StarTalk Radio Episode Summary: "Asteroids Headed Towards Earth with Rick Binzel"
Release Date: March 25, 2025
Host: Neil deGrasse Tyson
Co-host: Chuck Nice
Guest: Professor Richard (Rick) Binzel, MIT
Introduction
In this captivating episode of StarTalk Radio, astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson teams up with co-host Chuck Nice and esteemed guest Professor Richard Binzel to delve deep into the intriguing and sometimes perilous world of asteroids threatening Earth. Professor Binzel, a retired planetary scientist from MIT and the inventor of the Torino Scale, brings a wealth of knowledge about asteroid detection, impact assessment, and the broader implications for our planet.
1. Meet Rick Binzel: The Man Behind the Torino Scale
Neil kicks off the episode by introducing Rick Binzel, highlighting his significant contributions to planetary science, including his role as a co-investigator on the OSIRIS-REx mission—the groundbreaking project that successfully returned an asteroid sample to Earth.
Notable Quote:
[04:12] Rick Binzel: “Osiris Rex was the touch and go that successfully returned an asteroid sample to the Earth.”
This mission not only marked a milestone in space exploration but also provided invaluable insights into the composition of asteroids, furthering our understanding of the solar system's building blocks.
2. Pluto, Charon, and the Mysteries of Albedo
The conversation shifts to Pluto, where Rick reminisces about his graduate school days and the pivotal discovery of Pluto's moon, Charon. By observing transits—where Charon passes in front of Pluto—Binzel was able to calculate Pluto's mass and size with greater accuracy. This led to a refined understanding of albedo, the measure of how much light a celestial body reflects.
Notable Quotes:
[09:02] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “And confess, Rick, that we got the mass for Pluto and was way littler than people wanted it to be.”
[14:17] Rick Binzel: “Albedo is a fancy name for reflectivity. Something with a low albedo doesn't reflect very much light and something with a high albedo reflects a lot of light.”
The revelation that Pluto has a higher albedo than initially thought meant that its size was overestimated when assuming lower reflectivity. This significant adjustment showcased the critical role of albedo in astronomical measurements.
3. Understanding the Torino Scale: Assessing Asteroid Threats
A major highlight of the episode is the introduction and thorough explanation of the Torino Scale, a 10-point system developed by Rick Binzel to quantify the impact risk posed by near-Earth objects (NEOs). The scale evaluates both the probability of an asteroid colliding with Earth and the potential damage it could cause.
Notable Quote:
[21:03] Rick Binzel: “The Torino scale is a 10 point scale from 0 to 10. 0 is really good and 10 is a really bad day for the dinosaurs.”
Binzel elaborates that the scale ranges from green (no threat) to red (certain impact with catastrophic consequences). This tool has become essential for astronomers and policymakers in prioritizing asteroid monitoring and potential deflection missions.
4. Current Threat Assessment: Asteroid 2024 YR4
The discussion zeroes in on the asteroid 2024 YR4, which currently holds a 3 on the Torino Scale, categorizing it as a yellow alert—astronomers should monitor it closely but there's no immediate cause for panic.
Notable Quotes:
[24:00] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “We saw that it had a 1.3% chance of hitting us. What does that mean?”
[25:46] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “Were you able to get a pre discovery image of this asteroid?”
Rick explains that the 1.3% probability stems from the limited tracking window, making it difficult to predict its exact path far into the future. Efforts are underway to locate pre-discovery images to extend the observation period and refine its orbit, which could potentially reduce the uncertainty and likelihood of impact.
5. Apophis: From Threat to Scientific Opportunity
Rick Binzel recounts the history of Apophis, another asteroid that once peaked at 4 on the Torino Scale but was later downgraded as more data became available. The upcoming close approach of Apophis in 2029 offers a unique scientific opportunity to study its composition and behavior under Earth's gravitational influence.
Notable Quotes:
[38:20] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “Tell us what's the latest about Apophis? Isn't Osiris Rex visiting Apophis?”
[42:19] Rick Binzel: “NASA has approved that the next mission for this Osiris Rex spacecraft, which is now renamed as Osiris Apex, will visit Apophis.”
The Osiris-Apex mission aims to observe Apophis as it passes Earth, providing insights into asteroid structure and resilience against tidal forces. This data is crucial for developing future asteroid deflection strategies.
6. The Quest for Planet Nine: Unveiling the Unknown
Towards the end of the episode, the trio explores the enigmatic Planet Nine, a hypothesized planet lurking in the far reaches of our solar system. While evidence for its existence is based on gravitational influences observed in the Kuiper Belt, its actual detection remains elusive.
Notable Quotes:
[46:58] Chuck Nice: “It's a place where I'm doing fine. North Cloud nine. Okay.”
[47:10] Rick Binzel: “Planet nine is just some indications in the data that there may be something even further out in our solar system that's been tugging on some of these other asteroids out there.”
The search for Planet Nine underscores the dynamic and ever-evolving nature of astronomical research, highlighting how new discoveries continually reshape our understanding of the cosmos.
7. The Significance of Asteroid Samples: Insights into Life's Origins
Reflecting on the OSIRIS-REx mission's success, Rick emphasizes the importance of studying asteroid samples to unlock secrets about the early solar system and the building blocks of life. The pristine conditions of these samples offer unparalleled information that meteorites on Earth cannot provide due to atmospheric contamination and degradation.
Notable Quotes:
[44:25] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “That was even expected though, right?”
[45:35] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “These asteroids harken from the beginning of the solar system, undisturbed by weather, erosion, contamination.”
The discovery of primitive carbon chemistry on asteroids like Bennu has profound implications for understanding the origins of life, suggesting that essential amino acids might have been delivered to Earth via celestial objects.
Conclusion: The Ongoing Battle and Journey
As the episode wraps up, Neil praises Rick Binzel for his invaluable contributions and reiterates the importance of continuous monitoring and scientific investigation to safeguard Earth from potential asteroid threats. The collaboration between NASA and international space agencies exemplifies the collective effort required to address cosmic challenges.
Notable Quotes:
[50:38] Chuck Nice: “It also works when you're looking for a job.”
[50:49] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “Because I'm a galaxy guy, you know, large scale universe guy...”
Rick Binzel leaves listeners with a sense of awe and responsibility, emphasizing that while we have made significant strides in asteroid detection and analysis, the quest for knowledge and planetary defense is far from over.
Closing Remarks
This episode of StarTalk Radio masterfully balances humor, expert insights, and scientific rigor to educate and engage listeners on the critical topic of asteroid threats and planetary science. Professor Rick Binzel's expertise provides a deeper understanding of how humanity can navigate the dangers and opportunities presented by the celestial bodies that share our solar system.
Final Quote:
[50:56] Neil deGrasse Tyson: “All right. All right. This has been StarTalk, the hazardous asteroid edition. Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. Keep looking up.”
For those eager to delve deeper into the topics discussed, subscribing to SiriusXM Podcasts+ offers ad-free listening and early access to episodes. Stay informed and inspired by the wonders of the universe with StarTalk Radio.