Episode Summary: Something Was Wrong | S22 E7: Scam the Scammer

Release Date: December 5, 2024

Introduction

In the seventh episode of the 22nd season of Something Was Wrong, titled "Scam the Scammer", host Tiffany Reese delves deep into the manipulative actions of Megan Stoner, a figure embroiled in a series of scams and criminal activities. This episode unpacks the community's response to Stoner's deceit, the emotional toll on her victims, and the relentless pursuit of justice by those determined to hold her accountable.

Background on Megan Stoner and Previous Episodes

Megan Stoner emerged in the Indianapolis community not just as a political figure but as someone whose actions led to significant trauma and financial loss for many. In prior episodes, listeners were introduced to Alyssa, an Indianapolis community member who first became aware of Stoner's questionable behavior. Alyssa had posted free items for those in need on Facebook, only to find Stoner removing these items from her porch, revealing her ulterior motives. This act led Alyssa to report Stoner to the Buy Nothing Facebook group admin, marking the beginning of a longer investigation into Stoner's activities.

The Scam Awareness Facebook Group

Years after the initial incident, Alyssa discovered the Megan Stoner Scam Awareness Facebook group, a community of alleged victims and concerned locals. This group became a hub for sharing experiences and strategies to combat Stoner's ongoing fraudulent activities. As Megan faced legal charges, including an OWI and nine felony counts, her continued alleged misconduct, even after being released on bond, highlighted the severity of her deceitful behavior.

The Story of Tom

A pivotal moment in the episode revolves around Tom, a victim who had loaned Stoner money and shared his card information with her. Unaware of her rental scams, Tom experienced significant financial strain as Stoner provided inconsistent excuses about her legal troubles. Over time, Tom's growing suspicions led him to the Scam Awareness group, where he learned the extent of Stoner's manipulations. Discovering that someone he admired had scammed him deeply affected Tom, transforming his relationship with Stoner from admiration to betrayal.

[05:09] Alyssa: "She had a warrant for the OWI case and around that time she had her court date coming up for the felony charges out of Hamilton county... She was staying in and out of Airbnbs, changing them up every night."

Alyssa's Investigation and Attempts to Approach Stoner

Driven by a sense of justice and personal connection to Tom's plight, Alyssa took matters into her own hands. Posing as a reporter named Valerie, she reached out to Stoner, aiming to gather incriminating information by befriending her. Alyssa recounted:

[09:13] Alyssa: "It's important to note when listening to most of the calls we're including this season with Megan to keep in mind that the goal... was to gather more evidence by getting her to accidentally slip up and share important information."

Alyssa's strategy involved gaining Stoner's trust by expressing interest in buying the life rights to her story, hoping Stoner would inadvertently reveal critical details about her scams and legal issues.

The Failed Arrest Attempt

A significant part of Alyssa's efforts culminated in a risky plan to confront and arrest Stoner. On a tense August night in 2023, Alyssa, accompanied by Vero (the group admin), orchestrated a meeting with Stoner at a local Airbnb. The plan was to have Stoner meet them, and with Vero's help, alert the authorities to apprehend her.

[23:26] Megan Stoner: "I'm like, I'm down for it. Let's go. I'll go pick you up. We'll do this."

However, the operation faced unforeseen challenges. Despite initially locating Stoner, a miscommunication and a non-extraditable warrant led to her abrupt release by the police. Stoner's dismissive reaction post-release only fueled Alyssa's determination.

[30:01] Alyssa: "And then I see somebody message in the group chat, and they're like, they just said non extraditable warrant on the scanner... they let her go."

Continued Efforts and New Strategies by the Group

Undeterred by the failed attempt, Alyssa and her allies ramped up their efforts. They spearheaded innovative sting operations, including creating fake social media accounts to lure Stoner into interactions where she might reveal incriminating information. One notable strategy involved Amanda, who leveraged her graphic design skills to craft a believable business entity, True Renewal Bloomington, aimed at attracting Stoner's interest.

[41:13] Amanda: "I have a graphic design background, so I made an Instagram account. I made it in 20 minutes. I called it True Renewal Bloomington... we thought Megan loves to present herself as an expert on things."

This approach paid off when Stoner, under financial strain, took the bait and engaged with the fake business, setting the stage for another round of attempted arrest.

Emotional and Community Impact

Throughout the episode, the emotional weight of the community's struggle against Stoner is palpable. Victims like Tom feel betrayed and vulnerable, while members like Alyssa grapple with the risks of their vigilantism. The episode underscores the challenges faced by those seeking justice outside formal legal channels, highlighting themes of trust, betrayal, and resilience.

[16:12] Alyssa: "I feel like they just are watching your every move, and you just keep giving them ammo to do so. Okay. That's my best advice to you, is don't give them so much ammo."

Conclusion and Ongoing Mission for Justice

Something Was Wrong concludes with an unwavering commitment from Alyssa and her group to continue their pursuit of Megan Stoner. Despite setbacks, their mission to expose Stoner's crimes and prevent further victimization remains resolute. The episode serves as a testament to community-driven justice and the lengths individuals will go to protect and support one another against prevalent deceit.

Notable Quotes

• Alyssa: "No one deserves to be treated like this. No one deserves to put trust in someone and then have someone completely ruin that trust." [05:09]

• Megan Stoner: "My life for weeks now, and I'm just... I'm so tired of hiding in seclusion." [14:31]

• Alyssa: "I will not stop until you are behind bars and you pay for your crimes." [30:01]

Final Thoughts

"Scam the Scammer" offers a gripping narrative of deceit, community response, and the quest for justice. Through detailed storytelling and emotional testimonies, the episode sheds light on the complexities of dealing with fraudulent individuals and the power of collective action in combating such threats.