in. Acorns makes it easy to start automatically saving and investing so your money has a chance to grow for you, your family and your retirement. You don't need to be an expert. Acorns will recommend a diversified portfolio that fits you and your money goals. You can even invest with Acorns with spare money you've got right now. You can start with as little as $5 or just your spare change. And thankfully you don't need a ton of time because you can create your Acorns account and start investing in just five minutes. Acorns gives you small, simple steps to get you and your money on track. Basically, Acorns does the hard part so you can give your money a chance to grow Acorn. Head to acorns.comsww or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today. Paid non client endorsement compensation provides incentive to positively promote Acorns. Tier 3 compensation provided investing involves risk. Acorn Advisors LLC and SEC registered investment advisor view important disclosures@acorns.com SWW I'm excited to head to the snow for my winter vacation here shortly. But the thing is, I didn't have a practical cold weather jacket and this is where Quince comes in. Even those of us that embrace the cold weather still need something to break up the long winter nights. Which is why I selected their lightweight, down packable puffer jacket. It is perfect for a cold weather vacation and I love it because it won't take up lots of space in my suitcase. Whatever you're looking for, all Quince Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. They use premium fabrics and finishes for that luxury feel in every piece. Treat yourself this winter without the luxury price tag. Go to quince.comsww for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q U I n c e.com to get free shipping and 365 day returns quince.comSWW On December 19, 2024, Stoner pled guilty to three criminal misdemeanor charges in Elwood, Indiana. One was for a criminal misdemeanor case opened on July 12, 2023 for violation of driving conditions pursuant to distracted driving and driving while suspended. The other criminal misdemeanor she pled guilty to was opened on July 31, 2023 for possession, display of fictitious, suspended, altered driver's license, operating a motor vehicle without financial responsibility, speeding and driving while suspended. The third criminal misdemeanor case was for a case opened on August 2, 2023 for theft. On September 19, Stoner's Anderson City court case was closed and her probation was closed due to defendants incarceration. End quote. This case was Stoner's criminal misdemeanor opened on March 1, 2022 for operating a vehicle while intoxicated, endangering a person operating a vehicle with a Schedule 1 or 2 controlled substance, and speeding. As of December 23, 2024, Stoner still has an outstanding balance of $682 for her fine, court costs and filing fees for this case. In relation to the other cases she pled guilty to, she was ordered to pay a $250 fine. Back in September, my second call with Stoner abruptly ended because of bad cell service. My next call with her was three days later on September 30, 2024, where we jumped back into reviewing the timeline of her crimes. Once again, I'm glad it worked.
Unknown
I think I finally figured it out.
Megan Stoner
Thank you for doing so.
Unknown
Yeah, no problem. I don't know if you are considering making further comment, but if you'd like. What I can do is similar to before, go through essentially the timeline document that we have now that it's filled out and I have all the sources filled in and like basically we have gathered and intend to include or we can just leave it at no comment in general, it's completely up to you. And since we spoke before and we had talked about potentially speaking again, I just wanted to make sure you had the opportunity because the trailer is going out not this Thursday, but next Thursday for early release. So we're about two weeks out at this point.
Megan Stoner
Okay. What are you thinking your first episode's gonna be? Can I ask?
Unknown
We honestly haven't decided yet. We've gone through like all the footage and it's all marked and like scripted as we call it. But we are actually like making the decisions of how we want to approach it and the Structure and stuff still. We're still finalizing that. And I also wanted to wait until this conversation, too. I try to, like, not make that call until I've pretty much finalized every anticipated interview. And I have our call. I have one more call with Alyssa, hopefully tomorrow. And then I have a pending call with Sergeant Maudlin, who is the officer on this case. I did listen to the interview with Pastor Stacey and Michael Anderson. What they allege is when you were 15 or 16 years old, you falsely accused them of texting you to invite you to come over to watch Stacy and Michael have sex with one another. Stacy and Michael report that they called the police and the police spoke with you. They're claiming that it was found out that you had fabricated the text messages and therefore the allegations against them were false. And again, the source is the Facebook Live interview with them.
Megan Stoner
What was the name of the Facebook people that interviewed them? My aunt's been trying to find that.
Unknown
It's called Forensic Foreplay. What they allege, though, is that the cop not only spoke to you, but that after speaking to you, that you were essentially a psychopath. That's what they said in the interview.
Megan Stoner
My cop, I mean, my time, Obi. He's not a psychologist or a psychiatrist.
Unknown
Right.
Megan Stoner
Diagnose me.
Unknown
Okay. Faith Burnside.
Lainey
I reached out to her.
Unknown
Her testimony was in the Twitter space live. And she essentially alleges that you tried to convince her that you were involved in an Indiana based sex trafficking ring similar to Pizzagate. She claims that you claimed that the attorney general, senators, and governor were sexually assaulting you on a daily basis and that you told Faith Burnside some of these men had fake phone number and they began texting her violent and sexually explicit messages. And that it was discovered later that you were the one sending those messages to her.
Megan Stoner
That's not true. That's my only comment on that one.
Unknown
So it was alleged by some of the members of the previous Facebook groups that you were in, such as Spice Girls and Cute Servatives. The allegations are that you would essentially take on the stories of other people in these groups and pretend that the same things that were happening to them were happening to you. Some examples are they're alleging fake stalking stories about you being stalked by a medical professional or a local politician. Fake deaths of loved ones. They're alleging that you lied about sexual assault and that you lied about getting run off the road by itown.
Megan Stoner
Okay, yeah, I will just leave it at that then. I'm not trying to label with everyone, obviously.
Lainey
Hi, my name is Lainey and I met Megan Stoner through the Spice Girls Facebook groups around 2016. I had seen Megan post a few times, and it was always stuff that came off a little bit weird, like she just didn't know how to do something that seemed really basic. And so I always was kind of like, she needs a friend. And then Megan and I started talking when she made a post she had been sexually assaulted. I later found out that she was alleging she had been sexually assaulted by an Indiana House of Representatives member, Brian Bosma. She told me directly, yeah, that she had been sexually assaulted by Brian Bosma. She told me that she worked for him, which I now know is not true. And she had made a post about having a hard time because she was just dealing with this sexual assault. And so I reached out to her because I'm a survivor of sexual assault. I see this girl around, like, it looks like she needs a friend. Maybe I can be that friend to her. And so I reached out to her, and that's how Megan and I started messaging. We talked a lot through Facebook Messenger. And then at one point, I gave her my cell phone number. I wouldn't say that I considered her a close friend. I think she may have considered me a close friend. She reached out to me a lot for, like, help with stuff. I considered more of someone that just needed somebody there for them that I was just trying to help, support and be nice to. She told me that Brian Bosma made her sign an NDA and asked me to take a look at it because I was in law school at this point. I was starting to think, something is not adding up here. I would like to see this NDA. So I had her send it to me. It was an NDA talking about, like, business practices. It would be something that, like, you would sign if you worked at a company, certainly not something you would sign if you were assaulted. She forged Brian Bosna's signature at the bottom. And I remember looking at it, and I was like, this is not right. And so I went on Google and copied and pasted the first paragraph of the NDA into the search with quotation marks. And it came up to some website. I don't know the exact website, but it was the equivalent of www.getitnda.com. so she was passing that fake document around that she. I don't know if she forwards his signature on it or photoshopped it in or what, but it was allegedly signed by him. And so I told Megan, I was like, this NDA doesn't cover any type of sexual assault or anything like this. This is talking about business practices. This wouldn't make sense for him to have you sign. And frankly, if he's an Indiana House of Representatives, then he would have people on his staff that know that Megan doubled down and was very adamant. Like, he made me sign this. He made me sign this.
Unknown
This is real.
Lainey
And I was like, all right, whatever. She told me that she had a therapist. His name was Adriana. I don't know if this person is even real. You know, he's a figment of her imagination or if he's some poor real therapist that she decided to take it out on, but she told me that she saw him a few times, and then, of course, he started stalking her because everybody loved to stalk Megan, and that she was trying to flee from him and that he followed her across state lines one night, and she was like, wouldn't that be a felony? And I was like, probably so. But why is this man following you? What does he want from you? Like, are you safe? And she was like, yes, I'm back home now. Well, then later, she told me that Adriano showed up to her house and stripped down to his underwear on her front porch and that she freaked out and had, like, talk him down, that he was going through a psychotic break and that she was terrified of him and he was a stalker and just, like, all this craziness. But again, I don't know if this is even a real person.
Unknown
Did you ever get her to admit to any of this?
Lainey
No, she would never admit to anything. This girl would just double down. Everyone was out to get her. Everyone was wrong but her. After she got put out of the groups, everything started coming out about her lying and, like, how crazy it was. And so I just kind of faded to the background. There's a lot of different groups. She got put out of some groups but wasn't in another group. And she posted about she needed help and that she was sorry for everyone she'd hurt and that she was taking inventory of herself and all this stuff. And it really pissed me off because it was so ungenuine. It was so obvious that she's not actually sorry. And I sent her a message and told her to shove her apology up her ass.
Unknown
Then she blocked me.
Wow.
And that was when she left the Facebook group. That would have still probably end of 2018 or so.
Lainey
Yeah.
Tiffany Reese
As much as I love the holiday season, it's also nice to get back into the swing of things in the new year. No matter what goals you have, thrive Market can help you know. It's a startling statistic. Over 10,000 chemicals have entered our US food supply, yet the EU limits this to just 300 additives. I personally don't have a ton of time to sift through ingredient labels to see what's in my food, which is why I love using Thrive Market. Thrive Market makes it so easy to find better options without the hassle. One of my favorite features is the Healthy Swap Scanner in the Thrive Market Apple. You can scan any item and it'll instantly suggest a cleaner, healthier grocery alternative. The best part? Everything gets delivered right to your door and you get savings on every order. All of their products are 100% non GMO and free from over a thousand harmful ingredients. Whether you're looking for dye, free snacks, non toxic cleaning supplies, or high protein meals that fit your dietary needs, Thrive Market has you covered in a few clicks. Ready for a cleaner start in 2025? Head to thrivemarket.com SWW and get 30% off your first order plus a free $60 gift. That's T H R I V E market.comSWW thrivemarket.comSWW this message comes from Greenlight Ready to start talking to your kids about financial literacy?
Justin
Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money.
Tiffany Reese
App that teaches kids and teens how.
Justin
To earn, save, spend wisely and invest.
Tiffany Reese
With your guardrails in place.
Justin
With Greenlight, you can send money to kids quickly, set up chores automate allowance.
Tiffany Reese
And keep an eye on your kids.
Justin
Spending with real time notifications. Join millions of parents and kids building healthy financial habits together on Greenlight. Get started risk free@greenlight.com Wondry.
Unknown
Okay, allegations against Bosma. Do you want to speak to that?
Megan Stoner
Nope, I'm good.
Unknown
Okay. There was conversation that at one time you were working with a journalist at the Indianapolis Star and that those journalists harassed you at some point. Were you ever working with an Indianapolis Star reporter on a piece related to sexual assault allegations? No, I'm not commenting my case noted the civil case between yourself and your aunt. It looks like it settled as of now. Has that debt been fully repaid?
Megan Stoner
My aunt is considering dropping a lawsuit. My aunt and I have become extremely close, as with my mom's death, and she regrets taking it out of the family.
Unknown
Yeah. Again, very sorry for your loss of both of your parents. It's difficult to lose loved ones. I'm curious what you would say to the allegations that your parents had some records and some things on their background that were perhaps a little bit shady. Basically, that your parents had some Charges and some misdemeanor fraud scam charges on their records.
Megan Stoner
Oh, my mom might have some bad check. Honestly, I don't know. I was a child.
Unknown
Would you say your parents were like, honest people? Were they involved in any of your crimes?
Megan Stoner
My mom was 100% an honest person. That's why, you know, you will see that she even paid the cleaner when she. The cleaning lady when she had heard that she wasn't paid on time. My mom was an absolute honest person, and my dad was too. Both had integrity and both raised me much better than the choices I made.
Unknown
Okay. Now, Tom, I interviewed him at length, and I will say he supplied a significant amount of organized evidence. Is there any comment you want to make on that situation?
Megan Stoner
No.
Unknown
At one point, there was conversation between you and Alyssa about writing a letter to the credit card company to clarify the charges on credit report. Did that ever end up happening?
Megan Stoner
No. She was promising bail money if I did it.
Unknown
Got it. Is that something you would be willing to consider in the future?
Megan Stoner
You know, I'll just. Actually, I just won't comment. I will just say I felt very coerced into things because she was like, I'll bail you out if you do this and this and this. And I really didn't have a choice, I felt, because I just. I wanted to get spotted out this time last year.
Unknown
Okay. Did you specifically target Tom and because of their disabilities?
Megan Stoner
No, they were friends of mine.
Unknown
Do you have guilt with that consideration?
Megan Stoner
Yes, I do. But I think that's a tough question because neither will speak to me to get resolution on the situations at hand. And I think both have been blown way out of proportion.
Unknown
Obviously, it's hard to stomach a lot of the manipulation. I think that was the hardest part for me to taken. And I think that's the reason why people were so motivated. Because it's one thing to scam a corporation, it's another thing to scam a person. It's a whole other thing to scam somebody you know has disabilities. Right. Or you know, is by definition more susceptible to this kind of stuff. And I don't view them more susceptible.
Megan Stoner
Because they're very intelligent human beings. My intention was never to scam.
Unknown
Right. But when you were talking to Steven in the Tesla text, as Abby, you outlined in detail, like, the ways that autistic people can be impacted by those sort of interactions. And autistic people are more susceptible to gaslighting and fraud, both from a data standpoint and a psychological. One minute remaining. I guess I was just curious, you know, because it seems to me like you perhaps targeted them because of their disabilities.
Megan Stoner
I did not.
Unknown
Okay. I hope not.
Megan Stoner
I did not.
Unknown
Okay.
Megan Stoner
They were my friend.
Unknown
Yeah. They trusted you. Really thought he had you as a friend and you broke his heart. There's allegations of fraud against the Small Business Administration that you obtained a PPP loan fraudulently. Do you have any comment on that?
Megan Stoner
I did not obtain it fraudulently.
Unknown
Okay.
Lainey
Okay.
Unknown
On the Sinking Arc podcast, there was allegations against Itown. They're alleging that you lied about getting run off the road by Itown and that you lied about Itown sending you the box of sex toys. I know there was this fake murder for hire plot. I spoke to Pastor Jeff Thompson and I actually interviewed Julie Royce on the record. Do you want to comment on any of that?
Megan Stoner
No, I'm good.
Unknown
Okay. This was confirmed through a few different interviews and, you know, some screenshots were sent and links, etc, but essentially this Itown controversy and that somebody had allegedly shot your mom. Do you want to comment on that?
Megan Stoner
No, I think everything. I think. I think everything speaks for itself.
Unknown
What about Bulldogs moving company sorted out in court. Okay. Something that was mentioned here about you creating a GoFundMe while you had pending legal charges. Were those Go fund me's posted under false pretenses or were they legitimate funding exercises?
Megan Stoner
The money went to the moving company, not Bulldogs. But then company would help me move. I needed some money to get my stuff out of storage. No, the money was provided to them immediately. And I had to provide funding. I had to provide proof to GoFundMe because GoFundMe tried to shut it down several times. Because people complain. Whatever.
Unknown
Okay. Steven Mason. I will say I read the 128 page civil document. In it, you make claims that you have a child that again dies. I believe a 12 year old child in the text messages. Do you want to make any comment to that?
Megan Stoner
No. Did you even get an interview?
Unknown
He did not. I tried to reach out to him. It's pretty detailed, the civil document. But I also understand, like a lot of people are just like over it. They want to move forward and they don't want to talk about it anymore or be associated with that when they're like, you know, and more the public eye or like business people, things of that nature. Okay. There was the dwi that was then changed over to the owi, which kind of led to some of the warrants and things of that nature. Do you want to make any comment on that?
Megan Stoner
Yeah, it was due to cough medicine that was in my System, which everyone knows. I made that very public. And the fact that I was on allergy medicine and they tried to say that I had above the therapeutic dose. I will say that I was at my mom's prior to getting pulled over. My father was passing away later. Passed away a few weeks later. It was my birthday. Anyone that knows me knows I never had a drink of alcohol. I had maybe one sip of wine, but other than that, everyone that knows me knows I don't drink. It was just a situation that I couldn't argue. They said it was above the therapeutic level.
Unknown
Okay.
Megan Stoner
I have a prescription. And there is nothing else that could really be said. So I pled guilty and got a year of probation.
Unknown
Okay. Haribo? Not yet.
Megan Stoner
Is he going to.
Unknown
I'm not sure. I have not heard a response yet. But I have seen the online post that you made alleging that he sexually assaulted you.
Lainey
You.
Unknown
Do you want to clarify any of those claims?
Megan Stoner
I would just say that, you know, our relationship that we had was a very intimate and close relationship. My trauma was on full display, and I had a lot of things that I had to navigate through during that time. And I believe that Harry and I did so successfully. And we were talking as of the times that I was arrested last year, so 12 months ago, and we spoke once or twice. Why I've been in jail.
Unknown
Okay. Do you have a current relationship?
Megan Stoner
I've been locked up, so I don't know how you want to classify that.
Unknown
Do you speak on a frequent basis, would you say, like, in the more recent months?
Megan Stoner
Well, we were starting to work again together when I got picked up last year.
Unknown
Got it. And how long did you work together in total, would you say?
Megan Stoner
Six months.
Unknown
And February, March, April, May, June.
Megan Stoner
Then we kind of paused in June. He was out of the country for his honeymoon. And then we picked back up when he got back in late August, September, right before I got arrested.
Unknown
Hi, I'm Hannah. I met Megan Stoner, I believe, back in 2016. She friended me on Facebook. And for years, she's been the topic of many group chats because we were all friends with her. We had all fallen into somehow the algorithm suggesting and whatever. She's friending all of us. There was some element of watching kind of a train wreck in some ways. She just was a lot on the Internet, and it was entertaining. I think her looks really played into a lot of how she got away with her scamming. And in the beginning, she was just attacking everything with so much confidence. In a way, I admired it because I felt like I've kind of struggled in my confidence in some areas of my life before. And when she was running for office or doing all these things, I thought, if she's doing it, so can I. Like, I support that. You're wanting to, like, make a difference no matter what, and you're not letting anything hold you back. Then you come to find out everything and it's all like a house of cards and none of it was real. It makes you have this weird feeling. All of her victims are like a similar type of person, like a good hearted person person, a trusting person. She's damaged society in a way where she's made it so people are less trusting. Like the trusting and good hearted people in the world are a little bit more jaded now because of her actions. She's posting all this stuff about Haribo and the yoni massages. Some of my perspective shifted in speaking with Haribo because he did kind of become a friend. And Haribo is a victim in this majorly. He genuinely was trying to help her. He's not a therapist, He's a sex guru. I think this is a technical title. He lives in New Jersey in his early 30s, and she was stealing the money from to pay Harry Beau. She racked up a debt with him at one point, and he had suspended their services until she could pay it. She eventually did, but he didn't know what to believe. When I contacted him, I sent him something that was like, I know I sound like a crazy person, but you've got to believe me. This is what's going on. I'm worried it's happening to you. We got on the phone. It took me a little bit to convince him. Then we talked several times after that because she started filing false sexual assault allegations. I have all of my text messages. So we first connected April 30th of 2023. And we last connected September 11th. I was just keeping him updated with stuff that was going on. So I sent him April 30, Chloe's tweet that says justice is finally served. Megan Stoner's arrested for fraud, stealing and lying is long overdue. And said, hi, Harry. She has been charged with several counts of felony fraud. And I was wondering if you have any experience with her that would be of note. Have you heard about this? And he said, I haven't heard about it and I haven't had any serious issues with her. And then I sent him the finding pleasure after sexual violence, like Canva article thing. The don't waste this fucking session this whole, like, hairstyle profile she wrote about herself. I said, and have you been compensated for your services? That seems to be the common theme, that she's not paid for services and products she has agreed to and has tried to install in money from many people. And he said, may I ask how you'll be using this information? I said, I've personally experienced some of the scamming and many of my friends have as well, but there are many others who've had far worse done to them because of her actions. There's a group of people who are trying to uncover the truth behind what has been going on. You've been a large character in the things she has said online, so I just wanted to reach out and see if everything was okay with you in case the things she's saying aren't true. There have been instances of her claiming people are connected to her who are not. And he said, finances are something that Megan and I have had some challenges with. It's definitely an area of improvement for her. What have you personally experienced? And I told him about the rent scams and he said, I'm sorry to hear all this. I do have a contract written up with her and if she fails to pay, I will take legal action. But so far she's been coming through on the payments. A little late at times, but still coming through. If it does get ugly, I'll let you know. And he didn't respond to those after that. But then I sent him screenshots from Twitter of her DMing with someone saying, hi, are you around? So I probably should warn you, this mentions trauma and sexual assault, but not in graphic detail. I was doing some bodywork and I realized it's going to sound questionable. It was my second session and when the professional I've been working with went to do internal massage work, I don't remember him asking. And this is where I vomit every time because there's no good solution. I have prior trauma, so it's possible I dissociated. I could go to the police, but I don't feel that would help me and I'm not sure what the solution is. This person wrote back, is this the professional you've been writing your book about? And she said, yep, and doing the NYT stuff with and speaking about. I'm really conflicted. Do you have any advice? This had been posted to Twitter, those screenshots of somebody's DMs with her. Who posted them? I sent them to Haribo on April 30th at 10:41pm and said, Harry, I know you probably think I'm crazy, but I'm genuinely trying to protect people from being future victims. I just received these screenshots of messages where Megan is accusing you of sexual impropriety. This is another one of her patterns. She has accused many pastors and Indiana elected officials of sexual assault and rape against her, which have all been found to be untrue, even some she admitted she made up. I just want you to be aware of what she has been leading people to believe. The next day he texted back, thanks Hannah. I'm going to have a talk with Megan tomorrow. We got on the phone on May 3rd. My like kind of Hail Mary to speak with him was Carrie, I watched your video on human needs and you said something that really resonated with me, contributing my energy to solving injustices and suffering I see in the world world and I very much wonder if I'm doing that. But always actively strive to. You and Lavina speak very eloquently and explain things very well and I truly have enjoyed watching your videos and hearing your thoughts on navigating conflict and loving relationships. I realize again, you must think I'm a nut and I really would love to just introduce myself properly to you so you know I'm not. Can I schedule one of your time slots with you for a phone call tomorrow so you can better know me? He said, hi Hannah, I don't think that you're a nut at all and I appreciate your persistence in connecting with me. I'm open for a call today between 10 to 12 or 1 to 2. Any of these times work for you? And I said 1pm Great. That's when we spoke on the phone and we spoke for about an hour two different times.
Tiffany Reese
That's next time on the season finale of Something Was Wrong. Thank you so much for listening. Something Was Wrong is a broken Cycle Media production created and produced by me, Tiffany Reese. Thank you so much to our associate producers Amy B. Chesler and Lily Rowe. Thank you to our audio engineer Becca High and our social media marketing manager Lauren Barkman of Luxury Media. Additional thanks to our partners Grant at Wondery, Marissa, Travis and Artee team at wme, Jason and Jennifer at ksco, our cybersecurity team Darkbox Security and my lawyer Alan, and to all of you who make our show possible with your support and listenership. Special shout out to Neon Honey and Gabbanes for covering our theme song Glad Rag's original song youg Think youk this season. For more music from them, check out the episode notes or your favorite streaming app. In the Episode Notes, you'll always find content, warnings, sources and resources with links to our websites and social media as well. Thank you so much to every survivor and ally who has trusted us to help share their stories. We are forever grateful. Until next time, stay safe friends. If you like something was wrong, you can listen early and ad free right now by joining Wondery plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey@wondery.com survey.
Justin
Behind the closed doors of government offices and military compounds, there are hidden stories and buried secrets from the darkest corners of history. From COVID experiments pushing the boundaries of science to operations so secretive they were barely whispered about, each week on Redacted Declassified Mysteries, we pull back the curtain on These hidden histories, 100% true and verifiable stories that expose the shadowy underbelly of power. Consider Operation Paperclip, where former Nazi scientists were brought to America after World War II not as prisoners but as assets to advance US intelligence during the Cold War. These aren't just old conspiracy theories, they're thoroughly investigated accounts that reveal the uncomfortable truths still shaping our world today. The stories are real. The secrets are shocking. Follow Declassified Mysteries with me, Luke Lamanna, on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts to listen ad free. Join Wondery in the Wondery App.
Something Was Wrong – Season 22, Episode 11: Double Down (Finale Part 1)
Release Date: January 2, 2025
Host: Tiffany Reese, Broken Cycle Media | Wondery
In the gripping finale of Something Was Wrong, Tiffany Reese delves deeper into the intricate web surrounding Megan Stoner, a central figure accused of various crimes including fraud, identity theft, and manipulation. This episode, titled "Double Down (Finale Part 1)," serves as the culmination of a season-long investigation into Stoner's tumultuous history of deceit and legal battles.
Reese begins by recapping the previous episode, highlighting how Alex uncovered the mysteries behind Stoner's dealings with Mason Motors. Through civil lawsuits and allegations of identity theft, significant evidence emerged, including a pending judgment of $68,002.10 against Stoner. Reese acknowledges the contributions of community members like Justin, whose early interviews provided crucial insights into Stoner's behavior.
"When my team and I first started working on this case, summer of 2024, I spoke with community member and former politico Justin in one of my early interviews. I'm so thankful to Justin and all of the participants this season for their time."
[03:05] – Tiffany Reese
The episode features intense interactions between Reese and Megan Stoner. Initial communications reveal Stoner's reluctance to engage, opting instead for non-committal responses.
"I mean, I'm happy to touch base with you in November."
[06:56] – Megan Stoner
Reese details her strategic approach in handling Stoner, balancing empathy with directness to elicit truthful disclosures.
"When speaking with someone like Megan Stoner, I knew I had to play my cards correctly."
[04:48] – Tiffany Reese
Stoner discusses her legal troubles, including multiple misdemeanor charges related to driving violations and theft. She outlines her plans for probation and repayment of fines, expressing hope for a clean slate upon release.
"I have probation for a year, but unfortunately, if I found a place. But if I hadn't found transitional living, I would literally just be on the streets because I'm not under any supervision other than probation."
[08:15] – Megan Stoner
Stoner also addresses her stance on outstanding debts, prioritizing repayment of smaller fines before tackling larger judgments.
"So my first will be the Hamilton county case, because my police stipulates that has to be done first before anything else."
[10:53] – Megan Stoner
A significant portion of the episode focuses on the numerous allegations against Stoner and her responses. Reese presents accusations from various individuals, including fabricated claims of sexual assault and fraud.
"Those allegations are that you would essentially take on the stories of other people in these groups and pretend that the same things that were happening to them were happening to you."
[19:58] – Unknown
Stoner firmly denies these allegations, maintaining her innocence and dismissing claims of deceit.
"That's not true. That's my only comment on that one."
[19:09] – Megan Stoner
The episode includes heartfelt accounts from individuals like Lainey and Hannah, who recount their personal interactions with Stoner. They describe Stoner's manipulative behaviors and the impact of her deceit on their lives.
"She would never admit to anything. This girl would just double down."
[23:35] – Lainey
"All her victims are like a similar type of person, like a good-hearted person person, a trusting person."
[24:27] – Lainey
These testimonies provide a broader perspective on Stoner's pattern of manipulation and fraud, emphasizing the emotional and financial toll on her victims.
Reese updates listeners on the latest legal developments, including Stoner's guilty pleas to three misdemeanor charges in Elwood, Indiana, and the subsequent closure of related court cases.
"On December 19, 2024, Stoner pled guilty to three criminal misdemeanor charges in Elwood, Indiana."
[07:41] – Tiffany Reese
Despite pledges to rectify her wrongs, Stoner remains entangled in legal obligations, with unresolved judgments and ongoing probation.
As the episode draws to a close, Reese hints at forthcoming revelations and investigative threads that will continue in the next installment of the finale. The intricate details of Stoner's case highlight the complexities of uncovering truth amidst layers of deception.
"That's next time on the season finale of Something Was Wrong."
[44:16] – Tiffany Reese
"I'm not trying to label with everyone, obviously."
[19:58] – Megan Stoner
"Everyone that knows me knows I never had a drink of alcohol."
[34:55] – Megan Stoner
"Our relationship that we had was a very intimate and close relationship. My trauma was on full display."
[35:24] – Megan Stoner
In this intense finale, Something Was Wrong sheds light on the convoluted case of Megan Stoner, intertwining legal battles, personal testimonies, and the relentless pursuit of truth by Tiffany Reese. As the season concludes, listeners are left anticipating the next part of the finale, promising further unraveling of Stoner's enigmatic and troubling narrative.
For more information, visit James Patterson's Holmes Is Missing and follow Something Was Wrong on your favorite podcast platform. Stay tuned for the continuation of this riveting story in the upcoming episode.