Spittin’ Chiclets Episode 562: Featuring James Van Riemsdyk & Mike Modano

Released on May 12, 2025 by Barstool Sports

Introduction

In the 562nd episode of Spittin’ Chiclets, hosts Ryan Whitney, Paul Bissonnette, and Mike Grinnelli dive deep into the intense NHL playoff action, focusing primarily on the Toronto Maple Leafs' series against the Florida Panthers. Their conversations are laced with humor, candid insights, and sharp critiques, making for an engaging listen even for those who haven't tuned in.

NHL Playoffs Update

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Florida Panthers

Game 3 Recap & Analysis

• Ryan Whitney kicks off the discussion by praising the Leafs' performance in the first two periods of Game 3, stating, “Period one and two. Phenomenal. Phenomenal hockey by the Leafs.” [05:07]
• Mike Grinnelli echoes this sentiment, highlighting Leon Draisaitl’s game-changing abilities and commending the Panthers for their resilience despite early setbacks: “They just couldn't find the back of the net. But that one... brutal fucking start.” [05:32]

Game 4 Breakdown

• The conversation shifts to Game 4, where the Leafs faced unexpected challenges:
  • Grinnelli criticizes Mitch Marner’s performance, noting his lack of impact on the 5-on-5 scenarios: “Five on five, he's not nearly as much of a factor... I really hope that Matthews is able to maybe hit the net a little bit more.” [08:14]
  • Whitney discusses goalie Kyle Petrovic’s controversial goal, emphasizing the Leafs' defensive lapses: “Joseph Wall finally looked like himself... That could have easily been their game.” [17:32]

Goaltending Concerns

• Paul Bissonnette and Grinnelli delve into the struggles of Leafs’ goaltenders:
  • Grinnelli points out the inconsistency of Stuart Skinner, stressing the urgency for him to secure wins: “What do you make of his post-game scrum?... Plug that fucking hole.” [20:48]
  • Whitney expresses frustration over Petrovic’s decisions, advocating for more disciplined goalie play: “Why didn't he just stay on the post?” [45:42]

Player Performances & Team Dynamics

• Bissonnette highlights the strength and grit of the Panthers, particularly praising their defensive lineup: “Carter Verhagi isn't a physical guy... He skates faster than 90% of the league.” [24:27]
• The hosts discuss potential lineup adjustments, including the possible removal of Matthew Tkachuk from the core four, arguing that his performance under pressure is subpar: “I think there has to be something that ignites the group... so plug that fucking hole.” [19:35]

Guest Segment: James Van Riemsdyk & Mike Modano

Guest Introduction

• The episode welcomes James Van Riemsdyk, a Hockey Hall of Famer and Executive Advisor with the Minnesota Wild, and Mike Modano, providing listeners with expert insights from former NHL legends.

Playoff Strategies & Player Spotlights

• Van Riemsdyk shares his experiences and strategies for players to excel in high-pressure playoff environments, emphasizing the importance of puck possession and timing at the net: “One of the key things... is something I've tried to do again, especially with that timing.” [99:31]
• Modano reminisces about past playoff battles and the emotional roller coaster associated with high-stakes games, drawing parallels to the current series: “There is so much hatred in this series now. It's a best of three and that's why I love it.” [25:47]

Youth and Character Lessons

• A touching narrative unfolds as Merle recounts a flag football game between his son Ryder’s team and a teammate’s son. The story underscores the importance of character and sportsmanship, inspired by NFL legend Matthew Slater’s actions: “A man of character. I'm not winning like that... So Tricky Mickey was the hero.” [133:00-135:31]

Personal Anecdotes & Highlights

• Business and Brand Promotions: The hosts promote their sponsors, including Pink Whitney Vodka and Noble Footwear, offering exclusive discounts to listeners.
• James Van Riemsdyk’s Backpack: A humorous segment highlights Van Riemsdyk’s eclectic backpack filled with recovery devices and coffee, showcasing his meticulous preparation for games: “I have some different, like, recovery devices and maybe some of the coffee that I like.” [108:38]

Fan Engagement & Merchandise

• The hosts discuss their branded merchandise, including “Biz Idiot” shirts and Leaf-themed apparel, encouraging listeners to support the show by purchasing these items. Whitney humorously promotes the shirts: “What you haters out there, just remember you got to be the only ambassador hated by the fan base because ambassadors are legends.” [141:12]

Closing Remarks

As the episode wraps up, the hosts express their anticipation for upcoming playoff games, particularly Game 5, while maintaining their signature humor and camaraderie. They also highlight ongoing projects and personal milestones, such as James Van Riemsdyk’s impending fatherhood and Mike Grinnelli’s ownership of the Greensboro Gargoyles in the ECHL.

Notable Quotes:

• Ryan Whitney on Marner’s performance: “If you think you're worth $13, $14 million in free agency and you don't have the hockey sense...” [17:26]
• Mike Grinnelli on Bob’s saves: “I actually thought they were snapping around pretty good on the first three. They just couldn’t find the back of the net.” [06:03]
• James Van Riemsdyk on playoff pressure: “It's key to just have that good sort of support system and try to block it out as much as you can.” [116:58]

Conclusion

Episode 562 of Spittin’ Chiclets offers a comprehensive and spirited analysis of the NHL playoffs, enriched by expert opinions from seasoned hosts and special guests James Van Riemsdyk and Mike Modano. Through in-depth discussions, personal stories, and interactive segments, the episode delivers a multifaceted look at the triumphs and tribulations of playoff hockey, all while maintaining the show’s trademark irreverence and enthusiasm.

You can listen to this episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube. Prime Members enjoy ad-free listening on Amazon Music. For more details, visit barstool.link/schiclets.