
What is time? Is it infinite? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comedian Chuck Nice answer questions all about time. Does time even exist?
Loading summary
Chuck Nice
AT T customers Switching to T Mobile has never been easier.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
We'll pay off your existing phone and.
Chuck Nice
Give you a new one free all on America's largest 5G network. Visit t mobile.com carrierfreedom to switch today.
T-Mobile Announcer
Pay off up to 650 via virtual prepaid MasterCard in 15 days. Free phone up to 830 via 24 monthly bill credits plus tax qualifying port in trade in service on Go 5G next and credit required. Contact us before canceling entire account to continue bill credits or credit stop and balance and required finance agreement is due.
Chuck Nice
Oh it feels great to make progress on a language Learning new words and phrases Are you feeling ready to make conversation this holiday season? Share a new language with your loved ones. A lifetime membership to Rosetta Stone makes a meaningful present for friends and family. My brother vowed to move to Spain recently and he's always walking around now saying things like in Espana, la comida es deliciosa. And soon the two of us will have a secret language that everybody who speaks Spanish knows. Start learning today with Rosetta Stone's Lifetime Membership Holiday Special. Visit rosettastone.com startalk for unlimited access to 25 language courses for the rest of your life. Available for a short time@Rosetta Stone.com startalk.
Diablo 4 Announcer
With incredible new features and upgrades, there's never been a better time to armor up Critically acclaimed action RPG Diablo 4. Get ready to continue the epic story in your battle against evil in the new expansion Vessel of Hatred. As darkness spreads through the lands of Sanctuary, it's up to you to fight back the encroaching corruption. Reap the benefits of massive updates to character progression, loot systems difficulties and tons of added activities. Face off against new and iconic bosses teeming with the spoils of Sanctuary. Plus harness formidable powers of the jungle with the all new Spirit Born class now yours to customize and progress alongside five other iconic classes. Embark on the epic journey solo or with friends. You'll quickly understand why Diablo 4 has been called one of the best action RPGs of the last decade by PC Gamer Forge your own path through hell torn lands of Sanctuary. Save 35% off Diablo 4 and Vessel of Hatred in the expansion bundle today. Rated M for mature.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now. This is StarTalk. I'm your host Neil Degrasse Tyson. I'm an astrophysicist at the American Museum of Natural History right here in New York City and I also serve as Director of the Hayden Planetarium. We are cosmic queries. Startalk after hours. I like to think of it. I would never do cosmic queries alone. I get Chuck, nice to join me. Yes, Chuck, Nice. Comic.
Chuck Nice
Uchucknicecomic. That's me. How are you?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That's what they call you in the Twitterverse.
Chuck Nice
In the Twitterverse. I love that word. Twitterverse.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I can put a verse on everything, and it is. And we take ownership of it in the universe.
Chuck Nice
There you go.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah. Yes. The chuckiverse.
Chuck Nice
That's scary. The chuckiverse is scary.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And so thanks for being on.
Chuck Nice
Absolutely.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And you got a TV show where you just bust into people's homes.
Chuck Nice
Yes.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That's crazy.
Chuck Nice
I love it.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
How did he even let you do that?
Chuck Nice
You know, I ask myself that question every time I'm on it, like, how did this happen? But, yes, the show is called Home, Strange Home, and I pretty much invade the homes of unsuspecting people, show up with cameras, and they take me on a tour of their weird, wonderful house.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And you just talk about them. And seriously, I do Home and garden tv. That's my sister's favorite TV show.
Chuck Nice
I love your sister.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I mean, her favorite TV network. And she'll find you for sure.
Chuck Nice
I love it.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
So we got questions. The topic today is on time.
Chuck Nice
Time and timekeeping. Here's the question. All right. Is time infinite? Okay. And so I'm going to. This is Scott, and this is Milad. These two questions. One, is time infinite? And so I might as well ask Scott's question along with that, which is, what is time? And now here's the third part of that. I believe time doesn't exist. So that's the third part. I just want to know if I'm right or wrong.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
The theory, according to Chuck, time does not exist.
Chuck Nice
That's my theory. That's my personal theory, is that time doesn't exist. But the question is we have evolutionary.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Theory, quantum theory, and Chuck's theory. Yes. Just to put this in context, what you really mean is you have a hypothesis.
Chuck Nice
I have a hypothesis really exists. Because it's really not a theory. All right, So I have a hypothesis that time does not exist.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Einstein described time as being defined to motion. Look. Simple. Wow.
Chuck Nice
That Einstein dude was kind of deep.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
He was deep. He was deep. And in physics, what we really care about is not what is true. Yes, that's fun over a beer. But what we really care about is how does the universe reveal itself to us in ways that we can calculate and then understand what we See, and make predictions about what is yet to be tested. And so we're, we're dependent on our interaction with the universe. And so if time is a thing, if we can define it in a way to make motion look simple, we're all over it. And so time is not infinite. Time, as we have defined it, had a beginning, and that was the Big Bang. If it were infinite, it would have go to the infinite past.
Chuck Nice
Correct.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
But there's a stopwatch that got started at the Big Bang. The birth of space and time, matter and energy. Now, as far as we know, we're going to expand forever into the future. And if that's the case, time is what we call semi infinite. It's infinite in one direction, but not the other. It's an actual math term. Semi infinite.
Chuck Nice
Semi infinite, Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And so it's like a number line. No, like a number line.
Chuck Nice
Like a number. You start at one point and then boom, you just keep going.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Semi infinite. Half infinite. Like a semicircle is half a circle, right? Yeah. Semi infinite. You're half infinite.
Chuck Nice
Is that good God, that sounds so counterintuitive. You are semi infinite.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You are only half an infinity, right?
Chuck Nice
You're only half of infinity. It's like, that's really cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And so in that as far as we know, time will continue going forward forevermore.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And so there you have it now, the Chuck theory, Right, along with quantum theory.
Chuck Nice
My hypothesis.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes, thank you. Is that time does not exist.
Chuck Nice
It doesn't exist.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And what's your evidence for this?
Chuck Nice
Okay, so what my think of it this way. If there were absolutely nothing, then there would be nothing to measure and therefore time wouldn't exist. That's what I'm saying.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Oh, okay. So what you're saying is time is a construct of the places where there are things to measure it.
Chuck Nice
Exactly. That's my point.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I'll give you that.
Chuck Nice
Oh, really? Yeah, I'm right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, okay, I'm going with.
Chuck Nice
I'm right. I'm going with. Let me explain. I must explain. No, don't explain. It's too good. I love it too much. I'm going everywhere. Now, Neil Degrasse Tyson said my hypothesis was right, so screw you, buddy. I can't wait to get to a beer tonight.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right.
Chuck Nice
By the way, you know time doesn't exist, right?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right, here it is. We measure time with phenomena that repeat, right?
Chuck Nice
Okay.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
The clock dial turns. Well, initially it was astronomical, referencing the sun goes around.
Chuck Nice
I mean, earth goes around.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That's what we thought. So the sun would go around the Earth, the moon goes around the Earth, this sort of thing. And you'd keep, you'd reckon time in these ways. And then we found you could track time to a vibrating atom. Something's got to repeat to measure time. So you could pose the following comment, that if there exist places where nothing repeats, then you cannot reckon the passage of time with any kind of reliability. Not only that, getting back to the Chuck hypothesis, you can imagine a universe, or perhaps outside of our universe, where there is no matter, there is no space, there is no energy, it's just that which is not those three.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And if it is that which is not those three, and all three of those conspire to allow us to measure time with tools, then where there aren't those three, time would in fact have no meaning.
Chuck Nice
Exactly.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That's exactly what you were thinking.
Chuck Nice
That's what I'm thinking. Awesome.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
God, Chuck. So I'll give you that, Chuck.
Chuck Nice
Yes.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
But that doesn't mean it doesn't have meaning in our universe, but in some meta place.
Chuck Nice
In some meta place. Yes.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You got it. Yeah, I'll grant you that. Yeah. So you've been dropping questions in my lap and that last one was a good one. I have more to add to it. What was it?
Chuck Nice
Yeah, the question really simply was how would a space faring people keep time?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah. And so the good one, my favorite example of that is the Apollo astronauts that went to the moon, who are they talking to?
Chuck Nice
Talking to mission control of Houston.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And Houston. It's Houston time.
Chuck Nice
It's Houston time. That's hilarious.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
They just say, hello, Pakistan. So they kept time. They kept Houston time. And on Mars, right. Mars actually has its own clock, which is slightly different from Earth clock. The Mars day is slightly longer than Earth day. And so that matters because the rovers that are there need sunlight to drive their solar panels. And so Mars professionals who study Mars keep a wristwatch that is Mars time and not Earth time. And they slowly migrate out of phase from one another. And. Yeah, because if you don't match perfectly, you slowly, slowly, right. You slowly migrate.
Chuck Nice
You drop out of phase.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You drop out of phase. And so astronomers on Earth studying Mars are on Mars time with sunrise and sunset at the location of the rover that they're studying. That's cool.
Chuck Nice
That's very cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah, yeah. And on the International Space Station, each module is put up by a, is supported by a different country. Country and nationality. Their time is the time, but from their home base. So the Russian capsule is like Moscow time, right. Not New York time.
Chuck Nice
So there's five different time zones on the International Space Station.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
The International Space Station. Oh, that's. And here's the question of all questions. If a time zone is separated by sort of degrees of longitude every 15 degrees, multiply 15 by 24, what do you get?
Chuck Nice
Oh, God. I couldn't do that.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
This would not take God to answer. It just takes the times table.
Chuck Nice
So let me see. That's 240 plus five times 24.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes.
Chuck Nice
So it's 120. So 240 and 120. So that's nice.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Chuck gets it. It comes in at 360. So all 360 degrees of the Earth are split into 24 time zones, basically at 15 degrees of width. Right. So as you crawl east, west, you can change your time zone. As you come near the poles, the time zones get narrower and narrower and narrower. And on the Pole, every single time zone converges. So what time does Santa keep on his watch?
Chuck Nice
I'm gonna say pole time.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Pole time. It's Hammer time. Now we got pole time. Yeah, you'd have to invent some time. There is no day. There's six months of sunlight, six months of dark. The concept of a rotating Earth loses meaning on the Pole, where there are no time zones.
Chuck Nice
That's weird. That's great.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah, very cool. What else you got?
Chuck Nice
All right, let's move on here. Okay, this is a good one.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Oh, by the way. Oh, I got to add one other thing. If you had an actual colony, space colony that was nowhere near Earth and you didn't care about Earth, then you're not dependent on the rotation of the Earth or daylight or nighttime. You can create whatever kind of days you want. Studies in psychology showed that if you lock people away and had them set up their own cycles, that their day is today. Typically 25 hours.
Chuck Nice
Really?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Five and a half. That's why you never quite feel right. Like the day is always a little bit ahead of you.
Chuck Nice
Yeah.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
It's because you really want a 25 hour.
Chuck Nice
You need an extra hour.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You need an extra couple hours.
Chuck Nice
And I thought I was just hungover.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay, here is long ago, long ago, Earth's day was longer than it is today. Yeah, we've been. We've been slowing down.
Chuck Nice
Okay. Because of the rotation.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah. Did I say longer? I'm sorry.
Chuck Nice
We had a faster, faster day.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay, but go on.
Chuck Nice
Okay, so now, here. I don't understand this question. And you're gonna have take me to school on this one. Summarize the timelessness of a Photon.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Oh, beautiful. That is beautiful. Are you ready?
Chuck Nice
I'm ready.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Are you ready?
Chuck Nice
I'm ready for this.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, you're not ready. I don't think you're ready.
Chuck Nice
You sound like Beyonce.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I don't think you're.
Chuck Nice
Are you ready for this? Okay.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Are you ready for this?
Chuck Nice
Tell me. Are you ready? I'm ready.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, you're not ready.
Chuck Nice
I'm not ready.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No. Tell me again.
Chuck Nice
Okay, I'm ready.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right. You should know, if you study relativity, Einstein's relativity, that as you increase your speed, time ticks more slowly for you than it does for anyone who's watching you.
Chuck Nice
Right?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right? This is the relativity of time. This is well known. We've measured this. It's not just your clock that's ticking slower. Your metabolism is unfolding more slowly. Your brain synapses firing more slowly. Everything about you is slowing down. All right? As you travel faster and faster, get closer and closer to the speed of light, you age more and more and more slowly. Time ticks more and more slowly for you.
Chuck Nice
Okay?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
If you hit the speed of light, which we don't know how to do yet, but if you ever hit the speed of light, then time stops.
Chuck Nice
Stops.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Photons, which is the carrier of light. Right. Exists at the speed of light. It doesn't accelerate from zero to speed of light in 3.4 seconds.
Chuck Nice
Correct.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
It exists at the speed of light. And because it exists at the speed of light, any watch that it's carrying never ticks. Which means if you are the photon, become the photon. If you are. This is not a proton. Now, particle in the nucleus of an atom. The photon. The particle of light. If you are a photon and you are emitted from across the universe, you will be absorbed. You will slam into whatever you are destined to hit as far as you are concerned, instantaneously. That's correct.
Chuck Nice
Right?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Because no time would have.
Chuck Nice
Because no time's right. Because you can't. Because at that speed where you exist, that speed, time has stopped.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Stopped.
Chuck Nice
So for you, time doesn't exist.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Time does not exist.
Chuck Nice
Dude, this is mind blowing.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Time does not exist.
Chuck Nice
Oh, yo, man.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay, now, here's.
Chuck Nice
Now, wait a minute. You gotta give me a second, man.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You gotta absorb that now.
Chuck Nice
That was great. Anybody got some weed? I need some weed Right there.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Is that good for you?
Chuck Nice
Cause that was cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Some people would have requested it in advance of this. Let's all move to Colorado and get the weed.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Exactly. So it's why we knew that the neutrino could not be traveling at the speed of light. Because the neutrino actually changes species midway.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
There's one kind of neutrino that can become a different kind of neutrino species. How would it know to do that unless it's keeping track of time?
Chuck Nice
Exactly.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
It knew to do this. It does that at a predictable interval. It can only do that if it's carrying a stopwatch.
Chuck Nice
Wow.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
So we knew the neutrinos were not.
Chuck Nice
Traveling at speed because if they were.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
They would never change.
Chuck Nice
Wow.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
They would not change.
Chuck Nice
This begs the question. I'm going to take Todd Smith's question one step further. So if you surpass the speed of light, does time go backwards?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes.
Chuck Nice
No. No.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes.
Chuck Nice
Get out of here.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And we invented a particle that we would call. If we found a particle that did that, we have a name for it. They're called tachyons, from the Greek root for the tachometer. Comes from that. It means fast.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay. And so this proposed species of particles only ever exists faster than light, and they can travel infinitely fast. They would go backwards in time. If I sent you a tachyon signal, you would get it before I sent.
Chuck Nice
Before you sent it to Correct.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Imagine messing with the tachyons. Oh, it's fake. Never mind. It's like, oh, what are we gonna do?
Chuck Nice
Wow.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah. So tachyons travel faster than light and move backwards in time, and it's perfectly consistent with Einstein's relativity. We're cool with that. We just never found them before.
Chuck Nice
Awesome.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
We don't know if they exist, but it works on paper.
Chuck Nice
All right, all right. Okay.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Got time for one more question before we start.
Chuck Nice
Mark Swift. Why hasn't time been decimalized?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Ooh, it was decimalized.
Chuck Nice
What?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes. In the French Revolution. Did you know they had decimal time in the French. The French. Did you know that the metric system is conjoined with the French Revolution?
Chuck Nice
I did not know that.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
The French said, as long as we're taking stuff up, let's fix this crap. These fractions, this stuff that came out of England with the pints and the quartz and the this and the fifth and the dram and all of this. So they decimalized everything. And they got a little carried away because they wanted to decimalize time. So they turned a day into 10 hours, an hour into 100 minutes, and a minute into 100 seconds. That's correct.
Chuck Nice
So under that, you get a 10 hour day.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes, a 10 hour day. So they decimalize time, and if you do it right, if you do the math, the number of seconds in a decimalized day is about the Same like within 10% of the number of seconds in a normal day. So you wouldn't have to do much to redefine the second. You just have to get people accustomed to decimalize hours and minutes. But it failed. It failed. The meter stuck and other things stuck, but not decimal time.
Chuck Nice
Look at that.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And I like my base 60 my sexageimal time from the Babylonians. What do you got against 60? We are StarTalk Radio when we come back, More cosmic Queries.
Chuck Nice
Foreign T customers Switching to T Mobile has never been easier.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
We'll pay off your existing phone and.
Chuck Nice
Give you a new one free all on America's largest 5G network. Visit t mobile.com carrierfreedom to switch today.
T-Mobile Announcer
Pay off up to 650 via virtual prepaid MasterCard in 15 days. Free phone up to 830 via 24 monthly bill credits plus tax qualifying porting trade in service on go 5G next and credit required. Contact us before canceling entire account to continue bill credits or credit stop and balance and required finance agreement is due.
Kia Announcer
If you're ready to elevate your driving experience, the first ever Kia K4 is worth a closer look. It combines style and performance with a sleek, futuristic design featuring star map, LED headlights and an available panoramic display for unforgettable looks. SiriusXM comes standard in every Kia K4, bringing you closer to what you love. Plus, with an available 190 horsepower turbocharged engine, the Kia K4 delivers everything driving enthusiasts crave. Learn more at kia.com K4 did you.
Greenlight Announcer
Know adults with financial literacy skills have 82% more wealth than those who don't? From swimming lessons to piano classes, as parents we invest in so many things to enrich our kids lives. But how much are we investing in their future financial success? With Greenlight, you can teach your kids essential skills like earning, saving and investing, giving them the tools for financial confidence. This investment costs less than an after school treat at Starbucks. Start prioritizing their financial education today with Greenlight. Invest in their future@greenlight.com podcast.
Chuck Nice
Hello, I'm Vinki Baroque Allen and I support StarTalk on Patreon. This is StarTalk with Neil DeGrasse Tyson.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
This is StarTalk. I'm Neil DeGrasse Tyson, your personal and private astrophysicist in studio here in New York City with Chuck Nice. Yes, you're with me on my Cosmic Queries part of the show. That's right, you've called questions from the Internet.
Chuck Nice
Yes sir.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
From our website@startalkradio.net and on Twitterverse. Tartalkradio. Where else? Google. We're everywhere.
Chuck Nice
Yeah, we got Google, we got Facebook.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You name it, you name it, we're there.
Chuck Nice
Pinterest, YouTube. I mean, we're not taking questions from there, but we're still there.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
We're still working it. All right, so what do you got for me? All right, we're talking about time reckoning, I guess. Yeah.
Chuck Nice
Yeah. So I think. All right, here's a funny question. So this is from Jeff Sloan, and Jeff says, just an interesting thought that I had that I would like you to explore or completely debunk. If objects moving faster than the speed of sound can cause a sonic boom, is it at all possible that the Big Bang was a result of something traveling faster than the speed of light? If I'm correct, please provide an address where I can pick up my Nobel Peace Prize.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
First of all, the Peace Prize is not given for discoveries in physics. That would be the Nobel Physics Prize.
Chuck Nice
Aha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Just to clarify that.
Chuck Nice
There you go, Jeff. Sorry, buddy. No Peace Prize for you. No matter what.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No matter what. Occasionally, a scientist can win a Peace Prize, but it's rare. It usually goes to a politician in power.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Or a dissident in power. Right, Right. So what do you want? So he wants to know if you can get a sonic boom. A light boom.
Chuck Nice
Yes, Basically, a light boom is what he's talking about.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
The answer is yes. It's called Cherenkov radiation.
Chuck Nice
Dude, you are killing me.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah.
Chuck Nice
Yes.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
If you go travel, if you travel faster than light, there is the light equivalent to a sonic boom, where the light pulse builds up on itself and it's a flash of light, and it's called Cherenkov radiation. Now, but since you can never travel faster than light, you might ask, how does one come up with this stuff?
Chuck Nice
Exactly.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Here's how it works. If you have light traveling through water, transparent water, light travels slower through water than through a vacuum. It travels. So let's start. It's fastest in a vacuum. Travels a little slower going through air. Travels a little slower going through water. Travels even slower going through glass. Travels even slower going through diamond.
Chuck Nice
Okay. And of course, that is because it is both a wave and a particle.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah. It's trying to get through the meter. You gotta get through them. And in fact, the diamond, I remember my number. It's 40% as fast in a diamond as in a vacuum. Wow. Yes. It's slow. That's a huge difference. That's what makes diamonds so cool. So if you put facets in the diamond at the right angles, at the correct angles. Because the right angle would be 90 degrees at the correct angles. Because what we call the index of refraction is so large, because light travels so slowly in a diamond that it bends back on itself multiple times within the angles that you can create on your ring, and then it shows up again in a different direction. So that's why a diamond looks like it sparkles. Because if it was only light coming from where the light came from, you say, well, that's just the light I'm looking at. But if it comes from a new angle, you say, hey, that diamond is sparkling, is talking to me.
Chuck Nice
Right?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
So now you have light going through all these media. Now you send a particle through there faster than that speed, that will create a mini sonic boom. Except it's not sound. It's light. A mini light boom. And it was first described by the physician named Cherenkov. And he won a Nobel Prize for this discovery.
Chuck Nice
Look at that.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
So tell him the Nobel Prize has already been claimed.
Chuck Nice
It's already been. Sorry, Jeff. Your prize has been claimed. You were right. But somebody beats you to the punch.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Wait, wait. But let me get back to the Big Bang. So the Big Bang was an expansion of the universe faster than life, but it's not the universe expanding faster than light in a medium.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
It is the very fabric of space and time itself expanding. And you don't get Cherenkov radiation for that from that.
Chuck Nice
Okay, right. Because it's actually happening in the vacuum, which is space.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Well, no, I mean, all of space is the explosion. It's not a vacuum within the space.
Chuck Nice
Oh, okay. So the space itself is the explosion.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Is the explosion. Exactly.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Duh. Look at that.
Chuck Nice
That's too. That's awesome.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay.
Chuck Nice
All right. All right, let's move on. Okay, I love this question, too. This is Theo Potter. What would actually happen to the planet if. Stupid. If Superman made the world spin in the opposite direction like in the 1978 movie? I'm assuming our gravity would shift and time would not rewind. Okay, so now let's just say, for instance, you can spin the Earth backwards. Okay, what are the results?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right, so while Superman was flying around the Earth the opposite way, and we saw the Earth slow down. Well, okay, The Earth is going. If you're at the equator, you're moving a thousand miles an hour on the rotation path that the Earth brings you. If you slow down from 1,000 miles an hour to zero. Excuse me, if you're not wearing a seatbelt. Connected to Earth, you're going to fall over and roll due east at 1,000 miles an hour.
Chuck Nice
So you mean the whole Earth, Everything on Earth.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Everything on Earth is not bolted, would fall over and roll due east commensurate with the speed that it had going east west at the beginning of this, Santa would be fine, right?
Chuck Nice
Cause he's up on pole time on pole time. And he's chilling.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
He's chilling on pole time. So everyone would just fall over and then he stopped earth and then spun it back and you'd fall, but you'd roll back the other way. So we'd be completely battered from this process and nothing would have happened to time and our gravity would remain exactly the same.
Chuck Nice
So basically nothing would have happened to time. Nothing happens to gravity. We're just in a huge planetary auto accident.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Auto accident. A train wreck of an auto accident. Yes. And so right, right now, by the way, you're a little lighter on the equator because of the centrifugal force of the rotating earth, but not enough that's going to matter. You're a couple of ounces lighter. So if it stopped turning, you'd be just a little heavier, but nothing that anyone would notice. We got to come back to start talk cosmic queries with Chuck Knights. We'll see you in a moment.
Chuck Nice
At and T customers switching to T Mobile has never been easier.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
We'll pay off your existing phone and.
Chuck Nice
Give you a new one free. All on America's largest 5G network. Visit t mobile.com carrierfreedom to switch today.
T-Mobile Announcer
Pay off up to $650 via virtual prepaid MasterCard in 15 days. Free phone up to $830 via 24 monthly bill credits plus tax qualifying, porting trade in service on Go 5G next and credit required. Contact us before canceling entire account to continue bill credits or credit stop and balance and required finance agreement is due.
Kia Announcer
If you're ready to elevate your driving experience, the first ever Kia K4 is worth a closer look. It combines style and performance with a sleek, futuristic design. Featuring Starma headlights and an available panoramic display for unforgettable looks. SiriusXM comes standard in every Kia K4, bringing you closer to what you love. Plus, with an available 190 horsepower turbocharged engine, the Kia K4 delivers everything driving enthusiasts crave. Learn more at kia.comk4 did you know.
Greenlight Announcer
That parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families with Greenlight, you Can set up chores automate allowance and keep an eye on your kids spending with real time notifications, kids learn to earn, save, and spend wisely. And parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money. With guardrails in place. Sign up for Greenlight today@Greenlight.com podcast.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
We're back on StarTalk Radio Cosmic Queries. I'm Neil Degrasse Tyson, your home astrophysicist, with Chuck Nice. Yes, Chucky baby tweeting at Chuck Nice comics.
Chuck Nice
That's correct.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yeah. So we. At the. At the intermission, we were talking about Superman's feet, right? Not his feet, but his feet of.
Chuck Nice
Spinning the earth backwards.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Thank you. Not his anatomical feet. He spun the earth backwards, reversing time.
Chuck Nice
So theopter had said, you know, wanted to know what would happen if the earth actually went backwards. And you answered that. But Clarissa Wegner actually says, at Theo, I think what happened was that Superman didn't reverse the spin of the earth. He was just going so fast that he himself went back into time and was able to do whatever he had to do. So.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Oh, okay.
Chuck Nice
So not the earth spun backwards. He went backwards into time.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay, so this is who now?
Chuck Nice
This is Clarissa.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
So. So Clarissa is talking to Theo, and we ain't even in that. We're.
Chuck Nice
They are having their own conversation.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I'm sorry, Theo, I didn't get your answer fast enough to get other readers jumping in on it. So I remember when I saw that movie, because my girlfriend at the time, you know, I'm people's own astrophysicist, right? So they asked me the questions. So she said, could that really happen? She asked. At no time else in that movie did she ask me if what she saw could actually happen. Like, could a man in blue pantyhose fly? That question did not come up. Can he block bullets off his chest? That question did not come up. But can he go back in time? That came up. So could he have been taking himself back in time? But why would we watch Earth slow down, stop in reverse? You can't go back in time yourself.
Chuck Nice
Okay.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And. Well, unless back in time, we are revisiting the earth at that rotational phase. Okay, now that I think about it, yeah, I can let that go.
Chuck Nice
So Clarissa has some legs here.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
He is not turning earth backwards. He is going back in time, rewinding the clock.
Chuck Nice
Right?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
So Earth didn't actually stop.
Chuck Nice
Right? That's what Clarissa is saying.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I gotta give her that.
Chuck Nice
Clarissa's onto something.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Clarissa, you're onto something.
Chuck Nice
Look at that.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I'll give you that. Okay, now, why she would do that for Lois Lane? That's a bigger question.
Chuck Nice
Oh, that's rough.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Sorry, sorry.
Greenlight Announcer
Cold blooded.
Chuck Nice
Okay. That was cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, we need Lois. We need Lois. Sorry.
Chuck Nice
All right, cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Plus, I met Superman in the comic. You didn't see this comic? I was in the comic. I was in the Superman comic. Me and Superman were chilling.
Chuck Nice
Yo, man, I think that's so cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
But Lois Lane was not there. I didn't meet Lois Lane. Maybe I feel differently about her if I got to know her as a.
Chuck Nice
Person, you know, I'm just glad that you didn't meet her, because that would have been awkward. All right, here we go. Yeah, I've been hearing a lot about this. This is from Jordan Navarro. I've been hearing a lot about this theory that if we place a giant mirror 22 light years away from away and point it at an extremely efficient telescope, we would see things happening in real time, in the past. That's what he's saying. So since the mirror is 22 light years away, wouldn't it still take that light 22 years to travel back to the mirror? So I think what he's saying is, if you were to put a mirror 22 light years away from Earth, point it back at Earth, would you be able to see Earth 22 years in the past?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, you would see it 44 years in the past. Right.
Chuck Nice
Because it's got to go there and come back.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Do the math.
Chuck Nice
Yeah, you got to look at it, and then it's got to come back. Back to your eyes.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Exactly. So you see yourself in a mirror not as you are, but as you once were 2 billionths of a second ago.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
If you're a foot away.
Chuck Nice
If you're a foot away.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Light travels a foot every billionth of a second. One foot per nanosecond, if you want to be exact. We came up with the number 22. I don't know. Stick a mirror out there, let the light go, and come back. You will see however many light years away. Double that, because it's the round trip time. That's how far in the past you were viewing events on Earth.
Chuck Nice
So you're viewing the events that you're actually looking at the past in real time for you.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That's exactly what's happening. That beam is on its way to the mirror, and it's on its way back, and you're catching it.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That's all. And by the way, we see other objects in the past. Because their light has just reached us. So this is not magical thinking.
Chuck Nice
Right.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
My favorite is a galaxy that's 65 light years away. I'm sorry, 65 million light years away. It's a galaxy called M100 M100 M165 million light years away. And guess what they're seeing on Earth right now? If they had a telescope big enough.
Chuck Nice
What?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
The extinction of the dinosaurs.
Chuck Nice
Look at that. That's so cool.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
That beam of light that conveys the information that they got slammed is just now reaching them. It's just reaching them because they're 65 million light years away. And when did the dinosaurs go extinct on Earth?
Chuck Nice
Six, five million years ago.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You got it. We hardly got through any of these questions. Yeah.
Chuck Nice
So, you know, we got through a goodly amount. But you know what? Because we're gonna try to get to as many as possible now. We're gonna call this our lightning round.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Lightning round. So now you want me to answer fast?
Chuck Nice
It's just. Yeah, you know. Well, look, if we get to it, we get to it.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right, I'll try. I'll try.
Chuck Nice
All right, so let's jump right into it here. We got the lightning round, the lightning round.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I need a bell.
Chuck Nice
Let's go, Steven. Kevin Castaneda says, is the perception of time universal, or do we all perceive time differently? I wonder if a house fly and other organisms perceive time to be quicker, so shorter lifespan, shorter time span. I mean, do you. So you know what I mean?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Like, it's fun to think about other life forms that live shorter or longer as perceiving time differently, but typically when we do that, we are humanizing their life. So one dog year is seven human years. Yeah. Dogs don't care about humans, but the passage of time, as measured by the atomic vibrations of atoms within them, is the same for everyone.
Chuck Nice
Okay.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Oh, yeah.
Chuck Nice
So that's it. On an atomic level, that's it. That's it. No difference.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You can slow it down, speed it up with relativity, but otherwise, if you put the frog and the mayfly and the human and the elephant together in a room, the passage time is the same.
Chuck Nice
I got you. And that makes great sense for dogs because that means a dog would be licking its butt for about two months.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Total out of its life if it were a human. Yeah, right.
Chuck Nice
Okay, here we go.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Keep going.
Chuck Nice
Samir Schuman, would time exist without motion?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No. Next question. Oh, well, no, it could exist. You could never measure it.
Chuck Nice
Gotcha.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
And not only that, you'd have to be able to Measure it with motion that repeats. If it's motion that's non repeats, you'd have no real way to measure it. Okay, all right, got it. Next.
Chuck Nice
Here is Tom Shilson and Tom Shilson asks, is there any evidence.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No. Next. Lightning round.
Chuck Nice
You're good at this.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Oh, man. Man.
Chuck Nice
Okay, no. Is there any evidence that time is broken into little bits? Now this guy, he's going on some space time continuum trip now. Man. So here's Tom says, can time be broken into little bits?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes.
Chuck Nice
What?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes. I said no. But the answer is yes. All of our understanding of the nature of reality tell us that time is quantized on the smallest scales. It is quantized so that time, it does not pass continuously. But there's the smallest possible unit of time you can measure and you need quantum physics to recognize that. So yes, time gets quantized.
Chuck Nice
Oh, man. We don't have time for my follow up question.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Next.
Chuck Nice
Okay, here I gotta ask my question.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
This is the lightning round. Go. I've done a lightning round. You go.
Chuck Nice
All right, here we go. Joey Carasone. Joey says if like.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Joey.
Chuck Nice
Hey, Joey. Joey. If light can't escape a black hole, how would time be affected inside the black hole? So now you got a force that is stronger. The gravity is stronger than light itself.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
As you fall into a black hole, time ticks more slowly for you and you look out to the rest of the universe. And the rest of the universe goes by quickly. In fact, as you descend to that cosmic abyss, moments go by for you and trillions of years go by for the universe itself. You will outlive the universe in your descent to the center of a black hole. Next.
Chuck Nice
Whoa, dude, that's awesome.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Okay, enlightening. Round. There's no time to comment on whether it's awesome.
Chuck Nice
There is no comments in lightning round. Okay, here we go. If you were living in an era without time keeping as we know it, how would you map out time?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
I would map out time by asking what happens before what. So you're a baby before you're an adolescent. You can sequence events even if you cannot measure the interval between those events. And that way you get some sense of the ordering of life.
Chuck Nice
So whatever is measurable, that's what you use to measure?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, you don't even measure. You say this happened before that.
Chuck Nice
Well, that's what I measure. Whatever is a sequence, that's what you use, right?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
You just sequence it. And so, yeah, so that's what you do.
Chuck Nice
All right, let's move on. Next. Danish Memon says is the universe necessary for time to exist? For example, was time present within whatever came before for the universe?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Time as we have defined it exists only within this universe. If we go outside of our universe, we'll have to think up something else to keep track of things. Maybe there's some meta time that we can think of, just the way we can think of a multiverse, a word bigger than the word universe itself. Maybe we are longing for that word, such as meta time, that can accommodate our measuring needs when we exit this universe in which we're born. Next.
Chuck Nice
Jeez, that was good, man. You're just making this stuff up.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
No, we're running down. Quick. I got one last one.
Chuck Nice
All right, here we go. Here we go.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Knock it out.
Chuck Nice
Is there a place in the universe where you could still see the Big Bang happening? In other words, can you still see the Big Bang?
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Yes, we see it. Now. You look far enough away. The light from the Big Bang, From a distance 13.7 billion light years away is only now just reaching us. Everybody looking in every direction, look. If you look far enough away, you see the birth of the universe. And the remnants of that is the cosmic microwave background itself. The universe is a time machine.
Chuck Nice
Look at that.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Writ large to the light that reaches our telescopes.
Chuck Nice
Awesome.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Did I do okay?
Chuck Nice
Yo, man, you killed it.
Neil DeGrasse Tyson
All right. You nailed it. We are StarTalk Radio, brought to you by Bob Grant from the National Science Foundation. I'm Neil Degrasse Tyshen, bidding you once and forever to keep looking up. Chuck, thanks for being here.
Chuck Nice
You got it.
Kia Announcer
If you're ready to elevate your driving experience, the first ever Kia K4 is worth a closer look. It combines style and performance with a sleek, futuristic design featuring StarMap LED headlights and an available panoramic display for unforgettable looks. SiriusXM comes standard in every Kia K4, bringing you closer to what you love. Plus, with an available 100200 and 90 horsepower turbocharged engine, the Kia K4 delivers everything driving enthusiasts crave. Learn more@kia.com K4 Parents did you know.
Greenlight Announcer
That only 50% of US adults are financially literate? Millions of people don't fully understand how to manage money, and it's up to you to not let your kids grow up into that statistic. With Greenlight's educational money app and parent controlled debit card, you can teach them how to earn, save and invest wisely. The earlier they learn, the better prepared they'll be to manage their money and build a financially secure life. Give your kids the financial edge they need. Sign up for Greenlight today@Greenlight.com podcast. That's Greenlight.com podcast.
StarTalk Radio Episode Summary: "Cosmic Queries: Time-Keeping"
Release Date: December 31, 2024
Host: Neil deGrasse Tyson
Co-Host: Chuck Nice
In this engaging episode of StarTalk Radio, astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson teams up with his comic co-host, Chuck Nice, to delve into one of the most profound concepts in science: time. The show, blending science, pop culture, and comedy, invites listeners to explore complex astronomical and physical phenomena through accessible and entertaining dialogue.
(04:24 - 09:12)
The episode kicks off with Chuck Nice presenting his bold personal hypothesis: "Time doesn't exist." He poses several intertwined questions:
Neil responds by clarifying the scientific perspective, explaining that while Chuck's hypothesis is intriguing, it's essential to differentiate between personal hypotheses and established theories. He elaborates on Einstein's conception of time, highlighting its connection to motion and the universe's expansion.
Notable Quote:
Chuck Nice [04:24]: "I have a hypothesis that time does not exist."
Neil concurs partially, explaining that time, as we understand it, began with the Big Bang and is "semi-infinite"—infinite in one direction (the future) but not the other.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [06:04]: "Time is what we call semi-infinite. It's infinite in one direction, but not the other."
They further discuss the idea that time is a construct dependent on the presence of motion and measurable phenomena. Without matter, energy, or space to measure against, "time would have no meaning"—aligning with Chuck’s hypothesis in a broader, more abstract context.
(09:20 - 16:17)
Transitioning from theory to application, Neil and Chuck explore how time is managed in space exploration:
Apollo Missions: Astronauts kept Houston Time, synchronizing with mission control on Earth.
Mars Exploration: Mars has its own timekeeping due to its longer day (~24 hours and 39 minutes). Scientists use Mars time to ensure activities like rover operations align with sunlight availability.
International Space Station (ISS): Features multiple time zones based on the participating countries' home times, leading to five different time zones on board.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [10:31]: "So, essentially, there are 360 degrees of the Earth split into 24 time zones, each spanning 15 degrees."
They also touch upon the psychological aspects of time in space colonies, noting that isolated environments might adopt non-Earth-like day cycles, such as a 25-hour day, to better suit human adaptation.
(13:22 - 16:31)
The conversation shifts to the fascinating realm of Einstein's Relativity, particularly how time behaves at speeds approaching light:
Time Dilation: As one approaches the speed of light, time slows down relative to observers at rest.
Photons: Particles of light, always traveling at the speed of light, experience no passage of time. For a photon, "time does not exist."
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [15:24]: "Time does not exist."
Chuck reacts with astonishment, highlighting the profound implications of these concepts on our understanding of existence and perception.
(21:49 - 25:33)
Jeff poses an intriguing question: "If objects moving faster than the speed of sound can cause a sonic boom, is it possible that the Big Bang was a result of something traveling faster than the speed of light?"
Neil clarifies that while Cherenkov radiation occurs when particles exceed light speed in a medium like water, the Big Bang involved the fabric of space-time itself expanding, not objects moving through space. Therefore, Cherenkov radiation doesn't apply to the Big Bang since the expansion wasn't within a medium.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [24:46]: "The Big Bang was an expansion of the universe itself, not something moving through space faster than light."
(29:03 - 32:02)
Clarissa introduces a pop culture twist: "If Superman made the world spin in the opposite direction, reversing time, what would happen?"
Neil and Chuck humorously dissect the scenario, concluding that reversing Earth's rotation would lead to catastrophic consequences without affecting gravity or time itself. However, Clarissa suggests an alternative where Superman's actions allow him to "go back in time" without reversing Earth's spin, prompting further scientific musing.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [26:40]: "Nothing would happen to time and our gravity would remain exactly the same."
(32:02 - 34:38)
Jordan asks whether a mirror placed 22 light-years away could allow us to see the Big Bang in real-time. Neil explains that the light would take 44 years for a round trip, meaning we wouldn't witness the Big Bang directly. Instead, such a mirror would enable us to observe events from 44 years in the past.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [33:07]: "You would see it 44 years in the past."
(34:38 - 40:15)
In an accelerated segment, Neil and Chuck tackle rapid-fire questions, providing succinct yet informative answers:
Kevin Castaneda: "Is the perception of time universal?"
Neil: Universally, time passes the same at the atomic level, though perceptions may vary among different life forms.
Samir Schuman: "Would time exist without motion?"
Neil: Time relies on measurable motion; without motion, time lacks a framework for measurement.
Tom Shilson: "Is there any evidence that time is broken into little bits?"
Neil: Yes, time is quantized at the smallest scales, aligning with quantum physics principles.
Joey Carasone: "If light can't escape a black hole, how would time be affected inside it?"
Neil: As one approaches a black hole, time slows dramatically, with the outside universe speeding past relative to the observer falling in.
Additional Questions:
Topics included mapping time without conventional timekeeping and whether the universe is necessary for time to exist.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [39:48]: "Time as we have defined it exists only within this universe."
(40:15 - 41:09)
As the episode wraps up, Neil and Chuck reflect on the vastness and intricacies of time, encouraging listeners to continue exploring the universe's mysteries. They emphasize the importance of scientific inquiry and maintaining a sense of wonder.
Notable Quote:
Neil deGrasse Tyson [40:28]: "Keep looking up."
Time's Nature: Time is intertwined with motion and the universe's expansion, having a defined beginning with the Big Bang and continuing infinitely into the future.
Relativity: As objects approach the speed of light, time dilation becomes significant, leading to intriguing phenomena like the timeless existence of photons.
Practical Timekeeping: Space missions require unique timekeeping systems tailored to their operational needs, such as Mars time or multiple time zones on the ISS.
Scientific Inquiry: Listener questions highlight the intersection of science and popular culture, underscoring the relevance of astrophysical concepts in everyday conversations.
Chuck Nice [04:24]: "I have a hypothesis that time does not exist."
Neil deGrasse Tyson [06:04]: "Time is what we call semi-infinite. It's infinite in one direction, but not the other."
Neil deGrasse Tyson [15:24]: "Time does not exist."
Neil deGrasse Tyson [33:07]: "You would see it 44 years in the past."
Neil deGrasse Tyson [40:28]: "Keep looking up."
This episode of StarTalk Radio masterfully balances scientific depth with humor and accessibility, making complex topics like the nature of time understandable and engaging for a broad audience. Whether discussing theoretical physics or entertaining hypothetical scenarios, Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice provide insightful perspectives that inspire curiosity and wonder about the universe.