
Loading summary
Mike Carruthers
The holidays have arrived at the Home Depot and we're here to help bring the excitement with decor for every part of your home. Check out our wide assortment of easy to assemble pre lit trees so you can spend less time setting up and more time celebrating. And bring your holiday spirit outdoors with unique decor like one of our Santa inflatables. Whatever your style, find the right pieces at the right prices this holiday season at the Home Depot. Today on something you should know. If you know older people who tend to forget things, you need to hear something then understanding your emotions and why they can be difficult to control.
Julia Digangi
What the evidence shows us is the more we obsessively seek certainty, you would think that's kind of logical, right? We'll feel better when we're certain. But the more we obsessively seek certainty, the sicker we get. The more anxious we get, the more afraid we get, the more agitated we get.
Mike Carruthers
Also, an effective and simple remedy for the next time you have trouble sleeping. And elevators. We need them. We willingly go in them, but they are a little creepy and scary.
Lee Gray
If you made a list of the most socially awkward spaces, you know the elevator's probably at the top of the list. Especially as Americans, you know, we don't necessarily like standing that close to each other.
Mike Carruthers
All this today on something you should know. One thing I've learned about running a business is this. Just because you can run a business doesn't mean you're good at hiring. Hiring is a skill all its own, and if you get it wrong, it costs you time, money and momentum. I've been there. That's why I recommend Indeed because they make the whole process faster, easier, and they deliver better outcomes. When it comes to hiring, Indeed is all you need. Instead of struggling to get your job post noticed, indeed's sponsored jobs helps you stand out. So what happens is your listing jumps right to the top of the page for the right candidates so you reach the people you actually want to reach faster. And the difference is real. According to Indeed data, Sponsored Jobs posted directly on indeed get 45% more applications than non sponsored jobs. I mean, that's huge. And to give you an idea of just how fast it works in the minute I've been talking, 23 hires were made on Indeed according to Indeed data worldwide. No wonder more than three and a half million employers already use it. There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed and listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsor job credit to get your jobs, more visibility and@ Indeed.com something just go to Indeed.com something right now and support this show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com something terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need.
Lee Gray
Something you should know Fascinating intel, the.
Mike Carruthers
World'S top experts and practical advice you.
Lee Gray
Can use in your life today.
Mike Carruthers
Something you should Know with Mike Carruthers hi, welcome to Something you should know you may have noticed or experienced if you know someone older who might be suffering some memory loss that Older people who have memory loss have more trouble holding on to recent memories than older ones. They can remember what happened 30 years ago as clear as a bell, but often can't remember what happened yesterday. According to memory expert Dr. William Cohn, memory loss in older people is common and sometimes it just happens. But there are two other reasons that older people can't remember what happened yesterday. One of them is that nothing happened yesterday. Older people, especially those suffering memory loss, often don't do very much of anything all day long, so there's really nothing to remember. Plus, that lack of brain activity slows the brain function even more. Increasing activity, physical activity can really help. And then there's medication. For people taking several medications, there's an excellent chance those medicines are interfering with the thinking process. Having a medication evaluation and making some adjustments in the medicine can work wonders for brain function and memory. And that is something you should know. If you think about it, when life is easy, well, then life is easy in part because your emotions are not engaged. It is when life is hard that your emotions kick in and life becomes more challenging. How you use those emotions in those challenging times, that is your emotional power. And that's what Julia Digangi is here to discuss. Julia is a neuropsychologist, founder of Neuro Health Partners, and author of a book called Energy the Neuroscience of Leading with Emotional Power. Hi Julia, welcome to something you should know.
Julia Digangi
I'm so glad to be here. Thank you for having me, Mike.
Mike Carruthers
So explain if you will, in a little more detail what my emotional power is. So everyone understands emotional power.
Julia Digangi
So let me actually back up and think, sort of talk more broadly about emotions. So in the moments in your life where things are just working out for you, and I hope people have plenty of days like this, right? So the people are just listening. The kids are just obeying. Our partners are just kind of cooperating with us. Our teams are listening. Those are wonderful moments, but they don't require an ounce of our strength or our power. All of our emotional power shows up in the moments of Emotional resistance. Right. So who do I become in these moments when people are not cooperating with me, when people are not listening to me, when things are not working out as I wanted? And if you really understand the brain, what those situations really generate, the reason we even call them problems is more fundamentally, they create negative emotional energy, which I call emotional pain. So things like stress, irritation, frustration, I could go on and on. There's probably a thousand synonyms. So our emotional power is who we become in the moment when we hit this emotional resistance or this emotional pain.
Mike Carruthers
And a lot of us aren't too thrilled with that person we become when those things happen.
Julia Digangi
Not at all. I mean, I think a lot of it has to do with, you know, we simply don't have enough conversations like this. You know, one of the things I always say is it kind of blows my mind that we pay more attention to figuring out how to operate ChatGPT or our cell phones than we pay attention to understanding how to operate our brains. Our brain is the most powerful, magnificent machine we'll ever own. And I think in today's day and age, we have a lot of really strong neuropsychological evidence that tells us how to powerfully navigate difficult situations, scary situations, and uncertain situations.
Mike Carruthers
Well, I think that the assumption is, or my assumption is that how you react to those things when people don't cooperate, when things don't go your way, that that is largely hardwired in. And yeah, you can jiggle the wires maybe, but that you are who you are and you react how you react.
Julia Digangi
You know what, As a neuropsychologist, I couldn't disagree more. So I really believe in emotional transformation, behavioral transformation. And I don't just believe in it. You know, I've done a lot of, and I'm really well published in the scientific literature, so I sort of have seen very clearly the evidence of emotional and behavioral change. And I work with people all day long for many, many years. You know, one of the things that I think surprises people is if you really want to achieve change, you have to understand the brain's relationship with uncertainty. Can I, Can I talk about this for a minute?
Mike Carruthers
Absolutely.
Julia Digangi
So, as I mentioned, I'm sort of most fundamentally a trauma expert. So I've worked with you know, incredibly int human emotions. Rage, despondency, betrayal. And certainly those emotional experiences are very painful. But one of the things that struck me in my work is we actually underestimate what could potentially be the most taxing emotion of all. And that emotion is confusion. Now, I don't care if you call it confusion or ambiguity or uncertainty from a neural perspective, the brain is kind of doing the same thing. Now, to understand why uncertainty is so difficult for your brain or why confusion is so difficult for your brain, you have to understand what the brain is. So the best way to think about your brain is as a pattern detection machine, right? So you are going through your life and your brain is basically going apple, apple, apple, fill in the blank that should be an apple. So you can see the only thing that will really stop the brain from doing its core function is confusion. So even if you're, you know, even if I have to experience rage or if I'm sad, my brain can handle those things much better than it can handle me not knowing what to do next. So a lot of our pain actually comes. It's this very counterintuitive thing. And this is why I think it's so powerful to learn the brain. A lot of our pain actually comes when we try to create certainty, right? So I just said the brain is a pattern detection machine. It's kryptonite are these moments of uncertainty or confusion. So what a lot of us do to try to create certainty is we try to do it through what I call the overs. Okay? So the overs, and I think your listeners are really going to resonate with this. The overs are things like overworking, overthinking, overdoing, over communicating, over giving. I mean, I could just go on and on and on. And in each of those moments, what I'm really doing is I'm trying to use an abundance of my energy to create certainty where there is none, right? So working is amazing. But over. The only reason anyone ever overworks is because they're afraid. Thinking is very pleasant. The only reason someone overthinks is because they're anxious. So here's the final point and then I'll kind of come up for air is what we're very clear about from the neuropsychological research, and I think this is such a mind blowing moment for people, is actually what the evidence shows us is that the more we obsessively seek certainty, you would think that's kind of logical, right? We'll feel better when we're certain. But the more we obsessively seek certainty, the sicker we get. The more anxious we get, the more afraid we get, the more scared we get, the more agitated we get. So if we really want to lead emotionally powerful lives, we have to understand how the brain responds to uncertainty, certainty, and how to navigate that Powerfully so.
Mike Carruthers
Well, what it sounds like is if you're trying to create certainty when there isn't any, so don't try. So just, well, que sera sera, whatever happens, happens. But that's not human nature. We need to try to get our way, to control things, to move forward the way we want. We have wants and needs too.
Julia Digangi
Absolutely, absolutely. So here's the thing though, and this is such like this, this, we're coming back to this core idea that everyone's heard a million times before of balance. So is it important to on some level understand how to navigate the external world? Of course it would be absurd to say otherwise, but I would tell you I think one of the most pressing behavioral problems in our individual lives, in our homes, and I do a lot of work in organizations in the larger culture is we are obsessed with, we are obsessed with what is happening in the external world. Hey, what are you doing? Why is this person talking like this? Why are the people on social media doing this? Why are those. It just goes on and on and on. If I had to distill all of my work down to a single question, it would be this. How can I control these people who matter to me? So how can I control the behavior of these people around me so that their behavior doesn't make me feel the things I don't like to feel? So what happens is that because we're so externally obsessed, we over focus on the external environment and we totally neglect our inner environment. So what I'm really saying, again, this is kind of counterintuitive is like absolutely navigate the external world. That's what we're on this planet to in part do. But if you think the opposite of uncertainty is certainty, that's not true. And in fact the more you seek certainty obsessively, the worse you're going to feel. So then what is the opposite of uncertainty? The opposite of uncertainty is self trust that even if these people don't cooperate the way that I need them to cooperate, it's okay that even I work in a lot of organizational settings where micromanagement is a big problem. All micromanagement is at its core is certainty seeking. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Jim, I'm going to need to see that email before you send it. Sarah, I'm going to need to be in that meeting. I'm going to need you guys to run the idea by me a hundred times. So I'm trying to control. Why am I trying to control? Because I don't think I'll be okay if not.
Mike Carruthers
And why is that why is it that we feel we won't be okay if we can't control it?
Julia Digangi
Your brain is actually the native universal language of every single human being is a language of emotion. This is true. I mean, and if we're really honest about it, it's a, it's a language of negative emotion because every single one of us showed up on this planet red face, terrified, screaming and enraged. Okay, so the brain's kind of running on this emotional energy. I don't mean this metaphorically, I mean it neurobiologically. So in the ways that you get into pain in your life, you have a core emotional pattern and it's gonna sound something like this. People just don't really listen to me. People just don't really listen to me. People just don't really listen to me. Maybe my emotional pattern is things just never work out for me. Things just never work out for me. Things just never work out for me. Then watch me find a new relationship and I promise you, you will come to see that things just don't work out for you.
Mike Carruthers
Yeah, it's like a self fulfilling prophecy. And I think people have a sense of that because it's probably easier to see it in other people. You see people who always say things aren't going to work out and they never work out. I'm speaking with Julia Digangi, she's a neuropsychologist, author of the book Energy the Neuroscience of Leading with Emotional Power. Introducing your new Dell PC. Powered by the Intel Core Ultra processor, it helps you handle a lot. Even when your holiday to do list gets to be a lot. Because it's built with all day battery plus powerful AI features that help you do it all with ease. From editing images to drafting emails, to summarizing large documents, to multitasking. So you can organize your holiday shopping and make custom holiday decor and search for great holiday deals and respond to holiday requests and customer questions and customers requesting custom things. And plan the perfect holiday dinner for vegans, vegetarians, pescatarians and Uncle Mike's carnivore diet. Luckily, you can get a PC that helps you do it all faster so you can get it all done. That's the power of a Dell PC with Intel inside backed by Dell's price match guarantee. Get yours today@dell.com deals, terms and conditions apply. See Dell.com for details. As the weather cools, I'm getting clothes that are warm, durable and built to last. And for me the only place to get them is quints. They've become My go to for fall staples. My favorites. Their pants, cashmere sweaters and their polo shirts. I mean, the quality is first rate and I find myself reaching for my quince clothes more than anything else in my closet. Their 100% Mongolian cashmere sweaters start at just 60 bucks, which is incredible when you realize how soft and well made they are. And their polo shirts, they just have a better fit than any other I've ever tried. And if you're looking for outerwear, Quince has classic fit denim, real leather and wool pieces that look sharp and are built to last. And I've got my eye on this suede trucker jacket. It's casual but still really polished. And it's perfect for layering this fall. Here's what makes quints different. They work directly with ethical factories and top artisans, cutting out the middlemen so you get premium quality at half the cost of similar brands. And it's not just clothes. Quince has expanded into bedding, bath cookware, even travel accessories with the same focus on quality and value. Layer up this fall with pieces that feel as good as they look. Go to Quince.comSYSK for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q U I N C E Quince.comSYSK Free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.comSYSK so Julia, talk some more about this self fulfilling prophecy idea and how you know it to be true.
Julia Digangi
In one of my experience, so we use in FMRI and EEG research, we use this well validated face paradigm, okay. And we put people in scanners and we show them four faces. Angry faces, fearful faces, mad faces or neutral faces. One of the most interesting faces is actually the neutral faces. So everyone is seeing the same faces. But interestingly, people who are, we call them, you know, healthy controls. So people that don't have a diagnosis like anxiety or depression will report the faces as neutral. They'll just say, I don't know, they're kind of blank. Whereas people who already have anxiety will say the faces are threatening. Who's right? The point I'm driving at here is there's based on how the brain works, there's no way to take affect out of it. So go back to your micromanagement thing. You're saying I need to micromanage because Suzy can't do her job? I'm saying I would ask a different question. I would say, what is it about in your emotional coding that is signaling to you that Suzy can't do her job. And even if you said to me, you know what, Julia? I've had 20, because this happens a lot. I've had 27 conversations with Susie about how you. So you're telling me 28 email review. 28 is going to save you. You see what I'm saying? A big thing I see is like, it's very difficult for people to give difficult feedback. Why? Because it makes them anxious, because it makes them scared, because they're afraid that someone's going to get mad at them. I'm afraid to fire her. Why? Because I don't. I believe that there's nothing people that I could hire to do this job. I feel that someone's going to get. It's always coming back to emotional energy. Why? Because how your brain makes meaning is predicated on affective circuits in the brain. In other words, do you have a good life? I don't know. How do you feel about it? Do people work hard for you? I don't know. How do you feel about it? How much money is enough money? How much time is enough time? All of these things are ultimately mediated by emotion. And so when people just talk about situation without talking about emotion, we are denying the very physiology upon which consciousness rises.
Mike Carruthers
The micromanager guy, let's say you convince him not to read Susie's email before she sends it. You're asking him to change. So what does he do? Because a lot of this is about, don't do this, don't do this. Well, but you gotta do something. You can't just don't do something.
Julia Digangi
Totally. So here's the thing. I'm going to give you one more quick story. So I'm brought in a lot to help organizations with employee engagement. Okay? So I'll say, what's going on around here? And they'll say, for example, things aren't looking good. Morale is low. There's not a lot of inspiration. There's not a lot of engagement because the staff is X, Y and Z. And I say, great, that's super valid. We're going to totally get to that. Just really quick, tell me how you're doing. And what invariably I hear, Mike, is people say, I'm not doing good. I'm frustrated, I'm burnt out, I'm irritated, I'm frustrated. I keep saying the same. So in other words, they're embodying the very energy they're saying they want out of their team, whether it's their team at work or their team in their home. Now, here's the Thing. Neuroscience tells us that emotion is a thing of contagion. You quite literally catch. We catch each other's emotions the way we catch colds. You already know this is true because you. Plenty of times you've been in a great mood, you walk into a room, and you're like, oh, God. And your mood just sinks like a lead balloon. Or alternatively, this is my favorite one is like, you've definitely walked into rooms before where people are cracking up. You don't even know what they're laughing about, and you just start laughing. We are wired to catch emotion. So overwhelmingly, in my experience with leaders, they want their people to do well. They want to run a happy organization, a happy house, so they'll start to obsess. How do I make these people feel more inspired? How do I make them feel more motivated? How do I make them feel more engaged? And I say, your job is actually not to motivate anyone. Your job is to motivate yourself and trust that they will catch the energy of that motivation. They will catch the energy of that inspiration. Your job is to inspire no one. Because until you tell me how you can get inside someone's nervous system and, like, click around in there and zing, zing, zap, zap, zoink, zoink, zoink. So they feel a feeling inside their own body. It will never work. But what does work is we know the mechanism. We know that emotions are contagious. So I need to start thinking, what is the emotional energy that is missing on my team? Is it patience? Is it clarity? Is it kindness? Is it authenticity? And then I need to start thinking about how do I want to embody the very energy that I am saying I want to see more of on my team?
Mike Carruthers
Which sounds a little like, lead by example, do as I do, watch me, and hopefully you will do the same. But it seems a little, I don't know, iffy, like, maybe they will, maybe they won't. And when you think about leading and motivating, it's like you're supposed to be doing something, telling people, rallying the troops. That's what motivating is.
Julia Digangi
If I'm serious about motivating. And we've all been around leaders who inspire us, and never once have I heard someone say, you know, who's really motivating and inspiring to me are the leaders who try to micromanage the hell out of me, the ones who tell me how to do it, the ones who keep checking in on me. We are inspired by people who are really lit up by the work who are really authentic. So what I'm saying here is that if you want. And I, I completely understand if this has not been the way that you've been living your life for. And I think a lot of us don't. It seems like a very big paradigm shift. But the thing that I think anchors us is like, well, all of this is ultimately being told by how the brain operates. So let me just think here for a second. Okay? What's the problem? The problem is people are motivated. Okay, how do I get them motivated? I should give them more Starbucks gift cards. We already know that extrinsic forms of motivation don't meaningfully work. They. Right. So we have, we have those data. Well, we know that there are two circuits for motivation in the brain. There's extrinsic motivation, which is like, I'm going to give you a Starbucks gift card. I'm going to give you a bonus. And we know that there are intrinsic forms of motivation which is, do I feel happy to be here? Is this aligned with my. So even if these things feel nebulous, which I understand for a lot of people, they do, that doesn't. They're still real. They still work at the level of the brain. Okay? So if I'm, if I'm a boss and I say I want people around here more motivated, I understand that I've kind of tapped out extrinsic forms of motivation. I need to tap into internal systems of motivation. I can't get inside of their nervous system. Let me work on mine.
Mike Carruthers
Can you give me another example of how emotional energy works? Maybe not in a business setting, but maybe a parenting setting?
Julia Digangi
So I was at the park the other day. I have little kids, and there was this little Noah. So little Noah was like up on the slide and little Noah's mom was like, noah, no, get, get down off that slide. Noah. Noah, come down. Noah. And I, I was kind of watching this, right? And like, little Noah looked quite sure footed. He looked quite confident. He was having a good time up there. He kept telling his mom, like, I think I'm okay. Like, I don't want to come down. So eventually, little Noah complies. What was really happening in that transaction? Was it really that little Noah was going to get so catastrophically injured? Or was it more that mom was having very big feelings inside of her body and she needed Noah to come down off that slide so she could control the feelings in her body also, I want you to think about this. We say that we want to raise really powerful Children, meaning they're self reliant, they're self intimate, they really understand themselves. We give our kids a lot of interesting messages, right? So the most powerful form of leadership on the planet is parent leadership. So, you know, we will say things to our kids like, eat that broccoli. I don't want to eat the broccoli. Eat it anyway. Go tell her you're sorry. Wait, but I'm not sorry. Hey, I said go tell her you're sorry. March over there right now. Right. So it's like we as parents have these ideas of how things should go. What happens though in the child is the child's having an emotional experience. I don't like broccoli. I am not afraid. I do not want to apologize because mom didn't see. But you know, this kid hit me in the head first. Right. Whatever it is. But then we're telling our children, you're having this emotional experience, override the emotional experience and behave in a way that I'm telling you to behave in. The problem with that chronically is that what we're really teaching our children is their own emotional experiences can't be trusted. And this is when you start to see we have a whole society of people right now talking about people pleasing and performers and obsessed with attention and not confident and unable to help themselves. There's real consequences of these things. I will tell you. I work with a lot of anxious, like parents that come for coaching for anxious kids. You want to know one of the biggest hallmarks of anxiety in the child? Anxiety in the parent.
Mike Carruthers
Well, and every parent's done that where, you know, say the child doesn't want to do his homework. And then somehow you, you like catastrophize that into some horrible. Their, their whole academic career will be ruined because you're having trouble getting them to do their homework. And we do that, that anxiety, right?
Julia Digangi
So there's like the kid won't do the math homework the way the parent wants the math homework done. And now it's become this like epic thing where like no one's respecting, no one's loving. And when you really start to work on the parent's energy, you start to always see that the parent is telling, often unconsciously, a catastrophic story to themselves. They're not going to do well in geometry, they're not going to be successful in high school, they're never going to get into a good college, they won't have a good job. And by the of this story, once you get them to verbalize it, their child is homeless living in a refrigerator box underneath a bridge. It's like, whoa, whoa, whoa. Like we did that to ourselves, right? And there can be something very healing and very empowering when we start to understand how our emotions are coloring the ways we're acting with our children and other people we love.
Mike Carruthers
Well, this is a very different, unique way of looking at how emotions work that, that I know I haven't really thought much about before. I've been speaking with Julia Dagangi. She is a neuropsychologist and author of the book Energy the Neuroscience of Leading With Emotional Power. There's a link to that book in the show notes. Thank you for being here, Julia, and explaining all this.
Julia Digangi
Thank you. You are awesome. And I actually like the you had challenging questions and I appreciated that as well.
Mike Carruthers
You chose to hit play on this podcast today.
Julia Digangi
Smart Choice Progressive loves to help people make smart choices. That's why they offer a tool called Auto Quote Explorer that allows you to compare your Progressive car insurance quote with rates from other companies so you save time on the research and can enjoy savings when you choose the best rate for you. Give it a try after this episode@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in all states or situations. Prices vary based on how you buy.
Mike Carruthers
If you've ever shopped online, you've probably run into this. You find something you want, you're ready to buy. But checkout feels like such a chore. Digging out your wallet, typing in info, and sometimes you just give up and abandon the cart. That's exactly why the Purple Shop pay button is such a game changer. It makes checkout so simple. And here's the kicker. When you see that button, it means the store is powered by by Shopify. And Shopify doesn't just make it easy to buy, it makes it incredibly easy to start and run your own business. It powers 10% of all U.S. e commerce with millions of businesses on board, from big names like Mattel and Gymshark to entrepreneurs just getting started, you can handle everything. Inventory, payments, shipping, analytics, all in one place. And if you need marketing help, well, Shopify has built in tools for email and social campaigns so you can find and keep customers. And that Purple Shop pay button? Well, it's love worldwide because it gives you the best converting checkout on the planet. If you want to see fewer carts being abandoned, it's time for you to head over to Shopify. Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling at shopify.com sw go to shopify.com sysk shopify.com sysk in the near future, you are likely going to step into a small room, possibly with total strangers. The door will lock behind you, and there you will stand. You may struggle deciding if you should say something or even look at these other people in the room with you. As this room moves up or down in a building, it is, of course, an elevator. Elevators are weird little spaces, yet they changed the world in a way. They made tall buildings possible, but they are a little mysterious. I'm sure you've worried when an elevator bounces a little when it stops on a floor. Should you worry? Is that a problem? What about those open and closed door buttons that often don't really seem to do anything? Could an elevator actually come loose and plummet to the ground? Here to explain things about the elevator is Lee Gray. He is a professor of architectural history at the University of North Carolina and author of a book called From Ascending Rooms to Express A history of the passenger elevator. Hi, Lee. Welcome to something you should know.
Lee Gray
Hi.
Mike Carruthers
So I know there are conflicting stories about which was the first passenger elevator, but pick one that is your best guess as to probably the most important or the first or whatever, and when and how and why and where.
Lee Gray
The one that I know of, of an elevator that was specifically designed to carry passengers was 1859 in the Fifth Avenue Hotel in New York City.
Mike Carruthers
And where did it come from? Who created it? How did it get in the building?
Lee Gray
So what we have to remember is mid 19th century, large urban hotels were just becoming a major part of a major feature, rather in American cities, but in cities also throughout Europe. And when you went to one of those hotels, you had incredible amenities that you didn't have at home, so to speak. Running water in your room, a bathroom adjacent to your room, steam heat, all of these incredible things that many people didn't have at home. And in planning for the Fifth Avenue Hotel, the developer of the hotel thought, well, we have all this wonderful technology. What if we can put technology in the hotel that would transport the past, the. The guests up and down from the lobby to their rooms? And the proprietor contacted a gentleman named Otis Tufts. We think of Otis as associated with elevators. This is a different one where his first name is Otis, Otis Tufts, who was a Boston engineer, and he designed a machine exclusively for the Fifth Avenue Hotel to carry guests up and down. This was a very, actually very strange machine in that the designer was very safety conscious and therefore thought, well, if we suspend a car or cabin by cables, the cables could always break. Passengers would fall Bad things would happen. So he eliminated the cables and designed and they constructed this enormous shaft from the basement to the top of the building. And it was a screw shaft, if you will. And the car fit on the shaft just like a nut on a bolt. And the steam engine rotated this massive metal shaft. And as it turned, the car slowly, very, very slowly would rise and fall throughout going, moving up and down the shaft. The idea was that it was perfectly safe because there were no cables.
Mike Carruthers
So it was basically on a screw. It screwed up and down. It screwed up and down.
Lee Gray
Yes, that's exactly what it did.
Mike Carruthers
Well, that must have been amazingly slow.
Lee Gray
It was amazingly slow. Even for the time period. It was ridiculously expensive, around $25,000 and 25,000 DOL 1859 is real money. I mean, it was insanely expensive. And only one other similar machine was built for a hotel in Philadelphia. And that technology was very rapidly abandoned because it was too expensive. And even for a hotel, it was.
Mike Carruthers
Too slow, yet there it was.
Lee Gray
But what it did do is it set an important paradigm for how hotels, excuse me, how elevators in hotels and later on in fine department stores and other settings worked in that you approached the elevator, station operator would open the door, you would go into the elevator car, take a seat on a really very comfortable, well cushioned little bench, admiring the fine woodwork of the car, nice mirrors on the walls, little gas chandelier hanging down. And after everyone was seated, the door would be closed by the operator, and then he would slowly and gracefully ride up to your floor, and then the operation would reverse itself. Because the idea initially, of course, wasn't speed, it was luxury. I'm going to this hotel to be pampered and to be well taken care of.
Mike Carruthers
So as we move along the chronology here, I wanted to ask you, at what point in the chronology of elevators do escalators show up? Is it early on, later on, prior to after the fact? When.
Lee Gray
So escalators begin to show up in the 1890s. And they begin to show up for primarily two reasons. One, it is a form of vertical transportation that doesn't require an operator. Therefore, quite simply, I don't have to pay for one. And two, they operate all the time. You know, they don't stop and start. And, and I guess really then there's a third reason, because they operate all the time. They carry many, many more passengers in the same amount of time than an elevator can. And, and this is, you know, if you watched an escalator, you know, there's an endless flow of passengers Moving non stop elevators, of course, stop. Doors open, people exit, you enter, doors close, and so on. It's obviously much slower.
Mike Carruthers
The early elevators, and I don't know how early early is before it started to change. But was it a case of like somebody, an elevator operator, had to kind of manually line up the elevator with the floor, or was that already in place that the elevator knew how to stop at the floor? Or like how automatic versus manually driven was it?
Lee Gray
All right, that's a great question. Up until the early 1920s, all elevator stops were under the control of the operator. And if you stopped the car within 1/2 inch of level to the floor, that was considered a good job. So up until the early 1920s, it was all up to the skill of the operator to stop the car. Level. By the mid-1920s, we had automatic leveling systems which meant that the car would automatically stop and be perfectly level. And as one sort of cultural footnote to that, one of the an early silent movie, I want to say 1917, 1918 was actually predicated on this hapless but penniless inventor who invents a system that, that elevators would stop level with the floor, which makes him a fortune, and then he marries his boss's daughter and all that kind of thing.
Mike Carruthers
The elevator operator. Like it, like how tough was it? Was it. Because it seems like that's got to be a relatively dull job, but maybe it was more skilled than I realized.
Lee Gray
So it's, there's there, it's kind of a paradox here. It was skilled to be able to drive the elevator primarily to stop at level with the floor. Floor. But it was also more than that until actually until the late 1920s. So let's imagine a 10 story building. And what do I do as an elevator? Elevator operator? I would start my day on the lobby floor. And if there are four other elevators, I'm not going anywhere until I'm directed to by a person called the starter. The starter was the staff member in a building in charge of directing elevator traffic. Traffic. So I would be in my elevator car and people would start piling in. And when the starter gave me a signal, I would start my elevator and I would go all the way up to the 10th floor. And then I would go all the way down to the first floor, even if I didn't have any passengers to pick up because there's no automated control. While I'm running my elevator, if somebody wants the car, they'll push a button and a signal goes off in my car that says stop on floor Six. So I've got to watch for signals. Stop where I'm supposed to stop. Stop, level where I'm supposed to stop. Open the doors for passengers to come in, close the doors after the passengers have come in. Ask them what floor they're supposed to go to. So you get the idea. There was, I'm doing a lot. And it also, and here's the paradox, was one of the lowest paying jobs in the building.
Mike Carruthers
The modern elevator today, is it like because it does the same thing as it did in the 60s and the 50s and the 40s and it gets people up and down, Is it technologically just so much better or is it basically the same thing today as it's always been?
Lee Gray
In some ways it's the same thing it's always been. But all of the features that we encounter have been enhanced. Most of the enhancements have to do with two fundamental ideas. The first is safety. Elevators are incredibly safe and many, many improvements are predicated on increasing that safety. A good example would be, we don't tend to think about this are the elevator doors. Most elevator doors now have sensor arrays that are not only between the two doors, but often will extend three dimensions in front of the doors to make sure that they open and close properly. But most importantly, they don't close on a passeng either exiting or entering. And it's very, very sophisticated systems, but most of those are refinements to existing technology that begins in the 1950s.
Mike Carruthers
So despite what you might see in the movies or whatever, have there been many, any free falling elevators that killed.
Lee Gray
People in the 19th century? Yes, from 1950 to the present. I won't say that there are none because I don't know the history of every elevator accident. It's very, very rare. And because one of the things that would happen and the example I always use is in the movie Speed, everybody remembers the bus. But what the other thing that we find in the movie Speed, if you remember the first sort of third of it, it is when the, I guess, mad bomber blows up the cables on the elevator car and it starts to fall down the shaft and then you see the safeties grab onto the guide rails and the car stops. That's what would happen.
Mike Carruthers
So if you go into a building, a tall building in New York City, you'll often see banks of elevators that don't all go to all floors. These elevators only go up to this floor, these elevators past that floor and start stopping later on. Is that just for convenience so people don't have to stand in the elevator? So Long or is there a mechanical reason for that?
Lee Gray
Fundamentally, that's about efficient traffic control in a building. If I can direct, if it's a 30 story building and I have elevators serving 1 to 10, 10 to 20, 20 to 30, and then a handful that serve the whole building, I can divide the building, you know, traffic into, into three zones. So first thing in the morning and at the end of the day, it's, it's very efficient for people entering the building, getting to work and leaving. What? That also means that bank that serves 1 to 10 above the 10th floor. That space is no longer occupied by elevator shafts, which means it's available for use or for rent. So it's both about efficient traffic control in a building and also taking up the smallest amount of space possible because of course, that space is incredibly valuable for rental purposes or leasing purposes.
Mike Carruthers
We've all been in an elevator where it comes to a stop and then it does like a little bounce and everybody goes, oh, what is that the.
Lee Gray
First thing about the bounce? You're perfectly safe. That's the first thing to know. If an elevator hasn't been maintained in a while, you can get a little cable stretch and the motor can have a little bit of play in it and you can get a little bit of a bounce. It's perfectly safe. It just, it may mean not, not always, but it may mean that the elevator just needs a little, a little maintenance.
Mike Carruthers
I've always thought it had something to do with like, there's too many people in here, something's wrong, somebody needs to get out.
Lee Gray
Out. That's, that's another good point. In most elevators, if there's too many people in them and it's too heavy, that's when the alarm goes off and that's the elevator. And the elevator won't leave the landing until one or more people get off. So most elevators are very good about letting you know, no, there's too many people on board, I'm not going anywhere.
Mike Carruthers
And what. These are just like random questions that come up, up as I'm thinking about my elevator rides. Whenever I get in an elevator and I push the closed door button, it doesn't really seem to do anything.
Lee Gray
So there's a lot of sort of urban myths about those. You'll hear that they don't do anything, that the companies just put them there to make people feel good. They are supposed to function. But depending on how the elevator is set up, it may not function immediately because the elevator is predicated on being at the landing for a certain period of Time to ensure that waiting passengers have an opportunity to approach and to board. But no, it is supposed to work, although that doesn't mean it always does.
Mike Carruthers
So there's basically a timer on it first, and that overrides you pushing the button to close the doors?
Lee Gray
Yes, it's predicated on waiting a certain amount of time before the doors start to close. And that's a safety feature.
Mike Carruthers
Are the people who do elevators are the same, make them and install them the same people that do escalators? Are those two different industries.
Lee Gray
Same industry? Most elevator companies, manufacturers, will manufacture elevators, escalators, and many of them also manufacture moving sidewalks and in some instances, what are often referred to as people movers at airports, the sort of automated train systems where the doors open and close very much like an elevator. Those are also, in some instances, manufactured by the same folks who build elevators.
Mike Carruthers
So when you. When you put an elevator in a building or you build a building with elevators, elevators in it, at what point does that elevator or the guts of that elevator become obsolete? How typically often do they have to be replaced and modernized?
Lee Gray
If an elevator is well maintained, it can last a long, long time. Now, this is perhaps more true of elevators built Pre World War II or just after. Modern elevators are like a lot of other modern things. Because of modern materials that are used, they don't last as long. There are in some American cities.
Mike Carruthers
Elevator.
Lee Gray
Systems that have been there 60, 70, 80 years, and they're well maintained and they work, they work fine. What tends to happen and when modernization is needed is when the elevator no longer meets the needs of the occupants of the building. In terms of speed of operation, it's mostly speed and getting people where they need to go. Sometimes it's the amenities. So a good example would be operator less elevators. Fully automatic operators first appear in the 1950s. Throughout the 50s, 60s and 70s took about 30 years. Elevator systems were replaced in buildings with the newest technology that did not require an elevator. But most of the time, if it works, you modernize or you update just bits and pieces. You might update a motor, but not the cabs and other things.
Mike Carruthers
This seems to happen like in apartment buildings, residential buildings that have old elevators in them. It's that experience of it's probably going to be pretty slow, and then when it gets to the floor, you want it to get on. It sits there for a while and the door doesn't open, and it doesn't open, and then it opens. And I've always thought, well, why can't they fix that? Why can't. When you get there. Why can't the door just open? Open.
Lee Gray
You probably could fix that depending on the building. But the issue there is. Now, obviously, I'm just speculating here. The elevator is perfectly safe. Therefore, the building owner has no, you know, no reason to improve that. Now, if it was an office building. Yes, you. It would be worked on immediately to make sure that. That the occupants of the office building, especially a class A building, that it works really quickly in apartment buildings, in theory. The idea is we're not in that big a hurry.
Mike Carruthers
Is there something about elevators that you find, like, really fascinating or odd or peculiar or something?
Lee Gray
If you made a list of the most socially awkward spaces, you know, the elevator's probably at the top of the list. And the reason for that, this is my speculation. It has to do with what an elevator car is. If it's got doors, it's got a ceiling, it's got a floor, it's got four walls. When we walk into any building, the building's filled with rooms. We can decode the rooms pretty quickly in terms of their function. And culturally, we know how we're supposed to behave and how we can navigate that space. An elevator is this tiny little room that moves. And we'd also. We don't know how it moves. It just moves. It's like magic. But especially as Americans, you know, we don't necessarily like standing that close to each other, so hence socially awkward, especially in a building where you don't know people. The example used in an apartment building, if I get to know my neighbors, then the elevator is kind of a social space. And it's very different than when you're in a place where you don't know people. And how close do I stand? Do I find my corner? Do I talk to them? You know, it's culturally weird.
Mike Carruthers
And you know, what I notice about elevators is elevators all have a smell. It smells like nothing else but elevator. But that they're all different elevator smells. And I have no idea if there's any significance to that, that or not. I've been talking with Dr. Lee Gray. He's a professor of architectural history at the University of North Carolina in Charlotte and author of a book called From Ascending Rooms to Express Elevators, A History of the Passenger Elevator. And there's a link to that book in the show notes. Hey, this was fun, Lee. Thanks for coming on.
Lee Gray
You are very welcome, Mike. I've really enjoyed talking to you.
Mike Carruthers
Next time you're having trouble sleeping, you'll. You might want to tidy up your bedroom and put on some clean sheets. It does seem that being in a clean environment can put your body at ease more quickly, leading to better sleep and clean sheets. Well, in an article In Prevention magazine, 78% of people reported feeling more excited about going to bed when they have clean sheets, 71% reported sleeping better on clean sheets, and 29% said they go to bed earlier when they have clean sheets on their bed. So if you're having trouble sleeping, clean up your room, put on some clean sheets. And that is something you should know. You know, if it weren't for our sponsors, we, well, we wouldn't be doing this. They make this podcast possible and our advertisers have some great products and services they offer. So if you hear one that sounds interesting to you, I hope you'll check it out. And usually you will find a link to whoever that advertiser is in the show notes. I'm Mike Carruthers. Thanks for listening today to something you should know. And Doug, Here we have the Limu.
Lee Gray
Emu in its natural habitat, helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. Fascinating. It's accompanied by his natural ally, Doug.
Julia Digangi
Uh, limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us.
Lee Gray
Cut the camera.
Mike Carruthers
They see us. Only pay for what you need@libertymutual.com Liberty Liberty Liberty. Liberty Savings Ferry unwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and affiliates, excludes Massachusetts. I'm often asked, as you might imagine, what podcast do I listen to? And I actually have an eclectic taste and I jump around, try different ones. But I will say that I have a couple I'm very consistent about and one of them is the Jordan Harbinger Show. It's kind of a little like something you should know, but Jordan goes in interestingly different directions. I do know that we share a lot of listeners, a lot of listeners who like this podcast. Like the Jordan Harbinger Show, Jordan is really good at getting his guests to open up and share great insights. Recently, he discussed modern romance scam tag tactics. I mean, that's the lowest of the low, but you gotta know about them so you can fight back against them. And another episode he did was about how society has engineered a generation of lonely men. The show covers a lot of great topics which, well, like I said, if you like this show, you're gonna like his show. There's so much here. Check out the Jordan Harbinger show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Podcast: Something You Should Know
Host: Mike Carruthers
Guests: Dr. Julia DiGangi (Neuropsychologist), Dr. Lee Gray (Professor of Architectural History)
Date: October 18, 2025
This episode is divided into two main explorations:
This episode offers thought-provoking perspectives on human behavior, leadership, parenthood, and the objects (like elevators) that quietly shape our daily lives. Dr. Julia DiGangi’s insights on emotional mastery and Dr. Lee Gray’s exploration of elevator history are not only informational, but also packed with practical takeaways for personal wellbeing and social understanding. Whether you’re seeking emotional wisdom or simply want to never worry about elevators again, this episode is, as always, something you should know.