StarTalk Radio: Can We Predict the Future? with Charles Liu Episode Release Date: March 7, 2025

Hosts and Guests:

• Neil deGrasse Tyson – Host, Astrophysicist, Director of New York's Hayden Planetarium
• Gary O'Reilly – Co-host
• Chuck – Co-host
• Charles Liu – Guest, Professor at City University of New York, Host of the "Loonaverse" podcast

1. Introduction to Predicting the Future

Timestamp: 00:47 – 04:05

Neil deGrasse Tyson opens the discussion by highlighting the perennial fascination with predicting the future, particularly through the lens of science fiction. He reminisces about classic shows like The Jetsons and movies like Blade Runner, acknowledging that while many predictions miss the mark, accurate forecasts can provide valuable insights.

Neil deGrasse Tyson:
"Predicting the future and getting it wrong most of the time. But when you get it right, it's good." ([00:47])

Charles Liu introduces his perspective, emphasizing the role of younger scientists and innovators in shaping future technologies. He underscores that scientific models, while inherently imperfect, are essential for informed predictions and educational discourse.

Charles Liu:
"We are taking what knowledge we have now and modeling it for the future. And models are always wrong, but sometimes they're useful." ([05:14])

2. Science Fiction and Reality: The Jetsons and Blade Runner

Timestamp: 04:05 – 11:14

The conversation delves into how science fiction has shaped our expectations of the future. Tyson critiques the optimistic yet often inaccurate visions presented in The Jetsons, noting discrepancies between imagined robots and real-world advancements in automation and AI.

Neil deGrasse Tyson:
"They didn't understand that a robot can be anything that does something that you wouldn't otherwise do." ([09:03])

Chuck adds that current robots, like those in Amazon warehouses, are far more utilitarian and less humanoid than those depicted in classic sci-fi.

Chuck:
"They're all boxes just moving around. They're moving the boxes, doing stuff. Moving boxes. But they're all robots, right?" ([10:43])

The discussion transitions to Blade Runner, exploring the concept of the Turing Test and the blurred lines between human and machine intelligence. Charles Liu connects this to contemporary issues with AI, emphasizing the ongoing challenge of distinguishing authentic human emotions from machine-generated responses.

3. The Turing Test and Artificial Intelligence

Timestamp: 11:14 – 22:05

Tyson elaborates on the Turing Test, a measure of a machine's ability to exhibit intelligent behavior indistinguishable from a human. He relates it to modern AI applications, expressing concerns over the authenticity of machine interactions.

Charles Liu:
"If you can tell the difference between the responses of a machine and the responses of a human being without seeing who's behind the curtain, that determines whether a machine is truly intelligent." ([19:30])

The hosts discuss scenarios from Blade Runner where replicants fail to exhibit genuine human emotions, drawing parallels to today's AI systems like ChatGPT. They debate the implications of AI passing sophisticated tests of consciousness and intelligence, highlighting the ethical considerations and potential societal impacts.

Neil deGrasse Tyson:
"We're conducting the Turing Test in real time, but a better not." ([19:14])

4. Predictions in Neil's Book: Starry Messenger

Timestamp: 22:05 – 40:14

Neil deGrasse Tyson introduces his book Starry Messenger, particularly the chapter "Exploration and Discovery," where he makes a series of predictions for the year 2050. He acknowledges the inherent inaccuracies in such forecasts but values them as a means to reflect on progress and missteps.

Neil deGrasse Tyson:
"I'm gonna make predictions for 2050 so that in 2050 people can look back and see everything I got wrong." ([06:35])

Charles Liu and Chuck provide critical yet constructive feedback on Tyson's predictions, discussing the feasibility of turning space programs into commercial industries and the advancements in medicine through genetic profiling and AI.

5. The Nature of Exponential Growth in Technology

Timestamp: 40:14 – 52:03

The hosts explore the concept of exponential growth in technology, emphasizing how rapidly advancements can alter societal norms and capabilities. Tyson points out that exponential curves often appear vertical due to their steep ascent, making it challenging to predict their trajectory accurately.

Neil deGrasse Tyson:
"The line always looks vertical when you're at that end of the exponential." ([50:12])

Charles Liu cautions that exponential growth isn't limitless and can plateau, using historical examples like the human population to illustrate how initial predictions may not account for technological and societal adaptations.

Charles Liu:
"Sometimes the exponentials turn over. There's a period of exponential growth followed by a leveling off." ([52:34])

6. 2050 Predictions: Space Industry, Medicine, and AI

Timestamp: 40:14 – 55:24

Space Industry: Tyson predicts that by 2050, the space program will transition into a thriving space industry driven by space tourism and asteroid mining. Charles Liu challenges this, suggesting that without significant cost reductions and governmental support, such a transition may not materialize within the next three decades.

Charles Liu:
"Prices are not going to drop low enough for people to want to go into space just for the heck of it." ([42:08])

Medicine: Tyson foresees advancements in personalized medicine, where treatments are tailored to individual genetic profiles, eliminating side effects. Charles Liu expresses optimism but tempers expectations, noting that while behavioral control may advance, curing diseases entirely by 2050 remains uncertain.

Neil deGrasse Tyson:
"Medicine will be tuned to your genetic profile so that there are zero side effects." ([50:42])

Artificial Intelligence: The discussion shifts to AI's role in medicine and other fields. Tyson is bullish on AI's potential to revolutionize healthcare, while Charles Liu emphasizes the need for cautious optimism, acknowledging both the transformative benefits and the ethical dilemmas posed by AI advancements.

7. Final Predictions and Reflections

Timestamp: 55:24 – 56:48

As the episode concludes, each participant shares their final predictions:

• Chuck:
  "We are at a global tipping point with respect to democracy globally. It's either going to be that people want to govern themselves through democratic processes or that we're all so sleep that we descend into authoritarianism worldwide." ([54:21])

• Gary:
  "Desire to fully engage with climate change because the knock-on effect has influence on so many global societies. We're suffering from climate migration and rising sea levels." ([54:35])

• Charles Liu:
  "Within 25 years, there will be a professional sport played in orbit." ([56:03])

Tyson reflects on the importance of continual innovation and the unpredictable nature of technological progress, reinforcing the theme that while predicting the future is fraught with challenges, it remains a vital exercise for understanding and shaping the trajectory of human civilization.

Notable Quotes:

• Neil deGrasse Tyson ([00:47]):
  "Predicting the future and getting it wrong most of the time. But when you get it right, it's good."

• Charles Liu ([05:14]):
  "We are taking what knowledge we have now and modeling it for the future. And models are always wrong, but sometimes they're useful."

• Chuck ([54:21]):
  "We are at a global tipping point with respect to democracy globally. It's either going to be that people want to govern themselves through democratic processes or that we're all so sleep that we descend into authoritarianism worldwide."

• Gary O'Reilly ([54:35]):
  "Desire to fully engage with climate change because the knock-on effect has influence on so many global societies. We're suffering from climate migration and rising sea levels."

• Charles Liu ([56:03]):
  "Within 25 years, there will be a professional sport played in orbit."

Conclusion: In this enlightening episode of StarTalk Radio, Neil deGrasse Tyson, alongside co-hosts Gary O'Reilly and Chuck, and guest Charles Liu, navigates the intricate landscape of future predictions. Through the exploration of science fiction, technological advancements, and societal trends, the discussion underscores the complexities inherent in forecasting the future. While acknowledging the frequent inaccuracies of predictions, the conversation highlights the indispensable role of such exercises in driving innovation and fostering informed discourse about humanity's path forward.

Keep Looking Up!