← Something You Should Know
Loading summary
Transcript78 lines
- [00:01]
Sarah Gabrielli
Imagine what's possible when learning doesn't get.
- [00:03]
Mike Carruthers
In the way of life.
- [00:04]
Sarah Gabrielli
At Capella University, our game changing flexpath learning format lets you set your own deadline so you can learn at a time and pace that works for you.
- [00:12]
Mike Carruthers
It's an education you can tailor to your schedule.
- [00:15]
Sarah Gabrielli
That means you don't have to put your life on hold to pursue your professional goals. Instead, enjoy learning your way and earn your degree without missing a beat. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University.
- [00:27]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Learn more at Capella Eduardo Today on something you should know why are Dalmatians associated with firefighting, firehouses and firefighters? Then some interesting things you never knew about optimism.
- [00:45]
Sunita Saw
People who are strongly optimistic tend to live longer. They tend to be healthier. They tend to be more successful. People who score high on pessimism that associates quite strongly with depression. And depression is characterized, among other things, by an inability to see that there is any other way forward.
- [01:01]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Also, the best ways to stay warm in the winter cold, and a new way to look at defiance and the power it can give you.
- [01:10]
Mike Carruthers
The old definition to defy is to challenge the power of another person to resist boldly and openly. And my definition to defy is to act in accordance with your true values when there is pressure to do otherwise.
- [01:26]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
All this today on something you should know. So I want to talk to you if you have a lot to do this time of year and also have to hire someone like you really need that to add to your to do list. But if that's the case, really, it's time to try Indeed. Indeed is your matching and hiring platform with over 350 million global monthly visitors according to Indeed Data, and a matching engine that helps you find quality candidates fast and without all the busy work and paperwork. And here's what I love about indeed. They walk you through the entire process of matching just the right person to the job opening you have, and they do it really well. In fact, three and a half million businesses worldwide use Indeed to hire great talent fast. So they must be pretty good at what they do in the minute I've been talking to you. 23 hires were made on Indeed according to Indeed Data worldwide. Look, you can try to wing it by yourself, or you can put Indeed to work to help you get the right person quickly. And listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to get your jobs more visibility@ Indeed.com something just go to Indeed.com something right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com something terms and conditions apply. Need to hire you need indeed.
- [03:00]
Mike Carruthers
Something you should know.
- [03:01]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Fascinating intel, the world's top experts and practical advice you can use in your life today. Something you should know with Mike Carruthers. Hi. Welcome. We're gonna start today by talking about dalmatians. You know the dogs, dalmatians. I imagine you've probably wondered why they're so synonymous and closely associated with firefighters, fire trucks, firehouses. Well, that tradition dates back more than a century and today their role is much more of a mascot than anything else. But back in the day, they played a vital role. In the 1700s, Dalmatians were the preferred breed for aristocrats. They served as carriage dogs. You see, dalmatians get along really well with horses and form strong bonds with those horses. So they were used to keep pace, running alongside or behind the horses on long carriage rides. In the days of horse drawn firefighting wagons, Dalmatians were really well suited for that job because horses are afraid of fire and they were less likely to get spooked or distracted when they were escorted by one or more of their canine buddies in the midst of a chaotic fire scene. Now, if you've ever heard that dalmatians are kept at firehouses because they're deaf or unaffected by sirens, that is an old wives tale. There are some hearing issues associated with that breed of dog, but it is their loyalty and gentle disposition and proud history that has earned them a spot at the fire station and on the fire truck. And that is something you should know. What is an optimist? Is it someone who simply looks for the good in everything? Who sees the bright side? Who finds the silver lining? Are you born an optimist or a pessimist? Or do you become one or the other as a result of your life experience? Are other animals optimistic or is this a human characteristic? Is it worth trying to be more optimistic? Well, here to discuss the science of optimism is Shumit Pal Choudhury. He is a former editor in chief of New Scientist. He trained as an astrophysicist, and he is author of a book called the Bright side How Optimists Change the World. Hi, Shumit. Welcome to Something youg Should Know.
- [05:40]
Sunita Saw
Hi, Mike. Thanks for having me.
- [05:42]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
So what exactly is optimism? I mean, it's not an emotion, it's what is it?
- [05:49]
Sunita Saw
Well, one of the reasons I kind of started looking into this subject is because actually, I think we all kind of think we know what optimism is. We kind of think it's this sort of general attitude that life will go all right and Things will work themselves out. But when you start digging into it, you find there are actually kind of several distinct flavors of optimism. There's a psychological version of optimism, there's a philosophical version of optimism, and then there's kind of a practical version of optimism, and they kind of flow on from each other. The psychological definition of it is essentially having expectations about the future that are not supportable by the available evidence. So you kind of have. You think things are going to go well even when you don't have evidence that know testifies to that or makes or demonstrates that's going to be true.
- [06:32]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
What about that idea, that attitude towards life that is often associated with optimism, that things have a tendency to turn out okay? Because as I look back at my life and the lives of people, I know that often seems to be the case. Not that things don't go horribly wrong sometimes, or that things don't work out the way you had hoped they would, but that often things have a way of turning out okay. And is that a good way to approach life? Is that a safe assumption?
- [07:09]
Sunita Saw
It's one of those things. It's a safe assumption, except when it isn't. So one of the kind of things I dug into was the evolutionary origins of optimism and where optimism, why it seems to be that we have this innate, very widespread tendency to look on the bright side, and why that seems to be part of the human condition actually goes beyond the human condition. Because actually you also find that animals are optimistic or they express biases in the way they look at the world that reflect what we would think of as optimism. For example, you can do an experiment with chickens in which you train basically chicks to associate, some say, a black card with food and a white card with no food. So, you know, if they move a black card, there'll be food behind it. If they move the white card, there won't be. And once they're trained to do this, you show them a gray card and you see what they do. And what happens is that most chickens tend to go for the gray card. And that's. Which basically means they think, well, it's probably going to have food. It's more likely to have food behind it than it's not, which is essentially, you know, an animal version, a chicken version of optimism. And when you start looking around, you discover that lots of animals do this, and all sorts of animals, kind of the clever animals you might expect, like monkeys and dolphins and dogs, but also, as I say, chickens, sheep, even animals that we think of as being really simple, like Bumblebees express this kind of bias. And the most compelling explanation I found for this is that essentially you need something to motivate you to take action. When you don't know what the future holds, or when you're presented with an ambiguous situation, when you don't know what the answer is, when you have a gray card, or in the human case, when you have a glass half full of water. Obviously nobody ever does that experiment, but you understand the point. If you have the half glass of water and you have to decide if it's half full or half empty, there isn't actually a good answer to that. There's no meaningful answer that you have to make a call of some decision in kind of the long run. If you don't do anything every time you're presented with that kind of situation, you're going to go extinct, you're not going to thrive. If every time you don't know what's going to happen next, you do nothing. That isn't a recipe for success. So optimism, and most of the time in life, we're faced with situations where we don't know what's going to come next, not in detail. We may have an idea. And humans are better than most species obviously at figuring out what's coming next. But most of the time we don't have enough information to know what's coming next. So you have to have something that makes you act. And essentially, if you kind of work through the logic of this, if we make the right kind of mistake or you make the right kind of assumption, as long as the negative effects of that small, every now and again, the positives are large. So you can think about this in all sorts of circumstances in your life, really. I mean, if you apply for many jobs, for example, that you're not very likely to get, fair enough, most of the time you won't get them. But you haven't expended much beyond the cost of applying for those jobs. When you get one that is transformative for your life, on the other hand, it transforms your life. And so then when you look back at this, of course you say, well, things did mostly work out. You know, things have worked out pretty well. And that's kind of optimism working on an incremental, step by step basis. One of the psychological ways of looking at optimism is explanatory style, which is, say, do you look back at your life and think things worked out well, or do you look back at your life and think they didn't work out so well? Most people tend to go for the optimistic end of things.
- [10:39]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Is optimism or your level of optimism, is that set at birth or is it formed and moved around over time based on your experiences in life?
- [10:52]
Sunita Saw
A bit of both. So like most psychological traits or most traits in general, it's a mixture of your inheritance, your genetic inheritance, and your environment. In the case of optimism, it seems to be a bit more about experience than it is about genetics. Your genetics sort of account for a decent chunk of your level of optimism as an adult, but not the majority of it. Your experiences in your environment seem to play quite a significant role in molding your optimism. And the pattern tends to be that young children are very hyper optimistic. They're extremely optimistic, and you can kind of understand why that would be because you think about the challenges a little kid, I mean, a really small child faces. You know, they can't speak, they have no motor control, they can't feed themselves, but they're essentially helpless. But from there, they have to get to a position where they can do all those things, where they can stand, they can walk, they can eat, they can talk, they can eventually write and tie their shoelaces and all those kinds of things. And if you did not expect that you were going to succeed, you know, in those, I mean, if you didn't think you could, you would succeed at managing those tasks. Even though when you start out, you have absolutely no ability to do them and no way to communicate with anyone about them, you know, you would get nowhere. Right. I mean, you know, as a, as an infant, you have to be a hyper optimist because you have to kind of believe that you can achieve these things. So children are hyper optimistic. And that kind of tends to gradually wane over the course of our. As we get older for various reasons. I mean, there are sort of a number of reasons why that might happen. One of them is just the accumulation of negative experience. Over time, it seems like we've become better understanding what negative experiences are telling us about the world. When we're very young, we tend to ignore them. We kind of pay a lot of attention to the positives, but we brush off the negatives. And again, if you know any kids, you know that kids forget a bad thing pretty quickly, but they remember when they're successful and they remember how to build on that. Over time, we start to become better at absorbing negative information because as we become more independent, we're going to encounter more situations where we need to be good at handling that. That's one we build better models of the world. We understand how the world works better. And we kind of get different feedback from the adults around us. We don't get told like, you know, you can do anything, like just put your mind to it. You start getting, you know, hopefully constructive criticism about what you're doing. So eventually kind of, you know, those experiences gradually mount up and they essentially set your adult level of optimism. From there on, it fluctuates a bit with life experience and you know, depending on how well or badly things go for you, it does go up and down a bit. Trying to move the needle on optimism is not that easy. It's not a short term thing. I think that, and this is kind of moving away from the research really into what I concluded. I think that if you do various practices, you can probably improve the way that you look at the world. Particularly if you're talking about more intellectual kind of problems rather than emotional, intuitive things. I think you can, but I think it probably takes a lot of repetition over a lot of time. And the chances are if you haven't been doing it for a lot of your life already, you may not make that much difference.
- [14:01]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
One of the things I've always wondered about optimism is, is it in a sense a self fulfilling prophecy? Meaning that if you have an optimistic view of the world, you're looking and noticing the good things that happen, that supports your optimistic view of the world, that good things happen. And if you're a pessimist, you tend to notice the bad things that happen and that supports your pessimistic view of the world.
- [14:31]
Sunita Saw
I think it's even more polarized than that actually. I think the. So what I eventually concluded was that the essence of optimism is openness to possibility. Because essentially I kind of said that optimism comes into its own when you don't know what the future holds. I think the critical thing that an optimist does, and there are various studies that back this up in different ways, the critical thing that an optimist does, a strongly optimistic person does, is they remain open to the possibilities, to the idea that there are many possibilities that lie ahead of them. And optimists kind of tend to think about the positive ones. But I think just the very awareness there are lots of possibilities makes you more inclined to go out and look for them and to seek them. A pessimist, by contrast. I think it's not so much that you look at things, many things, and look at them negatively so much as you just don't see alternatives. I think really speaking in a practical sense, the opposite of optimism is fatalism. It's this idea that actually there is nothing you can do. You can only carry on down the track that you're on at the moment. And that kind of is reflected in so in psychology, for example, people who score highly on optimism tend to do well. It's an association rather than a causative thing. But people who are strongly optimistic tend to live longer, they tend to be healthier, they tend to be more successful. People are complicated, so there's no hard and fast rules here, but that tends to be the case. People who score very low on optimism, people who score high on pessimism, that associates quite strongly with mental illness, in particular with depression. And depression is characterized, among other things, by an inability to see that there is any other way forward or to believe that you can do anything that would change your status or your situation. So I think that's the one thing, really. I think optimism is about being able to appreciate that there are more possibilities ahead of you than you may necessarily be able to see.
- [16:36]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
We're talking about optimism and looking at the bright side. My guest is Shumit Pal Chowdhury. He's author of a book called the Bright How Optimism Changes the World and how you can be one.
- [16:49]
Sarah Gabrielli
A new year means new opportunities, and if you've been thinking about starting your own business, let this be your sign to take the leap. Of course, this decision comes with a lot of questions like how do I get started? How do I come up with a brand? How do I sell stuff to people? What am I even going to sell? Well, if you have all those questions, you can take a deep breath because Shopify's got you. Shopify makes it simple to create your brand, open for business and get your first sale. With Shopify, you can get your store up and running easily with thousands of customizable templates. No coding or design skills required. All you need to do is drag and drop. Their powerful social media tools let you connect all your channels and create shoppable posts to help you sell everywhere people scroll. And Shopify makes it easy to manage all the details like shipping, taxes and payments from one single dashboard, allowing you to focus on the important stuff like growing your business. The best time to start your business is right now, and with Shopify, your first sale is closer than you think. Established in 2025 has a nice ring to it, doesn't it? Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com realm. All lowercase go to shopify.com realm to start selling with Shopify today. Shopify.com realm. Hey there, Ryan Reynolds here.
- [18:13]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
It's a new year and you know what that means. No, not the diet resolutions.
- [18:18]
Sunita Saw
A way for us all to try.
- [18:19]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
And do a little bit better than we did last year.
- [18:21]
Sarah Gabrielli
And my resolution, unlike big wireless, is to not be a raging and raise the price of wireless on you every chance I get. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch $45 upfront payment required equivalent to $15 per month. New customers on first 3 month plan only. Taxes and fees, extra speed slower above 40 gigabytes on unlimited. See mintmobile.com for details.
- [18:42]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
So shumit A lot of people I've heard say I'm not an optimist or a pessimist. I'm a realist. And an optimist is just somebody who looks at the bright side, thinks everything's fine, but I take a more critical view of the world. I'm a realist.
- [18:59]
Sunita Saw
Yeah, I mean people do say that. And I don't have a lot of time for realism. I think it's a fig leaf for ignorance a lot of the time, not all the time, but a lot of the time. Someone who says they're being a realist is simply saying, I don't want to engage with the possibilities. I'm going to stick to what I know and assume that carries on. And what we know from history is that history doesn't really move in straight lines. If you look back at just the course of this past century so far, there have been a number of epochal events since the year 2000. Most of them were not kind of straight line continuations of where we were going or what we thought was going to happen. If you were being a realist under those circumstances, I think you would have missed most of the surprises that we've had in the past 25 years.
- [19:45]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
I've often heard the advice that people say, if you want to be more optimistic, stop watching the news. Because the news by its nature tends to be bad news. If it bleeds, it leads. And if you watch that, you get a very skewed vision of the world as being a bad place and horrible things happen and horrible things are likely to happen. And that if you want to be more optimistic, just don't watch the news. Do you think that's a fair statement? Can watching the news affect your level of optimism?
- [20:19]
Sunita Saw
I think it's more in the. It seems like it might be the case. The evidence this is a contentious subject. Right. Is the degree to which. To which the ad media diet, if you like, is making it hard for us to see, you know, any beyond that. I think there's a, I mean, personally, I think there is a degree of truth to that. It's hard to see how being, you know, exposed to negative information, negative, bad news, terrible news a lot of the time, often about things that are happening, you know, in places and at times where we really can't, you know, you know, at an individual level do very much about them. It's hard to see how that doesn't take a slight psychological toll. It's, you know, it's very easy to understand how that might, very easy to, to think that that might have a negative effect in terms of the causation that is less well researched, less well attested. It's not really clear how that feeds directly into our levels of optimism or otherwise.
- [21:20]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Isn't it true, though, I remember hearing that there are a lot of parents today, for example, who are very concerned about the safety of their children. You know, don't let them walk alone, stranger danger, always walk with a friend. And yet statistically, the world is a safer place than it's ever been and that just random acts of kidnapping children are so amazingly rare that it really isn't something to worry about at the level that people worry about it. It's just their exposure to these anecdotal stories in the news where it occasionally happens or it seems like it happens that riles up people's sense of fear.
- [22:04]
Sunita Saw
Yeah, there's been a lot of work done in the past couple of decades by people like Steven Pinker or the Max Roser who runs the Our World and Data website that kind of show us that, you know, on a numbers basis, you know, it's a good time to be alive. And I think that's a good message. And I, you know, and I, you know, I support it. I mean, if you look at, it is probably better to be an ordinary person today and certainly in the industrialized world than it would have been to be a monarch 200 years ago. Certainly better than a thousand years ago. You know, we live longer, we live healthier lives. We have, know, material standards of living that are incomparable to anybody who's come before us. And in most other respects, in things like crime as well, there's probably, you know, I think it's probably reasonable to say that we live in safer times. But I think that the psychological difficulty here is that those gross aggregate statistics are all very well, but they don't necessarily help me very much when it comes to what I'm going to do about my own life. I mean, you're right. There is this kind of focus on effect of, you know, a terrible story breaks in the news and then it sticks in your head and you kind of think. I mean, even if you are irrationally kind of think, well, the chances of that happening are very small. You still don't want to be the person who that very small probability happens to. So that's kind of one thing. Regardless, it's hard to kind of get away from the irrationality of being. Well, I mean, from the concern that you would feel about having been exposed to that. The other is that, of course, aggregate statistics. I mean, as I just said, that it's probably better to be an ordinary person today than it was a monarch 300 years ago. Kind of irrelevant because I wasn't a monarch 300 years ago. I'm an ordinary person now. And whatever concerns I have about the world I live in now are the concerns I have about the world I live in now. It's not especially helpful to me living my life to know that if I'd been alive 250 years ago, it probably would have been worse. That doesn't really help me when I hear about an act of violence in my neighborhood that is much more relevant to me than what the crime statistics show for the last 30 years.
- [24:07]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, it is the subtitle of your book about Optimists are the ones who change the world. And when you think about it, it is the optimists, the ones who see the possibilities, who do change the world. That if you're pessimistic and you think, well, that'll never work, well, then you're unlikely to go try and do something. But if you're an optimist, you're more likely to give something a try. So in that sense, optimists change the world.
- [24:36]
Sunita Saw
I don't know if I'd go so far as to say it's only optimists who change the world, but certainly it's substantially optimists who change the world, I would say, because they are the ones who find solutions, who find technologies, who find ideas that the rest of us don't necessarily, I say the rest of us. Actually, I count myself as an optimist, but some people really put that into practice. I think if you look at someone like Elon Musk, I mean, set aside his politics, or you might think of him personally, you think about what he's achieved in terms of revolutionizing the car industry, revolutionizing the space industry, becoming the richest man in the world, and now something close to the most powerful man in the world. That's an extraordinary thing. And he is a self described optimist because he's set out to do things that most people looking at them would have said, that is out of scope. That is not something that you can do from a standing start. So I think Elon Musk is a very good example of an optimist who's changed the world. There are many other people who fit those sorts of templates who've gone out for something that the rest of us would say that's really not possible, and it turns out it is.
- [25:46]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
So do you think it's possible and, and is it worth it to try to increase your level of optimism or does the needle not move much? I mean, you are who you are.
- [25:58]
Sunita Saw
I think you can change your default level of optimism when it comes to your own life. I think you can do that. And this is, you know, I think if you kind of get into the habit of challenging yourself, and there are various ways that psychologists are supposed to do that, of challenging yourself to, to think more optimistically, you can do that. I think the piece that we can change, that I think all of us can change, is the intellectual part of this, because we're not just creatures of instinct. We formulate views about the world and we assess what we know, what we learn critically, and we think about what we're told and we think about how to frame it. That part, I think, is amenable to an effort of will. I think if you try there to think about the world in a positive light, if you try to think about what's happening in more constructive ways there, I think it is possible to be more of an optimist. And I think that's actually where the need is. We're pretty good at being optimistic about our own lives. I think what we're not so good at is being optimistic about our social lives, about our collective lives, I think that's kind of where we could do with putting in the practice.
- [27:03]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, this has been a really great conversation about optimism and the benefits and the reasons why trying to look at the world through a more optimistic lens can really pay off. I've been speaking with Shumit Paul Chaudhary. He is author of a book called the Bright how optimists changed the world and how you can be one. And there's a link to his book at Amazon in the show notes. Shumit, thanks. I've really enjoyed this.
- [27:29]
Sunita Saw
Thank you very much for having me. That was great. I enjoyed that a lot. And thank you for the interesting questions, and let's keep the dialogue going.
- [27:36]
Sarah Gabrielli
Hi, I'm Sarah Gabrielli and I've traveled to every single lesbian bar in the country for my podcast, Cruising. Each episode of Cruising features a different space and tells the stories of the humans that run it and the humans that call it home. You can listen to Cruising on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Season one and two are available now, so be sure to binge them before season three, which will go beyond the bars to queer bookstores, farms, peace encampments and more. Premiering February 4th. Do you love Disney? Then you are going to love our hit podcast Disney Countdown. I'm Megan the magical Millennial.
- [28:13]
Mike Carruthers
And I'm the Dapper Danielle.
- [28:15]
Sarah Gabrielli
On every episode of our fun and family friendly show, we count down our 10 list of all things Disney. There is nothing we don't cover.
- [28:22]
Mike Carruthers
We are famous for rabbit holes, Disney themed games, and fun facts you didn't know you needed but you definitely need in your life. So if you're looking for a healthy dose of Disney magic, check out Disney Countdown wherever you get your podcasts.
- [28:40]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
There's a lot of value given to the idea of being agreeable. People like it when you're agreeable, compliant, you go along with the group or the consensus. But what about those times when you're not in agreement and you don't want to be compliant because you know it's wrong but you stay quiet anyway because, well, to speak up would be considered defiant. And whereas being compliant and agreeable is usually considered a good thing, being defiant is often thought to be a bad thing. But sometimes speaking up, being defiant is the right thing to do. So what do you do? Well, that's what Dr. Sunita saw is here to talk about. She is an award winning professor at Cornell University and an expert in organizational psychology. She's author of a book called the Power of no in a World that Demands yes Hi Sunita, welcome to Something youg Should Know.
- [29:39]
Mike Carruthers
Hi Mike, it's wonderful to be here.
- [29:42]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
So I think everybody can relate to this issue, this dilemma of not speaking up, not being defiant. Who hasn't been in a meeting and thought, oh God, that is a really dumb idea. I really should say something or similar situation where you don't speak up even though you know you're right. What fascinates you about this topic?
- [30:05]
Mike Carruthers
Well, I've been fascinated by what this single powerful word defy means for a very long time. As a child I was known for being an obedient daughter and student And I remember asking my dad, what does my name mean? And he said, in Sanskrit, sunita means good. And mostly I lived up to that. So I did what I was told, went to school as expected, did all my homework. And these were the types of messages I received, not just from parents, but teachers and community. They were to be good, to fit in, obey, not make a first, don't question authority. And many of us receive these messages, and we equate being compliant with being good and defiance with being bad. And when I delved into it in more detail, I discovered some problems with that. For example, one survey found that only 1 in 10 healthcare workers, many of them nurses, felt comfortable speaking up when they saw their colleague making an error or taking a shortcut. And findings from another survey of over 1700 crew members on commercial airlines found that only 50% of them felt comfortable speaking up when they noticed a mistake. So these are huge problems. And I started to wonder, what if it's sometimes bad to be good? What do we sacrifice by always trying to be so compliant and so polite? And that was a question that really inspired a lot of my work and research. I often felt drained and muted by looking after everybody else's feelings. And keeping silent when you know something is wrong can become soul destroying. So I spent decades studying this and what I found that is crucial and substantially changed how I think, is that we have misunderstood what it means to defy.
- [32:07]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, what you just said is so interesting to me because you're so right. I mean, when you think about the good kids, they're the ones that do what they're told. We equate that with goodness and compliant is good and defiant is bad. And people kind of just accept that. I mean, this isn't really a topic that people debate. This is like one is good and one is bad. But when you stop and think about it in the frame that you just framed, you're right. I mean, if, if people aren't speaking up, what, what are the consequences of that?
- [32:51]
Mike Carruthers
Yeah, absolutely. Which is why I came to this revelation that we need a new definition for defiance. So the old definition in the Oxford English Dictionary is to defy is to challenge the power of another person, to resist boldly and openly. And I'm not one to usually disagree with the Oxford English Dictionary. I was raised in the uk, after all. But I think that definition is way too narrow. And my definition is that to defy is to act in accordance with your true values when there is pressure to do otherwise. So defiance is actually reframed as A proactive, positive forces in society. Because if you think about it, like all our individual actions of consent and dissent, they create the society that we live in. So it affects our lives, our workplaces, our communities. And that's why I'm so passionate about it.
- [33:51]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
So let's talk about why people have trouble speaking up, saying no, being defiant. What's like, what is the fear of what might happen?
- [34:05]
Mike Carruthers
What I found is that we tend to actively resist defiance. And there's three key reasons for why this happens. First of all, we feel enormous pressure to go along with other people for a variety of reasons. We're conditioned to comply. And we also have some distinct psychological processes which I can go into that make it very difficult for us to reject another person's recommendation or suggestion. That's the first one, this pressure to go along with other people. Second, we don't really understand what compliance and defiance actually are. I've given you my new definition of defiance, which really helps. But once we totally understand what's involved in complying, consenting and defying, that helps us determine when we need to defy. And then the last one is, once we decide that we should defy in this situation or we want to defy in this particular situation, we don't actually know how. We don't have the skill set or the ability, and we're not practiced enough to put our values into action again.
- [35:18]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
I guess, like, why is that? What is it we're so afraid of by speaking up what we believe to be correct?
- [35:27]
Mike Carruthers
Sometimes it's fear that's keeping us from speaking up, so we might fear the consequences. For example, oh, I don't want to lose a relationship. Maybe I'll lose a job or I'll be embarrassed. And we very much think about the costs of defiance, but we don't think about the costs of actually complying as much as we should, because they are costs. From bowing your head to other people continuously, from disregarding your values, it can leave you drained and muted. And not being able to live your own authentic, honest life. So they could be fear. It doesn't need to be fear. And in fact, what I found in some of my interviews is sometimes fear allows us to defy. Fear of terrible consequences, of not defying motivates us. So there is that aspect. The fact that we are so strongly socialized. And let me tell you about this psychological process that I've discovered in my research, which also keeps us compliant at times. So it's one that I call insinuation anxiety. And this is a Very distinct type of anxiety that arises when we worry that our non compliance with another person's wishes may be interpreted as a signal of distrust. So it insinuates that the person is not whom they appear to be or should be and that increases the pressure for us to comply. So for example, if your boss tells you to do something and you don't think that's the right way to go, it's hard to insinuate that they're incompetent a lot of the time, especially if everybody else is agreeing around you. Insinuation anxiety could explain why some of the nurses didn't speak up when they saw medical errors. Because it's difficult to tell another nurse or a doctor that you're doing that wrong. It should be this way. And it's also the same with, with crew members on commercial airlines, why the co pilots don't speak up to their pilots. So it is this aversive emotional state where we become so concerned with offending the other person that these relationship concerns which I found arises even in one off situations with strangers is so powerful. It keeps us compliant and it keeps us silent.
- [37:46]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, it also seems like when I think about times where I haven't spoken up, a big part of the reason I don't speak up is self doubt. Like well, maybe I'm wrong, maybe they really are doing it correctly and I'm incorrect.
- [38:02]
Mike Carruthers
Yeah, that's such a great point. And I actually define that self doubt or some kind of tension as the first stage of defiance. So when we feel uneasy in a situation, when we feel that there's some tension between what's expected of us and what we think is right, this tension can manifest in many different ways. So for example, Mike, you're telling me that you feel tension as some kind of self doubt? Well, they could be right, you know, maybe I'm wrong that I've seen happen a lot of times, I often have self doubt. I also feel tension, maybe butterflies in the stomach, maybe a headache, something that basically signals to you that this might actually be the time you need to defy. So it's a warning signal. But most of the time we push it away, we don't acknowledge it to ourselves. We just think it's not worth our doubt, it's not worth our attention because the other person must know best. Or we just want to listen to authority. And that's a shame because we're ignoring a really powerful signal that you might want to look at this in more depth. So that is actually the first stage of defiance. That tension, that self doubt that you might want to think and acknowledge to yourself, I am feeling this. Something might not be quite right here. And then that's the second stage. The third stage is to articulate that to someone else and tell them I'm not comfortable with this or ask some clarifying questions. And that stage is really important. I mean, you're still in a subservient position. You're not saying you're not doing anything, you're clarifying and you're saying what your concerns are and why that stage is so critical is that the research shows if you can get to stage three, you're more likely to go through all the stages of defiance and get to the end stage, your actual act of defiance.
- [40:01]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
There's a difference between that's not the way I would do it and you're doing it wrong. I just may have a different way. But doesn't mean you're wrong, it just means that's not the way I would do it. But, you know, so maybe it's not worth speaking up because there can be two paths to the same end.
- [40:22]
Mike Carruthers
That's certainly true. And one of the things that you need for defiance is knowledge and understanding. So the way that I look at it is that I take informed consent in medicine and I apply it to other critical decisions in our lives. For informed consent, five elements need to be present. So first of all, capacity that you have the mental capacity to make this decision, you have the knowledge, which is the information and the understanding, so you know the risks, the benefits and the alternatives. And the fourth element is that you are free to say no, because if you don't have a choice, you can't really consent to anything. So you should feel free to say no. And then you can authorize either your informed consent or your informed refusal, which is the last element. Now, if you take all these factors, not just for consent, but also for defiance, that I have the capacity, this is not a knee jerk emotional reaction I'm having to this because I want things done my way. I have the capacity, the knowledge, the understanding. I have the freedom to actually say no in this situation. Then then if all those elements are present, I might want to say no.
- [41:37]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
When you use the word defiance, though, there's something about that word that not only implies that I don't agree with you, but it's not that it's a violent word, but it implies almost disobedience. Like it's not just saying you're doing it wrong or this isn't wrong and this is how we should do it. It's condemning, and you know what I mean. Defiance is a strong word.
- [42:06]
Mike Carruthers
It is a strong word. And I think people do often think about defiance as being loud and bold or violent and angry and aggressive. They either think about it in that way or they think about it as being heroic or superhuman and out of reach when they think about iconic figures like Rosa Parks, for example, refusing to move on the bus. But in actual fact, neither are true. You don't have to be brave, a superhero, have a strong personality, or be larger than life to incorporate defiance in your life. It's not just for the extraordinary people. It's available and it's necessary for all of us. We all need to learn how to defy so we don't go along with unethical practices. We allow for unfairness if we hear a sexist or racist remark. We all need to learn how to defy in order to live our lives according to our values. And interestingly enough, Stanley Milgram, who conducted the famous electric shock experiments, where he had participants come in and give what they thought were harmful electric shocks to another person. They weren't actually giving those shocks, but they thought they were. He actually said the people that obeyed the experimenter to give those harmful shocks, he described them as obedient and the ones that declined as defiant because we need that skill set to say no when things are very wrong.
- [43:37]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
What about, though? I mean, I can imagine as you're talking about this, about the people speaking up every time they hear something offensive or every time that that's the person. I don't want. I don't want to be the killjoy who's outraged every time anybody does anything that might possibly be offensive or incorrect or maybe different. Boy, I don't want to be near that. I don't want to be near that person, nor do I want to be that person.
- [44:07]
Mike Carruthers
So it's not about moral outrage and it's not often about confrontation at all. It's determining how we want to live our lives and the type of society we want to create. Now, people have been under the influence of their peers because they're too polite to say no, and they end up in situations that they would rather not. And given that we value certain things, such as integrity, very, very highly, we might want to decrease that gap between what we think our values are and how we actually behave. So let me tell you, there's a survey of over 20,000 high school students, and in that survey, nearly two thirds of students have said that they've cheated on a test. Nearly one third said that they have stolen something from a store in the past year. And over 80% said that they had lied to their parents about something significant. And I find that heartbreaking because I have a high school student right now. And this isn't unique to high school students. We start at an early age believing that our values are really important to us and we want to live by them. When I ask my executive students to explicitly write out what their values are, integrity is seen again and again as a very important value. And then I ask them. So rate yourself in your level of honesty compared to everybody else in the room. If you think you're the most honest, on a scale of 0 to 100, you should put 100. If you think you're the least honest in the room, you should put yourself at zero. And if you think you're about average, it should be 50. And guess what I find? Time after time, I find that most people are rating themselves 85 or over. Of course, not everybody in the room can be 85 or over. The average needs to be 50, but we hardly get anyone saying 50 and no one going below that. We rate integrity so highly, and yet we find that we don't act in that way when the time requires it. We fail to put our values into action. And what my studies have shown time and time again is that gap between who we think we are and what we actually do is enormous. And learning how to defy, given that a lot of our behavior is influenced by other people is, decreases that gap. It sometimes allows us to put our values into action. And I think that's really important. So rather than viewing it as sort of a knee jerk emotional reaction or reacting with moral outrage to someone and telling them that they're wrong, that's not how I view defiance. I view defiance as living your life according to your values, which according to.
- [47:11]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
You, not many of us seem to do.
- [47:14]
Mike Carruthers
Not just according to me. According to the research, we often.
- [47:17]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, that's what I mean. Yeah.
- [47:18]
Mike Carruthers
Yes, absolutely.
- [47:19]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
There's some clear evidence.
- [47:21]
Mike Carruthers
There's a large gap. There's a large gap between who we think we are and what we actually do.
- [47:26]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, why is that? I guess, you know, in order to get up in the morning, you have to think good of yourself. You can't think you're not, or you wouldn't get up. I mean, you. So you. I imagine we're all deluding ourselves a bit. Some more than others.
- [47:41]
Mike Carruthers
Yeah. We do have what is called positive illusions. That helps us live in the world at times. But also we have what is called an empathy gap. So if we see someone behaving badly, we think, oh, I would never do that in that particular circumstance. Oh, I would be able to have said no. I wouldn't have listened to my boss asking me to do something unethical. I would have said no. And it's easy for us when we're not in the situation, to say how we would react, but we actually don't know. Sometimes we enter that situation and we end up freezing or we're confused and we're unprepared because we don't have an action plan of defiance. We don't know how to defy because we've spent our whole lives complying, and we don't have any training in defiance at all. So we need an action plan long before the moment of crisis. So when we really need to, we can defy.
- [48:42]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
And so how do we do that? I mean, if you are someone who's tendency is to be compliant and go along and have a really hard time speaking up and saying, hey, wait a minute, how do you get good at that?
- [48:56]
Mike Carruthers
One of the things is that we can start anticipating because there's numerous times where we've complied and we wish we defied, and we know those times are going to happen again. So all we have to do is anticipate it. Some of these things are really predictable because we know what factors enable our defiance and what factors disable it. And we can get explicit about them, write them down, so we can anticipate what's difficult for us. Then we visualize it, we picture it, and we practice by scripting and role playing and repeating it. And the reason we have to do those things is because we have been so trained for compliance that those neural pathways are really strong. We need to now start practicing for defiance and building those neural pathways. And this a wonderful quote that's often attributed to Bruce Lee, but it comes from a Greek poet that says, under duress, we don't rise to the level of our expectations, but we fall to the level of our training. And that is why it's so important to practice and train for defiance. Because once we're in the situation, we can't just wish ourselves to speak up. We might predict that we would do that in advance, but we know there are times when we often comply and we need to practice for defiance.
- [50:18]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
I think there is this image, though, that you can't be defiant and polite at the same time, that defiance is not the opposite of polite, but they're not compatible, but it seems like that's not necessarily true.
- [50:33]
Mike Carruthers
Right. So I always say when we get to stage three of Defiance, which is basically saying you're not comfortable or you're clarifying. And that doesn't, as you say, you definitely don't need to be a jerk. You can approach with curiosity rather than confrontation. Like, what do you mean by that? Help me understand. I'm not sure I am comfortable with that. Oh, I have some concerns. There's just short little things that you can say to put your concern on the table, and it's not even leaving that subservient position at that point. All you're doing is clarifying before you move to stage four and say, I'm not sure I can do that.
- [51:13]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
Well, I really like this idea of taking Defiance out of the closet and really reframing it. Not as a bad thing, but as something really quite necessary in so many situations. And it doesn't mean you have to be a jerk about it. It's just a matter of speaking up and doing what's right. I've been speaking with Sunita Saw. She's an award winning professor at Cornell University and she's author of a book called the Power of no In a World that Demands yes, and there's a link to that book in the show notes. Sunita, thank you. Thanks for coming on today.
- [51:50]
Mike Carruthers
Thank you so much. It was wonderful to speak with you.
- [51:55]
Shumit Pal Choudhury
In the cold of winter, it can be difficult and expensive to try to keep warm, so here are some suggestions. Use a humidifier in your home because humid air feels warmer. Make sure all the heat vents are clear of obstructions like furniture and rugs. Otherwise the heat doesn't get into your room even though you paid for it. Run ceiling fans in reverse. That pushes the warm air back down from the ceiling. Use rugs on bare floors and always wear something on your feet like socks or slippers because if your feet are warm, you feel warm all over. Go upstairs if you have an upstairs because heat rises so it's usually warmer up there. And if you're cooking, leave the oven door open after you're done to let the heat into the house and help heat things up. And that is something you should know. And while you're staying nice and warm inside your home this winter, maybe you could take a few moments and share this podcast with someone you know, a couple of people you know. Tell them about it so they too will listen and become regular listeners, hopefully just like you. I'm Mike Carruthers. Thanks for listening today to something you should know.
- [53:10]
Mike Carruthers
Hey.
- [53:10]
Sarah Gabrielli
Hey. Are you ready for some real talk and some fantastic laughs? Join me, Megan Rinks and Melissa D? Montz for Don't Blame Me, But Am I Wrong? We're serving up four hilarious shows every week designed to entertain and engage and, you know, possibly enrage you. And Don't Blame Me. We dive deep into listeners questions, offering advice that's funny, relatable and real. Whether you're dealing with relationship drama or you just need a friend's perspective, we've got you. Then switch gears with But Am I Wrong? Which is for listeners who didn't take our advice and want to know if they are the villains in the situation. Plus, we share our hot takes on current events and present situations that we might even be wrong in our lives. Spoiler alert. We are actually, quite literally never wrong. But wait, there's more. Check out See youe Next Tuesday, where we reveal the juicy results from our listener polls from But Am I Wrong? And Don't Miss Fisting Friday, where we catch up chat about pop culture, TV and movies. It's the perfect way to kick off your weekend. So if you're looking for a podcast that feels like a chat with your besties, listen to Don't Blame Me, But Am I Wrong on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes every Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday.