Episode Summary: Stars on Suspense (Old Time Radio) – Episode 406: Herbert Marshall (Part 9)

Hosted by Mean Streets Podcasts

Release Date: March 27, 2025

Introduction

In Episode 406 of Stars on Suspense, the Mean Streets Podcasts bid a heartfelt farewell to Herbert Marshall, a stalwart presence on the classic radio drama series Suspense. With a remarkable twenty appearances spanning fifteen years—from 1944 to 1959—Marshall's rich British accent and commanding presence captivated audiences in a myriad of thrilling tales. This final installment features the ninth episode dedicated to his unforgettable performances, presenting three gripping narratives: "Dead Alive," "The Long Shot," and "The Man Called X."

Herbert Marshall: A Hollywood Legend on Suspense

Herbert Marshall's legacy on Suspense is nothing short of legendary. He was a foundational figure, even starring in the 1940 audition show that launched Suspense into prominence. Marshall adeptly portrayed a wide range of characters, from classic literary adaptations like Frankenstein and The Mystery of Edwin Drood to original murder mysteries and historical dramas. His final appearance is a testament to his versatility and enduring talent in the realm of radio drama.

Story 1: Dead Alive

Adapted from Wilkie Collins’ Novella

Original Air Date: March 9, 1953
Adaptation by: Sam Rolfe
Supporting Cast: Mary Jane Croft (Naomi), Lamont Johnson (Silas), Joseph Kearns (Mr. Jago), Jeannette Nolan (Letty)

Plot Summary:

Dead Alive transports listeners to early 19th-century America, inspired by the true story of the Bourne brothers—the first instance of a wrongful conviction in the United States. Herbert Marshall stars as Philip Le Frank, an English barrister seeking rest and familial connections in America. Upon his arrival, Philip becomes entangled in a local feud and a mysterious disappearance that casts suspicion on his cousins.

As tensions mount, Philip discovers unsettling secrets within Meadowcroft Farm. The presence of John Jago, the family's overseer, introduces a sinister element, culminating in suspenseful confrontations and a haunting discovery in the dark grove near the estate.

Notable Quotes:

• Philip Le Frank: "The hushed voice, the prowling step in the dead of night... Mystery and intrigue and dangerous adventure. We invite you to enjoy stories that keep you in suspense." (00:09)

• Silas: "You have murder on your soul." (Timestamp: [mid-story])

Memorable Moments:

• The eerie ambiance created by the twisted grove and the ominous presence of John Jago.

• The climactic revelation where the true culprit is unmasked, showcasing Marshall's impeccable timing and delivery.

Story 2: The Long Shot

Original Air Date: February 9, 1958
Broadcast By: Armed Forces Radio Service
Adaptation by: Sam Rolfe

Plot Summary:

In The Long Shot, Marshall portrays Raymond Hendricks, an Englishman who answers a seemingly innocuous advertisement seeking a driving companion for a cross-country trip to San Francisco. As the journey unfolds, Raymond discovers that his companion harbors a sinister motive: to commit murder and secure a hefty reward.

The narrative twists through deceit, moral dilemmas, and unexpected betrayals, drawing parallels to earlier adaptations of the story and culminating in a classic suspenseful twist that leaves listeners on the edge of their seats.

Notable Quotes:

• Narrator: "It's a great story, one that was previously presented on Suspense in 1946 with George Calores and later as a TV episode of Alfred Hitchcock Presents with Peter Lawford, and has a classic suspense twist ending." (Introduction)

• Raymond: "It was a long shot, Raymond, and it was almost a sure thing." (Climactic confrontation)

Memorable Moments:

• The tension-filled car ride where Raymond senses something amiss but struggles to piece together the truth.

• The unexpected twist at the end, a signature element of Suspense, delivered with perfect timing by Marshall.

Story 3: The Man Called X

Original Air Date: January 13th & February 17th, 1951
Broadcast By: NBC
Production by: Elliot Lewis
Adaptation by: Harold Swanton
Supporting Cast: Florence Walcott (Elise), Ben Wright (Pagon Zellschmidt), Peggy Webber, and others

Plot Summary:

The Man Called X is a serialized espionage thriller featuring Herbert Marshall as Ken Thurston, a suave and resourceful secret agent. Across multiple episodes, Ken navigates the perilous world of espionage, facing off against formidable adversaries such as Pagon Zellschmidt.

In this installment, Ken is thrust into a high-stakes mission involving sabotage pamphlets threatening global security. As he delves deeper, Ken uncovers a web of deceit, leading to confrontations in smoky Tokyo streets and abandoned warehouses. The narrative weaves through intense action sequences, philosophical banter, and intricate plot twists, showcasing Marshall's ability to embody the quintessential spy hero.

Notable Quotes:

• Philip Le Frank: "What's wrong, Philip? Your face. It's party pain." (From Dead Alive, establishing suspense) (00:09)

• Silas: "You have murder on your soul." (From Dead Alive, illustrating character depth) (mid-story)

• Ken Thurston: "The only way to deal with a spreading infection is to find the center of it and eliminate it." (Strategic thinking)

Memorable Moments:

• The dynamic interplay between Ken Thurston and Pagon Zellschmidt, highlighting Marshall's nuanced performance.

• High-tension scenes such as shootouts, narrow escapes, and the strategic dismantling of sabotage plots.

• The philosophical undertones in Ken’s dialogues, adding depth to his character beyond typical action-based storytelling.

Conclusion: Farewell to a Legend

As the episode draws to a close, Mean Streets Podcasts reflects on Herbert Marshall's invaluable contributions to Suspense. Marshall's ability to infuse each character with authenticity and intensity made him a beloved figure among old-time radio enthusiasts. His final performances in Dead Alive, The Long Shot, and The Man Called X serve as a fitting tribute to his enduring legacy in the golden age of radio drama.

Host's Final Thoughts:

"We just heard Herbert Marshall in 'Dead Alive,' 'The Long Shot,' and 'The Man Called X.' That will do it for this week's show. Thanks so much for joining me. I hope you'll be back next time for more old-time radio thrillers."

Notable Quotes Throughout the Episode

• Herbert Marshall (Opening): "Mystery and intrigue and dangerous adventure. We invite you to enjoy stories that keep you in suspense." (00:09)

• Host: "The story with the surprise ending is one of the most difficult to write yet." (Reflection on storytelling) (Near the end)

• Host: "It's a difficult form because the switch must come logically out of the characters and their behavior. But it must come suddenly, unexpectedly, and at the very end of the story you are about to hear a modern example." (Discussion on plot twists) (After story introductions)

Final Thoughts

Episode 406 of Stars on Suspense not only celebrates Herbert Marshall's illustrious career but also delivers enthralling stories that exemplify the best of old-time radio drama. Marshall's masterful performances across diverse narratives continue to resonate, offering both nostalgia and timeless suspense to new and returning listeners alike.

For those unacquainted with this episode, it serves as an inviting gateway into the world of classic radio thrillers, showcasing why Suspense remains a cornerstone of radio entertainment history.

Note: This episode was produced and directed by Elliot Lewis, with music composed by Lucian Morris and conducted by Lud Gluskin. Adaptations were crafted by Sam Rolfe and Harold Swanton, ensuring high-quality storytelling that kept audiences enthralled.